00:00 Witness Introduction 00:18 State Direct Examination 07:46 Cross-Examination Catch up on the FACTS here: www.courttv.com/news/ga-v-hannah-payne-car-crash-vigilante-trial/?
I love how most of these witnesses he's attempted to make falter, have instead doubled down and made him look like a badgering jackass of a dime store lawyer.
Yes, because the defense attorney kept trying to trip up the other young lady. He was using semantics and questioning her on tiny details to get her frustrated. But he couldn’t trip up this witness. She was a very good witness!! And they found this lying defendant GUILTY in almost record time!!
I hope to God I will never have to go to court at to give evidence because I would never b able to keep my cool this long,knowing I am telling the truth and defence going around like that talking cap.😅
I am so happy she kept her 😎, but she gave him the eyes at one point, when she realized he was trying to put words in her mouth, and, trick her in her testimony. clearly this guy was nervous and grasping at straws. He knew his client didn't really have a defense. All of his crosses were on the witnesses statements, and maps.
The defense attorney succeeded in getting the witness to say at least 2 dozen times his client jumped out and tussled with the victim and then pulled her gun and shot him. What an idiot.
I've never seen such bumbling. Then a character witness got lost when she's being sentenced. I think she's got grounds for a new trial for ineffective Council.
This is just so tragic. I can’t imagine his families pain. I’m a nurse and I’m willing to bet my life his blood glucose level was so dramatically off the charts that’s what caused the original accident. And it’s even more apparent that’s the case when he’s experiencing disorientation & confusion afterwards. He lost his life because her entitled ass assumed he had to be drunk Or high. She never tried to figure out what wa wrong, she just killed him. He was killed for being a brittle diabetic . Lord I pray for both families!
both of my parents are diabetic and they get in states like this on rare occasions. mainly my father cause he is terrible about getting his protein in at the right times and doesn't think to feed himself through the day. just thinking that if either of them had this happen while they are in public terrified me. now it makes it a nightmare seeing how an entitled ass woman just shot a man for a medical issue. just sad as hell.
@@KM-re5dyhe wasn’t thinking rationally, was disoriented. Sometimes the grip of fear to get to help, fast is the only driving force. When my son died we transported him because in our state of shock we thought it was the fastest, best way to get to help.
When your client is guilty as hell, and you're required to create a defense, but have nothing to work with, you do your best to discredit the witness/es. Sadly for him, but fortunately for justice, this lady just wasn't having any of his bs, and slapped I'm round the room. Wonder which WS group she belongs to?
He was reaching she states in the interview like she’s an officer and it was grounds for her to shoot him, completely negating everything leading up to the encounter.
i disagree. she for some reason, is talking to defense's attorney during cross examination to make the defendant look as bad as possible. she doesn't seem non-biased at all. its clear that she wants the defendant to go to prison and she will fight the defense's attorney on any question that helps the defendant. - for example, she refuses to answer a simple question "is it possible for a car to drive up on that curb?" - a very simple question, but she refuses to answer it because it would help the defendant. someone who oozes honesty and truth in a courtroom is someone who can try to be as unbiased as possible and also, someone who is willing to assume that the defendant is innocent until proven guilty.
@@briannadboyd when the defense lawyer asked her this simple question, why did she refuse to answer? "is it possible for a car to drive up on that curb?"
This woman is a rock. She sat there and held her truth and did not allow the slimy lawyer to box her into contradicting herself. She was a solid witness. He was very unprofessional.
Ashley Jackson was the best witness. What got me was when the defense attorney said So you didn’t see her get out of her vehicle? I think when Ashley wrote her statement to the detectives she wrote that Hannah got out of her vehicle, Ashley pulled over to videotape but everything happened so fast. When questioned on the stand Ashley answered No I didn’t see her get out of her vehicle. The defense attorney tried to make a big deal out of this.
Hey NO need to call her pale, yes she is a demon... but not all of us white people are pale or pink. I could call you something but I will take the high road. @@mamanemcakesandtreats3974
For the people who say that the man who was killed was a criminal because he left the scene of the accident. . . Maybe he left to try to drive himself to a hospital because it had been 20 to 30 minutes since the ambulance was called and they hadn’t arrived yet and he realized he was having a medical emergency.
This is the type of questioning that occurs when you literally have zero defense or evidence to exonerate your client. This woman should have taken a plea. Absolutely painful testimony.
No matter how many times he tries to put words in her mouth and ask the same question a million times, like a tree planted by the river, she unwavering in her testimony.
This witness gives me faith in humanity. She’s defending what she saw and the horrid murder she saw take place. She was calm, collected and stood up for herself.
@VeraxMusic the witness probably wouldn't even have been on the witness stand if the defendant was black. I am black and know this. Most likely. But this is what the culture has come to.
@@HoneyCrampstbh I think they just speak on the fact that some people assume black people are ghetto loud and noisey so they compliment in shock at those who aren’t as if most black people aren’t this way in general.
He's grossly incompetent if he doesn't know basic motor vehicle laws and driving on the shoulder or sidewalk is illegal... technically, you cannot even pass another car by using the shoulder or sidewalk--forget an accident scene.
I've watched most of this trial, and I STILL wonder when a defendant becomes their attorney's ASSISTANT? This defendant has searched for notepads and documents and, at one point, even looked up things for this guy on a laptop. TOTAL INSANITY!
Seems like he is her assistant,shes the one in control. She's been writing him notes on the legal pads, trading them back & forth the entire time, he runs asking her questions before asking certain questions of the witnesses, etc.. That's why she wanted to keep him as her lawyer, bc he did what SHE said to do. Imagine how much crap he's had to listen to & put up with from her over the past 4 years 😂 No other lawyer is gonna put up w that crap.
@@M.O.W.no other lawyer in their right frame of mind would have even thought about taking that case! He made mad money off family he knew damned well she was guilty!
His cross examination did not help his client at all. His focus on whether or not the witness saw Hannah got out of the vehicle was so pointless and did not get anywhere
Hannah's family had to have order this lawyer from Temu... all ge does is re-read witnesses statements back to them with no valid point, making it worse for his client with every word that he utters.
This lady on the stand is extremely believable. And this girl who murdered that man tried to make him the criminal. That makes me so mad she's sickening.
He did cause an accident and left the scene. Had he not died the way he did, you would be calling him a criminal. Because he was. Now, that doesn’t mean she’s innocent of what she is being accused. She didn’t have to follow and could’ve left it alone after she got the plate number. But she kept following, cut him off and confronted him with a gun. She got herself where she is. However, the video doesn’t show her pulling the trigger since shes facing the deceased and not the camera and even witnesses say they didn’t see her shooting, they only heard the gunshot. She could be telling the truth about him being the one who pulled the trigger while trying to disarm her. The law says people are innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt. They can’t prove she murdered him. She should’ve gotten manslaughter or somewhere around the line. Not murdered.
Never mind, I just got to the part where the witness says he didn’t grab the gun. I just knew about the witness who called 911 but didn’t see where she shot him and another witness who said they heard a gunshot but didn’t see when she shot him. But still, he was a criminal.
@@PhobicEra He did caused an accident but he didn't kill anyone.She is not a law enforcement officer.She should have kept her ass quiet and take her nose out of what don't concern her.But she wanted her 15 minutes of fame and she is surely getting it.She wanted to be on TV news.
@@PhobicEraYou just had to add “but still”. People like you will always defend people like this shooter because you see yourself in her. You relate to them. SMH
The lawyer has to do his job, but he knows his client is guilty and that’s why he keeps asking the same questions 10 different ways🤦🏽♀️… I admire how this witness held strong to her truth and that side eye she gave him was
The fact that he tried to make her out to be a liar, asked her the SAME question 10 DIFFERENT WAYS, being combative with his questions, and tried to mix her words up is ridiculous- 27:58 said it all "I know what I saw ND you're not gonna play with me on this stand"
I love this witness!! He thought he was going to contradict her account of that day with her own words ....she stood her ground with facts and confidence ...she handled his a**!!! That is a prosector's dream for a witness. They let her handle him with no objections other than his repeat questions and smiles on their face 😂😂😂 Love this woman❤
The defense attorney kept asking the same questions over and over again thinking that the witness was going to trip up and when she didn't he got irritated😂😂😂😂.... I love the way it ended with the answer saying "get out of the car MF"
That's what happens in criminal Court. I would try to show her as a human being or anything good she's given to her community. I'm guessing there's nothing there. She's going away.
This is what happens when people decide to do the opposite of what they were told by the 911 operator. Ahmaud Arbery another person who was murdered by over zealous White People in GA who took the law into their own hands and ended up behind bars for life. It's never a good idea for individuals to confront others about incidents that don't have anything to do with them ,then claim to be the victim when things go bad. Hannah Payne is a great example of a Karen 😭🤣. All she had to do was take a picture of the guy's tags and give them to 911, instead she ended up killing him and probably will spend half of her life behind bars. Just saying! 😏
@@patriciawilson155 Same thing with Treyvon Martin. Zimmerman did the very same thing after being told by the operator to stay away, police were on their way.
You can’t confuse people who know the truth already. He tired very hard to throw her off. Very good she stayed with her truth and didn’t let him confuse her.
This is how to use your power when someone is literally trying to twist your words and gaslight your own experience. Yes ma’am honey you did that. Justice for the victim.
OK, her attorney is acting like a fool, but what else does he have to work with? A remorseless unsympathetic client, who is recorded both on audio and video killing an unarmed man sitting in his car, who lies repeatedly about it after the fact. Lawyer is doing everything he can, but I don't think it's gonna help her. His own opening statement was essentially, "Don't believe what you eyes will see and your ears hear."
He’s probably the only attorney that agreed to defend her lol. Everyone knew she was guilty due to all the evidence back in 2019. He’s probably desperate for work I guess.
This man was racing to the hospital, because he thought he was dying. How ironic this woman was the reason his life would end that day. This is one of the most disgusting cases I’ve recently come across.
He was on his way to hospital afraid he was having serious problems? Gahhh that is so sad, so scary. Poor guy 😢 she's a damn lunatic shooting someone like that. So infuriating. Remorseless too.
@@chastityporter6729 ya very sad, the witness' at the original crash mentioned that maybe he was in diabetic shock or having some kind of medical crisis.
Her lawyer can’t afford a legal assistant. That says a lot about the type of lawyer she hired. I’m actually surprised that Killer Hannah didn’t raise a million from Republicans like that little devil kid Kyle Rittenhouse did.
@@darlashannon1202 That is not how it works for any lawyer who has a successful enough business. It’s called a legal assistant or paralegal. “A legal assistant is a professional who provides administrative and clerical support to lawyers and other legal professionals. Legal assistants may perform tasks such as managing documents and files, scheduling appointments and court dates, and communicating with clients and other parties involved in legal matters.”
Them prosecutor don't seem to be working very hard to see that Justice is served in this case, they allowed that defense attorney too ask her the same question OVER and OVER again with no objections.
Yes she knew she gave her truth. He tried to twist her words from when it happened till now. But it backfired on him. She was not the the only one on the scene that told the Police Officer Hannah killed Mr Herring
I just listened to the 911 call Hannah made and all I hear is “ I’m gonna take matters into my own hands.” The dispatch directly told her not to follow the man. Proceeded to follow him. The dispatch said to go back to the location where the accident happened. She proceeded to get out and start a fight and then shoot the man. and then demanded that the dispatcher tell the police to come to her “immediately.” MIND YOU…. The car accident that happened didn’t even involve her. She just wanted to be nosey.
Right! He’s like “you didn’t dot the i over your middle name, so that makes this statement invalid.” Lol. It is normal to assume she exited the vehicle. Maybe he wanted her to say she teleported.
It takes balls to stand up to a defence attorney without training, LEOs and forensic scientists get tons of training on how not to be tripped up by them
He's a boring bully, but what a horror he's defending. He's got nothing to do but bully, cos his client did it and refused a plea deal. Heres to a life for a life sentence next.
Is it just me who watched this video several times and has come to this every once in a while? She's one of the best witnesses I've ever seen in a trial.
Here's a free tip for defense attorneys: Don't leave the jury wondering 'What point is defense even trying to make?' Also, pretending you don't understand straightforward, coherent testimony does not affect the witness's credibility...it only makes you look dim.
i love this lady ( the witness ) ! she understood the assignment & stood on business ! her whole demeanor changed ( in a good way ) when he got up there to question her cause she knew insta what type of timing he was going to be on .. which was trying to twist her words & make her look like a liar or catch her up in some kind of “ lie “. great job to her ! don’t even know this lady but i’m proud of her 🙌🏾👏🏾👌🏾🗣️🗣️
To be fair, based on America's legal system history. Females get leniency, whytes get leniency. Whyte + female = double leniency. If I was her, I'd think getting away with killing a black man was highly likely. Happened THOUSANDS of times with 0 penalty.
I 😘 ve this witness.. Shes telling what she saw. To the defense attorney "maybe she flew to the victims window, maybe she crawled out her window, but she made it to the victim's window and shot him." I love this young woman! Not intimidated by this guy! 👍🥰👍