What if Obi Wan NEVER Followed Padme to Mustafar FULL MOVIE 

Thank you for your patience 😊😘

SW Theory: "I'm not good at endings" Also SW Theory: *Writes an amazing ending*

Why can’t Disney hire Theory for a “What If…” like with marvel’s “What If…” ? He’d have a good sized budget and he’d be able to possibly work along side the dream team of Dave and Jon. I can only dream of it.

Broke my heart when Padme told Anakin "Anakin, you're breaking my heart". That shit got me in tears, and i barely cry watching movies.

I like how in this timeline Anakin's fate was the same as the real one. He redeemed himself through self sacrifice.

Palpatine-“You trusted them and they betrayed you!” Anakin-“I trusted you and you manipulated me!” Audience-“Oooooooooooooooooh!”

“Hey Master” “ANAKIN YOU HAVE DESTROYED EVERYTHING” 😂😂

The tragedy of Darth Vader... and How he broke his chains. A thing very few Sith manage to accomplish. A Sith story that the Jedi learn from. I like it.

This is the best Star Wars story I’ve ever heard. It literally made me tear up. This was the most beautiful and believable Star Wars story as it relates to darth Vader and Anakin. This is more what the story should have been. Unbelievable story telling!

If he never went to Mustafar, we wouldn’t have such a good lightsaber battle.

"HIS HATRED FOR SAND!" best line by far

I love how we can still theorize on what "bringing balance to the force" truly means. Many regard it as the Jedi and the Sith co existing in either light or dark. However, this fan fiction brings with it some great insight into how true balance means embracing the force as a whole. Great video!

There needs to be an alternate ending trilogy where something like this happens. It actually made me sad, knowing what happened, but happy at the same time.

Seeing that old intro was like meeting an old friend again

“Anakin’s final powers was not because he chose the light side or the dark. But because he chose the force itself.”

This was absolutly amazing. Honestly, I am certain that if the Star Wars were made in order, and hence no need to keep Palpatine alive and Vadar alive, that this would have been the ending giving to us in movies. The logic and interpretation of the lore you used to reach this conclusion is honestly so well done. Wow!

Can we just appreciate this man's voice acting? If there's another series like The Clone Wars, they should hire this man for the voices.

I’d really like to see a fan fiction about “What if Padme agrees to Rule The Galaxy with Anakin and overthrow the Chancellor”

Anakin: "Can i have a happy ending?" Star Wars theory: "We dont do that here"

The ending made me tear up. How powerful. Dude, you killed that story. From a Star Wars fan who grew up with the prequels, thank you. Much love.

Totally loved the young Anikan communicating with the older one. Breaking away from the "bondage" of slavery. His transition to a new form of force user was incredible 👏

The What if was finished because Theory discovered the secrets of the Polynesian Spa.

This is exactly why Star Wars needs a "What if" like Marvel. Truly a good job Theory!

Straight masterpiece. One of Theory’s greatest work IMO. Truly such a great writer with a deep understanding of Star Wars and it’s characters.

That was beautiful! You created so many gripping moments. The icing on the cake was Anakin still fulfilling the prophecy. Having him sacrifice himself was so unexpected and sad. I absolutely loved it!

When you see theory posting part 2 of a fan fiction after 4 years: "I have waited a long time for this, my little green friend! "

"He chose neither the Dark or the light, he chose The Force".... THAT was GOOD!

This fan fiction is one of the best I’ve seen. The voice acting, the production, the storytelling are incredible, and it feels for the most part similar to how things would have gone down. My only gripe with it is the aftermath of the battle feels a little to good to be true. Despite Palpatine’s death, the Republic still regard the Jedi as traitors, which would only have been vindicated by the death of not only Palpatine, but also Anakin, who in the eyes of the senate was still loyal to him. So I’m not sure it would be as simple as just returning to the temple and rebuilding the Jedi order. Perhaps with help from Organa and other senators sympathetic to the Jedi could convince the Republic that Palpatine was the one who betrayed them, and explain how he orchestrated the clone wars and played both sides, but they didn’t really have any evidence of that. And even if they had proof, it may have been ignored given the corruption in the senate. I think the Jedi would still have been forced into exile, with the clones potentially still hunting down what was left of the order, with their fate being decided by whoever was appointed as the new Chancellor. But that’s just my opinion. Still it doesn’t really take away from your video. Really good job!

The final moment of Anakin gave me constant goosebumps that I forgot to breathe and had a heart attack and died.. C'mon is there one happy ending for Ani 😭 he deserves it..(your ending was so awesome and tragic btw)

Man the ending was so satisfactory...perfectly balanced and the time taken is worth it

This was the best ending I've ever experienced, Anakin's power, his sacrifice, truly amazing theory!

This was amazing and made me emotional. Better than movies and tv series we have been given lately. Thank you so much!!

That line about him being finally free was something that really tugs the heartstrings.

Best fan fiction ever. That would have played out way better. Anakin was a great Man, he had so much greatness in him, its not like he was stupid, he was just desperate.

"I don't like Palpatine, he's coarse, rough, and gets everywhere." *This wasn't my comment, just thought it was funny*

I cried in the end. It is such an emotional story the way you have written it. A story of a young slave boy not a slave to a master but a slave to himself. A masterpiece so to speak.

In 16:42 Epic scene😎Thats how to get rid of the biggest Villian.Great Video Star Wars Theory👍

Obi Wan: “He was the best star pilot in the galaxy…and a cunning warrior…and he was a good friend.” Anyways good video Master Theory! Keep it up! 😁🔥

... when Anakin fell into the flames I expected his destiny to continue as it actually did: wounded in flames, surviving via a (white?) suit, and living on with Padme afterwards in the Light Side of the Force.

This one made me tear up man, well done. This is probably one of the best fanfics you’ve ever done

Fantastic story. Simply amazing. My one edit. When Anakin has his "moment", rather than his eyes turn yellow than back to blue, the whites of his eyes turn black and the blue irises glow, like that of the Father on Mortis.

Dude I know you’ve said you possibly don’t think you’re qualified to be a creator at lucasfilm, but honestly theory, your stories are really good, your versions of Star Wars are very good, maybe you shouldn’t sell yourself short so quickly friend.

I can’t believe that I’ve had the privilege to grow up with this channel. I started watching this channel in September of 2017, and I’ve stuck with this channel ever since. I’m so thankful

This was pure art. Been captivated every second of it. Thank you for this masterpiece!

I feel like Anakin's story would definitely have been something like this had the Prequels not been.. well, the Prequels. When George Lucas wrote the Prequels, I think he wrote a new story based on the concept of Anakin, and not the actual backstory for Darth Vader. You could tell that the character he created with Anakin was a unique and separate person from Darth Vader in the Originals, and, although his story makes sense, and is cannon to Darth Vader's past, it feels like just another good Star Wars story that happens to fit into the time before the Original Trilogy.

7:46 "There is only one life left to take." Dude, that line is so Anakin.

Marvel has its “What If..?” And Star Wars has Star Wars Theory Fan Fictions which is goooooood

That was amazing. You reading the story. The thoughts. The actions. Now I understand why they say the book was better. No way a video could capture the final moments of the battle. It brought a tear to my eye. Thank you.

Cannot believe this is free to watch! This definitely belongs to my personal favourites. You are such a talented storyteller, I cannot even begin to imagine what Star Wars would have been like, had you been a part of the directing or producing the movies.

After all, even with this timeline, anakin brought balance to the force. Only he did it way better by balancing himself into the force. Great fan fic.

This was probably the best one you've ever done. The music, the words, the story, you've truly outdone yourself with this one. Couldnt help the tears as i listened, and wished this could have been how the movies went. Thank you Theory!

"im not good at writing endings" proceeds to write an ending that gives me goosebumps. incredible work.

WHY DID THIS VIDEO HAD SUCH AN EMOTIONAL ENDING!😭 LOVE IT

Theory dude, this is a masterpiece. The emotions I felt during this hit me right in the heart. I wish this was the actual ending so bad.

I love how he mentioned that you could use the dark side or use dark side abilities for good, kinda like a lighter version of Starkiller. That's what I would like to be in the SW universe

I really loved this one. This is the best "balance to the force" interpretationive ever heard of. I love it.

Pure genius, thanks for what you do. Your work is appreciated more than can be expressed.

When Anakin did the sacrifice (two red lightsabers into him) for Obi-wan, that HITs my heart HARD.

This fan fiction had me in tears, the story feels so real, like it would actually happen. On top with the nostalgic imagery of the 3rd Episode made it so much more enjoyable. I appreciate you!

This was awesome man! Thanks for finally making it. I really enjoyed the twist and ESPECIALLY the ending! Great job dude.

This is beautiful man! So emotional,touchy. It's perfect! Sad for Anakin but this is it. Again perfect! Thank so much for this :) The Force will be with you too

When you let Anakin speak to Sideous, I really heard his way of speaking. Respect for that.

I fucking love the change in your Anakin's voice from 4 years ago to now. It has such a sense of power while still maintaining Haden's voice, which is exactly how I always think of Anakin's (Haden's) voice in the movies. He doesn't need a fierce voice. His actions (always) speak for themselves... even at their worst.

This was SO GOOD. that up his sleeve line was just outstanding. 10 solid 10. You have a gift. :) thank you for sharing this!

Lost myself in that. Quality. What a story. Love how you unleashed the true power of the force as well

Padme: the bravest woman to stand against all four Sith

What if when Palpatine was trying to kill Mace Windu with force lightning, Anakin stuck his blade up to help Windu deflect it, Windu then chopped Anakin's other hand off and told Palpatine, 'You see Master, I told you he would not turn". Then Anakin realized the horrible truth, Mace Windu was Palpatine's true apprentice.

Man I appreciate how much you put your heart into this. Probably my favorite vid of yours

Kudos for opening yourself at the end about the struggle you have to conclude some of your work, I enjoyed this piece and wish your inspiration will continue to flow

This is the best ending you have ever written theory. It felt like the ending I always wanted for Anakin even after he became Vader.

I didnt expect to be tearing up watching a fan fiction story of star wars today. It's telling how well Anakin's character was developed in the films, and paired with your flawless marriage of fan fiction, it created a new story that was able to move me in a matter of minutes. Bavo!

Man I just found your channel after watching the one you did about if Anakin hadn't sat back down when mace told him to. This is soo good. Actually made me cry a bit when Anakin sacrificed himself. Keep doing these, you're amazing

I love it, it literally mimics the story of Revan in a way, but rather than the Jedi refusing to see and acknowledge what it was that Revan achieved and learn from it, Yoda and Kenobi, two of wisest Jedi to ever live embraced Anakins story. Nice job.

I’m really looking forward to Kenobi. Just to hear their pov of how everything happened. To see the rage of Vader and Obi Wans sadness for what was lost. This is going to be epic. I hope😊

Dude this is friggin amazing man , we need more of this . Keep up the great work !

This was well put together. Thank you for taking the time 🕙 to do this... The force is one now.

I don’t know why star wars is such a beautiful story to all of us. But this really is quite amazing. So well done.

“i have been waiting a ling time for this moment “ i havnt been only waiting but enjoying your content for 4 years aswell! keep it up theory

I don't usually comment, but this plot was especially good. I love bittersweet endings the most, and this really delivered.

This story was amazing! I honestly think you should keep doing these! Thank you so much

Jesus this was intense I could almost feel my heart beat

This is amazing! That ending blew me away! Disney NEEDS you as a writer for star wars. You sir, could bring star wars back to the beautiful story it once was.

That was incredible... this was the most beautiful story I have heard in a while. Great job. 5 stars

That was absolutely amazing and gave me chills the whole way through. I can't wait to see what else you come up with.

This was amazing finally you are finishing them, I am most excited to see the continuation of "What if Anakin turned Obi-Wan to the Dark Side"

Maaaan, this was a great fan fiction. I feel like you REALLY hit the mark on what would've gone down in Anakin's very soul with these choices. That really lended the story credibility. And with the ending, I felt the hole that the tragedy of Anakin Skywalker left in us. The Hero redeemed, in a truly genuine way. Thank you.

Brilliant. Almost teared up. This piece of story induced some very strong emotions in me. Congrats bro.

Legit cried while watching this .. great work theory 💯❤️

Ahhhhhh yes, back when Theory used actual Star Wars music in his vids. Also, it was cool to see the upgrade in quality halfway through the vid.

For me, Anakin was the most powerful force user when he tapped into both love and anger. I think that had Padmé been allowed to talk to him without Obi-Wan/Obi-Wan was not confrontational and she/they made him realize the manipulation of Sidious, he would have gone on an absolute rampage destrying everything and anyone who dared stand between him and his goal to kill Palpatine. Then he would either go away with Padmé or kill himself

“How can I learn this power?” “Not from a Jedi.” Palpatine was speaking the truth. Palpatine was a genius at creating win-win scenarios. He knew the Jedi did not possess such knowledge. If Jedi did have such knowledge, then they would have been using it, which they were not. Palpatine’s words to Anakin were the truth, but not for the reasons that Anakin believed.

This has got to be one of my favorite fan fictions of yours. Fantastic!

This was brilliant. I loved the duality of light and dark in Anakin and his sacrifice at the end. This story also defines WHY Anakin is “the chosen one.” Nicely done. Worth waiting four years.

Never doubt your talents. That was absolutely how it should have ended for Anakin.

This is absolutely the best fan fiction I’ve seen

Just have to say this was fun, loved the theory, thanks for taking the time and effort into putting this together, well thought out.

"I've become the very thing I've sworn to destroy" - This Anakin

Star Wars Theory, can you make such video: What if Yoda KILLED Darth Sidious in Revenge of the Sith?

Your sequence breaks my heart. And fortifies the depth of the possibilities with in so much lore.

Great work! Thank You.. may the force with You, always!