Ex-Top Gear Star Sets Electric Car "Experts" Straight. Shocking Truth About EVs!

Подписаться 1,1 млн

Просмотров 642 тыс.

50% 1

Is it any wonder that politicians like Rishi Sunak & Donald Trump are pushing back so hard against Electric Cars when there is so much wrong with them? Too expensive, too heavy, flawed batteries, flawed infrastructure, & are they really 'greener ' anyway? These are just some of the things that we hear every day. So why are sales of battery electric vehicles growing like crazy around the globe?
Watch as an ex-Top Gear presenter & a 'scrapheap specialist' dismantle everything you thought you knew about electric vehicles. See the "Biggest Electric Car 'Bull' Shattered", & in front of a live audience. Isn't it time to #StopBS, & start to put the poor motorist & the beleaguered taxpayer first?
This episode was filmed very recently in Westminster in front of an assembled audience of politicians, press and motorists. Be sure to share 'the truth about electric cars' widely....
For more on the organisers of this event, head to: / stopburningstuff
There are several stories quoted in this episode, here are as many of them as we could fit here:
- "Electric cars are better for the climate than petrol or diesel" - Hannah Ritchie, Our World in Data; www.sustainabilitybynumbers.c...
- "EVs are really much better" - Auke Hoekstra, Eindhoven University of Technology; x.com/AukeHoekstra/status/133...
- "Do Electric Vehicles reduce air pollution?" - Hannah Ritchie, Our World in Data; www.sustainabilitybynumbers.c...
- "The End of the ICE age, and how EVs will win" - Rocky Mountain Institute; rmi.org/insight/x-change-cars
- "Consumer support key to faster and fairer EV transition as market enters new phase" - SMMT;
www.smmt.co.uk/2023/09/consum...
- "Battery makers slash cobalt intensity in face of accelerating demand" - SP Global; www.spglobal.com/commodityins....
- "Tesla is already using cobalt-free LFP batteries in half of its new cars produced" - Electrek; electrek.co/2022/04/22/tesla-....
- "Here’s why sodium-ion batteries are shaping up to be a big technology breakthrough" - CNBC; www.cnbc.com/2023/05/10/sodiu...
- "The electricity grid won’t be able to handle the increase in EVs" - National Grid; www.nationalgrid.com/stories/...
- "Electric cars catch fire less often than fossil fuel cars" - Swedish Civil Contingencies Agency; www.warpnews.org/transportati....
- "No EVs in the multi-storey car park collapse" - BBC News; www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-c...
- "No EVs in this multi-storey car park fire" - Sky News; news.sky.com/story/fire-has-d...
- "Do EVs produce more tyre & brake pollution than petrol and diesel equivalents?" - Euan McTurk; www.rac.co.uk/drive/electric-...
- “I'm Grateful That I Was Driving My EV When I Got Stuck On I-95” - ZETA; www.zeta2030.org/insights/im-...
- "Owning an electric vehicle in Europe could be cheaper than you think, new research shows" - World Economic Forum; europeansting.com/2023/02/23/...
- "Winter range for popular EV models" - Recurrent Auto; www.recurrentauto.com/researc...
- "Electric Car costs set to plummet" - Sky News; news.sky.com/story/electric-c...
#ElectricCars #ElectricVehicles #Tesla #NetZero #ZeroEmissions #Motorist #RishiSunak #DonaldTrump #ElonMusk #StopBurningStuff #TopGear #rowanatkinson
00:00 Intro
02:59 Doubt
12:40 Stand Up
14:48 EVs Cleaner?
19:14 Dirty Batteries?
29:08 Fire Risk?
34:12 Tyre Dust?
36:40 Grid Cope?
40:37 Invisible Infrastructure?
43:20 Heavy BEVs?
47:30 Too Expensive?
49:15 Too Soon?

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

27 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 5 тыс.

@netgnostic1627 6 месяцев назад

I'm 63. I have never in my life bought a new car. The most I've ever spent on a used car was $7500, Canadian - and that one was 7 years old, but with low mileage. I know I can't buy a used EV that's any good, for that price. Right now, that's my barrier to owning an EV.

@PeterJames143 5 месяцев назад

Yes, that's a few years away. You probably don't drive a lot or you would buy more expensive cars. But if you put a lot of miles on your car you could factor in the price of gas to your price. There are used EVs that are cheaper, but they're the ugly slow ones. Nissan Leafs and Chevy Bolts. But you're still looking at 12k or 18k respectively. You can check carvana. Leafs have a reputation for losing range, I don't know how well that is deserved though. I would think that unless you're in a warm part of Canada you might not want a cheaper EV because it might not handle the low temperatures too well. But to be honest you are very careful with money. And it is at least arguable that if your real full concern is the environment then it is better not to buy a car at all but live in a place with good public transportation, or if your real full concern is affordability then maybe the same solution is best. Maybe it is worth splurging on a used Tesla. Well I'm on carvana right now and I see a 2012 Mitubishi i-MiEV with 31k miles selling for $9,990. Range is 62 miles. :( That's the problem, half the cars these OEMs manufactured are basically golf carts, only useful as grocery or short commute cars. I commute to a city and this mitubishi would basically bring me halfway to the first point in my roundtrip visit.

@joandodds7626 5 месяцев назад

@@PeterJames143ANOTHER Canadian living in rural northern Canada, I must have a 4x4 to get to my house, which I have a unreliable hydro (electric) supplier that I pay Twice per kilowatt hour compared to cities, with a Diesel generator back up, I have fuel oil and propane as a heat source as well as water from my well because natural gas will not run a line to our community. I COMPLETELY DISAGREE with the EV brain wash scam as the closest Ev charging station is 1/2 hour drive away. I won’t get into our weather in Canada as it is what it is. Solar doesn’t work here... even if I clear cut my forest giving me shade. I truly believe that the corporate & government scam is spinning and shutting down the HYDROGEN being the TRUE SOLUTION! Conversion kits won’t sell new cars and won’t put massive tax dollars in the government! YOU keep and buy your EV’s but DO NOT try to shove your scam down my throat. GO TOYOTA & their hydrogen path👍‼️🇨🇦

@thomaswilson2917 5 месяцев назад

@@joandodds7626 hydrogen is a scam just designed to keep people buying gas powered cars. Hydrogen will never become a reality. Where do you think you will get hydrogen? Not at your home. Takes a lot of electricity to make hydrogen.

@laser_simon922 4 месяца назад

@@joandodds7626I‘m sorry, but this does not make sense. You live in a very special place and you have a very special situation. Just because it doesn‘t work for you, does not mean it is the wrong solution. 1. 4x4 EVs exist and can even work better than ICE 4x4. 2. ½ hour drive to the charge, I assume is simmilar to the next gas station and shops, so not ideal at the moment, but also not too bad. 3. If you get, e.g. the F150 lightning, you could power your home during cut outs up to 3 days, without the need for a diesel generator. and 4. Hydrogen is THE scam from big companies to still be able to sell you something they can put s huge margin on, like diesel. Because electricity (solar) can be „made“ by most people on their roof, but hydrogen has to be bought at a gas station or distributed with s grid. Which means you are still in need of these big coroprations…

@synnical77 4 месяца назад

@@laser_simon922 I also live in Canada (calgary) and don't have a garage so my family's three vehicles park in the driveway and street. Some winters it gets down to -30 Degrees celcius. Being forced into an EV is not going to work for me. The most expensive car I've ever purchased was a used 2013 Chevy Sonic 9 years ago for $15,000 CAD. Although EV's may fit many people's lifestyles they definitely don't fit mine. People living in apartment buildings and similar situations won't have personal garages and private charging stations. The early adopters are obviously the one's with ideal situations as they chose to go electric. Good for them. There's a huge amount of people who don't have the money or living conveniences to follow suit.

@katiemmm347 8 месяцев назад

As a EV owner if the ceo had asked the audience to stand if they were happy with the charging infrastructure I wonder how many would have stood 🤔

@StormyDog 8 месяцев назад

Probably just the Tesla owners (at least in the US).

@paulbuckingham15 8 месяцев назад

80 percent. That being representative of the charging infrastructure at home.

@jaffahassan4720 8 месяцев назад

Well all the Tesla owners would & some others who now use Teslas Super Chargers too, it’s all good 😊

@danielcarroll3358 8 месяцев назад

@@jaffahassan4720 Don't forget those who just use them for city driving and only charge at home. That's why some are happy buying a cheap early Leaf with a 30 mile range.

@DavidKnowles0 8 месяцев назад

No one happy about that. I also bet no one was happy about the petrol/diesel infrastructure when petrol/diesel cars come along. It will get done and people will find ways to cope whilst the infrastructure catches up.

@beckyrichmond2046 7 месяцев назад

The stand up, sit down game was a little silly using a massively biased audience but gave me a chuckle though 😂

@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Месяц назад

So what you’re saying is you should ask EV owners if they would buy another EV for their next car? Who should you be asking then?

@beckyrichmond2046 Месяц назад

@@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Can’t you read! What I was saying was that the stupid ass game made me laugh out loud, what did you not get from that after 5 fekin months!

@tommasoterzano5180 5 месяцев назад

The only problem hardly solvable is that, as demonstrated during the stand up part, this show can't pierce the audience bubble . Everyone that whatches the fully charged show already agrees with it, so it's very hard that it manages to convince new people to buy EVs

@SteveRomigsongwriter 4 месяца назад

Tesla is already outselling every other car manufacturer in the EV market and is the 2nd biggest selling car manufacturer in the world overall. The predictions are it will be the biggest overall, and by overall that includes ICE vehicles, by 2024. The cheapest Tesla’s, at around $25k us, will be coming out of China by the end of 2024 and that will be the nail in the coffin for ICE vehicles. Cyber truck preorders are at 2 million+ and rising. In spite of the blatant misinformation from the fossil fuel industry the adoption and sales of EV’s will continue to climb and the misinformation will get worse. And the misinformation is all shit.

@karlosh9286 4 месяца назад

I'd love for EVs to be better and cheaper than ICE vehicles. For me , currently they're not. That's the reality that needs to change for me to consider an EV. It's all really around the batteries, charging and cost. If it was just down to the electric-motor versus IC-engine, then we'd have all been driving EVs decades ago. electric motors are much simpler , more reliable, no need for clutches or multi ratio gearboxes, along with much simpler lubrication and cooling. Trains are predominantly electric, but they get their power via over head lines, or track based pickup, and don't require batteries and charging. In trains IC-engines are only used where the government has been too lazy or tight to electrify the lines. That has needed fixing for decades.

@SteveRomigsongwriter 4 месяца назад

@@karlosh9286 they are better and getting cheaper.

@karlosh9286 4 месяца назад

@@SteveRomigsongwriterI guess they're getting better and cheaper, but they're not better, more convenient or cheaper than ICE cars yet. When they are, then if I can afford one, I'll probably get one.

@HermanWillems 4 месяца назад

You are so right. EV's spread best by mouth by mouth and real life experience. Not by some forced show like this. Psychology says that people even though you are right don't like to get forced with it.

@williamarmstrong7199 8 месяцев назад

My MG5 Taxi is at 116000 fault free miles so far. My brake pads are not even 1/2 worn! Yes I have had to replace tyres but no quicker than I would expect to replace the tyres on an equally powerful fossil car. In total my vehicle has ises 2 liters of brake fluid (a pointless service requirement) and 1 liter of greabox / diferential oil (essential for long life). That is it. Oh and 2 headlight and 2 number plate lights and a quantity of screen wash. By 130,000 miles it will have saved me the cost of the vehicle in fuel savings alone. No drop in range visable yet nor performance.

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

If they stop refining crude oil for diesel and petrol, where will your transmission get it's oil from?

@user-sd3ik9rt6d 8 месяцев назад

Nicer to drive too?

@4literv6 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 plant's of course, there already plant based lubricants on the market.

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

@@4literv6 Used to love the smell of Castrol R in the morning! Lubricants can be made from many things. Are you suggesting we have enough arable land to grow food for everyone and grow all our lubricants?

@4literv6 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 well if we stopped growing corn for ethanol and used that lane for solar we could power our grid. So sure we can reuse some wasted crop space, or just do vertical indoor farming? 👍🏻

@DarkJonas33 8 месяцев назад

I own an EV, have solar panels and heat pumps. These technologies are much better than their fossil fuel equivalents. However, we also need to recognise they still have huge environmental footprints. Private EV ownership is much worse for the environment than walking, cycling and public transport. We should be able to hold both these ideas in our heads at once rather than resorting to the EVs are good or bad binary.

@fallinginthed33p 8 месяцев назад

It's the hidden cost of any large private vehicle, EV or ICE. My fear has been EV usage papering over unsustainable suburban lifestyles and low density sprawling developments.

@michaelhammond5106 8 месяцев назад

Well said 👏

@whowhy9023 8 месяцев назад

Ever decreasing environmental footprints. We will not go back to living in caves. EV batteries are getting more & more environmentally friendly and in 20 years when we can start recycling some car batteries they will become incredibly green.

@caleidoo 8 месяцев назад

The majority of people on this planet will never be able to afford those upgrades, either for their house or their car. Or at least get into heavy debt. Or they need a practical vehicle for work with a certain range and storage room - none of which can be done on foot. That is the reality so many keep ignoring and the main reaons why most people are still against buying an EV. Putting out comments implying "My life is great with my 50K-80K investment in new tech, everyone else not doing the same is just being difficult or doesn't want to save the planet" is just confirming those opinions. It's not hard to understand that you will not convince people to invest their life savings into something they don't need.

@MoaningGit 8 месяцев назад

@@caleidoo such a non educated reply. It doesn't cost that much to be efficient.

@Jimmy-ew2xe 7 месяцев назад

There will be kick back when people are pressured into something they don’t feel ready to try. Expense in these times, lack of infrastructure is a joke, government pressure is inappropriate and giving the impression of being corrupt.

@doingourbit8551 4 месяца назад

You can buy a brand new petrol /diesel car until 2035 (UK/Europe) and second hand after that, so the 'pressure' is being manufactured (more later about this) as objectively this is just a newer better option on the market. The infrastructure which gets so much headline isn't perfect bar arguably Tesla (but improving every week) but if you can charge at home and you need to at this point to make it viable, then for 90% of people it really isn't a problem as you will only use it 10% of the time. The expense now there are 2020 models pre owned at 10k (circa 200 mile range) less of an issue and this will only get better, but the real pressure a a consumer should be the air you breathe. Staggering really we been douped for so long that it's 'safe' given its a method of suicide in an enclosed space. The corruption is there, yes, but ironically it's the fossil fuel industry and parts of the automotive industry using think tanks and lobbying groups to influence government's that have been funding that... there is no dirty money flowing from the clean side as its not needed and the reason we are having this conversation. In a normal situation this is like switching from a dumb phone to a smart phone... but largely unlike that transition it didn't take money away from one very rich industry. This is the source of the pushback they are trying to transfer to consumers as they really don't like losing money. This gets repeated in the media daily in a desperate attempt to stop the transition, but thankfully it will fall because of ironically cost (it is cheaper and will only get cheaper still) and just a better product.

@unacceptablepiotr9976 4 месяца назад

This already happens with heat pumps. In a few countries people are paying 2-3x for heating their homes now than before when they had NG furnaces.

@doingourbit8551 4 месяца назад

@@unacceptablepiotr9976This can happen but only when incorrectly installed or installed in properties unsuitable for said. Otherwise they are usually a little cheaper. Have Air to air heatpump myself which is cheaper than running gas central heating but is a hell of lot easier to install than air to water... hense the issue plus the UK grant giving the false impression that going electric is only air to water.

@jericoba 3 месяца назад

Don't feel ready to try? Solution? Education. Besides, that pressure is subjective.

@trevorberridge6079 3 месяца назад

Infrastructure currently provides more chargers per EV than there are petrol pumps per ICE vehicle. And that's not including home charging.

@Sgt_Bill_T_Co 5 месяцев назад

Time will tell, But as a retired engineer I have seen far more well researched information on this subject than most, the pro's and cons - and for me, at this time and with the current offerings, lack of infrastructure, overall cost, and poor design of electric vehicles I'll stick with the car for long journeys, the motor cycle, push bikes & shank's pony (as well as using my OAP bus pass) for all other journeys. At the end of the day it's about disposable income, most folk don't have enough to buy EVs.

@ondago2 4 месяца назад

34 years engineer here and I agree in concept. I own 1 PHEV (Volt actually) and I can't find enough working charging in the past 5 years to "PLAY", EV. I drove 30k to 52k mi \yr on that car and over 100,000 per year across 4 cars & trucks plus a Good Wing motorcycle. I see a LOT and go to hundreds of gas stations and pass thousands of charge points. It's STILL Not NEARLY enough! Tesla, MAYBE and they front have enough for me to depend on our far enough of main interstates. All these other charging companies are a 75% downtime\creeping slow garbage like of an unusable mess. Never in my life have I gone to a great station that was down and had the pumps at the one across the street have the same non working problem making nearest gas be 50 miles away, unless power was out aha I've seen that overcome. Generators can run a pump or manual pumping is possible. Not true for 40 Amps @ 240V or 250kW at a Supercharger.

@thekaxmax 4 месяца назад

leasing, though, is affordable. Well, more affordable than buying one outright, and the price difference per km is so big it's much the same as paying off an ICE car loan.

@HermanWillems 4 месяца назад

@@thekaxmax in my country leasing has a big influence on your financial possibilities. Because that monthly payment they distract from what you can get for a mortgage... that's why people don't like leasing in this hot housing market it can destroy your chances to own a house.

@cayminlast 4 месяца назад

From my perspetive the entire EV industry is still in the experimental/R&D phase, there are some promising developements but untill the Battery Technology has been sorted it will take a while before it becomes accepted by all.

@thekaxmax 4 месяца назад

@@cayminlast yes, that's what we're going through. But acceptance and upgrading is happening. And new battery tech will be trivial to implement in older cars, all you need to do is match the casing shape and mounts, amps, and voltage, plus a software upgrade for the controller and sensors.

@lemongavine 8 месяцев назад

I never get into the environment debate with people. I tell them I bought an EV for the performance. It makes for a civilized discussion about the benefits of EV instead of arguing about which one is greener.

@FIGHTTHECABLE 8 месяцев назад

Good point

@SmolBiscuit 8 месяцев назад

Exactly! Speaking from owning an Electric Vehicle in the United States, the first thing I steer the discussion toward is the cost savings that I've experienced in owning an Electric Vehicle. The excitement of instant torque that comes with it, the environment is the last thing I touch if at all because THAT is the touchy subject. Most of the time by choosing performance and cost savings that's how I've convinced others to give Electric a try.

@lemongavine 8 месяцев назад

@@SmolBiscuit 💯

@kadmow 8 месяцев назад

- yes and that is the whole point, if it works for your use case and enjoyment, go for it. Long term whichever solutions use the least input energy will win. FUD goes both ways. Cost saving is to avoid if talking with folk who might not purchase high value new cars (for anyone with an annual 25-30k depreciation budget - the cost argument is moot) - the majority of purchasers of EVs still seem to be private (or salary sacrificing executives - price no object, nor barrier) affluent types - The average 3-5 year lease on a Tesla model 3 unlikely to cost less than my ICE (3 year) expense.

@Brian-om2hh 8 месяцев назад

I simply say any environmental benefits are purely incidental as far I'm concerned. I bought it because it's so much cheaper to run than my last petrol car....

@mrbc1848vu 8 месяцев назад

USA: I have had a VWID4 for 2 years - it works great. We drive it daily - doing errands/going to work (50 miles/day), soccer practices, etc, etc. It couldn't be more simple - we charge every night and drive a fully charged car each day w/ no issue. VERY VERY RARELY (1%) - do we have a challenge w/ range which we can overcome in a variety of ways. (eg - public charging station, even Tesla's Charge Station, etc). The take away after 2 years: EV's are CLEANER, EASIER, MORE ENJOYABLE TO DRIVE, BETTER ACCELERATION, & 99% of the time the range is not an issue. If you can have a 99% solution for ANYTHING - one should do it. We look forward to future improvements in range (eg Lucid 500 miles, etc).....like a computer, this EV battery technology will improve over time and become more & more affordable.

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

It's so strange that like you, most people would be fine with an BEV 99% of the time. But that 1% just puts them off so they don't try one and never know what they are missing. Hope something comes along in battery tech soon. We seem to have hit bit of a lull. Model S is now 12 years old and very little has changed.

@johndonovan7897 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 As someone that has owned 3 Model S vehicles (2013, 2015 and 2022), I have to disagree. The Model S may still look the same on the exterior, but "under the hood" there has been enormous improvements. For just one aspect, my 2013 Tesla went ~200 miles and my 2022 goes 405 miles on a charge. That combined with the Tesla super charger network means we now have a 100% solution.

@FIGHTTHECABLE 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 You should ride a horse. They have more benefits that a car in 99% of the time. It recharges itself for free and doesn't have road taxes. A horse also won't catch fire and can off road in all terrain. You won't be needing those pesky blocked motorways anymore. Parking is of course free and you sitting on that horse is a big win for the girls out there! Buy a horse, the only 1% downside is, it doesn't go very fast.

@phillargus2757 8 месяцев назад

@@FIGHTTHECABLE Where in hells name did you get the idea that riding a horse is cheap? Farriers fees alone would fix you right up!!! Nevermind stabling, grooming and feeding.

@robinhood4640 8 месяцев назад

@@phillargus2757 That's all misinformation. You are just talking nonsense to stop people riding horses to work. Horses don't need special shoes, they can wear slippers from Tesco and they eat plastic waste and rubble, which is not only totally free of charge, it's also good for the environment. Stop lying.

@rwkh10 7 месяцев назад

It's now fully respected that if you drive within the range of your home EV is very good. If you want to travel over your range it's a disaster.

@johnmitchinson9577 4 месяца назад

Has House insurance cover increased with the rise in reported EVs spontaneously catching fire and burning down the house. EV car insurance is also going up.

@user-wt7ec1pb7u 4 месяца назад

& they make great fire starters

@hcw199 4 месяца назад

15 minute city. Car won't get you any further!

@Tschacki_Quacki 4 месяца назад

What is a "disaster" about going to the bathroom, grabbing a coffee and browsing 5min on my phone? 😂 It would be a disaster if I wouldn't go to the bathroom.

@davidfogg1845 4 месяца назад

@@user-wt7ec1pb7u 19 times less likely than your petrol burner

@garyandrews8005 7 месяцев назад

You now need to talk about insurance companies, they are raising the premiums to crazy costs, some are refusing to now insure EV cars

@ondago2 4 месяца назад

Somebody in my family just Got Lyriq, and the insurance jumped up another extra $1000 / 6 months from their 2 year old Cadillac XT5. It's not safe, it's not brand because they are both basically new Cadillacs. There's nothing left but the EV-ness and maybe construction. They are an 80 year old could BTW so no it's not age either.

@stan3452344 4 месяца назад

Insurance companies raise rates when claims go up. When you have to replace a battery after a fender bender and the battery costs 25-50k, the only consequence you can expect is that your insurance goes up.

@george6977 3 месяца назад

Insurers realise that an EV battery fire may not only write off your car but your house aswell or destroy a multi story car park.

@DavidJohnson-yg8qm 3 месяца назад

Insurance companies base their costs on risk.

@ondago2 3 месяца назад

In response to the first few comments in agreeance insurance is based on risk so keep in mind that there are absolutely atrocious resale values for EV cars now The risk that insurance is worried about is partially writing off a car for being damaged they're extremely expensive pretty fragile if they're hit in terms of electronics and wiring and keep in mind that the decision to write off a car is based on the cost to fix it versus what it's worth if the resale value is incredibly low very soon after you buy it like weeks after than anything that damages it cost way more than what you're going to get for the car at wholesale than they won't pay to fix it because if you don't want it they don't want to have the car turned over to them for scrap and they got nothing that they can do anything with.

@db7948 8 месяцев назад

The fact that Sunak is scaling back on Ev targets while his family have such deep ties with oil companies is disgraceful.

@wolfgangpreier9160 8 месяцев назад

Its not disgraceful when its pure survival on his part. Imagine his wife having to tell her Papa that he will loose a few hundred trillions in 10 years?

@Brian-om2hh 8 месяцев назад

@@wolfgangpreier9160 Only one letter O in lose.....

@wolfgangpreier9160 8 месяцев назад

@@Brian-om2hh Ahh yes, you are of course wright...

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

@@wolfgangpreier9160 😂😂 I see what you did there!

@wolfgangpreier9160 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 Gut Gut! 😎

@IDann1 8 месяцев назад

My 10 year old Zoé is going strong, 80k 92% Battery,and hasn't caught fire 🔥 yet.

@mbak7801 8 месяцев назад

Hmmm. My two year old Zoe also has 92% battery.

@IDann1 8 месяцев назад

@@mbak7801 maybe the BMS is a bit sticky, I'm 5,months new to EVs inherited from family.

@MrIsmilealot 8 месяцев назад

9 year old Leaf 107,000 km 90% Battery original brakes 3rd set of tyres and wipers and 2 cabin air filters thats it ! oh and no fires.

@peterwells2142 8 месяцев назад

Hmm@@mbak7801my 3 year ZE50 also has 92% SoH at 29k miles!

@swecreations 8 месяцев назад

Same thing with my 2014 Zoe!

@davebaker8362 6 месяцев назад

Are you going to challenge Geoff buys cars to a driving challenge to prove ev are better than ice vehicles

@ImLivinSD Месяц назад

Very hard to actually find discussions that host both sides of the issue. Funny how Not a Single EV caught fire in the Audience ? and they did not acknowledge that when EV's catch fire its typically pretty Fatal and UNSTOPABLE !

@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Месяц назад

@@ImLivinSDit is difficult to stop. But hardly fatal. Thermal runaway takes a VERY long time to take hold. Between 0.5-1.5 hours. Meanwhile a combustion car can be completely engulfed in flames in under a minute. As for the likelihood of a fire. Even insurance companies and safety regulators across the globe agree EV’s are some 20-60 times less likely to combust compared to an ICE.

@mikestanton571 7 месяцев назад

That stand up if piece was pointless, a captive audience, it’s like asking the audience at the Tory party conference if they will vote Tory.

@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Месяц назад

So you shouldn’t be asking EV owners if they would buy another EV as their next car? Who should you be asking then?

@peterdurnien9084 7 месяцев назад

I keep seeing videos of burning EV's, some just parked, some in use, some being charged. They produce plenty of smoke when they burn.

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

Whoever invents the fire suppression chemical or system for EVs is gonna be a billionaire.

@muskrat3291 4 месяца назад

@@crtmojo2705 Google "EV Fire Cloak"

@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Месяц назад

And yet road safety authorities and even insurance companies around the world agree that EV’s are 20-60 times less likely to combust than ICE. And if you crunch the numbers you find that EV fires are reported disproportionately around 200x more often than ICE fires. As in, if you every car fire, regardless of drive type, had an equal chance of being reported. You’d see 200 headlines about an ICE car fire for every 1 headline of an EV car fire.

@engineeringtheweirdguy2103 Месяц назад

The problem being that EV car fire news, sells headlines, and gets clicks. Ice car fires don’t. Nobody cares unless someone famous dies .

@tzeimet 8 месяцев назад

What difference does it make if the Westminster government is moving the goalposts if local authorities like TFL are pushing for a ban on combustion engine vehicles by 2030? With European cities such as Paris (most major French cities in fact), Barcelona and Amsterdam following suite, surely the possibility of being banned from most major cities is enough to put people off buying a combustion engine vehicle in the next few years.

@FIGHTTHECABLE 8 месяцев назад

They will just have to feel it when time comes. Then people won't want to buy those cars 2nd hand cars anymore and the idiots that bought them ICE cars, will have to sell them with a value loss. I'm okay with people buying ice cars, I don't need to support them in their financial decissions. 😊

@christophmartin5381 8 месяцев назад

I guess it is the try to prevent delays. And that is important, there is no time to loose. Propaganda against a brighter should be prevented at nearly all cost. I think this campaign is good! But I want to mention that this campaign should be hold with normal people who do not own EVs and PVs etc...

@christophmartin5381 8 месяцев назад

...brighter future....

@richardkingadi5511 8 месяцев назад

The UK produces 1% of global carbon. If you took every single rehicle off the road - and the UK sank beneath the waves, it would make a miniscule difference to climate change... ;)

@Nikoo033 8 месяцев назад

@@richardkingadi5511what matters is the lack of climate change leadership that it shows, from one of the major economy in the world.

@lightworkeight4136 4 месяца назад

Oh, they want to stop burning stuff, maybe they should start by stopping the burning of EVs, LI batteries, garages, houses, car parks, rows of buses, ferries, eBikes, eScooters. What an unfortunate choice of mantra....could not agree more.

@superchargedxjr 7 месяцев назад

Very interesting. I think the pace of introduction and government dictat are the issues. The EV as an option is fine. I am also minded that Quentin Wilson told his audience at a Jaguar dealership launch at Park Royal, NW10 that the future for cars is hydrogen power and not electric.

@timsmith5339 6 месяцев назад

@superchargedxjr I confess that I was hopeful for hydrogen until very recently too. I don't think you can knock a man who will go with the evidence when it is presented to him though. For many years I was happy to go with popular opinion on these things until I realised how blatantly wrong public opinion sometimes is. Now, if it matters, I dig deeper and find credible, trusted and corroborated sources with evidence before I leap onto the nearest bandwagon. I cannot believe that people (especially big business with profits at stake) can lie so openly without finding themselves in criminal proceedings.

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Depends who is paying him LOL

@thekaxmax 6 месяцев назад

hydrogen's not efficient enough unless it's a fuel cell. And those have a way to go at the moment, and refuelling a bugger.

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Its also storing hydrogen as it takes a lot of electricity to cool it.@@thekaxmax

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

@@thekaxmaxexactly. Once we have enough electrical energy sources; we can make hydrogen cheaper and sell it at a reasonable price. We may have to bring back full service stations with trained techs for refueling. I see people smoke and use their phones at the gas stations too often.

@SirHackaL0t. 8 месяцев назад

I was told this year that EVs are great around town but you can’t go further afield. I told him I drove to Hamburg for a weekend, did 10 days holiday driving around Norway. Not sure how much further around town I’d have to go.

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

Norway is a lovely country. They have taken to EV's like a duck to water. Rural France, another place I like to go, not so good for EV's.

@JakobusVdL 8 месяцев назад

Depends where you live. Can we assume its not on the northern outskirts of Humburg?

@djtaylorutube 8 месяцев назад

Yes, apparently they're only suitable for going to the local shops. I wanted to buy a gift for my daughter from a "local shop", except the shop was in Switzerland. We're in the middle of the UK. I wish I had been told that this wasn't possible before we set off. Silly me! :)

@SirHackaL0t. 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 Norway taxes new cars in such a way that EVs are way cheaper than ICE cars. There’s a video on YT explaining why.

@SirHackaL0t. 8 месяцев назад

@@JakobusVdL lol, correct. :) I lived in Eastbourne, UK at the time.

@HermanVonPetri 8 месяцев назад

Whenever my conservative family members complain about high gasoline prices I always remind them that we have an opportunity to give up gasoline and ignore the expense and uncertainty of a global oil market that's being manipulated by organizations who purposely drive up prices only to enrich themselves, and make us reliant on them through economic blackmail.

@jaffahassan4720 8 месяцев назад

Touch’e you know it makes sense it’s all good😊

@jamesgrover2005 8 месяцев назад

Not to mention the wars they create in the middle east resulting in waves of refugees.

@roland9367 8 месяцев назад

Exactly this

@kellyklingbeil5802 8 месяцев назад

And the power companies are immune to such character flaws as greed? Once a majority of the fleet is electric you don't think they will hold people hostage?

@MandyFlame 8 месяцев назад

@@kellyklingbeil5802yes, but I have enough solar on my roof to cover my needs and charge my car. A huge hedge against runaway electricity prices while is not possible to hedge against oil prices. (And yes, I’m privileged in owning a house with a suitable roof, but I could equally invest in a community microgrid)

@pacificbob24 4 месяца назад

Unfortunately, with the extreme cold we’ve experienced in western Canada, electric vehicles are a liability. Almost every car I see abandoned on the side of a freeway is an electric car. The range in cold weather is reduced substantially. Also, wait times at charging stations are up to 4 hours because the cold weather severely increases charging time. Range anxiety is intensified in the frigid weather.

@Clampett01 5 месяцев назад

As a very early adopter, I love my electric cars and motorcycles for my local commuting. They are perfect for 90% of my journeys. I have ventured further afar on many occasions over the years. What was a pleasure with FOC rapid chargers and very few EV’s on the road it was easy. As more and more cars come onto the market, the infrastructure has become overwhelmed. More than likely charge points are now either busy, blocked or broken. I have had to purchase a long distance fossil fuel car to keep my sanity in check and prevent high levels of stress in my life. Please do not deny or argue against this fact, I too wish it was a myth. Only Tesla drivers have some immunity through their supercharger network. Fully charged, please your efforts into lobbying to fix the UK’s broken charging infrastructure. BTW it’s all about location and management. Installing high power chargers in Village co-op car parks is ridiculous. They are rarely, if ever used and It just pisses off the villagers who loose a couple of valuable car parking slots.

@billpaliwoda5012 4 месяца назад

When somebody says "Please do not argue against this fact" it means "My argument is completely anectodical and has no data to back it up". The Tesla Supercharger network is widespread and very reliable (96% are operational at any given time). Granted the other networks are less reliable (only 76-80%) and not as widespread. You say "They are perfect for 90% of my journeys". Well my Toyota Avalon is suitable for 90% of my needs but then I also need a truck for doing my occasional handyman gigs. Does that mean Toyota Avalons are no good? No, it means that one vehicle can't over all yours needs 100% of the time. Why is this OK for ICE cars but not for EVs. Granted the charging network in the UK may be shit, that is a UK-specific problem. It's pretty robust here in the US. Finally, even though the chargers may all be busy, the people there are not all charging from 0-100% taking 60-90 minutes. Many are only charging for 5-15 minutes so chargers will continually be becoming available. When I pull into highway service areas I typically have to wait 10-20 minutes just to get to the gas pump (though every time I stopped to charge my Tesla there has always been open chargers). We'll have to see what happens what happens when the Supercharger networks is open to all EVs.

@wojciechjanecki9221 4 месяца назад

Widze ze pasuje ci spadek wartosci twojego samochodu o 40+% po pierwszym roku uzytkowania. Za chwile nie bedziesz mogl parkowac w garazach podziemnych ani uzywac promow w swoich podruzach, ale to nic dla fana samochodow na baterie.

@johntanner5215 7 месяцев назад

Hhmmm - what about the 40% of people on average income living in flats who cannot charge at home? Public charging is frankly not cutting in terms on availablity or cost, especially on the motorways.

@peterpan6821 7 месяцев назад

Poor people can catch the bus.

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

If my boss would add some at work; I would gladly pay to charge. 8 hours. Low level. Easy on the batteries. I’m there 5 days a week. Just waiting on the businesses to catch up. Anywhere you spend 30 mins or more is great place to charge.

@Skiridr22 7 месяцев назад

The worse thing is when a well respected educated public figure repeats and try to push disinformation on others

@danielcarroll3358 7 месяцев назад

We've been here before. It's just that everyone is dead who would have remembered, "Get a horse!"

@markstarmer3677 7 месяцев назад

I think the powers that be must think the majority of us are stupid. EVs are miles away from being a serious alternative to petrol and diesel. They have their own agenda which inevitable isn't ours.

@DrMontague 7 месяцев назад

The solution: build a state of the art public transport system, have thousands of free electric taxis on the roads, this will take millions of cars off the road, our carbon foot print would reduce dramatically. Amazing that no one has thought of this!

@markstarmer3677 7 месяцев назад

@DrMontague at tax payers expense ! Why this country wastes money on carbon associated issues when China, Russia, India, Brazil etc don't bother. We are a pin prick on the global map, why make uk citizens suffer this pathetic green tax. The aforementioned countries must be laughing their heads off at our pathetic liberal government. Labour ironically would be ten times worse.

@richardweyland116 7 месяцев назад

@@DrMontague Sure they have. Watch the movie Soylent Green. That's the goal with this BS. How many active volcanoes are on this planet? How much emissions do they produce?

@fluffycotton4683 7 месяцев назад

An eminent professor recently stated that “our world does not have enough earth to dig for lithium” One ton of suitable lithium requires mining and processing as much as 500 tons of earth. How much does these processes cost in terms of money and more importantly, environmental damage in so many ways? Not sustainable, Not acknowledged, Not acceptable.

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

There’s also brine extraction and the closed system of recycling. If they can maintain the lithium within the system, less is required for mining. Let’s not forget how we get oil out of the ground with drilling and fracking and military might.

@daphnethornton4829 7 месяцев назад

The figures on car numbers quoted is nothing in comparison go by the number of ICE cars on the road when doing a true comparison of fires in cars go by %.

@olisipocity 7 месяцев назад

I will consider go electric if you can explain a few things to me. 1 - If I live in the 20th floor of a building of 40 with four flats per floor with no parking on the basement or a public park in the vicinity, just the street of a neighborhood made up of similar buildings all around, how do I charge? 2 - If i am going on a holiday driving on the road to some touristic site, along side hundreds or thousands of other cars and maybe 10 or 20 cars are already parked at a service station (as already has happened), what is the minimum acceptable time that I should wait for my turn? 3 - If my work implies being ready to go and drive at any moments notice 24/7 on journeys that exceed the battery's capacity and you have to keep to a tight schedule? What will happen to the electric grill if the demand increases to the full need of 1.44 billion vehicles estimated to be in circulation today? 4 - If a fire starts because or despite of a battery or charger in an underground garage, and it leads to a thermal runaway reaction, would you be comfortable to live or work, or having your children in that building? Are you confident that the fire fighters are well equipped to cope with the situation? I could go on, but I think these ones are enough. Don't you?

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

You have identified the major business opportunities associated with EVs. Problems = solutions that customers will pay for.

@olisipocity 5 месяцев назад

@@crtmojo2705 And Christmas comes once a year...

@neilanderson2374 2 месяца назад

You need to just try one. I was skeptical, my wife bought an MG EV. Its been flawless for 20k miles. Range is bob on and the driving experience is greatly improved Yes you have to plan journeys better; but more infrastructure is coming online all the time.

@olisipocity 2 месяца назад

@@neilanderson2374 Thanks, but no, thanks. This is my 3rd hybrid LPG car. The last one, I bought second hand and I made over 400.000 km on it no problems, and even sold it to someone else. Didn't go to scrap.

@Krueger444 8 месяцев назад

I had someone recently tell me that they wouldn't get an electric car until an electric minivan got 600km/charge and fully recharged in 7 minutes. The goalposts are on a rocket sled zipping across the salt flats.

@robinrdale8318 8 месяцев назад

There’s a car company that can change the hole battery for a new one for about that time . But range is still not there yet

@theelectricmonk3909 8 месяцев назад

Ironically, they'll probably not have to wait more than 10 years to get their wish.... Some EVs are already up in the 400km/charge range, and the 800v ones (like the Hyundai Ionic 5) can already charge to ~80% in a little over 10 minutes... New battery tech + high voltage architecture + ultrafast chargers will likely bring that 600km/7 minute "dream" to reality.

@Tom55data 8 месяцев назад

And he has bottles in his van full of pee.

@thelifeofbatteries2603 8 месяцев назад

my car will already do more than 600km

@Brian-om2hh 7 месяцев назад

It does make me wonder how these people would have coped in the days when we all used horses?

@paulinmazurek2769 6 месяцев назад

Nearly all the audience drive an electric car amazing .

@MrMarkieg 4 месяца назад

Nearly all the audience are sheep and naively believing that their choice of transport is the future!

@PatrickDraper 4 месяца назад

Because the audience aren't morons and realize that electric cars are 1) better than ICE cars 2) aren't dedicated to signalling to people around them that they're Trump fans.

@beastieboy3926 7 месяцев назад

Seems the insurance industry is now realising how expensive these things are to repair and how easy they are to write off.Much anecdotal evidence of massive increase in premiums,and resale values are a real concern.

@steve6375 7 месяцев назад

Is it true that any EV involved in a prang has to have a 15m exclusion zone around it? Plus battery technology will leap frog in 2026/27 which could double the range of new cars, so the value of the current EVs (made in China using 90% coal fired energy) will plummet and they will be recycled/scrapped after just 5 years of life - surely that isn't green?

@jgreen9361 7 месяцев назад

Anecdotal. That is how a nugget of truth is turned into a big fat lie. The truth. In the U.K., the average cost of insuring an EV is 9% higher than a petrol car. That is less than you might think because the average value of an EV is 23% higher. So beastieboys claim is untrue, but what is the nugget of information that has generated the story? Some models of EV are indeed more difficult to repair than others. The cost of insurance of some EVs has gone up significantly, but the cost for other models has come down relative to the average. This is because, with more EVs on the road they are generating more detailed data for insurance companies to set their prices for specific models.

@kiwipics 7 месяцев назад

Unfortunately the average (actually the mean) person on the street cannot afford to buy an EV, and secondhand EVs make so sense.

@greyangelpilot 7 месяцев назад

@@jgreen9361 In the world of the Anecdotal, Sensational & Viral, it appears even the largest financial institutions in the world bought into SBF FTX Crypto Exchange. Despite resources to conduct Due Diligence, they simply got caught up in the Hype & False Hopes. Human being's are particularly prone to chase the shinny, exciting moving objects of the world. Let's hope we can do better at being objective & rational over important decisions.

@guyboisvert66 7 месяцев назад

@@jgreen9361 Exactly. Just desperately trying to twist reality or plain lying, the ICE car companies are late to the party and they know it. While they were too busy laughing at Tesla, the sheer lack of vision was doing its thing. So now that they have a really steep hill to climb, they're left to use the same old crappy deceptive tactics to try gaining time...

@snoopy10411 7 месяцев назад

What a surprise that those people in the audience who can all afford a £30k+ car all charge at home. How will someone with on street parking or living in a block of flats charge an EV without paying more expensive tarrifs at public charging stations? Good video on the whole but still managed to miss out lots of other basic concerns people have. Is there a way to submit questions to be discussed next time?

@patrickcardon1643 7 месяцев назад

I think we all agree the lack of exhaust gasses are perfect for city use, however practically and financially it is not a replacement for current cars. They should look at the whole user base and in particular the user with less financial means. EVs are alternatives but cannot be considered (at this moment) a complete replacement solution for all combustion vehicles. People tend to go for a one solution for everything while reality is much more complex (after all we do not use a passenger car to transport a container, and a truck to drop off kids at school, we don't use a small city car to get around in the countryside). What we want are real solutions and working alternatives, not an alternative only for the well off

@hunchanchoc8418 7 месяцев назад

@@patrickcardon1643 To be fair, I do use a small city car (15 y.o.) to get around in the countryside; not-infrequently doing 600+ miles in 2 days. I get about 60 mpg, on petrol. I find I get into the car, travel, and arrive at another place... ...exactly as I would in a larger car! Admittedly I have to wear earplugs and my body gets fair pummelled-about.

@patrickcardon1643 7 месяцев назад

@@hunchanchoc8418 oh it's possible, just as you could drop off your kid with your truck ... just not optimised ;) You can do long distances with a small battery EV, you'll just take waaaaay more time to do it

@hunchanchoc8418 7 месяцев назад

@@patrickcardon1643 We're in agreement :-)

@LuciusC 7 месяцев назад

Charging can be set up anywhere that cars can park. In fact it'd be ideal to charge during the day when your personal vehicle is parked at work. But even if that's not an option I'd wager the public charging stations are still cheaper than any gas station.

@cbcdesign001 8 месяцев назад

The irony is this video is aimed at myth busting but the some will still post those same mistruths in the comments without bothering to watch the video

@ElRel 8 месяцев назад

Deffo.... They need to jump to 15:00 where the facts start

@t1n4444 8 месяцев назад

No. The entire show was quite slick, without doubt, however being slick, in the same way as Trump rally, does not mean it's all true.

@RoonMian 8 месяцев назад

@@t1n4444 What in the video in particular was not true? Please show your sources.

@GrahamRead101 8 месяцев назад

@@t1n4444 apart from, well facts, given from people actually running fleets of EV's.....

@t1n4444 8 месяцев назад

@@RoonMian Seriously? You swallowed it whole. That type of presentation is what is known as greenwashing. Of you believed that stuff then good for you. I objected to the glib comment that batteries cars are "green" yet no mention of how much green energy was used for charging or indeed how much fossil fuel. Rishi has signed off on Rosebank exploitation so UK will see some of the output. Who can say then how clean the energy is, or will be, for charging EVs? .

@tullochgorum6323 5 месяцев назад

They don't address the real show-stopping issue, which is that mining industry analysts say that there is nothing like enough rare earth metal supplies coming on stream to meet the demand for even the advanced countries to transition to EVs. No amount of magical thinking will overcome this. We should be focusing on alternative green technologies if we really want to stop burning stuff.

@Skotty64081 4 месяца назад

I don't think this will be a problem. Rare earth metals aren't really that rare, an in each case where there could be shortages, alternatives exist. The most common rare earth shortage argument I've seen in the past is for the permanent magnet motors, but A/C induction motors are an alternative that have already been used on a lot of different EVs. Pretty much all shortages will be addressed by either switching to alternatives or increased mineral extraction. The industry will adapt as needed.

@AnalogX64 7 месяцев назад

I've been the proud owner of a Hyundai Kona EV for a delightful 16 months now, and I must say, I'm never looking back at traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. Each morning, I kick-start my day with a full charge, which sets me back a mere $1.5 to $3 when I charge it at home, and even better, it's absolutely free at my workplace. With nearly 25,000 kilometers logged on the odometer, my Kona has been a model of reliability, requiring only the scheduled maintenance checks. The first scheduled maintenance, which came due at 14,000 kilometers, cost me a modest $88. The second, at 24,000 kilometers, was slightly pricier at $350. But what a difference from the days of regular oil changes and the constant mental gymnastics of timing my gas purchases with the ever-fluctuating fuel prices. Gone are the days of the pervasive gas smell and the constant upselling attempts at gas stations, when all I really wanted was to pay for fuel. That being said, I do acknowledge that electric vehicles may not be suitable for everyone and every situation. However, if the opportunity arises for you to make the switch to an EV, I wholeheartedly endorse it as one of the most rewarding decisions you can make. It's an experience that's truly transformed my perspective on driving and vehicle ownership.

@mikestanton571 7 месяцев назад

Your cheap charging will not last, governments who will be losing millions from tax on fuel for ice vehicles will find a way to get that back,

@aaronsmegmasson7184 7 месяцев назад

Realize that car is still a baby at that mileage

@retiefgregorovich810 7 месяцев назад

Good for you. I'll buy an EV when there is no other choice.

@jackmorganfiftyfive 5 месяцев назад

Good to know that your employer pays for your fuel. Not many here work for a company that does that.

@muskrat3291 4 месяца назад

I also drive a Kona EV. I am averaging 4.3 miles/kWh. I will never go back to gas.

@BobQuigley 8 месяцев назад

Our Miele electric heat pump dryer plugs into standard outlet and uses less the 900 watts while operating. No hole in our house for exhaust.

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

Learn something new everyday. Thanks!

@lukeclifton4392 8 месяцев назад

Why are Americans so behind in this kind of stuff. Condenser and heat pump dryers have been in use the world over for 10+yrs. Inverter AC compressors 20yrs in Asia-pacific, yet only becoming a thing in the US recently!

@crtmojo2705 5 месяцев назад

@@lukeclifton4392Americans can get dug in on an idea. Despite the facts. And their news sources aren’t very trustworthy.

@ohnoitisnt 2 месяца назад

happy with my 5kw 0.5L/hr red diesel burner. 90p/L

@paulus1011 7 месяцев назад

Sounds so rosy! So why then has John lewis insurance had a moratorium on electric car cover? also why has the cost of insurance for electric cars skyrocketed?

@roviwoteap2375 7 месяцев назад

Not to mention (which they didn’t) that the price to charge an EV has gone up - now no cheaper than filling up at the petrol station.

@AnonymousAndy2 7 месяцев назад

Ok, so less likely to catch fire compared to ice cars, but when they do catch fire they are very difficult to put out due to thermal runaway!

@brucevernon5827 4 месяца назад

One fact is the amount of evs sitting in paddocks around the world no one wants, what will be the impact on the environment will these car's make with there battery's, and the loss of resale to the customer

@Brian-om2hh 27 дней назад

But can you tell us exactly where these paddocks full of EV's that nobody wants, actually are?

@takenoshortcuts 8 месяцев назад

This needs to be widely spread, that ~"the (ev) car pays back it's carbon debt in 12-17 months and then, after that, it's in a huge credit..." and "~if you took all the alternative energy CO2 emissions (batteries, wind, solar, etc) over 30 years it would only equal 6 months of Oil emissions..."

@andybrice2711 8 месяцев назад

Though as I understand it: That does depend upon where you live. If you're in a US state where most of the electricity is generated from coal. And you tend to make longer journeys. Then it is possible that an electric vehicle is no greener than a combustion vehicle.

@lukeclifton4392 8 месяцев назад

The average EV world wide breaks even around the 8yr mark, the general battery replacement timeframe is 10yrs…. Bringing in a huge CO2 input again from the battery replacement. Wind turbines have a lifespan of 15yrs (non recyclable), solar 10yrs…. But that really doesn’t matter because most of the world are charging at night when those renewables are operating.

@timscott3027 8 месяцев назад

I crunched the numbers once and I worked it out somewhere around 20000 miles or so I can't remember exactly. All EVs will produce less co2 over their lifespan Vs any petrol or diesel. Some better some worse, also true of ice. I think it's important to remember that co2 isn't the only thing that matters with EVs too. Local air pollution for me is way more important.

@MegaWilderness 8 месяцев назад

The problem is that only the wealthy can afford new cars

@waynecartwright-js8tw 7 месяцев назад

@@andybrice2711 Define "Greener" does it include brake dust, clutch dust , cam/alternator drive belt particulates, fuel / lubricant leaks ?

@mddah01 8 месяцев назад

When I returned to Australia in 2019, I wanted to do my best to reduce emissions from our home and personal transport. I had a 200 km round trip to drive to work and public transport was not available. There was little guidance at the time, but I did some basic math, took a big swallow, and bought 40 solar panels, a 10kW home battery and a Tesla Model 3. The initial cost was high - $25,000 for the home system and $70,000 for the car. Four years later after 130,000 km in the (mainly) solar-charged EV and a house with aircon, ovens and a pool, my energy costs have been almost zero (mainly connection fee for the grid). I was skeptical and nervous about the original decisions but now it’s a complete no brainer. I fully understand that I am privileged in owning a home with enough roof space for solar, a suitable climate, and enough money to buy a Tesla. But I am far from being alone. If you own a home in 2023 and have no solar and a Range Rover (or two) in the drive, you are actually being a dickhead.

@DavidKnowles0 8 месяцев назад

Not neccessary, some people can't do this in the UK because they live in a conservation area, so the law prevents them from putting in solar on the roof or even replacing windows with double glazing in some cases.

@MjMurphy777 8 месяцев назад

😆👍

@zagan1 8 месяцев назад

@@DavidKnowles0 That's the overall problem. Some will have the money to spend but a renter will never be allowed to do this ever.

@ukandrew 7 месяцев назад

@@DavidKnowles0 Fair true comment and you raise an important issue. The present rules are all backwards when you can’t upgrade, insulate or add solar because it's a ‘conservation' area. If we carry on with that attitude there will be nothing left to conserve!

@hunchanchoc8418 7 месяцев назад

I'm glad that you understand you are privileged, and if I were in your position I would do the same - it's a no-brainer; good on ya. Now if only the govt or someone would give me $100,000 I too could reduce my energy bills to near-zero. If the Fed would just print the dollar bills (like they do anyway) and hand them out, *everybody* could do the same. But the laughable irony is, after all that, the climate would still keep changing.

@JPS-hd8qz 4 месяца назад

I suppose all those poor people in the audience are there for the free drinks and food...

@magnusa1386 Месяц назад

... or to shout hallelujah after each EV catchphrase.

@smacfe4076 4 месяца назад

So I'm supposed to believe a bunch of blokes whose livelihood depends on selling electric vehicles? Oh, and also, they are in the entertainment industry; which has always told nothing but the truth without distortion.

@simonb3225 2 месяца назад

Best to trust the billion dollar fossil fuel industry. They never lie.

@pauleedeehimself8489 7 месяцев назад

37.000km on the original tires on my Hyundai Ioniq5. If you constantly launch in Tesla Ludicrous mode you eat through the tires like candy. But if you drive normally... the tires are just fine.

@MrBigbangbuzz 5 месяцев назад

Mates M3 , just 10km before needing tyres

@pauleedeehimself8489 5 месяцев назад

😂

@MrBigbangbuzz 5 месяцев назад

@@pauleedeehimself8489 he’s a led foot . Model s tyres you are lucky to get 15k on them

@trevorshields7347 5 месяцев назад

Like anything. It's how you drive@@MrBigbangbuzz

@MrBigbangbuzz 5 месяцев назад

@@trevorshields7347 mates mode 3 dual motor he’s in his 4 set of tires at 55k km

@ashodgkin 7 месяцев назад

Talk about preaching to the converted. They should do the same show with an exclusive audience of petrol heads. By the way our “toxic” relationship with fossil fuels, as Llewelyn called it, propelled us through the industrial revolution to where we are now. Without that progress we’d still be gathering firewood for cooking and hardly ever venturing outside our villages.

@AndyInTheUK 7 месяцев назад

I wish the UK Government had required all house builders to put in EV chargers for all new-build houses, and communal chargers for flats and apartments from YEARS ago. These things would cost peanuts for builders. I also think that they could have required all new-build houses to have solar panels (except where not permitted e.g. conservation areas), from years ago. Again, a hell of a lot cheaper and easier to build in than to retro-fit. Some neighbours put in a car charger even though they didn't have an EV, and that helped them to sell their house quickly. It's a no-brainer.

@MrWolseley1660 4 месяца назад

Having had a pure Electric car for three years I have changed to a plug in hybrid because I learned the hard way about the lack of reliable charging infrastructure, the greatly over stated milage possibilities and exaggerated financial benifits. Electric cars are a part but only a part of the solution due to a lack of both generation and distribution capacity.

@surferdude4487 4 месяца назад

Traitor! But seriously, Have you tried a Tesla lately? For the most part, they have solved the charging problem. Also, you can plug your car in at night for that full-tank feeling every morning.

@MrWolseley1660 4 месяца назад

@@surferdude4487 Yes a daughter has a new Model Y company car . I do not like the appearance nor the touch screen for everything and as an engineer nor am I impressed with the build quality. Tesla’s In my opinion are light years behind my Lexus NX 450 F Sport but I concede that in England (not Scotland) their charging infrastructure is vastly superior.

@mnhsty 4 месяца назад

I suspect the Biden plan to fund charging stations is gumming up the works. Since its inception, it has built no charging stations and has probably discouraged or delayed private investment in charging.

@rogerphelps9939 4 месяца назад

Teslas are crap. That is the verdict of the UK not for profit Consumers Association.@@MrWolseley1660

@bubandit06 8 месяцев назад

The companies providing these services are still fully entitled to reach their goals at the earlier deadline. We don't need to throw out our own principles becasue somebody else does

@LB-W 7 месяцев назад

Why has UK insurance costs gone through the roof.

@Loupa57 7 месяцев назад

1 week later the answer to this insurance question has changed. Premiums are up and rising. One insurance company has refused to take on EVs. Luton airport fire has sent a strong message that is changing the willingness to listen to the other side of the issue.

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Because we are ripped off for driving. My renewal jumped from £300 to £547 so I moved and got insurance for £320. Shop around on comparison sites.

@monkeyjim9398 6 месяцев назад

because they are awake to the scam.

@stan3452344 6 месяцев назад

Because many EVs have to be totaled after an accident that damaged the battery. Battery replacement can cost 20k+ making the repair of a 2 or 3 yo EV uneconomical.

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Is that the manufacturer ripping us off a second time ? EV batteries can be fixed but manufacturers do not want to do that preferring to rip us off.@@stan3452344

@lnostdal 4 месяца назад

I got a 16kW solar system - soon to be 20kW, but there's no way I'm buying an electric car. You can talk all you want, but replacing the battery on, say, a 2nd hand ecar is insanely costly compared to just buying a 2nd hand gasoline car that'll run for 15-20 years with just oil changes.

@gribbler1695 2 месяца назад

Not really (Hyundai and Kia are exceptions). Ref: Electric Car Battery Replacement Costs

@fanjan7527 5 месяцев назад

To the question about why do journalists not check....in mainstream media we have very very few journalists left...reporters are abundant.

@JustfishNascar 8 месяцев назад

I made a 4800-mile trip in a Rivian R1T from Texas to Vancouver, BC for the Fully Charged Live Canada show. I have two very minor public charging issues that took 5 mins each to resolve. I got to meet Robert again while I was there and explained it was 2000 miles to get to Vancouver from Amarillo, Texas. It can be done without a worry.

@jaffahassan4720 8 месяцев назад

Keep the faith it’s all good 😊

@clusterm2 7 месяцев назад

Exactly how long did it take you in this $90,000+ (for the basic with max battery pack) vehicle of the people 😂

@JustfishNascar 7 месяцев назад

Drove from Amarillo to Portland in two days. Drove about 10 hrs each day. Then Portland to Vancouver in 6 hours. Surprising that those that have no clue don't get that these things are possible. And without much time for charging. Hotels and AirBnB had slow chargers so I woke up in the morning with 100%. And my $90k truck falls just in line with a top of the line Ford F150 that requires gasoline or diesel. @@clusterm2

@zoobrizz 7 месяцев назад

We took our friends Tesla from Miami to Atlanta. What should have been a 9 hour trip. It took 17 hours of anxiety. It was horrible.

@raymondvaughan6262 7 месяцев назад

Very lucky

@turbogeek.421 8 месяцев назад

The biggest shame is that the people that NEED to watch this video, won’t.

@dodgemF1 8 месяцев назад

And the people who watch these videos couldn't explain thermal runaway, when you realise there's bad actors on both sides, you find this channel is just as bad as the Fleet st rags.

@korswe 8 месяцев назад

Don't worry. These luddites will see enough Teslas on the road. More cars Tesla sells, the, more cars Tesla will sell.

@Brian-om2hh 8 месяцев назад

That's because many of them are signed up members of the " don't bother me with the facts, because I've made my mind up" club......

@wolfgangpreier9160 8 месяцев назад

@@korsweI like that one. 🚗😎

@t1n4444 8 месяцев назад

@@korswe Really? You type as if understand the situation, which you clearly don't.

@loveLTi 7 месяцев назад

As an engineer of some 50 years standing I absolutely despair of organisation such as this who have carried out no in depth research and have no knowledge of the real life time cycle global warming consequences of electrification nor the environmental destruction caused by mining activities. This organisation lives in cloud cuckoo land. Martyn L

@fullychargedshow 7 месяцев назад

Well well Martyn L, have you had any in depth knowledge of real life time cycle global warming consequences of burning literally billions of barrels of liquid hydrocarbons every year. Oh no, you've never even considered it like millions of others because we all grew up in a world where burning toxic, finite liquid fuel has been normal. That fuel requires a massive, global infrastructure of massive energy consumption and unspeakable environmental damage going back 120 years. But don't concern yourself with that, be clever with your 50 years of incredible insights into the world of engineering. Show me one litre, just one, of recycled diesel or petrol and I'll change my mind. Can we and are we recycling 99% of the material in batteries? Yes we are, now, today. Is there any environmental destruction caused by extracting oil and gas, transporting it, storing it, refining it and burning it once? Is there. No, absolutely not, there is zero impact, nothing to see there. You clearly work for them, I hope they pay you well

@loveLTi 7 месяцев назад

Firstly I work for no one and I’m not paid as I am retired. I have spent the last few years delving into independent studies comparing fossil fuels, battery driven transportation and electricity generation. Even VW’s own website (along with other manufacturers) accept that the GWP of an electric vehicle during manufacturing is double that if an ICEV. For an average generation mix the break even is around 40,000 km, only Norway with some 90% hydro generation achieved a lower figure. In Poland it’s around 190,00 km. Have you studied the lifetime terrestrial acidification potential and particulate matter formation? They all show an ICEV to be less polluting by a large margin. Have you studied the the UK electrical generation profiles for renewables against actual demand? Have you read the IEA World Energy Investment and Critical Minerals Clean Energy Report? Have you studied the Geopolitical implications of mining and processing critical minerals? Listen to the CEO’s of Stellantis, Toyota and Honda. I started from ground zero after an enjoyable drive in a Fiat Abarth 500e to try and understand the implications. Those manufacturers who go all electric will be bankrupt in 5-7 years. Instead of the Johnson May greenwash energy reports, Sunak is finally showing some realise on the challenges. Continuing down the road of electrification for vehicles and heat pumps (which I have been involved in for 40 years and wouldn’t put one in my house) will result in hospitals, hotels and offices running their emergency diesel generators for long spells. When you’ve properly investigated these facts rather than and you still disagree then I suggest you don’t have the ability to put 2 & 2 together. ML

@paul756uk2 7 месяцев назад

@@fullychargedshowjust the kind of answer I'd expect from an entertaining luvvie.

@fullychargedshow 7 месяцев назад

@@loveLTi A fascinating but sad;y very unoriginal response. I have seen, read and heard about all the references you make so many times over the past 13 years I cannot begin to recall how many. Literally thousands of older men love telling me who wrong I am, and yet they are proven incorrect time and again, not that it makes the slightest bit of difference because they, and you, truly believe what you state with such surety. I'm not going to respond to all your assumptions, but the first is so blaringly incorrect it deserves a take down. The fact that you quote, and believe VW, a long standing combustion car makers who have been pushed, kicking and screaming, lying (dieselgate) and whining into making electric vehicles says everything. The Volvo report, on which this frankly offensively wrong assumption of the CO2 and energy impact of battery manufacturing has been so thoroughly debunked by actual scientists, actual battery specialists, academics and engineers all overt the world, again and again. See Auke Hoekstra and Euan McTurk for two, very thorough examples. An electric car needs to be driven about 6,000 miles before it is MUCH cleaner than a diesel and petrol car of the same size, and then it continues to get cleaner while the filthy, dated, inefficient combustion engine mashes its way through spare parts, wears down, is even less efficient and therefore burns more and more fuel leaving more and more filth in it's wake, which, according to you, is 100% fine. But obviously you are not going to research that. You are just going too blindly accept this lie. It fits your narrative. And I will repeat, your narrative is that burning billions of barrels of fossil fuel every day is absolutely fine and we don't need to do anything about it. Therefore there is no discussion to be had.

@fullychargedshow 7 месяцев назад

@@paul756uk2 You used the tired, 1990's term 'luvvie' which says everything about you. Very sad.

@David-fj5lz 7 месяцев назад

Wait until there is a massive power cut, there will be rows of flat electric cars!!How Will an electric car face a 4 hour traffic jam on a motorway?

@taloire43 4 месяца назад

An electric car sitting in a 4 hour traffic jam on a motorway will use will use zero power because the drive motor is not operating.

@mikeypc3592 Месяц назад

On how exactly are you going to put fuel in your car if there's a power cut?

@kng128 Месяц назад

@@mikeypc3592 My car is fully charged, or well enough at 80%, from the get go when there's a power outage. If there's a power outage my gas burning furnace doesn't work at all.

@lucasnilsson2952 8 месяцев назад

It's a bit dissapointing that the experts still don't recognise that there's a huge amount of people without home charging access. And, that price comes back to you over time, yes that's great but it still matters not if you can’t get to that initial payment or cover such a large monthly expense. All I'm saying is that public charging and purchase price is still a problem, I'd like the experts to recognise that. Great cause, good stuff brought up, I really appreciate what you do, go EV🙏

@rogerphelps9939 7 месяцев назад

Public charging prices should be regulated. No more than 50% more than domestic charging might be a sensible limit.

@Brian-om2hh 7 месяцев назад

@@rogerphelps9939 That's already here to some extent Roger, but of course it does depend on the greed levels of those operating the charge networks. My local charge network - Charge My Street - offers public charging as low as 38p per kwh, if you take out the higher user of the three subscriptions they offer....

@frankcoldwell4424 7 месяцев назад

They recognise it, they just refuse to accept that it’s an issue for the normal working person paying a mortgage etc while juggling childcare and all the rest.

@johnblythe6261 7 месяцев назад

But rapid charger prices are similar if not cheaper than petrol, if you don't have home charging you do exactly how you do if you need petrol, got to a rapid charger and charge it. I don't understand this argument made that EV is no good if you live in a flat?!

@MT-ys6ju 7 месяцев назад

@@johnblythe6261it's because it works out to be equal or more expensive with an EV if you charge exclusively on public chargers. So why pay more for an EV if it's not cheaper to run. Petrol prices in Europe are currently about 1.98 / ltr. If you drive a Hybrid car with a consumption of 6.5l/100km, that's 12.87 / 100kms. Charging an EV publicly in Europe, you'd expect to pay at least 0.75 / Kwh. Take the MG4 for example, with a battery of 61Kwh and a range of about 380kms (Less if you're driving on a highway), you'd be be paying 12.04 / 100km.. This is exactly why i decided to go ahead with a self charging hybrid car this year instead of an EV.

@eckartjack 8 месяцев назад

The biggest incentive for adoption of BEV’s would be porting one’s home Tariff to every public charger. This would help flat dwellers and those without off-road parking next to their home. AI should be able to make it possible. Linking a car to an address and electricity account and make that a default for charging would make it less attractive to car thieves. Voters would appreciate a level playing field. Governments could subsidise the loss to charging stations out of taxation of the oil and gas industries. All park and ride buses in Cambridge are now electric as are more and more taxis. It already makes for better air quality in the town centre. It also helps that park and ride buses accept those passengers without cars. Eckart Jack, CB4 2AS.

@DrRogB 8 месяцев назад

Great idea. It wouldn't need AI, it would be easier than cell phones.

@stuart7620 8 месяцев назад

great idea, let the energy providers own the public roll out of onstreet parking charging systems and we will see more investment too.

@db7948 8 месяцев назад

Great idea over the long term but in the short term the installation of the infastructure needs to be paid for some how. Of course they could always just up the corporation tax for oil companies by 1% to pay for it as part of a carbon tax but Sunak wont do that because of his connections to the oil companies..

@thelifeofbatteries2603 8 месяцев назад

Great idea but don't let the british gov implement it or it will be a disaster

@ArhipDroid 7 месяцев назад

Went electric spent twice as much as a ice car, problem is it's battery has lost 15 to 20% and charging away from home is more expensive than my diesel car to run, no way to refurbish battery in this country, so I'll not be getting another electric car until battery problem is solved

@jtsinspain 7 месяцев назад

I am not yet an EV user, my main gripes being the low range on a full charge and the purchase price - if the first multiplies by a factor of 4 and the second decreases by half I may come on board. I must explain that I do a lot of long-distance driving - I recently drove across the whole of France in one night and the whole of Spain the following day, with a short pause to rest; my diesel-engined car has a range of up to 1000 kms, and at present I do not see how that same trip could be completed in the time available practically non-stop.

@Apjooz 7 месяцев назад

Is it legal to drive nonstop? Atleast it's not adviced.

@jtsinspain 7 месяцев назад

@@Apjooz It is definitely not recommended by me, even if I am confident in my own ability; it is not illegal, however, to drive a private vehicle non-stop - what can cause a person legal problems is if they fall asleep while driving and cause an accident, in this case they are legally responsible due to their reckless and irresponsible behavior (which must be proven in a court of law). However, they will only be breaking the law if while they are driving trucks or buses/coaches as professional drivers when they are legally required to use a tachograph, in this case there are very strict regulations preventing them from driving non-stop for many hours. In coaches and trucks 4.5 hours non-stop and then minimum 45 minutes rest before another four and a half hours when they will reach their maximum nine hours driving per 24-hour period. Note that these are European Union rules applicable to long-distance truck and bus/coach drivers - on town buses and short delivery distances (less than 50 kilometres) there is no legal obligation to use a tachograph. Caveat: There are special considerations when the passengers you transport are school-children and minors.

@miskatonic6210 7 месяцев назад

Nobody gives a shit what you want and what you would like to pay. Regulations and the market will force you to adapt.

@jtsinspain 7 месяцев назад

@@miskatonic6210 Your choice of words is surprising, but I guess what you are saying is "Nobody in corridors of power gives a sh-t". I probably agree.

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Yes down side to both EV and ICE cars. Many things to consider : How many long trips do you do a year ? Cost of ownership a EV costs more to buy but same to lease as an ICE car and you can rapid charge it everyday as its not yours. Servicing cost: EV 380 a year wheee as an ice car is £200 or more. Emissions and harmful exhaust gases. .

@davidevans3822 7 месяцев назад

I rented a Polestar 2 in May and drove from Stansted Airport to Kent and the charging options were surprisingly poor; and I live in Ireland where charging is garbage. I'm very pro-EV but I genuinely don't think charging infrastructure problems can be dismissed; Kent isn't exactly the Gobi desert.

@mickfitz76 7 месяцев назад

Private sector needs to do more. In Thailand the retailers/landlords put ev chargers in their parking lots to get people to their malls/stores. Government isn't going to flood the streets with them.

@thekaxmax 6 месяцев назад

they do specify in the talk that the infrastructure, as a whole, is there. If your local council isn't keeping up, tell them to do so.

@maxflight777 5 месяцев назад

Pray tell … why didn’t you buy a Tesla ? 🤦‍♂️

@thekaxmax 5 месяцев назад

@@maxflight777 build quality and owner.

@richardglover314 8 месяцев назад

Robert Llewellyn made me aware of the existence of the Nissan Leaf and I purchased one in 2011, now we have a BMW i3 REX and Tesla model 3. And I have been a patron of Fully Charged for years because their heart is in the right place. However it saddens me that so much of the FUD has been in response to the purest zeal to be rid of the internal combustion engine. For centuries we have progressed by replacing old technology with new but made full use of today's technology whilst doing so. But what is an EV? What is the fundamental change in technology that this transition to us all driving electric one day about? What did that first Tesla roadster cause to be written into history? What was it that the legacy automakers needed to grasp that I am not sure all have done so yet? That electric motors should now be the only thing turning our wheels. Instead of EVs becoming a political football we should already be seeing a real reduction in fossil fuel use. OK Tesla would not be the leading force they are today, Toyota, VW, Ford, GM etc would be vying to give more battery capacity with each new model and range extenders would have dispensed with any need to wear a hair-shirt on longer trips. There would not talk of plans to ban ICE vehicles because customers would want EVs simply because they were better to drive and cheaper to run. Those who only wanted a BEV could have them and those who needed the back-up generator could have those also. There doesn't need to be a battle, there doesn't need to be nonsense from both sides. Just better vehicles that all can live with and enjoy.

@stevezodiac491 7 месяцев назад

How long have you kept any individual EV ?

@shanecampbell8955 7 месяцев назад

GM Ford and Jeep are stopping production of EV's imagine that

@rileybenstead3574 6 месяцев назад

Why do the people in government or people in power use things like Range Rovers and not electric vehicles? Glad I have a reliable old diesel.

@MrArtist7777 8 месяцев назад

I’ve worked in the solar and wind power industry for the past 16-years and have driven an EV for the past 7-years and have combated renewable energy and EV lies, the entire time. No question, the fossil fuel industry spends a ton of time and effort perpetuating lies and misinformation. Great to see efforts like this, delivering truth and facts.

@oorya1780 8 месяцев назад

So what is your answer to those who don't have access to home charging such as those who live in terraced streets or flats and don't suggest lamp post charging as where would the people that park in those streets park their cars if they can't park in a space reserved for EVs?

@RichardBrooklyn 8 месяцев назад

@@oorya1780just use public chargers. You don't have a petrol pump at home, do you?

@waynecartwright-js8tw 7 месяцев назад

@@oorya1780 workplace charging would help

@Sekir80 7 месяцев назад

@@RichardBrooklyn You need to remember that people hardly want to change their life. If he used to 5 minute breaks in a gas station he would be annoyed to spend 35 minutes at a public charger. Then you need to have your options ready: what if you plug your car while doing grocery shopping? What if you just call up your buddy and spend time on the phone while the car is charging? People pretend they are so busy they forget to manage two things at the same time.

@RichardBrooklyn 7 месяцев назад

@@Sekir80 oh no! Anyway...

@richardjohnson5529 8 месяцев назад

sunak and his wife are in the pockets of shell, bp, exxonmobil. etc.

@wulliethedent 7 месяцев назад

A ICV doesn’t do thermal runaway or off highly toxic gas for a number of days. It doesn’t burn hot enough to melt concrete and high carbon steel. An ev actually does. Also within the frontline car trade no dealer wants to take back a used ev. They are rapidly becoming disposable just like your phone. In 10/20/30 years there will still be 100% viable icv on the road but very few EV’s for various reasons. One of which is the ticking time bomb of a battery the could at worst explode. At best simply fail.

@gw4838 4 месяца назад

An employee at of the national grid pro EV/Green transport (bias to sell more electricity). Yet they would howl "biased" if an Oil company commented on supplying fuel. The guy on the left berated an article by journalist on how slow it was to charge his car. By making a joke he was charging it from a 13 amp socket in his living room. Then a couple sentences on, he tells a story where he used to knock on doors and ask if he could plug his car in. A 13 amp socket is roughly capable of output 3Kw, but I doubt a plug in charger would have such a rating. I note they made no reference to the cost of insuring an EV. Why is that? perhaps it is indicative of how expensive it is to insure an EV.

@bizjakboris 7 месяцев назад

Not having an opsition in this debate is a like having no debate at all.

@BriBCG 5 месяцев назад

As much as I agree the media blow EV issues way out of proportion, it's pretty disingenuous when the supposed 'truth' is coming from a obviously biased source with a vested interest in making EVs look good. The actual 'truth' is somewhere in between.

@technohamster4783 4 месяца назад

There's no way these 3 would ever risk that.

@StevePotter 4 месяца назад

It was a panel discussion, not a debate.

@arthurdinucci 4 месяца назад

It's propaganda - they don't do conservation - the market will decide - if the politicians etc and the WEF let them

@michaelmeehan5505 4 месяца назад

Have at it. What's your best 'argument'? Lay it out.

@naxxtor 8 месяцев назад

My work has an underground car park with an EV chargepoint. It has been turned off because its a "fire risk" 😮 This is the effect this kind of misinformation has.

@AlexanderAddams 8 месяцев назад

That's rediculous

@jaffahassan4720 8 месяцев назад

Oh that’s a shame we’ll share this video with your boss who switched it off & let’s get it on again it’s all good 😊

@andrewlucas6214 8 месяцев назад

No such think as mis-information… just information..true, false or debatable. m-i is a politically generated tern to allow censorship

@MegaWilderness 8 месяцев назад

This is an entirely sensible decision. EV fires in contained spaces are lethal due to toxic fumes especially those batteries containing cobalt. I'll wait for safer batteries before buying an EV

@naxxtor 8 месяцев назад

@@MegaWilderness don't ICE cars also produce extremely toxic fumes in a confined space when they catch fire? Which certainly happens .. quite frequently ...

@oktc68 7 месяцев назад

The UK grid can't handle electric utopia. It's a poor technology to replace ICE, it's just moving the pollution from the exhaust pipe to the power station. How do you think the government will replace the lost fuel duty? EV's and Hybrids are a fire hazard, smoke from some types of batteries is extremely toxic and storage of accident damaged vehicles is horrendously expensive, EV's aren't a solution to environmental issues, we can do better. In a few years they will be seen for the disastrous mistake that they are.

@RayRhymer 6 месяцев назад

It is obvious to most sensible people that, if you live in a house with a driveway, can have a socket available for charging your car, and only use your electric car to make an all round journey of 150-200 miles, then electric cars will suit your lifestyle very well...if you can afford to purchase and insure a vehicle in the first place. If however you need use public chargers, you could easily experience problems such as long delays in charging your vehicle up to paying more for the electricity than you would for petrol or diesel.

@alaneasthope2357 8 месяцев назад

Bravo. What a shame Mr Sunak wasn't in the audience, rather than fulfilling Quentin's prophecy and cutting back on all the green policies. An excellent presentation. Well done.

@jaffahassan4720 8 месяцев назад

Don’t worry just share the video with no 10’s office who will let him know & also your local MP unless his name is Graig McKinley whose support for petro companies is known, but it’s all gonna good in the end despite whatever they do😊

@geoffhaylock6848 8 месяцев назад

These 4 people didn't help green policies they helped push BEV sales. A green policy would be, take all those batteries, put them in new build houses with solar. Not as nice as a shiny new car, but greener (unless you drive a lot of miles every year). People spend far more hours producing CO2 at home then they do driving to Tesco's once a week or the daily school run. Green or shiny! Me, I like shiny.

@RoonMian 8 месяцев назад

@@geoffhaylock6848 You're still here talking bullshit. When people are not driving their EVs, they **ARE** batteries for the house with solar on the roof.

@FIGHTTHECABLE 8 месяцев назад

I am suprised the citizens of the UK have been voting themselves into poverty for the last 10 Years. First they shoot themselves in the knee, now they jam a spoon inside the wound and stir it. The UK is in so much trouble, the only part holding the UK above water is london. The rest of the UK is getting poorer and poorer. Yet they continue to vote those political parties that point fingers at others and speak about the negatives, without criticizing their own mistakes. The AFD in germany does the same. This is sadly the weakpoint of democracy, stupid easy influencial people vote those politicians that promise to do miracles. Brexit = bad Boris Johnson = bad Theresa May = bad The salad head woman = bad Rishi Sunak = bad

@Moses_VII 8 месяцев назад

@@RoonMianYou say this like all cars are Ford F 150 Lightning or BYD

@MrAdopado 8 месяцев назад

The real experiences of people running fleets of thousands of EVs were most relevant to hear! Did they have any vehicles going on fire? ... eh, no. Did they have higher tyre wear than ICE vehicles ... eh, no. Was the maintenance of EVs really cheaper ... yup. A slam dunk in my book!

@jediofthejungle 7 месяцев назад

wow. the "real experiences of people running fleets of thousands of EVs". Can you find me the source of that information? People are running fleets of THOUSANDS?? How many solar panels are needed to fylly charge just one? Can you find the math on that while you're collecting the other info? Cheers. Appreciate it. :)

@stephensharp975 7 месяцев назад

@@jediofthejungle i live near Geneva, have had a few EVs and solar panels. Heres some simple results for my particular usage. My 3kw small solar array gives me about 3400/3500kwh of electric in a year,. my i3 has a battery of 44kwh and i can drive it about 300km,or 186 miles. on a full charge. So 3400/44 x300 = 23,181 kms per year. Last year i drove 20,000kms with it so my driving was covered be the energy generated by a small solar system with 10 panels. This is a rough estimate but does not take into account charging losses and the fact that the batteries real capacity is less than 44kwh, i assume these two will cancel out. Hope this helps?

@MoesKeckeEcke 7 месяцев назад

did the fleet owners milk the fk out of any support by the state for ev's (secret booster of the car industry from my tax money with no return of investment, people still lose their job at will of the industry which pushes out higher rates on their shares) Most private owners charge at night when they come back from work.. does Solar or Wind power the grid at night here in europe.. NOPE Natural Gas Trubine for peak hours or old atomic powerplant in france.. So in europe the average private ev owner just damages the enviroment more than it helps

@ronmiles26 7 месяцев назад

Would they have told you of any vehicles catching fire? I doubt it, wouldn't have fitted the narrative!

@GamezGuru1 7 месяцев назад

@@ronmiles26 so the same way the media doesn't report on ICE vehicles that catch fire or explode at far higher numbers? lol

@messier4033 6 месяцев назад

Room full of well healed folk preaching EVs. Audience with lots of folk who can afford an EV an obviously have homes where they can charge at home. 'White noise' was the term used at the beginning. Apt.

@nigelwilliams768 7 месяцев назад

Stop Burning Stuff. Good slogan. Please tell that to the owner of the diesel hybrid Range Rover that destroyed the Luton Airport car park recently. The video appeared to show that the lithium battery under the floor had self ignited and caused the conflagration.

@Keef-cd9os 7 месяцев назад

I like the idea of a small EV that I can economically charge at home and use around town and for short trips. I still have doubts that longer journeys that incur higher costs and delays at public charging points will convince people to part with their hard earned cash on an EV.

@hunchanchoc8418 7 месяцев назад

Yes - it would be nice if the small EV's battery was so small that it could be removed and taken into the house to be recharged, for the millions of people who don't have a driveway. Provided it doesn't catch fire, of course.

@ReverendRandy 7 месяцев назад

I have been fortunate to have driven small BEV "town cars" for several decades and saved a ton of money from not buying gas or having to have the vehicles serviced. If you have room and the budget for a second car, this would be an excellent choice for your pocketbook and the environment. Peace

@the_lost_navigator7266 7 месяцев назад

What about a phev? EV for local journeys but having the backup of an engine for longer trips.

@Keef-cd9os 7 месяцев назад

@@the_lost_navigator7266 definitely worth some consideration!

@ReverendRandy 7 месяцев назад

You might as well get an economical EV with a 250-mile range if you are serious about ending fossil fuels. You will still be way ahead from not having to burn gas or have expensive repairs done. Peace @@the_lost_navigator7266

@PMaynard-22 7 месяцев назад

Its "your" dis information in front of a group that agrees with you why not have the opposite side on stage with you? I know why it's harder to change the subject in person when they will trip you up.

@wulliethedent 7 месяцев назад

Irrespective of the circumstances, if you lease an EV you should be fine. If you buy an EV, undoubtedly you will loose a huge chunk of your money. Nothing will get round the fact.

@tycurtin7565 4 месяца назад

Lots of talks about how 'green' electric cars are or wind or solar. However that's 100% the wrong point. These technologies are way way more expensive than gas cars, trucks or natural gas power plants. Economies of scale will not be enough to get costs down. Cheap energy is the key to a powerful economy, not GREEN stuff....... it's CHEAP stuff.

@GoCoyote 8 месяцев назад

Having driven EVs, and owning a Chevy Volt PHEV, I will never purchase another ICE vehicle again. I save hundreds of dollars a month on fuel and vehicle maintenance cost.

@Jcewazhere 8 месяцев назад

How you know it's not America: They had a 'lively debate" with a police officer that didn't end up with shots fired.

@mdf2mdf287 7 месяцев назад

They were bobbing up and down out of their seats like turkeys voting for Christmas

@SHOdown13 7 месяцев назад

As for infrastructure, every manufacturer should have to pay for 1 EV charger installation for every 1 vehicle produced. And yes, i do realize that will just increase the cost of the vehicle at time of purchase, but if you want an ev that bad, then pay for it to help utilization.

@steffl27 7 месяцев назад

This would be complete overkill. We also don't have one petrol pump per ICE car sold, that would be complete nonsense.

@GDM22 5 месяцев назад

Why do that when they can get the recalcitrants like your self to chip in.

@brettski74 7 месяцев назад

You've missed the point on EV fires. The issue is not how regularly EVs catch fire. It's what happens when they do. ICE cars may catch fire as often or more often than EVs, depending on what region's stats you're looking at, but when an ICE car catches fire, fire fighters can do something to contain and suppress the fire. For EVs in many places around the world, the answer is let it burn itself out. There are a few techniques developed in recent years to either limit collateral damage from EV fires or even to put them out even with a battery in thermal runaway, but most fire departments just don't have the equipment and training to deal with EV fires today and if they happen in an enclosed space alongside other EVs, like in a car park, on a ferry or on a container ship, the results can be rather catastrophic. This is a situation that will get better with time. As more EVs roll out, there will be more and more justification for fire departments to invest in this kind of equipment and so they will. But suggesting that there's no issue because ICE cars catch fire more often is completely missing the point. I am curious to learn more about your embodied carbon numbers. I don't see evangelizing EVs as a solution to climate change as a good idea, though - even if your numbers are good. I drive an EV. I really enjoy driving my EV. There are lots of good reasons to drive an EV aside from them being great to drive, even some environmental ones but solving climate change just isn't one of them. Look at how much carbon emission comes from small passenger vehicles. It's something like 8% of total emissions. Even if we replaced every car on the road tomorrow with an EV, the most you can possibly do is remove those 8% or so of emissions. Touting EVs as any kind of a solution to climate change seems to be mostly taking the focus off of much more important areas in energy generation and industrial processes.

@alexd302 8 месяцев назад

Very close to my heart. I got so fed up reading the FUD being published in the newsletter of my old car club (VVC. Vintage and Veteran car club) that I wrote an article rebuffing the myths around EV's, which they published recently. The challenge is to address, not the ill-informed, but rather the mis-informed. Clearly EV's pose an existential threat to so many that it has predictably spawned this mis-information industry. A lot of the articles published are simply deliberate lies being peddled by some journalists in exchange for perhaps, a few pieces of silver from the fossil fuel industries war chest.

@cbcdesign001 8 месяцев назад

Yep, there is definitely a push-back by the FF industry at play. But also people who love the ICE feel the demise of them coming and understandably dont want to lose what they love. I used to love the noises and sounds of ICE when young too, I even had a V8 in my first car, impossible now of course for a young driver. But as I got older, comfort and music from a good sound system in the car replaced my need of a noisy engine and I love the quiet of EVs but enjoy the performance they have, they are quicker than many ICE cars.

@Markcain268 7 месяцев назад

Evs are like marmite, you either love em or hate them lol

@frankcoldwell4424 7 месяцев назад

Look up conflict minerals.

@alexd302 7 месяцев назад

Cobalt is pretty much phased out of EV batteries but still used in diesel refining. Shameful, isn't it.@@frankcoldwell4424

@williamwoods8022 7 месяцев назад

The EVs pose an existential threat to your LIFE - you are sitting in a MICROWAVE oven on top of those batteries that are interfering with you electromagnetic field cooking you slowly to future cancer. ICE cars have the same problem having those screens in their cars as well with wi-fi, bluetooth etc cooking them as well and the metal of the cars keeping all of that inside the cars cooking you slowly but the EVs are cooking you quicker. Plenty of doctors and other experts such as Barry Trower exposing all of this re the 5g, wi-fi and electro-magnetic fields etc on here and online but of course they are slowly being shut down from exposing all of this with the "online harms" etc bills being brought out to cover all of these things up. People are just addicted sheep though poisoning themselves with drink, cigarettes. drugs, junk food etc and do not like giving up their addiction which mobile phones are now as well and it is then poor me when they are dying with cancer etc and how did this happen to me. They all even queued up for their suicide shots this last few years and are now wondering why millions of people are dropping dead like flies all over the world - the carbon they want to get rid of is YOU.

@chrisbarron5861 4 месяца назад

If you have a working car, of any sort, the worst thing you can do for the environment is to buy any new car of any sort

@garryjackson9161 7 месяцев назад

I have driven a few EVs and loved the driving experience however the impracticalities of owning one is a no no for me is like have a petrol car with a 3 gallon fuel tank and you can only fill it with a eye dropper I’ll wait until they get better and I’m sure they will

@GDM22 5 месяцев назад

I hate going to the service station and handing over $100 each time so for me that is impractical, each to their own. They will get better, like everything, the problem with waiting is when do you stop.

@HermanWillems 4 месяца назад

I just charge once a week at the company while i work. Easy.

@kimblecheat 8 месяцев назад

Solar panels on ALL govt buildings and council houses. Solar and wind farms on ‘Royal’ land. That fed the new charging network. That would work…and think of the jobs

@stevenham1937 8 месяцев назад

lol you realise how little of our energy usage is actually electric don’t you?

@danielcarroll3358 8 месяцев назад

@@stevenham1937 You don't think that there will be more EVs on the road in the future?

@gino2465 7 месяцев назад

These 2 well know guys lovely guys just need to think about the mass of working class. I am an EV owner love it to bits. It has to go as long journeys are too stressful. 9 hour travel journey added 5 hours and 40 minutes to my 9 hour journey. It's unfortunate too often . So going back to diesel car now.

@casualagent7250 6 месяцев назад

Don’t blame you sir 🚘

@gregchristie2763 6 месяцев назад

It's going to be like this for sone time..we are still in the birth period of EV.. EV only suits people who are wealthy enough to afford to buy EV.. Not much second-hand market available.. These are often old tech bad EVs. Once we are further up the life cycle of the EV things will be better. Evie's in China coming now with 10min charge time .. But today will be expensive in Europe and the infrastructure is not there for charging as many say.. There's not even such thing as a 500 kilowatt charger in europe for cars... And new tech like this is always expensive like I say it's just going to take time

@RB-lt8kt 6 месяцев назад

Shame but many people saying the same. How many long trips do we actually do a year ? France has far more EV charge stations.

@monkeyjim9398 6 месяцев назад

them well paid guys are Paid to push the garbage of lies over EV saving the planet..

@kennethhawley1063 6 месяцев назад

@@RB-lt8kt What has the number of long journeys got to do with anything? If you have an EV and you need to do a long journey, you are knackered.

@atlaspath5803 6 месяцев назад

The major issue is battery life over 10 years of use, cost of replacement batteries and batteries imploding inside your garage!

@albertiwong 6 месяцев назад

Don't ask taxpayer to pay for toys for the rich. User should pay for infrastructure upgrades as required, or ask your ESG friends with deep pockets to front the infrastructure upgrades. If there is a business case, someone will do it.

@Brian-om2hh 27 дней назад

Who do you suppose has funded the £billions in subsidies to the oil industry over the decades?

@albertiwong 27 дней назад

@@Brian-om2hh the same ESG guys, the invisible hand, funded the same fossil fuels, into the $trillion over the decades. We didn't know better, but we are where we are.

@skierpage 15 дней назад

Fossil fuel users should pay a carbon tax for the massive worsening harms that burning this crap causes, with half of the money going into low-emissions investments like charging and the other half rebated to poor people. It's blindingly obvious and nearly all economists say it's the best way to incentivize and pay for the green energy transition. And obviously fossil fuel companies will spend and bribe whatever it takes to make sure it doesn't happen.

@tonyhughes7792 7 месяцев назад

During this presentation i would like to have seen mention of the problems encountered with EV`s when they are damaged in road accidents and have to be stored in a scrap yard, or similar area, while they are processed. The information i read is that a large vacant space around the vehicle has to be maintained for safety reasons until the vehicle is repaired or broken up for parts recycling. The critical factor here being the potential waste of storage space around the vehicle during this time. Any opinions?

@guyboisvert66 7 месяцев назад

Batteries are recycled, the rest of the card is cleaner that an ICE...

@KingBravo-lo3vc 7 месяцев назад

Ground up batteries are sold on the same exchanges as wheat these days. About 20,000 dollars per ton. About 10,000 per car.

@robinspat 7 месяцев назад

Remove batteries if serviceable and use as static energy storage

@StevenRoy 7 месяцев назад

You're absolutely right. We should stop the transition now, and go back to burning fuel. It's too wasteful when EVs that have been in an accident, need extra storage space for a few days, before being safely disassembled. That's not something that can be dealt with. There simply isn't enough empty space in the world to store all these cars for dozens of hours.

@timmoore9736 7 месяцев назад

Insurance companies are charging a serious premium for the EV, as any accident which impinges on the battery setup means the car is totaled. And it does not take too much of an accident to damage the battery area - damages that on an ICE would result in a repaired vehicle. The rest of the car may be cleaner than an ICE when the batteries are removed, but that vehicle is nothing but clean scrap. And while we are at it, ask about to see how resales of EVs are going. Or not going.

@ChrisBrengel 7 месяцев назад

Right, and what is being done about the other 95% of carbon dioxide emissions? Only 5% of carbon dioxide emissions are from Ice cars. 95% from agriculture, construction, industry, etc etc etc. Keep in mind that converting ice Cars to Evs doesn't completely eliminate the carbon dioxide emissions, just reduces it. I'm all for the adoption of EVs, and it's a very worthwhile thing to do, but I do wish people would spend a whole lot more time thinking of all of the other sources of CO2. The number of coal-fired power plants in Germany (part of how they made up for a lack of Russian natural gas) would be a good place to start.

@magnusa1386 Месяц назад

Spot on!

@Bodzio1982 5 месяцев назад

I bought a second hand BMW i3 rex around 4 years ago. I’m not sure if the braking pads were replaced before but so far I drove nearly 80k kilometers and only changed tires once and rear wiper. At this moment I have over 170k driven and the battery still going strong. I just never charge battery to full and I think this is secret to battery longevity.

@SERGIO-cr6uy 2 месяца назад

How much more expensive was your BMW i3 in comparison to an ICE car? if electricity was taxed at 50% as petrol is, would you keep that smile ? How long do you expect the government to let that money escape? The government will either raise the price of the KW/H (which will impact any use of domestic electrical equipment at home such as Oven, Heating system, TV, etc) or they will create a tax per mile. Also bare in mind that your non-polluting car is powered by non-clean energy as 50% of electricity produced in the UK is non-renewable.

@Bodzio1982 2 месяца назад

@@SERGIO-cr6uyI traded in my 2014 BMW 1 series and paid around €5k more for 2 years younger car. I recently purchased another electric car and traded in my old i3. Still got good value for it.

@SERGIO-cr6uy 2 месяца назад

@@Bodzio1982 funny that you replied nothing in relation to my comment.

@starr_helix6770 6 месяцев назад

Wonder when these guys are gonna realise they can’t avoid eating the humble pie circling them ? A month on from this and all EV production - is reduced with a possible cancellation of the Mexico Tesla Gigafactory factory tick ticket gentlemen

@davidfoley1743 7 месяцев назад

The overall issue is these basic things How much it costs to charge, how long it takes , especially when you can pull into a fuel station fill up and go, and this is the biggest one. Then milage, how far we get on a tank of fuel compared to a full charge Then this one , There are over a thousands households along my road, and 95% are unable to have a home charging point, due to no drive way , plus not even being able to park outside there own homes!! O and the council stop you from running leads due to heath and safety issues, o and the costs to have a home charging point installed at your home! So answerson that ? How do we move forward?? Then , plus the fact that EV cars / van are more expensive to buy !!

@eap8317 7 месяцев назад

I have friends working in car manufacturers (aFORDable ones! wink) and they say the industry has invested lots of money for the 2030 change and are furious at this government for delaying the transition to 2035... the industry and people in the UK were getting ready and the economy was able to make these changes but the government is trying to appeal to a minority of the population that still thinks we can afford (as a species) to keep burning stuff... old dinosaurs who are steadily dying out leaving the younger generations to sort their sh*t!