What If Everyone Luffy Asked Actually JOINED THE CREW? | One Piece | Grand Line Review 

This was wildly exciting! But still not as exciting as speculating what if everyone pressed that subscribe button. EVERYONE getting One Piece content straight into their RU-vid feed? Now that’s exciting.

I used to think Luffy had a good eye for talent but I'm starting to think he just gets really lucky with his picks.

“KAIDO! JOIN MY CREW” “...Sure”

Remember when Luffy was offered Foxy's entire crew as a reward for winning the Davy Back Fight? Imagine if he kept those crewmembers and we'd have to juggle 515 characters.

if this really happened, ODA will surely makes us cry about the Zombie Tree & Unicorn backstory

We're all better for not having such a large crew, I can only imagine how zombie tree's multi-chapter backstory would have broken us all even more than the death of the Mary

Chopper is left out, this is the darkest timeline.

If you made an excuse for Jimbei we can also make an excuse with Chopper. Let's say Crocus knows what bit Nami, however, he does not possess the antidote. Being as smart as he is (and after a few dramatic zooms) he suggests going to Drum Island, which is known for its experts in medicine ;)

“Our new mascot is a bush in a box so never fear” *Sad Karoo noises*

Alternative ending to the War of The Great where the pirates win. Luffy to Whitebeard: Yo old man! Join my crew!

"...Only his legs. Luffy did not, I repeat, did not ask the rest of him." LMAO

Imagine Kuma sending 50 people to different island and we're watching all of the story that explains what happened them

Now I'm imagining a story where everyone says no and Luffy has to grow super powerful and become the pirate king on his own

Luffy: You’re a doctor?! You should be our doctor! Krokis: Well shit guess you’re right

Zoro, Sanji and Jinbei? Pfft.. Luffy, Ace and Sabo? Don't be absurd Gaimon, Carue and Leopard Centaur are the new monster trio.

Why do I get the feeling Usopp would clue into Luffy's ability to just ask people to join and they magically agree? Any time they run into someone strong that scares him. Usopp would be like "Luffy, he should join the crew" Depending how fast he notices this, the crew gets big and strong pretty quick.. and probably also has some dinosaurs from Little Garden :P

Imagine the Thousand Sunny being much larger than it was originally. Pretty interesting.

I'm just imaging Kuma running out of ideas on where to send the extra straw hats. Crocus just gets sent to Shaki's bar because he doesn't need a training trip.

Imagine Luffy asks the Yonko to join his crew and their only response is "Bet. Let's get this bread."

Could you imagine how much more OP Luffy's crew would be if this was real. But it makes me sad that Chopper won't be in the Straw Hats if this happened

Imagine all the hilarious interactions we would get. Gaimon alone being in the crew opens up so many possibilities.

Wait if Luffy had a Ace as a crew member throughout Sabaody, then Ace would’ve met Rayleigh and learned more about Roger through him.

I really can’t get over, tree and unicorn zombie’s deaths. Those were some hard times in One Piece history...

Chopper still joins because they'd need supplies to cure Nami from Kestia which is a rare disease eradicated over 100 years ago and she just happened to have the antidote (it's unlikely Crocus would it handy) so they would still go to Drum Island and Luffy would still ask Chopper to join because he's a "cool transforming reindeer"/emergency food supply!

"I gained 9 more members" "but at what cost?" " i lost a racoo- I mean a deer"

If they all joined then robin and chopper would get to do even less stuff than they do now.

Most importantly this alternative universe would create the true monster trio Gaimon, Karoo, and Kinemons legs.

I think Luffy would still pick up chopper, because correct me if I’m wrong but the log pose will still point to drum island, and the crew would still get caught up in that conflict while the logpose is finding the next island, so Luffy would still meet chopper and probably ask him to join the crew anyway because of his circumstances rather than for the need of a doctor

Didn't he also ask Smoker in alabasta and also said to someone (I don't remember who) that Law was from his crew? Also, only Kureiha had the pre-historic medicine and Chopper was asked to join because of his transformations, so that could be an excuse. This video is great! I was thinking one of those days about that and I'm glad someone did it. Imagine a OVA like that, would be a mess. Poor Bartolomeo, everyone joins but him.

There is a major detail you are missing. Blackbeard's original plan was to chase down Luffy and capture him for the world government so he could become a Shichibukai. Ace just interrupted that and ended up fulfilling the same purpose so he never went after Luffy. I think a better situation would be to substitute Impel Down/Marineford for a situation where Luffy is captured and the rest of the crew attempts to free him. If they also failed to free him from Impel Down, potentially Crocus could gather up the Roger Pirate remnants to have their own war at Marineford for Luffy

This is the alternate timeline where Luffy maxed out his charisma

Actually, the blood transfusion wouldn't even happen now that I think about it. because Ace has a blood type of S (O) which is the universal donor.

Gaimon D Box is the strongest of the Strawhat Crew.

10:09 Lmao, could you imagine: *The crew finishes up their business in Wano* *Everyone makes their way back to ship* *Luffy stops Kinemon* Kinemon: Wait, I thought I was part of the crew? Luffy: Uh-uh, just the legs Kinemon: Just my legs? *Luffy nods* Kinemon: ..... Kinemon: k.

Tree and unicorn need to join so the strawhats can be truly be yonko level crew.

Nakama Gaimon would make the journey to Laugh Tale too easy with his army of rare animals.

Seeing Crocus meeting Brook on his ship would be really interesting

I like how everyone just joined for no reason but a change of heart lol

Luffy meets Aokiji for the first time:" Wow you are a actual iceman???? Join my crew! " Aokiji:"Oh man here we go. Come on little man hop on my bicycle we have to get my penguin."

Could I have an F for the best crew mates ever, Zombie Tree and Zombie Unicorn. I pour one out for both of you.

Honestly, I think Luffy being the impulsive person he is might've just asked Frankie to join because no one fills the Robot/Cyborg role of the straw hats at that point

Imagine Crocus meeting Rayleigh in Sabaody that would be interesting

It should have been like this: Crocus lacks the materials on curing Nami and thus they still head to Drum island.

Can you imagine Gaimon infiltrating Enies Lobby and fighting a CP9 member? Lmao

It’s like Luffy has Geass but the only thing he ever commands is “join my crew.”

Dude..... just hearing the statement “ace, luffy, and zoro joining together” THAT early in the show throws my head into places I never thought it would go lol.

The real monster trio: Buggy D. Clown, Go D. Usopp, and Gaimon D. Shrub

This became hilarious once he stated everyone who would be there at Innie's Lobby to save Robin😂😂😂

I think we would still have chopper as doctor kureha said that the medicine for nami was rare and luckily kureha had the medicine... So yahhh, they would come to drum island from their ship doctor's request

Chopper would still join. The crew would still have to pass through Drum and wait, for the log to set. Luffy would probably want to deal with wapol as he does in every other island, and with all the time he spends on the island he would definitely meet Chopper, and would immediately ask the talking reindeer/ raccoon to join the crew. And they would definitely meet cause Chopper came down to the town, plus was living in wapol's castle, luffy's new target. Even if they don't go to drum specifically for a doctor, Chopper would still join.

Well they have Crocus on the crew and that guy has been to the new world. He had seen the dangers of that place first hand and he would be the first in line to tell everyone, being the crews doctor after all, that they are NOT ready for the new world. Also they could have a nice reunion scene with Crocus and Rayleigh.

Luffy asked Ace to join his crew in Alabasta too. I just want Ace to have Mera Mera no mi.

Blackbeard was originally hunting for Luffy tho when Ace rather took his place for the execution

So mihawk saying that luffy has the ability to make allies wherever he goes is a literal power, impressive.

This clearly prove that Chopper is indead the most important crew member without him no Drum island arc, Wapol isn't defeated, no discovery of the wapo metal, the marine and vegapunk probably won't achieve the same level of power during the paramount war maybe no human weapon. Franky wouldn't create something as great as the general franky. But the same could be said with Crocus if he joined the crew the change in the story could have been insanely huge, in saboady he will meet with his former vice captain and with this fact we may learn sooner that Ace is Roger's son, seeing a former crewmate being a pirate again with one highly value by shanks and the son of his friend, Rayleigh joining the crew isn't an impossibility. Concerning the paramount i still think it would happend either way teach is still chasing Luffy to become a warlord. I can see a version where either Ace or luffy is captured (trying to save luffy and we learn about Ace's father) and the rest unfold almost in the same way but instead we may have Shanks coming with the revolutionary army this time and the help of whitebeard (because Teach still kill his son). By the way i don't think Ace would have wait 2 more year for luffy to be a pirate, i think he would have began his journey the same way, eating the mera mera no mi, being part of whitebeard crew until the first bounty of Luffy. At this point he would join his first captain around Alasbata but before blackbeard kill Satch so that the event in Jaya doesn't feel too weird... But notheless those 3 a probably the one with the bigger impact if they joined or not the crew

Respect for acknowledging that Merry was the first Crewmember to die

I can’t believe you neglected to mention the great Con D. Oriano

You completely forgot how Luffy told Law he was joining his crew in Dressrosa!

The crew really missed out on that one old man stuck in a treasure chest

If everyone he invited joined his crew then he probably have zombie crew since he invited almost every zombies he met in thriller bark

Imagine Oda gives us a back story for all the crew members that's another 2 years added to one piece end

Jinbe did have a connection with Luffy: Arlong. When he first met Luffy in Impel Down Jinbe knew he had already defeated Arlong. He also apologized to Nami for letting him roam her island. So assuming he is in FI post timeskip he'd still approach the SH to apologize, at which point they would have joined forces to defeat Hody. No way Luffy wouldn't ask him

Completely lost it with giggles when he got to Kinemon's legs.

Imagine if Luffy, Ace, and Sabo really formed a pirate crew together

Actually in nami's village lufy asked doctor of that village to join the crew

I was planning to make a drawing of everyone Luffy have asked to join his crew but haven't do it yet. And then, this video comes up. I guess it's a sign

I think they'd still need to head up drum island, because before the events of this they'd have no supplies for medicine or have visited any island with any Seeing as how whiskey peak was a struggling bounty hunters den with dwindling supplies And theyd still come across Wapol on the sea and inevitably need to find an island with supplies thus adding Kureha and Chopper to this list

Nami's disease is rare. Crocus is a retired ship doctor, He probably doesn't have the medicine for Nami's disease because of it's rarity. So the trip to Drum island should still happen.

Kinimon: "I am leaving!" *stays* … damn legs won´t move

genuinely haven't laughed this much in a while Thank you GrandLineReview.

Chopper should be in the crew. If I am correct, luffy didn't invite him to be a doctor. He invited him because he liked him so much he called Chopper his friend. So basically, they have two doctors now

I think the Paramount War still would've happened. Blackbeard's original target was Luffy, and had he captured him, a similar situation would've occurred, just with Luffy being the one set for execution. The secret revealed at the execution would be him being Dragon's son, and the Emperor that showed up would be Shanks instead of Whitebeard. Dragon would've broken into Impel down to get Ivankov to join the war as well, and have shown up at the end where Shanks originally does. Same lines from Dragon, with him debating whether we should go see the now passed out from trauma Luffy. Sabo would also regain his memories at Marineford. If they were fighting Shanks, I doubt Mihawk would've participated in the war either, so he would also be booted from the title of Warlord. If Ace was already a part of the crew, I feel for "fate" related reasons, when Kuma separates them, he would've sent Ace to the island with the Flame Flame Fruit, and he would've trained it over the timeskip, which is coincidentally the same amount of time he has it for before his original death. Also Chopper would've still been recruited, they had to stop at Drum Island anyway, to follow the Log pose.

I guess Kinemom no longer has legs now :(

Just a picture of Luffy, Ace and Zoro together already makes me excited.

What if Shank actually let Lufy join him when Luffy first asked him?

Once Luffy learns Ryuo he can finally free Gaimon from his box.

OOO WAIT THO. I THOUGHT OF SOMETHING. Originally, Blackbeard was going to Water 7 to hunt Luffy when he ran into Ace instead. So if Luffy got captured instead, the war could’ve still happened. But it’s complicated. Granted, Ace was in a 1v1 vs Blackbeard and this would be Strawhat Pirates vs. Blackbeard Pirates (at Water 7). I definitely think Blackbeard has much less of a chance of winning here. But if the Strawhats did lose, there may be some fatalities and I wouldn’t put it passed Blackbeard to capture everyone in the crew who had a bounty above 100 mil (Luffy, Zoro, and Ace (probably)) So the war would set up 3 executions and they’re the 3 strongest members in the crew. The remaining Strawhats would have a hard time even getting to Marineford, but let’s say they make it somehow. They help out a little bit, but I think the majority of saving comes from outside the crew. You know Shanks would show up and there’s a good chance Dragon would too (based on how Ivankov talked about him during the war. When he was under the impression that Ace was also Dragon’s son, Ivankov says something along the lines of “why would the Navy start something with both Whitebeard and Dragon?”) That would be an opportunity for Sabo to get his memories back when he finds out that both Luffy and Ace are set to be executed. Overall I have no idea who would win this war. Whitebeard was a beast at Marineford but the fact remains that he wasn’t even close to being in his prime. It’s not completely unreasonable to assume that Dragon is Yonko level, so having both Shanks and Dragon on the Strawhat side would definitely stand a chance against the marines. It’s also not unreasonable to assume that Shanks has allies in the New World similar to how Whitebeard did. After writing it out, I feel like the Strawhats would have the same, if not an even better chance at success than Whitebeard. I’d be super interested to see how this version of the arc would turn out :)

Would they need a time skip? Since Crocus was already on board, he can tell Luffy about Haki early on, to help him train, if not train him personally ( as we don't really know if Crocus can use haki).

Dang it!!! Even in an alternate universe Straw hat crew Bon Chan still didn't make it? *sad Okama noises. ಥ⌣ಥ

Kaido: Thunder Bargu... Luffy: Oreno Nakama... Kaido: Oh shit, say no more.

how did they escape smoker on alabasta if ace didnt have the mera fruit, thats the only reason they survived smoker

before asking sanji, luffy asked red leg jeff..so if he said yes, then the straw hats would take aboard two chefs from baratie as luffy would definitely have asked sanji to join the crew after seeing him feed gin

Meanwhile.. Chopper : *still stuck at drum island*

I feel Apis could’ve actually been a pretty useful member, being able to talk to animals could be very useful, she’d basically be the crew’s scout.

My favorite part is when Gaimon went into his monster form to beat Kumadori.

*Luffy would take back the offer when he comes to know that Crocus knows about ONE PIECE. Nami becomes sick. So, Chopper Joins!*

Me: Oh the crew would be soooo cool! [sees no drum island]: **cries in no chopper**

About not picking up chopper and the old lady doctor, I don’t know how to spell her name, but they would most likely still join the crew. The disease Nami caught has been extinct for over a hundred years. Crocus most likely wouldn’t know how to treat it due to not being that old, therefore they would have to seek out someone who was that old, and boom. Now the straw hats have 3 doctors.

A thing I think you're missing is Dr. Kureha says that the poison Nami was effected by was very rare and she happens to keep the antidote just in case, so I think that they would still have to go to Drum island for help and then they would recruit Chopper and Kureha meaning there would be 3 doctors on the crew

Then Ace would still be alive :,)

Ah yes my favorite straw hat member, kinemon's legs

What if Luffy actually had 10 nakama join his crew before entering the Grand Line like he intended? Do Johnny & Yosaku get recruited? Does Luffy meet Bartolomeo sooner? Think it'd make a good vid

I didnt expect to find the exact video that i was searching for. Cheers!

The truth is that everyone that Luffy met became his nakama somehow. "That man possesses the most terrifying power"

this has nothing to do with this video but i started rewatching one piece and smoker is literally the best marine and knows true justice, i respect him so much cuz he didnt want to take luffys credit for defeating crocodile so he told the government to go to hell, favourite scene. Also he understands luffy is doing more good then the goverment.

Kinemon's legs as a straw hat were the cherry on the top of the cake. LMAO. You made our day, thanks.

Looks like the gum gum fruit had a extra ability in this timeline: the ability to force people to join your crew like a rubber band can bind dolls together. (Best way I can explain it while still fitting the rubber theme)

I can’t imagine Gaimon after the two year timeskip.

I think luffy asked jeff to Join the crew when he realised jeff was a cook.

I think that there is a very decent chance that staying behind to pay respects to the fallen zombie horse and zombie tree would have left them in the Florian Triangle long enough for the giant monster seen in the distance at the end of the arc to find the Straw Hats. Notably, the narrator in canon states that it is "fortunate" that the Straw Hats escaped the creature's notice, implying that they would have gone missing like countless other crews had in the Florian Triangle. TLDR if the zombies had joined the Straw Hats, they may have all ultimately died right after the Thriller Bark Arc in this universe.