I started watching john in 2019. His videos convinced me to start going to Mass again after a decade away from the Church. 5 years later I’m married to a Catholic gal and starting a family.
What does that say about how screwed up you are? Doyle kisses Trump's butt. He won't ever let his audience know that the reason he wants Trump, a New England *Protestant* elite, back in office is to trigger the libs. Not to mention that he couldn't just cheer on DeSantis, his Floridian brother in Christ. He started the lie about DeSantis being an establishment plant to thwart Trump. He's catty.
John Doyle has some must watch videos. "The Very Real Link Between Christianity & Conservatism" and "The Very Real Link Between Satanism & Liberalism" are extremely good.
@@tc9459 I think he just means people who aren't terminally online, not to say I'm not terminally online, but it's like a niche drama thing. It doesn't mean you're not a good Catholic, you're just not up to date on the lore so to speak.
@@billymays7958 Oh im well aware, I got sick to my stomach seeing this creep on Mats show. This guy is extremely sus based on his circles. You can always point out the “independent thinkers” who spend all their time on YT following this caliber of personality.
This is why I like Christians. This comment right here. You guys need to tolerate way less. I’d totally go for a Christian / catholic hedgemony over what we have now. In a heartbeat.
@@valuedCustomer2929 What perspective is the "meh" from? That it really doesn't matter, and the Federal Reserve has a negligible impact on things? Or even from some thought that it is beneficial?
John Doyle sounds like a very intelligent, well-grounded man. I can't wait to check back in 10 years when he has a little more perspective on life. There is a streak of authority and invincibility in his opinions that feels untempered by years of lived experience of the world. I will stay tuned to see where he goes.
I was going to make this exact comment, there's a streak of self-righteousness that shows immaturity and lack of life experience. I don't know about his disappointments, but I know mine have soften my previous anger streak.
@@johnx140 of course they exist. The problem is that moral theology always deals with theoretical situations. But the application of Good and evil, of moral theology, can only be done in the particular circumstance it takes places. We can say killing is an evil action. We can also say that a woman who kills in self-defense against a rapist is choosing the moral good. Good and evil exist. But the longer you live, the more relationships and connections you make with other humans, the more you realize that there is room for nuance and Love tampered with Mercy. Doyle seems to have a lot of high moral opinions which is wonderful, but they do not seem to be tempered by the wisdom of lived experience.
Thank you so much for having john on. I cant begin to describe how important what you are doing is for people matt. From the bottom of my heart thank you.
Hi, I’m a real “tradwife.” I have four children and I stay home with them most of the time. I also work for income when my husband asks me to. I raise my children in the Faith and honor my husband in my word, dress, and deed. I do not have an Instagram account showing me making sourdough and dusting already clean vintage vases full of sunflowers, I do not wear a crisp sundress with a ruffled apron every day, I do not get up at 5am to milk our cow and prepare fresh butter and use the excess buttermilk to make fresh pancakes for my apple-cheeked and impeccably clean children from my own hand milled wheat. You are absolutely right that what is online is larping. I work extremely hard and so does my husband. I am a “tradwife” because I understand that my proper position as a Christian is to be oriented to follow my husband and not to lead him, just as he follows Christ. That’s it.
Like Doyle said in the interview, Buckley and National Review were some of the first to embrace cancel culture and purge paleos from the conservative movement.
He literally talked about this in the video. He claimed old conservatism (JBS) and said neocons (NR) systematically blacklisted the old ones. He left out a couple details, like the fact that the first neocons where Jewish Trotskyites who flipped against the USSR for backing Arabs against Israel. That's a big reason the right is so pro-Israel today. The old conservatives stood for America First always and it's about time we blacklist the neocons.
I got married young and I will say it is really hard especially in this economy and while I don’t regret it and don’t feel controlled by my wife (idk maybe I got lucky) I will say consoling women can definitely feel like an unwanted and obstructive burden when you are trying to work to make something of your legacy.
He totally nailed it with the description of paleo vs neo conservatism. I’m glad some conservatives are calling out William F. Buckley and his style of conservatism. I’ve heard Michael Knowles claim that Buckley invented conservatism! How ridiculous! Not that I am completely opposed to Michael Knowles (or Buckley for that matter), but he is starting from the wrong place historically speaking. Two years before the founding of National Review, Russell Kirk wrote The Conservatives Mind which featured real traditional conservatives like Calhoun, John Randolph, John Adam’s etc. These days, conservatives seem to think that Lincoln or MLK were conservatives. Good to see young people figuring this out and starting from a correct historical perspective.
@@Snoopy-apollo well, true. Adam’s was more a European style conservative. Just didn’t want to exclude all of the yankees. I respect Adams but he’s not my favorite. Are you saying that because I included Adams, I must also think that Lincoln was conservative? Because he just objectively was not in the context of his time. I’m not sure that writing one sentence about someone counts as a screed. Maybe take your own advice, bro.
@@Snoopy-apolloLincoln is only conservative in the sense that he was racist (most people for most of history were racist). He was pretty mediocre. The Confederates were far more conservative, generally.
I don’t want to get roasted because I am a woman asking this. I think a place like Steubenville would be so good for my husband who never had a present or engaged father. He NEEDS men. So I’m down with him going and having a cigar or pipe with friends. But, he has battled with alcoholism and has been sober for many years. It nearly destroyed our marriage. So how do the men handle a man who is sober from alcohol? Is it weird? Or do they encourage? Would the temptation be too much for him and if so, where in the world is he supposed to connect with men? We live in DFW area, but I’d almost be willing to move to find my husband some MEN to hang with. He’s in his late forties and has been starved of friendship for years because he doesn’t drink. I know, I know, this is me being mommy.
It’s a valid concern. I wish I knew what to tell you. Your husband would have to be very strong in his sobriety, not to be tempted among men who bond over alcohol. While I don’t want to 100% condemn the practice, I do have mixed feelings about it because of the temptation it may present to people who struggle over alcohol.
Perhaps he could first reach out to Catholic society/organizations like Calix or Catholic Recovery in an effort to connect with men who have recovered. And look into Catholic organizations like Fraternus and Knights of Columbus or secular ones like U.S. Men's Sheds (would love to know if Catholic men have started one) that do charity volunteering programs and/or workshop activities focused on fraternity, sharing practical skills and socializing. God bless you
Find good catholic men. If any friend of mine says in response to a drink offer “I don’t drink” I immediately understand without question and have the drink to myself. We can still have good conversation and a good time without alcohol.
Two of my favorites, together at last. Fradd and Doyle are right where the culture needs to go. I'd love to see Doyle and the New Polity guys get together and start building up more of a popular movement for conservative Catholic integralism.
John Doyle is going far. I've been a fan for a while 🔥 LETS GOOO!! I'm getting baptized at the Easter vigil this year, and partly, this conversion of mine is thanks to John.
1:28:02 As someone who had fallen pretty deep into the mindset described here. Thank you for the perspective. I don’t know what to do with this yet, but i needed to hear this.
Na. Society looked down on smoking because cigarettes are freaking disgusting. Smoke pipes and cigars or whatever you want. Cigars don't smell horrid. But I had parents who smokes cigarettes all the time, and it's gross, and I can't blame anyone who doesn't want to be exposed to cigarette smoke.
Yeah, I don't know where this new pro smoking thing on the right is coming from. We all have observed people with our own eyes who smoked for years and the terrible effect it had on them.
@@s.t.652I think it’s more a push against the nanny state. I can understand that. However, cigarettes were a deal breaker for me when dating in my teens-20s and again in my late 40s. Still would be if I were dating.
Agree 100% about the smell. And I don't even mind the smell of the smoke that much, but that nasty odor that soaks into people's houses when they smoke is awful
I’d like to hear John define what he means by “do something great.” I think he draws a false dichotomy between “doing something great in the world” and “doing something great at home.” I see a lot of people in the comments “reacting to the normies” that think he is too far right. In reality, nothing says normie to me like waiting until your mid-30’s to get married and start a family because you were “doing something more important.”
Amen brother. I was quite amazed just glancing through the comments that no one was speaking up about...franky how wrong Mr. Doyle was regarding this issue.
You can do both without forcing yourself into a box, which I think is Doyle’s point. It can be just as silly for a boy to get married at 18 for the sole purpose of fulfilling a trad aesthetic as it is for a man to put off marriage for the sake of a decade of career building. A single man shouldn’t put his career goals on hold to chase marriage, in the same way that he shouldn’t put his home life on hold to chase money. Doing that is a recipe to end up finding success at neither. I’ve known peers, young men, who lack all motivation because they make their youth all about having a wife by 25, and lamenting their singleness at 26. Whereas if they’d invested in building themselves, their faith, their career, their masculinity, and their other relationships, they’d much more naturally be finding a wife by 26-30 and would be perfectly in line to have all of the home and career success that they’d always wanted.
The interesting thing about these long interviews is, it's just enough time to get a better understanding of what one truly believes. Building one self for marriage in all the areas your talking about is important. But this shouldn't be postponed for one into their twenties or thirties to start doing. And career building is not just restricted to being a business owner, a doctorate graduate, waiting for mom/dad to pay for your way or hand you an empire, or waiting to have a 1 to 2 child family which usually is controlled by birth control....unfortunately. I know of multiple examples of men who lived simple lives for their families teaching them the faith and responsibility which if that is trad them I'm all for it.
We would drive around our town and other towns nearby and find ways to climb on top of schools. It became a challenge to see how many schools you could climb up. We became rather creative on how to climb up these schools, never using a ladder.
What are the comments on this? 😅 I’m gen Z and I’m lost as to why we are bashing John, eachother, and some dude named nick? Cmon people, enjoy the interview on its own merits. Peddle your political ridiculousness elsewhere por favor
Thank you! You took the words out of my mouth. Except that I am a millennial and I know what’s going on in the comments. It’s so annoying. Idk why what John does has to have anything to do with another man.
To be fair, chewing on cocaine leaves gives a similar effect to caffeine. The problem is cocaine is distilled down to a ridiculous degree. It would be like ingesting tons of pure caffeine, which is a really bad idea.
@@pinochet3698 Do your own research, of course, but I also don't have any problem with people being tea-totalers. If alcohol and such don't appeal to you, you are totally fine not partaking in them. You will still live a totally fulfilling life without them.
Im getting tired of single people giving advice on relationships and marriage. Just admit you want to keep pursuing self-centered pleasures or goals and aren't ready to put the needs of others ahead of yours. Thats fine, i would respect the candid talk way more then all this "marriage hampers your ability to do great things" garbage. Nothing against John in particular here, he's definitely not the only 20 something year old internet personality to say these things.
Yep pretty much. Imagine thinking a man spending time with his wife and children and providing for them isn’t achieving greatness. What in the world was he even talking about?
@@alqoshgirlwell it is true that detonating time to family fundamentally takes away resources from other ventures. This doesn’t mean marriage should be avoided but it’s a reality.
I realize he's young, but the descriptions of newly married men.😳 The two become one flesh. Maybe young men aren't as interested in spending time the same way as they used to spend it. And as far as "getting permission"....i feel like thats courtesy. I wouldn't call it getting permission, but couples tend to want to spend their time together early on. Its not emasculating.🤨
Right! Yes when you’re married you kinda need to communicate your whereabouts. That has nothing to do with being emasculating.. you have to be a pretty pathetic man if you can’t understand that simple concept of love
Communicating with your wife and changing some priorities isn’t emasculating. What’s emasculating is withdrawing from all male activities in your free time in order to live a life 100% centered around the things that your wife wants to do. Men need time with other men and there are ways to find time for that amidst life changes, it just takes more commitment and preparation than it does as a single man with less responsibility. Most men could do both but many drop the ball on their male time because they don’t understand how important it is until that they stop watering that’s plant and it dies.
Doyle? He's the kind of Catholic who picks and chooses which (parts of) teachings to follow. He kisses Trump's butt and swears the elderly dotard is a strong alpha male who's the basedest right-winger ever in spite of the overwhelming evidence against that notion. Trump invested millions of dollars into Anheuser-Busch, as revealed by an FEC filing, which is why he and Trump Jr. tried to get MAGA to end the Bud Light boycott.
@cameronpack3965 he was one of the first with an insanely long interview. I think George Farmer might have gotten longer than his first one. Now Akin at over 6 hrs... gonna be hard to even want to beat haha
Nooo that interview was a SLOG. You could tell Seamus wanted it so bad and Matt just couldn't muster the enthusiasm. I think they ordered a pizza at one point.
My grandfather says men should get married a little older (around 28 to 30) and use those early twenties to do great things. And that is what he did...I think it is good advice for lots of guys! Maybe not everyone and getting married at twenty can lead to your doing greater things :)
I both agree and disagree. I think it completely depends on the person and what greatness is in store for them. I think having the wife and kids could fuel them to become even greater or at least out a bit of focus in their lives, though where I agree is if it's something very time consuming and resource heavy, such as climbing everest or being in the military. Wouldn't wanna miss the most important years of my child's life
Most men don’t. Kids and children makes a man mature and strive for more out of love and duty. Men always married young in the past. They just always have been slightly older than the woman. But still in the same agerange.
He is not bashing it to say no one prefers it, he is bashing it to break people’s trance thinking its okay for men to shadow themselves from their friends due to a relationship
Idk if you’re a Christian but in the true orthodox ethos of the early church there are many teaching as to why you and your wife should not be “friends”. You are companions and bonded to eachother through matrimony but you are a protector and provider first.
Very off putting.. his view on masculinity and a man’s mission are really weird too. At one point he made a comment that having children do men want it or did the woman force the husband 🤨 what in the world does that even mean?
41:25 My brother lives in the town we grew up in and his son goes to the same schools we went to. My dad still lives in the same house we grew up in too. I wish my kids could grow up there. My daughter loves it when we visit and has said that she wants to live there too. My husband doesn’t want to have to shovel snow or pay over $10k in property taxes though, so that’s not going to happen.
I appreciate Matt because he always tries to speak with humility. John doesn’t seem to be able to do that. Hopefully that will come with age and wisdom, both of which he seems to be lacking at this stage.
All we can do is stream and say based things .. as a married man, and son of a carpenter... who has no practical skills ... and a theology and theatre degree.... yes....
The no weed and no adult entertainment argument sounds like the 1984 slavery is freedom argument. I say the real freedom is not having the desire in the first place. I think about how much less of a drug war or a drug sale we would have if someone addressed why anybody ever desired to try drugs. The most amazing comment I once heard was that opiates felt like the love they never got. This is why I say banning things is not an answer. It's just a band aid on a bullet wound.
I’m a millennial woman and… yeah I’m not feeling this interview. I like some of his heck off commie content but he talks down on women for using the new internet lingo yet he uses it a lot through this interview too 😂 and talking fast doesn’t make you sound smarter
I agree with a lot of what John said about DeSantis, that he ran prematurely and shouldn't have cozied up to the never-trumpers. However, I think he underplayed just how much DeSantis changed florida. Florida went from a joke of a state that no one really cared about except the gays in Miami, the retirees, and the spring breakers to a beacon of republicanism. He turned a squishy purple state deep red. He also didn't start with the unified government he has now, he largely created that (or at least created the environment that enticed voters to create that). To me, DeSantis's lack of charisma shows me that he isn't a normal political type, he's an effective guy that answered God's calling and changed the landscape of this country
Pot to me is a simple thing. #1) most people lionizing it just lie about it. That is a bad sign off the bat. #2) People I know who consume THC or Pot derivatives regularly when 100% sober commonly seem off. Like they are missing a step they can never get back. I don't know how to say it. Like even people who were stoners and quit a decade ago, you can tell before you know that they seem a split second slower than they should be, some odd subtle formation of the eyes too, like their eye movement, eye lid reactiveness... They seem slower and more perpectually tired. Tobacco is a thing if you can avoid habituation is full of benefits to you. Coffee similarly. I'm unsure of alcohol, but I know many high producing people who use it when they make time to slow down. I understand phsiologically it is just a poison but spiritually it seems fine if you avoid habituation.
Thursday has tweeted: "Nick is an ego maniac who does not care about anything but himself." You can speak all you want, but the truth is that no one else has a massive crowd of young men shouting "Christ Is King" and animated to turn America into a Christian country again.
@@piface3016 You're not very involved in Traditional Catholic circles then. I was just shouting "Viva Cristo Rey" with a bunch of dudes at March for Life and I don't think a single one of them knows Nick Fuentes. Besides that, these public displays are good, but don't mistake it for interior devotion.
Dear Mr. Doyle, I would like to present you with both praise and wisdom: Praise: Thank you for your good work on taking a stand against the sins of both porn and masterbation. They will both enslave and ruin a man's soul and his relationships. Wisdom: I picked up that your neither married or have children. I do believe your current philosophy on these topics will change If you get married and have children. In marriage a spouse's job is to help the other get to heaven. They are to be open to life and multiply. Then, raise their children to know and love God. It is not the parents job to grow an empire to make things easier for their children (that could actually be quite uncharitable). Nor is a Dad who chooses to get married and have children while choosing not to be an entrepreneur just simply going through life. Is Joseph (step father of Jesus) one of these Dads that just went kinda through life because he didnt choose not only to build himself an empire, but claim rightfully what was due to him. Is my grandfather, who had 7 children, raised them Catholic and provided for them by working as a janitor at his home parish at St. Peter's in Canton, just going through life? Am I simply going through life because I work hourly and choose to spend my free time taking my daughter to adoration, reading her stories and taking time to pay with her? The empire I'm persuing is permanent and I want nothing more for myself, spouse and children to be there with me. Additional wisdom: you may be referring to more of a single man's vocation as far as building an empire goes. Although not impossible, it is very difficult to balance priorities owed to family regarding God and building your own permanent empire. It's kinda similar to why in the Roman rite priests don't marry. It's hard to take on both vocations while keeping your soul heaven bound. P.S. Don't be gay man :)
