Best Hole Saw Brand? DeWalt vs Milwaukee vs Irwin, Bosch, Lenox, Diablo, Bosch, MK Morse

Подписаться 3,2 млн

Просмотров 2,1 млн

50% 1

Best hole saw brand for drilling through mild, medium and hardened metal? Let's find out! Using a twist drill bit might not be the best option for large diameter holes. Why not use a bi-metal or carbide tooth hole saw? Hole saws compared for speed, accuracy of hole size, durability, and price. Brands tested: Diablo, Milwaukee Hole Dozer, MK Morse, Irwin, DeWalt 2x, Dewalt Impact Ready, DeWalt Carbide, Lenox, TCT Carbide, Milwaukee Shockwave, Drill Hog, and Bosch HB100. I bought all of the hole saws tested. No sponsors for free products from manufacturers.
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: www.Project-Farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Diablo Hole Saw: amzn.to/31czGJL
Milwaukee Hole Dozer: amzn.to/34bG1ap
MK Morse: amzn.to/3l1W0xC
Irwin: amzn.to/3l1H0A0
DeWalt 2x: amzn.to/3hcI5m1
Dewalt Impact Ready: amzn.to/326qOF1
DeWalt Carbide: amzn.to/3aR5Y0p
Lenox: amzn.to/3iWVUFE
TCT Carbide: amzn.to/3iUHZ2R
Milwaukee Shockwave: amzn.to/322AxMq
Drill Hog: amzn.to/329BF0K
Bosch HB100: amzn.to/2QabO37
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/31aince
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC

Хобби

Опубликовано:

7 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 6 тыс.

@t-55am2b5 3 года назад

Imagine how credible you are when there's thousands of people coming as early as possible to watch your video. That means that the community loves you, and they sure do have a reason for it. We trust your reviews more than anybody else's

@dagurorarinsson2827 3 года назад

couldn't have said it any better.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much! This feedback means a lot to me!!

@lewiemcneely9143 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm Truth is a rare commodity so your's goes a L O N G way!

@wantapgt 3 года назад

Yessir

@Youtubeforcedmetochangemyname 3 года назад

Indeed

@OldBuford 3 года назад

"were gonna test that" * marketing sweating intensifies *

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for watching.

@MRSketch09 3 года назад

Good ol "marketing dept" trying to earn their keep.. even if it means shooting themselves in the foot.

@jbw5485 3 года назад

Haha I love when he says that. Like he already knows better. It we get to watch it get rated anyway.

@MMSieBreeze 3 года назад

American made should dwarf all competitors! Enough chinese steel! Let bring back our own refineries and make American steel the best in the world!

@MRSketch09 3 года назад

@@MMSieBreeze I don't disagree with you one bit. Production equals wealth. That being said... If you have broken people, you will have a broken society, a broken economy etc.. This problem goes deeper than mere .. jobs or whatever.

@ee-wo9rh 3 года назад

when turning back in drill hog because warranty: cashier: wtf were you drilling him: armor plating

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

lol Thanks for watching.

@colbyjackcheese9806 3 года назад

lmao dudes responses are the best

@FlourescentPotato 3 года назад

@@colbyjackcheese9806 lol Thanks for watching.

@facediaper4607 3 года назад

AR isn't Armor plate🤦‍♂️

@ee-wo9rh 3 года назад

@@facediaper4607 he literally called it armor plating

@IggyWon 3 года назад

"We're gonna test that" is the nicest way I've ever heard anyone say "bullshit!".

@justtime6736 3 года назад

@Gary Garretson Really?

@seniorxj2931 3 года назад

I posted this reply as a reply to your original message but felt it needed to be here too. You have no idea how much your content is appreciated! I have bought several products based off your videos and even more so, you've stopped me from buying others saving me money! You're the only RU-vidr whose videos I watch regardless if I need the product or not because the knowledge is priceless. I appreciate everything you do and I thank you for your hard work and dedication!!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Wow, thank you!

@seniorxj2931 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm Your welcome!

@paulkolodner2445 3 года назад

Same here! Keep up the good work.

@jbturbs 3 года назад

Agreed. This is the best channel of it's kind in the world. It's been helping me around the house/garage for a few years now, so I brought it to work with me and now its helping there too. I'm in the US Army Corps of Engineers and I've turned several of my coworkers in our district onto this channel. It is positively influencing our equipment purchasing decisions, saving the district money and giving us invaluable intel on certain products we use and abuse here everyday!👍👍👍

@bkinurface 3 года назад

I'd rather buy a tool that does the job slowly 2000 times than a tool that does the job quickly 20 times.

@lemonheadoo7 3 года назад

Depending on the cost of the tool and the time savings involved, the trade-off might be worth the time spent changing tooling that often.

@bkinurface 3 года назад

Lemonhead and also if you can be bothered to keep buying the same tool twice a week.

@lemonheadoo7 3 года назад

True, for a general consumer. A corporation would likely buy the tools a pallet full at a time if that were the case, though.

@svtirefire 3 года назад

That's what she said

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the feedback.

@RegalCobra097 3 года назад

The "40% faster" on the Milwaukee Shockwave actually stands for: "The teeth wear out 40% faster"

@CH-lg3st 3 года назад

40% faster regret

@sethdeppen8439 3 года назад

😂

@danielcrintea 3 года назад

😂😂😂😂

@TheRealMikeWilly 3 года назад

The Milwaukee Shockwave works great with my Milwaukee Fuel gen 2 impact driver, with a rated 3600 RPMs

@MrDarthbader 3 года назад

These are meant for making knock outs in electrical panels/sheet metal. Look at how fine the teeth are, and how thin/shallow they are. The dewalt hole saw before it is the same design. Not meant for thicker metal.

@RealCyclops 3 года назад

"Made in the USA with global materials" - translation: "Tool made in China, Packaging made in (insert country here). Tool put in packaging in USA"

@a4000t 2 года назад

Yea,they lie as much as the Main Stream Media.. lol

@AlexanderMason1 2 года назад

you clearly don’t know what you are talking about. It means the materials the item is made from is from an other country.

@RealCyclops 2 года назад

@@AlexanderMason1 Actually, I do know what I am talking about having previously worked for companies that did exactly that!!! Check the US laws as that is the bare minimum needed for them to be allowed to put the "Made in USA" tag on anything.

@AlexanderMason1 2 года назад

@@RealCyclops still, “made in USA with global materials” means just that, made inthe USA with materials from elsewhere. Also something in China and packaged in the USA cannot be said to be made in the USA. You are exaggerating for added drama.

@fmachine86 3 года назад

Bicycle wheel, Briggs and Stratton 5 horse, DeWalt battery drill: $100 Producing more accurate real world results than a standards testing lab: Priceless. There are some things money can’t buy. For everything else, there’s Project Farm.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much for the positive feedback!

@supersimon126 3 года назад

Anyone else read that with the for "For everything else, there's Mastercard." voice.

@michael931 3 года назад

Its a good review of the drill press also...

@endutubecensorship 3 года назад

Is life? No, Demorez

@larryblackmon2341 Год назад

😆😆😆

@MarkMeadows90 3 года назад

I know you always say “thanks for the positive feedback”, but as always, you are doing an amazing job with these reviews Todd.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

I appreciate that!

@zachholler8316 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm you should try the best circular saw blade for metal I have found that the diablo steel demon is pretty good.

@js6729 3 года назад

@@zachholler8316 that would be interesting

@HelloKittyFanMan. 2 года назад

He doesn't always say that, actually. Even when he does thank us for the feedback, I haven't seen him say "positive."

@MarkMeadows90 2 года назад

@@HelloKittyFanMan. just a nice thing to say. But I understand.

@Nate-ld7zj 3 года назад

"Claims to be 9000 times faster, were gonna test that!" I love when he says that lol

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for watching!

@wesbaumguardner8829 3 года назад

Well, it is 9,000 times faster than the hand crank drill bits used in the 1800's.

@superimposedgoat6009 3 года назад

This kind of testing is invaluable for so many trades!

@EricTann 3 года назад

I have never, and likely will never, purchase a hole saw. I'm watching the whole video anyway.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much! I appreciate it!!

@iancoxey2295 3 года назад

You mean, watching the "hole" video.... right?

@SWhite-hp5xq 3 года назад

You will now.. and you’ll know which one to get after this :)

@svtirefire 3 года назад

@@iancoxey2295 😆

@orijimi 3 года назад

Don't limit yourself to a life lived without sawing a hole.

@jbweb 3 года назад

This dude checked each of the teeth after testing for each test. Think about all of that. Then like and subscribe.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for watching and subscribing!

@AlexusMaximusDE 3 года назад

Fine. I don't really care about many of the tests but you are right.

@boosted2.4_sky 3 года назад

@@AlexusMaximusDE I think after subscribing and watching the videos you will begin to care more and more.... as a consumer don't you want to know where (on which product) to spend your money?... AND who is working to make the best product for you and not just taking your money and giving you what they know is crap...

@AlexusMaximusDE 3 года назад

@@boosted2.4_sky Well most of the products are not really relevant to me because I don't work with cars/engines or do much metal working.

@spooningkat6933 3 года назад

@@AlexusMaximusDE then wtf are u doing here? lmao

@robertstonebreaker8394 3 года назад

I like your reviews I have used all these products and still keep going back to Morse and Irwin when I need to get the job completed .

@Critter145 2 года назад

I’ve been having a time and a half finding decent hole saws and then I thought to myself “I will set what project farm thinks” and here I am! Thank you again for the content you make!

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

You are welcome!

@Buddy-po4hv 3 года назад

Manufacturers are reaching out to Project Farm and talking about how would they make their products better, you are literally changing the world 👌👍💪

@guitartec 3 года назад

I once worked at a HVAC contractor store where we had a hole saw display behind the counter. The display had every size known to man. Being a musician first and foremost, I quickly learned how to tap out the song Happy Birthday using a pencil, so when it was a cusomer's birthday, I could pay homage to their day on the hole saws. Then, I started learning Xmas songs. My boss finally had it when I learned Hava Nagila for our Jewish friends. Had I not been stopped, I would have learned some bag pipe tunes and maybe something by Charlie Daniels.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

lol. Nice!! I wish I had musical talent! I can make an engine tap and knock. Does that count? lol. Have a great week!

@guitartec 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm Todd, I will be over with the harmonica, washboard.and a pencil. You supply the hole saws. I buy the libations. You'll be playing in no time.

@justgonnagetbetter1037 3 года назад

@@guitartec I would definitely watch the devil went down to Georgia on hole saws, maybe followed by some metal!? Question is, do they djent?

@SWhite-hp5xq 3 года назад

Pics or its not true 😆

@hank1556 3 года назад

RIP Charlie Daniels

@R1CKYB0BbY 3 года назад

Goes to show that “most expensive” isn’t always the best choice. I like these videos

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Good Point! Thanks!

@b-2466 2 года назад

Rarely is

@HelloKittyFanMan. 2 года назад

Why the quotes? Is the one you're talking about _not_ actually the most expensive one, or...?

@IstasPumaNevada Год назад

You don't always get what you pay for. But you also rarely get what you don't pay for too.

@the70boss302 3 года назад

I use a Diablo kit with the quick connect head. I freaking love it! I cut very little metal, but it is so nice being able to swap sizes so easy. They seem to hold up extremely well. I have had to replace the pilot bit a few times, but not the hole saw itself.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

That is awesome!

@TechieTard 2 года назад

Same

@CC-ts2se 3 года назад

Man, pretty soon I'm going to have a garage full of tools and products that actually work because they will all be Project Farm Tested and Approved! Keep it up!!!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Sounds great! Thanks, will do!

@brumby92 3 года назад

haha! I've been on a mission to buy quality tools that will last my lifetime. No more crap that goes in the bin in 12 months. PF is a great help in this endeavour.

@willpestka2745 3 года назад

His oil showdown is the reason why I now use Pennzoil in my truck. Super freakin helpful

@JoaoAmadoTV 3 года назад

That actually asks for a sticker “PF Tested & Approved” 😉

@serjekk 3 года назад

I've never needed a hole saw but I'm going to watch this video with a smile on my face anyway, just like all of your videos.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Glad to hear! Thanks for watching!

@karenbrauneis4290 2 года назад

I recently came across your videos and I absolutely love them. Your testing is extremely thorough and comprehensive. At one time, our property had to have some fairly extensive foundation and plumbing work. This resulted in a number of areas where concrete was repaired very poorly (the ratios were nowhere near correct). I would love to see a comparison on concrete grinder discs. Thank you.

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.

@5400bowen 3 года назад

I have studied science and technology my whole life. I worked in a machine shop that did all the work for the San Diego city bus system and I say....you are the man. That last phrase is supposed to be in capitals! Your videos started out home spun and technically great. Your attitude is number one. Now you have moved into the field of materials science. So thorough, insightful....dang! And the timing of your smiles, quite telling. You are like the Johnny Carson of product review vids on utube. Don’t get a swelled head (another amazing attribute, that you have not). Your videos seem to have benefitted from better resources. And you put them to the most apt aspects. Merry Christmas and thanx.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

So nice of you! Merry Christmas!

@gregaria3664 3 года назад

Great video once again. "We're gonna test that!" Needs to be made into a shirt with your name/logo on it.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

That would be cool!

@mikeniner8154 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm I'd buy one.

@staind288 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm hey man, I suggest you make a video on comparing the different types of turbo nozzles for pressure washers. If they're all the same or if some are better than others. Just the turbo style

@electrontransferconduit657 3 года назад

I want one of those. Would definitely but a hoodie version.

@derekwright113 3 года назад

Yes

@electronicsNmore 3 года назад

I use hole saws a lot. Thank you for all the time you put into making videos to help others make the right choice when making purchases!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much!

@julianpetkov8320 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm They all suck at it, but it is a very difficult cut without coolant. Cubic boron nitride would have handled the armor plate easy. Try with lighter speed and feed.

@pflaffik 3 года назад

@@julianpetkov8320 Agree with you, too hard feed on that old belt geared machine will chip off pieces of the carbide teeth every time it stalls. Im used to industrial stuff, drills with real gearboxes and coolant, i bet i could get at least 100 holes from that dewalt carbide. One can even feed them hard since there is no risk of stalling when in the lowest gears.

@julianpetkov8320 3 года назад

@@pflaffik I have trick for the home shop for tempered steels. I touch the hole to be with a stick welder for about two seconds. Carbon electrodes are best for the purpose. They are made for cutting. It will soften the spot. Like you said, there is no point wasting carbide on hobby machines.

@king-su5uc 3 года назад

Wow I can only understand some part your guys were talking about ..... But the knowledge is sure a lot on this thread 👍

@mr.dahliaking.202 Год назад

I noticed that almost in every of these amazing tool comparison videos, the Irwin tools always excel compared to their price. Its something else and I love it. I talked my boss into buying Irwin holesaw set to be used in our small metal shop and it actually worked much better than the Karnach hole saws that we were using since 2003. Much cheaper and marginally better. My boss has started to watch your videos after that :)

@ProjectFarm Год назад

Thanks for sharing.

@jjscheckel2 3 года назад

Your experimental methods are really exceptional. I am really impressed by your use of empirical measures whenever possible, and I love your new hardness scratchers! I work at a heat treater as a metallurgist, and my favorite part of my job is figuring out why something broke or didn't work as expected. My work has some chemical and material analysis tools I think I could use to enhance your tool competitions. I'd like to work with you, let me know!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much!

@guitarmaniac6491 3 года назад

Seeing the “lifetime tooth break warranty” on the Milwaukee sparked an idea. Maybe you should follow up on some of these warranties to compare the customer service of brands. I wouldn’t limit to just the hole saws. Having good customer service is something I look for in companies and usually influences my decision to purchase their product.

@jonanderson5137 3 года назад

Agreed, a real no hassle warranty is rare.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the suggestion.

@otroflores91 3 года назад

I would tune in to find out results of a warranty claim on the bit.

@js6729 3 года назад

I'd like to see the results of that test lol

@HammondOfTexas0 3 года назад

Yep, good idea. When talking to them, I would probably leave out the torture test, then decline to follow though on the warranty replacement because of what you actually did to them. By that point you probably would know all you need in terms of how easy the warranty process is.

@theKRB93 3 года назад

This is the first video of yours I have seen, and I am instantly a fan. Your intro is brief, product descriptions include all the relevant information (so you don't end up with hundreds of questions in the comments asking you the same thing over and over, I'm sure), tests are thorough, precise, and offer every measurement imaginable to determine which item performed best, etc. You just got a subscriber and my husband and I are going to binge on your videos now!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for watching and subscribing! Enjoy!

@Cautionary_Tale_Harris 3 года назад

Lol... I've started keeping a Notebook app open while watching his videos (and rewatching the old ones) so I can keep tabs on what products performed the best. It helps me if I'm looking for something.

@5400bowen 3 года назад

It’s not every measurement imaginable, but it is really succinct and economical, yet hits all the critical parameters.

@christopherrau9793 10 месяцев назад

I think of this channel so often when I need to make a tool purchase, your reviews are the best on RU-vid. Phenomenal quality as always.

@ProjectFarm 10 месяцев назад

Thanks!

@user-bi6pp3fg8r 10 месяцев назад

I needed to cut a 1 inch hole in mild steel channel iron o my car trailer. I watched the Project Farm video to select a brand. I could not find the brand I wanted but I was able to get the Diablo saw at Homeless Depot. Thanks PF!!!! The saw made it thru the steel with a hand held drill in less than three minutes. I had to hold it in an awkward position with limited visibility. I backed off the RPM and pressed maybe 15-20 lbs weight on bit. I was thrilled and delighted that it cut a hole so easily. Thanks for the video… it saved me so much trial & error time. Now I can new trailer light wiring.

@ProjectFarm 10 месяцев назад

You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.

@Brown-Bird 3 года назад

Suggestion: testing and comparing ratchet straps. Brands like Powertye against your everyday husky and other common brands found at hardware stores.

@GeoffCostanza 3 года назад

That's a good idea. He could test the tensile strength, durability around sharp corners/tight bends, how well they hold up when lightly frayed, and resistance to UV/weathering/salt water/oil/grease/friction. I've also wondered how much twisting the band actually reduces its strength. I'm guessing that in some of the cheaper brands, the strap could outlast the ratchet and the hooks!

@lamagra22 3 года назад

I was going to suggest this as well, glad someone else thought of it too.

@benaguilar1787 3 года назад

This would be fantastic. And please include the retractable ones that you can purchase through McMaster. They are so very convenient to use, but I don't know if they are as durable.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great suggestion! Thank you.

@OchoCinco5K 3 года назад

Dont forget tractor supply ratchet straps

@mattsnyder4754 3 года назад

Project farm “we’re gonna test that.” Manufacturers “crap.”

@thanasisxask6597 3 года назад

🤣🤣🤣🤣

@alienpoker 3 года назад

Would be interesting to try to claim on the “lifetime warranty” they offer. Send a letter or call customer service saying it wore out the first day of use. See what they offer !

@dmitryplatonov 2 года назад

Usually warranty is from manufacturing defects. If it just sucks, it's not defect, it's how it was designed to perform (to cut costs).

@Phoenix-One0922 2 года назад

When some company writes in the package "lifetime warranty", No one really understands what it really means... Your 'life time' or the tool? A tool doesn't have a "life time", only "wear and tear" and Everything 'wears and tears', doesn't it? it is really a "term" open to 'interpretation'... Like you've said, it could 'wear out' in A Day! And that would be the "life" of the tool! See what I mean? Gee...

@haloharry97 2 года назад

@@Phoenix-One0922 Halfords in UK offer a life time, it breaks from uses or wares out, you get a new one.

@joeashbubemma 2 года назад

You're actually paying for 6-7 bits up front. They'll 'warranty" the tool, until you figure out that shipping costs are on YOU. Drill Hog just states "lifetime warranty", there are no details to be found on their website. I hate to say it but a LOT of US companies, especially big corporations, are shady as F.

@mikealexander4166 3 года назад

I always use cutting fluid with my hole saws on metal. Wonder how this would have affected the cutting times and jamming from the first test and then into the next tests. These things cost a lot of money. I like to get as much use out of then as possible. As usual, nice job👍. Always appreciate your effort.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@s60t5M 3 года назад

Did you send in any of the “lifetime warranty” products for replacement after this test?

@MakeItWithCalvin 3 года назад

^ that alone would be an awesome test.

@darktrip 3 года назад

Not if you use wrong (not made to drill ultra hard steel)

@nickw7619 3 года назад

Thats a great idea actually... Would be curious just to see what they said lol

@HammondOfTexas0 3 года назад

Under normal circumstances, I'd say that he voided the warranty by abusing them, but it would be a very good test to see how many hoops the manufacturers make you jump through to get a replacement. He wouldn't when have to do the replacement, just get to the point where he could send it in then decline.

@s60t5M 3 года назад

Could have a follow up video to review the warranty process 😂

@komitadjie 3 года назад

Just off the top of my head, I strongly suspect that the relatively poor rigidity of the drill press arrangement here without the mandrel might have significantly hurt the carbide-tipped saws. They're not good at all under loads that press off-axis and will tend to chip or fracture the carbide. I'd love to see those re-tested in a setup that does not allow so much side-slip! Perhaps a method for this could be pre-drilling a hole to guide it, and replacing the drill with a matched diameter piece of blank drill rod or something to guide in the pre-drilled hole. Great test, thanks, man! Fun to watch as always. :)

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the suggestion.

@Turbochargedtwelve 3 года назад

Yea I noticed the run-out too and it definitely isn’t ideal for carbide, but at the same time how many people using these are going to be mounting them in super rigid stuff like a mill?

@dethmaul 3 года назад

I love learning things in the comments!

@zendell37 3 года назад

@@Turbochargedtwelve I'm with you, testing the carbide the way it works best isn't a real world test, sort of making it pointless. Hell, I'm sure most hole saws are used in a powered hand drill, even if on thinner metals.

@komitadjie 3 года назад

@@Turbochargedtwelve Not all that many, but that's one of the purposes of the mandrel, to keep the saw running in a single path, without a large amount of runout.

@user-bw5xf3yr3m Год назад

Honesty, does pay off. Glad people like you are still around god bless you brother

@ProjectFarm Год назад

Thanks!

@truthmatters6719 5 месяцев назад

I absolutely agree, but God is should always be written with a capital "g", all respect and glory to the Almighty.

@danielxu5121 5 месяцев назад

I appreciate how informative and direct your videos are, no time wasting. Most other channels I have to speed the video up

@ProjectFarm 5 месяцев назад

Thanks and you are welcome!

@nothanks3462 3 года назад

I gotta say, the testing methodology on this one was full of holes.....

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

lol Thanks for watching.

@clickster1883 3 года назад

A whole lot of holes?

@itsprivate3061 3 года назад

*I GET IT*

@Fister_of_Muppets 3 года назад

Hahaha

@gavin5861 3 года назад

"Up to 40% Faster" - literally, the only one that couldn't cut through the metal.

@andybub45 3 года назад

Besides the no name

@dballer51 3 года назад

40% faster at dulling

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the feedback.

@stephenarling1667 3 года назад

Up to 40% faster than atmospheric erosion.

@captainheat2314 3 года назад

Up to 40% also means 0.1%

@madfictionfpv8246 3 года назад

Just bought one of your shirts, love this channel!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you very much for supporting the Project Farm Channel!

@apuuvah 3 года назад

Your consumer tests are some of the best on Tube. Watching these many DIY folks could save money and nerves.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@T80Delta 3 года назад

I don't own a hole saw, but I'd just like to say thank you for the consistently-awesome & enlightening content. You are appreciated!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Awesome! Thank you!

@mitchelcline9759 3 года назад

Todd! Wow! I'm grateful you're out there man. Your integrity comes through in your work, which I hope you find fantastic success in. Your win is everyones win. We all want to see more people online like yourself. You're showing people so much more then just these products. You're showing people it's ok to simply make honest, good content. You're really raising the bar on so many levels here. Powerful stuff man, keep up the great work

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

I appreciate that!

@Jcrash1 3 года назад

Every time I see one of his videos I think to myself this guy deserves way more subs than he has. He puts so much work into these videos.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the nice comment!

@austinmckelvey8025 3 года назад

Keep up the good work man. Always go to you if I want to find out what's the best or prove to someone else what's the best 👏👏

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks! Will do!

@assessor1276 3 года назад

Gosh you do a fine job on these tests - very impressive!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you!

@billharris3049 3 года назад

I now no longer need to guess which hole saw to purchase....I love this channel 👍👍

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thank you!

@thelasttimeitried 3 года назад

Thanks for your amazing videos. As someone who is just starting to get experience in metal lathe tooling, I think the carbide hole cutters would have had a much better chance of surviving with a different test setup. The chipping indicates that they're experiencing impacts while cutting, either from binding (possibly from too aggressive a cut), or from chatter. Utilizing the mandrel is absolutely critical to prevent the saw from rattling around inside the trough, and a firm, but limited feed to prevent binding should extend the life of the hard-but-brittle carbide. It was definitely interesting to see some of those bi-metal saws make it through the harder materials like champs. Thanks again!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

You are welcome!

@Lucas_sGarage 2 года назад

I think that in this case a bridge port mill could do better (i think)

@SMRacer91 2 года назад

I agree.. the modest drill press just isn't cut out for this kind of work. The chatter and binding mean the tool is beyond it's capacity. I have a similar drill press and a JET mill/drill. I can do so much more with the JET than the Delta just because it is more stable and powerful. The teeth just disappear on the Delta but last much longer on hard metal with the JET. That does not mean this test is invalid, however. Most of us with a home shop have one of these lightweight drill presses. Great information!

@campinghack0675 3 года назад

The Greenlee Quick Change Carbide Cutter Set Catalogue # 660 is the ONLY kit to own. I’ve been using the 7/8” (1/2 EMT) in a factory for 6 YEARS and it still eats steel easily! I have had to replace the starter drill bit a few times but the hole saws are phenomenal! It will be the only kit I’ll ever buy If I ever have to replace it. Thanks for the awesome video. I love your content. Great editing also.

@swasyt9419 3 года назад

Dude! Your content is amazing!!! You're honest and doing amazing reviews. Thank you for doing these videos!! Love it

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

I appreciate that!

@stephenkeller1347 3 года назад

I have been purchasing “PF” recommended products from engine oil to glues. You need to patent your logo and get royalties for every product sold from these large companies. Thank You for all the testing you do.

@johanponin1360 3 года назад

'seen on PF'

@StonedSaber 3 года назад

are these real stickers? omg

@jasonproebstel1879 3 года назад

@@johanponin1360 That sticker just means that it FAILED on PF

@happycamper6352 3 года назад

Absolutely not. The lack of sponsorship and royalties from the products themselves is what makes the reviews unbiased. The very second I find out that a reviewer profits from the product manufacturer or seller is the very second that I dismiss all sense of credibility and trust. Wranglerstar is an example of a youtuber that uses sponsorships to promote products. I asked RU-vid to never recommend any of his videos for that reason. I don't hate him; I just don't trust sponsored reviews or any reviews where the reviewer is compensated by the seller or manufacturer.

@nyazz22 3 года назад

*trademark

@DaaaaaaaaBears8 3 года назад

"I'm gonna kick your ass!" *We're* *gonna* *test* *that*

@draaks1 2 года назад

I use Ideal Carbide holesaws all the time. Specifically for electrical conduit and holes for door contacts in storefront door frames. They last a long time and give me consistent and clean holes which are especially needed when drilling storefront door frames.

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

Thanks for sharing.

@bartlomiejhryniewicki 3 года назад

11:07 You made a mistake, you said 140 seconds while it should be 1 minute 40 seconds.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Oops, thanks for catching that. Yes, 1 minute 40 seconds!

@christopherstaples6758 3 года назад

or 100 seconds

@manueldossinger 3 года назад

But it was correctly entered in the sheet at the end :)

@flawedideas 3 года назад

metric time :p

@wtfisitthat 3 года назад

I picked up on that too was seeing how many others did still interesting video

@UserMan2014 3 года назад

I am an electrician, we use Greenlee and Ideal hole saws, I was missing them in this competition.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the suggestion for future round of testing.

@TheMcdrewb 3 года назад

Lol I just repeated your comment greenlee 7/8 ,1-1/8, 1-3/8 set is great...I was also saying how the impact holesaws are only good with the 1/2-7/8” ones cause the larger ones warp...due to thin wall...electricians rule the tools!!

@bryanjk 3 года назад

Yes! I was really hoping they were included as well.

@RRaucina 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm Also Starret hole saws although possibly an Irwin product

@z50com 3 года назад

Greenlee is good, ATI (Aircraft Tools Inc.) is the BEST. . . .

@OllieOctober 3 года назад

When using your drill press I think you should raise your table so the spindle isn’t extended so far. It looked like that could have broken those really expensive one because of that wobble with how hard the carbide was

@rockypyle2879 10 месяцев назад

Thank You so much for the "find past videos" catalog, extremely helpful.

@ProjectFarm 10 месяцев назад

You are welcome!

@thistledownwoodcraft3426 3 года назад

Thanks, Home Depot has the Hole Dozer 18 piece set for 90 bucks, nearly half off. Because of your video I just bought one. THANKS!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Glad I could help!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

It happens all the time and I fail to select the best lineup of brands to test. So, I would greatly appreciate your help. I periodically ask for a vote on which brands to test. The “vote” notification only goes out to those who have both a) subscribed and b) selected the “bell”. ru-vid.com/show-UC2rzsm1Qi6N1X-wuOg_p0Ng Diablo Hole Saw: amzn.to/31czGJL Milwaukee Hole Dozer: amzn.to/34bG1ap MK Morse: amzn.to/3l1W0xC Irwin: amzn.to/3l1H0A0 DeWalt 2x: amzn.to/3hcI5m1 Dewalt Impact Ready: amzn.to/326qOF1 DeWalt Carbide: amzn.to/3aR5Y0p Lenox: amzn.to/3iWVUFE TCT Carbide: amzn.to/3iUHZ2R Milwaukee Shockwave: amzn.to/322AxMq Drill Hog: amzn.to/329BF0K Bosch HB100: amzn.to/2QabO37 By the way, the testing is having a positive impact. In addition to helping viewers select the best products for their needs, product manufacturers are watching these videos. Several manufacturers have informed me that they are working to make their products even better. So, thank you for supporting the channel and I’m looking forward to many more product test reviews in the future. Looking forward to reading your comments. Best regards, Todd

@Proillbelly 3 года назад

You should do the best file

@KTHKUHNKK 3 года назад

U R 1 hard working Guy. Keith Kuhn

@o1mtbiker 3 года назад

Just think of it a little differently. You’re testing the best bang for the buck. Not the most expensive contractors stuff

@kevinmonzel 3 года назад

I wish you would have included Milwaukee Carbide hole saws. I really want to know how they stack up in tough metals.

@SteveVi0lence 3 года назад

Just no more Chinese made tools.

@terrygoyan3022 3 года назад

Thanks for this test. I use hole saws for carpentry and often find that I need to drill metal as well. I appreciate the experimental protocols you come up with for testing. Can you possibly put up the various charts you made for the drills performance in different materials? I think that would be useful at the conclusion of future videos. Also, can you put in a link for the hardness testing picks? Great video!!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great suggestion! Thank you.

@crazyflyboy30 3 года назад

I use the Lenox hole saw to make a starter hole in cold roll steel in my turning lathe and then work very well and a lot quicker than drilling alot for metal out and no need for the center drill and I can cut over 2" has I can cut from both sides then I have a small rod that can be used for turning into something.

@anesnurkic1469 3 года назад

Suggestion: testing which oscillating multi-tool blade/attachment is the best for different applications such as cutting wood, nails/screws, pvc, drywall and etc. keep up the great videos!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great suggestion! Thank you.

@MJorgy5 3 года назад

Fein would likely win.

@preston1614 3 года назад

Lol I literally just typed this suggestion above because I just got done polishing a blade trying to cut a drywall screw out. 😂😂

@BrentRoberts01 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm be sure to test Diablo's brand new full line of Oscillating Multi-Tool blades

@phantomwalker8251 3 года назад

if it cuts hard screws,it cuts everything..

@AppleiReviewer 3 года назад

11:06 “140 seconds”, I think you misspoke, and meant 1 minute and 40 seconds. Just a heads up!

@joserangel4195 3 года назад

I caught that too lol

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Good catch! Yes I meant to say 1 minute and 40 seconds!

@AppleiReviewer 3 года назад

Project Farm keep up the amazing work you absolute beauty!

@bait28 3 года назад

i was gonna say lol

@dispositivosdesalomao7874 3 года назад

doesnt a minute have 100 seconds??????

@alidulger 3 года назад

Man you're doing great job here. Helping people with your tests and experience. Thank you very much.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

You are welcome!

@pmartinjob 3 года назад

Thanks for the time an effort that you put into these videos. Very entertaining. I'm curious if you have ever tried a warranty claim on a product after a torture test. I'd also like to see a review of impact torque sticks to see if they're vaguely accurate. Thanks.

@maoristereo 3 года назад

Ive said it before and i say it again: Best consumer advice on youtube. You're the salt of the earth, dude!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@TehButterflyEffect 3 года назад

"We're gonna test that!" - Todd, 2020 ------ Music to my ears. Love these videos.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@gmarch4618 Год назад

You are becoming my go to for just about anything I buy on line. This is the real consumer reports site!

@ProjectFarm Год назад

Thanks!

@denniskennedyjr.9128 2 года назад

Amazing unbiased video!! If I’m looking to purchase tools this is the first place I go. It’s unfortunate consumer reports doesn’t take this approach anymore. If you ever branch out into testing appliances or anything else I would follow you in that as well, thank you!!

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

Thank you!

@alexbingham7796 3 года назад

Anyone else notice how he pronounces “wheel?” It’s just like how Stewie from Family Guy pronounces “cool whip.” 9:56 As always, great video. I’m a big fan of the hole dozers.

@svtirefire 3 года назад

I don't know hwhat you're talking about.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for watching!

@heggeprojects3614 3 года назад

Why are you acting so wheird. Oh come on that one doesn't even have a H in it.

@johncarlberg4481 3 года назад

Stewie says cool hwip

@jbthestoner5504 3 года назад

A lot of older folks where I work say words like wheel and white that way. Must be some sort of dialect from a few decades ago.

@Cautionary_Tale_Harris 3 года назад

My daughter and I were watching The King of Random a few minutes ago. They were testing the hardness of a few rattle can clearcoats. I said, "This is like what I keep asking Todd on Project Farm to do." And then they mentioned you and your channel! Last night I watched a video of someone "testing" tools. A commenter said, "Check out Project Farm if you want to see how to do a thorough, unbiased test." Pretty cool to see your influence across RU-vid.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for sharing!

@williamroberts4758 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm Hi it is not the hardness that I would worry about, it is the UV resistance. This goes for inside or outside, UV means more than just sun light. It has a lot of chemicals in the bonding that make it far superior in the hardness than any clearcoat ( hardness of a few rattle can clearcoats) by it self. I will say this, just buy any 3M product and you will not be steered to far from wrong. 3M is AMERICAN MADE.

@aisforannihilation1662 3 года назад

Makes me happy to hear ppl recommend & give credit to PF. Lord knows I'm forever spreading the word of PF's work. I don't have an audience like those channels but I do gladly recommended quality products, companies & PF everywhere I can.

@roberthoffman4681 3 года назад

I very much appreciate the videos that you make. I am on disability and I need to do as many repairs myself as I can. I have always tried to buy good tools that should last my lifetime and hopefully my stepsons as he is the only one I have to leave them to, and even when he was right out of high school I had been picking up basic hand tools and he used them and when he left for the Army his mom and I moved in together and part of what we moved was his tool box. I saw that he kept them all in great shape with no missing tool. I hope he takes care of mine as he will always be able to make money with them. Your videos help me to pick the best for what I can afford. That information is priceless. So again I thank you. I wonder if you ever start testing and things go wrong and you think wow I should have stayed in bed?

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much! Thanks for sharing. That is very nice of you to gather up tools for your grandson.

@TheGuitarman1968 3 года назад

Best Channel on RU-vid, by far. Right to the point with useful and unbiased testing. No annoying distractions like music, politics or wokeness either. I have actually been using Lenox hole saws and mandrels for many years. They work well, are reasonably priced and they are also readily available at Lowe's. Recently, I was away from home and needed a 3.5 inch hole saw in an emergency. I picked up a Hercules hole saw and Warrior mandrel at Harbor Freight. Both devices worked surprisingly well. Granted, probably not as well as the Lenox would have done, but pretty impressive none the less. I just wanted to pass on the information. Keep up the great work!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks, will do.

@jbooze703 3 года назад

thanks, for taking the time to make this video. great job.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

My pleasure!

@dagurorarinsson2827 3 года назад

''assembled in china with swiss components'' is that a good thing? i feel like its usually the other way around

@allothernamesbutthis 3 года назад

maybe the paper packing was printed in Switzerland and oil sourced from usa for the plastic packaging?

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great point. Thank you

@kjdude8765 3 года назад

I'm guessing Swiss Carbides that are brazed in place in China.

@well_as_an_expert_id_say 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm that made no sense

@svtirefire 3 года назад

@@well_as_an_expert_id_say your mom makes no sense

@dylanschmidt4166 Год назад

Reasonable quality carbide cutting tools usually excel at higher rpm/feeds relative to HSS. Running it at lower speeds leads to hardening of the base material, etc. probably why the carbide saws slowed down. Great video as always.

@ProjectFarm Год назад

Thanks!

@ray29ish 3 года назад

The tct is what we use. Absolutely amazing

@mscd9676 3 года назад

IMO you should measure the depth of the holes left in the armor plating and include them, too. Anyway, great video, as always :)

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Good point! Thanks!

@elijahdean5389 3 года назад

As always, thank you for the videos. If you want to take another look at hole saws, would you consider doing tests with hand held drills? I've always heard that carbide tipped drill bits should never be used on a hand held tool because the instability will break off the carbide tips and ruin tool life. A video with tests of hand held drills and impact drivers using hole saws would be great!

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great suggestion! Thank you.

@phillipallsopp4376 2 года назад

Today I am drilling some 1" holes in a steel frame for rubber grommets for pex plumbing. I was most disappointed with the performance of the Bosch, Milwaukee, and Makita hole saws. Some of them lasted only cutting four holes. The Lenox 1" hole saw saved my day. So far I have cut 25 holes with this saw and there is still lots more life in this saw. That Lenox was imported directly from Amazon.

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

Thanks for sharing.

@gypsy6211 Год назад

One thing I found with cutting oil is the need for force. If there's not enough, even the tiniest difference in blade height means oil under the cutting edge, and that dulls a blade fast and can be the reason for blown out edges on carbide teeth.

@jacobduryea8030 3 года назад

When I’m out tool shopping I just check in at project farm RU-vid channel and see the best tool for the job. Your videos are always very entertaining and educational also saves $$ too with the knowledge you give. Thanks for the great video can’t wait for the next one

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Wow, thank you!

@Mikedacoolboy2 3 года назад

Your my favorite, farmer/engineer/scientist/mechanic.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks and thanks for watching!

@rexthomas2259 2 года назад

What can I say... I pretty much use your video's exclusively before making a purchase. Great job and god bless!

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

Awesome! Thank you!

@dantesparda5916 3 года назад

11:06 "One hundred and forty seconds" 😂😂 I was like wait whatttt??? Great videos though, keep it up🔥

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Oops, meant to say 1 minute 40 seconds. Thanks for catching that!

@29JoeBoo 3 года назад

Very cool! Always enjoy watching your videos. You add in things (like measuring the size of the hole, once it was cut) that I would never have thought of. Very informative, and fair testing, as usual.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks!

@jamesfarmer2748 3 года назад

Carbide cutters will make very accurate and clean cut holes compared to bi metal.

@staberdearth3130 3 года назад

Damn, you beat out my lineup of music based videos for viewing time this week!

@keithrichardsson9008 3 года назад

One thing that wasn't considered was stress, the holes were very close to each other and even though you controlled the temperature, the molecular stress that occurs from heat would give incorrect readings on every hole except the first. To solve this the steel plates could be stress relieved between each drilling, then all the molecules would be back in position. I love your tests, keep up the good work, thanks.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the feedback.

@glumpy10 3 года назад

That Vid was a LOT of work. Very interesting and well presented as usual. Thanks for putting in the substantial time and effort.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@Donarturo650 3 года назад

I never skip an ad on any of your videos. Your dedication and hard work just to help us save a couple bucks really means a lot. Responding to our comments shows you really care for everyone. Trust me i speak for everyone! Glad you and the Farm family are doing well during this pandemic.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Awesome! Thank you!

@The101Hammer 3 года назад

I have sub'd. I have been witnessing your videos for some time. Thank you very much for your time spent helping all of us with these excellent breakdowns.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Awesome, thank you!

@Captain_Yodelstein 3 года назад

I bought a set of the Irwin bi-metal hole saws to cut a bunch of thick washers (from 3/16" mild plate steel) to build body mount hardware for my truck. I gotta say I was very impressed with the way they cut but the arbors and pilot hile bits leave some to be desired. The bits bend easy and the arbor doesn't hold the hole saw centered so thats what makes the cut hole a little wonky.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Thanks for the feedback.

@cblade007 3 года назад

Project Farm I never even heard of Morse until now. Home Depot nor Lowe's carries that brand. Now I know of a cheap reliable brand name.

@jondeiler9536 3 года назад

They carry them at Menards, but that's more of a regional store.

@SteadArcFab_Ministries 3 года назад

Jon Deiler Morse also makes very good band saw blades! Yes Menards, Amazon and some Milwaukee dealers.

@GKBigmack 3 года назад

And great drill bits and lathe tooling.

@shanester366 3 года назад

our company usually buys Morse hole saws, im sure they get them at a supply house. they seem to last pretty decently in the field

@leftyeh6495 3 года назад

Guess I got a bad kit. 25 piece hole saw kit, and they all sucked. Melted the teeth right off. They weren't even sharp enough to do anything but burn through wood right out of the case. I still have a Milwaukee Cold set (think they were some cryo treated weirdness) that keeps going and going. I'm sad they discontinued them, probably because they lasted too long.

@preston1614 3 года назад

Here's another idea, multi-tool blades. I use my vibration saw (multi tool), to cut a lot of metal, screws, wood, etc. and I go through blades like crazy. It would be nice to know which ones are the strongest because they are quite expensive.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great video idea. Thank you.

@KC_Woodworks_LLC 2 года назад

I second this

@dextermosqueda6954 Год назад

He made one!!

@alisafari82 2 года назад

as an electrician I use a lot of hole saws(different brands) but honestly when it comes to cutting metal , I would say i have had the best results with the greenle hole saws.i am surprised that you didint test them or klein tools. a great video none the less. thank you

@ProjectFarm 2 года назад

You are welcome!

@jessepremo7398 3 года назад

Thank you for all the valuable research you do. Bless you and yours.

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

You are so welcome!

@zacle3985 3 года назад

To Project Farm, you should add (lower/higher is better) when you are showing comparison chart, it would help some viewers a lot

@ProjectFarm 3 года назад

Great suggestion! Thank you

@Kitteh.B 3 года назад

@@ProjectFarm also watermark your graphs in some way with the PF logo, they'll inevitably start getting screencapped and put onto websites without permission. Naturally, some will go to the effort to remove it but there's no stopping those kinds of people. It's mostly just a deterrent.