Brushed Motor Showdown Holmes VS Reedy!

Подписаться 72 тыс.

Просмотров 22 тыс.

50% 1

This was not what I expected!!! Well not completely, you guys just have to see this one! Links below for the Holmes motors shown and the parts and pieces of the Element Ecto. Use the links to help support Exocaged RC, Thank you guys!
Website holmeshobbies.com/
All the Holmes Hobbies Crawlmaster Sport Motors
holmeshobbies.com/motors/brus...
All Holmes Motors on Amain
bit.ly/3Aar1Gk
Holmes Crawlmaster Sport 550 10t
Holmes Hobbies holmeshobbies.com/motors/brus...
Amain bit.ly/3icI4Sh
All the Holmes Hobbies Crawlmaster Pro Motors
holmeshobbies.com/motors/brus...
Holmes Crawlmaster Pro 550 10t
Holmes Hobbies holmeshobbies.com/motors/brus...
Element Ecto
Dixieland RC dixielandrc.ecwid.com/Element...
Amain bit.ly/3f9cLpj
Ebay ebay.us/JNJ6Dq
Flysky GT5 Radio
Amazon amzn.to/3f4Tk0P
Ebay ebay.us/VM8xAr
Proline Trencher Tires
Amain bit.ly/3zLjqhs
Amazon amzn.to/3iaikWy
Ebay ebay.us/IXzrD1
Horizon bit.ly/3lcB9dt
Hobbywing 1080 ESC
Amain bit.ly/3iXUrkj
Amazon amzn.to/3rDHOP8
Ebay ebay.us/LAAbX9
Holmes Hobbies 10t Crawlmaster Sport
Holmes Hobbies holmeshobbies.com/motors/brus...
Amain bit.ly/3icI4Sh
SSD Brass Knuckles
Amain bit.ly/3zOsKkO
Amazon amzn.to/37dKPfv
Ebay ebay.us/K133l3
Crawler Innovations Foams
Amain bit.ly/3l3EKux
CHANNEL MEMBER INFO
If you would like to be a channel member now's the time! I will start a monthly giveaway in a direct paypal payment in the amount of TWICE your monthly membership fees, they are $1.99, $4.99, $9.99 and for the big guys $24.99. So you could win $4,$10,$20, or even $50 depending on your level. Take a look! / @exocagedrc

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

7 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 156

@HolmesHobbies 2 года назад

Some comments! Higher quality ingredients can slow a motor down. More torque, more drag brake, lower turn count for same speed. As evidenced by the 10t sport being slower than the 14t reedy. The sport motor had better "hold" brake due to drill balancing. The Pro will start up smoother and slower, but the tradeoff is less static hold. The pro would shine more when loaded down more, as you guessed. It has about twice the torque of the sport, but more than twice the price. Price to value ratio, I would also call it in the favor of the Sport!

@mikebird8290 2 года назад

THANKS FOR YOUR HONEST OPINION SIR

@brookerobinson85 2 года назад

Swapping to a Holmes motor in a few of my crawlers was definitely a big upgrade . Watching this makes me think maybe a 8t sport in my enduro ?

@thomasheathcote1642 2 года назад

I think the crawlmaster pro would've been a better comparison to the reedy or the crawlmaster sport if it were a 550 can as opposed to the 540 can that you used in this video

@thomasgross8289 2 года назад

I ran a HH trailmaster 27t sport for 3 years and beat it like it owed me money, ran it in mud and water and all i ever did was spray it out with wd40 once a blue moon and it was still going strong when I lost the rig. You make GREAT motors!

@malky525 2 года назад

The dig dawg himself...Dirk Diggler!

@scheers100 2 года назад

The crawlmaster sport is the best (price/quality) brushed motor for many crawlers I think.

@roblowrie1969 2 года назад

I've got a 12t 550 Crawlmaster Sport in my TRX4, and I have to say, for the money, £25, it can't be beaten!! It's been in the car for a year, and hasn't missed a beat. Great comparison test. 👍🏻

@NikkiNexo777 2 года назад

I have a Crawlmaster Sport in all of my crawlers with a HW 1080. Zero complaints.

@Frank-st7ku 2 года назад

Perfect timing! I'm getting my 10t 550 today for my redcat gen8, I'm thinking of gearing up now from 13t to 17t since its so much slower.

@crawling86 2 года назад

21 turn trail master sport (hobby Holmes) with 28 tooth absolute love 👌🙏 Gears mean everything.................

@addamwright704 2 года назад

I only use the The Crawlmaster sports in my trucks, they work great, seem to be almost bulletproof and you can't beat the price!

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

you got that right!

@hellorc7678 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC awesome motors for the price. Think I've installed about 5 of them in the last few weeks!

@JMHZ2401 2 года назад

Can't beat the value of the Crawl Master Sport motors.

@thomasvanderpool4735 2 года назад

I totally agree with you there!

@mikebird8290 2 года назад

So TRUE JOHN VHRC

@mrstanton81 2 года назад

The crawl master sport is something special imo. Love the vids and discussions! Thanks

@jeffziola 2 года назад

I am definitely mind blown on how much these motors have come 👍

@scottdaubenspeck2291 2 года назад

Wow. That was a great video. Didnt think the sport would have a better drag break. But thats impressive. I simply love the way you do your videos and reviews. Keep up the awesome work Joe.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Thanks 👍

@toddmiddleton1442 2 года назад

I’ve got the HW1080 and a Crawlmaster Sport 16t in my Capra. For a budget friendly set up it’s great. Low speed control and a nice little punch. Love the videos as usual.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Right on

@TRKISH324 2 года назад

Ive got the 1080 and Crawlmaster Sport 15T 550 in my 10-3. Crawls for days!

@gonncalomariamonteiro4176 2 года назад

And you've just opened the Pandora's box...because next is the big debate between brushed and brushless. In this video its obvious to see the difference between a generic can and the propose built ones. Not only in performance but in build quality as well. No questions here. But regardless of the motor, if the ESC is also generic, common sense dictates that, only by swapping the can, the performance gain is residual...at best. Hence, first swap the ESC and then the motor. So no huge deal. My problem here is when brushless comes to play. As you know, there are those who are fanatics for brushed and those who swear that brushless combos are the next big thing after the invention os sliced bread. Videos on this subject are immense, but most of the time, you end up with more questions than answers. I would love to see what's your opinion and advice on this...and since ECTO is still on the bench... I think you get the point. Thanks a lot for another great video. Keep them coming! Cheers mate!!!

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Well, yeah this is debated, I also went through the brushless is everything and brushed sucks phase, as I get deeper into the hobby I see brushed is still a very competent setup. I like the Crawlmaster Magnums as I have 2, one in Optimus 3 and one in Myolnir and they have tons of power and control. In crawlers, brushless is still usually more efficient and more powerful and they usually require less maintenance. If I did a lot of wet mud runs, I'd be brushless for sure. Now I have brushless and brushed crawlers of all kinds of ranges. For a trail truck it will be brushless and the better I get at driving down low and really crawling, the more I like brushed. Not sure if that helps any but that's some of my thoughts on the subject.

@gonncalomariamonteiro4176 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC thank you.

@ChiefRickyRC 2 года назад

Thanks for showing us a good crawler motor ! 😊 🙏

@Love2Wander Год назад

Getting the motor for my Capra I think I will be happy. Nice review

@jdvtec 2 года назад

I haven't really tried a reedy motor but I have 3 crawl master sports 2 12t and 1 10t and love them. Great performance for the price.

@SPPTA 2 года назад

I absolutely love that sport. Have them in all my crawlers.

@idontcaresapo8233 2 года назад

I was thinking to get the sport but it's confusing with the turns term... I have a 2021 bronco stock and I do more trail than Rock crawling. What turn should I get? 12t or 15t?

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

sapo, I did a test with the TRX 21t vs the CM 12t, the speeds are about identical but the CM 12 was the better choice. If you want more speed go with the 10t or even the 8t. the CM motors have 5 slots so the effective KV output is lower than a 3slot motor.

@idontcaresapo8233 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC thanks buddy I saw the vídeo...I'm ok with the 21t titan speed but the crawling control is not the best. I'm gonna go with the 12t and thank you again for answering my question

@hellorc7678 2 года назад

Great comparison. Should I consider th 8t sport for my ecto to keep the speed up a bit?

@showtime813 Год назад

Great videos. Just ordered a shirt. And a Crawlmaster Sport!!

@paulpitmon6663 2 года назад

I'd love to see you try a team Brood motor. Thanks for a great video.

@shadow7796 2 года назад

I would like to have seen the Magnum as well but a great comparison for sure. The Reedy Radon line is a bit better than the stock I think. But it would be cool to see where my 11t Magnum falls in at.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I only have two magnums and they are at home in Optimus 3 and Myolnir

@tomlucasrccrawlers9108 2 года назад

Fun comparison. Keep it up Buddy.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Glad you liked it!

@paulschryer9571 2 года назад

- Hey EXO, Thankyou again, for another "great" video !!!! Yes, "WE" saw it, with our own eyes !!! - I love a straight-up guy !! Tell it how it is, no cover-ups here !!! 😉🇺🇸 - So I started my RC Crawling with a (KIT) AXIAL SCX10 II w/2-speed option. I was on a tight budget to start out my crawling experience.....but in the process of upgrading, I learned probably more than those people, who have the "moo-la" ($$$) to go for the great, highly modified : motor, esc, high quality lipos, and all the bells & whistles - (from the start). 🤔..... I learned that I can run my SCX10 II on a TRAXXAS 1/16th scale (stock) Titan 12-turn brushed motor, paired with the other original piece of equipment, the (stock) TRAXXAS 1/16 scale ESC, which is the

@paulschryer9571 2 года назад

- I have the Crawlmaster Sport 12T, and I "really" like it... A LOT !!!! 🤘😎👌 - Best $20, I ever spent !!! 😉

@nobudgetrc6063 11 месяцев назад

I changed out all the stock electronics on my ecto……..hw 1080, crawl master sport 13t, Savox servo and a nicer radio…….big difference

@kravenkrawlhobby5438 2 года назад

Holmes Hobbies is my all time always go to motor.

@RobKingRC 2 года назад

Got my Ecto today💪🏻 and ordered a pack of pinion gears 12t-17t Awesome rig! like you said ,will have to tame the Beast!! Gonna throw the 13t in first.

@patc8653 2 года назад

Would love to see a comparison with the 5 slot Reedy Radon 2 motors.

@Scale-Crawler-Xray-RC 2 года назад

Very interesting , thanks for vidéo 👍👍💯

@TangoOne 2 года назад

Brushless is cool and all, but for me nothing beats the feel of a hand wound brushed motor. I don't need my crawler to go more than 8mph, I have a nitro buggy for that. On my pro motor I always pull the end bell off and spray out all the dirt and copper then wipe the commutator with a alcohol swab. My brushes seem to last forever on my Crawlmaster Pro 13t

@RC_Ludz_N_Co 2 года назад

First of all, i wanna say thank you for all your videos, learning so much, it's a real pleasure and so helpful. Now here my trouble, i'm looking for THE ideal brushed motor, but i thought the more the T the slowest it is, then 27T/35T would be the way to go for pure crawling. But in you videos (and in the comments), seems everyone's loving this series of 10T, and to be honnest technically i don't really get it. If you could help me with that, thanks in advance.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

hey buddy, these ar 5-slot motors, so the are about 1/2 the speed of a 3-slot normal motor, this is why they work so well. Basically you put 3 shots of power in a 3 slot to get one revolution but it take 5 shots of power to get the same revolution so its slower and start up is usually smoother. Hope that helps

@RC_Ludz_N_Co 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC , got it. Thanks a lot for the super fast reply.

@davidpigg3942 2 года назад

I wouldn't mind seeing a side-by-side comparison with the 10 t crawl master in the 8 t

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

hmmm interesting, I'll have to find another 10t LOL but I think I have an 8t in the bin.

@TheAurabell 2 года назад

I have 3 CP pro 10t,s. love those motors

@just_inolredneck8319 2 года назад

I love my 16t hh crawlmaster pro in tha capra. I do need to go n with the program card and turn on the drag brake..

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

if you have a 1080 it should have came with a programmer

@just_inolredneck8319 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC it did I just have been lazy and haven’t changed the setting

@thomasvanderpool4735 2 года назад

I had terrible luck with the stock electronics in my gatekeeper. Bought the gatekeeper brand new, the servo burned up for seemly no reason the second time I ever used it and fried the reciever somehow in the process. The 5 or 6 time out the motor died. Never had taken it in the water or mud. Gave me a great excuse to upgrade the electronics right away haha

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

My servo is still alive in Thor. The stock motor and esc had to go. They are not very good

@ed0c 2 года назад

i have 10turn 550 sport. i LOVE IT. dood gear down too, go down to like 12-10tooth pinion can pull a car on 3s lmao

@vinceruland9236 2 года назад

Don't look overlook the Tekin motors. I have a 12t in my trx4 and it has gobs of torque. They're not a popular company as they were in the past but they make quality stuff 👍👍

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I’ve had the Tekin a before. Really good motors. I had a 45t that was awesome and stayed cool on 4S.

@timle1286 2 года назад

On the CrawlMaster Sport motor, is the front bearing pressed fit into the output shaft?

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

it was on there pretty good, I'd have to say it could be either way on that.

@517rctrailcrawling 2 года назад

Love it! Great video bro! 🔥🔥🔥💯✅

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

thanks!

@paulschryer9571 2 года назад

(1:05) I guessed 7.6 !! Man, was I close.....pretty darn close !!!! 😲😁🤘👍

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

😀😀

@johngray8798 2 года назад

Any chance you would share the settings you have chosen on the HW1080? Thanks

@TacticalMatt. 2 года назад

Hey what thumb wheel do you have attached to your flysky? I just bought one and I don’t like the one I purchased:/ yours looks perfect

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I recently did a whole video on one handed driving, I have links to everything in the description as well as links to the thingiverse page to print your own.

@motojoe5421 2 года назад

Went from a HH trail master 21 turn 550 to a HH crawl master 8 turn 550 the drag brake is night and day stronger crawl master than the trail master when using the crawl master on a heavy Gen 7 it makes a big difference when crawling. Great video by the way, what voltage were you running ? 3s is what I am running.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

yeah 3s always in my crawlers

@WillB.6759 2 года назад

Reedy is pricey over the crawlmaster sport, glad I choose the crawlmaster lol. Sweet!!!!

@latefangs423 2 года назад

how is the 14t reedy faster then the 10t crawlmaster sport, should it higher turn mean slower speed?

@mnmvuk 2 года назад

Nice video as usual! Can I ask where you got that thumb steer adapter for your GT5?

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I printed it from a file on thingiverse

@mikebird8290 2 года назад

VERY INTERESTING VIDEO SIR.

@romper4444 Год назад

In my experience, the reedy motors are way better than the titan. But I haven't ran these 5-slot armature reedy crawler motors. I think if your looking to have speed and good crawling, the reedy is the best option, and it's not like it crawled badly right? I though it looked very smooth, no? You should have a look at Reedys 10t 550 rebuildable 5-slot motor. That'd be my go to. I love the radon 2 540 15t for bashing, wish they did a 10t or 12t 3 slot rebuildable 550, or a 12t 540 rebuildable. Fast!

@67smit 2 года назад

I have the same radio and I don't know how to use it right or what it means on it specifically for a crawler can you make a video on how to use it all the ways that you can thanks

@jcbaja404 2 года назад

Great Video!!! How would the Holmes compare to the Reedy Radon 2 Crawler 550 10T 5-Slot 2270 KV?

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Don’t know about that reedy motor.

@gabrielguadarrama8701 2 года назад

I’m still running the stock axial brushed motor on my version of the superlite 😂 Which one of these motors would you recommend to use with the tgh 2.low?

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I've never had that but possibly a 16t 540 size CM Sport or one of the higher end ones like a torque master.

@gabrielguadarrama8701 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC K I’m getting that. I like 540s. Let me know when you would have time To drive my trx4 go through the nasty.

@ChiefRickyRC 2 года назад

Whats the best Axial rtr scale crawler under 300? I have a JL SCX24 that needs a big brother

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

probably the current model scx10.3

@ChiefRickyRC 2 года назад

Okay its in the shopping cart.. how about under 200?

@scottishrc7857 2 года назад

It would have been good to see how one of the Surpass Hobby 5 slot 550's would have compared to these ones as well.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I've done a 5slot 10t Surpass and it ran really good, the insides were a little less on things like laminate but it did good for me.

@FaithSaraG 2 года назад

I had a 10 turn Surpass, the armature came unwound in 15 minutes.

@scottishrc7857 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC I seem to remember that vaguely but i can't remember what motor it was compared to. I'll need to search and re-watch.

@scottishrc7857 2 года назад

@@FaithSaraG That sucks. Maybe just unlucky. They're far from being the best motors for sure, but they used to be good value for me. I've been running a 12t 550 on 4s in my Bronco for quite a while now and no issues with it dying.

@FaithSaraG 2 года назад

@@scottishrc7857 It wasn't a total loss. I took the armature and magnets from a HH 10 turn Crawlmaster Sport that had a worn out bushing and put it in the Surpass can to make a Frankenmotor.

@MangoJim90 2 года назад

I definetly wanna try CrawlMaster Sport 550 8T in my 10 scale axle Monster Truck and in Wheely King also. Time to try smth better than chipo aliexpress stuff. Thanks!!!

@weschambers7612 11 месяцев назад

This is why I love holmes

@MikelangeloPhoto 2 года назад

Pretty sure the Pro will be smoother than any of them... making crawling experience overall better. Great vid.

@ChiefRickyRC 2 года назад

Whats the fastest brushed 540ish motor that you know of? I have a 979b in a serious speed war with a 45.5mph 2s VATOS Spirit Q901.. any help 🙏

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

The really fast brushed motors are almost part of history now, its all brushless for speed, just find one that has a low turn count and it should be good. 9t or something if you can find them.

@ChiefRickyRC 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC I see sure go like 9t then bump the gear ratio up. Thanks🙏

@lowrider181 2 года назад

Looks like I'm going to have to replace me reedy motor!

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Yep

@joeboisselle6856 2 года назад

Ok . You seem like a person that would answer my ? . I just got done with scale build . Just got into the hobby 4 years age . Jumped rite in . Don't know much about motors I guess . I put a 55 t in it and it don't have to much power . I would rather have power than speed . What should I have ? Mine is a rs-540 tuned machine modified. Looks like snow panther hobby is the name of it. I have a planitary gear trans and a separate transfer case . I did that to keep from cutting up the body . Remember it's my first build . I'm just now putting some roll bars in it . I will have a video of it very soon . Thanks for your time. P.s. what do you think about the redcat short corse truck ? . I have the pro .

@javyjav1977 6 месяцев назад

How you get yours to go so straight?!?!?

@TOYitCUTE 2 года назад

i hope to see another tire test soon

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I've got a few, The different compounds now makes it difficult.

@zonegamma8197 2 года назад

holmes so good motors!

@troysawyers9781 Год назад

Not sure is comparing a 550 to a 540 is the best comparison.

@chrispalusak7725 2 года назад

Joe are you runing your ryft with brake calipers on.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

@old-rcplane-phart 2 года назад

#1 today! 👍😁😁😁🥇

@reddeerrebelrc6674 2 года назад

Wrong Reedy to be testing fairly. Reedy Radon 16t 5 slot

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Well it’s what was in the truck.

@mishmasta 2 года назад

Swapping to a 10T Crawlmaster Sport in my Gen8 totally changed the rig for the better...even with the stock ESC. Holmes definitely got the formula right with the Sport line. I have been eyeballing the Pro as an upgrade for the sake of upgrading, but this review makes me think I should just hold off for a Revolver and the new Crawlmaster ESC instead.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

I just recorded the Crawlmaster mini esc and an 1800 revolver in the Ecto. Man I like it!

@mishmasta 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC I would love to see a comparison back to the Sport and Pro brushed motors.

@ezboyrc553 2 года назад

Nice comparison test. You got a awesome course Is that just for you or do you hope competitions there? And I wish you could send me the motors you took apart I would put them back together I need one bad. I have a small RC channel check it out if you get a chance. I just built a truck for my handicapped brother out of donated parts people have gathered for me But his motor is going out. And thanks for the good content I've learned a lot from your videos over the years

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

yeah those are long gone now. these CM Sports are really cheap at about $22.

@ezboyrc553 2 года назад

@@ExocagedRC ok thanks buddy I'm going to pick up a couple

@FaithSaraG 2 года назад

Running "pro" style motors on a trail truck is a waste of money. Motors without a fan are not a good fit for trail use. With no fan, the motor gets hot and stays hot. Not a big deal on a competition crawler with a time limit, but a multi hour trail session will cook a fancy "pro" motor.

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Good points.

@romper4444 Год назад

If it's geared correctly you'll never need a fan, I never have

@rezzrollinrc 2 года назад

Team brood ✊🏽👊🏽

@jonthomas8487 2 года назад

The Team Brood motor is identical to the Surpass Hobby crawler motor

@TheLilhulk1111 2 года назад

Sport all day

@dirtrider88 Год назад

i cant beleive you can buy a really good brushed motor for 1/10 crawler for the same or even less $ than a mediocre brushed motor for a 1/24 crawler

@romper4444 Год назад

It's just the production volume of the runs of motors they make for that size is so smaller that it costs more to produce them. 1/24 scale crawling is a niche market and it will come and go in popularity pretty quickly.

@shawnbyrnesrccrawlersrccra2911 2 года назад

Mr reedy won't l ikme this video 😆😆😆

@ExocagedRC 2 года назад

Probably not but it is what it is

@joshrichie9833 2 года назад

Will never buy another Holmes product again

@scottishrc7857 2 года назад

Why not?

@HolmesHobbies 2 года назад

He's mad he got a non waterproof servo wet and it stopped working and we won't give him a freebie.

@HolmesHobbies 2 года назад

We do have a scrap trade in program now but I'm guessing he wouldn't use it on the principle of the matter.

@joshrichie9833 2 года назад

You got it all wrong mr Holmes . I don't need ur freebie I put 777 servos in all my rigs after your servos that are not trail ready

@scottishrc7857 2 года назад

@@joshrichie9833 You still haven't answered why you won't use another Holmes product. Seems a bit silly to get a non waterproof servo wet, then blame the seller because you didn't use it correctly.