Тёмный
No video :(

'What Happens Now?' by Porcupine Tree EXPLAINED 

Yogev Gabay
Подписаться 87 тыс.
Просмотров 9 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

26 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 67   
@assaultk47
@assaultk47 2 года назад
More porcupine tree please
@FredNagel
@FredNagel 3 года назад
I had the joy of watching Gavin Harisson explain and then play this section at a drum clinic. Absolute genius what they accomplished here.
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Oh boy I'm so jealous!
@RudolfHorvath
@RudolfHorvath 3 года назад
@@YogevGabay No idea if you ever saw it, but Gavin explains it here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-A2ReDqc3aFs.html&ab_channel=jez12
@darwingabriel4463
@darwingabriel4463 3 года назад
You all prolly dont give a shit but does someone know of a tool to log back into an instagram account?? I stupidly lost the password. I appreciate any assistance you can offer me!
@beauneil878
@beauneil878 3 года назад
@Darwin Gabriel Instablaster ;)
@darwingabriel4463
@darwingabriel4463 3 года назад
@Beau Neil Thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site on google and I'm trying it out atm. I see it takes quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@dinokatdrummer
@dinokatdrummer 3 года назад
Man, this channel is freaking gold
@iSlowSilver
@iSlowSilver 3 года назад
Your production is great, really hope you get more viewers to make this worthwhile for you because I find it so informative!
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
I appreciate that!
@delusionwalker8852
@delusionwalker8852 3 года назад
I am impressed by how well you are able to explain things without rumbling without over complicating to the point and so elegantly. Your videos are top. I really enjoy your channel. Thank you!
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Glad it was helpful!
@didsa
@didsa 2 года назад
This is amazing! The thing that made this part even more confusing the first time I heard it is that the 5/8 guitar part showed up a year or so before in the song Anesthetize, with a completely different drum groove (4/4 as the host, I think?).
@oreothebest
@oreothebest 9 месяцев назад
It’s because the ep were the songs they cut from blank planet, so this might’ve been a part of anesthetize, or a call back or something like that. Hence the same guitar part.
@lifeattractslife
@lifeattractslife Год назад
Thank you for this delightful analysis! Keep it up!
@TheProgSchool
@TheProgSchool 3 года назад
Great analysis of this! This has always been one of my favorite PT songs because of this section. Especially when they all sync up on the 3 (or 9?). Good stuff!
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Yeah man that half time feel is so goooddddd
@ofirg7152
@ofirg7152 11 месяцев назад
Amazing! Got to know the song a week ago (though I'm a huge fan of porcupine tree for years). As always, your videos are so fun :) Also proud to say I figured this stuff out too hahaha
@jijst5
@jijst5 3 года назад
Seriously underrated channel!!!
@tamirleibovich
@tamirleibovich 3 года назад
You make a very complicated stuff so easy and intuitive !!! כזה מלך
@francoiswaterbee8376
@francoiswaterbee8376 Год назад
Wow! very well explained, many thanks! I cannot stop listening to this section and wondering how can you play so complex music that seem so natural! PT are just geniuses
@stefan86wtf
@stefan86wtf 3 года назад
So interesting, as chaotic as music gets :D
@DiogoSilva-ld7we
@DiogoSilva-ld7we 3 года назад
Dude, thank you so much for this video. I've loved this section ever since I've first heard it and always wanted an explanation of how all the different beats intertwine and come together in the end (I'm not very knowlegable in the rhythm department ahah). I can finally rest assured that I now (somewhat) understand it ahah
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Great ! Man that's the goal I'm happy you get it a bit better now !
@charlieno3909
@charlieno3909 3 года назад
Great content, I totally agree, your production is very interesting and unique. Keep up this amazing work!
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Thanks a lot ! Happy you like it
@banehog
@banehog Год назад
*YES!* This is the most insane thing ever! First time I heard it was on the Anesthetize Blu-Ray, instant nirvana for my ADHD brain. I can only keep track of two of the signatures simultaneously in my head, first the 5 and the 7, then the 7 and the 3 (my favorite). The part where 5, 7 and 3 are all playing, I have to sacrifice the 5. Man, Gavin is such a beast. He has a great philosophy regarding time signatures: Everything is just patterns of 2s and 3s.
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay Год назад
Yeh man Gavin is and always has been a HUGE inspiration for me
@PieceOfDuke
@PieceOfDuke 3 года назад
Listened to the song for years and never knew )
@moadot720
@moadot720 2 года назад
7:08 is so cool! You need to do this in future videos!
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 2 года назад
That final run through you mean ?
@americanidiot5563
@americanidiot5563 2 года назад
Huge thank you dor explaining!
@pavelduda8170
@pavelduda8170 3 года назад
Every single one of your videos is amazing! Thank you
@brutalvocalcovers
@brutalvocalcovers 3 года назад
What a great analysis.
@foomfs
@foomfs 3 года назад
ok last one i swear: Car Bomb - Constant Sleep ( 1m03s ) this one's got to be one of my best submissions :D
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Noted!
@a.s.henderson483
@a.s.henderson483 3 года назад
Very cool indeed. Thanks for the effort. Been looking forward to yr videos each week.
@ThePhlegming
@ThePhlegming 3 года назад
Thank you so much Yogev, you the man
@TheAciddropper
@TheAciddropper 3 года назад
just discovered your channel, awesome work. made really clear and comprehensive, thank u
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Welcome aboard, Glad you like them!
@felipebiana73
@felipebiana73 3 года назад
Amaizing videos!
@rodjenihm
@rodjenihm 3 месяца назад
Steven Wilson: I don't know any music theory
@foomfs
@foomfs 3 года назад
great stuff! :D
@clubgrubbug
@clubgrubbug 3 года назад
What about the intro to swarm by Meshuggah? I have always felt this concept at work in there but no way I could nail it down.
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Will listen!
@MrDrummerultime
@MrDrummerultime 3 года назад
to my ear the host is 5/4 all the time because all of the rythmical illusion is think around it and it works with the harmony...
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Even after it goes away?
@DruMMaSt3R666
@DruMMaSt3R666 2 года назад
Aren't the drums just playing metric modulation over the original riff that's in 5? It's not a different time signature, he's just modulating into the triplets
@joaoguerreiro52
@joaoguerreiro52 3 года назад
Do king crimson indiscipline version with the 3 drummers, Gavin among them,
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Will look into it!
@yoavmenuhin5360
@yoavmenuhin5360 3 года назад
Yo Yogev! This video is so good! The song puzzeld me for very long time, thank you for solving it! I think you should do a video about agent fresco - the autoumn red, the end is a jungle full of polyrhythms and complex time signature, check it out! :)
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Noted! Man I was just introduced to them not to long ago they're epic!
@toprak3479
@toprak3479 3 года назад
Why would the last part be in 9? It's either in 3, 6 or 12. The chord changes after 12 beats. Edit: Read the other comment. I suspected that answer but I think it's just a triplet-feel carried over from the previous part rather than actually being the time signature.
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Yeah it's kinda 6/8 but it's in triplets. That's why haha
@arthurfurman5362
@arthurfurman5362 3 года назад
You are a beautiful person
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Are you just saying it so I buy your table? Because it's working.
@arthurfurman5362
@arthurfurman5362 3 года назад
@@YogevGabay I will never sell it! Unless you really want it.
@arthurfurman5362
@arthurfurman5362 3 года назад
@@YogevGabay BTW love the animations you are adding lately :)
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
All thanks to Sharon Renold !
@mojocampbell___
@mojocampbell___ 3 года назад
Why is the last part in 9? It’s in 3 and phrased in intervals of 4 bars, which would be 12 if anything. I have no clue how it could be considered 9.
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Yeah I may have needed to explain that further hahahaha You said it's in 3 right? but each of those 3 main beats is also divided into3. It's the same 3 that the ride cymbal is playing, only now they became the main beats. Makes sense?
@VictorPageMusic
@VictorPageMusic 3 года назад
​@@YogevGabay Sure, but don't you think it's just a tempo change ? I feel like the former tempo is gone when that last part hits. Great video btw, as usual ! 🍻🥁
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 3 года назад
Sure sure yes, the main beats get redefined so the tempo follows, that's correct!
@georgeaiken2965
@georgeaiken2965 2 года назад
They use the exact same guitar riff in 5/8 in the middle of "anesthesize". In a similar context too, except anesthesize is a way better song
@YogevGabay
@YogevGabay 2 года назад
Dude anesthetize is insane.
Далее
'Modul 29_14' by Nik Bärtsch EXPLAINED
13:15
Просмотров 6 тыс.
Making Complicated Music Sound Easy
13:43
Просмотров 16 тыс.
Коротко о моей жизни:
01:00
Просмотров 312 тыс.
"Sentimental" by Porcupine Tree EXPLAINED
10:52
Просмотров 20 тыс.
Metal Drummer Hears Led Zeppelin For The First Time
20:38
Snarky Puppy's 5s!
12:20
Просмотров 14 тыс.
2030: Privacy's Dead. What happens next?
23:56
Просмотров 2,1 млн
What Happens Now?
8:24
Просмотров 79 тыс.
Jacob Collier is a polyrhythm GURU !
10:11
Просмотров 15 тыс.
What is a Tihai?
10:47
Просмотров 18 тыс.
Writing BANGER METAL RIFFS using Indian methods
11:36
The weird groove from Jacob Colliers "Hideaway"
8:25
Коротко о моей жизни:
01:00
Просмотров 312 тыс.