Тёмный

The Year That Killed Received Pronunciation (RP) 

Dr Geoff Lindsey
Подписаться 248 тыс.
Просмотров 300 тыс.
50% 1

Sign up for a 14-day free trial and enjoy all the amazing features MyHeritage has to offer bit.ly/DrGeoffLindseyMH
Practically the moment the familiar vowel symbols for British English were published, they plummeted drastically out of fashion. This video explains how and why.
0:00 Introduction
1:04 MyHeritage
2:45 A. C. Gimson's book
5:33 The 1960's
10:30 Advanced RP
14:02 Beautiful working class?
16:18 Satirizing RP
17:35 Stigmatization of poshness
18:08 Relaxing the front vowels
20:00 What didn't change
21:46 The fate of the term 'RP'
Piper www.pipebandsnc.com/pipe-band...
Queenslander Soldier Portraits • Soldier Portraits
Pillenwekker www.flickr.com/photos/nationa...
That Was The Week That Was • That Was The Week That...
Interview with John Profumo • INTERVIEW WITH JOHN PR...
Harold Wilson and Beatles • The Beatles receive a ...

Опубликовано:

 

13 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,3 тыс.   
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Sign up for a 14-day free trial and enjoy all the amazing features MyHeritage has to offer bit.ly/DrGeoffLindseyMH
@artemislogic5252
@artemislogic5252 Месяц назад
well integrated into the video, ill get the trial, im curious
@rogink
@rogink Месяц назад
I'm sold! First time I've followed a link from a YT video. My dad started logging the family history over 20 years ago. Considering we have a really unusual surname it's odd that he couldn't get back more than 200 years. I know my parents DoBs, but no further back; Dad is 91 so a bit late to ask for his parents' this late. I'll need to pester Dad tomorrow.
@erikgstewart
@erikgstewart Месяц назад
Have been building my family tree with MyHeritage since 2018, and also took their DNA-test. Have made lots of discoveries on both my British and Norwegian side of my family. Can highly recommend!
@cjay2
@cjay2 Месяц назад
NEVER give any biological sample to ANY company that offers to tell you some things. Why do you think it's free?
@xyz.ijk.
@xyz.ijk. Месяц назад
Do you teach improved accents?
@electricgecko8997
@electricgecko8997 Месяц назад
As a Canadian raised on Monty Python, I thought making fun of the upper class had ALWAYS been been a part of British identity. Fascinating.
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Well, you can find examples of the silly ass like Bertie Wooster, but it was new to treat the whole class as a joke.
@javiergilvidal1558
@javiergilvidal1558 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey That´s the point! The leading class (and traditional social conventions) had always been joked about, but never treated as a joke .... until the dire Sixties came along
@Ylyrra
@Ylyrra Месяц назад
It always has been, you can see this in print media going back centuries, however radio and TV were initially the playgrounds of the upper classes. That broke down in the 60s, first by an invasion of upper class comedians willing to mock other upper class figures and poshness in general, and gradually the old boys network breaking down after that. Personally I take the viewpoint that the *perceived* popularity of RP was the outlier, an artificial product of the temporary dominance of class barriers in the new forms of mass media that conveyed an accent for the first time, but I imagine there's historians who have far better knowledge of the subject than me.
@mkozlinski
@mkozlinski Месяц назад
As a Polish raised on Monty Python - same here :)
@nzlemming
@nzlemming Месяц назад
The fact that it was so popular in its time testifies to how unusual it was.
@dnavid
@dnavid Месяц назад
I left the UK in 76 for the USA. When I saw the movie Attack the Block and it's young Londoners I realized that the accent I had grown up with was becoming a fossil.
@thork6974
@thork6974 Месяц назад
"Allow it!"
@misterwhipple2870
@misterwhipple2870 Месяц назад
Looks like you got while the gettin' was good, pod'ner.
@dnavid
@dnavid Месяц назад
yep or as we used to say. yorp@@misterwhipple2870
@devenscience8894
@devenscience8894 Месяц назад
Trust.
@krayze144
@krayze144 25 дней назад
​@@misterwhipple2870 The gettin' in the UK was already very bad in 1976,much worse than it is even now unless you're talking about demographics in which case no comment lol
@MatthewMcVeagh
@MatthewMcVeagh Месяц назад
Alternative title: that was the accent that was.
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Excellent. If only it started with a W
@B_Ruphe
@B_Ruphe 28 дней назад
Not at all. Both ELF teachers in particular and attentive first-language English tutors know that this is far from being the case and the trend is markedly in the opposite direction among the young.
@MatthewMcVeagh
@MatthewMcVeagh 28 дней назад
@@B_Ruphe What is ELF? English as a Language Foreign? :D Do you have any studies that show what you say to be true?
@B_Ruphe
@B_Ruphe 28 дней назад
@@MatthewMcVeagh ELF is English as a Lingua Franca. It is hardly an obscure term in the English language teaching sphere. Large ELF movement in continental Europe. Probably less so out in the far west. ELF is rather at odds with mainstream EFL/ESOL thinking, since it promotes the notion of the inevitability of non-native teachers becoming the dominant force in ELT, by and by. ELF learners largely learn through CLIL.
@MatthewMcVeagh
@MatthewMcVeagh 27 дней назад
@@B_Ruphe OK, but it sounds like you're talking about non-native speakers adopting it. I can believe that, although I think with time it's probably going to fade away there too. I've also never heard a full RP accent from a non-native speaker, and I wonder how close the accents learned by ELF learners are.
@SianaGearz
@SianaGearz Месяц назад
I started learning English in the Soviet Union at the very end of 80s. We were supposed to learn RP from these squiggles, and maybe some old and well worn reel to reel tapes that were played in class once or twice. We also learned that there's 12 pence to a shilling, 20 shillings to a pound, and other such nonsense. We were tested on that, apparently this was important knowledge. I think the textbooks may have been a little out of date. We also learned German from pre-war era textbooks. It's absurd remembering how we were taught in comparison with the language spoken today. I suspect the most up-to-date language curriculum must have been Latin.
@samuelrobinson5842
@samuelrobinson5842 28 дней назад
It is fascinating learning about the 20th century being a Gen Z guy born in 2000. I can not conceive of a world where foreign languages were that foreign. You used to have tape and books, while now every language is accessible everywhere all at once in digital platform through the internet. Gone are the days of our American Code-Talkers
@MHLivestreams
@MHLivestreams 26 дней назад
Yes, learning about the old currency in the 80s was somewhat outdated, that system ended in 1971, some aspects remained though, such as 20 shillings in a pound, a shilling took the new value of 5 pence.
@sebastianriemer1777
@sebastianriemer1777 17 дней назад
When I meet my Finnish ex I started learning the language with the only book I could get my hands on (no real Internet in those days.). A language dictionary for the German soldier from 1941. My ex had lots of fun with my vocabulary. 🤣
@carnation_cat
@carnation_cat 13 дней назад
I don't have any stories to tell about language, but I still feel betrayed by my American school system because in the early 70s, they told us we needed to learn the metric system because that's what we would all be using in the USA when we grew up. 🙄 For grades 1-6, I was in an American school for missionary kids in the Philippines (2 years in an international school but it wasn't much different) but I'm pretty sure my peers back in the US were being told the same thing. Liars!! 😂 Somehow Britain managed to go metric, at least for most things, but Americans obviously weren't going to stand for such nonsense. 😝
@seamusesparza1943
@seamusesparza1943 13 дней назад
My formal education has consisted of dead languages, hence I don't care what the slang of the week is for jaggoffs.
@columbus8myhw
@columbus8myhw Месяц назад
As an American, those comedy sketches would have completely baffled me if you had not told me that they were making fun of the accent.
@DrunkenHotei
@DrunkenHotei Месяц назад
Same here, and my mom was a real anglophile. She even married a Brit later in life!
@christinescreativitycabine280
@christinescreativitycabine280 Месяц назад
"Pardon me, Mater, I'm off to play the GRAHND PEEAHNO!! Excuse me while I fly in my AEROPLANE!!" It all makes sense now!
@JoeStuffzAlt
@JoeStuffzAlt Месяц назад
When someone told me they were doing that in Monty Python, I was like "Oooohhh...." I had no idea
@kylemanson9355
@kylemanson9355 Месяц назад
Also that Jack Whitehalls speech is immediately recognizable as posh. As an American I never would have thought about that😂
@ZephyrysBaum
@ZephyrysBaum Месяц назад
As a British-Australian same.
@headlessnotahorseman
@headlessnotahorseman Месяц назад
"This whirlwind of social change had phonetic consequences" is the greatest line ever uttered in a history documentary.
@MrOtistetrax
@MrOtistetrax Месяц назад
“An* history” 😉
@j2k14
@j2k14 Месяц назад
​@@MrOtistetrax...no?
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
@@MrOtistetrax 'An' is only possible if the following syllable is weak, as in 'an historic event'. It's related to the fact that the /h/ can be dropped. Or maybe you were joking.
@MrOtistetrax
@MrOtistetrax Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey Hi Dr Geoff. Yeah, it was a weak attempt at a joke.
@saiyajedi
@saiyajedi Месяц назад
@@MrOtistetrax If you ’ave an accent that drops the aitches, sure. "An historic" is an outlier brought about by the initial syllable being unaccented and partly reduced.
@mytube001
@mytube001 Месяц назад
A smaller but equally rapid change took place in Sweden at around the same time. In the late 1960s, over the course of just a couple of years, the entire population went from addressing other people using formal titles, last names or "polite" pronouns, to using the informal second-person singular "du" (cognate with "thou", of course) throughout all levels of society. It hugely simplified interactions with people you before the change wouldn't have been on a first-name basis with. Instead of having to figure out what title to use, or resorting to convoluted and bizarre indirect sentence structures, everyone could just use one simple word. It made social interactions much less stressful and it helped lessen the gap between social classes.
@bevinboulder5039
@bevinboulder5039 Месяц назад
I spent a semester in Paris in 1969. As an American it was a minefield to negotiate the formal and informal forms of address especially since we were only taught the formal forms in our French classes. It was just as much a problem if you addressed someone as "vous" when you ought to use "tu". Just a nightmare.
@marsdeat
@marsdeat Месяц назад
@@bevinboulder5039 This is actually a problem I have with modern French teaching too. Classes are still not great at teaching the circumstances in which to use 'tu' and 'vous', but I do think it's been getting better (the fact that the informal seems to be creeping into higher and higher social registers helps). However, to this day, French classes will teach the first-person plural as "nous", despite the fact that as a subject pronoun "on" is far and away the more current form for most interactions. And yet they teach "on" as an afterthought, maybe mention that it's used for "we", but brush it aside after that and keep on teaching "nous" as the default.
@zbigniewkoza1973
@zbigniewkoza1973 Месяц назад
@@bevinboulder5039When I first came in France in 1990, I had already completed a one-year course of French based on a textbook printed in France. It advised to greet unknown women via "Je suis enchantée". I remember this was hilarious for the French, especially young ones, who certainly had never heard it spoken in a place other than a theater.
@bevinboulder5039
@bevinboulder5039 Месяц назад
@@zbigniewkoza1973 OMG! They're still doing it.
@bevinboulder5039
@bevinboulder5039 Месяц назад
@@marsdeat Not surprised. Taking this opportunity to say that learning French messed up my ability to spell English. I still keep trying to spell surprise with a "z"
@erictaylor5462
@erictaylor5462 13 дней назад
In the late 1970's we had a next door neighbor, the Bakers. He was American ands managed the local hardware store. His wife was English, spoke with a very pompous and very posh RP accent. I don't know how posh she was in England, but while he was very down to earth and quite friendly, she gave the impression that she considered herself well above those in her social circle and according to my parents, not very popular. I'm not sure she was entirely happy being married to a man who ran a shop, but he provided for his family well enough. The daughter was my age and we even dated a bit in high school. The house we lived in was part of a brand new development, and my family was the first to move into the street. The yards were all undone, and my dad delighted in having a yard to design. He worked as a welder and he built a heavy duty utility trailer and he let my sister (6) and me (8) choose the color. It was 1978 and we picked the brightest, most obnoxious color we could find. A super bright, day glow green. Dad kept the trailer next to the house and it lit up everything in green. We were all extremely delighted when the English neighbor complained that the trailer "Offended the finer senses." She was right, and that was the point. When dad got his yard installed he sold the trailer to a guy with a landscaping business. I happened to see him, he still had the trailer after owning it for 20 years. I walked up to the guy and asked him about it. I asked if he had it pained that color, or had repainted that color. He said, "No. The man I bought the trailer from said his kids chose the color. I purchased it because I had an accident with another driver who said he did not see the old trailer." I smiled and said, "Well, I'm glad my sister and I picked a good color no one would miss even 20 years later." We laughed and he said no one ever failed to see the trailer. It still offended the finer senses.
@csipawpaw7921
@csipawpaw7921 Месяц назад
This reminded me of something I heard from a retired FBI agent who joined the FBI around 1940. He was talking about the rules J. Edgar Hoover had established. One was that all employees had to speak with something close to what he thought of as an American mid-western accent (Which was close to what you heard in the American Hollywood movies of the time.). This was to ensure accurate communications. Any applicant that had a strong regional accent would be rejected.
@GizmoFromPizmo
@GizmoFromPizmo 28 дней назад
That automatically excludes those who speak with a "blackcent". 😆
@CalLadyQED
@CalLadyQED 28 дней назад
Probably an old version of General American.
@anndeecosita3586
@anndeecosita3586 20 дней назад
@@GizmoFromPizmoRednecks need not apply. Including the ones in the MidWest.
@anndeecosita3586
@anndeecosita3586 20 дней назад
I don’t know about the past but having moved to the Midwest, I have encountered people with what I consider as strong regional accents. I am from Southern California. A lot of MW people sound flat and nasal to me. Many pronounce their vowels differently than I do. Roof sounds like rough. As and Os are oftentimes dragged out here. I have mistaken some Northern MD people for Canadians or Scandinavians.
@imacds
@imacds 15 дней назад
​@GizmoFromPizmo Yeah, AAVE definitely comes to mind. This just sounded like the kind of rule that would exclude most immigrants, minorities, etc, without "appearing racist" on paper. It also sounds like a myth they would intentionally perpetuate so their non-midwestern-accented undercover agents could more easily infiltrate groups. xD
@MinionofNobody
@MinionofNobody Месяц назад
At the same time The Beatles were making a working class Liverpool accent more acceptable in Britain, their producer, George Martin, was using an affected upper class British accent to make himself more acceptable in business and social circles. Things were definitely changing.
@WhiteCamry
@WhiteCamry Месяц назад
What was GM's natural accent?
@MinionofNobody
@MinionofNobody Месяц назад
@@WhiteCamry I don’t remember. I once watched an interview in which he discussed it. He said his posh accent was fake but his wife’s was real. There is a lengthy Wikipedia article on him but, as an America, the various place names where he was born and lived are meaningless to me.
@thejoin4687
@thejoin4687 Месяц назад
And old Brian too.
@nsf001-3
@nsf001-3 Месяц назад
Code switching, another psychotic human creation
@Elitist20
@Elitist20 Месяц назад
He first adopted the RP accent as a naval officer in WW2. Coming from north London, most likely he would have grown up sounding (mildly) Cockney.
@zak3744
@zak3744 Месяц назад
With regard to the change of social perceptions of accents, something I stumbled upon recently was that you can find recordings of election results programmes from different years on RU-vid. This was fascinating to me as you can see how the speech of the presenters change over time. They always inherently tend towards formal and "posh" speech as heavyweight political TV commentators, and the event itself is one of the most formal and "serious" on TV, so it's hardly a snapshot of normal speech, and the speech on such programmes will always appear rather stuffy and formal, even slightly archaic at the time of broadcast, but it's a constant setting that you can compare throughout the years. (And you hear the contrast of the "posh, presentery" with regional accents from candidates and pundits in any single programme) So I was looking through some of these, fascinated at hearing the historic accents, when I stumbled into the 1997 coverage, when I was a couple of years too young to vote, but definitely remember watching it all at the time. (I very dimly recall 1992, but 1997 was really my "first" election as an observer) And I was struck by how almost comically archaic some of the accents sounded! Yet, I never had this sense at the time. It would have sounded a bit stuffy, sure, but not amusingly alien. A real eye-opener on how much my own perceptions must have changed with the changing of the language!
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Yes, a treasure trove.
@jonathanfinan722
@jonathanfinan722 Месяц назад
You should listen to how journalism royalty, Kate Adie's accent changed over the years. It's quite astonishing.
@elmike-o5290
@elmike-o5290 Месяц назад
And - to combine a couple of themes here - Monty Python’s “Election coverage” sketch makes fun of this very point.
@twolery1514
@twolery1514 Месяц назад
Perhaps one lesson is that if you want to kill off some form of speech, you should write a book declaring that it is the new standard!
@KateGladstone
@KateGladstone 15 дней назад
I wonder if that will happen with some of the recent changes in third-person pronouns in English, which are so hotly defended and increasingly enforced.
@jazztrombone
@jazztrombone 14 дней назад
@@KateGladstone When I was in school I remember being marked down in my essay writing for using the pronoun “they” and told to use the more cumbersome “he or she.” I think what is more likely is that gender specific pronouns like he or she will be used less and less.
@SamDiMento
@SamDiMento 14 дней назад
That is exactly correct! Those are the kinds of times we live in.
@edenwylie8917
@edenwylie8917 14 дней назад
@@KateGladstone are the words themselves being enforced, or just tolerance for people's identity? i don't think anyone is being asked to use "they" for people who aren't non-binary. we make up a very small proportion of the population too, so it seems unlikely to have much effect on the language as a whole other than slightly increased use of a few specific words. it'll be interesting to see what happens with romantic languages though, and others that are fully gendered.
@Meepersa
@Meepersa 12 дней назад
@@jazztrombone I specifically asked an English teacher for one of my classes if singular "they" was acceptable to use in essays for his class. He was fine with it, so there seems to be at least some changing attitudes. Not the least because it's a very old usage of the word and it's quite common in informal speech for people of unknown or irrelevant gender.
@mariposahorribilis
@mariposahorribilis Месяц назад
A lovely example of the rise in acceptance of regional accents can be heard in the BBC documentary about the climbing of The Old Man of Hoy in the 1980s. In it, you can hear clips from the earlier televised climb in the 1960s. Joe Brown, a working class mancunian who took part in both climbs, can be heard veering from a strangulated RP in the older documentary to a more relaxed and natural mode of speech in the newer programme.
@ticketyboo2456
@ticketyboo2456 26 дней назад
Unfortunately the Manchester accent has now become quite ugly.
@PeteLorimer
@PeteLorimer Месяц назад
The Advanced RP of the UK was mirrored by a similar trend in American accents at prestigious, private schools. (This was still the era of the mid-Atlantic accent in Hollywood). Look to the character of Gloria Upson in the 1958 movie Auntie Mame. Her affected accent has many of the same vowel sounds as Advanced RP. Which are most easily made by jutting it your jaw and locking it in place.
@RossReedstrom
@RossReedstrom Месяц назад
I learned that as "Locust Valley Lockjaw"
@placebojesus5652
@placebojesus5652 Месяц назад
Is that like the “Transatlantic” accent of someone like William F. Buckley?
@placebojesus5652
@placebojesus5652 Месяц назад
Is that like the “Transatlantic” accent of someone like William F. Buckley?
@placebojesus5652
@placebojesus5652 Месяц назад
Is that like the “Transatlantic” accent of someone like William F. Buckley?
@squirlmy
@squirlmy Месяц назад
@@placebojesus5652 that's a "Yale accent" although also noticeable in the alumni of other Ivy League schools at that time. Note that Buckley first enrolled at the National Autonomous University of Mexico until 1943, then after serving in the US Army, he attended Yale. It's also the accent of Thurston Howell in the show Giligan's Island. Also, Cary Grant tried to imitate this accent in his early career, and did so badly, but with such consistent effort, that it his accent became his own exclusive "trademark". Upper-class Americans didn't feel their speech was being made fun of, there was no real resemblance to it, while lower class understood he was speaking in some sort of accent that identified "poshness", even though it wasn't a real accent of anyone else. Could even have been interpreted as a foreign accent, as if he was a recent but well-educated immigrant! He was not, of course.
@ghostofmybrain
@ghostofmybrain Месяц назад
"As long as we know what we're talking about, we could call the accent Kevin" had me on the floor
@BrennanYoung
@BrennanYoung Месяц назад
Kevinist propaganda
@kevingray4980
@kevingray4980 Месяц назад
That might confuse me.
@jamesdewane1642
@jamesdewane1642 Месяц назад
Kevin is not the most prominent Minion by accident. The star character in Home Alone is Kevin. Stereotypically, Kevin is prone to interpret the world in an idiosyncratic way, generally without malice, leading to consternation and delight by turns. Kevin is always well-loved. Great name for an accent.
@faithlesshound5621
@faithlesshound5621 Месяц назад
Not many non-specialists called it "Received Pronunciation." It was commoner to speak of "The Queen's English" (earlier The King's English") but that created an ambiguity. Were they talking about how the Queen herself spoke? That was quite unlike most of her subjects, but no one dared to lampoon her before Lord Altrincham took the gloves off in 1957. That led to the Queen undergoing instruction to change the way she spoke.
@thomasrengel5577
@thomasrengel5577 Месяц назад
Lionel were better!
@pamelaroyce5285
@pamelaroyce5285 Месяц назад
I’m an American and always loved hearing RP in old movies. As a child I liked movies with Ronald Colman and David Niven, who made English sound beautiful.
@ccxl8260
@ccxl8260 Месяц назад
Unfortunately, it doesn’t exist anymore. nowadays, almost all British try to sound uneducated and sound like they brought up in slums.
@jonathanfinan722
@jonathanfinan722 Месяц назад
As an English person I find those accents nauseating. They are so redolent of everything that was wrong with colonial arrogance and, if I may coin a term, utter twattery.
@MrBulky992
@MrBulky992 Месяц назад
My favourite for old RP is "Brief Encounter", the film of 1945 with Trevor Howard and Celia Johnson which is iconic. Miss Johnson says "tirriblih, tirriblih" at one point but the whole film is like that. The woman serving in the station buffet has an attempt at a cockney-style, lower class accent.
@hektor6766
@hektor6766 Месяц назад
And Americans like Katherine Hepburn and Gloria Swanson spoke with that Mid-Atlantic accent as well.
@misterwhipple2870
@misterwhipple2870 Месяц назад
I have no real reason, but I always hated David Niven, that is, the character he always played. To me, it seemed unbelievably prissy and overdone. To me, that was RP at its most strained.
@666deadman1988
@666deadman1988 Месяц назад
We have our own version of RP in Northern Ireland which I've heard called a "newsreader" or "UTV" (Ulster Television) accent which is essentially a particularly posh, almost anglophone version of a Belfast accent. The name comes from the fact that it is usually the kind of accent used by people on the news or TV in general over here that is considered very put on and inauthentic. A lot of celebrities from here go a bit newsreader to our ears when they get famous in Britain or America, probably done so in case their real way of speaking might be hard to understand to other English speakers.
@wobblybobengland
@wobblybobengland Месяц назад
do they say fylam instead of film?
@Mordecrox
@Mordecrox 8 дней назад
As ESL, the bit about people not understanding their original accent reminds me of that interview with Pierce Brosnan when the interviewer reveals he comes from his hometown of Navan. From that point my comprehension dropped by 40% as Brosnan reminisces about his time as a wee lad in 'avan, it is pretty clear he defaulted to his hometown accent since the host can keep up.
@thejoin4687
@thejoin4687 Месяц назад
Worth mentioning the interview with the Beatles on the eve of their appearance at the 1963 royal variety show. The interviewer is asking them about whether they'll modify their behaviour/appearance/speech given that they'll be appearing before the Queen Mother. He then mentions that Tory MP Ted Heath (who epitomised an 'affected' RP accent) had said that he "couldn't distinguish the Beatles' accents", and Lennon answers with a mock RP accent and the jibe that he "won't vote for Ted".
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
The look to camera as he says that chills the blood. So much more to be said about all of this.
@bjornopitz6561
@bjornopitz6561 Месяц назад
​@@DrGeoffLindsey yes, please! :-)
@gerrycoogan6544
@gerrycoogan6544 Месяц назад
When I first heard that interview, I was convulsed with laughter. It was so refreshing to hear "The Establishment" being so ruthlessly and directly lampooned. It made me an instant fan of John Lennon. I'd love to hear it again. I think the interviewer may have been Peter Woods.
@squirlmy
@squirlmy 29 дней назад
Yes ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1tvdJYxqxWM.html then he does some Scot accent (i think).
@squirlmy
@squirlmy 29 дней назад
​@@DrGeoffLindsey I think what's chilling about the jibe, is that they are four boys kidding around and literally poking each other playfully, and then John becomes the informed adult, who knows what his political interests are. Exactly parallel to the misperception of lower-class accents indicating ignorance. Dare I say 'bit of Irish in 'im coming out. ☘
@SteinGauslaaStrindhaug
@SteinGauslaaStrindhaug Месяц назад
I'm pretty sure the 60s was when most people in Norway stopped putting on a "standard accent" (i.e. bokmål with a western Oslo accent, or Nynorsk with any big city accent) when speaking in more formal settings and started using their regular accent/dialect in all settings. Somewhat ironically in the 70s (or so) a lot of people in the labour movement who naturally spoke a western Oslo accent began putting on a fake eastern Oslo working class accent to avoid sounding too posh. The 60s/70s is also (like in Sweden) the time we more or less completely stopped using the traditional polite address of using last names and titles and the second person plural "De" to refer to people politely to ising the second person singular "du" and first names. By the 1990s we barely even remember to address the royals in polite forms when speaking to them in person. One journalist famously kept saying "du" (informal "you") rather than "deres kongelige høyhet" ("your royal highness") to the crown prince in a series of interviews filmed over several days because it's now so unnatural for us not to be informal with everyone. And when we speak about the royals we fairly regularly refer to them only by their first name without any titles; and the crown prince which properly is "kronprinsen" we very often refer to as the silly shortened form "krompen".
@seramer8752
@seramer8752 Месяц назад
And we have an african shaman screwing the princess. Such progress.
@Jablicek
@Jablicek Месяц назад
I was told, when living there, that the "Frogner" accent was true Norwegian/Bokmål, but that was from my ex-husband who was a bit peculiar.
@edwardblair4096
@edwardblair4096 Месяц назад
Well as long as you don't use Krumpas you will probably be ok.
@squirlmy
@squirlmy Месяц назад
@@edwardblair4096 Krumpus is the accent of trolls, of course.
@pavelandel1538
@pavelandel1538 23 дня назад
Norway reminds me somewhat of Switzerland, where people stick to their regional accents, but due to lack of standardization of the various Allemanic dialects, Hochdeutsch is used in formal settings. Strangely enough, this doesn't apply to the French speaking part, where everyone pretty much sounds standard French. I think, it's great when people resist the homogenization of their speech, it keeps the linguistic diversity alive.
@higfny
@higfny 15 дней назад
As a non-native english speaker (and having never lived in a english speaking country) I don't relate british dialects/sosiolects to class as brits do. But I must say that what you describe as old fashioned RP (like the queen spoke) is much easier to understand and more pleasant to listen to than most speakers today. Thats the impression of most people I know.
@martijnb5887
@martijnb5887 11 дней назад
agreed
@psoon04286
@psoon04286 10 дней назад
I think that’s why international audience enjoy listening to Attenborough’s narration
@alexalexin9491
@alexalexin9491 10 дней назад
Absolutely. And the glottal stop instead of T's is so vulgar, ew.
@ChrisLonsdale67
@ChrisLonsdale67 9 дней назад
RP was certainly lovely to listen to. The mockery of the '60s generation which consigned RP to the dustbin ushered in an era of endlessly lowering standards in speech. Nowadays, people's accents, grammar, diction, etc, are in a lamentable state. So I, for one, do not celebrate the demise of RP.
@JeantheSecond-ip7qm
@JeantheSecond-ip7qm 9 дней назад
@@ChrisLonsdale67What you call a lamentable state is actually just language changing.
@pamelamanning99
@pamelamanning99 10 дней назад
I'm a New England native having morning coffee and seeing what random videos are popping up on my feed. I had little interest in this topic yet you captured my full attention throughout. Oh, if only more university professors here had your excellent communication skill! Thank you.
@torchris1
@torchris1 Месяц назад
I finally understand where Dr Frankenfurter's accent in Rocky Horror Picture Show comes from!!
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Especially 'lab' and 'slab'
@torchris1
@torchris1 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey I saw a snippet of an interview with Tim Curry where he said he tried German and it just didn’t work and he ended up doing a “Belgravia Hostess with the Mostest” accent.
@xxPenjoxx
@xxPenjoxx Месяц назад
I always thought Tim Curry must have been Scottish because he rolled his R's so much, especially in "kicked to the ground"
@torchris1
@torchris1 Месяц назад
@@xxPenjoxx If you listen closely to Sweet Transvesite, he has a crazy way of pronouncing "around" and "sound" that has to be this Advanced RP!
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
@@torchris1 I haven't got total recall of the song, but that MOUTH vowel was definitely an RP signature which I mention in various videos including my previous one. The most noticeable feature was the lack of rounding. People would sometimes write 'house' as 'hice' to depict a posh accent.
@wolfie854
@wolfie854 Месяц назад
This is fascinating. So glad you posted this.
@Twannnng
@Twannnng Месяц назад
Lovely work on the closing credits too!
@CookieFonster
@CookieFonster Месяц назад
oh my god, i love that credits sequence. i can't wait for the follow-up to this video
@RickyHarline
@RickyHarline 17 дней назад
Truly outstanding presentation. Seriously well done! You are a gifted communicator and educator.
@peterjohncooper
@peterjohncooper 26 дней назад
What a fascinating and well reasoned presentation. As a user of the English language (I'm a poet and playwright) who lived through this era I was aware of this shift but have never heard it analysed and explained so clearly. Thank you.
@megapangolin1093
@megapangolin1093 Месяц назад
Cracking delve into the joys of the British obsession with class, and its linguistic identifiers. Loved the historical and cultural elements to this vid, Geoff. It would be good to throw in a few more like this for other elements of language in the future, do'n cha know. Thank you.
@Ralphieboy
@Ralphieboy Месяц назад
A friend of mine in Germany (whose teacher must've studied RP) approacher her teachier about translating the lyrics to the Beathles' "Yesterday". At which point he corrected her in that it was pronounced "YestaDEE". As in "Yesterday, all my troubles were so far awee..."
@jeffreyjoshuarollin9554
@jeffreyjoshuarollin9554 Месяц назад
Fascinating video, as always
@verify231
@verify231 Месяц назад
What an excellent and fascinating video! Thank you dr Lindsey for continously sharing your expertise here on YT. Special kudos for the credits sequence. A video on why and how phonetic symbols became fossilised would be very interesting as well!
@Iopia100
@Iopia100 Месяц назад
Fascinating as always. The story of advanced RP reminds me in some ways of the Dublin 4 accent in Ireland, which became popular among young elites in the 1970s-80s, before quickly becoming so ridiculed to the point where it became largely neutered only 20 or 30 years later. Nonetheless, its legacy as the stereotypical 'posh' Dublin accent carries on to this day. Geoff, I would love to see a video on this topic, if it is something that interests you! From Wikipedia: "New Dublin English largely evolved out of an even more innovative variety, Dublin 4 English, which originated around the 1970s or 1980s from middle- or higher-class speakers in South Dublin before spreading outwards. Also known as "D4" or "DART speak" because of local associations, or, mockingly, "Dortspeak", this dialect rejected traditional, conservative, and working-class notions of Irishness, with its speakers instead regarding themselves as more trendy and sophisticated. However, particular aspects of the D4 accent became quickly noticed and ridiculed as sounding affected or elitist by the 1990s, causing its defining features to fall out of fashion by the 1990s."
@lamudri
@lamudri Месяц назад
The situation in Dublin seems extremely complicated - even more so than in London. I'd like to know more about the dialects there, but I think it would take a real expert on that specific topic to explain it.
@faithlesshound5621
@faithlesshound5621 Месяц назад
@@lamudri Would Dortspeak have been ridiculed for being "West British," I wonder?
@c.h.benwan3793
@c.h.benwan3793 Месяц назад
Hi Geoff, I found this particularly priceless. RP being not that geographically geared is, I think, a direct product of the British class system. For a foreign learner like me, the video provides invaluable social context. Thank you.
@joebloggs396
@joebloggs396 Месяц назад
Class systems have been in place everywhere in the world and it's natural they would be linked to language
@snowmonster42
@snowmonster42 Месяц назад
I think that I finally understand Richard E. Grant's accent fully. -- his teachers were in Africa while all of those social changes were occurring. I guess this applies to Freddie Mercury as well, but I'm more familiar with his singing voice than his speaking voice. Edit: as I re-read this comment I realize I haven't offered any context. I have seen several sources remarking that the people who speak the best, most perfect English (i.e., with the "right" accent) are those who were raised in Africa or India or other, now former colonies. Two famous examples are Grant, who was born in Swaziland, Freddie Mercury in Zanzibar. Very interesting and all that, but presumably because I am American, I wondered first if this was actually true and second why that would be the case. Still not sure if this is really a "tell," but your video definitely explains why this could occur. Thanks!
@thedarkthird1474
@thedarkthird1474 Месяц назад
Reckon this is your best video so far mate, well done. The history section was very good and shows how all of these things are interconnected and you can't just look at a topic like this in a vacuum. Would love to hear more examples of phonetics as influenced by a wider cultural shift
@osvaldobenavides5086
@osvaldobenavides5086 Месяц назад
I love this channel!!! Every video a gem!
@leod-sigefast
@leod-sigefast Месяц назад
18:05 "...it became possible to sound too posh for your own good". The first thought that popped into my head was that twit (tamest word I could employ) Rees-Mogg.
@misterwhipple2870
@misterwhipple2870 Месяц назад
Yes, he really went ape with his accent.
@smacwhinnie
@smacwhinnie Месяц назад
As an American, i find him easy on the ears.
@squirlmy
@squirlmy 29 дней назад
​@@smacwhinnie I didn't know who he was, found a video of a BBC interview. Interestingly the interviewer starts by asking isn't the American killing of Al Zawahiri "a huge scalp to get"? WTF? I guess the interviewer is getting ready to set him up later, by starting with some casual racism.
@cheradenine1980
@cheradenine1980 Месяц назад
I say, what a simply exquisite moving picture.
@derekdurst9984
@derekdurst9984 15 дней назад
BRAVO! Stunningly well done!
@eworr
@eworr 16 дней назад
Dear Dr. Lindsey. I've just cime across this video and found it fascinating. As a language student of the late 1980s-early 1990s, the tremendous preoccupation with RP has always fascinated me, particularly as a fan of George Bernard Shaw and the plan to invent an acceptable and inoffensive accent for the BBC. I hope you realize that your video would have greatly upset some of the lesser but more popularized authorities on linguistics, phonetics ad, particularly, accents of my generation. The real experts would, of course, have recognized the inevitable futility of an imposed form of speech as a long-term project. Thanks for this. You've made my day!
@ianboard544
@ianboard544 26 дней назад
As an American who lived in England when I was younger, I found it interesting that you could tell a lot more about someone's socioeconomic class in England from their speech than you could in the United States.
@Jadzia_Dax
@Jadzia_Dax Месяц назад
This change in prestige is commented upon in the opening minutes of the first ever Doctor Who episode 'An Unearthly Child' originally broadcast on 23 November 1963. (LIVELY MUSIC PLAYING ON RADIO) Barbara: Susan. Susan: Oh, I'm sorry, Miss Wright. I didn't hear you coming in. Aren't they fabulous? Barbara: Who? Susan: It's John Smith and the Common Men. They've gone from 19 to 2. Barbara: Oh. Ian: John Smith is the stage name of the honourable Aubrey Waites. He started his career as Chris Waites and the Carollers, didn't he, Susan? Susan: You are surprising, Mr Chesterton. I wouldn't expect you to know things like that. Ian: I have an enquiring mind. And a very sensitive ear.
@longhaulblue
@longhaulblue Месяц назад
I still have a copy of the Oxford Dictionary (the abridged or the shorter?) my parents gave me when I left Malaysia to go to the US to study. I recognized the Gimson symbols; the dictionary used it to describe pronunciation. And I also distinctly remember being confused when I encountered the IPA years later, trying to correlate it with the Gimson symbols. It was not something I dwelt on but this video has finally cleared it up for me. Many thanks. I really enjoyed the video.
@mkss1421
@mkss1421 11 дней назад
Very informative. Interesting and concise
@RatelHBadger
@RatelHBadger Месяц назад
Traditional RP- The Goons Advanced RP - Monty Python Southern English - Shawn of the Dead
@susanhenderson5001
@susanhenderson5001 Месяц назад
I have long been an ardent admirer of Cary Grant and would love to see how he ended up coming up with his iconic and unique accent - where all the parts of it came from and its construction. Hope this is something that would interest you. Thanks for your continually engaging content. Best wishes from the Pacific NW.
@michaelwisniewski6047
@michaelwisniewski6047 Месяц назад
That’s brilliantly put! Thank you, this actually clarifies some matters for me, given I wasn’t around in 1960s and I’m not native.
@Sithoid
@Sithoid 25 дней назад
I can't believe you missed out on the title "RIP RP" Thanks for all the information though, that was fascinating!
@Andrew-rc3vh
@Andrew-rc3vh Месяц назад
Reverse Polish was killed after the HP calculator.
@irgendwieanders2121
@irgendwieanders2121 Месяц назад
Fringe (not all of them will have had my maths teacher...)
@KitagumaIgen
@KitagumaIgen Месяц назад
It never died - I have an HP 15C on my mobile phone.
@quantisedspace7047
@quantisedspace7047 Месяц назад
Didn't Texas Instruments do one ? Then there the language Forth. Actually, maybe someone should do an RPN calc as an Android app.
@irgendwieanders2121
@irgendwieanders2121 Месяц назад
@@quantisedspace7047 Playstore offered me RPN calculator apps via autocomplete after inputting "reverse po"...
@bjornopitz6561
@bjornopitz6561 Месяц назад
What the hell are you talking about? 😂
@livrowland171
@livrowland171 Месяц назад
This is insightful, but I would say the demise of RP shouldn't be too overexaggerated. I grew up in a middle class family in North Yorkshire and went to a private 'prep' school in the late 70s to early 80s and we all spoke 'RP' more or less then (I remember one teacher there in particular, who had a very old-fashioned upper class, drawling kind of speech - he looked and sounded rather like Churchill). Apparently I started off with a slight Yorkshire accent from my state nursery school but my first teacher at the prep school soon told me the 'right' way to speak, with long 'ah' sounds in bath and path etc. I went to a state comprehensive after that where more people (but not everyone) had Yorkshire accents. But then I went to a (more academic, but still 'state') grammar school, where I remember an English teacher, helping me prepare for a debating competition, telling me my pronunciation of bury (with an 'uh' sound) was wrong and I should say it like 'berry' - so I probably lost my last more Yorkshire pronunciation then! An RP accent was definitely still associated with prestige and education then. My accent now is not as posh as when I was little, but it is still a quite neutral, 'dictionary' sort of pronunciation, and not regional. I live abroad now but most of my family and their friends in the UK still speak more or less 'RP', though toned down compared to the old BBC newsreaders. You won't often now hear the sort of accent where, for example, people would have said something like 'het' instead of 'hat' and 'room' would have the same sound as 'foot'. But maybe all accents are tending to move a bit closer -- fewer speak with a really 'broad' Yorkshire accent, and fewer speak with an extreme version of RP.
@0ia
@0ia Месяц назад
Haven't watched the video yet but I like the idea that "RP"stands for role-play.
@williambavington5392
@williambavington5392 Месяц назад
I grew up in Kent and with a lower middle-class upbringing so I went to a state school. We were taught what I mistakenly called RP but was really General Southern English with correct grammar and no dialect. Same at university (Bristol, 1970s); people from all over with many, mostly middle-class 'softened' accents but correct grammar, no dialect. In the 1980s I lived and worked in Manchester for five years, again with mostly middle-class people from all over where the accents veered toward what I tend to call (don't know if that is the correct term) General Northern English with the short 'a' etc. That being the North-West so I don't know if the North-East middle-class (as opposed to working-class regional) English is much different. There are always the occasional people I've met with strong regional accents (and not necessarily living in the areas where their accent comes from) but I tended to find them in the minority in the circles I frequented. I've never really met anyone who actually speaks 'posh' RP English: only seen it satirized on Television all my life.
@bruh666
@bruh666 9 дней назад
this is one of your most interesting videos yet
@brooke_reiverrose2949
@brooke_reiverrose2949 Месяц назад
Very interesting and enlightening, thank you!
@rozzgrey801
@rozzgrey801 Месяц назад
I had guessed the year would be 1963, so I was close. I grew up in a lower working class council estate in the 60's, a place built for Londoners displaced by the war where they spoke a kind of weird cockney accent, and I well recall the contempt we all had for rich posh gits who dressed like penguins and listened to chamber music (classical music) and we had hours of fun deriding them and their accent.
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Yes, you can make a case that 1963 was 'the' year (not that it matters tbh), but e.g. the seeds of the Profumo scandal were planted in 1962.
@threethrushes
@threethrushes Месяц назад
Aren't they wonderful!
@dinkster1729
@dinkster1729 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey I would say that the scandals in the modern Royal Family must have shaken the U.K. to its core. I do note that a poll of Canadians support Prince Harry which doesn't seem to be the case in the U.K. I guess he was trying to tell his Royal Familly members to straighten up and fly right. It hasn't worked. They are content to march on like lemmings going over a cliff.
@Confucius_76
@Confucius_76 15 дней назад
wow well done you!
@Vingul
@Vingul 6 дней назад
And now both accents (RP and cockney) are dead or dying. Would be a lot cooler if they were both still around.
@matthewrippingsby5384
@matthewrippingsby5384 Месяц назад
Great lecture, well argued. Thanks!
@Destructor111
@Destructor111 15 дней назад
I appreciate the attention to detail in how you processed the Patreon members' names. Very nice reproduction of the artefacts of sixties TV.
@leod-sigefast
@leod-sigefast Месяц назад
This video goes well with Simon Roper's Upper Class accents through time (Did the British Once Sound American?). Two fantastic academics on linguistics. Thanks Dr Lindsey!
@chrisrus1965
@chrisrus1965 Месяц назад
It's like the William F. Buckley and Gore Vidal upper class accent that seems to live on only in the movies. There was Thurston Howell the Third on Guligan's Island and his wife, Lovey. I think when Gore Vidal and those guys died, the accent died with them. No one could talk like that with a straight face. The same phenomenon happened in the UK and probably donno lots of other countries.
@elisaastorino2881
@elisaastorino2881 Месяц назад
I thought the same. There's a name for that accent - is it Mid Atlantic something or other? It was also widely taught.
@michaeltoohey1385
@michaeltoohey1385 Месяц назад
George Plimpton also sounded almost English, his accent being a product of his family background.
@ralphl7643
@ralphl7643 Месяц назад
Eleanor Roosevelt sounded more like the young late Queen than an American.
@pedazodetorpedo
@pedazodetorpedo Месяц назад
In the case of William F Buckley he actually learnt English as a child in England, so his accent was literally transatlantic.
@thork6974
@thork6974 Месяц назад
We Muricans call that the New England accent, or we once did.
@Jammyman998
@Jammyman998 Месяц назад
Fascinating video, thanks :)
@kitko33
@kitko33 Месяц назад
Fascinating video!
@JoeStuffzAlt
@JoeStuffzAlt Месяц назад
I remember a while ago, an American woman wanted to show how to pronounce a British accent. I think she heard a lot of the posh accent from British comedies, and some people said it was a very Monty Python accent (we got Monty Python in the USA for a very long time). She got lambasted Poor woman. Then again, the Internet wasn't at the stage it is now
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Yes, we now get far fewer Americans doing over-posh British and Brits doing 'American' as a cowboy.
@thork6974
@thork6974 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey There's a fun anecdote going around about a student of Japanese being told his diction is fine but his intonation comes from watching too many gangster films.
@user-pv2fd3eu3p
@user-pv2fd3eu3p Месяц назад
Fascinating set of comments to a fascinating video. Alongside the RP pronunciation there was also the "RP" grammar and sentence construction, for instance - " having agreed this, we can move on to..., based on continued struggle to reflect the meaning of Latin past participles, or the avoidance of prepositions at end of sentences, which is still the standard Dutch/Germanic way of constructing sentences. I also notice nowadays the common dropping of the "-ly" ending to convert adjectives into verbs ( whether that is a more recent change I don't know).
@cshairydude
@cshairydude Месяц назад
It's not standard, in fact it's an error, in German to put a preposition at the end of a sentence. Where a word that looks like a proposition appears there, it's not actually a preposition but a particle, the separated part of a separable verb. For example in "Ich steige auf mein Auto auf" = "I get in my car", "auf" appears twice, once as a preposition and again as a particle as part of the verb "aufsteigen". Dangling prepositions generally happen in English in relative clauses and questions, e.g. "Which car are you going to get in?" - in German, "Auf welches Auto stehst du auf?" - the preposition still goes before the noun. If you make the subject a pronoun, it merges with the preposition: "Which are you getting in?" - "Worauf stehst du auf?"
@terrytse1774
@terrytse1774 Месяц назад
Thank you for your video... this is fascinating. It would love to see you analyze the speech patterns of historical recordings before the 1960s.
@technoman9000
@technoman9000 Месяц назад
Your "advanced RP" examples reminded me of Lady Cynthia Fitzmelton from the Hitch Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy BBC Radio Play (first episode), when she arrived at Arthur's house to dedicate the "most splendid and worthwhile" bypass to be driven through his home. Her speech had the very air of "pompous self-importance" it's meant to convey. Fortunately, she soon thereafter vanished in a puff of hydrogen, ozone, and carbon monoxide.
@38mikefox
@38mikefox Месяц назад
Another great and informative episode.
@user-pq3dr7xb8u
@user-pq3dr7xb8u Месяц назад
Thanks! Interesting and good to know, as always.
@robkb4559
@robkb4559 28 дней назад
Ebsoliutely fescinating - thenk you sew march. Subscribed!
@martinholmes-ue9ko
@martinholmes-ue9ko Месяц назад
Fascinating. Thanks.
@Sidistic_Atheist
@Sidistic_Atheist Месяц назад
My mother was born in *Bolton* in 1929. Though one wouldn't have thought it, when hearing her speak.. She had her accent educated out of her by rout. And brought me in the same way, from 1965 (ie) "Mum, I'm going tut, shop." err!! "You mean you are going, to *the* shop." But now it's ok to say *"Thas dunt talk propa, like what us does"* . ha ha ha
@thork6974
@thork6974 Месяц назад
I don't think I ever heard my mother's Philadelphia accent, but she must have had one at some point.
@mags102755
@mags102755 Месяц назад
When I was younger, I traveled to the UK often for work (I'm a New Englander). This was about 30 years ago. RP was very much in evidence in London, where I stayed. I can see now how it has changed. Fascinating stuff. Thanks Dr. Lindsey.
@ezequielescobar7053
@ezequielescobar7053 Месяц назад
Great video as always! Thank Dr. Lindsey (and please consider continuing the dictionary's edition; it would love seeing the great change of symbols, or the real ones😅)
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Which dictionary?
@ezequielescobar7053
@ezequielescobar7053 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey the pronunciation dictionary that has been written by J. Wells.. now that he's not going to continue it, you could do a new version with the phonetic symbol system that you use. It could be a great opportunity to change/restore the symbols.
@drziggyabdelmalak1439
@drziggyabdelmalak1439 Месяц назад
Fascinating. Very interesting.
@GrahamMilkdrop
@GrahamMilkdrop Месяц назад
I live in Cornwall having moved down from Coventry 15 years ago. The other day I was walking past the local secondary school as they broke up for the day and amongst hundreds of teenagers I heard nothing that I would have called 'Cornish' or even 'West Country' just 10 years ago! If anything I'd describe the prevailing accent as southern middle class with a smattering of London council estate thrown in. No judgement! Just observation!
@shoutplenty
@shoutplenty Месяц назад
yeah i've noticed i've never heard this accent in current media
@dinkster1729
@dinkster1729 Месяц назад
Yes, I noticed in that interview of that woman who deflowered Prince Harry so many years ago that her accent was in no way comparable to the Newfoundland English from the Protestant outports and yet, that accent is said to be derived from the English of Cornwall. Something must hve changed in Cornwall English more recently and, of course, Newfoundland English is changing, too, because Newfoundland joined Canada in 1949 and modern means of communication are everywhere today.
@shaunsteele6926
@shaunsteele6926 12 дней назад
alright then I'll judge, these young people are terrible. Destroying our culture and heritage they are!
@pabloapostar7275
@pabloapostar7275 Месяц назад
I first saw Albert Finney in the Dresser. Extraordinary voice; funny scene in it where he stops a train by filling the entire station with his voice. A few years later I read Alec Guinness's (auto?)biography. He said the army medical examiner (when he enlisted) told him his lung capacity was significantly greater than normal and if he had an explanation for it. Guinness told him "I'm a stage actor."
@lwilton
@lwilton Месяц назад
Stage actors in the days before everyone wearing a microphone were taught to "speak from the diaphragm". It was a technique of keeping the shoulders back and your neck straight to keep the kinks out of the vocal path, and being able to breathe very deeply. You could produce absolutely amazing quantities of sound near effortlessly, without straining, and without shouting. You could do it for hours at a time with no more effort than a normal conversation.
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
In the 80s I saw Uncle Vanya with Michael Gambon and Jonathan Pryce. Gambon could speak 'quietly' and fill the theatre, but all Pryce could do was shout. (Pryce has grown on a bit more since.)
@pabloapostar7275
@pabloapostar7275 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindsey @lwilton's comment reminded me of the compliment people gave to Ben Gazzara; and since you've brought up the same thing, here it is: "...[from] his performance as Brick in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof on Broadway... [people] talk about how ... when Gazzara whispered he could be heard from the back balcony."
@setharnold9764
@setharnold9764 Месяц назад
Awesome video, somehow 25 minutes just flows right past and I'm surprised by the (excellent) credits at the end.
@LuisaAlfaro-sy6zo
@LuisaAlfaro-sy6zo Месяц назад
You know, Dr Lindsey, that I'm a Costa Rican Spanish speaker. I try hard to understand your phonetic work, but it attracts me very much. Thank you.
@doggedout
@doggedout Месяц назад
Waited from the first part of this video for when you would get to "Upper class twit of the year awards". Was not disappointed. ....and the Peter Cooke / Dudley Moore bit. In the movie Bedazzled, when Dudley is taking orders for Wimpy burgers (before he sells his soul) and then the Devil (Peter) makes him into an urbane sophisticate and then a rich cuckold, the whole movie is pitting working class accents against "posh" to hilarious effect. To an American ear it was all extremely funny. Had no idea there was a linguistics / generational war brewing underneath it all. But then, I remembered listening to people walking out of the first screening of The Holy Grail complaining that they "could not understand a word". My projectionist buddy and I had per-screened it the night before and it was all perfectly understandable to us. But I think we had both been watching The Flying Circus for some time on PBS by that time, so it all just sounded like British English.
@Gizathecat2
@Gizathecat2 Месяц назад
How does RP relate to the “posh” Trans Atlantic accent heard in many American movies from the 1940s and 1950s? Katherine Hepburn’s accent comes to mind. I hear a lot of the RP accent in Trans Atlantic.
@Leofwine
@Leofwine Месяц назад
The Transatlantic accent was based on 1920s RP with a few modifications from the East Coast of the US. An Australian elocutionist, William Tilly (and later, Edith Skinner), propagated a “World English” accent, and the nascent sound movie market picked the accent as it was deemed easy to understand in every part of the English speaking world.
@thork6974
@thork6974 Месяц назад
@@Leofwine In early American sound films, as portrayed in "Singin' In the Rain," stage actors were recruited to coach formerly-silent movie stars and that often resulted in a very strange standardized accent, notably pronouncing "you" as "yoh".
@claudiaigsa6900
@claudiaigsa6900 Месяц назад
Congratulations on a great and very informative video. I'm doing a PhD that partly deals with the phonetics and phonology of what used to be RP and now people recognise as Southern British English. I am using Gimson (1970) and Wells (1982) to compare them with more recent sources such as the latest edition of Gimson's Pronunciation of English by Alan Cruttenden which was published in 2014. There is a whole section in that last book dedicated to discuss what should be the name that replaces RP as the term to refer to the Southern British English and the author proposes General British and I was wondering what is your opinion on the matter. Again, I found your video most interesting and I will probably cite it in my thesis!
@maximilliancunningham6091
@maximilliancunningham6091 12 дней назад
Very interesting. Thank You.
@twilightmist7369
@twilightmist7369 Месяц назад
Interesting that you said that the TRAP and DRESS vowels hadn't lowered in Australian English. They definitely have, for younger speakers anyway. They're not as low as in England, but still much lower than they used to be. I think this change must have happened later than it did in England.
@andrewg.carvill4596
@andrewg.carvill4596 Месяц назад
I didn't associate the 60's with dresses becoming lower.
@shoutplenty
@shoutplenty Месяц назад
@@andrewg.carvill4596 they lowered once the new accent was used on them
@tealkerberus748
@tealkerberus748 24 дня назад
I think anyone who refers to Australian as a single accent probably isn't an authority on Australian accents. I can locate seven different accents just in the eastern states. I don't have enough samples from further west to be up-to-date with them.
@franks.6547
@franks.6547 Месяц назад
@DrGeoffLindsey This is fascinating, thank you! Now, as a German who was supposed to learn "Queen's English" in the around 1980, I would be very interested in a more dumbed down version on how to interpret IPA the British way as opposed to American which dominates the Internet. I recall your great hints about ship/sheep for the French - so I'm suggesting to contrast British and American English with respect to significant pronounciation features - but then for English as a foreign language: Like German "that" sounding like "dot" in the US, because we struggle to find the "flat" vowel, and the non-posh British do understand German "that" better (but es bunk bulance, thut is). In Holland and France, they also learn "bütler" for butler where I would say butt-ler. We simply don't know how to read the IPA. The problem could be that you would know too many dialects, so I refer only to average neutral News broadcasting in UK vs. US, and all in connection with the IPA symbols that might or might not differ for UK/US. Or else, take some time to advertise more of your older videos, I just may have overlooked the one I'm suggesting here.
@cshairydude
@cshairydude Месяц назад
Living and studying in Bavaria I was struck by how Germans would pronounce English loan words containing /æ/ with a much closer vowel, to the point that it sounded to me (native English speaker with a generic southern accent) more like /ɛ/. It was quite hard to understand them until I realised what they were doing. It would have been clearer to me if they'd opened it to their native /a/ instead.
@franks.6547
@franks.6547 Месяц назад
@@cshairydude exactly, we would say "flat/care" with closed/open "eh" influenced by the US (?) but "that" still like butt (dot?) - and now I remember vaguely one session in a so-called language lab (lepp? lahp?) in about 1978 where they tried to get us closer to the open ah, but probably without success - and I'm still confused about the "fat butler"...
@cshairydude
@cshairydude Месяц назад
@@franks.6547 The use of the letter /ʌ/ for "butt" is an especially egregious anachronism and probably misleading for 2nd language learners. It's usually more like German's /ɐ/ (the sound of -er when the r isn't articulated).
@dinkster1729
@dinkster1729 Месяц назад
Why not just imitate British commentators and American and Canadian commentators when you speak. If you listen to Democracy Now enough, and try to imitate that speech pattern and then, listen to the British commenators on Israel and imitate their speech patterns, you should succeed very well. Adopt whichever one you feel most comfortable with.
@franks.6547
@franks.6547 29 дней назад
@@dinkster1729 Thanks, I see what you are doing there :-) But my inquiry was more about the IPA symbols, and how they are to be interpreted in US or UK context. For they can't be used consistently on a global level with respect to pure phonetics, when they seem to reflect "regional" (UK/US) standards of bygone eras without being updated in the dictionaries every 30 years or so.
@wacojones8062
@wacojones8062 Месяц назад
I liked the heritage ad. My dad filled 2 3 drawer filing cabinets with the family genealogy going back 73 generations. One family book on the Sterling line published in 1858 goes back 600 years. As to pronunciation and word usage Between US and UK I know a few UK terms and can usually guess context on others.
@michaelarrowood4315
@michaelarrowood4315 Месяц назад
A very interesting linguistic examination of RP's role in the 1960's and beyond. Thank you, and I enjoyed it. But I think it would be much more informative (especially to your non-British audience) to include samples of the types of speech you are referencing. That would really make this lesson more compelling for today's speakers of English, I think. (p.s. I do understand about copyright and such.... probably very difficult to include examples of speech as a result).
@mikemosz
@mikemosz Месяц назад
Finally, a phonetic explanation of Gap Yah
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
Yes, that 'gup' is the continuation of the decompression I mention in the video, so it actually reaches (or passes) the quality Jilly Cooper was talking about.
@danielh7104
@danielh7104 Месяц назад
@@DrGeoffLindseyPrivate Eye used to call her ‘Jolly Super’
@blairmulholland
@blairmulholland Месяц назад
I think a lot of English speaking countries had this issue, and it mostly manifested itself in newsreaders. Nobody in New Zealand, for example, talked like Philip Sherry or Judy Bailey in real life, but that halfway-round-Cape-Horn accent was what they gave us.
@BartitsuSociety
@BartitsuSociety Месяц назад
My dad was a radio man (DJ, presenter, commercial voiceovers etc.) during the '60s and '70s and used RP. Even in his everyday speech, he never had a strong Kiwi accent (though partly as a matter of conscious choice, I think). During the '80s RP (and his "trained", resonant vocal style) started falling out of favour.
@davidlloyd7597
@davidlloyd7597 Месяц назад
People from outside of New Zealand and Australia did have problems understanding the NZ accent though. Those news readers may have adjusted their accents to communicate with people in the outside world. By the way, I grew up in NZ. I remember Phillip Sherry but not Judy Bailey. Are they from the same time?
@BartitsuSociety
@BartitsuSociety Месяц назад
@@davidlloyd7597 RP was very much an artifact of the general NZ attitude/assumption that New Zealand was a far-flung outpost of England, which lasted all the way through the 19th century into at least the 1960s. I was born in the late '60s and was very much aware of that as a kid. It only really started to shift (quite quickly, at the cultural scale) during the 1980s. Thus, early NZ radio and then TV presenters affected RP pronunciation simply because it was the "done thing" - it was expected, as professionals, that they would sound "English".
@davidlloyd7597
@davidlloyd7597 Месяц назад
​@@BartitsuSocietyyou probably don't remember standing up in movie theatres for God Save the Queen
@BartitsuSociety
@BartitsuSociety Месяц назад
@@davidlloyd7597 I do, actually, and I remember being aware when people stopped doing that.
@jamie7795
@jamie7795 26 дней назад
I can totally understand that before there was one way to learn a foreign language without leaving your country - through a textbook written ages ago. But it astonishes me that now, when this information is available for anybody who has access to the internet, some teachers of English have no idea that RP isn't used as it was before, or never heard about SSB and apply the term RP to English used in London. I study English in uni and my pronunciation would always get 'corrected'. I couldn't understand what the problem was and thought I can't hear the sounds until I saw one of your videos. So, thank you so much!
@Broadercasting
@Broadercasting Месяц назад
Het's orf to this raather good televisual explenetion!
@jamesoliver6625
@jamesoliver6625 Месяц назад
I was a child of 11 when the Profumo scandal hit. Looking at the UK now who would have believed he would be so prophetic.
@trevoro.9731
@trevoro.9731 Месяц назад
Another video on local readings of English words. Eventually, it appears right to remember them as Latin writing with some changes and remember some their local reading or dialect readings like in Chinese. I like how some Italians misspell English words in Latin manner, it is so much more understandable for foreigners than normal English.
@sluggo206
@sluggo206 Месяц назад
"it appears right to remember them as Latin writing with some change": But English is not a Romance language. "Latin words with some changes" are still not English words. It's only when they become a living part of the English language and participate in other English changes -- and some get so widely used that educated native speakers don't even recognize them as borrowed from Latin and can't believe they are -- that's when they contribute to English..
@sluggo206
@sluggo206 Месяц назад
I've read that L2 English speakers often find it easier to communicate with other L2 English speakers from different language backgrounds than with native English speakers. Now that non-native speakers are the majority, along with native speakers from non-English majority countries, that's becoming a bigger phenomenon. So there may be a growing dichotomy between English-majority countries and non-English majority countries, and those non-majority countries are developing their own indigenized forms of English (India English, Serbia English, Russia English, China English, etc). There's probably nothing speakers in English-majority countries can do about that, and of course they don't want their own language to change in a way that hinders its usefulness at home. So they'll increasingly diverge, but still remain mutually intelligible, at least nation to nation even if not every individual speaker. And their written English grammar and spelling will probably remain 98% in sync with the English-majority standards, because they have so far. Again, not every speaker, but their national standards and professional books.
@trevoro.9731
@trevoro.9731 Месяц назад
@@sluggo206It is generally easier to remember foreign language sounds as distinct and consistent ones, without n rules and even more exceptions. Latin, unlike English, is way more consistent and is easy to remember if your are outside the English-speaking environment. It is easier to recall and translate then into local dialects - for me, as I'm outside the English-speaking environment, English pronunciation or its variations fall into the category of "dialects", that is, for one word, remembered as its Latin approximation, there can be multiple dialect readings, which I recall when actually speaking to native English speakers, otherwise, I vocalize them to myself as heavily distorted Latin-like words (example: word as [v - o - r - d]), which have consistent and non-varying pronunciation (i.e. pronounced in the way they are written). It would take some extra effort to remember them as proper English outside English environment.
@alanchamberlain4173
@alanchamberlain4173 11 дней назад
Good survey. Delighted to sign up. I remember in about 1991 telling my then fiancée, who had a book with RP English pronunciation indicated, that very few people actually spoke like that. I also remember my mother in the 1960s insisting that the short endings of "happy" etc were "correct". She changed her own speech considerably in the last forty years of her life. But I'm not intending to change my own speech to conform with current trends by abandoning the word "an" and the glide in "the army".
@birdman4565
@birdman4565 18 дней назад
Dr Lindsey, we thenk you.
@CathyS_Bx
@CathyS_Bx Месяц назад
Albert Finney is a superb actor who did whatever accent was necessary for the character. More interesting to me is Michael Caine who seems to have stayed loyal to his original speech patterns--and Alfie was another huge English movie of the 1960s.
@000dr0g
@000dr0g Месяц назад
Superb video Geoff, I very much enjoyed it. I think class and region have very interesting intersecting dynamics. When I was at school in the 60s and 70s in Edinburgh, and later, Cupar, Fife, I would speak with my peers at school more towards the local accent, and posher at home, because my parents had "escaped" the glottal stop of their 1920s poor working class roots. Their accent wasn't RP, but it was "smoothed" out. On the grammar front, I wasn't allowed to say "me and James", rather, it had to be "James and I".
@DrGeoffLindsey
@DrGeoffLindsey Месяц назад
When I taught at Edinburgh in the 90s, a friend of a friend was an authentic RP-speaking Scot, but they must be a dwindling breed.
@000dr0g
@000dr0g Месяц назад
The closest I've heard to RP spoken by a Scot was more Miss Jean Brodie than Jacob Rees-Mogg. The best example I can think of are the Eton forged vowels of Tam Dalyell - I just checked out a YT video where Kirsty Wark (now there's an accent) is interviewing him in 2014. Checking his biography, I discover he was Nicolas Ridley's fag at Eton (shudders).
@000dr0g
@000dr0g Месяц назад
I was trying to think of such an example, and struggling a bit, until I thought of Tam Dalyell, who went to Eton in the 40s, and can be seen speaking with Kirsty Wark (now there's an accent) in a 2014 interview that's on YT. Even then, some Scottishness shines through to my ears. Otherwise, anything I've ever heard from Scots, that even approaches RP, has been closer to Miss Jean Brodie than Jacob Rees-Mogg.
@philroberts7238
@philroberts7238 Месяц назад
Stephen Fry does a very good imitation of a posh Scotsman claiming not to have a trace of a Scottish accent!
@000dr0g
@000dr0g Месяц назад
@@philroberts7238 I just watched that magnificent QI Fry Scottish Accents clip. I've definitely heard all the accents he mimics so accurately. Easy to picture the posh bloke's tattersall shirt and red corduroy trousers.
@systemakhaosu810
@systemakhaosu810 6 дней назад
The "might as be called Kevin" line made me laugh so hard I nearly choked. I had to rewind the video to see what had been drowned out by my laughter. Didn't expect to get such a good laugh from a grammer video, sincerely thank you for that :3
@michaelhorn6029
@michaelhorn6029 Месяц назад
I love that Profumo clip.
@petermsiegel573
@petermsiegel573 Месяц назад
Superbly researched video presented with panache. I hung on every word!
@j.philipjimenez3395
@j.philipjimenez3395 Месяц назад
In a broadly cultural sense, you certainly have a point. However, there have been quite a few widely respected and admired communicators who have carried on the tradition of pronunciation and prosody one associates with RP. Christopher Hitchens and Stephen Fry come to mind.
@scattygirl1
@scattygirl1 Месяц назад
It's the exceptions that prove the rule- the fact that you notice their different way of speaking proves his point. No one expects a 100% cut-off when change happens.
@j.philipjimenez3395
@j.philipjimenez3395 Месяц назад
@@scattygirl1 Hmmm. Well, I'm not so sure that the two public figures I named are simply outliers--relics of a fading past. I would say rather that they are exemplary and notable precisely because their use of language represents and demonstrates those wonderful characteristics that are associated with RP. It is doubtful that they would have made such a mark on our times if their speech did not align with the very best traditions in education and culture. There is an exactness, a clarity, a wonderful sense of rhythm and cadence that distinguishes them. These qualities are fostered in the institutions and traditions that continue to carry the banner. Huge swaths of academia, theatre, film, government speak RP or Modern RP. Aspiring actors still develop correct speech in acting conservatories. One hears RP in airports around the world. Lol! There are also younger exponents of RP on RU-vid who are teaching this pronunciation to non-native speakers. Very true--I only named two individuals, but on reflection I can hardly say that they're exactly oddities. There are great numbers of others. Probably 1% of British people speak with the RP accent. That's been true for a long time and I haven't heard much of a change in that. Certainly, the gritty realism of the late 1950s brought a broader palette to the viewing audience. And it is certainly provocative to announce "the year that killed RP". And perhaps there is some intended hyperbole in that. But he does make some good points, as always.
@KTyso
@KTyso Месяц назад
Love this
@AmorLucisPhotography
@AmorLucisPhotography 14 дней назад
A small correction: Harold Wilson was born and raised in Huddersfield. He was not a Merseysider. I agree completely with your analysis, however. And regarding the Queen - I shall never forget how startled I was to hear Her Majesty, whilst sitting for a portrait by Rolf Harris, offer as a response to a question not "no", but "nah", just as a Londoner would. I kid you not. I had to rewind my VCR several times in order to convince myself that I had heard her correctly. You can verify this yourself by looking up "The Queen by Rolf" on RU-vid and going to 11:09.
Далее
An American T-dropping conspiracy?!
25:20
Просмотров 379 тыс.
СКУФИЗАЦИЯ ЗА 4 МЕСЯЦА
00:16
Просмотров 288 тыс.
Why Do Experts Always Defend Language Mistakes
24:51
Просмотров 105 тыс.
What is a Monad? - Math vs Computer Science
13:58
Просмотров 6 тыс.
The Royal Title that No One Can Remember
18:31
Просмотров 660 тыс.
What if English actually SOUNDED like this??
22:23
Просмотров 187 тыс.
Conversational English in 1586
11:44
Просмотров 336 тыс.
An Upper-Class Southern British Accent, 1673 - 2023
24:32
Phonetic adventures in Prague
8:35
Просмотров 190 тыс.
СКУФИЗАЦИЯ ЗА 4 МЕСЯЦА
00:16
Просмотров 288 тыс.