I honestly didn't know who she was until I saw she was getting bullied for nothing. I've seen way too many idols and trainees lose their lives over crap like that, so I wanted to support her (couldn't vote since my phone is too old for the app version). Everyone was so quick to hate her but not the actual established idols on the show; no one deserves to be hated, especially for being born.
Let's be honest, a lot of the contestants on gp999 had an unfair advantage, not just Bahiyyih. Yujin was in CLC; Jiwon, Bora, and May are in Cherry Bullet; Yeseo was a well known child actress and former Buster's member; Doah, Chiayi, and Rayeon are in Fanatics; Chaehyun was a well known former SM trainee and Mashiro a former JYP trainee, that in itself is a feat since a lot of people are always curious to know what potential trainees might debut from the big3; and a lot of the chinese trainees were in previous survival shows such as Youth With You, etc, they were not unknown in their home country. These are just a few of many examples. So why the fuck only pick on her? Why single her out of many of the contestants? If people are going to point out unfair disadvantages, be fair yourself and apply it to all of those who had even a bit of a bonus above the other trainees. Otherwise, sit down and be quiet, support Kep1er if you want or don't. But stop with the ridiculous hate against Bahiyyih. She does not deserve it and no matter what anyone says, she's going to thrive and improve as an idol.
Personally I only agree for yujin and bahiyyih for having a spot already the others weren't that known in my opinion yeseo wasn't well known and I hadn't found out abt her acting career only after she debuted chaehyun was an SM trainee but no one rlly knew her that much to consider her "well known" also for mashiro no one noticed her due to Itzy members in the old video🙁
So basically they hate her because life isn’t fair and she happened to be from a celebrity family. (Not just her brother is famous). I find it so funny because it’s not a crime 😂 The Jenners became famous after Kim Kardashian got famous. Dixie got famous after Charlie Demalio. Why are K-pop fans so obsessed with the underdog agenda. She has to show herself crying and throwing up in the practice room for haters to say she deserves to debut. Lmao
I agree it's not a crime. It just so happened that at the beginning she was introduced as Kai's sister. Instantly people will be curious. I guess the show wants clout from her brother for higher ratings. The situation from the start is actually half positive and half negative. Even she has less screen time people already remember her name. It was a good exposure. But then she is in a competition. It is a survival show. There would be lots of people who will compare her to the other participants. And as you can see there are a lot of talented girls in the show but lacks publicity. In short some people will really find it unfair. Let's say you are applying for a certain job in a company. There are many applicants beside you.Then suddenly the interviewer ask you if you are somehow related to their co-worker. Do you think the other applicants will be happy to hear that? They will absolutely loathe you from the start. The hate will also be more intense when you actually got the job. Also those celebrities that you gave as an example has a different situation with Bahiyyih and Kai. I don't blame them for being siblings. I blame the show for highlighting her in the beginning as a sister of an idol and not focusing on what she is capable of to prove that she is worthy of competing in the show.
@@crisuigakumi4556 thissss. If there is anyone to blame, it would ultimately be the show not the contestants. The show asked her about her relatives. The show highlighted her connections. The show chose a voting system that is heavily influenced on popularity. Its the show that made those decisions. These are the results. Same thing In the company example. Its the company that prioritized the connections not the applicant. You cant even fault the applicant for telling the truth to the company's question. They asked them a question and you cant expect them to lie about it. Its the truth that you cant change. If the company then solely hires the applicant because of the connection, then the company is messed up. The other applicant's frustration should be towards the unjust company and it's priorities. Not the applicant. Both want a job at the end of the day.
This is super well edited! Thanks for this video. I personally think that everyone who passed the GP999 auditions, unlike in their older sister series Produce, were already good enough to debut. I feel like one of the few who would've been happy if any of the top18 debuted because I genuinely loved every contestant who made it at that point! I remember seeing so many comments such as "why can't they make two groups so everyone can debut?" "All of the top18 is so talented!" And then Bahiyyih debuted and people lost their minds with rage. People got beef with a 17 year old, and it's weird asf 😒
Bahiyyih just passed 1 Billion views on TikTok. Wadada MV has 66 M views and 3 awards. Her Wadada Fancam got 100 k views in 2 hours, fastest individual GG debut fancam in the history of Kpop, now it has 2.1 M views. 20 of her video clips and fancams have more than 1 M views, 30 have over 600 k views. She's been nominated for TC Candler 100 list of most beautiful faces in the World. She is number 1 in 115 countries. Her Fiesta Fancam has 3.5 M views. She's only 17 years old and is 2nd place among 16,000 participants. Verdict: his brother is innocent of all this, he never went to 115 countries to order them to vote for his sister as their number 1 and buy 150 k albums in one day or to view all her TikTok clips day and night until she's got 1 Billion views
I know right people are just bitter for no reason...😂😂😂 Hiyyih is only starting I can't wait for her to end her Kep1er activities and actually debut in a long lasting girl group with 1st or any other good company...I am looking forward to all her amazing achievement in the future oh and I will fully give her all my support ❤️❤️
@phantom thief alibaba Well her brother is kinda bad at promoting her... so I don't really think that's the case... She may have gotten a push, but it's not the only reason she is famous.
Bahiyyih is fking gorgeous! She, in one go occupied my gallery without even giving it a second thought. I just saw pretty pictures of her and saved it. That's it
I also don't find her aesthetically pleasing and saw her getting nonstop hate. I came here to find out why she gets so much to find out there's no valid reason at all. You can dislike someone but bro why send hate like that
I knew bahiyyih for almost two years now?? She was active on tiktok, insta and even was once chosen as a presenter at mama 2021 or 2020. Ofc I knew her because I'm a moa myself but I didn't follow the show, didn't I vote nor did I see moas hyping others to vote for her on my tl, moa were just excited to to see her shine and get the recognition she deserves.
I dont hate her, I just feel like there are more talented trainees than her. But since survival shows depend on votes than actual talent and overall performance in missions, she won the show legally.
I’m crying right now. “She won legally” ain’t that the truth lol. And it seems like newer KPOP fans only enjoy the “visual” aspect and not the actual vocal talent. I won’t knock her dancing ability because girl can move but her singing…ehhh
Yes, but the fans that goes overboard in showing their hate towards her is what's unacceptable. Imagine being ignored in front of hundreds of fans, and treat you like air, even though she was also a part of the group. No hate towards you, but I find it suitable to comment about this situation here
i found out about her through her relation to kai, yes, but i actually grew to like her through her introduction video and little videos of her pre gp999. i find it so stupid ppl hate on her pretty much for being a sister and having things she needs to work on just like anyone else. no one is saying that she’s perfect or the best performer out there, but ppl, like myself, like her and are tired of seeing ppl hate on a 17 y/o constantly for stupid reasons
I knew about Bahiyyih from seeing random videos about... why people hate her xD Then I realised she was on Kep1er and started paying more attention to her performance. I don't hate her, although I don't really enjoy her presence on videos and stage? I don't feel any... charisma? But that is personal opinion, I don't see anything wrong with her, I guess her stage presence just doesn't attract me (also, having like 3 seconds per song doesn't necessarily help lol)
Same I got a random video of her where she doesn't get any gifts so I just searched why people hate her and ended up I don't even know brother lol not even the group she is in
@@LauraMalfoy2011 at least you can see how unfair they are to her when it comes to line distribution..How does one improve when they barely get to sing ? Appreciate your comment ❤️
@@nancy4241 They're also probably not giving the girls vocal lessons at all, come to think of it. Sakura revealed that she got vocal lessons for the first time in her career (Izone and AKB48) at Source Music, and Wakeone managed Izone too. So any improvements the girls make over the next two years are probably going to come from their work in Kep1er and not much training with Wakeone. It sucks because Bahiyyih, Mashiro, and Xiaoting have great vocal potential already that just needs a bit of polishing! Recently, a fan channel shared a clip of Bahiyyih belting a G#5, and while high notes aren't everything, the fact fact that the capability to do so is within her range already... It's frustrating how we'll probably never get to see her harness that potential if Wakeone continues on the path that they're on with Kep1er.
@@goldyd144 Luckily for us, Hiyyih is signed to 1st entertainment as a trainee so when she goes back she will definitely prepare to debut with her own group just like Wonyoung and Yujin of ive did.. So she will finally receive proper vocal training and proper dance lessons from her agency...Her labels has groups like Apink, The Boyz, weeekly and Victon so I am happy for her life after kep1er...I really can't wait for them to disband that company is shitty to her she deserves better.
I got to know about her because of kai as i got to know about Txt by BTS but i became MOA because of Txt not because they are BTS's junior. The same goes for Bahiyyih.
other reason that people hate hiyyih mostly in korea is because she is half korean. Because in korea is really bad seen because for them is like making the korean 100% "pure" disappear and that happens to almost all kpop idols that are half korean. But with hiyyih summing up she being related to kai, being half korean and a girl in korea is really uppsettting that all hate is going to be for her
another problem i think was also the way she was marketed. in gp999, her whole identity was that of kai's sister and other than that, mnet barely gave her any other form of screen time (to be fair, though, it was more screen time than half of the contestants ever got). only used her when they felt the name was marketable and spent the rest of the time pushing contestants they actually wanted to debut. even after debut, i feel like she'd been sidelined and unable to actually prove she deserved her spot in the top 9, leading more people to believe her spot in the team was unjustified.
I actually first saw her in a RU-vid short with her siblings (the one were they keep trying to perfect the dance for Chasing that Feeling but keep messing up lmao) I thought it was funny and cute how well they all got along I didn’t even know her brother or txt tbh. People were calling them the Huening siblings so that’s kinda just how I saw them. When I found out that her brother was part of the popular group txt and saw people referring to Bhiyyih as just his sister I honestly felt bad😭 but I think it’s super sweet how the members or txt cheers her on and she seems very hard working so I hope she makes it far!!!!!
ill be honest i knew bahiyyih before i knew kai and thanks to her i found txt and i enjoyed both music but since txt is one of the biggest 4th gen groups a lot of people judge her because shes kais sister its insane
I know her before txt and now im a moa but i still do not rly like her, she literally stole yurina's, su ruiqi, and cai bing's spot that couldve been for them but we got her instead
bahiyyih doesn't deserve any of this hate. she has no control over what family she's in and how that impacts her dream. she is so hardworking, talented, and has improved sm since gp999. sure, most ppl (including me) know her because she's kai's sister but once I kept getting to know her more, I fell in love with her personality & who *she* is. If ppl didn't like Bahiyyih herself so much, there's no way she would've gotten Top 2 just by Kai/Txt's fans. She has true fans who love her for being *her*. It's unbelievable hm hate she's getting because she's someone's sister. Yujin didn't get any hate & she's known from CLC, etc. (no hate to Yujin i love her sm) I just don't know why people are taking it out on Bahiyyih. :( this is a super well edited video! :)
I found out about Hiyyih after getting to know that people hated her because she's a sister of one of txt's member in youtube short.I like her because she is calm,loyal, generous,kind,beautiful, talented.She's also strong,despise being hated by most people,she still moving forward her dream.She's really hardworking,instead of getting help by her brother,she do everything by herself.I mean,not like her brother doesnt help her at all,her brother always support her and gave tips and advice.It just that,she is succed not because of her brother,she succed for her own hardworking piece.
Honestly when I first became a moa, I didn't actually know that huening kai had sisters at all. I came across her when I saw an edit and thought she looked familiar than saw her and huening kai dancing to wadadada. I found out they were related through the comments. I always thought bahiyyih was cute but since I had just gotten I to kpop I didn't want to stan too many groups to fast but also because kep1er just didn't appeal to me much. I actually started stanning her when I heard up and saw videos of her, but also when no one gave her any gifts during the fansign and she just looked sad. What was weird was how the other members didn't seem to do anything to cheer her up, I could be wrong but that was how it seemed. Bahiyyih is honestly really talented, so people mightve found out about her through huening kai but stayed for her. It sucks cause she doesn't get alot of lines and her company isn't making proper use of her popularity. This may be an unpopular opinion but it would be better if she debuted with another group in a different company too. She passed auditions in yg and jyp and be:lift, she was even an cube trainee so I'm not too sure why she didn't go through with those and decided to sign with her current company. Her company isn't showcasing her talents properly and it's just sad to see cause she could be even more popular than she is currently if they did their job properly.
I found about Hiyyih bcs of TXT but as I watched and listened to her and I started liking her for her. I think her voice, visuals are just downright beautiful. Its not Hiyyih's fault being Kai's brother thats why its so dumb when I see people hating on her.
Watching GP999, I was shocked when she was picked. She wasn't memorable to me at all. I'll admit I don't see why people think she's super cute/pretty, and that's ok. I don't want her to get sh*t on even though she's not for me
People are immature and envious in a bad way. Personally, I think an idol is someone who has the ability to inspire people through their success. You see them achieve and you want to achieve in your life too. I think Bahiyyih has that quality. Not a lot of idols possess that. All the idols I support give me that feeling. BP, Sakura from LSF, Hwasa MMM, Minnie from Idle. Won Young from IVE. Now Bahiyyih from Kepler. Reminder: She is still a teenager, so grown adults hating her behind their computer screens is not a look.
i just got into kpop (more exclusively) a year ago, and interestingly enough, i knew bahiyyih first. when i watched wadada i didn’t like her at first because she was so pretty to my eyes and expressionless, so i felt an internalized hatred. overtime i began to know her better and become okay with her presence. months later i became a fan of txt because i liked bahiyyih and saw kai in the group. now i like her much better because i love kai and txt, which is too unfortunate. it is interesting how loving and caring for someone can inevitably influence your perception of the people they love. if a celebrity hates or loves someone, the fans obediently and mutually follow. same goes for haters of celebrities doing the contrary.
Whether she has a famous bro or not famous bro, talent or no talent, all kpop stars go through this stage and it's called "struggle". Every person goes through this, and the most successful people today did. I hope people realize that no one is perfect and she is just doing her best like all their fave and successful idols once did. It's also sad how they say she is unattractive because her facial features don't fit into korean beauty standards or society. Tbh, I'm not a fan of huening kai I also recently just discovered her from her fan signing vids which were quite sad, but I must say I'm totally rooting for her. Hope she turns out to be the ultimate underdog and laugh at most them hating vids 2-5 years from now lmao. Also, great vid
I had literally no idea of who Bahiyyih was until like after UP. She was my bias in Up because i liked her parts and her tambre was unique I didn't even know she was the sister of Kai lol. When i found out i was surprised. She;s not my bias as of now, as my bias is Mashiro.
its like lmao even if she IS a nepotism debut, what the fuck do these people think is going on in EVERY single entertainment industry around the world? the same people who hate on bahiyyih for being kais sister turn around and gush about kylie jenner or jaden smith or any number of nepotism celebrities in america.
There are nepotism babies and well-connected idols all through 3rd and 4th gen. The same people who hate Bahiyyih probably gush about how rich idols like all of Blackpink, Lia, Giselle (whose aunt is also Lee Soo-man's current gf), etc. are. I'd venture to say that 4th and probably 5th gen idols won't debut in big3 companies if they don't come from at least a middle class family to offset trainee debt, and the more established (won competitions, trained at certain academies, etc) or connected that you are before debut, the better.
Agree with all your opinions in this except there's absolutely no way bahiyyih would make it to even top 30 without kai's support There was a point in the show were she almost got eliminated probably cause most moas thought other moas would vote for her, meaning she didn't have any fanbase of her own Now Imagine if she had 0 moa support, she'd have been eliminated in the second elimination
I just don't understand how people could bully other people they don't like... I'm not a fan of her or her brother but I won't waste my energy just hating on them. She's pretty and I guess some people are just insecure and ugly lol You go, girl!
I didn’t know who she is until I watched this video “I’m tired of being… #kpopedit” and I saw Huening Bahiyyih. I like her because of how pretty and talented she is. (not because of her brother)
For me I saw a short of her being at a fan meet up and being the only member who didn’t get any presents or anything like that so I felt bad for her and looked more into her and ended up really liking her. I’ll be honest I don’t listen to a lot of guy groups so I didn’t even know who her brother was but I’ve since grown to like him a bit as well, tho Hiyyih will always be first for me.
Basically it's true that we all had an especial eye on her bcz she was hueningkai's sister. Basically, most of the viewers were just curious abt her, such as we had the ques in mind " if she is hueningkai's sister then would she be as talented as her brother!?" Even except from txt fans, non-fans were also curious about her. And believe it or not, i literally watched the first episode bcz i was curious about her or i wouldn’t have watch that show at all after what mnet did to their last produce series. Now, it's us, it was us who were curious abt her and it's the people’s nature to always keep ckecking things out when you are curious abt something. Now, we shouldn't blame bahiyyih for our own natural habit. Now, a lot of ppl can say how she got 2nd place just by people's natural habit!? See, it's not like she was worse or anything. She actually was very appealing than other trainees in that show. And she actually was improving on every stage step by step, since a lot of ppl were watching her out of curiosity it became an advantage for her to show her Improvement & talents. And i guess, she perfectly knew abt that and hold on to that advantage and worked hard. So, definitely she deserves her 2nd place, bcz she kept the higher expectations from the people who were watching her. If you want to blame then blame yourself, why did you watch her on the first place? You could've just ignored her. Now, it's not her fault that she was sister of someone very famous.
I knew Bahiyyih was Kai's sister but didn't become a fan of hers until her fiesta performance because she has a genuinely nice vocal color and is a stable live singer alongside being a good dancer. She also has a very nice and kind personality and was well liked among the other trainees. If she wasn't Kai's sister people would be hyping her up and go whoa look at this trainee she's so cool. Later in the show she didn't advocate for her getting more parts and honestly I blame watchers for criticizing her every move of course with all the excessive hate she'd become scared and insecure. Mnet also barely gave her any screentime, for fiesta team she was helping take care of ito miyu and helped her practice and for shoot! team bahiyyih ended up getting a lot more parts than she initially got and it was shocking watching the final performance cuz we didn't see at all how and why things changed. This only made Bahiyyih supporters more frustrated cuz mnet was like gatekeeping her screentime despite being a popular trainee. The current state of kep1er is also frustrating because Bahiyyih was 1st in international votes and 7th in korean votes meaning she received the most votes in total but korean votes counted like 10x more than int votes so she ranked 2nd but it only proves her popularity.
I don’t hate Bahiyyih, so don’t take this too harshly. I watched the entire ‘GP999’ survival show from start to finish, and she honestly didn’t stand out that much compared to others. Like she was stable & good, but didn’t impressed me. The other contestants just were better and stood out more. Considering Kep1er is only a temporary group, my thought process was give the more ready contestants a shot first because it might be their last shot at becoming a idol. At the time Bahiyyih didn’t look ready but now she improved a lot.
i've known her even before girls planet 999. I'm a casual listener of TXT and learned that TXT Huening Kai has a sister, who is Huening Lea. I've known Lea first even before bahiyyih. watch their random ig lives and stuff. I learned who bahiyyih is from Lea's Instagram lives. i was also a follower of her ig Account. but sadly, she deactivated because she became a trainee. I'm not really invested in her journey up until she joined girls planet 999. I mainly watched the show for Bahiyyih and Yujin, also due to the trailer that made Fu Yaning look bad. My first intention is to see how bahiyyih perform as an idol. I saw her performance with the O.O.O individual performance and saw that she has a potential as a dancer. not the greatest, but she can dance. Also watched that introduction video and saw that she's stable when singing. so that made me support her. The first episode air, i was really waiting for Bahiyyih's performance but it was for the 2nd episode so let's skip there. The 2nd episode, her performing Mr. Chu with her other members, wasn't the best performance for me. She was obviously nervous and the whole performance is kinda off for me. So expected, was kinda disappointed but we do need to consider the fact that she's trained for a short period of time. 1st mission, i was so happy that she got to perform fiesta because izone is my ult group. Though, i think she'll prefer performing How you like that by Blackpink instead. Her performance was GREAT. can't stop watching her fancam. she did so well apart that she didn't do the whistle (idk if you'll call that a whistle) in the ending part, but it was great! she's stable, she danced well, and overall, one of the carriers of the team. 2nd mission is the Ice cream. She finally got to perform a blackpink song! the whole mission showed her capabilities as a dancer. her short part managed to be one of the most killing part of the performance a long with dayeon's dance break. it proves that she doesn't have a poor facial expression and how she can improve over time. though, that mission almost made her fall and got eliminated (traumatizing moment). Next mission is the Shoot. She helped Yujin with cleaning the choreography. has the 2nd most lines and not surprisingly, stable. Though, her outfit wasn't great. hated the buckethat so much. Overall, a great performance!. Last mission is the O.O.O mission where i had to stream the sht out of me. was really worried for her because team 2 was really devastated and unmotivated. but it became the BEST (debatable) performance out of the 3 teams. she finally won a mission and got the benefit! last episode is where they performed shine, a single line of the song really concerned me, yet she still danced skillfully and did a great job. it was concerning that she didn't have any screentime during the last episode. i thought to myself that if bahiyyih isn't called after announcing the 5th place, it's over. but to my surprise, she became the top 1 candidate along with my other bias, kim chaehyun. she ranked top 2 and became the most voted trainee in 100+ countries, proving that she's really famous worldwide. Even before the show, bahiyyih already has a fanbase due to her appearing in public tv and to her performing prior to her debut (you can check her pre-debut activities). The lesson for this is that, i won't vote for someone's sister if she's untalented or doesn't have the potential. Huening Bahiyyih is talented, pretty, and can excel at anything. and antis are not ready to admit that.
THIS! I feel like people don't understand this. Even if her fans are MOAs, no fan is going to vote for someone they think is untalented just because she's someone's sister. A name drop can only get you so far. As well, there are people like me. I was never a MOA. I am barely even a casual listener as TXT's music doesn't appeal to me. I'm still not a fan. When TXT debuted, I was an ARMY, and I casually looked up the members and found out about Lea in VIVA and 1 other sister. Years later, I hear about that sister again on GP999 getting massive hate. I'm confused, so I check her out, and... she's fine. By the Ice Cream performance, I'm a full-blown supporter as it's clear this hate is completely unjustified. People also don't realize she's got fans like this who are here because we think she's talented, has a great personality, is pretty, and we want to protect her from the hate she continues to get. This hate is only advertising her skills more, like it did for Onda in Everglow.
Okay I also found out about her because she’s Kai’s sister but the Kepler fans should surely like her for that because I found about Kepler through that too. Millions of people including me found out about Kepler because of her being Huening Kai’s sister soo the fans of that group should be happy that she brings in so much free clout for their group
I don’t get it! She is the nicest girl I have ever seen! I don’t like to se idols thinking that they are nothing! I know that I knew Bahiyyih from Kai but she is my bias because her voice is amazing, her dancing skills and her visuals! How can people hate her? You want the best for kpop idols when you are doing this to a 17 year old girl who is a new kpop idol! Y’all better treat her how you want to be treated!
I love hiyyih... I know her because of kai but that was before the show I loved and idolized her but it wasn't because of kai... Yes i know her because of kai but i like her because she is herself she a great girl with a great personality who works hard to achieve her dreams and im proud to be her fan... Ilove huening siblings, that includes the 3 of them
She has so few lines in wa da da. I understand she didn’t choose a company because she didn’t want to be labelled as HK’s sister. But unfortunately people labelled her as HK’s sister. I was quite sad when they were at a fan meeting she didn’t receive any gifts it was pitiful.
also, can we please stop pushing the narrative of bahiyyih being the least talented in kepler? thats far from the truth and often leads to people giving her backhanded compliments
@@SkyFWWO dumbasses like you talk too much.hiyyih and youngeun aren’t far apart in technique which says a lot considering youngeun is constantly praised for her singing and for being a main vocal potential. you dumbasses always speaking on hiyyih without knowing anything.Bahiyyih sings with little to no strain(the only other person in this group that does that is Chae). She also has a connected range and know how to mix properly for notes higher in her register. Her head voice is very clear and developed. hiyyih also has a wide vocal range, a resonant tone and is constantly praised for being stable.
The reason why I think she gets hate is for people thinking she got her spot off hyuka now here is the thing people are mad about they think she doesn't deserve her spot as 2nd spot they believe she would of been off in 4th-5th episode which in truth is probably corrrct since MOA's were all over viral saying vote Huening Kai's sister🙁 it's sad that she has to face this hate.
Not a hater but I noticed that she stands out the most and I think she could work a little more on her expression, her covering other idol's dance's super good tho
How did i found out about Bahiyyih? I was on tiktok one day and saw her doing a cute dance. I really liked her and she stood out to me, then i looked her up and thought that she had such a familiar face. Very unique. Then after i looked up her kprofile, i understood she was kais sister, and that was like weeeeks after i knew her
I know her for clips and Edits hahah and the attention that She had. Later from wadada and girls planets 99. Became a fan of her bcz I liked her and thought She was talented. Later more diving in I saw txt kai was her brother. But I didn’t know the members only a few songs. But they are not one persone so why are people always involving her brother into her live. As a fan its soo annoying to see. There interactions are amazing too see but leave it at that.
honestly I love her, she is talented and beautiful,I really hope she ends up like a solo artist or in a better managed group, the hate its absolutely stupid and uncalled for, so unfair
I knew bahiyyih way before I got into txt. I was looking through yg trainee profile and she caught my attention. Right after I got into txt I noticed that they were siblings. I been a fan for bahiytih for a long time now and I hope lil miss heuning is doing well.
I also think that hating on someone, literally anyone out there, because you think they are not pretty is such a dumb and evil thing to do. In the idol industry, on the other hand, it's just so common. So so many idols are and were getting hate because they are/were apparently not pretty enough to be idols...the Korean beauty standard is so strict that some people actually calculate the percentages of how much an idol fits in it, so for many people out there being ''pretty'' is a requirement for being an idol like having dancing or singing abilities. And there are also companies that cast people because of their looks. These people do nothing to the bare minimum in their auditions, they just look so perfect that the company wants them as their visual since this ''position'' is still seen as a very important one in groups. That's just how the industry works... that doesn't mean visuals have no talent or is any hate towards idols holding this position, it's just a common fact that the most ''talented'' members are often not the most popular. That's not inherently bad or good, it's just a fact that proves, even if it's dumb or senseless, idols get a lot of hate or attention for their looks and it always matters in the industry
I remember why she is my fav, I was just a kepler stan, I never got into the fandom, the first MV lve ever saw was wingwing, I saw her and thougth "oh shes pretty, I like her hair, she looks like she's from another contry" then i search her up, she's """brazilian""" bc of ver father who is brazilian, and the turned my fav bcs im brazilian too, and i always tougth "damn she looks like kai" and my friend told me she was his sister, in the end 2 of my bias were siblings, i got happy for no reason at all
Number 1 I do like her but the problem is she won't get a chance and will be known as the shadow of the huening and yes I said that unless members leave kep1er due to idk what reasons she won't get a chance to shine but it is what it is. She will somehow find a chance I trust and hope in her.
I wish for her, that at the next fan meeting she gets a big cake of her favourite taste and stuffed animals and some big fat hugs 🤗 because when I would not be this far away, I would be there and give her a chocolate and a hug. Nobody should be bullied by others... Especially not fans. I love kep1ers music and many other groups like superkind and so on... Make love - no war!❤😊 Thanks
ok im not even gonna lie, i knew her first cuz she is kai sister, i liked her bc she was popular and hated (not a proud one guys 😭), and i still dont hate her, but she ended up not being my bias bc xiaoting was chinese (dont worry, after i got to know her i actually did like her)
Idk... I can't say that I hate her, but I like her the least from the group. For me she looks kinda average and appears to be in a kind of "ugly duckling" phase, I do believe she may turn out to be a very good performer, but right now... I just feel like she's not ready to be an idol yet. And i didn't even know who's her brother, I'm a girl group stanner.
Yeah let's say she appeared in the show in a universe where Hyuka straight-up doesn't exist, do yall really truly think she would've debuted? Mnet gave her like zero screentime too, she would've just gotten eliminated first round and no one would've noticed.. I feel so bad for her, she didn't do shit she's so unproblematic yet she's hated. Anyway check her cover out
Creo que muchos se equivocan al ponderar como factor principal de la popularidad de Bahiyyih, el hecho que sea la hermana de hueningkai. Osea es cierto que muchos conocieron a Bahiyyih por ser la "hermana de", pero el decir que solo Moas fueron los que movilizaron todos los votos que pudo tener Bahiyyih durante el programa es una falacia. El fandom de txt no se caracteriza por ser de los fandoms que más votos mueven en cualquier tipo de votación, entonces como puede atribuirse a este fandom la abrumadora cantidad de votos que recibió Bahiyyih. Creo que a Bahiyyih le ayudo ser la hermana de huyka en el aspecto de hacerse conocer más que el resto, pero luego la masiva cantidad de votos que recibió se debió a qué muchas personas empezaron a apoyarla por ella misma, yo incluida, quien no soy MOA, pero al conocerla y ver sus performances me dieron ganas de apoyarla, en realidad no me dedique a votar, pero si veía mucho sus fancams, si es que esto puede verse como apoyo, más que nada porque me encantaba la forma en que actuaba y como se desempeñaba en las diferentes presentaciones.
if Bahi wasn't talented, she wasn't an idol And stop saying she is ugly! She is cute and beautiful like is older brother and older sister. No one is born ugly. And what is the probleme If she is kai sister? Many pleople love kai(i am one),every kpop idol have haters and fans.This is normal. Pls stop hating Huening family!😢
YG does not care about talent boo. Who said that? They care about marketing and visuals. Lol they just happen to sign very talented VISUALLY MARKETABLE artists lol 😂
Well, personally, i dont like her. Dont know why. I just dont. But i dont hate on her. I just dont listen to her music. Its kinda sad how many people hate on her just because. Its not that hard, if you dont like her, go do something else, listen to other music. No one is forcing you to listen to her.
I find Bahiyyih's voice very attractive, her dancing skills are quite good and her beauty is improving day by day. Just by improving her stage performance skills, Bahiyyih will become perfect.
If you want to dig deeper, maybe look up racism in Korea, how they treat Chinese/Thai/Japanese/Other races in a kpop group and all the hate comments about them. I think that is the root. And also, they hate it when someone stands out the most (maybe because they want their bias to stand out instead) and this one isn't always about "not looking korean" but also about weight, if you get chubbier, you draw attention. If you wear different clothes from the other members, you draw attention, and such.
I don’t know much about keep1er I only know that girl, but every time I see her the only thing I can focus on is how sad her eyes look. No matter what situation she always looks like her mind is somewhere else
It not her fault that she has a famous celebrity sibling. So the hating needs to stop. People will find the smallest thing on why to hate. I see this time and time again with singling out a certain individual in a k pop group. I like her unique look
To be completely honest, I didn’t even know who she was within the entire survival show until they brought up her brother. She sticks out within the entire group and I do feel like her singing and dancing ability have improved but I usually find a balance where the members perform in a nice blended way with each other and she kind of overshadows all the other members in my opinion. BUT her blonde hair made her 10x more likable for me without having an internalized hate sensation. If they didn’t hold a public vote, didn’t showcase any background history, and purely based it off expert judges with Actual best performing long running idol judges then the final line up would’ve been more cohesively put together. This is my opinion and sure it may be bias but Girls Planet was not a successful survival program for me. But at the end of the day it was a popular vote. I would like to support her from afar but I refuse to take notice of this group anymore. 😭
bahiyyih.. hmm i found out about her bc i watched gp999 and later found out she was huening kai sister, bahiyyih is so nice and pretty. is there any reason to hate bahiyyih? i think not
The reason why I initially did not like her is because of the result of the show. If it was organically obtained and we saw that she went from 99 to 18 to 12 to 7 to 2 or something like that. We saw that she was never in the top 9 but somehow managed to get 2 at the end? Also the people that were already in the top 9 for the majority of the show did not get to debut?? I get that it’s the voters at the end of the day but it was just a bad surprising sequence of events. There was also the controversy of the Chinese members as well. Maybe the anger due to the Chinese members being evil edited transferred to BH because that was the easiest to bandwagon on. I don’t mind her now because well she doesn’t really stand out to me. Also this is a temp group so it’s a waste of energy to hate on something that is going to not last anyways.
i knew bahiyyih on the ice cream performance on the show, i liked her and though she was really good at dancing. i didn’t even knew she was kai’s sister until i saw the WA DA DA video and saw the comments :P
#1 - because she's Heuning Kai's sister #2 - I actually ended up liking her _because_ she was so hated. Injustice ticks me off, and the only reason why people hated her so much that I could see was that she was HK's sister. I'm a sucker for underdogs and hard-luck cases!
i know who is kai just bc he's bahiyyih is sister; I saw a lot of people say that she's kai is sister but i didn't know who is kai actually i even thought he was kai from exo.. +Sorry for bad english
I do not know her, I do not hate her, I wish her all the best just like any other stranger out there. She obviously works incredibly hard as all idols do, which is something I think is admirable. That being said, the first time I saw her was in a clip from Girls Planet 999 and I just remember thinking, "Oh no, poor girl clearly doesn't have enough training and probably got shoved onto the show by her company because they think she has an interesting look." Just zero stage presence and no commitment in her dancing, she looked like a backup dancer and I was confused why the camera kept focusing on her. Found out later she ranked number 2 and has a hate following. I hope everyone realizes that even if she did get rigged into the final lineup, she wasn't the one who orchestrated that. SHE didn't do anything wrong, she's working her ass off and trying her best. If you think she shouldn't have made it, that's no reason to be mean to HER. I do not like her performances but she's a damn person in a very demanding industry and doesn't deserve to feel bad about everything she's accomplished. Everyone chill. Edit to add: I do not know TXT or Huening Kai
why do people care so much wether or not she is huening kai sister like, its not about stuff like that but how you are as an idol, not your family, either way whats so wrong with her being huening sister? like leave Huening alone! its so stupid how people act like that, its not that deep
It's not that I don't like her, but I find her stans annoying and delusional af. Most of them can't accept that her brother is the only reason why she got attention. She only had one good performance in the show, and 0 screentime, how are you supposed to find her interesting if talent-wise she's average in a survival full of other amazing performers, and if they give her no screentime. Simply because you like her bother, therefore you like her. She was never well liked by the fans of the show. She wasn't as good as other partecipants and they weren't giving her chances to showcase her talents and funny side, so nobody was really invested in her. She just got in because of her solo stans, aka her brother stans. It's not her fault at all, but her fans should admit that this is what happened.
it amazes me how yall dog on hiyyihlights but never keep the same energy for keplians who have done snd continue to do worse. you just look goofy babes. bahiyyih was an attention point all throughout gp999 it didnt matter how much screentime she got because her fans always found other ways to get new content. why do you think her fancam views were always among the highest, if not the highest? bahiyyih debuting just proves my point even more cuz it shows that bahiyyih didnt just gain attention/hype for being kais sister. even now she’s by far the most popular member, this shows she wasnt being carried by moas. data was released that showed that people searched hiyyih up more as bahiyyih /huening bahiyyih than kai’s sister. bahiyyih is a valuable asset to kepler both talent and marketing wise. if you really want to pull the “there were better contestants” bs than pull that shit for the rest of the group
The reason why she's hated is simple: many regard her as untalented. While she definitely has some level of talent, it's undeniable there were lots of girls on GP999 who were more talented then her - at singing, dancing and stage presence. Therefore it's not unreasonable to come to the conclusion that she only got as popular as she did because of her family connections and thus they may think she didn't "deserve" all of this attention.
Look no k-pop company would let an untalented person debut in their company even how famous his/her brother or sister is. They would not want their company to go flop alright!? Being someone famous person's sibling is not a reason for you to hate on her. Being pretty is not everything in this world not everyone is pretty or good looking they didn't make their own faces!? Look at your face decide if you are pretty or not then hate other person face is not going to be with you the whole life when you will grow old your face is going to change or something!! You need to look into a person's talent, inner beauty and love them if you love them for their good looks then man sorry to say but you don't deserve to be loved! That's what I have to say about this!
Who mentioned that she is Kais Brother?She could have hidden that fact in Front of the cams at the survival Show, so that she doesn't have an unfair Advantage. I think thats why pple hate her. P.s I don't hate her and I don't love her since I don't know her...
was she the most talented trainee in gp999? no. but to say that she can’t sing or dance? that’s absolutely not true. you have to be lying to yourself to think that lmao. her dance and singing skills are above average AT LEAST.
Him:if u like her why did u like her if u don't like her why don't u like/hate her Me:sir I don't know anything abt her I just saw adits of her getting hate so now I listening to this so I won't answer