Тёмный

The Weeknd- House of Balloons ALBUM REVIEW 

theneedledrop
Подписаться 2,9 млн
Просмотров 438 тыс.
50% 1

Listen: the-weeknd.com
1. Matthewdavid Vid:
theneedledrop.com/?p=3928
2. LCD Soundsystem covers Franz Ferdinand:
theneedledrop.com/?p=3923
After numerous revisits, this Weeknd album just isn't sitting well with me. Though I'm all for any efforts the artists of today make to change the R&B landscape, the lyricism on this LP sticks up like an unwelcome weed.
Imagine this album as an indie film, and you've been given a free ticket. Considering the fact you paid no money, the picture quality, sets, costumes, and camerawork are all quite good. Loos pretty hi-production! Maybe it'll be promising.
But then the lead actor walks into frame, and it becomes painfully clear things are going downhill. His mannerisms are awkward, his phrasing is generic, and he wasn't given the best of lines.
He's kind of like a younger, more risk-taking version of Johnny in Tommy Wiseau's the Room. He's nobody to sympathize with. His emotions are legitimate--even if they are a little overly dramatic--but he lacks the ability to express himself in a remotely captivating way.
I usually do my best to avoid people like this, not listen to them sing about their self-created "problems."
What do you think of this album? Love it? Hate it? Why? What should I review next?
3/10
theneedledrop.com
bit.ly/tndsupport
bit.ly/TNDTwitter
bit.ly/TNDFacebook
bit.ly/TNDPodcast
theneedledrop.com/forum
FAV TRACKS: None, really. Sorry, bros.

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

 

12 апр 2011

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.   
@astridparungao4971
@astridparungao4971 6 лет назад
Anthony's worst review of all time
@abhinav5259
@abhinav5259 5 лет назад
@@davidadu8559 Neither do Anthony's but we all can share them.
@OMN1N
@OMN1N 4 года назад
No one cares about your opinion. The non-trilogy version is so fucking bad. Edit: I've changed my mind drasically, I think this is one of the best R&B projects of this decade. I listened to Wicked Games and thought the mixing was shit, so I just commented a bunch of bullshit because of it. Sorry.
@thraitor7819
@thraitor7819 4 года назад
@@OMN1N naw
@senorjerkbeefy3641
@senorjerkbeefy3641 4 года назад
@@OMN1N there's hardly any differences between the 3 tapes and the trilogy kid
@brother5671
@brother5671 4 года назад
PRO GAMING yes
@corteiz
@corteiz 5 лет назад
This has to be the lowest point in Anthony’s music reviewing career
@beigegecko
@beigegecko 4 года назад
nah, the score is pretty fair
@kmcorrea5805
@kmcorrea5805 4 года назад
His review of Mac’s Swimming
@nootnootmyboot10
@nootnootmyboot10 4 года назад
Why is it a bad review, exactly?
@cd22_2
@cd22_2 4 года назад
nootnootmyboot this is a year old I don’t think he’s gonna respond :/
@nootnootmyboot10
@nootnootmyboot10 4 года назад
@@cd22_2 :(
@DemDoolies
@DemDoolies 4 года назад
Love how The Weeknd was so mysterious that Anthony thought he was a group
@joe_3105
@joe_3105 2 года назад
Because there was a Canadian music band called "The Weekend" Because of that, he trademarked the name The Weeknd, as the letter e was removed to avoid copyright marks against him.
@obasiswift
@obasiswift 2 года назад
I did to at the time
@soloslava2392
@soloslava2392 2 года назад
@@joe_3105 I read this fuckin comment and i look at the weeknds name and it's missing the e everywhere i look there is no longer an e and i never noticed there was no e its pretty wild
@ianhh23
@ianhh23 2 года назад
@@joe_3105 Idk if I were gonna review someone's work I would search information about them
@Kinggrave
@Kinggrave Год назад
@@ianhh23 thing is back then, nobody knew who the weeknd was. It was only a guess that it was a group seeing as abel was so mysterious about it at the start.
@saintbeau2779
@saintbeau2779 4 года назад
anthony's most embarrassing review tbh.
@Jamieconstable
@Jamieconstable 4 года назад
for real it’s stupid. he doesn’t even seem to pay attention to the actual MUSIC. the actual SOUND. he focused way to much on the “character” and the “story” on the album😐😐
@jakegraham3758
@jakegraham3758 4 года назад
Jamie Constable I didn’t have a problem with the character of Abel on the album not every artist has to play the good guy all the time and this album is a sonic masterpiece idc
@papayasmith
@papayasmith 4 года назад
Jamie Constable the music and sound is just one part tho. If you don’t like the character and story, the songs can come off quite boring. That’s why he didn’t enjoy it, he didn’t care for the Abel was saying and I can understand that. To me this album is an 8 but I can see why he wouldn’t like it if he didn’t sympathize with the lyrics. That is an important part of the music after all
@danielrc14
@danielrc14 4 года назад
I agree that "the character" is annoying, I don't usually like The Weeknd's lyrics, but to base pretty much all the review on the lyrics alone is stupid, he doesn't even talk much about the instrumentals, while in other reviews he talks about it track by track. He's entitled by his opinion, but based on what he's saying here, a 3/10 makes no sense. Also his lyrics haven't changed that much even in After Hours, and he still using autotune, and Anthony gave that album a 7/10, but he probably won't ever admit the mistake he did in this review.
@nootnootmyboot10
@nootnootmyboot10 4 года назад
Well, its not like he didn't talk about it all. A reviewer, when making a shorter 5-10 minute review, will likely only talk about the things he or she actually has some thought in. He apparently had more to say on the story, and the story really ruined everything for him.
@EzPzLemnSqueezy
@EzPzLemnSqueezy 8 лет назад
This review is worse than MBDTF.
@morissmor
@morissmor 8 лет назад
Because you don't agree with it?
@EzPzLemnSqueezy
@EzPzLemnSqueezy 8 лет назад
Reptile estrin Basically
@MrBeastknows
@MrBeastknows 7 лет назад
Reptile estrin well the issue is that Anthony doesn't get it. We aren't supposed to sympathize with him, he is the bad guy in almost every song. That or it's just a party/sex song. The only time we would is on The Knowing which is absolutely beautiful and Coming Down. Well, maybe on Wicked Games but I've never enjoyed that song. Like a lot of Anthony's arguments "he thinks with his wang most of the time" yes, that's the point. That's the character The Weeknd is portraying. The thing about Anthony's opinion is he's so biased about the character he doesn't give a proper review. It's the same reason MBDTF got a bad review. Because of Anthony's bias to the character. If Anthony listened and reviewed both albums NOW, the reviews would be much different as he's grown as a reviewer. He now tends to leave his biases at the door and reviews it looking at all angles. He now sees who the album is made for and reviews mostly based off that with his opinion still in play. But back in 2011, his reviews were sometimes shit.
@lakiog1938
@lakiog1938 7 лет назад
EzPzLemnSqueezy no mbdtf review was just....
@promisethatyouwillsingabou7920
Shane Benjamson that makes no sense
@galaxygateway211
@galaxygateway211 4 года назад
Let's be real here, HoB was so ahead of it's time that most people failed to understand it's greatness. Even fantano wasn't ready for this.
@nationradical
@nationradical 4 года назад
Spot on man such a unique sound for the time! Timeless classic!
@lonal9937
@lonal9937 3 года назад
Absolutely true
@MT-pf1pv
@MT-pf1pv 7 месяцев назад
Totally agreed
@WoozyYami
@WoozyYami 4 года назад
"the singing was great, the production was experimental, i enjoyed the vibe, but the singer comes off like the guy who got more girls than me in high school, and i don't like that"
@pianoboi4842
@pianoboi4842 4 года назад
"He should've been white". Smh Anthony, you don't say that
@yubbityyubba7749
@yubbityyubba7749 4 года назад
I thought this comment was one of those meme comments that are flooded in all his comment sections but then i watched the vid and yeh thats the perfect way to summarise this review
@pianoboi4842
@pianoboi4842 4 года назад
@@WoozyYami Cal
@no1u521
@no1u521 3 года назад
Spot on
@MegaPaul88
@MegaPaul88 2 года назад
holy shit that’s so on point hahaha
@JordanBarclay
@JordanBarclay 4 года назад
“Could there possibly be a day where I’m enjoying auto-tune?” Gives KIDS SEE GHOSTS a 10/10 Yes.
@gool1076
@gool1076 4 года назад
Jordan Barclay rodeo gets an 8
@gool1076
@gool1076 4 года назад
Ronald McDonald reborn and cudi montage
@christina2071
@christina2071 4 года назад
charli gets a 9
@ickboiyugo3698
@ickboiyugo3698 4 года назад
@@gool1076 Feel the Love
@youknowhuwitis
@youknowhuwitis 4 года назад
@@christina2071 5th best record of the decade apparently
@dantelan-i-er5466
@dantelan-i-er5466 7 лет назад
I love how people are commenting on this like he just did it yesterday. Hahaha.
@Jamieconstable
@Jamieconstable 4 года назад
Dante LAN-I-ER still commenting😒😒
@bluvi
@bluvi 4 года назад
Still
@djillusii7333
@djillusii7333 4 года назад
Ha ha goodmoorning
@rediah
@rediah 4 года назад
Still
@Labanda_daniel
@Labanda_daniel 4 года назад
Haider still
@RayVonTv1
@RayVonTv1 12 лет назад
The album is amazing. Probably a review you'll regret in the future
@zephyr6927
@zephyr6927 2 года назад
how's life these days? do you still like the tape? wot do you think of after hours?
@prod.icemarisso
@prod.icemarisso 2 года назад
How you feel about Abel's recent projects?
@stratford1
@stratford1 2 года назад
Hey how ya doing? What do you think of the Weeknd now?
@nickyisok
@nickyisok 2 года назад
how you doin man? what are your thoughts on after hours and dawn fm?
@flylo3416
@flylo3416 2 года назад
she/he prolly forgot her/his youtube password
@noahxo7384
@noahxo7384 4 года назад
i come back to this atleast once a year just to torture myself
@JoelAdrianFilms
@JoelAdrianFilms 8 лет назад
A Re-Review is necessary. Giving this tape a 3/10 is a disservice!
@nah.4798
@nah.4798 6 лет назад
2 years later. A re-review is still needed.
@jmaxx7410
@jmaxx7410 5 лет назад
It's called an opinion
@spaco181
@spaco181 5 лет назад
He still doesn’t like The Weeknd tho
@Lycanvenom
@Lycanvenom 5 лет назад
I hope it drops to a 1/10.
@tbriecheese
@tbriecheese 4 года назад
@@spaco181 well that was a fucking lie
@TarikJasim
@TarikJasim 10 лет назад
I dont get it.. this mixtape is a masterpiece.
@dommy1715
@dommy1715 6 лет назад
mixtape
@Jamieconstable
@Jamieconstable 4 года назад
yes it is
@Jamieconstable
@Jamieconstable 4 года назад
anthony is the only one on planet earth who thinks this is a 3/10
@Nebdev
@Nebdev 4 года назад
'mixtape'
@TarikJasim
@TarikJasim 4 года назад
happy now, fuckers?
@midnightkylo582
@midnightkylo582 9 лет назад
the fuck is this. this mixtape is golden
@nathanshlap
@nathanshlap 7 лет назад
John Mate k YOUR FUCKING OPINION
@moecash8450
@moecash8450 3 года назад
Nigga is that the afterlife sign from mob of the dead?
@edgxr5511
@edgxr5511 3 года назад
@@moecash8450 😂
@matthewharrison3811
@matthewharrison3811 3 года назад
@@moecash8450 I’m dead
@fettywap659
@fettywap659 6 лет назад
HoB is an 11/10, an absolute masterpiece...
@joltiix
@joltiix 3 года назад
Not an 11/10
@zerdaloo
@zerdaloo 3 года назад
@@joltiix yeah, a 12/10 would be more suitable. I agree.
@2intheampm512
@2intheampm512 3 года назад
I really love House of Balloons, but I don’t think it’s flawless. What You Need is kind of a boring track, and GTG doesn’t have the best verses and drags on a bit too long. The lyricism is occasionally bland or lacking. I think HOB is a flawed masterpiece
@hgnihjsted6373
@hgnihjsted6373 2 года назад
@@2intheampm512 what you need is NOT a boring trach wym?????
@ImAgentK
@ImAgentK 2 года назад
@@2intheampm512 You should hear what you need the unreleased version it’s so much better
@landminelover926
@landminelover926 4 года назад
Well he put Trilogy in his top 200 of the decade so i guess it has grown on him lol
@MuhammadSalman7236
@MuhammadSalman7236 4 года назад
Yep. He definitely needs to do a redux.
@jakegraham3758
@jakegraham3758 4 года назад
Nah echoes of silence got a 8 and not sure about the other one but chances are he still hates house of balloons which is weird because it’s like everyone else’s favorite
@MuhammadSalman7236
@MuhammadSalman7236 4 года назад
@@jakegraham3758 he put trilogy In his top 200 of the decade. Which wouldn't be possible if he hates 9 songs from it.
@papayasmith
@papayasmith 4 года назад
Muhammad Salman I mean he did give this album a 3 to a light 4 so he probably thought a couple songs were decent and then they grew on him over time. He’d probably rate this album a 5 or 6 out of 10 now
@landminelover926
@landminelover926 4 года назад
On his recent livestream he said he’s open for HoB growing on him and that he may review Trilogy at the end of this year
@Kahnsie
@Kahnsie 9 лет назад
1. The Weeknd is a Person not a group 2. Theres no Auto-Tune 3. This was a AMAZING mixtape.. Wtf are you on? Lmao...
@heatcharger971
@heatcharger971 9 лет назад
Vuho ♥ People didn't know The Weeknd was one person when he first came out.
@user-rx3js1no3s
@user-rx3js1no3s 9 лет назад
Your presence isn't wanted on musical quality discussions, basic white girl.
@user-rx3js1no3s
@user-rx3js1no3s 9 лет назад
Vuho ♥ I once had a decent channel a few years back with a few dozen thousands of views, but I've lost interest to its topics so I made a new one. I really don't think someone with maybe a few dozen views can talk any shit to anyone. Especially considering you're just filming your PS4 using a camera (not enough money for a capture card I'd assume) on basic tutorials for games everyone's heard of and have already many hundreds of thousands of videos for.
@kunttulgar8981
@kunttulgar8981 9 лет назад
Vuho ♥ people didnt know about him at the time, he was unknown
@ymbertbonaventuredickens8878
@ymbertbonaventuredickens8878 7 лет назад
Check your shit man
@abusalehahmedroop2138
@abusalehahmedroop2138 4 года назад
Didn't even talked about a single track.
@TheLunarChannel
@TheLunarChannel 10 лет назад
You dont have enough sex to understand this album
@ciscolmt
@ciscolmt 10 лет назад
Exactly
@ExperienceLOS7713
@ExperienceLOS7713 9 лет назад
Honestly this is such a lame comment. Just a weak ass joke that wouldn't have made me laugh in middle school... OH HAR HAR HAR, YOU'RE BUSY SLAYING THE VAGOO WHILE FANDINGUS JERKS IT TO THE NEW SWANS ALBUM. Whatever man, Fantano is right: the lyrics sound like they were written by a tool. And this is coming from someone who overall enjoyed the album.
@jiggyy
@jiggyy 9 лет назад
I bet The Weeknd's a virgin.
@davida6557
@davida6557 9 лет назад
***** If anyone's a virgin its your ass lmao
@jiggyy
@jiggyy 9 лет назад
EOD davie A girl touched my pants once.
@seanboyle4467
@seanboyle4467 3 года назад
Wicked games alone should be enough to give this album at least an 8
@lucasphillips2177
@lucasphillips2177 2 года назад
and HOB/GTG plus The Knowing
@husaanshabendri4331
@husaanshabendri4331 Год назад
@@lucasphillips2177 plus the other 6 songs
@edonshatri6446
@edonshatri6446 9 месяцев назад
FRRRR wicked games is soooo good
@0v3rgr0wn
@0v3rgr0wn 7 лет назад
The Weeknd's best project imo. I wonder if his opinion has changed. 3/10 is very harsh.
@soumyadeepdas3886
@soumyadeepdas3886 7 лет назад
he seems to be a bit more favourable now on this project, especially on the remastered trilogy version. he prefers the production now, but he's still ambivalent towards the lyrics. you can check his kiss land review for his opinion on it now.
@EpicGamertje
@EpicGamertje 4 месяца назад
Dawn FM is his BEST!!!
@Ryank2150
@Ryank2150 4 года назад
“These guys are a Canadian rnb outfit”
@jamjam850
@jamjam850 3 года назад
He never revealed his identity by that time
@TheBlashMusic
@TheBlashMusic 3 года назад
Back then, people thought it was a band.
@yeezysmalls7782
@yeezysmalls7782 10 лет назад
I think the immature lyricism had purpose - it really brings out his relative innocence in this disgusting, sleazy world that he's talking about.
@Joela393
@Joela393 10 лет назад
You nearly summed it all up
@kefkapalazzo1
@kefkapalazzo1 9 лет назад
Lol sure
@termiiinuus
@termiiinuus 2 года назад
@@akielsteewart8577 but it didnt so theres no need to? He said it had a purpose so it would be different if it wasnt immature
@deekismusic
@deekismusic 9 лет назад
I don't normally deeply disagree with you, and I know this review is old.... but shit man, this mixtape was fire. I can understand if you didn't like the post-mixtapes stuff though.
@TheRantMaster53
@TheRantMaster53 8 лет назад
+deekismusic Kiss Land was incredible, though. BBTM, maybe not as much, but still good.
@Ilburto
@Ilburto 8 лет назад
+TheRantMaster53 Do you like Kissland more than BBTM? How come?
@TheRantMaster53
@TheRantMaster53 8 лет назад
Bart van Maanen I just liked the songs, the concept, and the overall feel of Kiss Land a lot more. It was very weighty and cinematic, which I'm a real sucker for when it comes to music. I didn't feel like BBTM captured the same essence of Kiss Land, which, it wasn't meant to obviously. But still the album was more pop-orientated, which isn't exactly my cup of tea, but there were still a lot of songs I loved from it. Overall though, Kiss Land was the album that had more for me to appreciate about it. How come you like BBTM more?
@wayned535
@wayned535 5 лет назад
@@TheRantMaster53 I honestly liked BBTM better. Kissland and starboy are the only projects he had ever done, where I haven't liked all the songs.
@a.s4711
@a.s4711 5 лет назад
Are you talking about The noise EP? That shit was trash and was released against Abel's own will
@Adrianology101
@Adrianology101 13 лет назад
I could not disagree with u more about this mixtape, I absolutely love it. It was about time indie artists started experimenting with R&B, this was a leap in the right direction. Yes there could have been more depth to the lyrics and subject matter but there doesn't have to be. 8/10
@lucifermorningstar3709
@lucifermorningstar3709 Год назад
My thoughts precisely, 11 years later
@koutoo
@koutoo 8 месяцев назад
'indie' man 🥶
@jsneed7216
@jsneed7216 4 года назад
Watching the review of this album and seeing why he gave it a three -Didn’t like auto tune -Production is mediocre (I think that’s what he said.. was kind of vague) -Doesn’t like lyrics because he doesn’t like the character singing it (not because the lyrics are bad) That’s it. I love fantano but this is one of his most close-minded reviews. His main reason for not liking the album was because he doesn’t like the character singing it. The album is a masterclass in telling what a life of drugs, partying, and sex can do to you. It’s fun in the moment, sure, but after the fun is deep regret. Would really like to see a re review of this because I hope he does come back to this album. Edit: He put trilogy (an album with the songs from HOB on it) on his top 100 albums of the decade, so maybe he has come around on the album. If he has would still like to see a re-review on it.
@kboyd9325
@kboyd9325 6 лет назад
Looks like it lasted the test of time. This tape is considered a modern R&B classic now, lol.
@18kingen
@18kingen 6 лет назад
bruh this tape shaped the whole rnb landscape thats going on rn... all these moody artists doin this thanks to abel
@TheRalouch
@TheRalouch 5 лет назад
HipHopBassBoost because it's easy.
@andrewyoules3699
@andrewyoules3699 3 года назад
@@thefunkeekatt_22 you are simply uninformed
@d9b9
@d9b9 Год назад
@@pedrohenriquepintodeolivei7676 bryson tiller, PND, brent faiyaz, etc
@Jdoylee811
@Jdoylee811 10 лет назад
Such a terrible review lol. He didn't even talk about the music, just the "character" of the tape smh.
@johnharrington1744
@johnharrington1744 9 лет назад
So true. That's the problem that I have with a lot of indie-centric critics like the ones who work at pitchfork, and anthony fantano's usually well above that. Definitely a disappointing review.
@zeroscorpio3692
@zeroscorpio3692 5 лет назад
that still has shit to do with the music dumbass
@luisven6247
@luisven6247 5 лет назад
Zero Scorpio 45 months late bruh
@shittelevision2384
@shittelevision2384 4 года назад
Oh no, it's not like the main character is one of the most important things in a narrative
@stringnumber221
@stringnumber221 4 года назад
Oh noooo the mixtape has a character? ???? peopl can not talk about the caraterrrrrrr
@xxeman445xx
@xxeman445xx 8 лет назад
Didn't even like Loft Music, aye? I think that's such a good track.
@caseydouglas3671
@caseydouglas3671 4 года назад
Ethan Arguably the best Weeknd song of all time
@davidpollard6502
@davidpollard6502 4 года назад
Nah HoB is best
@Andu_music
@Andu_music 4 года назад
Probably didnt like the "whats good young ho" line since he was calling him a tool haha
@sisilabtj6086
@sisilabtj6086 4 года назад
@@caseydouglas3671 what about the knowing
@Thepinkxx
@Thepinkxx 3 года назад
he is crazy
@Hufoverlouisv
@Hufoverlouisv 9 лет назад
Bro what autotune lol
@davidadu8559
@davidadu8559 5 лет назад
Hufoverlouisv there was auto tune.....
@wayned535
@wayned535 5 лет назад
There is autotune but just for pitch correction. He can actually hit most of those notes live.
@scottthedelinquent
@scottthedelinquent 5 лет назад
Wayne D nah the autotune is certainly for effect cause he can hit those notes very essily
@TwoTwoFourSix
@TwoTwoFourSix 5 лет назад
Wayne D auto tune and pitchcorrection are two peas in the same pod but they are not the same thing
@nonyashblob
@nonyashblob 9 лет назад
Lol people complaining he called him a group. I suppose you knew it was just one guy in April 2011? ffs
@darfi6185
@darfi6185 8 лет назад
he was so mysterious back then. it was very common for people to think he (or they lol) was a band or group. no one really knew what he looked like
@dripjeezus5651
@dripjeezus5651 3 года назад
Yeah
@Bestavashvili
@Bestavashvili 3 года назад
This video demonstrates perfectly why you never should take critics seriously
@xxEzraBxxx
@xxEzraBxxx 2 года назад
hes a subjective reviewer and he’s been reviewing music for 11 years now, with that timespan your pretty much guaranteed to make a shitty review at some poiny
@hgnihjsted6373
@hgnihjsted6373 2 года назад
@@xxEzraBxxx thats not what hes talking about
@owencarter7979
@owencarter7979 3 года назад
The like to dislike ratio is hilarious and deserved
@JoshSingleTon2
@JoshSingleTon2 2 года назад
Can't see :(
@jacklrolfe
@jacklrolfe 2 года назад
@@JoshSingleTon2 thanks youtube 😑
@soloslava2392
@soloslava2392 2 года назад
LLLLLLLL
@JoshSingleTon2
@JoshSingleTon2 2 года назад
@@jacklrolfe Just got my vanced, the video has 13k dislikes lol.
@jacklrolfe
@jacklrolfe 2 года назад
@@JoshSingleTon2 what does vanced mean?
@joshualee9540
@joshualee9540 2 года назад
Crazy how The Weeknd was so unknown that people thought he was a band.
@davidadams2395
@davidadams2395 7 лет назад
Anthony is in the minority with this release.
@peachabutt
@peachabutt 5 лет назад
That's a simple way to put it.
@justaguywholikeshentai4093
@justaguywholikeshentai4093 2 года назад
House of balloons is critically acclaimed and a fan favorite so yup
@r6raiden843
@r6raiden843 4 года назад
I think Fantano was too consumed by the lyrical context on this tape rather than the execution/production and overall vocally excellent performance by The Weeknd. Definitely would love to hear a re-review of this because I don't think it deserves a 3. I'm no fan of The Weeknd after Trilogy, but this is honestly one of the best projects I've ever listened to and I'm not R&B fanatic either.
@JosephGervais
@JosephGervais 4 года назад
You know we always talk about how he gave my beautiful dark twisted Fantasy a 6/10. But we never talk about how he gave arguably the weeknds best project a 3/10
@MiklosTamas1997
@MiklosTamas1997 8 лет назад
I don't give a fuck about his opinion i love this mixtape
@morissmor
@morissmor 8 лет назад
If you truly didn't give a fuck you wouldn't click on the video you stupid dipshit.
@MiklosTamas1997
@MiklosTamas1997 8 лет назад
+Reptile estrin go fuck yourself please i dont give a fuck what you think.
@morissmor
@morissmor 8 лет назад
+Miklós Tamás You're a moron. Do you know how "not giving a fuck" works. Now go listen to your shitty album.
@joymanchis
@joymanchis 7 лет назад
+Reptile estrin you clearly havent heard the fucking album if u think its shit
@morissmor
@morissmor 7 лет назад
+Joymanchis or I have a different opinion.
@soiboi4497
@soiboi4497 2 года назад
And people say his MBDTF review was bad…
@NikhilSingh-oe6iq
@NikhilSingh-oe6iq 2 года назад
If The Weeknd was as popular as Kanye that time, Anthony would have been canceled before getting canceled was a thing.
@lavarball528
@lavarball528 2 года назад
@@NikhilSingh-oe6iq How do you get canceled for making a review
@zackzallie8735
@zackzallie8735 2 года назад
I believe Anthony was behind the removal plan of the dislike button. Notice how he's brave in reviewing new music nowadays? It's no coincidence. This melon is no ordinary music nerd. He's a manipulator.
@chessvibes3182
@chessvibes3182 2 года назад
Melonipulator*
@zackzallie8735
@zackzallie8735 2 года назад
@@chessvibes3182 Dang.
@monnijr9446
@monnijr9446 2 года назад
Pretty more exaggerated comment He’s older and used to the internet now and he at the most his opinion
@levi-homer
@levi-homer 4 года назад
*^house of balloons is a easy strong 8 to light 9^*
@dripjeezus5651
@dripjeezus5651 3 года назад
Easy strong 9 to light 10 you mean?
@nenenomusic
@nenenomusic 6 лет назад
"Will there ever be a day where I like this much auto tune?" Gives Lil boat a 7/10 (and DAMN.)
@davidb5205
@davidb5205 6 лет назад
Visual Aids Fuck it! Let's just give Lil Pump 7/10 as well.
@JoeMama-tl4tr
@JoeMama-tl4tr Год назад
I love that he referred to The Weeknd as a group
@zkore_271
@zkore_271 Год назад
at the time he was mysterious, he thought it was the group “The Weekend”
@jericocortes7289
@jericocortes7289 3 года назад
Hey Fantano I love your reviews and I just want to say that ignore these haters, just because they can't accept your opinion doesn't mean you get the hate you deserved but hey keep doing reviews my man. Unsubscribed.
@xctye27
@xctye27 3 года назад
Lmao
@laithontop
@laithontop 2 года назад
never forget when anthony thought the weeknd was a group
@ickboiyugo3698
@ickboiyugo3698 4 года назад
U gave this amazing album a 3 out of 10 just because you're gay
@lenocr7
@lenocr7 4 года назад
Jajajajaja
@ickboiyugo3698
@ickboiyugo3698 3 года назад
@Saksham Tyagi HoMoPhObIa
@ickboiyugo3698
@ickboiyugo3698 3 года назад
@Saksham Tyagi I'm bi,get over it.
@ickboiyugo3698
@ickboiyugo3698 3 года назад
@Saksham Tyagi It is completely fine to be sarcastic over it. I don't see why are people so soft on humor these days. I can make jokes about females/males,why they can't do that same thing on me, good intentionally ofc?
@dustinyoung6349
@dustinyoung6349 7 лет назад
This was the 1st needle drop review I ever saw, & I disagreed with everything he said. 5 years later I still always can't wait for his take on modern music
@winterfrost99
@winterfrost99 7 лет назад
Dustin Young Same here
@maxramirez9955
@maxramirez9955 7 лет назад
DLLO Eiv he has a right to hate on him nowadays since he's radio trash
@zachleona2532
@zachleona2532 4 года назад
@@Elite328 EOS had a good review.
@KidBiggums
@KidBiggums 10 лет назад
i don't think anybody will anybody will ever understand the weeknd. even off of a mixtape or all of them, you can't say a full truthful conclusion about him. he barely speaks to social media because he wants to focus on his music, not his public image. also, they don't realize his lyrics. how dark and violent he really is. i don't see where him being a tool comes from honestly, there's much more deeper meaning in his songs than just sex and drugs. he's making kind of a story about that we'll have to find out through his later mixtapes/albums
@fu4627
@fu4627 9 лет назад
10/10 comment
@fu4627
@fu4627 9 лет назад
10/10 comment
@jiggyy
@jiggyy 9 лет назад
No. Stop trying to make this POS seem deeper than he is.
@quantumpiss4206
@quantumpiss4206 3 года назад
Here we have an example of the angry fanboy who says "you can't understand him! He's too deep for you!"
@DrKangeroo
@DrKangeroo 8 лет назад
How you gunna call The Weeknd they?
@marcobazan4187
@marcobazan4187 8 лет назад
at the time, no one knew who the weeknd was and people thought it was a duo
@jackofallfades2656
@jackofallfades2656 7 лет назад
+marco bazan fax
@Dondadator
@Dondadator 7 лет назад
He was like dvsn or nav...no one knew who they were, but the music hit
@giovannamatias586
@giovannamatias586 7 лет назад
This video is from 2011 dumbass.. no one knew who he was. #think
@thecosmicblueautie
@thecosmicblueautie 7 лет назад
Alex Howard-Lawal Producer Illangelo and Abel Tesfaye = The Weeknd back in that time. Now, it's just Abel.
@goodonekev
@goodonekev 9 лет назад
Dude there's no auto-tune driving The Weeknd at all, listen to him live, sounds perfect.
@hgnihjsted6373
@hgnihjsted6373 2 года назад
he talks about the album not the weeknd. in the album it is used several times fx what you need and gtg
@davidb5205
@davidb5205 6 лет назад
You gave Lil Boat and Lil Pump 7/10 but The Weeknd 3/10? This is the worst mistake of your career. Plz change rating system.
@bigtiddy2369
@bigtiddy2369 6 лет назад
His reviews are based on personal enjoyment.
@TeknoSquirrel
@TeknoSquirrel 6 лет назад
Richard Caridan 2.0 He's joking about how stupid comparing scores is.
@bigtiddy2369
@bigtiddy2369 6 лет назад
oh shit imma friggin doofus
@ANDR3alfaro
@ANDR3alfaro 6 лет назад
Lil Pump mixtape is the greatest review of all time.
@corteiz
@corteiz 6 лет назад
Personally I think he has a really shit taste when it comes to R&B/ Alternative RnB
@caseydouglas3671
@caseydouglas3671 4 года назад
This is genuinely my favorite music that has ever graced my ears, the best mixtape of all of Trilogy. Each of them deserves at least a 9...
@bionicallyacomputer292
@bionicallyacomputer292 2 года назад
fax
@omarmusa7968
@omarmusa7968 3 года назад
After nine years, the Weeknd is the most streamed artist in the world..
@tonin5047
@tonin5047 2 года назад
This is crazy...
@harunmemic9045
@harunmemic9045 Год назад
Now hes probably the most famous artist in the world. His numbers are going skyhigh
@wcdallen
@wcdallen 12 лет назад
pure 10/10 imo, one of my favorite albums ever.
@ant9274
@ant9274 10 лет назад
This album is great, this guy is way off.
@cherryboom724
@cherryboom724 Год назад
0 dislikes, I guess everyone agrees with his score
@mr.reallyunbotherexo
@mr.reallyunbotherexo Год назад
You mean nobody?
@Jequetepeq
@Jequetepeq Год назад
It has 15k dislikes btw Thats 5 dislikes for every like
@user-bv1ex6rr6v
@user-bv1ex6rr6v 7 лет назад
I love it when Fantano-sensei hates my favorite music
@dantetroina2049
@dantetroina2049 8 лет назад
House Of Balloons is my favorite album of all time.. Sucks that Anthony doesn't even feel good enough to give it a score over like 6..
@valeriamontoya469
@valeriamontoya469 2 года назад
horrendous review, one of the greatest mixtapes ever
@jonahdavis7833
@jonahdavis7833 8 лет назад
Even though I disagree with the review, Anthony knows what he's talking about with music. Calm down guys, Pitchfork gave it an 8.5
@guenthersteiner8163
@guenthersteiner8163 8 лет назад
Pitchfork also gave Kanye's new album a good review...
@MrSpaceSentry
@MrSpaceSentry 8 лет назад
because it's good lol
@CriticsConfession
@CriticsConfession 8 лет назад
+eddy Masson If you don't like TLOP you have objectively bad taste and you're taking yourself too seriously.
@cg2209
@cg2209 7 лет назад
>objectively bad tast >objective >taste
@maxinator317
@maxinator317 7 лет назад
+eddy Masson They always do
@theneedledrop
@theneedledrop 13 лет назад
@Djyonasty23 truthfully, you're a really smart person. you're beautiful in every way. you've probably got a great personality, and it's gonna bring you far in life. stay good, my friend. :-)
@CFTVVV
@CFTVVV 4 года назад
thanks anthony
@bigdongkong1854
@bigdongkong1854 2 года назад
-fantano’s letter to hitler
@addi5314
@addi5314 5 лет назад
He is being a tool, but that’s what makes this mixtape so beautiful. The vulnerability just hits you.
@jakobstrand4916
@jakobstrand4916 Год назад
01:48 ”the vocalist in this group”
@mjesec4081
@mjesec4081 2 года назад
“Could there possibly be a day where I’m enjoying auto-tune?” RODEO 8/10
@Fahad-pr7qu
@Fahad-pr7qu 2 года назад
Wow almost 3k likes and no dislikes, this must well liked among Anthony’s fans
@theneedledrop
@theneedledrop 13 лет назад
@MrBiggyben93 well i like you. :-) i hope you have a nice day. :-)
@notforsale9488
@notforsale9488 2 года назад
weeknd was too ahead of his time for the melon
@playboi_caid8301
@playboi_caid8301 3 года назад
“Man, giving MBDTF has to be the worst review that Anthony has ever done-“
@brandonpatel3121
@brandonpatel3121 2 года назад
To this day his worst review of all time
@allennatures2351
@allennatures2351 9 лет назад
I agree the lyrics are trash, but that criticism alone shouldn't hold much weight. People LOVE Paul McCartney, but how many beatles' songs are about "oh girl! hey girl!" with zero lyrical depth? The vocals and atmosphere on this album make it for me. My favorite Tom Waits album is Nighthawks at the Diner; it's nowhere near his lyrical best, but its atmosphere is solid.
@GiftedCombo
@GiftedCombo 6 лет назад
Allen Natures it was a different time back then for lyrics
@yagopaliza8749
@yagopaliza8749 5 месяцев назад
This need a classic album review/redux
@houston1293
@houston1293 7 месяцев назад
He doesn’t shut up abt auto tune. No wonder we would eventually hate birds in the trap
@canopaint2743
@canopaint2743 3 года назад
Anthony didnt like how cocky Abel was while singing. Little did he know he would give Lil Pump a 7 years later.
@crunkgirl711
@crunkgirl711 8 лет назад
Hold up did he call the weekend as a group lol I missed this review lol
@duartedsmoreira
@duartedsmoreira 8 лет назад
At that time people didnt knew if it was a group or a person, just look at The date...
@trenatibaker
@trenatibaker 8 лет назад
lol as soon as I heard that I immediately stopped the video lol
@duartedsmoreira
@duartedsmoreira 8 лет назад
ihatebitches oh i didn't even payed attention to That lmao
@sebastiank9997
@sebastiank9997 8 лет назад
the weeknd was originally Abel and Zodiac. there was beef, it never really got spoken about.
@Nimzie458202
@Nimzie458202 8 лет назад
+crunkgirl711 The Weekend is a Canadian band I believe, that's actually the reason for Abel changing the name to "The Weeknd" there was probably some confusion lol
@ubzue8402
@ubzue8402 2 года назад
I can see where he’s coming from. At the time this album was released, nobody really expected music like this, The Weeknd was way ahead of his time. But in this decade, this album is legendary.
@cesararellano9388
@cesararellano9388 4 года назад
I keep coming back to remind myself of how much of a low point this review is in Melon's career as a music reviewer. The first time I saw the review I was blinded by the fact he gave it a 3/10 when most people have it between a personal 8-10/10, so that didn't allow me to realize he criticized the album for showing its subject matters in the way it did. Anthony had no idea that was actually Abel's life and as such, he couldn't appreciate Abel being blatantly honest and putting that side of his life in HOB. Not to mention that his lifestyle is something many people are really far from relating to, which may have been an important factor for Anthony's point of view. It's so hard to relate to his lifestyle that in Kiss Land he sings the line: "This ain't nothing to relate to"
@ernestosanchez1612
@ernestosanchez1612 2 года назад
Lol. Ten years later. He calls the weekend “they” lol.
@man4437
@man4437 2 года назад
People lowkey just looking for reasons to hate him. I'm pretty sure it was a "they" initially and a lot of people thought this was like a full band
@davidhatle5486
@davidhatle5486 9 лет назад
I like that he acknowledges that the weeknd is not a one man project and doesn't idolize abel like all of his dumb hardcore fans do. Abel doesn't have a lot of input in the production of the sound, in fact, before he met Jeremy Rose he made regular r&b music and it never had such a dark atmosphere as in the trilogy. What i'm trying to say is that abel is a singer and the weeknd is a project
@superluigi2254
@superluigi2254 6 лет назад
The reason he called The Weeknd an "outfit" is because, at the time, it wasn't revealed that The Weeknd was only one person and most people thought it was a band.
@therandom58
@therandom58 6 лет назад
David Hatle u thought too deep and ended up sounding dumb
@megachadbrown7548
@megachadbrown7548 2 года назад
Bro would be a legend if he’d given this a good review
@man4437
@man4437 2 года назад
People would just find something else to complain about
@XBR4Da
@XBR4Da 8 лет назад
How dare you have an opinion!!!
@FleegalFlargel
@FleegalFlargel 8 лет назад
+XBR4Da An opinion that is based almost entirely on the character of this album, and not seemingly about anything else, then giving it a low score from that.
@xJoBoy
@xJoBoy 8 лет назад
+FleegalFlargel what does your comment even mean xD
@FleegalFlargel
@FleegalFlargel 8 лет назад
+xJoBoy To me Anthony barely talks about anything wrong with the album and concentrated on talking about something minute like the 'character of the album.' The only other thing he criticises is the 'autotune' which aside form the ending of one track there is none.
@xJoBoy
@xJoBoy 8 лет назад
FleegalFlargel thanks for clarifying.
@FleegalFlargel
@FleegalFlargel 8 лет назад
xJoBoy No problem.
@prod.bblickshit7923
@prod.bblickshit7923 5 лет назад
Anthony says he can’t imagine a day where he’ll enjoy auto tune then gives rodeo a 8. Oh how the times have changed
@williamschultz9517
@williamschultz9517 5 лет назад
3:52 sums up The Weeknd pretty well actually.
@morganfreeman2102
@morganfreeman2102 4 года назад
No?
@trapanddat.2125
@trapanddat.2125 3 года назад
Bruh Im pretty sure the lyrics for coming down won't fit for a geordie shore character. The melody for the knowing is one of the most beautiful things you will ever hear in your life. The production on house of balloons (song) is mind blowing and tbh the production is excellent on every single song. The weeknds voice is so capable it's awe -inspiring on tracks like the knowing and the morning. It really is an outstanding album. He really was another level it's maaad especially for his first album. And tbh fantano you kinda fucked up by not mentioning the production on this album it really is pristine. The opening synths on the morning with the blues guitar are exquisitely produced and come on that opening on the knowing.
@bionicallyacomputer292
@bionicallyacomputer292 2 года назад
fax
@J4zzyDrummer
@J4zzyDrummer 10 лет назад
Come on people, the guy has his own opinion. It is childish to come on here and do nothing but complain because he has a different taste in music than you or a different view on a certain album. He got a lot of requests for the review and knew that a lot of people liked house of balloons, but still had the balls to come out with his own honest review of what he thought of the album, and I respect him for that.
@projectx5154
@projectx5154 2 года назад
Wow, this must be a really good interview. I bet there are only 100 or so dislikes...
@beetlebat
@beetlebat 3 года назад
biggest L of all time
@Tmelton-bj3kf
@Tmelton-bj3kf 2 года назад
The glass tables is absolutely amazing I had no idea that this album would sound like this so glad I listened to it
@munirnayfeh94
@munirnayfeh94 5 лет назад
The weeknd isn’t a group he’s just that versatile
@mishmashmush
@mishmashmush 5 лет назад
Munir Nayfeh this was before anybody knew anything about the weeknd, people didn’t know if the weeknd was one guy or a group
@davidtheran911
@davidtheran911 3 года назад
damm 10 k dislikes is??????????????????? absolutely expected
@justarandomclonetrooperwit8119
@justarandomclonetrooperwit8119 3 года назад
Pre 2016 anthony had the worst music takes in history
@NikhilSingh-oe6iq
@NikhilSingh-oe6iq 2 года назад
2009 - 2013 was the worst phase known to humanity.
@deanorbase
@deanorbase 4 года назад
This album’s aged so well, still think it’s Abel’s best work to date
@Aryan-xs9kp
@Aryan-xs9kp 2 года назад
How can someone make a song like The Knowing??
@stuntxo3968
@stuntxo3968 2 года назад
That wasn't recorded on this planet , it's something indescribable
@jam4596
@jam4596 11 лет назад
Anthony, with all due respect, I think it's unfair to trash this album solely because of its lyrical content. I think you're completely underrating the quality of the production and the innovation he's brought to the R'n'B genre! I'm still astonished gave Asap's album an 8/10 seeing the quality of his lyrics compared to this one!
@GuysOfFilm
@GuysOfFilm 4 года назад
Live Love is years better than this shit, don't front
@shandharubinimohanaraj8235
@shandharubinimohanaraj8235 4 года назад
Anthony can't freaking relate to this masterpiece
@chasem4774
@chasem4774 3 года назад
Who’s here after The Weeknd’s incredible halftime show lmao?
@martytu20
@martytu20 3 года назад
An artist can release a shitty album and still deliver a halftime show for the ages. House of Balloons was far from shitty, it's an incredible mixtape that was part of the vanguard in alt-RnB. This review is terrible because Fantano got the facts wrong, it's clear his lens got in the way of him judging the artistic merits. He couldn't separate the persona in the album vs Weeknd the artist.
@kelleyreeves965
@kelleyreeves965 2 года назад
To this day, The Knowing is one of my favorite songs by The Weeknd. I feel like it's always overshadowed by Wicked Games
@Leo-wx3zy
@Leo-wx3zy 2 года назад
Wicked Games is so good
@kelleyreeves965
@kelleyreeves965 2 года назад
@@Leo-wx3zy I agree, but I think I like The Knowing a bit more. It's so beautiful
@theprinceofeverything1975
@theprinceofeverything1975 2 года назад
@@kelleyreeves965 well said man I like the knowing more too, imo there was more emotion put into it.
@kamikaze_2624
@kamikaze_2624 8 месяцев назад
3:15 crazy how he said this could be a tv show. The Idol. The show literally is about Abel’s experiences but people hates on it
@paulrg307
@paulrg307 3 года назад
Good luck explaining this to God
@martinquiroga5489
@martinquiroga5489 2 года назад
This just ain't the same without the dislike button
@RinsaVuIIer
@RinsaVuIIer 5 лет назад
1:32-1:37 is the only part of the review worth watching.
Далее
FANTANO RATINGS ON ALL THE WEEKND ALBUMS (2011-2023)
5:01
The Weeknd - After Hours ALBUM REVIEW
7:51
Просмотров 1,5 млн
He turned a baseball into a stylish shoe😱
00:59
Просмотров 534 тыс.
EVERY WEEKND ALBUM RANKED
2:59
Просмотров 122 тыс.
The Insane True Story of The Weeknd
43:45
Просмотров 1 млн
Drake - Scorpion ALBUM REVIEW
19:12
Просмотров 2,6 млн
The Weeknd - "After Hours" TRACK REVIEW
5:54
Просмотров 300 тыс.
The Weeknd - House of Balloons (first part only)
3:31
LISA - ROCKSTAR (Lyrics)
2:19
Просмотров 553 тыс.
Mirjalol Nematov - Barno (Videoklip)
3:30
Просмотров 1 млн