Тёмный

Walther PDP vs HK VP9- Tabletop Comparison 

Gruntreviews
Подписаться 11 тыс.
Просмотров 21 тыс.
50% 1

www.buymeacoffee.com/Gruntrev...

Спорт

Опубликовано:

 

4 июл 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 136   
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
I just got a PDP full size, I already have a Vp9, I have to honestly admit... The Vp9 is now the "second best striker fired trigger" on the market.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Walther really got the trigger right on the PDP. I wish I could blend the two of them together.
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews the Vp9 is awesome, no doubt, but the PDP just beats it. Unbelievable, and great video bud!!
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
@@bruce5168 thank you for the kind words. We appreciate it!
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews very welcome!!
@roberthendrickson3134
@roberthendrickson3134 Год назад
I just got a PDP pro tactical with the high performance trigger from the factory…… suddenly my VP9 is not as good as I thought it was….ordered a Lazy Wolf performance trigger for the VP9….. will see if that helps the notchyness of the VP9
@zone3adk872
@zone3adk872 2 года назад
Great vid. I'm new to handguns. Recently bought a VP9 and about to order a PDP. His and hers - sort of anyway, just became empty nesters and replacing kids with guns, LOL.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
I've been told guns are a bit less expensive
@oceandmike
@oceandmike 2 года назад
Guns never borrow your car and forget to put gas in.
@lousiffer5289
@lousiffer5289 Год назад
Never too late. Thankfully I got into guns before my kids because the third is on the way, and I don't get to shoot near as much lol
@intheknow3431
@intheknow3431 2 года назад
Your review was good. I happen to have both guns. The Walther is by far a better buy, about a couple hundred $$$. cheaper. The Walther trigger is better and if you're going to wear gloves the Walter has a bigger opening to accommodate the glove. The Walther slide serrations are much better to rack the slide. I purchased the HK years ago and it's been a very good gun but is showing it age. I'm looking for HK to upgrade or bring out a new gun in the near future. Striker fired gun improvements are moving very fast now with new models coming out all the time. I think the quality of these 2 guns are equal so the Walther is a better buy of coarse it a new model for Walther, they did a good job with it.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
That's a good synopsis. I too hope the VP9 gets a revamp or something new comes out of HK.
@awesomedave8484
@awesomedave8484 2 года назад
My vp9 tactical came with suppressor height sights. I also have the match but I think the ergonomics of hk can’t be beat. My buddy has the pdp and it just felt unfinished.
@MrCooper89
@MrCooper89 Год назад
Walthers are fudd guns.
@zmanphx
@zmanphx 2 года назад
I like both of them. I might buy both. Germans make good looking pistols.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
The Germans definition do build a nice firearm
@v.german11b
@v.german11b 2 года назад
Both are excellent combat handguns. I like the H&K very much, but my choice is the Walther PDP.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
I was an HK guy forever, but i've become a lot more open in recent years to other options.
@v.german11b
@v.german11b 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews H&K has an outstanding record and notorious quality. I love their firearms. Wouldn't mind to own a VP, maybe one day, but mostly, I am a Walther, CZ and Canik fan 😎
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
I love the VP9, just wish it would've gotten more of an update than just an optics cut.
@v.german11b
@v.german11b 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews Walther, CZ and Canik, all the way!
@dsd-downshiftdave8056
@dsd-downshiftdave8056 4 месяца назад
Best review, covers everything
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 4 месяца назад
Thank you for the kind words
@tims1415
@tims1415 2 года назад
My HK Tactical came with three seventeen round magazines. I ordered a twenty-four rounder from HK Parts just for good measure though.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Yup, the new ones are all getting the 17rd.
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
The PDP is surprisingly lite too!!
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
indeed
@ericguerrero2542
@ericguerrero2542 Год назад
Walther compact for the win!!
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
Thank you for the comment!
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
And the reset on the PDP is ridiculous!!!! Very very short
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Indeed. Walter did a fantastic job with the trigger
@1codygti
@1codygti Год назад
I have 3 PDP love all of them
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
I'll be reviewing the full size pro here in the coming weeks.
@tylerhaskiell1338
@tylerhaskiell1338 3 года назад
LOVE the pdp, my second favorite is my fn 509 mrd.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 3 года назад
I've review the 509 edge, but have not shot the 509 mrd. I may have to pick one up.
@RepentorPerish77
@RepentorPerish77 2 года назад
Love my VP9..if I didn't already have the P10C which I also love, Id consider the PDP.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
All three are solid options. It almost makes it hard to choose.
@noble6466
@noble6466 Год назад
P-10C is a really great gun, kinda seems like it flew under the radar though
@RepentorPerish77
@RepentorPerish77 Год назад
@@noble6466 yeah it does. That’s CZ for you. Not much marketing in the US. And typically unless you’re a gun person, you don’t know about them
@JW-vo5gs
@JW-vo5gs 7 месяцев назад
How would you rank the 3? I’ve been looking at the CZ P10-c, but found some good deals on the VP9 and PDP
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 7 месяцев назад
Vp9, PDP, P10c
@sixt3denied
@sixt3denied 2 года назад
Walther PDP is my next firearm. Just not sure which size to get it in. Thanks for the great video!
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
My pleasure
@wjggmt1180
@wjggmt1180 2 года назад
Me neither. I suppose I will error on the side of concealment. I have held one, its a real chunky monkey.
@sixt3denied
@sixt3denied 2 года назад
I bought the 4" compact which is still pretty big. The gun shoots amazingly smooth. Probably the most comfortable well designed grip of any gun out there right now. I absolutely love it. Incredibly accurate with the stock sights. Rear sight is adjustable. My favorite gun to shoot.
@wjggmt1180
@wjggmt1180 2 года назад
@@sixt3denied I see they make an SD Pro or something---not really sure I would want that threaded nipple coming out of the gun, but I do like the big fat mag well.
@sixt3denied
@sixt3denied 2 года назад
@@wjggmt1180 I agree. The big perk is the performance trigger. But the trigger is already so good I personally don't see the need to get the Pro version.
@bruce5168
@bruce5168 2 года назад
And the HK trigger is better then a lot of them out there, but the PDP beats it by a close margin.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
I would have to agree
@Payner2644
@Payner2644 2 года назад
Just got the PDP and love it! Had a PPQ M2, which was nice, but not as nice as the PDP!! Besides, HKs are overpriced.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
just about anything out of europe is overpriced, thats the downside to german precision
@alexmiller6848
@alexmiller6848 11 месяцев назад
I've noticed this too, HK is overpriced, as I tend not to buy American made pistols.
@JRWplus3
@JRWplus3 2 года назад
What are all the upgrades you put on this thing? Do you have a link to all the stuff? I really love the way you built it out. Great look and great functionality.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Truglo TFX sights, hk parts striker and back plate, lobos trigger, Taylor freelance magwell.
@jonbarlock848
@jonbarlock848 2 года назад
I own tbe VP9 I would love to own the PDP as well!
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
That would be a good combo.
@kuningaskolassas4720
@kuningaskolassas4720 6 дней назад
Pretty clear which your preference is.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 6 дней назад
We all have preferences. I will say the new PDP pro is a huge step up. I may need to do a follow up.
@VincitOmniaVeritas7
@VincitOmniaVeritas7 6 месяцев назад
Great comparison. Now that the VP9 tactical comes with a optics cut and 17-rd magazine and the PDP Pro comes with a threaded barrel and tall sights, it should be an easier comparison. I have the VP9T (old model) and still didn’t feel the need to upgrade or change to a PDP.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 6 месяцев назад
Indeed. It's taken them quite a while, but it's nice to see manufacturers adapting to the industry.
@elihollins1
@elihollins1 8 месяцев назад
Great review. 1st question, if you had to pick one pdp or vp9, which would it be? Overall which one do you like more? 2nd question. I hear the pdp is snappy, is it really that bad?
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 8 месяцев назад
That's a tough one. I'd probably go PDP Pro (wasn't out when I made this video. I've got a range review up on the PDP, it is snappier than some. I'll be reviewing the PDP pro this year.
@johnneill5960
@johnneill5960 2 года назад
lol I just bought both of these toady except I bought the optics cut VP9
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Good combo purchase. I've had my vp9 since they came out. May need to upgrade to the OR version at some point.
@jasondavis1187
@jasondavis1187 2 года назад
Where did you get an optical ready Vp9? I’m having trouble finding one !!
@johnneill5960
@johnneill5960 2 года назад
Jason Davis I bought them both at Bass Pro here in Branson. I've seen them on Gunbroker though .
@jcadvanced
@jcadvanced 2 года назад
@@jasondavis1187 I believe the 2020 models comes optic ready... I bought the VP9 LE which is optic ready, includes 3 mags, and 3 dot tritium night sights.
@MRsolidcolor
@MRsolidcolor 2 года назад
i have the hkvp9 and i dont think ill ever get rid of it.. really hard to beat it.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Vp9 is still a fantastic firearm, just getting a bit dated.
@ravidadz2354
@ravidadz2354 2 года назад
I have one and it’s smooth as fuck
@jonbarlock848
@jonbarlock848 2 года назад
Same here
@roc5291
@roc5291 7 месяцев назад
Whenever they do the next James Bond film, I’m hoping they finally ditch the PPK and give him the PDP. I think it would be huge for Walther’s marketing to get that gun in the hands of a character that made their brand huge in the first place.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 7 месяцев назад
I hadn't thought about that, but that would definitely boost marketing.
@Chris09978
@Chris09978 2 года назад
I’m curious about walthers barrel for pistol, is it a match grade barrel or a cold hammer forged polygonal
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
Polygonal rifling
@Chris09978
@Chris09978 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews oh shit that’s really cool, funny how they don’t list it on their website which is weird to me
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
It's become the standard lately. Button rifling has fallen off a bit in recent years. There's advantages and disadvantages to both.
@MRsolidcolor
@MRsolidcolor 2 года назад
i would like to send my gun to lazy wold and have them set it up.. they are some of the best at it.. i like what they do with the slide lock and triggers... they test and make a great trigger even better... but it dont need anything out of the box.. why i love my hk. glock cant even buy a trigger thats better the the hk.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
I believe lazy wolf is the guy who used to work for gray guns that left to do his own thing.
@champy1210
@champy1210 3 года назад
With an optic on it, you don't need the cocking ears. (And I'm an HK guy.)
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 3 года назад
The ears definitely aren't an absolute need, but they are nice on an irons only pistol.
@stizz1982
@stizz1982 2 года назад
Would you choose the P30 over the Walther PDP?
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
That's a tough one. I started shooting USPSA with a p30L. I have a lot of nostalgia for hammer fired actions. That being said, even with a top end trigger job, the stock PDP trigger is better. I like the grip module better on the walther, but I do like the smaller slide on the p30. Price wise, the PDP is a few bucks less and is optics ready.
@awokeone7997
@awokeone7997 3 года назад
Is the Lobos trigger on the VP9 really a improvement or should I just keep the stock one?
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 3 года назад
It's not night and day, but it feels slightly smoother. I've noticed its easier to keep a consistent trigger rhythm with the lobos over stock.
@awokeone7997
@awokeone7997 3 года назад
@@Gruntreviews what area is the most important would you say?
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 3 года назад
@@awokeone7997 I used the vp9 primarily for shooting USPSA. The consistency is definitely important for quick follow up shots. I like the fact that lobos retains all of the factory safeties. I would feel confident carrying in a duty pistol or for CCW.
@kuningaskolassas4720
@kuningaskolassas4720 6 дней назад
It seems strange to be comparing one gun out of the box, to another with several mods added. But you didn't seem to want to give the pdp much of a chance anyway.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 6 дней назад
It's what I had laying around. I will say the new PDP pro is night and day better from the original.
@searcheryea6579
@searcheryea6579 Год назад
Do any of these models have any type of safeties?? Looking for first firearm
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
They have several safeties built in, but do not have an external thumb safety.
@searcheryea6579
@searcheryea6579 Год назад
@@Gruntreviews thanks for the reply
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
My pleasure
@johndeere1951a
@johndeere1951a 2 месяца назад
Look at the CZ P-09 and P-07. They come with decocker levers, and include in the case Safety levers that are easy for you to switch out. Decocker or Safety levers included for a reasonable price.
@kotmartnoskin2322
@kotmartnoskin2322 Год назад
I have not try PDP yet but I would be really surprised if that mother lover gonna be better than my HK VP9……will see 🤔🤔🤔🤔
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
They're pretty dang close.
@marcmeadows6103
@marcmeadows6103 4 месяца назад
How do i get a threaded barrel for my vp9
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 4 месяца назад
Purchase one
@richardmcginty8819
@richardmcginty8819 2 года назад
How can you do a Fair comparison when the VP9 has aftermarket upgrades? Comparisons should be stock vs stock.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
That's why I left the trigger comparison out. That and the Magwell are the only changes. But I do agree and generally shoot for stock vs stock.
@lizzapaolia959
@lizzapaolia959 7 месяцев назад
Both are fantastic pistols. My husband and I have a good size collection of German pistols. I'm a huge fan of the HK, then some days the Walther.... HK is going to be releasing a new sub compact pistol in 2024. Thank you for sharing your videos 🙏
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for the kind words. I've heard the HK rumors, I'll have to keep my eye out.
@johndeere1951a
@johndeere1951a 2 месяца назад
What is your source on H&K coming out with a mini SK . Don't regurgitate rumours. 👎
@gutWrench9mm
@gutWrench9mm Год назад
Those plastic cocking ears are cool till they fall off
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
I haven't experienced that, but it would definitely suck to lose one.
@robertkarlmann6403
@robertkarlmann6403 3 года назад
How bout throwing in a Canik?
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 3 года назад
I'll have to get my hands on one.
@sweetcostarica
@sweetcostarica 2 года назад
There is a lot of focus today on a "good" trigger. The striker-fired *_Glock inspired_* trigger is neither good nor bad, it is just a different kind of trigger. Almost all modern guns have "good" 👍 triggers. So don't worry about them as in a gun fight your adrenaline will make your hands feel like flippers. If you practice/train with your gun to _learn_ the trigger you will hit anything well. Remember - it is not the gun, it is the man. FACT 1: most LEOs practice the minimum with their gun. Just enough to pass qualifications. FACT 2: most people shoot 🔫 between 120 to 200 shots a year. Think about it 🤔.
@ambienceization
@ambienceization Год назад
Shut up glock fanboy
@sweetcostarica
@sweetcostarica Год назад
@@ambienceization You mad bro 😡 ? Lo siento, mucho, you got triggered my man *ambienceization.*
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
Thank you for the comment!
@darknightbegins85
@darknightbegins85 11 месяцев назад
Close, hk is cooler tho
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 11 месяцев назад
I'd like to combine them into a hybrid
@wjggmt1180
@wjggmt1180 2 года назад
Hey, at least he is not reviewing Glocks. Glocks are made by swamp people, for swamp people.
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
If glock ever came out with something truly new, I'd review it. It seems all they do is add and remove finger groves and call it new.
@jhustler1992
@jhustler1992 Год назад
I was never a Glock fan myself for years but I really love the Gen 5 models. Gen 5 far surpasses the previous generation models in my opinion. Especially, when it comes to the grip too.
@alexmiller6848
@alexmiller6848 11 месяцев назад
It's funny that they are on the 5th generation of the same pistol design. If any other handgun company were to make 5 generations of the same pistol people would think they are crazy. The fact is the Glock design even with the 5th generation is basically the same ancient design Gaston came up with in the 80's with no real innovation other than maybe the optic cut.
@darylragland1502
@darylragland1502 Год назад
Notchiness. Wtf. It's the safety plunger
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
Indeed, the plunger is probably creating the notchy feeling.
@jaysview4009
@jaysview4009 2 года назад
🙄
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews Год назад
Thank you for the comment
@tereztiago9133
@tereztiago9133 2 года назад
That HK setup makes a glock look like a work of art..🤮😆
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
If you like shooting a brick, glock is where it's at.
@tereztiago9133
@tereztiago9133 2 года назад
@@Gruntreviews i dont i love HK’s and walther’s i have both
@Gruntreviews
@Gruntreviews 2 года назад
@@tereztiago9133 the Germans can definitely build a fine firearm.
@jonbarlock848
@jonbarlock848 2 года назад
Haha Glocks are ugly as hell.
Далее
Walther PDP Compact vs. H&K VP9sk
12:56
Просмотров 28 тыс.
Walther PDP, All Full Size Guns Should Feel This Good
7:05
ЛУЧШАЯ ПОКУПКА ЗА 180 000 РУБЛЕЙ
28:28
FN 509 LS Edge vs Walther PDP vs HK VP9
19:36
Просмотров 10 тыс.
The Trump Shooter was Wearing My Shirt...
5:54
Просмотров 2,7 млн
HK VP9...WHY DID I WAIT SO LONG?
27:53
Просмотров 78 тыс.
Top 5 John Wick Guns
12:42
Просмотров 7 млн
Walther PDP vs. PPQ
20:48
Просмотров 292 тыс.
New Walther PDP Pistol Review
25:06
Просмотров 500 тыс.
HK VP9 vs Glock G19 - Honest Comparison.
11:28
Просмотров 13 тыс.
HK VP9 Striker Fired Pistol Review
19:24
Просмотров 699 тыс.
ОНА СЛОМАЛА ВОРОТА🥅😱
0:57
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Мбаппе, ты где?
1:00
Просмотров 670 тыс.
Ronaldo Vs Other Players ☠️
0:42
Просмотров 13 млн