I Watched *A CINDERELLA STORY* For The FIRST TIME And I Solved The Murder Mystery NO ONE SAW! 

Did yall peep the murder mystery in this? Or was it just me? Don't forget to drink water and hit that like for me. Go to yoursapp.com/Billy to get a HUGE 60% off discount from the yearly Yours App subscription using the code BILLY

I’m literally convinced that there will never be a kiss that billy isn’t disgusted by 😂😂

“Dressed like jolly ranchers” 🤣🤣🤣 and “Dressed like Barney going to prom” 😂😂😂 Billy, thank you for providing the movie & fashion commentary we need 👏🏾

It's a shame the most iconic line of the movie was the one that bored you. 😭 "Waiting for you is like waiting for rain in this drought. Useless and disappointing."

Chad Michael Murray always looks so deep in thought in everything he plays in I always find it hilarious. He’s not that deep!!🤣🤣

So I know it sounds farfetched that the dad died in the earthquake, but here me out. This movie was set in California 2004 where Sam is probably around 17 as she's already sent her application to Princeton. Given that she looked around 10 when the earthquake that killed her father happened, I'm going to guess that the movie based the tragedy around the 1994 Northridge earthquake that killed at least 50 people, injured thousands, and caused almost $50b in property damages. Dunno if it's what the writers intended, but the numbers line up pretty well in the timeline.

Billy: That was overly dramatic for no reason. two seconds later Billy: Wait, her Dad DIED?! 🤣

The joke about their lawn being the best is not that their lawn is fake: it’s that they are the only losers using water in a drought, haha.

Love to Hate: Fiona is an absolutely horrible person with no redeeming traits of any kind but Jennifer Coolidge makes her a joy to watch every time she's on screen and makes her final fate even more satisfying.

#Bingers You should do Hidden Figures. It is about 3 African-American women who worked in NASA during the 60s. Funny, powerful and heart-warming. Love your reactions as always!!

When you said “This fool better not have on this Nike arm band”, and I saw it BARELY in the scene that followed after you said that, and you go “HE DOES!!! OH MY GOSH!!!”, the way you sound SO ANNOYED and IRRITATED over him wearing it and went off on a rant about him wearing the arm band for “12 days consecutively” got me ROLLING! LMAO ROFL! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

“When was the last time you’ve got a love note?” *shakes my head* “And tell me why it’s been never” *proceeds to combust* Billy you did not have to come for me like that 😂

your commentary had me laughing so hard i was in tears. the whole “snoop dizzle look” scene killed me 😭💀

This was my favourite Cinderella Story growing up. Also, Jennifer Coolidge (the stepmom) is hilarious! Yes. Please do The Parent Trap (1998). #bingers. Apart from Mulan, it’s my favourite Disney movie. I know it like a Taylor swift song, all too well.

One stepsister is Madeline Zima, the girl from "The Nanny" and the weird dude that dances like Neo from Matrix was going to be Howard from "The Big Bang Theory"... the cast for this movie is surprisingly good.

Hilary Duff was one of my role models as a kid and I still love her work today. Seen almost all her movies, bought her perfume, bought her clothing line, seen her Younger show, her Lizzie show and so much more. She’s great!

Billy ‘trying’ to not insult people is really relatable. I fight that urge so hard everyday but people sometimes be trifling head asses

The things Billy does for his audience 😂 Thank you for listening to recommendations, no matter how cringey. You’re hilarious. I heard in an interview ages ago that Hilary was so nervous about the kiss scene that they made her and CMM practice plenty before-hand. As a tween I was shocked to hear that 😂 Such scandal. Hilary Duff ruled the world in the early-mid 00s. We were obsessed. I was 12 when this came out and haven’t seen it since then. 💀 Feeling old 👵🏻

A junior novelization revealed some deleted ideas and concepts from the movie: -Austin was supposed to get up on stage during the pep-rally, only to pretend that the whole thing was a joke he was in on. This probably explains why the faculty never actually punishes Shelby and her friends for the skit, since they probably assumed it was All Part of the Show. It could also explain another reason why Sam was angry at him, and not Shelby, in the locker room scene. -Austin was also supposed to have a snippy line about how Sam could have been a trucker from New Jersey; the writers seemed to realize where Princeton was during production. -Shelby was originally supposed to get her comeuppance during the big football game at the end when she gets knocked into the mud. -The dress Rhonda gives to Sam was originally supposed to be her mother's wedding dress. -Rhonda also did not appear to be a waitress in the original script; one early line said she would be able to take Sam's shift to let her go to the ball because she always watched over her at work. -Fiona was supposed to have a cat. Sam's father died while trying to save it during the earthquake. -It also seems that Fiona was originally intended to be more of an Alpha Bitch grown up, with her referencing multiple dead husbands. Her working name was going to be Nora. -Astrid, in earlier drafts, was said to be friends with Sam and had an unrequited crush on Carter. She was also established as being more attractive than Shelby, she just preferred being an Unkempt Beauty.

I had such a rough day and sobbed my eyes out so now billy is going to make it better by reacting to this gem of a movie😂🙌🏼

“this fool is a pokemon trainer” has me in tears on the floor i thought someone should know 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I mentioned this when you were asking about Drew Seely in the HSM reaction, but now i have a SECOND excuse to recommend “Another Cinderella Story” its part of the same series of Cinderella Stories as this movie is! #bingers

I did not know I needed Billy shouting out Zavid in his reaction. Now I need a colab with you two 😂❤️❤️❤️

Just to clarify, the original Parent Trap is not in black and white. 😅 Just thought I’d throw that out there. Lol

Regina has always been and will continue to be the ultimate Queen! My heart goes out to her for losing her son this past month :(

Billy, the song playing at 3:43 is Sympathy by The Goo Goo Dolls. Check them out; they have many bops! They played a concert at my college auditorium, and I got to briefly meet them and watch the show up close since I worked there. 🤘

On a second date with this guy, he slipped a love note in my backpack and I found it when I went to class the next day. Flash forward 8 years… this guy is now my husband. ❤️

This movie was a cultural reset! I’m glad you’re finally watching it.

Not sure if someone else posted it but that song was Goo Goo Dolls - Sympathy. Can't believe you've never heard it before! I guess I'm just old. Watched this movie when I was 15 for the first time. ♥

So the San Fernando Valley earthquake was an actual earthquake that killed a lot of people so the dad dying in the same earthquake isn't as far-fetched as you would think especially since many people were not expecting it when it happened so people were very unprepared

I do not get why Billy is trying so hard to NOT make insults against people! It is the best part! ❤❤❤ That is my love note to Billy. P.S. Love at first sight is not a thing.

3:44 It's 'Sympathy' by The Goo Goo Dolls. They've also done 'Iris', which is a really good song, you might recognize. :D

The belt loop holding was definitely a thing in early 2000s, helps bring attention to the hips and waist which was everything at that time. Between the belly shirts, hip hugging jeans, and blingy or spiked belts. Everything was about showcasing your lower half.

The soundtrack of this movie is actually pretty good, so you should check it out. For me, this movie is a classic and still one of the best "modern Cinderella" kind of movies. I think you should do "Freaky Friday" with Lindsay Lohan (and also Chad Michael Murray) and of course The Parent Trap #Bingers

😂😂😂😂😂 Also also I just started rewatching “The Nanny” and it’s crazy cause one of the twins plays the youngest sister in it. Crazy!

Ok but during peak pandemic I didn’t recognize ANYONE with their mask on. Every conversation felt like I was witnessing a superhero identity reveal. 😭

15:31 - 15:35 my Good Mythical Morning heart went💙💙 ikykyk if you dont all I will say is Rhett & Link

Billy out here doing a spelling bee to his own word 😂😂 This is for sure a guilty pleasure. I'm so happy you did it!! Would love to see you do Disney's Emperor's new groove #bingers

When he sees Chad Michael Murray and says “he look like a tuna fish.” 💀

I really love this movie. There are so many corny moments but they fit in with the time and style of movies that were coming out.

I have watched this 3 times and I still can’t get over billy saying Regina looks like a sexy beaver 😂😂😂😂 family dollar Malibu’s most wanted 🤣🤣😂

“I’ll meet you at the crossroads so the train can hit you” Billy just roasts the movies I watched as a kid and It’s so funny 😂😂

I quote this movie almost as much as I do Mean Girls 😋😅 Favorite lines 🤣🤣🤣 "This is my Snoop Dizzle look" "Oh, I Know! A Fish!" "Are we having a catfight?" "Go ahead, girlfriend Call me girlfriend one more time " "Oh, it's the Botox. I can't show emotion for another hour and a half" Your sweet libations, my lady. "Mr. Anderson" "A devastating blow. A worthy opponent " "Uh-oh. Late entry"

Since you reacted to this you should react to Sydney White (it’s a take on Snow White’s story)

I’m loving your shirt! One of my favorite quotes is “stop talking while I’m interrupting” and this shirt gives me that vibe

Don't appreciate Billy coming for my life with that "why is it never" comment 🤣🤣🤣

the shoutout to ZZAVID at 23:35 had me screaming! i didn’t know you two know each other 😭 love both of your channels!

One my favs can't wait to watch your commentary on it ik it's going to be hillarious love your videos Billy!❤️😁

Thank you for making these videos, they truly have been helping me get through my husband’s deployment and manage to bring a smile to my face even on days when I’m struggling

That song when she first goes to the attic is Sympathy by The Goo Goo Dolls. Personal favourite band of mine 😋

Chad Michael Murphy, the guy who plays Austin, is in a movie called “House of Wax” idk if you’ve seen it, but you should definitely watch it, it’s like Horror/Thriller and gets crazy, it also has Paris Hilton and Robert Ri’chard who plays Arnaz in the sitcom, “One on One”

You should definitely do “another Cinderella story” with Selena Gomez I’d love to hear what you gotta say about that

Could you do Crazy Rich Asians or Scott Pilgrim vs the World, that would be awesome 😎 #bingers

In my web design class my professor asks us what our favorite media we’ve consumed that week and I said you. Now 12 more people know about your channel you’re welcome. I consider my PR work DONEE!!

Not gonna lie, I actually like this adaptation of Cinderella way better than the Disney animated feature.

It makes me laugh that he doesn't pay close attention to these movies and misses plot points. 😅

That song that Sam & Austin danced to in the gazebo was “I’ll Be” by Edwin McCain. It’s one of my all time favorite songs, just puts me directly in the feels every time Also, maybe you should check out the original Disneys “Cinderella” since you said you didn’t know the story too well 😍 #Bingers

Am I the only one who can't get enough of Billy absolutely roasting people??? Every time he says "I gotta stop" I cry a little

#bingers. House bunny, Sydney white, blazing saddles, walk to remember, can't hardly wait

#bingers She's the Man You cannot have old chick flicks without Amanda Bynes.

This is my 3rd fav Cinderella remake. Love this reaction billy! Could you pls react to Ever After? It’s another remake of Cinderella to be honest ever after is my number 1 fav remake of Cinderella.#bingers

You should watch Cheaper by the Dozen next! I’ve loved that movie ever since I was a kid!!

REMEMBER THE TITANS FOR BLACK HISTORY MONTH!!!!! COME ON BILLY ITS WAY TOO GOOD #Bingers

I think they were trying to show that it’s always the people around you that you never notice because you’re too busy doing your own thing. So Austin is a popular jock, why would he remember the so called “diner girl”. But I get what you saying Billy 😂😂😂

You HAVE to watch Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging. You're gonna laugh your ass off and it's corny as hell

Billy! I originally found you through your other channel and was so surprised to find you also did movie reactions. (but so happy!) Recently, I've gotten my mom and aunt hooked on your videos with me. We love watching them together in the living room. You're awesome!

Not him dragging us every now and then😂😂😭😭😭😭 highkey it’s what makes me come back bc he cracks me up

#Bingers Freaky Friday, Just My Luck, & Uptown Girls.

He pulled a Troy Bolton before Troy “I’m not giving up my dreams, I’m giving up yours” 😂 This movie is still a classic regardless of the cringe but I wanna know if Carter fixed his dads Mercedes 😂

What murder mystery?! Did I miss something here? Lol I am in for a ride with this one. There’s so many Cinderella movies, but this one I actually enjoyed, especially with Hilary Duff in it. Definitely in the top 5

3:44 song is "Sympathy" by Goo Goo Dolls

I have to tell you Billy, I’m an hyperactive person with ADHD and 3 weeks ago I’ve hurt my knee. I’m waiting for a surgery stuck in my bed for the last 3 weeks and your videos are one of the small things to make me laugh so thank you so much for that. 😉

The song near the beginning you really liked is Sympathy by The Goo Goo Dolls -- they're the same band who sang "iris" which isn't a name most people recognize, but if you hear it, trust, you'll know it. The band is fucking amazing! One of my all time favorites.

This was one of my favorites during high school. And I gotta say your commentary was hilarious. I laughed so hard the entire movie. Thank you, Billy 💕

Love notes are nice. Me and my husband write cute little notes to each other and stick them around the house sometimes. It keeps things fresh and romantic

YES do the parent trap it is my ALLTIME FAVOURITE movie, RHE lindsay Logan one of course 😌

Billy: Tell me about the last time you got a love note Me: Never Billy: And tell my why it's been never Me: You disrespectful Billy. Better be glad you make me laugh or I'd unsubscribe right now for that disrespect. Love you Billy xD

And you need to watch Ever After! It’s the best version of Cinderella and isn’t cheesy at all! Drew Barrymore is the most beautiful Cinderella and it’s so good!

“Why is she dressing like Barney going to prom?” Billy stoppp🤣🤣

That actor, Bradley Joseph, the one that says can't speak, died in real life RIP

15:32 once got the typical "do you like me, check yes or no" note in middle school, except that he was quoting Hunger Games.

Love this version of Cinderella! 💕 Jawbreaker 1999 Clue 1985 Romeo + Juliet 1997 Zootopia Heartbreakers 2001 #bingers

I can't believe I didn't realize Simon Helberg was in this movie until now 8:17

Y’all is that Wolowitz? I didn’t realize he was in this?

I have never seen this, but the fact that Simon Helberg is in it makes this reaction hilarious!

#bingers The Cheetah Girls!! 1, 2, AAAND 3! 😂😂

This was one of my favorite movies growing up. Thank you for reacting to it, Billy! ❤ And if you want to see Hilary Duff in something where she's not the same and not like Lizzie McGuire at all, I suggest According To Greta which she stars in with Diana Ross' son - Evan Ross. #Bingers

Love at first sight is hormones. Love after getting to know someone is genuine attraction and affection.

The song as she loses her dad is called sympathy by the goo goo dolls....it’s actually one of their fave songs and it’s underrated. And at the executive producer was Susan duff...related to Hilary. Then yes that is stiflers mom from American pie.

#Bingers I know you just did the story of Cinderella, but I would recommend "Ever After". It's a different telling of the story, set in older times but with a more "realism" twist. Not realistic, but realism. (Kinda of like this one was.)

If your curious about music in the movie just type in the soundtrack for this movie it should have a playlist and then you can find every song that is used in this movie and find out who or what song it is.

The original Parent Trap is by far the superior to the Lindsay Lohan version and is not in black and white. It's in colour.

The song at the beginning is by the Goo-Goo Dolls. They are fantastic! Definitely give them a listen.

That moment you realise why the guy searching for aliens looks familiar (because it's howard from The big bang theory).

That song is Sympathy by the Goo Goo Dolls. It is 100% a bop. I made a Stargate SG1 fan video using that song in middle school. Now I feel old.

I have been subscribed since January and love this channel makes my day and his reactions are so funny

I will say it billy is the best movie reactor in this platform he's always smiling laughing and makes everything positive

"this scene right here remind me of twilight" now THAT is disrespectful, come on Billy 😂😂😂

I’m with you Billy… the cheese was real in this one as far as romance goes 😆 but I still love Hilary Duff. Even as a person, I really respect her a lot.

*Chad Michael Murray making an appearance* Me: "Ah yes, childhood crush ♡" Billy: "That fool lookin like a tuna fish. That's yalls crush huh???" Me: omg noooooo 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀 🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣😅