The way Crystal hugged Sadie and said "We're not done looking" was truly a beautiful moment in such a sad story. I think this might be the first time in a long time that Sadie really believes someone will keep looking. You and Louis Carlos are doing fantastic work together and bringing attention to the case in a meaningful way.
Anthonette's case has haunted me for years. I think about her all the time. Im so glad someone is shedding light on her case and searching for her. Thank you for doing this. When will the next video be released? I cannot wait to keep following this journey to find her. Best of luck ❤
@@crystalgutierreztv I truly hope that the individual in question is her, as there is a striking resemblance to the girl in the picture. However, in a worst-case scenario, I trust that closure will find its way to this girl's family, shedding light on the mysterious events. Despite the passing of 38 long years (2024), an inkling persists within me that she continues to draw breath - who can fathom the trials and tribulations she endured during this time? The possibilities are haunting; she may have encountered the harsh reality that her mother rejected her, or worse, abandoned, neglected, or relinquished her. It is a thought too distressing to consider - the chilling notion that she may have met an untimely demise.
I’m so sad that we didn’t find her. I saw this headline and my heart jumped. I tried to keep a blog about missing people that might be alive, and Anthonette was only the second one I featured. I remember when she went missing as well. I was about 7. I think Crystal Gutierrez has done so much more for Anthonette and her family than anyone else.
I heard about Anthonette’s case 8 years ago and it’s one of several cases that I never forgot. You guys are doing an awesome job putting your all into trying to find answers; much more than the police and FBI are. I feel for Sadie who wants to know where is Anthonette. I hope someday we can get those answers. Prayers for Sadie and her family. 🙏🏻
Thank you so much for your support. We are also working on several other cases for other families who are waiting for their loved ones to come back home. If you are able to watch, comment and share those episodes, we would greatly appreciate it. The more eyes on these cases...the more opportunities for tips to come in. Thank you again :)
In a way I don’t blame Michelle for disputing it… the resemblance is uncanny, right down to the smile. I was shocked she was not Anthonette, but I trust DNA. I can understand her doubt though… try to be in her position. It’s so strange. So happy that people like you exist Crystal. Thanks to you both for your hard work!
@@evetteuriegas6610 prove it and i didnt ever think i was better than anyone in the family as i was abused by your mom since i moved in with her so is that why she abused me cause i thought i was better as i recall that is david thinking like that me--he is the one who pushed me away from the family not i--
I cried 😢my eyes out for sadie!! And for Michelle my heart goes out to her and what may have happened to her childhood. Someone out there holds the information and the light will reveal it!! Keep up the good work cuz!! #cantstopwontstop
It wouldn’t surprise me at all if Michelle could be a victim of the s£x trafficking ring that the gov of the U.S have been involved in for decades! If she was ever a ward of the state, then that’s a big 🚩 So many kids have been abducted and put through the gov’s MK Ultra program. My heart just breaks so badly for for these poor ladies😢 I pray that they find peace and comfort and the answers that they truly deserve!
I dont think Michelle was lying or inserting herself into the Anthonette Cayedito case out of boredom. I think she saw Anthonette on tv or a youtube video or whatever and possibly thought she was Anthonette or in the least a victim of the posible same crime ring that had taken Anthonette.
I'm her cousin and she's just want everyone to feel sorry for her because she thought she was better than the rest of her family. She's was the one that pushed us away. I'm in the picture by her and behind our dad that she knows. My parents raised her because my aunt Sylvia Flores couldn't. Don't believe me she all in my Facebook Happy and all we have pictures and family photos together and she not missing never was
I lived down the street from Antoinette and her family when this happened. I went to school with her younger sister. I have been following this case for several years and I was truly hoping that was her. Keep searching. She’s out there somewhere.
I was just wondering- will Sadie’s dna be kept on file in case others come forward claiming to be Anthonette? That way they can just compare it without Sadie having to go through all these emotions again. They would only have to tell her if it is her.
Omg when I tell you I'm from Gallup my mom was very good friends with Penny I sat her like what I feel bad for both I hope and pray they both find answers 🙏
Hi! First, thank you for your support. Second...do you think your mom would have any knowledge of the people Penny hung around with? If so, could you send me an email at ... info@beyondthecase.com ... Thank you again :)
I’m sorry but the little girl in the pictures is the adult woman. How do we know Antonette was a blood sibling to begin with hence why it was easy for the “mother” to sell her.
Exactly, just because the two women don't match as related doesn't mean she's not Anthonette. I've commented before, how many people think they're related and when the truth comes out, they're not.
WOW! She looks like anthonette. And the picture you showed her and she said its crazy how she had a picture that was almost the same but different occasion. I thought it was going to be a match. I'm stunned it is not.
I'm her first cousin and her mom and my mom are sister. Yes she was put in the system but my mom took her in and gave all her brothers and sister a lovely family home
Hi Crystal, any update from the FBI with what happened after they interviewed Penny? Thank you for your continued work on finding Anthonette. Keep up the good work!❤
Hi! We requested an interview with the FBI and are still waiting for someone to get back to us. Unfortunately, the FBI is one of the hardest agencies to get answers from. So...keep your fingers crossed and prayers coming!
This shook my heart. I had no idea what this story was until I read it in our local newspaper "The Independent: The Truth Well Told" I've been interested, heart struck & yearning for answers since... Anthonette if our out there wondering or even know you were taken, just know we're done looking for you & you have family who loves you.
Hey you bring up a super good point! Perhaps thats why her mom didnt care to sell her damm I hope this family finds answers because this is Just heartbreaking
There is a 47 year old woman named Antionette that lives in Albuquerque NM. She has the same mole by her nose and has a similar nose and teeth as the age progression. It's probably just a coincidence though.
I figured it wasn't true. I'm 40 and I can still remember things that happened when I was 2. Unless she had a traumatic brain injury of some sort, I don't quite see how she would of been unable to remember her mom and sisters at 9.
I had a very traumatic childhood and I only remember a few things from before 15. I have this thing were I block out bad things or sad things and I do that for so long I can’t actually remember. I unfortunately can remember the SA and Abuse but nothing really else.
@mariemartins8606 But to not even remember your name? Jaycee Dugard was kidnapped as a child and went through absolutely horrific things, and she was still able to remember her name 20 years later. And prior to Anthonette's kidnapping, it really doesn't sound like things were that traumatic with her mom and sisters. Her mom partied and they lived in poverty, but there didn't seem to be anything particularly abusive happening (Sadie and her sister can correct me if I'm wrong).
Ofcourse it wasn't. You think they'd find the truth on a show? Everyone who watches these type of shows know they're cut and edited to grab attention. Very interesting though.
@AresW.89 To be fair, these guys have done far more for this case than anyone else has. My opinion is it was essentially a case of human trafficking, and if she's still alive, she's probably in Mexico somewhere.
@@rebeccacloud4023 i guess. I think most just use the names because of it's a big mystery. Im big in astronomy and idk how long people will keep making things saying "are aliens real" literally will be an hour of everything but the answer till the end. Personally i think shes dead.
Dang the suspense killed me in this one. I knew within the 1st 10 minutes it wouldn’t be her but I held out hope. There’s no reason this case to still be such a mystery other than basic neglect in the original investigation. So heartbreaking
Exactly the comment I was looking for. People think they're related and when the truth come out they're really not. They would need to compare DNA with missing girl in this I think. She REALLY looks like the missing girl way too much. Why would her social been issued right before Anthonette went missing? Things don't add up
@@allyouneedisgodandjesusyes! The nefarious things and the trafficking that's been done since the 70s, the adoption rings, just ALL of it that goes on anymore.... She may have been placed with THEIR family until she was sent elsewhere, for whatever reason.
Crystal I’m glad I stumbled across this RU-vid show. You and the detective are so real I feel your sincerity. God bless both of you your work is amazing!!!!!
This woman looks similar to Anthonette, but the eyes are different, so I didn’t think it was going to be her. The woman in the picture in the end next to the photo of Anthonette’s mom, Penny, though… wow… the bone structure looks so much the same to me… and a lot more like Anthonette to me… I can’t wait to see the episode. I hope you find her. I respect the work you’re doing on this case, Crystal, Sadie, and team. Prayers for Anthonette’s safe return and for her and her family’s healing. 🙏 🙏 🙏
It is so sad that in the 80s and even 90s law enforcement had this case, had confessions and persons likely involved and NOTHING was done! We know currently native women are missing and gone at an alarming rate and I don’t know if Anthonette is native (I’m assuming) but either way she wasn’t ever even given a chance of being found when she went missing EVER!
1) how do you know Anthonette is Penny’s biological child? 2) an ear print would be a great way to match the woman to Anthonette’s picture, ears never change.
Crystal, I had no knowledge of you until I stumbled about your series about Anthonette. I was familiar woth her case because she disappeared the year i was born. You are such a wonderful human being for trying to bring Sadie closure. This has always been one of the ones I want solved. I was wondering because you asked Sadie if the 911 call could be Anthonette, but did anyone recognize the womans voice that told her who said you could use the phone?
I was watching a video on Johnny Gosch and I heard the name Emilio. apparently one of the men involved was named "Emilio". Johnny was abducted 4 years before Anthonette. I wonder if there's a connection
I just stumbled into your RU-vid channel and got hooked! What I had seen for some time now is that families are looking for help thru Psychic Detectives as they have been able to solve cold cases! I may sound crazy for the suggestion, but at the end whatever works should be use! I am truly hoping they find the girl, blessings your way🙏💖
Just found your channel today when this video showed up in my feed. I always look back to the oldest video on channels I visit bc I like to see the journey from the beginning when it's worth watching. It's crystal clear (no pun intended 🤭) that God has placed you on this path for a reason. What a wonderful gift it is to be called upon & to be in a position to use it accordingly. This case is so heartbreaking beginning with the 911 call & resulting in seeing her sister so upset afer the DNA results. Praying for peace & answers for them all.🕊
People like inserting themselves into cases, unfortunately. Out of boredom, or to feel belonging. I don't think I could ever do that unless I was 99% sure.
I think people with holes in their past, who have blocked out most of their childhoods due to trauma, or people who’s parents aren’t really their parents and the stories don’t make sense, should absolutely search websites like Charley project to see if a missing child could be them. We might have a million “no” results, but we might get one. We might find someone alive that way.
I don’t think that’s why she did it. She resembled Antoinette and I think she wanted answers to her past. But there are a lot of people that do it for attention seeking.
I don’t believe she did this out of meanest. I think she is a child that’s grown and looking for her family to. Heartbreaking. May they find everything they need. Thank you. Blessings Be.
I actually question if Anthonette was even blood related. Hence why the mother so easily let her go and then regretted. Maybe took in the daughter of a woman who was murdered (example) Claimed home birth or something, her birth certificate needs to be found.
I think the girls are half sisters. But there are some men who don’t acknowledge children by a mother they don’t love and then are amazing fathers to wives they love. So it’s possible I think that maybe the mom had bad beef with Antionette’s father and not the other daughter’s fathers? The father does need to be located.
Did she say she might have coffee breath? I'm a search angel and am quite familiar with dna tests. If you put anything in your mouth for example , toothpaste , gum, coffee, dentures for an hour prior to taking the test the test will come back inconclusive.
Honestly, they don't look at all like sisters. I agree with the comment before that is very possible that they were never related at all. Anthonette was an older sibling to this woman, so she has no memory of how her sister came to live in that home with her family. Someone should help Michelle find her past. It's possible she was a STEP sibling, and they just were not told and were to young to know. So many things could explain her being the missing girl and still not matching DNA.
I am so glad I found your channel today. I do not get how this channel do not have way more subscribers and likes. Thank you for raising awareness for this case. #AnthonetteCayedito #JusticeforAnthonetteCayedito #MissingPersons #missing #abducted #vanished
Chances are that she might be Anthonette and the reason that she went missing could be that she was never the biological child of penny in the first place but landed up in the household where Sadie them were and was kept there too as if she was penny's child. That's why she was passed on to other households.
Oh my Lord in Heaven. Help this family and other families I was young when this happened. Please help these find their families members Thank you. Blessings Be
When I first heard that I did not believe that. I even defended her. Even now, if the daughters are saying that, I might believe it. But initially these were posts by random people on the internet, so I wasn’t believing it. I’ll be watching part 1 and 2.
Did little Antoinette never see a dentist? Maybe there’s dental records for her that could be used to double check other claims? I’m asking because some of the comments below suggest Antoinette may have been adopted by Michelle’s mother as a baby? Or that someone may have gotten a bone marrow transplant
I’m starting to think maybe they never were biological sisters. What the mother was just raising the girls as sisters and them someone took the one girl back.
Ms Anthonette is on my mind when I drive in that part of Gallup. The apartments are still there, still looks the same. That was heartbreaking there was not a match and the search continues. Will the person Michelle mentioned be investigated? If she did indeed end up in Albuquerque, I doubt she was ever put in a public school. So if she’s didn’t have any formal education after the age of 9, what type of jobs would she have held? If any. I shudder to think what her captors made her do to bring in money. Somebody knows what happened to her, and it’s not just one person, maybe a whole family. I pray with Sadie, some day she’ll find her sister. If Anthonette has children, perhaps a dna match could be made through them too. Some day. 🙏🏼 ❤️
Michelle's concerns may very well be rooted in true information. Many lab tests have returned inaccurate results in the past when running "sibling DNA" tests. This is widely known within Ancestry/Genetic Genealogy circles that generally those tests are accurate for parent/child matches but that the accuracy goes down for siblings and it is even lower accuracy for half-siblings. Michelle and Sadie should both also take consumer DNA tests through AncestryDNA and 23andMe. It is possible they share a relative such as a grandparent, great-grandparent, or farther connection. This is something that a "sibling DNA test" cannot tell them but a consumer autosomal DNA test can tell them. I look the spitting image of my 2x great grandmother despite looking nothing like any of my siblings. They could very well be related even if not as full siblings. Even if no distant cousin relationship is found between them, Michelle could use the results with the help of a DNA Search Angel to help her identify her biological family. Sadie would also have her DNA in those databases in case her sister or her sister's children or sister's grandchildren ever test.
Im wondering if she got a bone marrow transplant or blood transfusions because her original DNA won't show but her donor's will. Just interesting, because she stated she had cancer.
I mean, she looks just like her!! Is there any chance that maybe the father wasn’t her father? Or maybe the none of the kids are who they say they are with the parents? Are the parents never have an affair or have something going on that they were not honest about where this young girl came from? The resemblance to me, and the connection is so much stronger than the DNA. I would question it. I really really would.
@@krystenburkhardt-hansyn9655 first thank you so much for your support and inquiry. Second: yes, we looked into more of Michelle’s story, despite the DNA test results. There are several reasons we do not believe she is Anthoinette. Also, we do know that Sadie and Anthonette are in fact blood relatives. There are other family members that have confirmed that with Sadie. Again, thank you for watching. Every view helps spread her story…we hope that will turn into tips. 😊
@angelawaterhouse4323 I don't know, I grew up my best yrs in traumas and I remember even from a toddler, the things I blocked out came back to me just by other traumas
Im in on minute 24:00 and my heart saids it's her ❤🥹 She looks so so much like in her child picture. The voice of her 911 call also resembles her voice now as an adult. Obviously it's different but it has the same tonalities in her vocals. ❤ I say it is her. Let see......
