the backstories make the ending so much sadder. Dutch trusted a man he met 6 months ago more than his two sons he raised. also heartbreaking that dutch left arthur and john for dead.
Dutch has a desperated and broken man, he had this grandiose imagine oh himself as this anarchist messiah of the wild west but the world he knew extinguished in front of his very own eyes, the dude just went totally insane, that if he was ever a sane person. rdr2 takes place in 1899, 15 years more and they would have seen the first world war, by the time of the game a band of outlaws cowboys was just an anachronism.
i think after trying to go to tahiti i think the mental decline of dutch started like you can tell like for example when they were in that cave on that island he could have knoked her out but instead hi choked her
Arthur also had a pet dog called Copper whom he took baths with. He keeps Copper's picture by his bed. Arthur slept with a 19 year old waitress called Eliza who birth his son Isaac. He would come every few months and stay a couple days until one day when he showed up, he discovered they were both killed by robbers for $10. This hardened Arthur's heart and he never fully coped with the pain. He stayed with the expectation that as long as he remained an outlaw, nothing good could be expected to happen to him.
I know Arthur was just broken, every time I play rdr2 I cry more and more because how could they have done Arthur so bad like that like he was just broken and needed someone 😭
Micahs brother (Amos) left the Outlaw life as well as becoming a preacher, and you can find a letter he sends to micah telling him to stop sending letters. Amos is a W.
I’m not Christian, so even though I started playing the game in 2019, I’m just realizing after half a decade that “Reverend” was a title and not Swanson’s name.
But Mary Beth was kidnapped by a man that tormented her. She got her revenge by slitting his neck and tried to find her mother, but she had already passed.
I know this is a joke so if you don't want your story ruined, dont click "read more" below But Uncle's lumbago was just some bullshit he founded up because he was lazy AF and didn't want contribute to the gang.
Lol uncle supposedly being "John Frum" is hilarious. If no one knows the story, there's a tribe in either Africa or South America (I forget which, sorry) who basically worship this soldier who came there during a war and showed them all these crazy things they never saw before (guns, lighters, etc) so they thought he was a God and started worshiping him once he left hoping he'd return one day with more gifts. The name John Frum is thought to just be shorthand for John From America.
I saw multiple characters being misspelled here and I am confused. Is it author's jokes or is it robot's attempt to name the chapters based on recognizing what it hears?
Never really thought about it: but some of the characters who have done petty things (or even honorable things) have ended up making it out of the criminal life. (Simon Pearson especially. I feel like he made it out and succeeded in his own way.)
John had a drunk and violent father (probably meaning violent also with john), gambler who lost view in a fight at some point and died in another bar fight And to precise, i like the idea that john used to be a violent outlaw, had tendency to drink and was near to loose view after the wolf attack. Basically, john always had a low opinion about himself, but the fact he was afraid to be an aweful husband and father could also come to the fact he had some similarities with his aweful father. And john never really had a good parental figure (no mother, aweful father, dutch being kinda good but during rdr2 john was doubting him and dutch always was manipulative, sometimes going extreme..., maybe hadn't hosea as a figure cause hosea left the gang to live with his wife for years but we don't really know when)
Great video, great custom footage, good editing, and interesting content. With all due respect, I feel that the pacing does need a little work. Sometimes I feel like you’re talking too fast and some of the transitions between each character’s backstory feel rushed.
The sad thing about Sadie I’m pretty sure it’s canon that the o Driscolls um well did stuff to her unfortunately I don’t know if it’s true tho correct me if I’m wrong pls
Mary Beth joined the Vanderlin gang shortly after her mother got typhoid an died which orphaned her an she was a petty pick pocket an was in the middle of robbing someone but got caught an Dutch an the gang pretty much took her in
I really get a kick of seeing what outfits other people put together in rdr2. Like the thumbnail. I never would've thought of that combo. With me it's mostly just variations of red and black or just all black with one mountain man with a bunch of skins thrown in on the final slot.
I think uncle joining the gang at around 1894 is wrong. In the first game John tells Jack that uncle was already old when he himself was a kid, and during the game when you antagonize him Arthur says that he ‘should have broken his neck long ago’ so I guess Uncle is one of the first members of the gang.
Love how we don’t know whos Jack father is actually is he’s basically whole group project of whole gang but lemme tell you Jack in Rdr looks like Javier
javiers background is so underrated tbh. Like ofc hes going to stick to Dutch because he's treating him like a son even if the relationship is manipulative and abusive. Javier knows that without Dutch he has literally nothing which turned out to be true after everything went downhill
I have a legitimate question...where do you get all these scene's? I didn’t see these clips in RDR2 nor in RDR1. Are these scene's mods (fake) or is these found in the RDR2 Game?
He makes them himself probably using a trainer to change his character and to spawn in npc to fight like the tilly scene or that's how I'd do it maybe he uses some sort of app
Dutch didn't indoctrinate others; he truly thought he could find peace in helping others. He was sympathetic to their needs and gave a helping hand when no others would. It wouldn't be until later that he would become a narcissist and his ideologies became counter intuitive to that of his former aspirations. He even mentioned giving money from a bank heist to those who needed it most; the poor and orphaned; taking the later idea from the relationship he had with young John Marston.
I have to disagree. It was dutch’s true nature to be violent and bloodthirsty but having people around believe he was a good man allowed him to build a facade of being a Robin Hood like figure which made him adopt the persona but when the people around him stopped believing the facade it fell apart, and he embraced his true nature
When you consistently pick up orphaned kids off the street and practically force them to join your criminal gang while raising them and constantly reminding them of how you saved them then I would consider that indoctrination
@@aidenginger4522when does Dutch does constantly remind them of how he saved them? He just tells everyone to have faith and that he’s working on a godamn plan
For final clarification, uncle is and will never be red Harlow. He was a completely separate character that was cut content sadly. I wish he was too for the longest time but the truth is more important than blissful ignorance.
Where does the scenes in this video comes from ? Especially the last with young Arthur and Dutch outside the house ? 🤔 Cuz these are definitely not something I’ve seen elsewhere and can’t recall them from the story mode 🤔
It's from the multiplayer. You can see that the character doesn't talk, only Trelawny does. Also that's why the character looks like Arthur but not really.
@@FarmerJoe-fs4nvwhat proof is there other than uncle saying he was the one shot kid or whatever. Uncle is notorious for lying and making up random stuff, we would need actual evidence other than just uncles word
Black/Native mix wasn’t uncommon at all in the south especially. There are entire tribes of Afro/Natives. Mississippi Choctaw and Louisiana Seminole to name a few.
