Commodore Buff | Planeswalker Party Precon Upgrades | Commodore Guff Precon 

You make a fantastic point. Which is also the real reason why I love planeswalkers. They’re a Swiss Army knife that can provide you multiple abilities for different scenarios and your opponents never know what you have up your sleeve.

Thank you so much, I really hope you enjoyed 😀

Thank you so much for your kind words, you just made my day. 😊

It’s a fantastic card, it’s just a little awkward putting it in because you end either removing a planeswalker or something like smothering tithe for it. If you don’t want to run smothering tithe then it’s a great substitution it just requires a good amount of setup for when it hits the third chapter.

You make a good point, I already have a planeswalker deck and I didn’t want to reuse the same ones so I was trying something different. At the end of the day, Saheeli is better for this deck or even the azorius Narset. Silent Arbiter is better than fog bank but I just wanted to try it out.

Don’t worry I take no offense to constructive criticism. However, before I took out any signets or lands the deck consisted of 12 mana rocks and 38 lands. I believe this to be way too much mana. That count is way too high and could lead to games where you’re constantly drawing mana producing cards instead of actually influencing pieces of cardboard. All I did was lower the mana rock count by 2 because I did add staff of completion and I also only removed 3 lands. So realistically my mana producing card count went down from 50 to 45. Which to be honest I still believe to be too high. You also have to take into account that the deck also has two Chandra’s that produce red mana. After playing with the deck for a few days now I actually find myself drawing into more mana than I need and might have to lower the count even more. This is all my opinion of course and I want to thank you for leaving a comment and hope to hear from you.

@@inittowinitmtgI think it probably depends on the speed of your meta, but I know I would prefer more mana sources than fewer, and I especially want as many cheap rocks as I can get. If you run the deck through a hypergeometric calculator, with 45 mana sources the chance that you will not hit 4 mana sources by turn 4 is about 20%, or 1 in 5 games. At 50, you cut that in half, to about 10%. I’d consider this pretty close to a fail case, because any game where I couldn’t play Guff or something of similar power by turn 3, is a game where I feel like the deck is falling behind. At 45 sources, this is only going to happen 75% of games, but at 50, about 85%. I actually stuck an extra rock in the deck for these reasons. In testing, I’ve been able to curve out, and there’s a lot of great card filtering that can keep you from flooding like Dack Fayden or Baby Jace. This is the hypergeometric calculator I used for this math: stattrek.com/online-calculator/hypergeometric

My playgroup is high power casual so I’m kind of the opposite. I run less mana producing cards but each of my decks will have at least 32 lands and 5 or 6 mana rocks. So I tend to run more things that help me look through my deck and you’re always going to run into a game where you don’t draw lands. It’s bound to happen but as long as know you’re decks mana curve you can optimize it to where it doesn’t happen that often.