WHY did A7X Do This to Us?!  

That is a beautiful interpretation of this song. For me personally, I kind of took it as similar to “higher” on The stage. Escaping this dark meaningless life, shadows and darkness and sadness and anger just shedding away from me and just being free traveling and exploring and flying through the beauty of space and time and being free and full of Joy and full of life and love and happiness and seeing the beauty of life and nature and space. Just free. Free of all pain. Sadness. Anger. Hopelessness. The first 2 thirds of the song I feel are the trying to find an escape and “building the rocket ship” to escape it all. “Rocket ship” being metaphorical since the song is cosmic and feels spacey and all of that. But the rocket could be anything from a literal rocket, to putting on headphones, to purchasing a ticket to go on a boat adventure, to driving to a mountain to climb it. Then When it gets to the beginning of the piano part, I feel like I am leaving. Not quite “free” yet, but hopeful, everything is ready. I’m taking off. Leaving atmosphere. Then when it gets to the really quiet part that sounds like spacey electronics, I feel I have broken out of this atmosphere. The things I’m escaping are shed from me and life is before me ready to be grasped, explored, seen, lived and loved. Then it explodes as I travel through space and time completely free and happy. Then the last few seconds are me returning back home to my life. Sitting down in my chair. Just smiling. Refreshed. A new perspective. A new fresh joy. A new fresh hope in the world. A new happiness. Filled with love from the journey I’m home from.

Its okay to cry we all did. This song makes us feel human in the messed up times we are in.

"I am so proud that this is my favourite band" YES BRO. Thats EXACTLY the feeling this album gave me too, like I got the deathbat tattoo at like 17 yrs old when self titled dropped and ive never felt more vindicated they're just above and beyond every single time

This song makes me cry. The solo, the reprise, is really a cosmic experience. FUCKING MASTERPIECE

im so glad you said "im so proud this is my favorite band", i feel the same way man! i fricken love it dude lets goo

Best song on the album. Any era of A7X fan will appreciate this masterpiece of a song!

Yes!!! The "I'm gone" hits me really hard, I was crying my first play through and I didn't even understabd why. Just an overwhelming feeling, A7X killed it with the album and this song will go down as one of their absolute bests

This song is a real masterpiece!!! This song should be learn on music classes in college

Never had a song bring me to tears the way this one does. I feel like I’m saying goodbye to all of my friends and family that have passed away when I hear this.

My girlfriend has a terminal illness and is unresponsive. This song is beyond deep and personal to me as I'm sure it is to many of you . Makes me tear up every time. It also gives me a sense of comfort with the idea that there is more life after death. Our energy doesn't die, our souls don't die. They just move on and become something else more beautiful. Our loved ones are always with us even when they are gone and we will meet them again. ❤

Im not gonna lie i was waiting for this album and the day it came out i got unreasonably stoned and got to this song and nearly had a panic attack because i couldnt figure out what kind of emotions i was going through during the different sections of the song. It had me feeling feelings i havent felt in years. I love A7X and this just further cements it for me

people be complaining about the vocoder section when it really adds so much to the aesthetic and overall narrative of the song. imo it potrays the protagonist becoming energy once again, transcending his physical form (after death), so having the vocals sound in an ethereal manner is more than fit for it likely the best, or at least most heartfelt, rock ballad a7x has ever done. and easily one of the best ones in modern rock. even better than Roman Sky imo (which this kinda feels like its sucessor, so to say)

dude this album is quite literally changing my life. I'm feeling more inspired, I'm writing more lyrics, having more intelligent conversations about the different themes. Cosmic makes me cry every time because it is that beautiful. As dark as this album can be at times it is as equally full of life, and it shines through 100%

“ Im so proud this is my favourite band” spot on

Loved your interpretation, s tier a7x song, if not the best. When i first heard it, after the solo, i was on the verge of crying my eyes out for the rest of the song, not knowing why. The atmosphere that produces this piece hits a spot in my brain that makes me very emotional, and i am sure that for a lot of people too. The need to cry for something that i cant quite grasp. Thanks for your video. Subbed.

G goes hard and Game Over but my favorite is life is but a dream

Im so glad there are people out there that enjoy and appreciate this album. I really want other bands to expand their horizons but are probably scared of the backlash. Lets support Genre bending albums

That chord woth the brass that hits at the end of each phrase legit makes me emotional everytime.

I LOVE THIS ALBUM. A lot of people may think otherwise, but I guarantee, if you love music, if you have a creative side, you will vibe to this like no other album. These guys are smart, these guys know what they are doing. They could honestly care less about if people hate them or love them. They want to express their love for the music. When I first heard Waking the Fallen, I 100% knew that they were eventually going to grow out of metal and into their own genre. You already could hear melodies, piano, classical guitar, just art in that album. This album really showed their growth and maturity and showed a big F U to labels and genres. Their genre is Avenged Sevenfold.

brooooo i had tears , was so beautiful … Rev was in my mind in the ‘there you’ll find me’ part and that solo whoah so insane

What a great interpretation of this song! So eloquently put!

This song broke me and put me back together. I’ve never had a song do that to me. I lost my uncle last year to health problems and my friend to suicide this year, I haven’t been able to move on but this song helps me with providing me closure that they’re safe where they’re at. Thank you Avenged Sevenfold… You will always be my favorite band

Had to stop this video because your explanation of your interpretation of the lyrics and orchestration brought me to tears. You're managed to put to words what I felt about the song but wasn't able to explain and phrase. A big thanks to you for that! ❤

I cried the first time I heard this. They are amazing and always will be.

The song that made me cry again after so far away

Fantastic reaction my friend, and all the commentary at the end was spot on. I heard this song for the first time with my wife and it hit us super hard, we both cried. Especially cause I'm currently at the hospital with a very serious condition, so this song in a way gave us hope that even if I don't make it, we'll reunite later. What a beautiful masterpiece of a song.

I don't remember the last time a song made me cry. Maybe when I was 5. This song produces tears everytime. It's pure love vibration. A7X has truly truly captured something special with this song... it's just an absolute masterpiece in every way.

These guys have been my favorite band since I was 10 (22 now). I cried my fucking eyes out when Cosmic played. You put out the video I would have made. These guys are a big reason I decided to pursue music as a career. So happy to share this love of music, and of their music with people like you.

I recently went through a drawn out, intense breakup with a romantic partner of 3 years. We both pulled away from each-other slowly as things got worse financially, mentally, etc. - When I heard Cosmic the first time, it was in the midst of that. I felt myself holding back tears & then started uncontrollably sobbing. At that moment I felt I could understand that we were both on the same universe, understand each others desires, have passionate love, but in a completely different realm. The ‘acceptance’ stage began and l started mentally unpacking. In an interview from a couple months ago, Matt explains how a-lot of the lyrics were inspired by a trip and a conversation with his longtime partner. Hard to put into an exact perspective; but the meaning narrows down to loving somebody so much, unconditionally, and having a deep understanding within the universe (and that person) that no matter what could have went differently in your lives, what places you were in, what jobs you worked at, or even where you lived; that the world would somehow always find a way to bring your energies together again - Because it’s meant to be, and I believe Matt is tapped into that frequency as a songwriter. Hence (“We loved so many times, and in so many lives, sometimes we got it right”) The energy in this is beyond words. The song is about love. Infinite love that repeats until the end of time. “Before the dawn of man, castles made of sand” - There you’ll find ME. This can also be applied for self love as well. We all could use more of that. Thanks for the video and amazing perspective. It’s people like you that push me to continue musically.

BAHAHA “that kicked my ass!” Same man 😂

after the solo it kinda made me feel like when i first watched INTERSTELLAR .... took me for a ride .

I LOVE the final lines of the song. It ends abruptly with the "Into that good..." lyric. The song that plays after this is "Beautiful Morning", so perhaps the song names finish that lyric? "I'm gone, into that good, beautiful morning."

I listened to this as they were uploading the visualizers on youtube. headphones in, complete darkness in the room with eyes closed and this is one of the very very few songs ive heard in my 30 years if life that brought me to tears as a musician. The bass blasts in the ending that matched up with Brooks' drumming and the atmospheric presence is what pulled the tears from me

I'm so relieved to know I'm not the only one who legit got emotional and almost cried in this song. This album is a fkn MASTERPIECE.

This is the exist / save me / little piece of heaven / strength of the world / i wont see you tonight of this album. One of my favorite songs ever, as are all of these

dude this song made me cry

Gives me goose bumps every listen still (and I've listened like 50 times)

The thumbnail to this video gave me goosebumps. Brooks Wackerman is the only one wearing black in the photo while the others wore plain white tees. RIP Jimmy ❤

I absolutely love this breakdown. You stole the words from my mind and I simply can’t believe we have been gifted with such an incredible, beautiful, euphoric and heart wrenching piece of art. The fact that we have been gifted with this life by pure chance at the time of the release of this song is immense. I love hearing other fans opinions interpretations of my favourite artists music and I can truly say that yours was SPOT on. From super fan to super fan, from artist to artist. Thank you 🙏 🫡 (This song has me in tears every time I listen to it) Lol

same as you, I'M PROUD TO BE A DIEHARD FAN OF AVENGED SEVENFOLD!

I thought this song was okay on my first listen. I thought it was one of the standout songs on the album, but only have it a C originally. After marinating in this song for 2 days, I think it's the most beautiful piece a7x has written. I've even teared up listening to it a couple times. Once you push through the strange textures and how different it is, it's a fantastic song.

That two minute outro is absolutely stunning ESPECIALLY the drums

I know i already commented on this upload but I had to come back and say this: Almost a year went by, and I've seen lots of reactions to this song, on youtube, reddit or even just with friends in general. No one comes even close to describing or understanding this song as well as you did back in june. I know music is different for everyone, and of course all ideas and perspectives are welcomed and valued. But your take on this is really my favorite, to this day. Respect Don 🤘🏼

Love your reaction ❤ Been a fan of A7X since day 1! Never sieze to amaze me. See you in Chula Vista Oct 7th!!!! Love you guys w everything ❤

Such an incredible incredible song. A7X has always showcased some amazing musicianship through their catalog but nothing has hit quite this hard before. The beautifully simple vocal melodies on top of the controlled chaos of the instrumentals take you on a musical journey all by themselves then add the lyrics and you have one absolute masterpiece of an emotional ride. Well done A7X!

Beautiful interpretation of the song. Hearing you mention the loved ones you've lost and the fear of leaving your loved ones behind got to me. Cheers man, gained a sub.

"I am so proud that this is my favorite band" - that had me in tears

I get choked up listening to this song everytime 😢 Just beautiful

I can say after only a single listen that this album is a masterpiece! So many influences that I can't name them all.

Dude! After watch every reactor react to this album, finally i found u who really understand the value of this album! I listening to a7x from 2012, and ur reaction to every a7x song is really same with mine. We easy to like new sevenfold songs cause we're listening to every their song, other fan say's this album is weird but, for me not, this is not first time the bang made this genre, was their made song called "Lost", and look familiar with this

This should have been played live from the first day of this tour. Was so bummed it wasn't when I saw them last week. For this is the crown jewel of the album, this song is such a journey!!!!

It's just so awesome that this video just showed up to me today, and I felt so represented by your reaction because it was really similar to how I reacted and felt back then. But even more amazing is the fact that I still feel this song deep and it gives me more meaning(s) each time I listen to it. The details... It's art I think the AI theme is also pretty relevant, specially if we consider what has been in discussion since the stage album. Makes us really think deep about everything that's going on

All cry with this song

i like the genus explanation of this song. its a person telling their live, friends, important person whoever, that though theyre dying, that it will not be the last goodbye, they’ll see each other again in another life, they’ll find each other again, open and shut yet another door in time.

My favorite band as well. Proud of this guys! What a refreshing album!

Syn Gates is the master of bending. I don't hear other great guitarists who bends as much as him. I really like the style.

Can’t wait to see this live in August!

I absolutely love the creativity in this album

Syn solo is make me cry, this solo is singing🤘🤘🤘🔥🔥🔥🥺🥺🥺

Gonna be epic like "Stairway to Heaven" or "Bohemian Rhapsody" or "Fade to Black"

Hey don. I found your channel when you reacted to we love you. Over the past 2 days I’ve listened to this album like 20 times. It makes me feel so much. A lot of sadness and I always cry on (D)eath. Having a long history with alot of mental health this album has alot of my personal thoughts in it. I’ve come to the point where if this is they last thing they ever put out I will be truly happy with every album we’ve gotten over the years. They all have a special place in my heart. I’m glad you like the album.

This song is the essence of audible beauty. Beyond being pure sound euphoria the lyrics bring you through all those emotions like a guide. I don't think a song has ever made me feel as emotional as this. In my opinion this will go down as top 3 avenged songs of all time. I want this played at my funeral

Great Reaction man! Enjoyed listening to it with you

Dude this video interpretation made me cry, haha. I love it dude

This was the best explanation of this album and understanding of the concept of it I've seem. Well done video man. I like that you had an initial reaction and then after 2 days of listening really gave your thoughts, it's so true, I've never had an album or songs grow on me to the extent this album did.

Don... you hit it on the head with this review quite honestly.... I appreciated you explaining your interpretation of existentialism it really helped me understanding and connecting with the song. Before seeing your review here I'd listened to Cosmic more than 10 times and it made me feel things, things I didn't understand, like I felt sadness but I don't know why and the sadder I felt the more I wanted to listen. Also the second part of the song here reminds me of M83 - Outro performed live with those drums and effects etc... I love the new album, glad to have found you on here and will certainly be checking out your other videos... thank you and love from the UK

To me, cosmic is about letting go of my comfort zone and old life. The syn solo describes the difficulty and metamorphosis I’m currently going through. Once the calming parts come, I’ve reached the end of my change! I’m in love w this song and always will bez

This is my second favourite song on the album, my favourite is (O)rdinary... it just makes my ears happy lol but i love the journey this song takes me on, its gives me a feeling of somewhat melancholic nostalgia with images of travelling through space in search of someone, which somehow feels like its yourself you're looking for. Although, i do wish i had experienced the song the same way you did

i love cosmic very much.. this is best Music in the album

This song has helped me with self improvement & relationship issues. A7X has given me the best life soundtrack ever. I love seeing them grow as a band

I have to say it because no one is saying it, this is the most Dream Theater sounding Ax7 tune I have heard in a long time. When those pianos come in, Scenes From A Memory. Love it

This is the first video of yours that I've ever, mad respect dude. You articulate your feelings very well.

6:40 i feel the same 🙏🏻🖤 foREVer 🖤

Avenged sevenfold is my absolute favorite band and when this album came out I was ecstatic. My interpretation of this song has been all over the place, from M. Shadows trying to display the Egg theory and the unity of humanity as one, to someone on a trip. But I think I finally figured out what I WANT this song to mean In section one, the protagonist is going through an existential crisis. He is battling the fact that he will perish to fate and leave whoever he is talking to in the beginning, but promises he will “follow” them “beyond forever” this is when the solo kicks up, and this marks beginning of this intense spiritual journey for this character After the solo, the protagonist comes to terms with reality, and almost unites with it, promising this person that he will always be there whenever wherever. Citing different unrelated things like “roses”, “castles made of sand” “Pharos clothes” to emphasize that he is there through it all, almost being one with space and time. When the music cuts out, the electro/synth we hear building up to that last drop is the heartmontior in the hospital for this individual, as he ascends to the afterlife in his final moments, becoming one with the universe, keeping his promise to always be anywhere and everywhere following. The “I’m gone” are his final words to this person as he passes away, and when the vocals cut out, he has taken his last breath, forever floating in the cosmos as a cosmic entity

YES. I heard a few tracks and thought - "They've either completely lost it or have achieved true musical ascension" I listened to it a few more times though, and came to the conclusion that this is a masterpiece. It WILL go down in history.

Great review ❤ you literally explained everything so perfectly about the flow of the song.

You've interpreted very clearly and accurately on this beautiful song. ❤️

This is something absolutely special. Either it or Ordinary are my favorites from this album, not fully decided... gives me similar vibes to Higher, though even this doesn't top how that song makes me feel when I'm brave enough to listen to it. Was expecting it more toward the end of the album, feels like it could have switched places with Beautiful Morning at least but it works. I'll bite my tongue on going deeper otherwise; Most are here to listen to good music which is great... few realize what it's truly like to hear something like this lyrics included, when you have an awareness or "memories" you're probably not supposed to. Thank you Avenged Sevenfold for existing and sharing your creations during my stay on this Earth.

I love this song

After losing a dear friend recently this song just hit harder than ever 🤍 I hope they play it this Friday at the concert.

Every time Syn plays, I feel it. I got chills on this. Everything about this song is amazing. I lost someone I consider my soulmate this past year and this encompasses what I feel for seeing him again. This whole album describes so many feelings I’ve felt since his passing and more of my philosophy on life in general. I’m so glad you mentioned music being art and respecting said art. I’ve heard so many people trashing this band and this album because it’s not their preferred listen or what they think the band is. It upsets me. They’re evolving as a band and as people and it’s reflected in their music. I am here for it. Great reaction!

cosmic is just beyond this world its like a bridge between here and afterdeath , its beautiful man always hits me hard , idk how they did it but every single time i play this song its a whole journey all past years to present and the day i'll be gone , just wow man .

Hands down the best song on the album. Beautiful Morning is also fucking awesome.

Such a beautiful song!

This is my favorite song off the album. I've listened to it maybe a hundred times. I love the whole album, but this song is just perfect since my dad had just passed away. I am on board with you and am proud to call Avenged Sevenfold my favorite band❤️ foREVer

Thankyou for this reaction Anthony Vincent🤟

Hey i really like and appreciated your reaction man! Since you didn't monetize your video, I'm gonna say you're one of the best if not the best reaction out there! Keep your goodwork can't wait for death or ordinary reaction, love you man!

The transition into transcendence was just grade A, top-notch, master quality. Avenged Sevenfold saved 2023

Best band of all time 🤘🏼☠️

The song is a beautiful musical odyssey, on my first listen I teared up without knowing why, but the music took me on a journey. When the drums and trumpet started I felt like my body was rising, as the electronic music and vocals hit I was disintegrating, I felt lost, hope, love. By the time I heard "I am gone" I just broke into tears. Thanks A7X for this masterpiece and great review! Keep it up!

i play this song while reading berserk, it fit perfectly

Brother… you absolutely nailed this. Beautiful video ❤ much love!

This song, so many feelings in one. Easily one top 3 in their career in my mind. Nods to so much of their old stuff and all the spacy vibes. 10/10 song

The transition after the solo is arguably the best transition I've ever heard in a song of theirs, maybe of any band lol.

Broooo this is a fucking jammmmmmm im so proud that this is my favorite band also bro, they open my mind to the rock world with bat country nd beast and harlot ❤❤❤

This song is a masterpiece. That solo brought me to tears

I've listened to this song at least 100 times now and it still gets me.. Masterpiece isn't enough to describe. It's on its own level.

This song is masterfookinclass dude...❤

I have interpreted very similar to you. The repeated, there you'll find me is the loved ones lost reassuring to us the listener of where we can find them. I instantly connected that because my grandmother loved Roses. Her mother grew them for competitions and she always talked about them. the dancing in the wind as roses born again really hits me every time because of that close connection. Excellent reaction!

It was nice to meet you at the avenged show yesterday. This is tony. Great show!!!