Voice Teacher Reacts - BTS Mic Drop SNL | Wow!! That's CRAZY! 

Maybe you can watch and review this one? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-a_ZHc3NKsl8.html This is live singing of BTS

I am an army, and I don’t see why some people down here are so brutal... She just said what she thought and of course there are backup vocals if the choreography is that hard, because they have to satisfy an enormous public with their performances and it just helps them when they are dancing like crazy

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BFqF-3qTzRg.html (this is a bts acoustic show, i think it´ll be better to react)

I suggest please react the live version and the studio version of evry BTS songs... And you can clearly hear their true vocals💜💜💜

Can you react on Epiphany live concert by Jin .

Oh great! I will! Thanks for the suggestion :)

Also Make it right in the other late night show, there are so many she didn't even take the time to look. There are so many. She is just being ridicules about it. It doesn't even require a voice coach or teacher to be able to hear they sang over background music & you can CLEARLY hear them.

@@SongsFromASuitcase yaas... can't wait for ur react to their boy w/ luv performance 👍🏻👍🏻

How am I being ridiculous? This is a TRUE reaction video. If I've seen a video before then it's not a true reaction. This is my first time seeing them. You're welcome to watch other channels where they are fake but in my channel it's real.

@@SongsFromASuitcase Listen a small minority of BTS fans are crazy, if you criticize them at all, thousands will come and attack you. For some reason Kpop fans are very protective and cant take any criticism, but trust me mosr understand you and love your content.

Yea I totally agree and I made sure to mention that in the video as well. They are dancing a LOT! I plan on reviewing something more vocally driven next.

Dude you'd be surprised. Back in the day Britney could sing really well, it was just a marketing choise to have her sing the way she did as she launched her image...but that's a whole other conversation haha! Also the whole video IS based off of me judging this one performance. That's why its a true reaction video. I do plan on and have already filmed a reaction video for The UNtold Truth which is totally different, but you'll have to wait for that ;)

@@SongsFromASuitcase britney can still ! there are some videos from these past years! btw bts is a group and britney a solo artist! bri cant take space to breath while other sing, she sings all the parts

Thats an interesting way for him to prove he's not lip syncing. I'd rather that if he's gonna do that, that maybe he does something new and original with the vocal melody line when he does come in. That way he's improving the song rather than just being late. I'm gonna check out House Of Cards live. Thanks for the suggestion!

@@SongsFromASuitcase Yea! House of Cards is a moody kind of song, so I'm excited! The members do change up melody sometimes in performances, but people still say they've simply recorded a different version for the performance to lip sync to. Haters get real intense about insisting negative things. And these kinds of bands attract INTENSE haters -- BTS was almost completely ruined before they got off the ground because of things like that. It's a whole thing.

I've actually just reviewed the truth untold live. It will release tomorrow. It was a whole different experience!

Did Jin say that?

Jin did that on purpose

Ok cool!

This is accoustic version, u can hear their clear vocals here

Yes!!

Oh yea UsU

Ditto! Try armypedia!!!

He is hilarious!

@@SongsFromASuitcase He‘s hilarious? What‘s that supposed to mean?

Which one was that? I don't know their names. Truthfully I didn't know I had been listening to their song previous to this until I started searching more.

Songs From A Suitcase the one that is singing in all black clothes with black hair. JUngkook is the main vocal of the group. You rarely see him make mistakes when it comes to live performances. Overall I would say the three rappers (J-Hope, RM, and Suga) are stable too along with the main vocal Jungkook. With Jungkook you mentioned that he had strong power when singing I think. I suggest you watch BTS On Kinetic movie, this song is their latest release. Along with the live performance :)

@@SongsFromASuitcase Please react to him singing "My time" (it's new so it does not yet have live performance) or Euphoria from Wembley stadium (it's very unique because he is flying on the "wire-hook" while singing).

Yes honestly Jungkook is the only vocalist doing great here and he's always great tbh

@@SongsFromASuitcase the one in the black outfit and black hair

I don't know if I can fully agree with you on this. I've never heard a voice that sound auto tuned when it isn't. It is more likely that we as listeners have become so accustomed to the auto tuned sound that we can't tell the difference anymore.

@@SongsFromASuitcase yes there is a backing track which is turned down really low. So what you're hearing is mostly their live vocals. I mean you heard how low the back track was when they didn't sing for a bit there. If vocals are loud, it's not the back track. And yes they are singers check out their carpool karaoke with James corden. You can hear jungkook singing without any auto tune.

@@SongsFromASuitcase You need to see the BTS Carpool Karaoke with James Corden. You can clearly hear Jungkooks voice on one section that I previously thought was autotuned but it wasn't.

Songs From A Suitcase if you don’t believe there’s a voice that sounds like auto tune then you should hear Jimins voice lmao. They usually use a back track when performing because they obviously won’t get all the parts and they might get really tired but they only use auto tune in their songs. They have really good voices especially when they’re not dancing and breathing really hard. I know it might sound like they’re using auto tune but trust me, they’re most likely not

Jungkook doesn't need autotune

hahahah! FRIENDS?!

@@SongsFromASuitcase yeah..its not easy to completely learn a different language by just watching a TV show , but I guess its possible for him because he has an IQ of 148 ( I am not kidding )..lol

@@screamthename_1772 he learned English in friends because friends has a lot of episode more then 50+

@@flowerjungkook4790 umm , ik

You're the second person to suggest this video. Looks like now I HAVE TO watch it ;)

@@SongsFromASuitcase As a blink, please do one with BP too.

Hahah! I;m actually not a "Blink" truthfully I had to look up online what that menat. They're just aname of a group that I know off hand. Perhaps because they say their own name within one of the songs I like :) I'm assuming BP means Black Pink correct?

A lot of people have suggested House Of Cards. Looks like that might be needed to review :)

@@SongsFromASuitcase House of card is legend\•~•/

It’s not a big deal. Look at Beyonce and Nicole Scherzinger. We know they have a great vocal but they also use backing vocals while dancing.

I wouldn't say it a bad thing, especially when they're dancing as much as they do. I personally would like to hear THEIR voices more than the backups. So perhaps turning down the backups or having sections with less movement that have less backing vocals for that moment ( so they can catch their breath and have proper support)

@@SongsFromASuitcase I was just curious :) thank you for explanation

Songs From A Suitcase the backup vocals are so soft though?? You can clearly distinguish between the live and backup vocals...

I agree with this comment, Image when you dance , sing and rap in the same time I kinda die for a minute 😂😅 BTS , Breath man 💕

That's good to know! How much of their music do they write? Are they the only writers on the songs or are there others and maybe even ghost writers?

@@felixungar7351 that's cool to know! I wonder how many other people Ed writes for? I'll also check out EXO. Thanks for the suggestion!

kpop idols can’t dance better than western idols, I don’t even know you were you got that from tbh.

Whats Armypedia?

@@SongsFromASuitcase. armypedia was a live they did in 2019 connecting armys around the world. They did in some cities, 2 in Europe and one in the United States. And a RU-vid live for the world

@@SongsFromASuitcase. They sang some songs on this live. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BFqF-3qTzRg.html the link is they singing the 3 songs, 10 minutes of video. They are just sitting around singing.

Oh! So that's the name of their tour?

Yes there are other videos that show their vocals more clearly and I now plan on reviewing those, however they are professional singers so whether it's a dance song or a ballad, they should still have their vocals well practiced.

So what you’re implying no actually saying is this performance isn’t good ...if that’s so I think your opinion is skewed and biased this is better than 99 % of western artistS out there right now . What they just did on that small stage is amazing period

nope. Never implied that nor said it.

Songs From A Suitcase Could you try dancing and singing at the same time yourself and post it on RU-vid? I just want to see the ‘real good voice while dancing’ that you’re talking about. You are vocal coach so you suppose to be able to do it perfectly right?

You'd think they would adjust the choreography to support the singing more rather than not have them sing

BTS, isn't just about vocals, they are so much more than that. Yes they have amazing live vocals (just search for any of the vocal lines live performances) but all of their performances on their tours are about the full package. Every thing means something, the choreography, the clothing, the make-up, the lyrics, the melody, the instruments. It's all part of it and it's all important they deliver a full story with each song. On tour they perform 20+ songs, all live. To me this was fine they deserve it. There are so many American artist that just stand there and still don't sing live. These guys atleast sing 99% live and pour their heart out for us. If you want to hear what they can do, please react to their best vocals compilations or one of their full MAMA performances.

@@SongsFromASuitcase it’s almost as if this is a performance song instead of a vocal heavy song?????? Huh???? You know- something extremely common and encouraged in the k-pop genre

That's a great explanation. Thanks for that

An intelligent comment. Like the reviewer, I prefer live singing outside the studio but very much like the full performance of BTS. SIS- really like your honest reaction. I learn from it. They have to dial up Jimin’s part as he is often off key.

Hey ᴍᴀᴄɪ! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)

Hey Echo Bay! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)

great!

You present backing vocals like it is a bad thing. I will tell you smth that you probably dont know. BTS is the only group who actually sing and not lipsync in their performances 24/7. They actually stood out from all the other groups for singing live even from their debut. You did your job(correctly) by pointing this out but your face reaction gives me that their performance was bad. Please dont be so negative about them just because you are biased. edit: with all due respect

bts win “bts is the only group who actually sings” ok so you obviously have never listened to a single other kpop group in your life huh

i truly appreciate you commenting so politely. I'll be truthful that my thumbnail is simply based on the fact that a look of shock or disgust always draws more clicks. I did a review on Shallow and I loved the singer but my thumbnail showed me covering my mouth almost unhappy. That's just kind of how thumbnails and the world of YT views goes. I mean you clicked on it right? I do plan on reviewing a more vocally driven video so i can give a better review. I though SNL was a good start since I;ve never reviewed them before. Now i know :)

@@marlanaclaire2576 No i said " Who actually sing and not lipsync" meaning they singing live

@@SongsFromASuitcase Thank you for not misunderstanding my point of view. (Eng is not my native language). You are right about the thumbnail this is how it is done these days. BTS has 3 rappers and 4 vocalists so if you wanna react in a more vocally driven video then I would recomment you to react to 'The thuth untold' by the 4 vocalists of the group --> ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-98pd0rvz_yE.html its like an acoustic version.

actually one of my singing students suggested that I DON'T review them because she said the Army would take me out. So I took the challenge and did it. ...Didn't know I'd end up doing more hahah!

Songs From A Suitcase ur very right blinks and armies can be very brutal. Which is what their doing now I see no reason to meantion that you don't know what Blink is.

Great! I'll have to check that out! thanks for the suggestion!

Ooooh! I just checked it out ( only for a second so I don't ruin my true reaction) and YES that sounds like it's more vocally driven. Thanks for the suggestion! I think that will be the video I'll react to.

Yess please!! 🥺😭🙏🏻😍🥰❤️

I've actually just reviewed the truth untold live. It will release tomorrow. It was a whole different experience!

Hahah! Yea she can be chill at times. She is almost 15 years old

yea thats true, but a lot of people don't hear it.

Hahah! That's my old lady Huahua. She's 15 years young and don't let her fool you. She's boss!

💜🎶💜

Hey yes im multifandom! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. So far I've had two other requests for this exact video, so it just might have to go on the list!

She is my BABY!! I love her sooooo much and she always gets what she wants. She wanted me to hold her during the recording so I do what she commands hahah!

@@SongsFromASuitcase a true queen 😍

All good. hahah! She's a show stopper for sure 💜

I've reacted to Truth Untold. It was a whole different experience!

Yes my channel is focused on learning how to sing and part of that is ear training. I point things out that a singer should listen to and learn

@@SongsFromASuitcase you're saying it like bts's vocal coaches are not exist lmao

Never said that :) perhaps this channel isn;t for you. It's not for everyone.

i am so sorry! I didnt know until people started commenting. oops!

Yes theres a lot of dancing thats for sure

Looks like I'll be reacting to the Truth Untold next

Songs From A Suitcase yess that too. Their vocals are really good

I totally agree! Had there been less dancing then I'm sure my vocal review would have been different. But I reviewed what I thought at the time was popular since that video has so many views.

@@SongsFromASuitcase it's ight fam

I watched your other BTS reaction, thanks for reacting to the truth untold! In that video, you mentioned that the one who hit that high note towards the end sounded a little off, I would like to say why: BTS were on tour at the time so obviously they were singing a lot, and I'm not a musician so I don't know the terms to explain it but I do know that that has a bad effect on the singer, so they should rest, but because BTS's schedules were full they couldn't. Now the other members don't get worn out easily, but Jimin (The one who kinda messed up hitting that high note) easily gets worn out and his voice gets messed up to say the least. But aside from that, that note isn't in the studio and album version, he just does it when gets energized by the audience like in that video, but he couldn't hit it well enough there. Also the backtrack thing: whoever says BTS doesn't use backtracks are retarded tbh. They do, sometimes a little, sometimes a lot, but yes, sometimes they don't use it. I explained it in my previous comment where and why they use the backtracks in songs with choreography, as for why and where they use the backtracks in songs without choreo like the truth untold: well, you noticed yourself that they didn't use it until the bridge/last chorus, now over there they used it for the echo effect, cuz in the original studio version the echo effect makes it sound amazing. Once again I'm not familiar with terms so by echo effect I actually mean like the quire sound, where there are multiple people singing the same thing at the same time. Anywho, because the other member's tones are very different from Jin's (The one who sang the final part with the back track), they couldn't have them do it, also they needed them for the adlibs that are supposed to be done in the final chorus while Jin sings, so yeah, they needed a backtrack for that. But yeah, normally there are always backtracks, but with BTS, you can actually hear that they are barely used and if they are they are very subtle or for stylistic reasons or because of choreo as I explained in my original comment.

It totally ok and even better in my opinion for a singer to be slightly off sometimes. It helps me know that there's not a ton of autotune being used. Also sometimes, especially in a song about dram or heartbeak, theres an added emotion that goes into the song when they sing it slightly off. ALmost like they're feeling the emotion of being broken. I personally like it, BUT this video was about reviewing, reacting and breaking down what they're doing so I always have to point out when somthing isn't "perfect". Though I have a feeling some people take that a little too personally. Oh well!

hahaaha! Yea that's my spoiled little fur baby Wawa. She's 15 years old so she gets her way all the time. She tells me what to do.

💜🎶🎶💜

Kiwitsune💜🎶🎶💜

I heard he learned it from watching Friends?!

@@SongsFromASuitcase yes he did, his name is RM and he has an IQ of 148 so it makes sense how he learned it from watching friends.

wow!

jiminisnotonfire The beauty in music is that we DON'T all agree. It's often not based on facts but more based on personal preference. I won't always like the sounds that you like and vice versa, but by listening and appreciating other peoples opinions it allows us to become more aware of our own. Welcome to my channel 💜

hahah! Yea my 15 year old forever puppy

Yea I think a lot of the anger of fans actually comes from them thinking that backup vocals are bad or that backups and autotune are one in the same. Hope you enjoy the rest of my vids :)

Thank you for that info. I truly appreciate your time

I've had a larger than expected amount of views on this video so I absolutely plan on reviewing a more vocally driven video of theirs very soon! I just didn't expect this ;)

Yea I watched the Untold Truth and it was a whole other experience

Great! Thanks for the suggestion!

I totally cracked up on this. I LITERALLY had to look up what OFC stands for and what Blink means. I thought you were saying I blink too much in this video! bwhahaha! ....I'm too old for this! haha!

lmfao army why u so pressed

i literally didn’t say anything, seems like you’re the pressed one

But you did. You LITERALLY said "ofc you’re a blink.. that pretty much explains your review...." ...hahaha! Sorry I had to say it!

i didn’t even insinuate that it was a bad one?!! but it’s actually hard to think that you’re not biased when you said that at 0:21 like was that really necessary?

Drop the mic as in make a mistake or as in slang for doing an amazing job?

@@SongsFromASuitcase as in you paused the video right before he drops it, hence the song 'mic drop' :) it's just kind of triggering to miss that part when you know the performance by heart as most armys do :D

oh! hahah! I see the connection. I like it.

seems like an odd thing to do.

Nice! I've actually never heard of them. I'll have to do that! Thanks for the suggestion

When I found that out I thought it was great! What an awesome way to learn! hahah!

Hahah! Yea that's my old lady Huahua. She's 15 years old and reserves her energy for special things like telling me it's dinner time

good point!

Songs From A Suitcase thx. From as unbiased a viewpoint I can have, he is more than capable of more demanding parts.

Thanks for that explanation

@@SongsFromASuitcase no problem, I'm always happy to see people check out my boys, I'm sorry if I came of salty in my other comment, BTS has been through hell and back in every way shape and form so we as a fanbase can be a bit overprotective at times.

haaha! Yea that's my old lady Wawa. She's the one in charge of the house so when she says "pick me up" you do it. Even if you're recording a reaction video

Mifla The beauty in music is that we DON'T all agree. It's often not based on facts but more based on personal preference. I won't always like the sounds that you like and vice versa, but by listening and appreciating other peoples opinions it allows us to become more aware of our own. Welcome to my channel 💜 My puppy says hello

Agree! i want to recommend EXO(another boy band group) and MAMAMOO(girl group) i think those groups have amazing vocals

GREAT! Will do!

they do have several members so they could stagger their breath

Hey Sara Fouda! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)

I think you are too generous with Jin. He missed his entrance.

hahah! Yea she was chill that morning. I'm not always so lucky

hahaha! Yea sorry about that. Now I know 💜🎶🎶💜

I can totally see where you're coming from and I appriciate your comment. It is true I am a vocal coach, but also a vocal performance coach. I teach how to perform and not just sing, so I do have some grounds for saying what I did. But taking my first experience of them is from THIS video, you could see how I could come about my comment. I realise now, after watching UntoldTruth, that they are stronger singers than I had thought, but the whole purpose of this video was to have a "reaction" to the video. I purposely didn't want to watch other videos first because I wanted to have a raw and true experience and review. It HAD to start somewhere from some video. That was this video. Clearly the more I watch of them, the more my reaction and reviews will change....but i had to start somewhere right? :)

@@SongsFromASuitcase Thanks for the reply, and apologies for the long post but I want to make sure I'm being clear. To start, as I said you were analyzing how they sound in this particular video based on your expertise, so of course you have the grounds for criticizing what they did in this one. Absolutely they were off key in parts, no problem pointing that out and you should. And yes, obviously as you watch and learn more about them, your speculations about who they are as singers will become more accurate. However, you say "the whole purpose of this video was to have a "reaction" to the video", but you did not do only that - and it's certainly fine to speculate, but in doing so by definition it's going beyond just a "reaction" to what you've watched. And as such, speculating also means that you are no longer dealing with just the facts, so by making statements that extrapolate how they are as singers based solely on one video, especially when the speculation about their singing ability is quite negative and far from the truth, you open yourself up to legit criticisms: - The speculations themselves were incorrect. As you'll come to find out if you're interested, BTS has very good singers - the 4 that are not the rappers; and 1-2 are arguably among the stronger singers in kpop (not just my opinion). Of course you weren't expected to know that based on this video, just noting how this makes your wording about your speculations that much more glaring... - You sounded like you were pretty much on one side of things in saying things like: "they are clearly a dancing group", followed by saying you can't tell if they have much singing skill based on this performance, followed by "Are they singers? But maybe they're not, maybe they're more performers", and finally the Britney comparison of being a performer but not a very good singer. You do realize that it's rather polarizing to say they're "maybe" not singers (you didn't say maybe not the best or great singers, just singers at all), and said another way, you're implying that perhaps they can't sing based on only this 4 minute performance. - About this video and the song itself: it could be the worst they've ever sounded live. Their other SNL song also had a couple of pitch problems, and it was said that some group members were struggling with the monitors and being able to hear (feel free to compare how they sound here with any other live performance they've ever done of those two songs). Certainly you aren't expected to know any of that either, however you did notice another point about the tough choreo and remarked how it could affect their vocals. Also, I get that you probably didn't realize Mic Drop was going to be predominantly rap, and you even said after that you want to hear songs with more vocals - so I would think with that awareness you'd be a little more cautious and hold off on a Britney comparison after one video containing little singing? If you had known more about them at this point or the issues they faced at SNL, I daresay your speculation would have been quite different. And this is where the frustration comes in for some people: reactors who don't know better at the time making incorrect, blanket statements characterizing the group as a whole based on a tiny sample size. An analogy would be like saying maybe Ariana isn't a good singer after watching only one song where she happened to go flat a couple of times. I assume you realize that even she and other greats have done so (and if not, then look up "vocal fails" and you'll see a bunch of videos showing how it can happen to the best of them)? I leave you with a suggestion: if you are still interested in viewing a stripped down showcase of their vocals, albeit brief, try their Carpool Karaoke session with James Corden. Thanks for reading.

Sheila Brannon The video reactions I do are based off of the voting on my Community tab on my channel. I suggest you subscribe so you can vote here when I post it: ru-vid.com/show-UCUd6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

I did :)

😂

@@SongsFromASuitcase That‘s really impolite.

A lot of people have been suggesting House Of Cards?

@@SongsFromASuitcase yes, that's a really good song with high notes. Also song let me know or solo song called Stigma. Please react to these songs live version. 💜

@@SongsFromASuitcase oh and there is this song called crystal snow and one of the members does triple high note. You should check it too

I've actually just reviewed the truth untold live. It will release tomorrow. It was a whole different experience!

OMG what world do we live in, when a vocal coach thinks BLACKPINK are better singers than BTS, by God are you really a vocal coach? I ask

I've reacted to Truth Untold. It was a whole different experience!

@@SongsFromASuitcase Thank you very much💜🥰

Hey Andra V Sousa! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)

Sorry! I didn't realise that was a thing until after I put out this video

Oh! I havn't been suggested that yet. I'll have to check it out! Thanks!

@@SongsFromASuitcase thank you!

Already happening! So far that seems to be the most requested. You can expect it soon ;)