Barstool Pizza Review - Natoli's Italian Deli (Secaucus, NJ) 

No bites... Everyone forgets the rules.

That’s the kind of guy you want to support. Glad to see everything working out for those people!

He's getting so good, he scores before taking a bite.

Natoli's becomes Natalie's. Everyone's confused by the rules.

Natoli’s is one GREAT spot. Dave is right about them having everything. Form one of the best wings sauces I’ve ever had to a fantastic breakfast. I lived on their food for years. I would even go so far as to bring food back to Albany for the kids. One afternoon traveling for work and staying at the Meadowlands Hotel I ordered a pie, walked over the rt3 foot bridge to pick it up only to realize when I got there I had left my wallet in the hotel room. “Momma” Natoli wouldn’t hear of me walking back to get it and handed me the pie free. You just don’t get that family feeling in many place’s these days. Best wishes to both Natoli’s and Dave and crew, JC.

Dave: try not to get faces Cameraman: records everyone’s face 😂🤣

I love how he just rated a little kid 7.9

One bite, everybody knows these family owned restaurants are the best to watch during the holidays.

The owner was great, genuine guy. I'm pretty sure I had plenty of Natoli's Pizza aka Natalie's when I worked at Alliance Capital.

Should be called 0 bite pizza reviews now lol. 7.9 even before trying it...I'm impressed!

It's crazy how a pizza review can bring back a flood of emotions. My father use to make Pasta Fasul from scratch. It's a name I hadn't heard in a very long time since he passed. Brought back a lot of fond memories. Thank you Dave. :)

Love it when Dave gets a tonne of genuine credit. We all love to mock the guy but he's as good as they come.

You know it's a legit Italian market, when they sell a wide variety of Pannettone holiday cakes. Sadly most of these places are a generation away from disappearing.

A genuine review, everybody knows Dave wants to be a a part of family

"They got everything here".... even Frankie surreptitiously coming here for his pizza (and pasta fasuli).

People hate on NJ but how many spots has dave gone to and absolutely loved? The neighborhood italian spots make NJ great, hate all you want but damn do I miss living there and having multiple great spots like this all within 15 minutes of where you live

While we wait, we hydrate!

Been there the pizza is good, not spectacular, 7.9 is aboot right. The magic of this place is the Italian sandwiches and soups they make fresh every day. One day you go in there they have garlic knots, another day they have home made canolis, great place if you are ever in the area stop by. Good review.

It’s Pasta Faggioli, also know as the Pasta FAZOOL ! Pasta with beans, a traditional southern Italian soup. For-get-about-it 🇮🇹

Zero bites and gives a score... no one knows the rules.

One bite, everybody knows dave likes to say pasta Fasuli. Merry Christmas everyone 🎅 🎄

"Try not to get peoples faces" *Frankie pans around the room with the camera getting every single person's face in the shot*

Great family been family friends with them for my whole life. Real humble people great food and great atmosphere!!

Jersey is one of the last strongholds we have for spots like this, we need the publicity, good review!

With each pronunciation of pasta fagioli Davey gets less Italian cred, everybody knows the rules.

"Your big balls, its refreshing!" mad respect for the boss level respect.

Those neighbourhood spots are iconic

Love this. Love they recognized and respected Pres as he should be.

i lived around the corner from natolis for 17 years and ate there 2 times a week....you wont find nicer people than Steve Natoli and his employees...they do treat you like family....all great people

That place looks awesome! The guy there at the end seems like a genuine, awesome guy as well. Great spot and review.

Yet again, NJ comes through with the nicest people. Based on one bite, friendliest state by far.

Awesome review, awesome people, and awesome looking pizza. That is 100% my style.

Sometimes Dave really surprises me, dude is really about the small businesses. Everyone knows the rules!

Natolis is the spot. Legit as they come 🇮🇹🇮🇹

One thing about folks in N.J. They always keep it real. I know! Born in Paterson and grew up in Fair Lawn. A real bite of America!

You gotta love these genuine, wholesome reviews with good, solid, loving people

Grew up in secaucus me and my brothers all worked for natolis my brother Anthony works there now lol good Friends of the family, Steve and Alex the owners are great I was freaking out when I seen this video my brother Anthony sent it to me

what a nice guy, i wanna be like that store worker, so pure and good hearted! thanks for the vid!

I'm proud to have grown up in New Jersey. Can't beat it!

I haven't seen one of those little mini breadsticks with the sesame seeds on them in 35 years. I used to murder packs of those when I had to go out to Sunday dinner as a kid. Then I'd never have any room for anything else. Breadsticks and kiddie cocktails.

I love the atmosphere it looks like the kind of place you can hang out in all day

What the owner said at the end is the same reason I love Dave …. He’s a beacon of hope in these dark days lol

My uncle comes down from New Hampshire for the fresh mozz and sandwiches. He brings goodies to my cousins on Virginia too. And Steve and Alex do so much for Secaucus. No better place.

Dude got emotional. I love it! He’s right too! That’s why I love Barstool. Keep kicking ass!

Place looks legit and awesome! Growing up Italian and seeing the stuff my early family tells me places like this are the real deal ! Family Growing up not to far from there 💯 makes me proud ❤ may these places stay around for the next generations!!

Wish there were more of these places still around.💜

1:48 message sound and his hand gesture fits perfectly 🤙

Right down the street from my office. Steve is a great guy. Great food there. 🍕

Dave to camera man: “Try not to get any faces.” Cameraman: Pretends he’s 9 feet tall and gets everyone’s face in the video

Take a shot every time he says pasta fizzule 😂😂😂

"Natalie's!!" Clownish --- Natoli's !! Dave is jacked on the snow here!

Steve is a great guy. A staple in Secaucus for years

Dave the patron saint of small businesses!!! Thank you Lord for El Presidente!

what a great spot. They have everything!

Best review in a while. Place looks GREAT! Natoli was my grandmothers maiden name. These people seem too nice to be my family!

There are 2 small Italian bakeries near me that are less of a deli than this but they have the same exact vibe. Great baked goods, Italian candies, coffees and other stuff. Both of them make out of this world Sicilian pizza. It's great to support local businesses like this place, even if you score the pizza before eating it

what a genuine owner, let me tell you if you find me in secaucus ill be at natolis!

One child getting too close to Dave, everyone knows he just violated his parole once again.

Sitting here in Europe watching all your video's; doesn't make any sense; but you got me here!! :-)

Dave keep being humble…. God bless. Class act!!!!

This place is amazing. Go here frequently when I am up at the nearby business park to visit customers. My first thought going in was the same as Dave's. They pack in everything so well.

Good choice. That was my go to spot for lunch when I worked out there. That and IL Forno. IL Forni just isn't the same anymore though.

Dave blocks the entrance, everybody knows the rules.

Natoli's is an awesome neighborhood spot. 💯💯💯 The best pizza/food in Secaucus hands down 💯💯💯 you are always treated like family there......

Love it when he supports family business! Love it

Steve Lisette Alex and family are the nicest/greatest owners of any establishment i have ever been in. I used to do Christmas catering for them 20 years ago. Dave is right plain pizza is usually the last thing I order there. It’s good but they have so many good things on the menu. Most underrated item is the hanger steak salad and grandma slice.

That bread stick was almost as crunchy as the one bite frozen pizzas 🍕

Idk why I enjoy watching these videos so much.

This is first review I have seen I will travel to see it 4 states over

Always think I’m getting more texts than I am when I watch these videos

The spots Dave’s reviewed have only gotten better

Natolis is fire... Came from Western Canada just for Natolis

That last 15 seconds of the owner made me went to go to this place.

Say "pasta fazool" as many times as possible. Everyone knows the rules

Shoutout to the Menendez family!!

Love it! THAT is a family you should always support!!

Gotta be in the top 5 reviews of all time. Top notch content.

Everyone knows that’s a 6.7. Inflated score like the economy.

What does Dave mean when he talks about rooting for Army or the Navy? They play a game against eachother or something?

Great Friggan Review

Really good pasta fasul

Dave ! Are those your dance boots ?! Looks like Gregory Heinse specials !!

Owner seems like a great guy.

I wish I had a spot like this growing up, where u could just get anything u needed and they know you. It's always the best feeling going to a spot where they know and sometimes even go "the normal?"

This spot is so good! I mean, everything is good. Give ‘em a try. You won’t regret it.

The little girl threw off Dave's rehearsed review score without taking a bite. He forgot the order of his rehearsed score. Everyone knows the rules 7.9.

My fridge is making a strange sound. I open it up and there's Dave's head saying I love this Pasta FASOOOOOOL!

absolutely not fair, he scored it before he even took a bite

Ive always wanted to see how the inside looked and this just blew my mind. Just wow

Ate this damn pizza ever Monday for 9 years straight

I want come there from my home in Australia. Thats spot looks amazing.

Fantastic Italian hero sandwiches, great people, great food!!

In my whole life I have never heard anyone say "Pasta Fazool" and now I've heard it 10 times in three minutes. That should see me through.

Good thing he said pasta fazool 12 times in the first 2 mins. I almost forgot what he was eating.

Excellent feel good review... 🙂👍

Those gifts are from my mom’s chocolate shop in Lyndhurst- Chocolate Fantasia. We are from Secaucus

Thanks For the Update!

Guy running that place is a beauty.

did you just score the pie before you tasted the pie?

Love the videos!! Good stuff