Carrie Gets Dumped via Post-It Note | Sex and the City | HBO 

Prior to Charlottes news Carrie said she had news. Charlotte jumped in first so that was kind of rude

@@hillyplays29 it was HUGE news! Obviously she had to interrupt

@@inmam.1299 She also literally ASKED. Lol.

Charlotte specifically asked Carrie after she told her news. But Charlotte always was the most enlightened with her views. (The post it over the ring was a bit rude.)

Selfishness covers friendship.

That line always makes me smile….love Samantha ❤

In Carrie's defense, Charlotte was the one who changed the subject and asked Carrie to talk about her news.

Toxic af

@@Valreea This is true, I stand corrected.

So ignore Samantha second ring dig, ignore the fact that Charlotte asked or that Miranda literally brought up how she was dumped. But ok!!!

That's Carrie in a nutshell. 🙄🙄😒😒

She was the best.

@@CR-be3un “motherf**ker is concise” 😂 …love Samantha ❤

How would that be a pun?

@@ZekeBurns-om3yt”Carrie” carried

​@ZekeBurns-om3yt "Having" a doorman like the one outside Charlotte's apartment block that she "had".

It's fu#%@g fiction ffks

Well, Charlotte did change the subject and ask her.

Lol Charlotte literally asked her “So Carrie what was your news?”

No I agree with you. Charlotte had no idea that Carrie had bad news. But if Carrie was a good friend, she would have either not mentioned it and saved it for later and or mentioned it briefly and reverted the conversation back to Charlotte. Plus don’t get me started when she put her post it note on Charlotte engagement ring. No one can say that if your best friend did that would you be okay with the disrespectful act. People who defend Carrie in this scene must not have seen other episodes. Carrie is a toxic friend.

I mean she is the protagonist

Yep and she had a great story

No one cares.

They always treat Charlotte like an alien.

Surprise....it's TV show.....

Well, Samantha and Miranda aren’t into marriage and romance much, though they were sweet and supportive to her nonetheless. Plus, you know Carrie, she was too absorbed with her own problems.

She was toking a joint. I know it was 2003 but seriously, it wasn’t that big of a deal to begin with.

😂😂😂

omg yess, I watched this yesterday for the first time, I laughed so hard I had to stop the episode🤣🤣🤣

I mean Charlotte did ask her what her news was

(Carrie is the main character)

@@philbecker4676 and she knows it, clearly.

💯

@@philbecker4676 now it's Miranda

Gee! I could hear Samatha saying that: “way - more fabulous!” 😍

I was just thinking the same thing while watching this. They were both amazing performers.

I swear I can feel the tension...maybe I'm crazy ..

It wasn't always done well. You can pick it up sometimes by sjp facial expressions in some scenes that would not have warranted it.

Who?

I found it fascinating because I never knew they didn’t get along until after the show ended. It’s testament to their skills as actors to be able to turn on chemistry with someone you can stand

Oui le coup du post it sur la bague était nul

Yep. But Carrie was a textbook benevolent narcissist. Not actively dangerous, but God help you if you don't do what she wants. Just ask Samantha.

@@elenachristian9860 There's no such thing as a benevolent narcissist.

The thing is... there was a clear moment of silence between the news. So it wasn't just Carrie, Miranda & Samantha also didn't have any interest in Charlotte's story besides quick complementing the ring. That's some friends.

This a common theme with Carrie. I am honestly surprised they stayed friends with her. Charlotte, Samantha and Miranda all have genuine issues that women deal with... E.I. unwanted pregnancy, balancing working a motherhood, infertility, realizing what you want vs. what you need in a relationship...

Maybe that's one of the reasons Sam/Kim didn't return to the show. She got tired of it always being about Carrie/SJP. Then again it might be kinda hard to say that bc the writers did a really good job @ giving each of the girls their own story and time.

But she did let Charlotte enjoy her happiness. She expressed happiness for her engagement and complimented the ring. Then when asked by Charlotte what her news was she responded. What else was she supposed to do?

@@afrosensei5308 yeah and then she put her post it note on top of her ring to prove a point that her break up trumps her engagement.

@@BengiKayScarlet In real life that could definitely be taken the wrong way. But in a tv show it's a good endpoint for a scene. Also, and I repeat Charlotte literally said "So Carrie what was your news?" Charlotte wanted to change the subject because Samantha bringing up her first engagement ring made her uncomfortable (not that Samantha meant to do that). Carrie isn't always a great friend. But other than the paper covers rock part, I don't see anything wrong with what she did here

@@CC-si3cr Kim said she wouldn't come back bc SJP bullied & ostracized her on set. I feel bad for Kim Cattrall, she was she best part of the show but often got no respect for it

@Keith Cousins delete your ridiculous reply from MY comment

Miranda's doorman was worse...nobody had to know how Carrie got dumped unless Carrie told them....Miranda's guy made the doorman the witness..awkward.

If i was a guy and had to break up with her, I'll do the same.

"Not beating around the bush" sounds like something Samantha could also have said. 😁

Aww this is my dream 😩 it’s fabulous 😍 it seems to me this is Tiffany… 🤔

Haha, same, i also watched this show when i was 20 and i pretty much liked everyone, including Carrie. Now she looks childish.

@@Nyuffykahyes!!! Same exact feelings. I’m wondering how I admired her.

Ok misogynist 🙄

Same. Very wavely and not too blonde!!!

Thank God !

You've got to be kidding 😂

Amen! Awesome show

Well, in Berger's defense he was in a bad place in his personal life to be starting a new relationship. Plus I guess he felt Carrie was not the one. At least he didn't string her along like Big did.

Absolutely - the worst kind of man is one who can’t get over feeling threatened by his girlfriend’s success. That’s why he chose such an under-handed way to break it off with her - he wanted to steal back all the power in the end and couldn’t have chosen a more cowardly, childish and petty way to do it.

He’s always been the WORST imo

100%. Which is hard 'cos I like the actor who played him

I know some people may feel like charlotte felt awkward of the reminder but you gotta know/understand Sam - she’s always rooting for the upgrade and basically compliments charlotte on doing better (and in Sam’s mind it’s how it should be)

I know! And such a cheap line in "Paper covers rock!" Who would say that to a supposed friend? Just for the sake of an easy laugh?

lol - I "ghis" was an acronym for something.

@@CC-si3cr don't be obtuse

Charlotte did ask Carrie to tell her story though

Carrie said she had news first and then Charlotte cut her off. It’s Charlotte’s second marriage, so how excited is everyone supposed to get. Plus Charlotte asked Carrie what her news was.

Non je la comprend sur ce coup là. Elle en avait gros sur la patate. En plus Charlotte lui demande ce qu'il se passe.

@@bleazyful they bring that up later in that episode, Charlotte didn't want everyone to make it a big deal because its her second marriage because she changes her mind later :)

they do , it’s called 2 movies and then afterwards it’s called AndJustLikeThat

​@@MooLounge just like that was terrible

Me too! But I think one of the reasons the greats from early premium/paid network prestige comedies and dramas like this and “Sopranos” stand the test of time and are so highly regarded is that they thoughtfully ended those shows *well before* they had a chance to fall in the quality of scripts, get bad direction, or lose their magic. There’s a real power in knowing when to leave the party.

True, because it makes the conversation all about MEEEEEEEE!

It is, but I think that's one of this show's biggest flaws, as much as I love it -- the writers so loved the witticisms and wordplay that sometimes they'd make the characters say something ridiculous and even insensitive just because it was funny.

I had to smile but it’s actually sad

@saranicolas1860 that wasn’t really the point. Main character or not she was a narcissist

And then they have to leave the club 😂😂

Shahhahahahahah ruuude😂😂😂

They’re actresses. They get paid to be friends. But they dont get paid to be friends off camera.

Carrie and Sam were besties it's Sarah and Kim that wasn't. They must've really loved the money they were making because they couldn't stand each other at all.

That was funny😂😂

You're not alone! I love Carrie too. Get lots of disapproval for it. I'm probably as selfish tbf but she's fun, witty and interesting. Imo anyway!😅

Yeah I like Carrie too. She’s humanly flawed, which is an outgrowth of her personality. Too many female characters today either aren’t flawed or their flaws feel too contrived or self conscious as if they’re screaming: “look at me, I’m a complex character (for a woman) because I’ve got all of these flaws!”

I agree. To me Samanthas comment to Charlotte about this ring is malicious. She takes the oppurtunity to remind everyone that it is the second engagement. Why would you tear your friend down like that. Charlotte is clearly sad about the previous marriage failing. By comparing rings it is suggested that the relationships are compareable. Also, Charlotte mentiones that the ring is a replica of a ring Elizabeth Taylor received. She was married 8 times. With Samantha pointing out that this is the second engagement ring immediately after Charlotte mentioning Elizabeth Taylor, it comes across as if Samantha is suggesting that Charlotte is collecting husbands and this won't be her last husband.

If you watched the beginning Carrie said she had news first. Then Charlotte jumped in and just continued on.

Carry had no real issue. She wanted to break up with Burger and then Burger brook up with her. Done, easy, next.

@@mooniet1 carrie is thr worst

Yup

Anytime Samantha's on screen is the best.