TIME FOR ANOTHER ONE! The Warning - Black Holes (Live) REACTION  

An emotional song about the despair of addiction written by a 13 year old who’s powers of observation completely captured a subject that thankfully she hasn’t personally experienced.

Ale on the bass was 13 for this. Pau was 15. Still very impressive! 🤩

Paulina is a phenom. The girls as a whole are so tight and versatile. I watched a vlog on Ale. In a live performance half way thru a song, Dani lost her voice. Ale stepped right to the Mic and took over lead. Never missed a beat. Just incredible.

To me the often overlooked part of this performance, is Dany with her beautiful, subtle guitar playing and wonderful backup vocals.

Pau wrote this song when she was 13. She would have been 15 or 16 during this performance. Ale would have been 13 or 14.

66 y.o. here, Pau's voice, on this song and a few others brings the tears every time. Love this band, truly incredible.

I am not going to be surprised by anything these three woman do. I think we have just scraped the surface of the talent of these three real musicans ( in the true sense of the word), especially Pau.

She's PUH PAU And She Is A Musical Genius It's Easy To See !!! There Is So Much More To React To Let's Get Busy !!! PUH PAU !!!

"I surrender in my defeat" ... Gives me chills every time. ✊

All 3 girls are classically trained pianists!!’

Pau has reduced a lot of grown men to tears with her songs! Oh, and subbing since you are continuing with The Warning.

Ale is 13 in this performance. Pau is 15 here. Paulina was 13 when she wrote the song. Listen to Pau singing "Escape the Mind" at age 13, live, @ Liceo (Liceo de Monterrey) (2015).

Lyrics are mind blowing for a lady so young We have a lifetime of music and lyrics to look forward to. Thanks ladies

Paulina will always amaze

I've been listening to The Warning for a year now. My mouth just drops everytime I listen and can't believe how talented they were when they were younger. This band is the real deal. They can be around for decades if they want to. I can't even imagine how great their future songs will be. They are going to bring back rock music the way we use to know it. They will appeal to more and more fans worldwide as they grow. The Warning makes the future of rock music exciting.

One of their classics - will go down in history

the guitar harmonics are brilliant and perfectly executed.... very very complex

They recentlly played this in a very acoustinc setting at a radio station in Montreal while touring with Three Days Grace. When you have the time you should check it up, they played around 8 songs. Ale wasn't there cause the cold really hit them hard during the tour. I was such a fun intimate gig very enjoyable. Nice reaction, you really nailed the meaning of the song.

If you like Paulinas voice try her Creep cover with piano! Or Dust to dust with her lead vocals! Both mind blowing 😉

I love watching people discover and fall in love with this band, as I did, years ago. Your falling into a black hole called The Warning, from which you will not return. Enjoy the journey!! Great review. 👍

10:49 Great reaction Rosalie, you hit it on the button right away! Paulina is an amazing songwriter and always has been - she wrote this when she was 13, pretty amazing eh? Not sure whether you’ve seen her sing Creep by Radiohead yet but if you’ve not and want to get the tissues out!

So much power and feeling in this song. Dany and Ale lay back a bit and let Pau take this one, though their subtle guitar and bass are all that is needed. And the backing vocals! Just another example of their versatility. They're so much more than just one of the best power trios. Their new album Error has plenty examples of the depth of their talent. Thanks for coming back again.

Pau sang this for the 1st time in about 5 years, about a month ago. (Link below) They were on tour in Canada at the end of last year and because they are not used to the brutal cold there, they all had gotten the Flu. At one point Dani and Pau were singing and playing on stage w/ the Flu and eventually it got to Ale, whom I assume got it worse because she had to miss a show. When Ale returned for the following shows she had to sit on a stool the whole show because she couldn't stand. Their ability to 'power through' and 'carry on' despite having the Flu is a testament to their drive and professionalism. All these Canada shows are on RU-vid in their entirety. Anyhow, the show that Ale had to miss was about a month ago in Montreal. Dani and Pau arranged an acoustic set w/ Q&A for the fans. Dani's voice was still in rough shape and Pau being the most recovered did most the singing. They did a lot of older songs that they haven't sung in years and it was cute to see Pau forgetting lyrics, at one point Dani had to pull lyrics up on her phone and hold them up for Pau. This is the link for the full show... Black Holes is the first song, starts at about 2 and a half minutes. Pau plays keys and sings the song for first time in years and it's beautiful. Dani just stands off to the side smiling at her sister. At one point Pau looks over and sees her and starts laughing, then Dani laughs, it's adorable. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-o-dFwhZd7w4.html&ab_channel=TheWarningArmy This is the setlist, Pau sings 9 of the 11 songs. It's especially funny during Free Falling when Dani struggles to remember the chords and Pau says "that's not the chord", then turns to Dani and says, "what happened to us, like what are we even singing about?" 2:49 Black Holes (Don't Hold On) 11:05 Amour 18:07 Revenant 25:54 23 32:50 When I'm alone (Huele a melon) 38:32 Show me the light 45:49 Take Me Down 47:21 Free falling 49:43 Sinister Smiles 52:20 Martirio 55:53 Money

your interpretation is correct is about adcition, amazin lyrics for three little girls, pau wrote this song inspired in a family friend i think...

All three of them play piano and sing, they also attended seminar classes at Berkeley College. These women are trained and have taken musical lessons. Listen to thier cord progression and changes. Off the hook. Timing is good on on time most cases. They are well on thier way being an ironic Rick band as well as one of the best female rock bands out there to-date.

This was at the Dakota Bar in 2018. At the time Pau was 16. She wrote the song when she was 13. This song and the other ballad, *Show Me the Light*, sung by Pau are from their first full album XXI century Blood. These two song sold me on the warning. *Black Holes* is about addiction and the mindset of someone unable to recover from it.

Great when family can be together and even better when they're all good.

Great job with your reaction and thoughts on Black Holes from The Warning it's my favorite song from Them. and it's still mind blowing that Pau wrote this very amazing and emotionally song at the age of 15 singing About this subject matter that she wrote about at the age of 13.

Great reaction! Glad others have addressed the inaccurate age for this. By the way, Pau is not the only one who plays piano. All three are classically trained on piano and by their own admission Ale' is the better player on the piano. Going through their catalog of performances you will see all 3 play piano in concert performances.

Wonderfully smart reaction. Thank you. When all is said and done, Paulina will be recognized as one of the best lyricists of her generation.

Paulina and Dani did an acoustic set in Canada they started off with this song And her voice is Waaay better. You should check that one out

Actually I believe Ale was around 13.. Pau was 15.. but whatever.. Pau actually wrote this.. about a family friend who was drinking himself to death.. and 3 teenagers made music years ahead beyond their ages.. and captured the emotional toll of it all.. like wise old ladies.. true talent

You would also like one of there live songs called Survive, The Ted X performance ..Epic!

This song gets me every time! (especially THIS performance at The Dakota Bar). Pau smiling near the beginning when she realizes the crowd is singing along!💖 This is, and probably will remain, my favorite rock ballad of all time. Pau's ability to pull you in with her crazy good lyrics and emotional delivery is amazing! For a 15 y.o., at the time of this performance, to have that kind of power, is almost scary.😮 🤘😍🤘

I had a classmate who was depressive, when I was in high school. I didn't realise it, back then. It was a long time before I got my own fair share of depression. I don't know, if she took her life. Her demon was: "I bring evil to everyone, trying to get (even mentally) close to me." I don't know, what caused this. Myself, I'm doing fairly well, today. But one will never get rid of it, completely. Ever. Something positive to share: I've recieved an email from a friend, just before the turn of this year. She is depressive, too. I had almost given up, to ever hear from her again.Sent her a mail, every once in a while, though. 'Cause I know, how us depressive folks can be. 1st mail from her, 2years, after we wrote back-and-forth: "Sorry, for answering so late. Every mail from you always made me smile: someone is thinking of me!" Deptession is a beast! Rosalie: schau' mal nach "Don't give up!" von Kate Bush und Peter Gabriel. Vorsicht! Taschentücher bereithalten! Ist aber ein geniales Lied.

The Warning and Angelina Jordan have become my favorite artists. Those 4 young women possess talent beyond comprehension. I have seen The Warning live twice and can't wait to see Angelina. My dream is to have them song a song together.

#UnleashThePau so clear why she’s so loved. ❤️🔥🤘#NumberlyGarfs

A really well composed song topped off with Pau bringing all the emotion needed to justify the lyrics and subject matter , perfection .

Pau also sang and played keyboards on the song "Escape the Mind", the title track from their EP "Escape the Mind", their first release. This is a link to that performance in front of their classmates: THE WARNING - ESCAPE THE MIND / ORIGINAL SONG @LICEO ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wtRLmnQ9-Cc.html This is about 3 months following the release of the EP "Escape the Mind" and a couple of months before they attended the Berklee College of Music in Boston. At this time Pau is 13; Dany 15; Ale 10. Pau also sings lead on "23", "Revenant", and "Breathe" on the "Error" album

Pau's cover of Creep at the piano is pretty good, you should give it a go.

You gotta love Paulina, Every time She sings This song with such heart, The tears automatically come. What a beautiful reaction thank you⚡️⚡️⚡️🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽

"WOW!" Is the only proper response to this song. It is an amazing song and you nailed the interpretation 🎯 So Wow yourself. Great reaction 💞💓❤️ Please find time to react to more of The Warning. 🔥🔥🔥 There is so much more to see. ✌️💖🎼

Very deep. She has an old soul. This band has grabbed my attention. I am amazed how they invest their emotions into their music. Great choice.

It was pretty there all badass they always have good music need more of this band you rock

This is such a powerful song when performed live.

Just to end the discussion of how old they where: "Live show at Dakota Bar in Monterrey, Mexico January 19th 2018 Dany 17 (Lead Voice, Guitar), Pau 15 (Drummer, Voice), Ale 13 (Bass, Voice)" (from the description of the video on their YT-page). But nevertheless a great song and a great performance and though I very seldom appreciate slower and mellow songs, it's different with The Warning, also those kind of songs (Show me the light, 23, Revenant,...) hit me deep.

Hey Rosalie, very cool reaction, and I'm sorry for not putting in the description that this song was performed when Pau was 15 years old. She actually wrote this when she was 13. None the less you pretty much nailed the meaning of the song. About addiction and for a 13-year-old to come up with such lyrics is amazing. These young women are way ahead of their time. Thank you for your time. Peace.

REACCIÓNA AMOUR THE WARNING 😎

Great reaction. You understood Pau's intentions perfectly. She has said this song is about addiction. Pau wrote this at age 13, but this performance was when Pau was 15. This song is on their album XXI Century Blood. At the beginning Pau was smiling because people were singing along (in English at a Mexican bar). The line that always gets me is "even black holes let me be." Amazing song writing.

This is my all time favorite by TheWarning,even had Paulina send me the lyrics written out as a Patreon reward.Paulina nailed this great ballad.She brings grown men to cry.Love your reaction earning you a sub, cant wait to see your next reactions and especially reactions of this great power trio from Monterrey.Keep Rockin Dany,Pau,Ale!And TWA!!

Pau also did Show Me the Light at this show. It has an excellent though very under appreciated guitar solo as well.

Recently Pau performed this for a very small group of fans. She hadn't performed the song live in a few years, and a fan brought up the lyrics for her on his phone; (it was either this one or Show Me the Light). Either or, it's funny how artist move on from their early works.

As always a great reaction and I like the lyrics as well they did a great job on this one and for Pau being so young singing this with such emotion and conviction that is very awesome I liked this one alot . as always your ride or die forever EyyyyOoooo

Look up creep, Pau piano and vocal all by herself, awesome

This is my favorite song by them with When I'm alone 2nd, both emotionally strong songs.

Hello Rosalie, magnificent reaction and the song.. my goodness one of my favorite songs.. thank you very much, you are missing many songs from this great band.. the truth is that any song you listen to will take you to the maximum.. greetings

TW ❤️🇧🇻

God, I love Pau's voice. I also love her drumming, but her voice! Man! 🖤🤘🏻

Pau lead vocals : Dust to Dust ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TeIbG8nkOiU.html. The End ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-FK7pLOWEYJU.html. Narcisista ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-O7IAEhN4RMM.html Creep Solo ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-A6Y4XpBxjU0.html

The Warning is part of my curtular studies of American continent, and positive one!

Pau + piano = 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Excellent reaction, what an amazing song. Thank you for sharing, 🤘rock on, my friend 🤘

Channel west coast of ridiculousness wore a shirt with the warning and Metallica logos on it on an episode in 2019. Fun fact.

Pau was not 13 here; she just wrote the song at that age. Incredible, eh? ALL three sisters were trained for classical piano very, very young; even before they began playing their current main respective instruments. The videos of them playing classical piano are available through their official RU-vid page.

Great reaction, Rosalie! I always appreciate your reactions cuz you are always honest while being respectful and not vulgar. You got the meaning of the song cuz it is about addiction but more specifically a family member of theirs that was struggling with an addiction. This is a beautiful piano ballad from Pau and the other piano ballad on XXI Century Blood, Show Me The Light is just as beautiful with a little more guitar and also sung by Pau, however Dany did a surprise solo acoustic version of that song on her livestream Thursday night as well. God bless and rock on🤘!

These young ladies are amazing! Thanks for another great reaction and analysis Rosalie!

Pau can sing for sure, even singing lead while playing the drums. To see that check out "Narcisista" or "Dust to Dust" for harder rockers, or "The End" or "23" for slower ones/power ballads. "Survive" is great too.

Check out another crude lyrics from them in the song: "Copper Bullets", a song about domestic violence and abuse. Their mom actually almost convinced them not to record it in their first album because of the dark theme

Their new album Error has two cool songs on it by Pau.

Powerful and emotional performance. Great message.

Damn. Paulina is a heckuva song writer. Great singer too!

Pau wrote this when she was 13. After she read an article about an addict. It hits so close to home for people with that past or present. She's 16 here, I believe

That guitar solo by Danny is amazing!! I need about 12 more bars of it tho!

TWARMY Award winning Patreon contributor here, fun fact when you see Pau smile at the beginning was her reaction to hearing the audience sing along with her. She was almost overwhelmed with emotion but composed herself like the pro she is... All three of the sisters are proficient pianists as they are singers too. Pau wrote this after reading a story about addiction in the newspaper when she was 13. She was 16 at the time of this performance... She also wrote the very powerful song about abuse and murder/suicide, Copper Bullets. In fact it's to difficult to pick just one great song from The Warning, of the 50+ original songs that they have written and recorded none are bad.

yes, paulina(pau) did lead on this one, and also wrote it, all three play piano(key board), danelia (danny) was 15, alexandra( ale) bass was 10... all, to me, were born talanted!!

Beautiful sad song

Pau is the Drumeo 2023 Rock Drummer of the Year! She started piano at a VERY young age, and by 10, she was hitting drums hard enough to break sticks. She wrote this at 13 and she's 15 in this performance. Her voice is very different from Dany's - not better, just different. She starts writing and composing most of their songs, and the sisters finish them as a group. But if a song is emotional like this one, or *Show Me the Light* from the same Dakota Studio Bar 2018 performance, or *23, Revenant, Dust to Dust,* or the pre-recorded version of *Breathe* from the intermission at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX, 08/29/2022, grab a box of tissues before you hit play! Pau sings those with total mastery. Her cover of RadioHead's *Creep,* shot on an iPhone in black-and-white at the out-of-tune piano in their living room, is the best version of that song I've ever heard. It left me on the floor, staring at the ceiling, marveling at what an emotive empath she is. There is a fan video of *Breathe,* performed live at the Pepsi Center last year, that is supposedly devastating. She broke down during the song. I'm waiting for an official release of that concert video to see it. (I don't like bad audio.)

Love the warning 🤘this song so deep. Show me the light song the warning please

In my opinion, one of the best lyrics written by Pau, even considering the lyrics on the Error album. The subject of addictions is obviously a very difficult subject to deal with for a song, and Pau with her lyrics was able to give us a moving insight into this difficult problem. Trust me, many people are moved to tears by this song.

If you are loving Pau's voice, take a look at her version of Creep. She did that as an Instagram challenge; learned it in 4 hours. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-A6Y4XpBxjU0.html

Thank you very much for sharing your excellent feedback and review. Pau's interpretation was surprising, how she has accustomed us today, it is incredible that at 15 years old she had the inspiration to achieve those lyrics and, in this performance, she, along with her sisters, gave us a sample of their interpretative capacity and their talents. But this song moves me a lot because, focusing on the lyrics and their meaning, I realize the high level of empathy that Pau has... and at her very young age... Wow!! Thank you very much and congratulations. Greetings ⚡🎸🥁🎸⚡

Pau’s Passion is something else 🔥🤘❤️ Thank you for reacting The Warning 🙏🏻🇫🇮

The Warning - Dust to Dust Live Whiskey Go Go ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-sNxrcJr4lrw.html Pau also sings here while she is on the drums. She is phenomenal. Would be cool if you also look at this with us. I would also like to recommend Eivør. You will never forget her voice. She has a beautiful voice. She is also a singer songwriter and plays umpteen instruments. Partly extraordinary instruments. Eivør - Falling Free (live) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-KNPIdGBn7M4.html

Excellent my friend!!!!!

Black Holes is Pau's masterpiece imo. Her voice is extraordinary on this beautiful, powerful, emotional song. I read that she was smiling because the crowd was singing along with her. Great reaction!

I feel like Dany’s ringing chords are love and life leaking away.

This group is so darn talented 👏 and they just keep getting better. The harmonies in choke marterio ans the enter sandman with Alessia Cara was so beautiful 😍 your reaction to this masterpiece was awesome 💖 😍 ❤️ 🔥

Not much i can add to the comments . . Im 63 and love them . . . Been following them for about 10yrs . . . Big future

Amo esta canción en mi top 5 de the warning lo cual es bastante reñido.

Pau sings this song at the Pepsi Center, Mexico City. Performed the song on Grand Piano with Orchestra be hind her.

There is a beast that lives in Pau and I pity, I pity the man who ever crosses or does her wrong, the beast will obliterate that unfortunate fool. Fabulous.

Pau es el poder de the warning, gran diosa del rock. Gracias por la reacción. Saludos feliz año

Thank you for your 2cents. When I say 2cents I'm talking value. So thank you for your explanation on the song. This 2cents has great value.

⚡⚡🤘🤘

You can sister WOW

Rosalie, this girls started playing classical piano at a very young age. They are amazing.

PAU, what an excellent interpretation of BLACK HOLES, PAU is a complete musician, Pau's great ability to compose is incredible, excellent lyrics and intelligent messages, Pau the new genius of Rock, there is no one who interprets and composes like Pau and his volume of composition is enormous

You have to listen to dust to dust or Narcisista, it's a song where Pau sings and plays the drums, the control of his voice without missing a beat is simply amazing

Love it; very mature theme and lyrics but not for Pau who is a great talent. 🤘😭❤️⚠️

This is a powerful and great song it hits home for a person who has had a addiction it go's right to the heart ❤️ I love this song 🎵 had me thinking of my past 💯 and now I'm over 27 years clean and sober these girls are awesome love you girls keep on rocking ❤️ 🤘🤘🤘