Тёмный

IS38 Hybrid turbo failures 

TurboDirect S.A
Подписаться 7 тыс.
Просмотров 21 тыс.
50% 1

We received communication after the release of the TurboDirect S.A High HP upgrade plans for 2020 video on the 27 Jan 2020 -- we touched on a sensitive subject where there is a common turbocharger failure in the hybrid turbochargers built for the IS38. We were asked to explain more about our video and to go into some more depth as to how and why these turbos fail.
We also received some criticism about the video and the fact that we exposed this via youtube. We decided to respond with FACT and go into the failure mechanism and explain in more detail as to the fact that these hybrid upgrades are in fact unreliable to support our first video - something the "nay sayers" didnt expect -
This video is a long one and outlines the fact that these hybrid turbochargers are unreliable - and WILL fail through a thrust bearing failure (axially) when boost pressures exceed 1.7-1.8bar boost.
Make sure to note - IN ORDER TO REACH THE ADVERTISED HP OF THESE HYBRIDS (500HP + - ) YOU NEED TO RUN HIGHER BOOST THAT 1.8-2.0BAR - TO THE DETRIMENT OF THE BEARING SYSTEM.
Hybrid designs for this specific turbocharger will remain reliable provided boost pressures are not pushed past 1.5-1.6bar boost MAXIMUM with enlarged rotating assemblies - with a maximum size exducer rotating assembly of around 62-66mm -- more than this, you are on borrowed time.

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 191   
@drhermanstein
@drhermanstein 2 года назад
I've personally torn down and built 4000 plus turbochargers over a 30 year period. This expert is correct on every point he makes.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
Thank you Herman - pity the majority of the "tooners" in the market especially in S.A have no idea what a turbo is or how it works, let alone limitations and how to spot a quality product and vice versa.
@acefighterpilot
@acefighterpilot 3 года назад
I was lucky to find this video on a Golf 7R forum. I really enjoy your style and presentation with hands on parts, and also that you are confirming my bias against aftermarket hybrid turbos. There is nothing I would love more than a G25-550 on my 7R. I used to work on TPE331s and I have the highest respect for Garrett AiResearch products.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Glad you enjoy the videos!
@geoffgorlick790
@geoffgorlick790 Год назад
Awesome explanation. I've heard that there can be issues but I haven't had anybody try to explain why. Thank you
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Glad to provide useful info - enjoy.
@blago6
@blago6 2 года назад
Mr. Gale Banks was right when he told us long time ago that the hybrid turbos are no good what a legend . Great video thanks for the info i always thought that how the original turbo was desined and calculated that is how is should be period.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
Hybrid upgrades are possible in some cases, not all. In most cases the inexperienced "hybrid builders" or "turbo guys" have no understanding of the relationship between the two rotating assemblies, and this is where they go wrong - bigger is almost NEVER better than a correctly matched/efficient combination. And then there is the bearing system - and this where where 99% of these "turbo guys" go wrong.
@fishfish8091
@fishfish8091 4 года назад
Great information for Any tuner who takes pride in their products and care about quality along with customer service. The haters are the ones who don't. Thank you for your hard work..
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Thanks for the comments - we love the haters, because our products prove themselves every time which fuels them even more, and they give us direction to make more videos to prove them wrong each time :-) There will always be nay sayers out there, we take them with a pinch of salt.
@sneakerfanatic39
@sneakerfanatic39 Год назад
im glad you touched on shaft diameter. good information
@Goose_JB74
@Goose_JB74 2 года назад
Thank you for share the clear details on the hybrid turbos, i was looking to upgrade to a hybrid is38 but that not going to happen.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
Pleasure - glad i could help and save you money and heart ache.
@tfk7106
@tfk7106 Месяц назад
My f82 m4 turbos are due for replacement. Ordered s55 pure stage 2 hybrid turbos last night. Just saw this video now and cancelled my order. Are all journal bearing hybrid turbos (for all modern cars) a bad idea? I was planning to run a basic OTS map around 24psi.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Месяц назад
@@tfk7106 if the OEM bearing system is used with upgraded rotating assembly components, bad idea. If you want reliability run a ball bearing setup in single turbo format, spool is good, performance is easy due to many available turbo options to suit. Price would be less aswell but fabrication would be involved
@alexhemming7060
@alexhemming7060 4 года назад
Found this video whilst looking to modify my Golf R. Nice to see a knowledgeable engineer passing on quality information. Saved myself and plenty others some headache and wasted money. Thanks!
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Thank you for the compliment - im glad you found value in what we do.
@DaseggMQB
@DaseggMQB 2 года назад
Thank you for the info! I’m still watching the video now, but would you say the common issues on is38’s are the same on is20’s?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
They share the same bearing system, the IS38 is more prone to failures, due to the larger rotating assembly and loads placed on the bearing system as a result. BUT they will both fail when you upgrade the rotating assemblies beyond a point - which is what all the "turbo guys" are doing --
@DaseggMQB
@DaseggMQB 2 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA thank you again for the knowledge. I am one of these guys, and just waiting a little longer to replace my is20. It’s been stage 2 for about 14k miles
@brianwilhelm9464
@brianwilhelm9464 2 года назад
@@DaseggMQB same boat here, what direction are you going to go? This video has been incredibly informative, I’ll probably still go the is38 route from FCP Euro as they have a lifetime warranty.
@DaseggMQB
@DaseggMQB 2 года назад
@@brianwilhelm9464 you know I’m still trying to decide the direction I want to go right now. I’m thinking I’ll do a vortex standard though honestly
@Carguylogan
@Carguylogan Год назад
What about the OEM is38? I'm using one on my GTI with a Unitronic tune that peaks at 1.6 bar.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Depending on tuning and how the speed limiter map was setup, you might/might not be on borrowed time. The IS38 is NOT reliable when pushed.
@Carguylogan
@Carguylogan Год назад
@@TurboDirectSA I am pretty sure they have the turbo speed set conservatively. It peaks at 22 psi at low elevation but drops to 19 psi at high elevation. Their stage 1 tune for the stock turbo didn't lose boost like that, it held the same boost pressure at elevation.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
@@Carguylogan Nothing conservative about a compressor map im afraid, these are real world tests results from a gas stand -
@southfloridaskimmin
@southfloridaskimmin 3 года назад
A certain company makes a turbo called a bb550 which is supposedly a whole new CHRA with ball bearings and it’s fitted with an exhaust housing built just for it as well as the compressor. Think it would be a reliable unit? Or would it have the same issue? Not sure if the redesign with ball bearings fixes the issues you’re showing
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
I have never heard of it, i cannot comment as i have no idea what BB cartridge is being used, for example there are various chinese companies who are marketing the BB setups, and purchasing these cartridges from a chinese company which wont be mentioned, but don't expect reliability from these inferior designs. There are other who import the cartridges from Europe and some from other countries, which seem to be more reliable. If you can find the original manufacturer of the BB cartridge of the OEM's you might find a reliable setup, IF you know how to engineer the internal structure of the supporting components. There is ALOT more to a BB setup than inserting a cartridge into a housing and bolting everything together and then balancing it. This is why we opted for the Genuine Garrett GTX3071R Gen2 inside our own housings. We will however have our own BB setup released this year to have an offering that competes with the Garrett G-series at a price point that is attractive.
@southfloridaskimmin
@southfloridaskimmin 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA it’s CTS bb550 turbo
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@southfloridaskimmin If its a Genuine OEM CHRA from the likes of Garrett or EFR, then trust it, provided the turbine housing is up to spec. If not - i would do research on what BB cartridge is used inside.
@perfect8639
@perfect8639 4 года назад
500hp or 500whp
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
The turbo makes 500WHP on our dyno - every dyno is different.
@fishfish8091
@fishfish8091 4 года назад
Hype versus facts. This is a must watch video before you spend your hard earned money...
@satajettube
@satajettube 4 года назад
Awesome vid , informative
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Thanks a lot!
@MikemoRides
@MikemoRides 3 года назад
Oh boy, my stock IS20 peaking at 1.9bar is going to pop.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
The IS20 has a smaller rotating assembly with less thrust loads - they will handle slightly higher boost than the larger IS38 will. Both turbos use the same internal bearing components, you safe -- for now, but who knows for how log.
@DJ-lc1en
@DJ-lc1en Год назад
I was going to upgrade to a pure turbo stage 2 turbo on my 2011 535i is this not a good idea?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
I wouldnt use a hybrid turbo as an upgrade, and especially not one that costs that much -- i would lean towards a ball bearing turbo and do the necessary manifold mods to accomodate.
@BeAllEndAll-i3e
@BeAllEndAll-i3e Год назад
Do you guys have any stock is38s that are second hand? Desperate for one
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Yes, the turbo from the development car is being refreshed and will be put up for sale - shoot an email to info@turbodirect.co.za
@arronlowley5659
@arronlowley5659 4 года назад
my cupra 280 has gone through 2 oem is38 turbos within the space of 2500 miles, i have logged the car many times, my tuner claims my boost levels to have been set to 1.8 bar mid range and 1.45 bar at the redline, however logs shows that my car can peak between 1.9-1.95 bar of boost, from my understanding this is overboost and could potentially be why both have failed.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
There are a number of issues with the Stock IS38 -- the first is that they dont like high boost when governed by the incorrect torque limiter. So Boost versus turbine speed dont line up - 1.8bar boost is high for a stock IS38, but how the boost is achieved is what causes the issues. There is a turbine speed limiter map in the tuning, and most maps seem to confuse this with a torque limiter and increase this to get more power/boost/torque etc This is not the way to achieve this - the trick is in the DSG software.
@PVW4EVER
@PVW4EVER 3 года назад
Absolutely the BEST!!! explanation of how a turbo works and fails. Also how cheap hybrids are made Salute to you mate!
@dylan4972
@dylan4972 Год назад
I've always said full frame is better glad this video confirms it.
@HP-qr7tt
@HP-qr7tt 3 года назад
This is going the rounds in Australia. I always knew something was sus with these hybrids. Those shaft bearings comparisons are in believable!
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Good to know.
@marcpec11
@marcpec11 Год назад
Im interested in getting a Garrett G2260S Powermax stage 1 turbo, is the shaft thickness 6mm like the G25-660? Is it more reliable than the standard IS38 and the IS38 hybrids? The 2260s is journal bearing so im not too sure if its as reliable as the G25-660
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Stay away from ANY IS38 hybrid - they WILL fail. The Ball bearing bolt on turbocharger we manufacture are proven and reliable and make the power - see here:- ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-mXeSW9B17bs.html
@tiktokshortsellabellahi7949
Hi I have a 2014 gti dsg pp I'm looking to get a little more power what recommendations do you have just looking for some decent knowledge from somebody who knows there stuff not looking to kill it tho just that little more umfffff
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Thanks for the comment - see these two links:- 1) store.turbodirect.co.za/index.php/shop/turbochargers/is38-450t-forged-5568-detail 2) store.turbodirect.co.za/index.php/shop/turbochargers/is38-550t-forged-5569-detail These are two options that will definitely give you ALOT more oumph.
@markd7922
@markd7922 4 года назад
REVO IS38ETR 2 years and still running great.
@digiviceking
@digiviceking 4 года назад
this is in my future mod list. 😄
@TheCinderellaman10
@TheCinderellaman10 Год назад
Is the revo is38etr a ff dual bb turbo? I have a 5f cupra 290 so too looking for a stage 3 setup with a good reliable turbo setup for around 550 max
@TheCinderellaman10
@TheCinderellaman10 Год назад
Watching this i learnt alot and now i know what to look for and ask for when upgrading to a hybrid is38 setup but a full frame gen2 dual bb is the way
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Glad you enjoy the content.
@billmelendez9246
@billmelendez9246 3 года назад
Thanks for the information! Why don't you show the company names? Just to create customer awareness. These hybrids are not cheap, to be risking the money for something that is going to break.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Sorry cant do this - we do not slander any company or person. I can give you a general warning on the IS38 turbochargers - while using OE size and specification bearing system components, THE TURBO WILL FAIL IF YOU UPGRADE IT IN ANY WAY OR FORM - GUARANTEED. If you run high boost on a stock IS38 - THE TURBO WILL FAIL. for 350WHP and more - original IS38 turbochargers aswell as hybrids using stock bearing systems WILL NOT LAST. No matter what the name plate says on it.
@everrojas9768
@everrojas9768 3 года назад
Congratulations for the video and the accurate information. I want to upgrade to stage 3 and I am evaluating the Racingline Stage 3 turbo kit (turbo hybrid). I know they use the IHI and use their own turbine wheels and high-spec bearing pack inside. They offer 490 hp on stage 3. Do you know the reliability of these turbos? Thank you
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Thanks for your comments. No matter what the name is on the turbo - if the bearing system and the shaft dimensions are not changed you WILL see a failure - guaranteed. We have just finished testing and tuning our latest is38-450 which is a dual ball bearing turbo (watch out for the video coming soon) This turbo was put up against one of the popular 500HP capable unit from the UK at the same boost, same dyno and the results were interesting. Ill post the video on the channel soon. What you want is a reliable rotating assembly, that is responsive and makes the claimed power (possibly more) - this is what we have concentrated on and have succeeded with this and to top it off we have a price point that no apples with apples turbo can match.
@AndrewSmith-sy7ws
@AndrewSmith-sy7ws 4 года назад
I have a IS20 hybrid turbo set to 1.4 bar on my 2013 Golf 7 Gti supported by a downpipe intake and software. Is my turbo safe since it was built by turbo direct?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Andrew Smith this boost pressure is not extreme and should not be unreliable. start to push the boundaries around 1.8bar and upwards of this and you will be on borrowed time, this i promise you.
@MegaHollywood1971
@MegaHollywood1971 3 года назад
So basically, by the "look" of the turbo shown at the end (rusted) it was in use for quite some time. Could be TUNE related, rather than manufacture related correct?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
The rust on the housing is simply surface rust, the housing has been standing for months, we use this for training, so this is not a clear indication of the condition of the turbo as it came off the car. the failure is directly related to the abnormal expectation for such a tiny rotating assembly to perform outside of any realistic environment. Regardless of tuning - even if this size combination was run at 1.0bar gauge pressure the turbo would never last long. Remember the rotating assembly is designed to produce 550HP - in order to make this power you need to run high boost - therein lies the problem - boost it and it dies, the higher the boost the faster it will die - but DIE it WILL.
@gaijins30
@gaijins30 3 года назад
Reminds me of the TD03 'upgrades' for the BMW N54 platforms, many of the same problems causing the same issues. SMH
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Exactly right buddy - Hybrid turbochargers on small rotating assemblies with small AR housings do not work - period.
@Babyarmsss
@Babyarmsss 3 года назад
so what big turbo do you say i should buy for a 2017 a3 quattro 2.0?? @turbodirect s.a
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
What HP target ?
@huka_ro7852
@huka_ro7852 3 года назад
Thank you for the clear explanation, and the tour inside the IS38. Subscribed!
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Pleasure sir - glad you enjoyed.
@bm717252
@bm717252 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA very informative and thanks 🙏
@corey7610
@corey7610 2 года назад
To be clear, this video is specifically referring to JOURNAL hybrid IS38 turbos. Ball bearing hybrid turbos do not have these problems that were described with the shaft flex etc.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
Correct - the journal bearing upgraded "hybrids" apply.
@TheCinderellaman10
@TheCinderellaman10 Год назад
More then 95% of is38 hybrid turbos in the UK are journal bearing. Full frame gen2 BB turbos are the best and the way to go
@jaylonchung9528
@jaylonchung9528 2 года назад
Very informative video. I have had my eyes on the CTS BB-550 hybrid is38, it’s got a td06 compressor wheel but mainly interested because it features a dual ceramic ball bearing. Would this be a reliable hybrid option?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
turbodirect.co.za/store/index.php/shop/category-layout/results,1-24?virtuemart_category_id=&keyword=is38+forged&limitstart=0&option=com_virtuemart&view=category&Itemid=541 These are reliable, and unbeatable bang for the buck - tested and proven on our own shop development car for over 40 000kms
@jaylonchung9528
@jaylonchung9528 2 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA thanks. What is the difference between logitudinal and transverse engines and how do i know which one i have
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
@@jaylonchung9528 If your engine is inline with the car its inline - if the engine sits sideways from left to right with the gearbox on the right hand side of the engine, its Transverse.
@JordieG8
@JordieG8 Год назад
Thanks for saving me from a Hybrid. I decided to go with a GT2260 PMax.
@TheBruhProductions
@TheBruhProductions 3 года назад
Is the Rev9 IS38 unreliable? The upgraded billet one to be specific.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Does this turbo use the stock bearing system ? If it does, then it is unreliable guaranteed especially if it has any upgraded rotating assembly parts.
@SlipperyPapi
@SlipperyPapi 2 года назад
Great video, great explanation.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 2 года назад
Thank you for the compliment
@koketsomnguni3224
@koketsomnguni3224 4 года назад
Awesome video bro! Thank you for saving me cash
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Pleasure
@beaubear6516
@beaubear6516 2 года назад
How about the v5 ....
@Eli07K
@Eli07K 3 года назад
I'm in the market looking for 500hp on a Audi S3 8V Pre-facelift. What's your take on Revo new IS38ETR V2? I'm would really appreciate your feedback?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
If the bearing system uses the stock OEM dimensions, it WILL fail - period. This is what i would suggest if it is a journal bearing setup bolt on, that you are after. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-POd230p7cTs.html If its a ball bearing turbo you after - this is what i would suggest - also bolt on. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N_sNwMPGNkM.html
@Eli07K
@Eli07K 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA They say and I quote: The bearing housing has also been enlarged and upgraded to make room for a specifically designed 360° thrust bearing system, incorporating a custom 4 oil-fed thrust pad for increased reliability. Precision VSR balanced to levels above the OEM specification
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@Eli07K If the bearing system and shaft diameter is enlarged, then they have addressed the weakness in the turbo.
@stephenpato5524
@stephenpato5524 3 года назад
Woah.... I've a stock ea113 in my A3. Now scared to just remap lol! K03s boost pretty low from factory (0.6bar I think). If these tuner are simply increasing peak boost and holding it it till redline then surely k03s can't last too long? Although the more expensive route I should be fine reliability wise just aiming for a k04 set up correct? Thanks for this video.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Stephen, dont stress, the K03 design bearing system is capable of handling ALOT more thrust loading than the IS38 can. The K04 route is reliable and you dont have to worry about too much with these upgrades. OBVIOUSLY exaggerate the upgrade it will fail on you.
@stephenpato5524
@stephenpato5524 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA Staying K03 you can do things incrementally and spread costs over time (albeit with a lower ceiling), k04 wants an immediate kidney/lung down-payment lol! Thanks for your responses, subscribed.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@stephenpato5524 LOL thanks for the comment Stephen
@damianblazevic1518
@damianblazevic1518 3 года назад
I like you..we are now friends
@jim7087
@jim7087 3 года назад
Hey , i have polo 1.5 150hp dsg, can you tell me please if its safe for engine and dsg to take it around 240hp ,what is tour opinion for these motors?what will you do?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Dimitris i have never had personal experience with this engine, i cannot give you an accurate answer im afraid. I would research online and check with tuners or companies who have played with these engines and see what they have achieved on a stock motor. Dont take chances, in case there is a hidden secret that might bite you later.
@jim7087
@jim7087 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA Thank you for your instant reply , i'l be waiting if you find something , thanks a lot
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@jim7087 Pleasure buddy
@tousseefharoun2746
@tousseefharoun2746 4 года назад
Can't wait for the N55 Hybrids from Turbo Direct
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Funny enough we will be releasing a video on our upgraded N55 compressor hybrid build in the next few days - watch out for this one coming soon. :-)
@thesneakerbully9530
@thesneakerbully9530 4 года назад
Hey I'm looking at the HPA IS38 OEM+ with stronger internals NOT A HYBRID IM ONLY LOOKING TO GET 400HP OUT OF THE CAR IS THIS A RELIABLE TURBO
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Provided the shaft and bearing system is upgraded (not changed for new IS38 dimensional replacements) then you should see more reliability.
@euroblackicechronicles8177
@euroblackicechronicles8177 4 года назад
This is enlightened, what do you recommend for 2.2 bar +?
@euroblackicechronicles8177
@euroblackicechronicles8177 4 года назад
Do you guys offer a twin scroll?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
What HP target do you have in mind? Why would you want a twin scroll?
@arronlowley5659
@arronlowley5659 4 года назад
Hi could you help me out, I recently sent back an is38 running stock turbine and compressor but apparently had uprated bearings, I sent it back as it had in and out play, when the turbo had returned to the company and was checked over, the rear of the turbine had chips In it and also the bearings were scored, what could have been the cause? The engine was flushed before the turbo was installed and the intercooler was cleaned out.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
It seems really odd that a stock IS38 has upgraded bearings. In order to upgrade the bearings, the entire bearing housing would have to be machined, the thrust bearing, journals and split seal rings would have to be changed, and then both the turbine wheel and compressor wheel would have to change aswell - one of the upgrades done to the jounal bearings is that the diameter is increased. I have never seen this before - however if you have pictures of everything you can send this to info@turbodirect.co.za and ill get Chris to look at them and comment for you.
@arronlowley8890
@arronlowley8890 4 года назад
I have had 2 oem is38s fail within 2500 miles of each other, the first time the shaft snapped where you show on this video, on the turbine side, the second one actually snapped on the compressor side, both times I noticed that on the back of the compressor wheel, on the flat side, that they were severely cracked, is this due to heat?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
The damage sustained to the compressor back disc is as a result of the failure - it is not the failure mechanism itself.
@FLeXJun
@FLeXJun 4 года назад
Do you offer turbos for mk7 gti MQB?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
yes we do -
@thecrazycomputer001
@thecrazycomputer001 4 года назад
Hello, is the IS38 reliable in a stage 1 configuration on a Mk7.5 Golf R? I’m thinking of pushing it to something like 370 horsepower
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Depending on boost and the tuning - now thats like saying how long is a piece of string. There is a map inside the SIMOS ECU which governs turbo speed, most "tuners" see this as a torque limiter and incorrectly increase this map which causes issues with reliability. Boost pressures should not exceed 1.5bar to be reliable from our experience. Together with a TCU tune you can get reliability but i doubt you will see 370WHP reliably on a stock IS38
@thecrazycomputer001
@thecrazycomputer001 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA Thank you for the answer! I was referring to 370 hp at the crank, is that more feasible?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
@@thecrazycomputer001 Im not worries about HP - its the tuning and boost pressure (rotational speed) that determines reliability - thats the long and the short of it im afraid. Keep the boost low and the turbo will last - regardless of HP -- Push the limits and bare the consequences.
@Ken888
@Ken888 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA so would running a JB4 create reliability issues since certain maps add +6 PSI of boost?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@Ken888 If the bearing system internally on the IS38 is stock and you run high boost (regardless of how you get the boost to increase or whether the rotating assembly is stock or upgraded) the turbo WILL fail - period.
@DVerbe
@DVerbe Год назад
Most turbos fail because people abuse them, expecting to much and boosting it to high.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA Год назад
Although i agree with you in many cases, the IS38 matter refers to a very under-designed bearing system, which cnnot handle stage1 software for long before showing signs of abnormal wear and resulting failure -- and then you get the 'turbo guys' who slap on the largest compressor wheel (because it makes power) and the turbo fails inside of 3 dyno runs..... In this case, the failures relate to 'tooners' who know very little about turbochargers in general. - Sad but true, especially in South Africa.
@AdrianPurcell916
@AdrianPurcell916 3 года назад
Great explanation sir, thanks for the great content
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Thank you Adrian much appreciated
@AdrianPurcell916
@AdrianPurcell916 3 года назад
Ijs...every dollar I spend on my car has to count. It's my daily and I put my kids in it all the time. The Is38 is the recommended unit for my car by a lot of tuners, without cracking into the engine anyway. I'm personally wanting to go with the GT3071R, it's just a money thing currently, due to needing to up the fuel delivery and injectors to go along with the extra flow. I'm currently driving/building a 2010 Audi A3 fwd. full bolt ons with apr stage 2. Any alternative to this I'm open to suggestions
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@AdrianPurcell916 thats the first sensible comment surrounding making a choice for an upgraded turbocharger i have seen. I believe everyone should share the same views when deciding on upgrading anything turbo related. The fuel system does not need to be upgraded unless you want to start pushing the HP boundaries - its all about how much power you intend making. 400WHP the stock fuel system should be fine. More than this you need to consider upgrading engine internals anyway, and then at the same time you should be upgrading the fuel system aswell. I would consider a bolt on setup like the IS38-700 here:- ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N_sNwMPGNkM.html This is one option of many out there
@AdrianPurcell916
@AdrianPurcell916 3 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA there's no reason to go over 400 in my family car, especially when it's fully upgraded with every Bolt on and software too boot. I just want a good ball bearing unit that makes great sounds lol. The kiddos are into wrenching ( all the elementary classmates think they are so cool coming to school in a "racecar"
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
@@AdrianPurcell916 My sentiment exactly fo a street family car - the IS38-700 is a perfect candidate for this.
@hassanabbashassan9767
@hassanabbashassan9767 4 года назад
Hi Chris Have you checked out Snail Turbo CBB IS38 Hybrid Turbo. Its a company from Taiwan.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
They still use stock turbine housing on the G7R unit, utilizing copied ball bearing call bearing cartridges from "imported from Germany" - which all the Chinese companies use. None of the original Garrett ball bearing cartridges are manufactured in Germany nor by a German company. The company that actually makes the ball bearing cartridges are called CNracing - and the quality is light years away from the original Garrett bearing design. See my other video on the copied G25-660 made by booshiwheel - they use the same "made in germany" bearing - the video speaks for itself.
@grahamorourke7155
@grahamorourke7155 4 года назад
Any experience with Littco L500. Currently have it fitted running 2 bar 500bhp
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
No we haven't had any experience with these turbos, not sure of the design or bearing system, so i cannot comment on this specific turbo.
@valterponte
@valterponte 4 года назад
have you heard of a german company that uses original td06 bearings in theirs is38 hybrids?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Its not whether or not the bearings are original MHI or not - it's the design of the shaft and bearing housing aswell as the thrust assembly that makes the setup reliable or not. The stock IS38 shaft diameter (compressor fit) is 5.0mm and the IS38-600 which is our journal bearing setup uses a shaft we designed with a diameter of 6.8mm - so far over 2.2bar boost we have yet to see we thrust failure
@kurtfarao6113
@kurtfarao6113 4 года назад
Very impressive diagnosis of turbo failure using math and science! You're shortlisted as someone I want to consult when I go big turbo on my Golf 5 GTI.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Thank you Kurt - what we do is in fact maths and a lot of science. :-)
@justincharlebois
@justincharlebois 3 года назад
So are they are ball bearing hybrids or only the journal bearing?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
Ball Bearing "turbos" are not modified OEM units, therefore we don't consider them as a hybrid. If you referring to chinese IS38 copies with BB cartridges inside, these are very far away from being reliable. Seen them, tested them and killed them.
@MeltingRubberZ28
@MeltingRubberZ28 4 года назад
Do you guys make an upgraded IS38? I'm struggling to search thru your website and stuff and am interested in some day upgrading my IS20 to one....
@tiktokshortsellabellahi7949
Me to for my gti just exploring options before I fcuk my car up lol
@MeltingRubberZ28
@MeltingRubberZ28 Год назад
@@tiktokshortsellabellahi7949 I went with FCP Euro. Lifetime warranty. IS38 is great.
@ivdubgti
@ivdubgti 3 года назад
OEM is38 running Great!
@SomeOne-on6yf
@SomeOne-on6yf 4 года назад
So this goes for the EQT XL as well???
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
If it has the same shaft and bearing system diameter as the original unit, and you are boosting above 1.6-1.8bar gauge - then it doesn't matter what the products name is - it will fail as soon as the shaft flexes - we have an upgraded shaft and bearing system with 30% enlarged distribution area on the thrust bearing and mating components, we testing this at 2.5bar gauge press currently with good results - however the boost pressure has reached diminishing gains - (more boost makes no additional power, just introduce heat into the engine) most of the 52mm inducer compressor designs will max out at around 2.2bar gauge -
@SomeOne-on6yf
@SomeOne-on6yf 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA we haven't tuned it yet, but i believe we should be good up to 2.6bar on the hybrid i have
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
@@SomeOne-on6yf I wish you all the luck with the tuning.
@SomeOne-on6yf
@SomeOne-on6yf 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA thanks, ill post dyno videos
@dwvw
@dwvw 4 года назад
The EQT and Tomioka aren't true hybrids, they use all new castings, I would think they have upgraded shafts at that point and shaft flex wouldn't be an issue.
@SayWhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat
@SayWhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat 3 года назад
3:05 as always no link no where...
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 3 года назад
It was a video removed as it was literally 2 minutes long and went about a compressor wheel that is designed to produce say 50lb/min of air flow (500HP) will need to run at a specific speed (boost) in order to make this power. The problem with the 99% of Hybrid turbochargers is that in order to make this power, you need to run more boost than the bearing system can handle - thereby killing the turbo - BMWN54, IS38, IS20, Audi 2.7T, and many others included.
@Lange1979
@Lange1979 4 года назад
How about Shuenk IS38+? any experience? They Increased-strength rotor shaft & stem with larger crosssection diameter... at least that is what you can read on their site. Thanks
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Hi Diego, never had experience with them but if they have upgraded the internal bearing system and shaft cross section, then they are addressing the problem area.
@MeltingRubberZ28
@MeltingRubberZ28 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA here is a link to one: sneekytuned.com/collections/vw-audi-products/products/copy-of-shuenk-is38-oem-upgraded-is38-turbocharger-for-mk7-golf-ea888-gen3-mqb Does this seem like a better offering than the standard IS38? I'm really not interested in a hybrid turbo honestly. I haven't watched your video yet but I have a pretty good idea of what you're going to say. Will watch shortly.
@MeltingRubberZ28
@MeltingRubberZ28 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA here is a direct link to the manufacturer: shuenk.com/products/is38 It appears that they are upgrading everything, just using the standard casting. The shaft, turbine wheels, and bearings, and seals all appear to be/claimed to be upgraded. In the one photo the shaft it sits on appears to be quite large.
@MeltingRubberZ28
@MeltingRubberZ28 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA are those bearings upgraded? Upon second look it appears they may have just changed materials? The photo of the shaft and turbine wheels themselves appears to have a larger shaft, but those bearings still look pretty small. The reason I'm asking all these questions is I'm basically just looking to be able to make ~375WHP reliably on an IS38....
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
@@MeltingRubberZ28 Thanks for the comments and questions, firstly changing materials will not make the hybrid IS38 turbocharger out there more reliable, nor will this increase the tolerance for high thrust loading when running around 1.8bar + boost. The design itself for the enlarged rotating assembly is the issue - this is why we changed the design entirely. ALL bearings and thrust components are not off the shelf products, they are custom made and proven at boost levels over 2.0bar boost on circuit racers with 100% reliability. The stock casings (turbine and compressor housings) are not able to flow enough to compliment the high flow rates of the upgraded wheels we use in our IS38-600 and IS38-700 -- we have larger AR housings which compliment the flow instead of restricting it.
@bboyvillain84
@bboyvillain84 4 года назад
So just go big turbo? CTS Boss kit?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
There are many products and options out there - and each one has a different budget requirement - we offer a range of products as an example - the client chooses what he likes/can afford / prefers. We aim to do the comparisons, reviews, and share factual information on the products out there - and we leave the rest to the customer to choose.
@BoostBroers
@BoostBroers 4 года назад
Thanks for this video. For me it was to late. My TTE610R Turbo broke. An expert told me Lots about why and it compare to what You say. Never run a TTE on your Golf. High money for a Turbo that was not made to handel the power. I will be dropping a video soon if Anyone wants to see for themself.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Please share the video, id be keen to see if the failure is similar to the ones we have seen coming past our lab. We have seen models and makes from all over the world.
@BoostBroers
@BoostBroers 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA will do soon
@BoostBroers
@BoostBroers 4 года назад
My video is up let me know what You think
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
@@BoostBroers Send the link here buddy
@qendrimberisha5773
@qendrimberisha5773 4 года назад
Hi! I have Leon Cupra ST 4drive DSG 2018 model and its stock, I was wondering do you think that I can do a stage 1 or 2 without causing turbo failure? I was thinking 400hp maximum.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
HI there Qendrim - the stock IS38 turbocharger with stage 2 software is already on the limits of reliability due to the small bearing system - upgrading the compressor stage to a 400HP setup is pushing the limits even more. Many say they have a reliable setup with similar mods, but there are more people who have suffered failures with the same upgrades. Its not reliable at all - Depending on the application (track, street, drag etc) I would recommend using the Swirl adapter and bolting on something like the EFR7163, or G25-550/660 - the swirl adapter can be found here:- ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-y6PA_Xc0feI.html
@gt-innovationgt-innovation5729
@gt-innovationgt-innovation5729 4 года назад
It was about time ...... Tuners have to wake up and this goes on for years even back when 1.6 turbo fords were top on the tuning scene..
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Agreed- we dont normally get involved with the weak points of products and upgrades, but there are so many customers screaming for our help in determining the cause of failures, that we had to release something to point customers toward to explain in some sort of understandable outline that people could find out why turbos are dying.
@gt-innovationgt-innovation5729
@gt-innovationgt-innovation5729 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA Is38 is weak by design as well...very bad platform for even tiny upgrades in the same shaft...Personally back in 2014 when i tried to push the golf 7 R to the limits i found out how weak they are very fast..
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
@@gt-innovationgt-innovation5729 exactly my point. Well there are solutions which we will put out a video on in the next two weeks - but first we have a bigger project we will be releasing this week.
@kamilw5620
@kamilw5620 4 года назад
good job
@Christdeliverme
@Christdeliverme 4 года назад
Exceptional mechanical forensics demonstration here
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
Thank you sire
@okkimistic
@okkimistic 3 года назад
Good info, but please use better microphone (and closer to the speaker) to get better audio.
@FLeXJun
@FLeXJun 4 года назад
I was able to recognize those wheels right away. Which turbos do you recommend for at least 580whp?
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
We have two options for the EA888 MQB platform - IS38-600 journal bearing and IS38-700 ball bearing models Check out this link for the journal bearing unit. turbodirect.co.za/store/index.php/shop/turbochargers/turbocharger-turbodirect-s-a/performance-racing-3/bolt-on-vehicle-specific-turbochargers/golf7r-is38-hulk-8blade-billet-compressor-4112-4288-4290-detail And this link for the Garrett GTX3071R CHRA built unit turbodirect.co.za/store/index.php/shop/turbochargers/turbocharger-turbodirect-s-a/performance-racing-3/bolt-on-vehicle-specific-turbochargers/golf7r-is38-hulk-8blade-billet-compressor-4112-4288-detail
@FLeXJun
@FLeXJun 4 года назад
@@TurboDirectSA I am highly interested in the IS38700. I have a built motor, built head, aftermarket manifold, 3.5inch downpipe, 1300cc injectors and dual 450 fuel pumps. I would like to test your unit to the max, I sent you an email (junjunm@gmail.com). Let's talk!
@RSX250
@RSX250 4 года назад
DBV2 is the only Hybrid is38 I know of that does have a full TD06 CHARA installed.
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
No Sir - we use TD06 turbine shaft BUT a further upgraded bearing design over the TD06 Thrust assembly, making our rotating assembly even more reliable then the TD06 setup. In fact ALL Hybrid setups use TD06 internals (shaft and compressor wheel) but still use the IS38 bearing system - which is why they are all unreliable
@Bigoleb0y.
@Bigoleb0y. 4 года назад
just buy a Littco turbo
@TurboDirectSA
@TurboDirectSA 4 года назад
for less money than anytinhg else on the market here are two options that fix and safeguard the failures in the poor design Hybrid turbos using stock bearing systems and shaft diameters ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-POd230p7cTs.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N_sNwMPGNkM.html
Далее
Golf7R IS38-450 Dual ball bearing turbocharger
22:41
Understanding T3:T4 turbochargers
29:16
Просмотров 24 тыс.
КВН 2024 Встреча выпускников
2:00:41
Golf R Hybrid TURBO Tuning! *PROBLEMS*
10:59
Просмотров 10 тыс.
Turbo Failure analysed
18:07
Просмотров 22 тыс.
BUILDING MY 500BHP GOLF R *LITTCO* HYBRID TURBO!!
23:43
Whats the best setup for a stock motor Golf7R MQB
9:55
How Hybrid Turbos Are Made & What They Do!
12:02
Просмотров 316 тыс.
We Installed A Hybrid Turbo For BIG Power Gains!
13:36
Просмотров 324 тыс.