Arrowverse Fans Choose The WORST Mistakes That The Arrowverse EVER Made! Is This Top 10 Correct!? 

Making Oliver and Felicity a cannon couple and killing Laurel

The biggest mistake was caving to Tumblr shippers and forcing Olicity upon us. It was all downhill from there, slowly but surely.

The biggest mistake was killing off Oliver in the first episode of Crisis only to have him return as some CGI beam shooting from his face guy. He should have been the Paragon of Humanity instead of Ryan Choi (another dumbass decision to add a new last minute character for such an important role instead of focusing on already established characters), so Oliver would represent humanity by fighting without superpowers, only bow and ARROWs and he dies fighting the Antimonitor at the dawn of time. That's how he should have gone out. Not just fighting some ghosts trying to save a universe that ended up being erased anyway.

I think the number one biggest mistake was dedicating so much of Arrow’s final season to another show. It was the founding father of the Arrowverse and to use the last season as a springboard instead of a proper send off was an insult to the cast, crew, and fans

A missed opportunity, Barry meeting the living Gideon from Legends.

They rushed to make a Yara Flor Wonder Girl show way too soon. When they announced the show, the character was just announced and didn’t even appear in a single page of a comic book yet. They were literally working with nothing.

Making Eric Wallace show runner of the flash was one of the worst decisions they’ve ever made. The only good season he made was season 6, after that he should’ve been fired or demoted, especially after season 7

Firing Ralph actor was Flashes biggest mistake! Giving Sara a permanent girlfriend and making her a regular on the show was one of Legends biggest mistakes, and stepping away from adding actual super heroes in Legends later seasons was a mistake as well.

I hated when they revealed Oliver’s identity as green arrow. Like the FBI chick was portraying him as a bad guy but like, he saved the world from an alien invasion, Nazi invasion, other awesome things, and they still wanted to arrest him!? To me the show runners did it just to put him in prison and that whole scenario. But you could have just sent him there for some reason that involved him being the mayor. And that FBI chick lost her job and sh!t the next season. That whole storyline made no sense to me whatsoever.

No particular order 1. Killing off Lauren (I agree that I like the "new" character but I wish that E1 Laurel left the show alive.) 2. Firing Ralph Dibney 3."killing" off Caitlin/ Kion in general 4. The flash changing Showrunners 5. Politicizing Supergirl 6. Dropping the superhero aspect of the characters in Legends. 7. Breaking up Kara and Mon- El 8. Not making Cobalt Blue's villain motivation the fact that Barry made his "sacrifice" meaningless. 9. Red Death in general 10. Flash defeating villains "with the power of friendship" (talking villians down)

Legends didn't end on its own accord Pagey, they were expecting a renewal that never came, same with Batwoman.

Not having Barry stay with Patty so that they could actually commit to killing his girlfriend in season 3 with Savitar. Not having Laurel be in Central city when the particle excelirator goes off so she could get her canary cry. Making Caitlin and Frost actually two different people like the Hulk was dumb. Cisco getting rid of his powers just to continue to go into the field with tech that simulates them. Not having Harry Wells and Jesse Wells death more of a big deal. I’m pretty sure only Cisco brought it up during an argument with Nash. In all honesty, keeping Nash over those two was a bigger mistake. Speaking of people who came back, Oliver really a h*e to Quentin and Sara considering he brought back his mom but chose earth 2 Laurel over our Laurel. To be fair though, I’m pretty sure they did that with the mindset that they were still making the spin-off show.

The fact that the 3 filler episodes of the flash s9 are so forgettable he thought s9 was 10 episodes not 13 speaks how bad they were

Not necessarily putting the blame squarely on DC's shoulders, but definitely WB has been screwing over Green Lantern fans for a decade. They did a massive disservice to the fans who were looking forward to Diggle becoming Green Lantern, and even if his decision not to take on the ring made sense to the character, it was a complete and total cop out. The two main arguments for not having Green Lantern on the show were a)we're saving him for a movie (really, WB? Saving him for what? Certainly not Justice League....prats) b) we can't handle the CG cost it would take to bring GL to the small screen. Well, looking at the amount of CG that was put into those avatars of speed in the 8th and 9th season....the plotline NO actual Flash fan ever asked for....I again have to call BS. WB seems to think their fans are complete idiots, in that the fans can't distinguish between two different Batmen (one on the big screen, one on the small screen) or different Supermen, or two different GL's. One thing that the Arrowverse had going for it was the demand for inclusion.....and I'm sorry but the Lanterns were ALL about inclusion. You had a wealth of different characters you could have brought to the table....Simon Baz, Kyle Rayner, Jessica Cruz, Alan Scott.....and you absolutely blew it on characters that no one was begging for. Really? Chillblaine? Bite me, WB.

I agree about Laurel. The way she was killed and the reason she was killed was not acceptable... but the Black Siren version of the character was a lot more entertaining to watch, and I think her new Black Canary in Season 8 is my favourite Black Canary portrayal for the run of the show. So yes, it's a mistake, but a mistake that gave rise to something better.

It would've been nice if Legends could have more tertiary characters from DC comics, I mean that was the big draw, but we didn't get Booster Gold until the very End!

Biggest miscasting i've ever seen was the guy who played Hawkman.

Frosts death was so anticlimactic

I will never forgive Arrow writers for killing Laurel in Arrow S4 for no reason, and then shoving Olicity down our throats, after its disastrous execution in S4. The series never truly recovered after that. S5 and S8 were decent though (as there was little to no Olicity) but they would have been better if they stopped pandering to Olicity shippers after S4.

At some point, Wally West should've been made the new protagonist of the Flash TV show to change things up e.g Wally not having a scientific background.

I always thought one of the biggest missed opportunities was not to do a soft reboot with these shows after Crisis. They could have brought something new and make big changes but the shows stayed pretty much the same. Superman and Lois was the only one that decided to make something very different to what had been established before with these characters before they decided to keep it in a different universe.

The black Canary kill was the worst, but for the reason of at the time there was consideration for a Black Canary movie rumors in the dceu that preceeded this, similar to how they had to kill of the suicide squad use the season prior

2 things 1. Batwoman should have been introduced as a series before elseworlds and 2. The Arrowverse in its entirety should have ended with Crisis considering aside from guest appearances we never got real crossover afterwords anyway

Having Cicile on the Flash is the biggest mistake on Arrowverse. #6 The best part of Arrowverse was their teams. But the way Tom Cavanagh and Carlos Valdes left did hurt the show, but not as much as Jessie Martin leaving in the last season. It felt as if the team was dismantled just because there was no Joe and we were stuck with a villain bigger than Reverse Flash a.k.a. Cicile Horten. 11:33 THEY CANCELLED LEGENDS and I can never forgive CW for that. We will never know if Team Legends was ever rescued from the time prison. 14:35 They could have mentioned in one line that Barry had to travel to a time prison to save the legends because he got an SOS from them or something.

Olicity should've broke up and have Oliver end up with Laurel

Flash’s final season didn’t answer the questions of how and why Batwoman was missing during the Red Death arc and how the blue crystal was created for the Cobalt Blue arc.

Definitely agree! With the exception of 2 episodes, Flash’s final season was a COMPLETE MISSFIRE!!!

The only way I see they could continue with GA and the canaries is through comic books. Didn’t care for Batwoman, imo it was a terrible show, I was disappointed with Legends cancellation, it should’ve had one more season. Also, preferred Laurel and Oliver’s relationship over Felicity.

I loved legends because how chaotic it was same with doom patrol

I agree they dropped the ball with GL ark for Diggle very disappointed

I liked Oliver and Felicity’s relationship for the most part. The ARROWVERSE’s BIGGEST MISTAKE WAS CANCELING LEGENDS!!! LEGENDS DESERVED A FINAL SEASON!!!!!

The Arrowverse slowly started going downhill as soon as it became the Arrowverse IMO. Arrow could’ve easily and should’ve IMO just stayed as it’s own self contained thing, same with the other shows. I’m glad they kept Superman and Lois out of the Arrowverse. And butchering Laurel’s character was a total misfire just to push up Felicity from side character who shows up every now and then to becoming a main character. Black Canary’s a really cool character, she should’ve gotten more attention. I’m not necessarily saying Ollie and Laurel should’ve been endgame though I would’ve loved that, just that her character was screwed over in general, even just to bring her back as a variant or I think doppelgänger was the Arrowverse term. Characters like Martian Manhunter who in Arrowverse canon, even Superman himself said is the most powerful being on Earth, even he to a degree would be scared to have to fight J’onn, were way underused though I do fully understand that J’onn could’ve eventually risked becoming a Deus Ex Machina, even risking overshadowing Supergirl on her own series though I personally wouldn’t have cared that much because I’ve always loved the character since the justice league cartoon (mainly because he’s green, my favourite colour). One last thing, I get this was probably a rights issue but that’s not really an excuse because they had a Bruce Wayne actor in Batwoman and even another one through the multiverse. They had the whole thing with Hush stealing Bruce’s identity, that should’ve been reason enough for Batman to come back with a vengeance if he was still alive, was it ever even confirmed what happened to him? Again I get that having Batman in the series would’ve inevitably overshadowed Batwoman in her own series but the show could’ve certainly benefited from the inevitable rise in viewership even just for those one or two Batman episodes, the positives would’ve outweighed the negatives.

Hated Olicity, but they seriously couldn't write Black Canary (they had a great actor, but They just couldn't write her good stuff).

I seriously loved Black Lightning but I was so excited for Painkiller, in the backdoor they made it so distinct from everything that came before. Loved it!

Batwoman's series ending with the zombie (maybe Dr. Phosphorus or Scarecrow or whoever it was) is definitely a cliffhanger. But I think they hedged their bets on a "maybe one more season" possibility like Pennyworth did; and they ended up not getting that. IMO these DC TV cliffhangers could easily be resolved in an another tie-in comic run like Earth-Prime. That JJ/William one still infuriates me, especially.

A mistake with Legends was making it about Time Travel; like right off the bat. I mean, the entire series was clearly just slapped together in an effort to take all of the ancillary characters from Flash and Arrow that the writers wanted to keep playing with, but didn't have room on those two shows and give them their own forum; yet they had no idea what to do with them. Case in point is the fact that the so-called "pilot" that sold the series was just a demo and then _none_ of that material actually ended up in the first episode (or I think _any_ episode). They very easily (and I would argue, more to the show's benefit) done the series as a take on "Justice League Dark" and instead of a time machine/space ship, make their base the House of Mysteries. Instead of Arthur Darville playing Rip Hunter, make him the Arrowverse's John Constantine. Nothing against Ryan, but Arthur would have played that part well. Maybe that would have kept him around, as it was disappointing to see him depart. As Constantine, he could have tricked the other main characters into accepting an invitation into the house of mysteries, which ensnares them in a curse where they become bound to the House in a mystical sense (not trapped inside it, but like, indentured to it). It can travel the world or even through time if they really still wanted to. Within the show's actual premise, I think it was a mistake ignoring Mick's time as Chronus. I thought that was one of the more brilliant twists of the first season; and they could have given his character a lot of growth, because it would have provided him a lot of accidental intelligence. Here's this goon who just like stealing and setting stuff on fire and he's given the knowledge about physics and time travel centuries ahead of anyone else, besides Rip. But that was kind of the larger problem for Legends, in my opinion, which was that it kind of relied on the main characters needing to be stupid in order for the plot to work. I mean, look what they did to Ray, for crying out loud. He became a caricature of the character introduced on Arrow. After they established that Gideon could get into the crews' head, I always thought it would have been interesting to find out that that Gideon, unlike the one from The Flash, was malevolent; and was actually manipulating the Legends the whole time, decreasing their intelligence to make them more complaint; and sending them on missions across time in order to manipulate history the way it wanted time to unfold.

Both legends and batwoman were on their last legs anyways before being canceled. The writers of legends were warned about the show possibility of being canceled

No thanks to WB, they did john constantine dirty in season 6. Flash tv show change their direction multiple times. Eddie and Iris relationship were too bland. Killed off laurel

Genuinely surprised that since Olicity made it on this list, West Allen wasn't..once those two got together that was litterally when Barry couldn't do shit for himself.

Doppleganger theory. I love the multiverse and multiple flashes showing up. But saying doppleganger theory and then back tracking to try to explain it works with Jay Garrick the FIRST TIME. But the moment Ezra shows up, 90s flash, etc. same for Superman in crisis. The word “doppleganger” never should have been said.

For me for the flash it felt like at some point they stopped focusing on Barry Allen and started focusing on the side characters far more than what they should have

The Flash not ending with Wally West taking the mantle for Barry or Wally just not being The Flash for abit before bringing Barry back in S4.

With Olicity, it was really more of the chase that got me involved. I liked seeing the nerdy girl fall for the rich and broody hero.

1. Olicity 2. Flash's dumb lightning sword 3. Dumbing down villains into freaks of the week 4. Evil Batman Kevin Conroy 5. Pushing non-comic characters on BL and LoT 6. No Justice League show after COIE. 7. Replacing Kate with Walder. 8. No Rogues 9. Arrow no longer noirish 10. Too many supporting characters.

Too many team members on the heavy hitter shows, especially flash. Also big villains from the comics like Brick, Komodo, count vertigo, etc were very underused. Those are my main ones

I agree with Laurel. Her death was stupid, but the earth 2 version is much better.

letting legends end on a cliffhanger will always be a big mistake to me. it was such a mess of a show but it was fun and it felt like there was genuine heart behind it, and i wish we could’ve got a satisfying ending

Not the biggest mistake but definitely one of the weirdest things in MY opinion was the fact that they made Barry and Iris adoptive siblings when they were the endgame pair. Like, why? What reasoning went there for this to be a logical conclusion??

Batwoman's existence at all .. was just unnecessary

From a comic book stand point, killing off Laurel (Black Canary) was the WORST thing they could’ve done. Green Arrow and Black Canary are one of the iconic DC couples. They even have their own comic run.

4:49 I noticed this GREATLY after Crisis. It made season 5 hard to push through and I couldnt even finish S6, tbh. A big shame because I really liked Seasons 1-4.

One of the worst mistakes they made was what they did to Batwoman from season 2 on they should have recast Kate Kane and continued with the original character the racist nightmare that the rest of the show became was horrifying

Number 1 has to be letting Eric Wallace right the Flash

Setting up Barry and iris as siblings

1)Batwoman having her own show 2)No Batman 3)Oliver and Felicity being a permanent thing 4)Getting rid of the original Laurel 5)Having two different black canaries 6)Diggle not becoming the green lantern 7)A second Batwoman 8)The last 3 seasons of the flash as a whole 9)Separating Superman & Louis from the rest of the shows. 10)No impulse on the flash finale.

I agree with merging Supergirl's with the rest of the Arrowverse sooner would have been better. That wouldn't have need to be a full on Crisis on Infinite Earths type crossover; it could have been a precursor, teasing out the eventual outcome or any number of ways to do it. An Earth 1 with no Superman or Supergirl seemed incomplete.

Let’s not forget how the kept replacing actual superheroes in Legends in the later seasons

Hey pagey I wish that the Reverse flash was the final villain of the flash season 9❤

I hated that it was always Supergirl going to earth 1 for the crossovers. I understand why, there's more characters there, and it's easier to have 1-3 characters go to one earth rather than 20 to another, but I felt like they didn't even try. Even for one-off crossovers like how felicity was always on the flash. That's why I was so excited when they were there for crisis, but it just wasn't enough. I also hate that they've put Superman on an earth of his own. What was the point in setting him up as Supergirl and earth primes Superman just to not do anything with it. Also, that Diggle crossover just confuses me, how do they know each other if there's no Arrow, Flash, or Supergirl on his earth?

I think the ending of StarGirl was heartbreaking and one of the worst things to happen on the cw!!!!

Legends getting cancelled And making Superman and Lois another Earth.

Totally agree about John Diggle/Lantern. Don't wind us up and not pay off, that's just lazy writing!

Good old bam smack pow 😂😂

10. I always thought that Flashpoint would merge "Supergirl-verse", but then CW butchered Flashpoint. Can't say that Black Lightning was merged too late since it was still a young show when Crisis happened. 9. I'm actually glad they didn't go with those spin-offs. Green Arrow & the Canaries had their backdoor pilot in Arrow season 8 and it didn't gove much hope as much as I love Katherine McNamara's Mia Queen. First time heard abput "Wonder Girl" project, though. 8. Supergirl never had a drop in quality. It was always bad. 7. Flash was a total misfire since start of Season 3. It went downhill in quality and writing and everything from there. The finale was the worst final arc/episode of any tv show I've ever seen. 6. Too much reliance on teams was not a problem. Everyone in the team being a superhero was a problem. I mean seriously, who needed Alex Danvers as a superhero? Or worse example, Cecile Horton, who needed Iris's stepmother to become "Virtue"? Cecile is a forgettable comic character and they made her powerful enough to defeat Godspeed by herself. The same dude whose defeat required every speedster (even goddamn Iris) to participate, was defeated by a lady who could read minds... Is the actress playing Cecile, a wife of one of the producers? 5. Yeah, dropping "Diggle Lantern" was a mistake. 4. Can't say much about that. Legends ran for I believe 7 seasons, even though it stopped being good after season 3. Or Supergirl stopped being good after the pilot. So yeah, some shows ran for too long. 3. Yeah, Olicity sucked. 2. Do not agree. Batwoman was awful from the start. It's a miracle it wasn't cancelled after 1st season when Ruby Rose left. Legends, well at some point it was my favourite Arrowverse show, but season 4 started dropping it's comedy and quality rapidly. And when it was cancelled, was long after I stopped watching and I actually didn't care for it. 1. 100% agree. Oliver and Laurel from the pilot is the type of relationship the audience is suppose to cheer for. Yeah, they had to "Ross and Rachel" them with the "will they, won't they", but I always thought that they would stay true to comic book at least with "Arrow & Canary" romance. Yet, they pushed Olicity so obsessively that they decided to kill off main female character. And by the lamest villain of the show. (Damien Darrk became interesting when he joined cast of Legends) Worst mistake they did.

I have a feeling we almost had a Vixen show, the character was been prepared, but they choose Supergirl instead, this is why Megalyn never returned. Ps: Legends and Batwoman deserved more seasons

Making iris team captain in s4 was a big mistake. She become so annoying and hardly had any proper development afterwards. I had no problem with olicity. From season 5 to season 7 (when they were married) they were written consistent and better than barry-iris.

Hmmm I genuinely haven't watched any Arrowverse episodes in a long time so I don't have that many fresh opinions about the list although I do agree on some of these but disagree on others. If I had to make a list of my own, this would be it(This list is not necesseary very realistic) 1. The way the seasons are structured(except for Legends) What I mean is that I feel the seasons of each show used their long seasons in very uncreative ways, like I do like filler but atleast I would like if the filler were creative and had some sort of purpose, like if you have so many episodes take advantage of that and expand the story with maybe more character drama or story that not only builds up to the finale but serves purpose through out the seasons. But since I feel like they couldn't do that, I feel like a shorter season would work better. 2. Ending The Flash It had to end at some point but come one! There were many ideas left to explore, the characters and story weren't in the right place for the show to end, Eric wanted to adapt more big stories in the future which made the final season so unsatifying because it never were intended to be the final season. 3. Not adding Comic Heroes/anti heroes to Legends of Tommorrow I remember the days of wishlist videos of which character to add to the team, Zatanna were one of the most wanted/requested characters I think, a lot of people(including me) were really interested to potentially see Dr.Fate. I feel like the earlier seasons nailed the feeling that I liked the series for, of course I love the goofy but have the goofy with more known comic characters and magic or cosmic powers. I feel the same about villains. Legends of Tommorrow was the show with most potential, while I love it I wish there were different characters that were introduced. 4. Not adding Wally West to the Legends I don't know how it was behind the scenes, if Keiynan didn't want or want to appear more or just couldn't. I just think Wally were a very fitting and fun part of the show, I think story wise the way to go would have him be a series regular. Plus it would have added more power to the team. 5. Removing Hartley Sawyer and not recasting Ralph The things he used to say were never okay, far from okay but as a trans person I question the firing, did he actually hold those same views? From what I know, no. He had already adressed his past and aplogised and said he don't thinks so anymore, if were gonna fire people for a transphobic past, let's apply it to Candice Patton who also said some nasty stuff about trans people. Ralph were one of my favorite Arrowverse characters and Hartley were one of my favorite cast members(based on performance). I guess there are some more but I feel like these 5 are the things I genuinely think:)

The creators of the Flash were hoping to get a few more seasons. That's why the last season is kinda rushed.

The Flash never changing up the formula, it needed a shake up and never got it, they stuck with STAR Labs at least three seasons too long. Sidelining Laurel, I'm not talking about killing her off, I'm talking about from the start, Laurel should've had her own personal "island" from the start, got her own training in those five years (like they almost sort of teased) and all that, then when the HIVE story came about you could've had her taken and come back with her powers, crazy to me they didn't bother exploring her mother's past which could've given Katie more to do. And yeah, Caity Lotz coming in as Sarah kinda stole Katie's thunder on the Canary front since Caity could do all the stuff Laurel/Black Canary should be able to do and then you had shippers (and the writers) with the hots for Felicity. Laurel was left in a state of nothing to do but the way they killed her off and the way Guggenheim handled it was really shitty and the backlash is why Katie got brought back. Making Supergirl too much of a Superman clone instead of someone traumatized by watching her home explode and everyone she loved dying. Then they also pretty much made the show the exact thing SNL had made fun of like a week prior to the first trailer dropping in their "Black Widow" parody trailer. Go watch it and then watch the first trailer for Supergirl... yikes. My personal standout moment from the show was the first season episode with Red Tornado and she lets out her rage through her heat vision and the way Melissa sold it, she deserved better than what the show's creative delivered. Batwoman's troubles started with show runner ego and stunt casting Kate with Ruby Rose instead of someone a better fit for the role, or even a favorite in Wallis Day who they ended up using to recast Kate anyway. Never mind the apparent incompetence on the set by the people in charge of safety with all the problems with accidents and people getting seriously hurt. The show was a mess in ways the others weren't.

I agree with number 6. I'm okay with teams with arrow but flash and supergirl doesn't need a team.

This should be interesting.

Hey pagey the episode that you are talking about is the flash season 9 episode 10

Not connecting reverse flash past to Legend of tomorrow s1 storyline with Vandal Savage or simply not dive into Eobard past. At the time Vandal conquerered, Eobard should've been around 16 years old. vandal conquest could've been a great show

Very cool video 😎

Legends being canceled is their biggest mistake

Worst mistakes are the same with most tv shows or movies which are plot errors and unanswered questions Now I havent read it yet but apparently in the earth prime comics which are canon to the arrowverse apparently its explained what happened to the legends after season 7 so read for yourself and see if that is the case cause i just heard that from someone who supposedly read it.

They Actually Were Gonna Do 1 Last Season But The Flash Movie Was Comin Out They Didn’t Wanna To Much Attention Off The Movie Bc WE All Know Grants The Better Flash

But my personal opinions on the list- 10.I dont exactly agree on that although I will say they needed to be utilized more in mini crossovers 9.Yeah I agree 8.Um for someone who started watching in season 2 I always thought the quality was wishy washy it never really stayed mostly great or mostly bad and I cant respond to production values, I guess people mean the cgi, I dont get upset at that stuff like alot of people, to me there is no good or bad cgi. 7.It was a mixed bag, it certainly wasnt a great season but there were a handful or two of cool moments and as mediocre as it was overall it was still better than the movie version. 6.I did complain about teams in the past on other comment boards but tbh when you have like 10, 15, 22 episodes you sort of need teams to balance it out cause focusing on one hero mainly can get boring. My whole issue is sometimes the titular character couldnt beat their own big bad let alone a criminal of the week,the team should be to help out the main hero not win the battle instead of them. The flash show was particularly the worst at that and if they called the show team flash it be different and would make sense the team get to win alot more than just barry. 5.Yeah and it was insulting considering diggle had like an arc where he appeared on idk if it was all the arrowverse shows but alot of them and they didnt really lead to anything in the grand plan and he never became the gl, I would say it was probably saved for that justice U show that never happened but then we hear justice U took place like either on its own world or superman and lois world I forget so its not using the same diggle from the main arrowverse. 4.Yeah I agree on that it just became repetition and mostly just wasting money and time after a while. And the worst part of it is when a show does go on for a zillion seasons, it ends and there is still big questions unanswered. 3.Im indifferent to olicity I dont love or hate it. 2.I havent seen batwoman yet but the legends tomorrow thing Im only slightly irritated we didnt get closure, again there supposedly exists closure in the earth prime comic but I was getting tired of the show by s7 anyway, I felt that too ran its course. 1.Im also indifferent to that especially that we got another version, what I found more odd is in the arrow series finale oliver uses his spectre power to bring back quentin, his mom, tommy but he dont bring laurel back and even quentin tells laurel 2 that is fine with him so I found that bizzare.

Happy to see Olicity in the top 3 mistakes. 100% agree. I don't agree with it backing them in a corner. They could have made Felicity "the person in the grave" when they teased someone from the Arrowverse dying. I like Felicity, I like Emily, but killing off Felicity instead of Laurel would have been much better over all.

With #4 I feel like if the seasons would’ve been like 6 episodes shorter then the amount of seasons would’ve been fine

Killer frost being evil cause the plot says so and then killing the black flash with a simple ice blast when eobard thawne, who worked with captain cold , was running from the black flash and didnt kil him when making a whole other reality cause he probably cant die but killer frost just boops him with a blast lol . They had no idea what to do with killer frost in season 3 and it was a harbinger of worse things lol

I'm rewatching season 1 &2 of the flash and another huge mistake was killing Henry Allen towards end of season 2. They should have kept him alive & had him marry Dr Magee!! They also should have made Wally kid flash & Caitlin Frost in season 2 rather then Barry making flashpoint & then they became kid flash & frost. Barry had just come to terms w/ his mom dying then they kill his dad! Terrible idea. Flashpoint story line was the beginning of the end for me really watching the flash. I forgot how much I didn't like about the decisions made at end of season 2

Agreed on #10 kinda, like I think Crisis was the perfect way & time to do it, but it sucked cause all the shows ended basically immediately after

I never personally cared about Batwoman or the later seasons of Legends . Laurel dying was stupid to just bring in the earth 2 variant . I hated how annoying the made Felicity for that whole relationship on screen . I thought how they did the multiverse was stupid and crisis on infinite earths was a waste of time . Diggle should’ve became the green lantern in the end . I think those are the points I cared about here anyways .

Which individual decisions were the worst are up for debate, but overall the writing really just fell off a cliff for every show after the first few seasons of Flash. There were maybe a few good episodes of shows here and there, but the early season of arrow and flash were what really allowed them to expand the universe to all the other shows in the first place, and then everything just got progressively worse from that point on.

Yes #1! I had finally just started actually liking Laurel. Tbh I hated Earth2 Laurel

In terms of the shows longevity, Arrow and Flash "ran too long" after their respective season 2. Although that's maybe disingenuous to the extent that, the later seasons would have been fine if the writing hadn't taken a dive; but maybe that's the same thing. If the writing standards can't be maintained, has a show run out of steam or run its course? On the other hand, there's arguably no reason either show should have taken the dip in quality it did; and I think that's the thing that's most frustrating. I remember, it was maybe during Flash season 6 or 7 or something, catching a random clip on youtube from Flash season 1, which was the first time seeing stuff from the first season in a long time; and it caught me off guard, because I had gotten used to what The Flash had become and I was like, "oh yeah, holy shit, this show was _so good._ What the hell happen?" And I think it's the to the same point with the Supergirl quality issue. I'd maybe question whether the actual production value of things like sets or effects was significantly different, but the writing wasn't great - but I'd also argue that the writing for Supergirl wasn't great in season 1 either. There's a reason CBS didn't keep it going; why they did a Hail Mary bringing the Flash on towards the end of the first season; and did a soft fold of it into the Arrowverse for season 2. It was already on par with the direction of the writing for the other Arrowverse shows; and was under the same overarching creative direction. The same thing can be said about Legends. I did not have high expectations for Arrow going into the first episode after 10 years of Smallville (at least 5 of which left me a bit disillusioned). Yet, it did win me over right out of the gate. Then they made The Flash work. But something happened not long after that, where the stories just weren't as compelling. It was like they were resting on their laurels. They overused certain villains and plot premises. They over-relied on the serial arc, to the point where they knew immediately who the season big bad was going to be and spent 7-8 months treading water, in order to have the final showdown in the season finale; and the failure to stop them in the interim just made the characters look incompetent. They needed better pacing, and they desperately needed the benefit of more one-off, stand alone episodes that could explore the characters, give them growth and give the season arc a rest. Buffy the Vampire Slay helped popularize the serial format, but Buffy at its best was when it had a blend of serial and episodic episodes. They also leaned too hard into the campiness. You can't avoid it entirely, but you have to be careful or it will consume the narrative, like it ultimately did with Legends.

The DC universe should’ve bring new Green Arrow and the Canaries & Wonder Girl in Arrowverse

Killing off Laurel Lance not putting Barry with Caitlin instead of boring Iris. Those were mistakes

1. Was the green lantern ark in John diggle and the build-up? Oh wow, what a waste of time. That was all the crossover episodes. The build-up leading to nothing like if you're not going to do something then don't lead up to it and promise it and then don't fulfill and even show the green lantern planet in crisis and then don't do anything about it. It was absolutely a waste of time and I was so angry at it 2. For me and I think most people will agree. The Supergirl finale was just awful. I mean I was expecting so much better but it was just awful for a final episode. There was no climax to it. It was crud. 3. Frosty's boyfriend. He was utterly pointless. I mean what was the point of him? I think they were trying to fulfill an extra team lender with this guy and he was just pointless. I just they were trying to build him up but I just didn't go with it. I was so disappointed by this guy. I wasn't really impressed with him at all even if he did try and bring frost back to life and I know they were doing that story arc but still he was just not good enough

Legends ended on a Cliffhanger😒

The biggest mistake, at least as I see it, was the universe doubling down on representation and diversity to the point even the people who liked that stuff or the people they were representing got sick of it.

Making the crisis event early and didn’t add the characters they should’ve the storyline was a whole mistake the storyline they should’ve have used was the flash 2024 newspaper and ended the show that way the flash season 9 or 10 whatever season they wanted to end it on the first half should’ve been crisis event and second half should’ve been the flash vs reverse flash disappeared scene from the newspaper

The problem is. The seasons were too long. Shows like these are meant to have 13-15 episodes a season. You can’t make 20 hour long episodes each season without drawing out the storyline or getting repetitive

Killing Sara was a mistake. I don't care how it played out with her eventually coming back and the whole "legends" thing. First off, Legends of Tomorrow became such a frickin' joke. That's its own separate entry, of course. But the nailed the live action depiction of Black Canary on the first try... and then they kept trying to improve it. And it did not work. With the first season of Arrow, they punted on their depiction of Dinah by making her "Laurel," with basically no foundation for her eventually become the Black Canary. As it turns out, when tried to give her that story, the writers weren't up to the task; they didn't know what to do with Laurel, so they kill her off, bring on Dinah, don't know what to do with her, bring on another Laurel.... it was a mess. More importantly though, they didn't need to do any of that. Caity killed it. I much preferred her black costume over the "White Canary" look. Like, make her the leader of "Team Arrow," doesn't matter if Ollie's still on the team or that the team is named after him; he was arguably a bad leader, if a good hero and Sara had what it takes to be a good leader, but deserved better than being the leader of the Keystone Time Cops. And while I'd much prefer a comic accurate pairing of Green Arrow and Black Canary (especially since I despised Oliver and Felicity; and frankly never cared for Sara and Ava) I could make my peace with Oliver and Sara not being end game - even if she had the best chemistry with Oliver than anyone else they tried to pair him with.

Combining the Supergirl and Flash universe. Continuity Confusion Crisis.

Savitar should’ve killed Iris. Still the single best moment in the entire shows history up until it’s revealed to be H.R. Wells.

These all apply to the flash Letting Eric Wallace write anything Mixing the flash up with starwars The amount of side characters its not called the cecile or the iris ITS THE FLASH DAMMIT Somehow giving normal speed people the ability to defeat a speedster Overusing tom cavanaghs reverse flash matt should have been alot more involved When carlos valdes left barrys reliance on star labs should have diminished of course Caitlin would still be barrys freind so if she showed up regularly it would make sense but no need for Chester The amount of filler episodes in the final season its already a shortened season ffs not to mention the LAST😮

Honestly Team flash got too big, It was better before it was a team full of metas, vs just flash and some support characters.

Eric Wallace