Who Organised The Holy Quran - Sayed Ammar Nakshawani 

Salamun elayqum. My name is Sajad Hossein, I am from India occupied Kashmir. I have a request to please upload some lecture on something good bid'ah and bad bid'ah. What does it actually mean ?

How is Qur'an NOT a history book?? It's full of historical events yet it's not a history book!!!

MR B it’s a book of signs and guidance that contains history, but it’s not a history book. A history book is devoted solely to history. There’s a big difference.

@@fjbazzi Agree my brother👍there is history in the Qur'an as well as guidance and wisdom.however the Quranic history is most accurate,more accurate than modern history as taught in schools.so we can use it as a source of history.god bless

For shia imam mahdi to come out is needed only 300 true believers.....and for the last 1300 years..there has been no true believers of that amount..oooowwww my shias brothers in humanity...wake up......

Can you explain this a bit more?

@@akhbari1752 may i?

mashallah

2nd or 3rd Khalifa..?

Yes and there are many proofs from the Holy Qur'an too to refute the ones who say that (Astaghfirullah)

It appears they tried to alter Quran. However Allah is the protector of the Quran.

No brother, the burned Qurans were the same wording as the ones we have today but the punctuations weren't accurate. So the made sure only the most accurate survived

It was the calliph before Hazrat Ali RA, the fourth calliph Uthman bin Affan RA who put the things in order. So all the punctuation and everything was put properly and the one which had nothing and were recited wrong due to the different dialect were all burnt.

@@zeeshanshaikh2133 no, it wasn’t Uthman, he had not that knowledge to fulfill such a task, it was Imam Ali a.s. by the order of Resulullah saas!

But he wasnt the last one? Hussain was a imam at one point. This makes no sense what you said.

@TNT-Spyral - you are right bro

Really don't remember the exact lecture... but the playlist is here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5wPDtQ1mR4I.html

This is untrue, surah al ikhlaas is shorter than that so why isn't it the last one?

Imaam Ali a s. Compiled Qur'an, handed over to Caliph, Abu bakkar, they too set up a committee, to collect revealed verses, this process continued, till 3rd Caliph, transcripted copies despatched to different inhabited muslim regions. Syria, Yemen, kufa... some remnants left burnt during 3rd Caliph. Imaam Ali a s. Compiled, handed over, quraan???. Five times a day Salah has not been mentioned in one Sura, chapter, in one verse. ???.

This is one clip. How about pardoning the individual before jumping to accusations. He has before but some people don't do it on every single mention. And by the way the Prophet ص Himself says Allahuma sali 3ala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad. Peace be upon Him and His Ahlul Bayt.. thats the way He told us to do it Sal Allahu Alaihi wa aalihi wa Salam

My brother there's no Muslim against what you mentioned about Ahlu Albayt, but your guy here forgot the Hadith of the prophet Muhammad salla Allah Alaihi wa sallam The stingiest is the one who hears my name and doesn't pray on me

When we pray on him what do we say?! We say: ALLAH who masalli 3alla Mohammad wa Aulhyi Mohammad. Who are we praising?? We are Praising The Prophet Mohammad PBUH. So you make nooo total sense.

Yes many sunnis are on the right path, also many shias on the right path. Having a sect doesn't save you, only following Quran and Sunnah does.

In every sect there are good ppl as well as bad bro but am stauch supporter of Sunnah.

Allah is the one who helps you

@@ayaanbhat5256 Exactly ALLAH helps everyone..bro

@@alsiratemustaqeem14 how will hazrat Ali rahmatullahiala help

@@alsiratemustaqeem14 he is indeed the slave of Allah

@@ayaanbhat5256 Ofcourse we can ask the divine Authorities appointed by God for help or intercession and make them intermediary between us and Allah (swt). Infact Allah (swt) himself commands in the Holy Qur'an to seek intermediary. *O you who believe! Fear Allah and seek the intermediary to Him and strive hard in His Way, perhaps you would be successful [**5:35**]* According to the exegesis of this verse the term intermediary refers to Ameer-ul-Mu'mineen Imam Ali Ibn Abi Taalib (pbuh). RasoolAllah (saws) and the Holy Imams (a) are the talking Qur'an. *(I Swear) by the star when it swoops down [53:1]* *Your companion does not err, and does not deviate [53:2]* *And he does not speak out of (personal) desire [53:3]* *Surely, it is only a Revelation He Revealed [53:4]* additionally, And stay in your houses and do not display your finery like the displaying of the Pre- Islamic period before; and establish the Salat and give the Zakat, and obey Allah and His Rasool. *But rather, Allah Intends to Keep the uncleanness away from you, People of the Household, and Purify you (with) a Purification [**33:33**]* Ayat e tatheer justifies to the infallibility of the Holy Prophet (saws) and the Holy Ahlulbayt (asws). so this means they do not lie nor do they misguide. so it's obligatory upon us to obey their commands and submit to thier will. *O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the Rasool and those with (Divine) Authority from you. Thus, if you were to quarrel about anything, refer it to Allah and the Rasool if you were believing in Allah and the Last Day, that would be better and of excellent interpretation [**4:59**]* [so it's obligatory upon us to obey their commands and submit to thier will] The Holy Prophet (saws) and the Holy Ahlulbayt (a) don't desire except for what Allah (عزّ وجلّ) desires. *And you are not desiring except if Allah so Desires. Surely Allah was always Knowing, Wise [76:30]* Sa’d Bin Abdullah, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad Al-Sayyari, from someone else from our companions, who has said: ‘Abu Al-Hassan (asws) The Third, having said: ‘Surely, Allah (عزّ وجلّ) has Made the hearts of the Imams (asws) as resources of His Will, and when He (عزّ وجلّ) Desires something, they (asws) do so (as well), and these are the Words of the Exalted: *And you are not desiring except if Allah so Desires [76:30]’* On another note, there are alot literally alot of verses in the Holy Qur'an which refers to none other than the Holy Ahlulbayt (asws) and which praised them. As proven above, The Holy Ahlulbayt (asws) are infallibles so they do not lie nor do they misguide (Nauzubillah). So if the Imams (a) said so and so verse refers to us so we have to accept the sayings of the Imams (asws). Also, we cannot interpret the Holy Qur'an by our personal desires. Just as Allah (عزّ وجلّ) said, He is the One Who Revealed the Book unto you; from it are Decisive Verses - these are the Mother of the Book; and others are Allegorical. Then as for those in whose hearts there is perversity, so they are following what is allegorical from it, seeking the Fitna and seeking its (personal) interpretation. *And none knows its interpretation except Allah, and those who are firmly rooted in the Knowledge.* They are saying, ‘We believe in it. It is all from the Presence of our Lord’. And none (would) mention except those with the understanding [3:7] Here "those who are firmly rooted in the knowledge" refers to none other than the Holy Ahlulbayt (asws). The Holy Ahlulbayt (asws) inherited the Holy Prophet (saws) in knowledge. So eventually we have to revert to the Holy Ahlulbayt (asws) for the interpretation of the Holy Qur'an and for its exegesis. And the 14 Infallibles (pbut) has a special status near Allah (swt). Allah (swt) does not deny granting if they ask. And the Holy Qur'an justifies to this too. The people at the time of Prophet Musa (a) themselves asked Musa (a) to ask in their behalf. And when you said: ‘O Musa! We can never be patient upon one food, *therefore supplicate for us to your Lord to bring forth for us out of what the earth grows, of its herbs, and its cucumbers, and its garlic, and its lentils, and its onions’.* He said: ‘Will you be replacing by that which is worse, for that which is better? Go down to a city, so there would be for you what you are asking for!’ And there was struck upon them, the disgrace, and the destitution, and epidemic, being a Wrath from Allah. That was due to their disbelieving in the Signs of Allah, and their killing the Prophets without the right. That was due to their disobeying, and theybwere transgressing [2:61] The Holy Qur'an itself justifies to this concept. you need to realize one thing i.e according to the hadeeth, obedience to the Imams (a) is obedience to RasoolAllah (saws) and obedience to RasoolAllah (saws) is obedience to Allah (عزّ وجلّ) and vice versa. similarly if we ask for help from RasoolAllah (saws) or the Imams (a), we are technically asking help from Allah (عزّ وجلّ). How? Just as Allah (عزّ وجلّ) says in the Holy Qur'an, *Say: ‘The Angel of death who is Allocated to you shall cause you to die, then to your Lord you will be returning’ [**32:11**]* Here Allah (عزّ وجلّ) says angel of death causes us to die/gives death. Then Allah (عزّ وجلّ) also says, *Have you not considered him (Nimrod) who disputed with Ibrahim regarding his Lord, because Allah had Given him the kingdom? So Ibrahim said: ‘My Lord is He Who Causes to live and Causes to die’. He said: ‘I cause to live and I cause to die’. Ibrahim said: ‘So surely, Allah Brings the sun from the east, so bring it from the west’. Thus, he who committed Kufr was confounded; and Allah does not Guide the unjust people [2:258]* *and Allah Causes to live and die and Allah Sees what you are doing [3:156]* So this isn't contradiction (Nauzubillah). But Allah refers thier acts as his own acts. Similarly in shia books there are Narrations that angels are the ones who rotate the planets, burst the clouds, start the rainfall etc etc. But Allah (عزّ وجلّ) says in the Holy Qur'an that he is the one who does these things. There is a lengthy conversation of a non-believer with Imam Ali (a) where the non-believer came to the Imam (a) and said, I would have embraced your religion but I found many inconsistencies and contradictions in Quran. (Astagfirullah) Then Imam (a) explicitly elucidated him many things in detail. So what i mentioned above was one from them. Allah (عزّ وجلّ) is so elevated that it is inappropriate for him to perform these tasks and work for himself. That's the reason he has appointed his servants who perform these tasks and work on his behalf. And Allah (عزّ وجلّ) refers their acts as his acts. So in conclusion, even if we ask help from Rasool-Allah (saws) or the Holy Imams (a), principally we are asking for help form Allah (عزّ وجلّ). Just as i explained obedience to the Holy Imams (a) is obedience to RasoolAllah (saws) and obedience to RasoolAllah (saws) is obedience to Allah (عزّ وجلّ). Similar is with disobedience. Also I'd like to mention another verse i just remembere *So you did not kill them but Allah Killed them, and you did not throw when you threw, but Allah Threw, and to Try the Momineen from it with a good trial. Surely Allah is Hearing, Knowing [**8:17**]* I couldn't find the exegesis right now, but i had read the exegesis in which Imam Muhammmad Al Baaqir (asws) said, Allah (عزّ وجلّ) referd the act of RasoolAllah (saws) as his act.

Whats that supposed to mean?

@@mahdiali872 it means his arguments are very slippery and he’s desperately trying distort reality and facts to fit not only with Ithna Ashari narrative but also his personal agenda.

​@@peskysmurf7414are you talking politically? Because of course the Quran supports Islam thats what it is for. But politics is a whole nother story. I prefer to listen to Sayyid Ammars educational and historical lectures and i love him for that

@@mahdiali872 I’m talking in all dimensions. His religious ones are also tough sells, always trying to diminish the status of the Sahaba. If you are a Shia, Naqshawani’s echo chamber might suit you. But he is full of hatred for Sunnis and the Sahaba. Listen to a more serene human, such as Hakim Abd al Murad. Naqshwani is always more interested to talk about Shi’ism and its differences with the Jama’ah (Sunnism) rather than advocate Islam in its breadth and unity.

@@peskysmurf7414 It sounds to me like you're taking Sayed Ammar's speeches personally. I've watched several of his videos and no where does he bash Sunnis or the Sahaba. He explains the Shia position on various topics which naturally is going to be at odds with the Sunni opinion. I agree that speakers should advocate for unity within the Ummah but there should also be a space for understanding each other's differences particularly as misconceptions about Shias are common amongst Sunnis and aggravated by Wahabbi/Salafi speakers.

Why don't you go and learn the history. I mean really read the history independently and don't listen to your Sunni mufti sand molvis. You will be shocked. I have been a Sunni all my life I'm over 50 years age and I am now Shia because I learnt for myself. I recommend a book named "when power and piety collide" and the author uses only Sunni sources. Its a basic start.

@@supersurfer1 hahaha my friend...uve been made like parrots to believe that we dont read history...by the way....i become a shia for almost five years as well.......there is nothing u can tell me about shias that i dont know....they are the worst of creatures existing at the moment.....if u have a bit of brain left..how come the very close friends of rasul be cursed by the acursed people rafidhwas????quraan says...u will will onow a persons attitude by the friends he hangs out with....so if the sahabas were bad..then rasul is worst as well according to the quraan....and Allah says..a bad wife for a bad husband and a bad husband for a bad wife....so if mama aysha was bad the rasul is worse accoding to the quraan...u shias are nothing but a worst curse ever existed.......

@@supersurfer1 every sunni source that shia uses...is either fabricated or miss interpreted....my brother....im your age as well..and i become a shia at my early 40s...then i got real leaned people from sunni and we have been having debates using only dalili no mouth words only dalil...and all the shia ayatollahs that i knew from iran iraq and east africa all of them ended insulting and cursing us after being exposed using lies and baricating and miss interprate our hadiths and the holy quraan.....shias are nothing but a curse.......

@@j_gh812 not all shias. I am a shia I dont curse anyone ffs

@@lestahass8849 can u tell us what shia sect are u that u claim u dont curse sahabas???unless u are using taqiya or u are shia zaidia....so what shia are u????lets hear it...

Why do you say this?

Al hujjat, search and know what are you accusing at.. As you are accountable for each and every word you have said!!!!

What Imam Ali AS said: "silence is the best reply to a fool" like you

@@ZainabHJZ · What I said is fairly well, it is a group that creates fascination inside the Shi'ite and is misleading Shia throughout the world.

@@ibrahimsulaiman9047 · Because this group creates fascination inside the Shia