The Vampire Diaries Season 1 & 2 Tier List! 

I agree with almost all of the choices for season 1 & 2 😄Except I think Stefan and Elena are top tier in season 1& 2 for me personally, they often get overlooked because they are mostly do-gooders with a moral compass who want to do the right thing & try to live a selfless life. But I actually really like that about them. I like characters who have a moral compass at the center of their character, I think characters who drive the moral compass on a show are very important, especially amidst all the chaos & evil agenda's going on. They offer a different kind of contrast. Those kind of characters on TV shows & in movies often get more criticism when they put a foot wrong (compared to other characters who perhaps don't have a high moral compass), because they're being held to a higher standard because their moral compass is essentially at the center of their character. Just my 2 cents :D I really enjoyed your discussion about this! And I can't wait to see you girls react to season 3! 😍

The fact that Matt is in awesome with no explanation whatsoever 😅😅 I was on board until Matt & Stefan...they should switch for sure!!

Matt and Tyler over Stefan is WILD. I still can’t understand what the girl on the right’s problem (sorry her name is escaping me atm) With Stefan is. Her reasonings don’t make sense to me 😅 My top tier is Stefan, Elena, Caroline, Alaric, Elijah and Damon Awesome is Katherine,Tyler, Bonnie, Jenna , Klaus and Cool would be Jenna, Lexi, Grams, Matt and Liz and Jeremy Meh would be Anna, John, Mason , Pearl and Andie and Rose Bin the rest

I actually really like your logic and enjoy your tiers - it’s for s1-2 ; it makes sense for me. ❤

I think this is what my Tier List would be top tier: Damon, Caroline, Klaus, Stefan, Katherine, Bonnie awesome: Elena, Jenna, Jeremy, Alaric, Elijah, Tyler cool: Anna, Grams, John, Mason, Rose, Matt meh: Andy, Liz, Luca, Pearl, Lexi, Vicky bin: Isobel, Kelly, Jules, Logan, Dr. Martin

Awesome video I love these type of video's also blooper reactions. I like your list because its very much not influenced by the community its what you 4 wanted mostly. 😊 though i did get my favorite character it top tier that being The Big Bad Vampire himselt Mr. Damon Salvatore. Would have personally put Elena and Klaus in Top Tier and moved Stefan to up to Awesome. My top tier would be 1. Damon 2. Klaus 3. Elena 4. Alaric 5. Stefan 6. Bon Bon Idk why but i find that when Stefan and Elena are on screen together just the two of them its the least entertaining times of their characters. Elena and Stefan are in my top 5 characters but they need to be interacting with other people for me to really enjoy them. Yes I am a Delena shipper but I like Elena so much more when shes interacting with Damon or someone other than Stefan by himself. I love when Stefan and Damon are interacting together. I feel Stefan needs someone to bounce off of for him to be at his best more than Elena does. Damon and Klaus I could watch them talk to a tree. They can be alone or with any character on the show and they make the episode for me but I need Damon or Klaus interacting with Stefan for him to shine if hes with one of the girls or alone i lose all interest in his character. Not 100% of the time but enough to make me notice.

“Very irresponsible policing” get used to that 😂😂

I'd like to see a ranking without restrictions as in as many characters in one category as each of you please. Great present list.

Of course these biased clowns have Matt and Tyler above Stefan. That biased woman who's already watched this show keeps defending everything Damon does and hate on everything Stefan does.

Biased but trying to think like I've only seen 2 seasons Top: Caroline, Damon, Alaric, Katherine, Awesome: Klaus, Elijah, Bonnie Cool: Eleana, Lexi, Anna, Stefan, Grams, Mason, Pearl, Rose, Meh: Jenna (sorry), Liz, Jeremy, Luca, Tyler, Matt Bin: John, Andy, Jules, Dr Martin, Vicki (ugh), Kelly, Logan

I'M SORRY BUT THIS IS MOST DISAPPOITING TIER LIST THAT I HAVE EVER SE MATT AND TYLER ABOVE STEFAN........ARE YOU SERIOS? I can never understand this at least Michael Trevino is a good actor but Zach Roerig is so a bad actor and his charachter is Matt most boring character in any TV I knew Stefan wouldnt make in your top tier but at least you could put him in awsome character Very disappoiting and cant watch your reaction anymore....... sorry not sorry

Top tier is very spacial category for me that I can just put anybody in there and for that reason the only people I would put there is Damon and Elena. Elena is the most complex and realistic female character in the show, she is the representative of love in this show, she is literally the glue that holds the whole group together. She’s way more mature for her own age more than Caroline and Bonnie. She’s strong, courageous, selfless and super loyal and her capacity for forgiveness is unmatched in this show. She is literally the saviour of the souls who brings them back from darkness and helped repair the bonds that has been damaged. Her good qualities have been very overlooked by the fandom but she definitely deserves a top tier. Damon is another representation of love because he’s driven by nothing but love, his whole existence revolves around love. He’s by far the most complex character in this show and the depth of his character reminds me of an ocean because it has no end. His love comes from the places of sacredness and unity where only unconditional and selfless love exists. To him love is not even about being loved back, it’s about loving the person for the sake of just loving them, without asking for anything in return. It’s about seeing the smile on their face even if he’s not the one who’s making them smile. He’s the most resilient character in this show, he’s courageous, fiercely loyal, he’s caring and selfless in times even too selfless. He knows how to make peace with his dark side and use it for love and that makes him very mature and wise. His capacity to love with such a passion and devotion is also unmatched in this show. Damon and Elena are the only people who deserve top tier in my opinion.

What.?! 😂 I love y’all but this is the funniest tier list I’ve ever seen not gon lie… How is Stefan that low.? Wtf? He and Bonnie are the only true hero in this show. I understand y’all are Damon fans and simps cause is just ruthless, funny with good looking jaw line and smile not to say he ruin a lot shit for them and try stealing his brother’s girl the whole seasons, I will never understand what the hype is with that Character fr… Yall really pissed me off with this ngl Stefan lower than Matt.? Matt.? The most boring character ever and Tyler.? You even put Lexi on Meh.? How dare you.? Even if Stefan isn’t on you Top Tier List at least he deserves to be on Awesome

Jennys face during this is great cause shes got the biased feelings like me and The list as yall did it is ALL WRONG LOL kidding, were all entitled to our faves

Damon and Caroline are overrated. Bonnie and Stefan are massively underrated.

Damon being top-tier is exactly where he belongs. He had me hooked from the very first episode of tvd. Damon brings so much levity and humor into the show. He’s one of my favorite characters because of how complex he is. He went from not caring about anything, to caring about saving everyone including Elena and Stefan. He has such a big heart but hides it behind humor so he doesn’t get hurt. He spent 145 years searching for love, but always ends up getting betrayed or hurt the most. He has many flaws and that’s why I relate to him more as a character. He’s not perfect, and he’s gonna make some mistakes.

seeing klaus not being top-tier, i felt like I needed to apologise to klaus along with jenny 🤧 😭 How ARE MATT AND TYLER ABOVE STEFAN? (Im sorry im just slightly offended over here, maybe more than slightly.) Continued the video and: LEXI ON MEH DEEPLY OFFENDED MY SOUL, JENNY'S EXPRESSIONS ARE EXACTLY HOW IM FEELING THROUGH THIS Oh no this tier ranking is hurting me. i do not agree with half this ranking but also i appreciate your reactions and opinions so yeah. I have watched TVD countless times and watching it with JD and Erin, i am finding more sympathy for certain characters that I never felt before, still some opinions are definitely WILD and I don't understand them at all, I do like how you have such different and strong opinions and how you discuss things. 🤍 Can't say I wasn't disappointed, still look forward to more seasons.