John Lennon Plastic Ono Band Ultimate Edition Review

Подписаться 16 тыс.

Просмотров 13 тыс.

50% 1

John Lennon Plastic Ono Band Ultimate Edition Review
Amazon Pre Order links here:
Deluxe 6CD + 2 Blu Ray box: amzn.to/3rk1A19
2 LP vinyl: amzn.to/2PtITtP
1LP vinyl: amzn.to/3sMy6sZ
2CD: amzn.to/3eTYu0y
1CD: amzn.to/3lzSj2P
Also reviewed by:
Norman Maslov "Mazzy": • John Lennon Plastic On...
Although I was very lucky and honoured to receive these products for free, I have not in any way been asked to promote them in any specific way, I was not even under any obligation to make a video on the subject. I am entirely free to be critical in these videos in any way I decide, with no editorial restrictions on me.
Video Contents:
0:00 Intro
1:00 Packaging
6:22 Out-Takes
10:33 Elements Mixes
15:09 Raw Studio Mixes
18:27 Evolution Mixes
20:33 Demos & Jams
23:45 Blu Ray Exclusives (inc. Yoko Sessions)
28:45 Main Album Remix
37:40 Outro
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Subscribe to see my future videos by clicking here: tinyurl.com/y4hnfsec
Visit my channel page : tinyurl.com/y2unpo36
Playlist of all my Beatles videos: • The Beatles
Playlist of all my Paul McCartney videos: • Paul McCartney
Playlist "McCartney Through The Decades" - all episodes - highlighting my favourite songs from each era of Paul's career: • Paul McCartney Through...
Playlist, my series of Paul McCartney album rankings - • Paul McCartney Album R...
Playlist, my Top 10 Albums of Each Decade: • Top 10 Albums of Each ...
Vinyl & CD Updates, a playlist of recent additions to my collection: • Vinyl & CD Updates - W...
Videos Background music by www.bensound.com
*DISCLAIMER: If the description contains links to purchase products mentioned in this video, then these are Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase something through one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission, at NO extra cost to you!
This helps to support the channel and allows me to continue creating videos like this.
Thanks for the support!

Опубликовано:

15 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 213

@jakebeaufell7780 3 года назад

I swear you’re the nicest person ever on RU-vid, watching your videos is always great and interesting, keep it up !!!

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thank you, much appreciated!

@einarjohannguleifsson9470 3 года назад

@@invisibleray6987 h

@danielpark9654 3 года назад

Lennon's estate a few days ago as a Twitter reply said they were "hopefully" going to do more remixes and reissues. Great review too .

@knockedoutloaded279 3 года назад

Hope they do every album, and dakota demos deluxe and bermuda tapes deluxe and streets of dreams and making of double fantasy with rare footage..

@kristdelgado 3 года назад

I read an interview with those people involved in the making of "Gimme Some Truth" box set (producers and mixing engineers) and they hinted that a serie of reissues are yet to come. They thought Yoko selected "Imagine" first because it was his most commercial album. Then "Plastic Ono Band". The order is going similar to the remixed albums released in 2000.

@raymondporter 3 года назад

What a comprehensive brilliant review. You are so honest caring and sincere.

@Pamela-rq8cy 3 года назад

Thanks for the great review! I second your vote for a “Sometime in NYC” box.

@farrellmcnulty909 2 года назад

Two words - "elephant's memory". Great musicians make an album rock, but Elephants Memory makes Sometime in New York City RAWCK!

@Linkjeeee 3 года назад

Awesome review man! Looking forward to it!

@edwardrhodes8983 3 года назад

Great review Andrew! Very helpful!!!

@philmulliner3913 3 года назад

Thanks Andrew , sounds terrific but the rest of us have to wait a whole month now for our copies ! Well well well ... oh well

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Hold on Phil, Phil hold on, it's gonna be alright! 😉👍

@tontofromtheloneranger1526 3 года назад

Better 39 minutes than a Game of Thrones episode

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

And a fraction of the budget 😄. Thank you.

@tontofromtheloneranger1526 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Master! You should visit John Lennon's instagram page. ;)

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@@tontofromtheloneranger1526 Yes Ive seen that, thanks, nice surprise 🙂

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@Lloyd Boon 🤢😲

@skee19 3 года назад

@Lloyd Boon 🤣

@williamtyler9123 3 года назад

Great review. I have both the 2 LP and the Deluxe Set ordered. This video got me excited so now I’m counting down the days. You only get to hear a song for the first time once, but with these remixes it’s like getting to hear everything for the first time again.

@lordwormpie 3 года назад

Just what we needed. Thanks so much.

@robscuremusic 3 года назад

Great review Andrew. I can't wait to get my copy.

@stevenjones57 3 года назад

Cor blimey, Andrew, you really know your stuff! So insightful, so knowledgeable, so articulate, so entertaining. Well done you! It's no wonder at all that Yoko & Sean sent you the new release! Stay safe and continue to enjoy your world. All the best, Steven

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Steven, much appreciated! 🙂👍

@byrons61 3 года назад

Another great review Andrew. Thank you!

@stephenjones101 3 года назад

Being "in the mood" for Yoko Ono's "singing" is like being in the mood for having Wisdom Teeth removed without anesthetic. Can't remember ever being in that mood.

@robintownrobintown 3 года назад

Come on, that's a bit harsh

@robscuremusic 3 года назад

You obviously need to open you eyes, your ears and your heart to new experiences.

@beatleszilla 3 года назад

If only they could just remove her vocal track, I’d totally be down for a couple extra hours of John, Ringo, and Klaus jamming psychedelically

@caelramos1005 3 года назад

Makes me sick Yoko is milking all the glorious and clips they made in vinyl videos unreleased material. And promoting over and over the new Plastic Ono Band. With paid reviewers!!!!!! What a shame. So greedy😖😩

@mountart2 3 года назад

Couldn't agree more, these remixes from the Lennon camp are a godsend... Can't wait for Walls & Bridges and Mind Games remix box sets, which, IMHO, really need remixing badly!

@1985indeed 3 года назад

Might be worth tracking down the 2002 remix of Mind Games then - as it sounds good to my ears. There was also a 2005 re-release of Walls And Bridges with some of the tracks remixed so probably worth tracking those down if you still can.

@markplank5929 3 года назад

Comprehensive & sincere. Thank you for your in depth review.

@timshearn8203 3 года назад

Great review Andrew, excited to hear it for myself.

@Holywell88 3 года назад

Can’t wait to get my hands on this

@mazzysmusic 3 года назад

Great detailed overview. Looking forward to listen to these version and really excited to hear the expanded Yoko tracks. ✌🏻

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Mazzy, hope yours is with you soon!

@fgrady1 3 года назад

Now, THAT’S what I call a thorough examination of the contents of a compilation of one of my favorite all-time artists. When my box set arrives, it’s likely to take a week for me to go through the bulk of it but, man, I am stoked for the arrival at my humble abode! Again, a superlative review, Andrew. Cheers!

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks Fred, I'm sure you'll love it when it arrives!

@jasonbrooks6562 3 года назад

Excellent appraisal of a wonderful album. Well done.

@Zholobov1 3 года назад

Thanks a lot, Andrew! My congratulations: you're the first with your very informative review 👍👍👍 I can't wait to hear the new release now 😊. Cheers!

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks! 😃

@Bobdulla30 3 года назад

Such a good, deep and interesting review Andrew. Apriciate your humble aproach to everything you talk about, though you seem to always speak your mind. Thank you.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks :-)

@tinostabile3256 3 года назад

Hi Andrew, I saw your unboxing and now your review. So happy you got this from those angels Yoko and Sean. I cannot wait to get my box set...... it cannot reach me fast enough. Counting the minutes for its release and the day it finally arrives. Thank you for this exquisite review, Tino

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thank Tino, I'm sure you'll enjoy yours when it arrives!

@NieznanyArtysta 3 года назад

Thank you for this review. I was very much looking forward to this album. I thought it would be released last year as the 50th anniversary. I was very dissapointed when there was no news about it. This is one of my favorite albums.

@78zappaf 3 года назад

Great review, plus nice shirt! I remember seeing that long ago online.

@johnschofield338 3 года назад

Hey Andrew, abolutely superb review. Top banana! Cheers John

@iainblack8662 3 года назад

Hi Andrew, it was nice to see a clip of your review pop up on the John Lennon page on FB this morning.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Iain, yes was a nice surprise!

@caelramos1005 3 года назад

Great quality brilliant review. Love it!💯💥

@anthonyh8153 3 года назад

Great review Andrew, this really seems like an amazing release I just wish that the 3 singles where on the vinyl release as well but it still looks set to be a great release

@glennonline 3 года назад

Love seeing this video and shout out to Yoko and Sean for recognising you this way.

@yanks1fan09 3 года назад

Great review Andrew! I ordered the Deluxe Box and probably will do the same for the 2 LP. but I am interested in the mixes.

@thefleshexperience 3 года назад

Wonderful review! If forced to choose, I always say this is my favorite album of all time. I cannot wait to hear all of the extra content. This has only made me more excited! Thank you. :)

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks Don , I;m sure you'll enjoy it all!

@brettweary8491 3 года назад

Absolutely Awesome Andrew

@baronsaturday951 3 года назад

Andrew, one word for you review : Exceptional ! The best review of all the time for a solo Beatles album ! A real performance ! Thanks to Yoko & Sean for choosing you ! you're the best ! Quality of vinyl, packaging, remix, outakes,....it's complete, exciting, interesting,...what review ! Thanks for this 39 minutes of hapiness !

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Wow, thank you Brice! :-)

@marktaylor7568 3 года назад

Excellent Review, very informative...mine is on preorder

@michaellaverty1844 3 года назад

Andrew, hats off to you again with a very heartfelt and honest review of this box set. Plastic Ono Band has always been in my top 5 of all time great Albums. I remember buying it when it was first released. I would listen to it over and over again with earphones. I went through server copies of the LP during the 70’s and presently don’t have a copy on CD. Although I do have the Lennon CD box set and the Lennon Anthology. I’m really looking forward to digging into this once it’s released here in America. After your review I will be getting the ultimate version. I agree with have to be in the mood for Yoko but always found her interesting. Good job.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks Michael, I think you're going to love this box set!

@danielcerda1907 3 года назад

Great review!; thanks a lot

@kingbrawler22 3 года назад

Your vids been put on the John Lennon Instagram page story

@benwilliams5492 3 года назад

Cool t-shirt, very apt!

@yrlic 3 года назад

This is a great review.

@holdenmisel5944 3 года назад

The John Lennon youtube account gave you a shout out! Congrats!! ✌❤

@1985indeed 3 года назад

Second time - they also did this for the GST review as well.

@chrisreed3385 3 года назад

Great in depth review Andrew 😀 I have the deluxe box set on order. Can’t wait! Any further news on the All Things Must Pass release?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Chris! I'm hoping within the next month we know something much more definite about ATMP (not certain though!)

@GlenKellawayfromthebasement 3 года назад

Andrew..you are the best..thank you so much..I am so excited for this release..I have pre ordered the deluxe box..❤️❤️👍👍glen kellaway

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks Glen, am sure you'll love it!

@stevebiesiada6338 3 года назад

Andrew, excellent review, I tell you I can’t wait to here all of John, He will always be No.1, My Favorite Forever , Andrew take care be safe my friend, Steve

@gerardjoseph17 3 года назад

Awesome review Andrew.... I received a notice in regards to the Beatles Get Back new book...that has now been pushed from August to September 2021. If you have some friends at Apple...tell them to just release the new documentary, the book, and the deluxe box set already!! Also your friend at Capitol...will we see a Beatles Capitol albums volume 3 from the original US releases?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Didn't know about the book delay Gerard, hoping nothing else about the project is being delayed. I wish I did have friends at Apple, I'd be pestering them for a job if I did! 😄

@gerardjoseph17 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic will let you know that I had at one time back in the late 1970s & early 80s that did work for Apple in New York,... I was able to get some really nice items including a 1st press 45 of Hey Jude... It don't come easy, and not sure what ever happen to this next item a 45 of Lennons Give Peace a Chance with the artist credited to The Beatles... I believe a person had taken it from my collection when I went to college and I never seen it again. Also of note ...a reason for the majority of those bootlegs came from folks who worked at various warehouses or pressing offices here in the states an they would leak things like acetates or sound equipment recordings so I was told.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@@gerardjoseph17 Wow, you must have lots of great memories of that time!

@gerardjoseph17 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic ...when the bootlegs dried up it got boring as all heck...LoL 😆 I have the original acetate vinyl of Hey Jude from Trident Studios...it runs like 16 minutes long, that was the same recording of soundboard audio from the David Frost program. Also have an incredible run out version of Dig it from the Saville Row Apple studio on cassette tape that ran somewhere in the neighborhood of 13 to 14 minutes long... including hisses and yowling by a very small Heather McCartney....hence the bootleg name...Jamming with Heather..some of which you can find audio or video on RU-vid Premium mate!

@bobace83 Месяц назад

a masterpiece of an album and probably John’s best

@tyronewhitehead3123 3 года назад

A great review carnt wait to here Isolation I want to here the different version beatiful looking package thanks 🙏

@petersvensson3154 3 года назад

Great review ! 🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪

@victorschwartzmann7681 3 года назад

Great review ! I can’t wait to get the 2LP set, it’s quite likely that Isolation distorts because of the inner groove distortion, because it’s the last song on side 1.

@Deebhoy 3 года назад

This has really conflicted me now. Was just going to buy the double vinyl but having second thoughts. Will likely go for the cds and single vinyl. Very informative review. Thanks

@ErikGT 3 года назад

This is so intresting!!!

@-dave3577 3 года назад

Thanks for the excellent overview; it really whets the appetite. These Lennon archive releases are beginning to set the benchmark on how to do things properly. Similar Presley releases are like kindergarten-compiled compared to the labour of love that shines through on this premium quality looking set.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks! I've not seen an Elvis sets but I certainly can't imagine them the depth of these, I guess they're probably catering to a different market though.

@-dave3577 3 года назад

Elvis sets - in the main - glaringly lack any kind of the creativity and meticulousness that is devoted to these John Lennon archive releases. It's like night and day.

@-dave3577 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Here is a recent example of an Elvis release. 99% of the material is previously released [I kid you not!]. A 3CD set [no HiRes audio here] including a flimsy booklet made up mostly of well-known photos, ads and session data. Just take after take after take. No creativity in its compilation whatsoever. Retails for around £50-60 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-hI4MvdcgGKU.html

@gregoryfagan6986 3 года назад

We need to see you doing a full version of Cold Turkey with your unique vibrato style!! Brilliant!

@davepowell9708 3 года назад

Great review Andrew very through can't wait to get my copy it's interesting to hear your opinion has changed on some of the gimmie some truth remixes. whats next? Ringo or Dylan Thanks Dave

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Just got the new Dylan 3rd disc to do and then I've made my way through those also!

@byrons61 3 года назад

I got the distortion as well on the vinyl. Beautiful set.

@davidtellett179 3 года назад

Loving your channel sir! Much appreciated. Have you ever done (or thought of) an in-depth comparison of McCartney live releases at all?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks David! It's something that's been on my list of potentials for a while (along with about 100 other ideas), so it may well happen one day!

@davidtellett179 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Excellent! I’ll keep watching :)

@LUFC123 3 года назад

Yoko and Sean also sent Liam Gallagher this too. You're in great company

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Yes, saw that! CELESTIAL! 😉

@paulhaworth6399 3 года назад

I didn’t get one!

@canadianstudmuffin 3 года назад

I agree about the Element Mixes version of "Mother". It's bone chilling with just his vocals. Also LOVE the blu ray with Yoko's Plastic Ono Band expanded... Great review, still watching. :D

@lukasweichert9391 3 года назад

Good morning Andrew thank you very much for this honest and rich review. Two things I want to ask: Plastic Ono Band was always a very raw and live album for me, so the raw studio mix sounds really interesting. The Plastic Ono Band Live Appearance in London 1969 that appears on Some Time In New York City really would fit to this deluxe edition of Plastic Ono Band, doesn´t it? It´s a shame that the Plastic Ono Band did not perform live more often, this open band concept was made for live appearances. Then, second, I am still really skeptical about this amount of mixes. Do you enjoy this amount or is it simply a bit overwhelming, not just in a postive way? Thanks again for your wonderful channel :)

@sharonevans6864 3 года назад

Andrew, you did a great job reviewing POB. I ordered everything that you reviewed but one thing I would like to see is the Yoko copy of the POB in vinyl with the updated cover. Do you see that coming out? Thank you for taking the time for your in-depth rev. Take care.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks Sharon, I'm not sure whether the fairly recent reissue of Yoko's album was also released on vinyl or just CD. With the full session on the Blu-ray here there's not really anything left to release.

@jnagarya519 Год назад

Thanks, Andy. I've not been interested in the solo box sets -- I have a hard time working out storage for "The Beatles" remixes. And I never bought the original CD. Now I'm looking at this because of fulsome reviews of this release. Next are reviews of the "Gimme Some Truth" release/s.

@robyoung9968 3 года назад

I listened to this album over and over when it was first released.

@TrancetasticWilza 3 года назад

It looks great quality 👌 the book sounds like a good read

@joet_swbo101 3 года назад

So it looks like a mastering defect. Good to know. I'll hold off to see if they rectify it. Thanks

@barrilitomusic 3 года назад

That version of Mother in Nowhere Boy was part of the Lennon Anthology, disc one called Ascot. There’s another version out there on Spotify on the Lennon Box set.

@1985indeed 3 года назад

Thanks for this! Great watch and very helpful in making a decision to purchase this box set. My question is based in your GST Love version vs this remix of Love: I'd have thought they are actually the same mixes, seeing as there is barely 7 months between the two releases and this boxset was quietly mentioned in the book to the GST edition. Are they actually two different mixes, or is the mastering what has made the difference? Nerdy question...but that's why I love compering the mixes!

@craigwarner6156 3 года назад

Excellant revew mate. Fantastic! But it's putting me in a quandary. You make me want it all and add I've already told you i cant afford it and usually go for the 2 CD version of these things, but Andrew what are you doing to me? LOL. I listened to YOKO ONO PLASTIC ONO BAND last night IN THE DARK and it's just a blast and now i want this full deluxe big box. But anyway very very good review Andrew and i spotted your (i think) little dig at people who are saying or thinking you are being told what to say and what you can and can't say, lol. Very classy. Thanks mate. P. S. I can't believe you've never heard the double cookie, lol. It's always a pick out point for me that i wait for and laugh at.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Craig, sorry for any predicaments I'm causing you! 😄 I bet you're right, lights off for Yoko's album and just get in the groove of it. I did that recently for George's Electronic Sound album and it was the most I've enjoyed it. Double cookie, I can't not hear it now, plain as day!

@robintownrobintown 3 года назад

Well, that was wonderful. I guess I'll buy Gimme Some Truth now that it isn't redundant. So I've got a couple queries for you: - How do you think the new remix of the straight album compares to the 2000s one? - Every track on the album plus the 3 singles are kept together on all but the Jams CD and BluRay, ie there are 14 tracks per CD? - Have you checked which songs from Anthology or the Home Tapes disk carry over? What have you found, if you have? - If you were going to be stuck on a desert island for a year right after you read this but had to bring one version of Plastic Ono Band with you, which would you pick at this very moment? Anyhow, keep up the wonderful work! Hope all's well, Justin

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers Justin, never spent too much time with 2000s remix but it doesn't have the clarity of this Yes pretty much album songs plus 3 singles on those other discs Not checked duplication, that's a task I can't face, too much work! At the moment would defintely take this new version!

@MrDirtybear 3 года назад

Thank you for this this review Andrew Dixon. You talked about the edit in 'Working Class Hero'. That song was one of the first songs of Lennon's that zapped me right between the ears. I had it as the B side of a single. Probably 'Imagine' was the A side, it was 1975 or so. I am allowed to forget some details in life. What is this notable edit? Where does it come in the song? And what is thought to be edited out?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

It's when the 3rd verse comes in "When they tortured and scared you..." at about 1 minute 22 and then towards the end of that verse it reverts back to the original take. I think John missed a verse out in his otherwise "best" take and wanted this verse from another take editing in.

@ricardo_miguel13 3 года назад

Great review! I just have to mention that Ringo didn't play on Instant Karma, but George did.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thank you, I get mixed up sometimes!

@westfield90 3 года назад

Haha yes I’m a mad type. I only buy it for the outtakes. That’s the reason i pray that before I leave this earth that Apple comes to their senses and releases all of the Beatles outtakes catalog either in an online subscription model if they’d like some revenue or donate it to a public foundation like the library of Congress to preserve it for future generations but accessible to the public. Beatles are now part of history and keeping these tapes locked up makes no sense. Who wouldn’t want to hear take one of in my life or nowhere man. It’s way overdue to do this. Instead apple releases a take here and there at the whim of some person. Other bands treat their fans better. Dylan and stones have released everything in their vaults. It’s time the Beatles do this now.

@victorschwartzmann7681 3 года назад

Hi Andrew ! I have a little question : in this review, you said that the 2LP and the 2CD didn’t have the same album outtakes, and I've seen that the tracklisting is not the same on the inner sleeve and on the label. The inner sleeve seems like they list the Raw Studio Outtakes, so is this what's on the LP ? And also, which one is your favourite selection of outtakes between the 2CD and the 2LP ?

@paulayers1111 3 года назад

Haven’t heard the vinyl, but just from hearing the Gimme Some Truth Ultimate Mixes last autumn, I heard some distortion on those loud sections of “isolation.”

@sheffieldandbeyond8644 3 года назад

Thanks for the video Andrew, would you recommend the box set?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Definitely, It's the box set the album deserves!

@TrancetasticWilza 3 года назад

That cover would be great framed

@joet_swbo101 3 года назад

If you're getting distortion in the song Isolation, it's most likely a mastering defect. Bet it's on all copies not just yours. This happened years ago on the Houses of the Holy super deluxe set, with The Ocean. They ended up fixing is later on. I was able to reach out to Rhino and they sent me a new copy free of charge.

@sundodger1 3 года назад

Well done! I listened to the Ultimate Mix of Working Class Hero and yes that edit is so obvious now. Has there ever been an explanation as to why there was an edit? It sounds like a take from another recording studio. It just looses so much presence and life. Oh well. I'm glad I have the box on order. Can't wait to dive in as you have. Thanks for all the time you put in doing this.

@MeanMrMayo 3 года назад

John forgot a middle verse when he did Take 9, which was ultimately considered the best take. Later on, John just decided he'd simply have the missing verse inserted into Take 9.

@sundodger1 3 года назад

@@MeanMrMayo that edit is so jarring. It would have been a nice extra if they had released the unedited version. I’m just assuming it’s not included.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Take 9 that Joe mentions is in the Deluxe box, no edits there.

@kianwelsh4451 3 года назад

hey andrew you're on john lennon's instagram and facebook stories!

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

It's crazy! 😄

@michaellundsrensen2292 3 года назад

Thanks for another really good review! You're really thorough, nice, Thank you! But unfortunately, there is an audible low-frequency noise in the left speaker. It was also there on the two unboxing videos, but not as powerful as here, and it is actually very disturbing! Maybe you can take the sound of the video and remove the noise and put the good sound back. I have not seen if others have reprimanded it, but it is only heard by good speakers that reproduce bass properly. I'm really looking forward to getting the deluxe box myself!

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Thanks for pointing that out, I'll look in to it! 👍

@trevorbrown2813 3 года назад

How is Working Class Hero on side 3 on your vinyl, as I have a light scratch over the whole of the track? I noticed on its first play. I was wondering have they done this while packing record or something.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

No problem with mine Trevor. Just some weird distortion on Isolation, other than that all sounds good.

@trevordixon1427 3 года назад

Which of the pob books is best?? .ta

@MarcusMaximus909 3 года назад

Ok a couple of questions...difference between vinyl and cd version of the album ( in sound) . Also is the original album included? Thanks for the video great overview Andrew. I've never heard the second cookie! I think double fantasy is a big contender for the remix treatment

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

vinyl and CD are consistently similar and good, apart from Mother which is noticeably low on treble on vinyl as I mention in the vid

@MarcusMaximus909 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic I'm both by the way...hi res, and vinyl...depends on the mood...as you say in your video

@kianwelsh4451 3 года назад

i only watched up to the packaging as i dont want my opinion to be tampered in anyway. i will give this a fulll watch when i get mine and ive listened to all of it.

@kianwelsh4451 3 года назад

also just curious, have you listened to zoom in by ringo yet?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@@kianwelsh4451 I have listened twice to Ringo now, it's a pleasant listen!

@kianwelsh4451 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic it sounds so much better on a cd than on spotify in my opinion

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@@kianwelsh4451 I've listened on CD, it's a Bellman/Grundig mastered recording so would expect it to sound good.

@kianwelsh4451 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic fair enough, have you got the vinyl? i was gonna get the vinyl but i decided to get the cd first because i dont have a ringo record collection as of yet.

@PeKe999 3 года назад

Hi mate, You did a great job with this review. What do you think of You'll Never Walk Alone? John was in a good mood during these sessions. Looking forward to get this set ....... 3 and a falf week to wait.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Hi Pe, it's fun! "Hold your leg up high" , definitely in a good mood that day!

@josephsirchia65 3 года назад

Hi Andrew I may have asked this earlier but are the tracks on this set mixed the same as the same tracks on the Gimme Some Truth Box Set ? Thanks

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Hi, no these are new mixes. Very similar in some cases, or in the case of Love, there is a very noticeable difference as I discuss towards the back end of this video.

@josephsirchia65 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Hi Andrew, thanks I apologize, should have listened to your full presentation before asking. One comment, I’ll add, this album appears to me to be a differ type of Phil Spector’s production in the sense this album is not orchestrated as his usual work. I’m certainly looking forward to receiving this. I’m also grateful to Yoko that she had this delivered to you and Joe Mayo ahead of the release date so both of you can share your thoughts on this. Thanks again

@johngill277 3 года назад

Great review Andrew as always, I'm just weighing up which version to get, do you think the Deluxe 6 CD edition is worth £99.99, which is what it is on Amazon. Interesting to see the outtakes on vinyl are different to CD, I just assumed they would be the same.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Cheers John, for me it would be worth it, it might not be for everyone, but the way my mind works I wouldn't want to have missed out if it sells out.

@johngill277 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Appreciate the quick response, true I completely agree, I was going to buy both the CD and vinyl which I'd be paying about £60 anyway, so if I'm paying that might aswell go for the full boxset. Thankyou, I was lucky at Xmas because my generous sister bought me the boxset of Gimme some truth, I only asked her for the 2 vinyl but she bought me the boxset as a surprise.

@davidbacon6097 3 года назад

Are the outtakes and raw mixes presented in 5.1 surround like they were on the imagine box? The screen capture I took from your unboxing video would suggest ...no. What is the Dolby digital mix? ...and how is it different from the high resolution stereo mix. Great videos Andrew...thanks

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

They've upped the hi Res to 192kHz this time rather than having 5.1 for things other than the main album, I guess that's good news for some people and not for others. The Dolby digital I think is 48kHz so still hi Res but I'm assuming that's there for those who can't play the full 192 hi Res!? Perhaps.... 🤔

@davidbacon6097 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic thanks for the update. Personally, I’m disappointed that the only thing presented in 5.1 is the main album. Still, the box set looks fantastic...and I can’t wait

@Mario_11 3 года назад

What was the edit that you were talking about on Working Class Hero?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Start of verse 3, about 1 minute 23 seconds in

@MultiJoe84 3 года назад

Hi Andrew, I wonder if you read the book ‘John Lennon 1980’ by Kenneth Womack, which was released late last year? A really good read and unique in its subject matter.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Hi, I got the book for Christmas but not had chance to read it yet, might be a while before I do but I will definitely get round to it as I would like to learn a lot more about John in 1980! 🙂👍

@zumadale 3 года назад

Got the original vinyl when it first came out...I took up piano cuz of this album 🤠

@adamadachi 3 года назад

Yes! I cannot hear the second “cookie” on the iTunes remaster, but I can hear it on my 1980 Canadian pressing very clear as well. I think the remaster has buried it, but I’m glad the remix brings it out again :)

@prettyshinyspaghetti8332 3 года назад

Strange. I can hear it clearly on the CD version I have

@adamadachi 3 года назад

@@prettyshinyspaghetti8332 That is interesting. I wonder why that is. I never noticed it until I bought the LP.

@1985indeed 3 года назад

I have only ever heard it as clear as day as it is as prominent s e rest of the vocals on the album. The 2000 mix, which is utterly brilliant imo, is the version that I fell in love with. I only have the original mix from the 2010 remaster.

@adamadachi 3 года назад

@@1985indeed I did not know that it was remixed in 2000. I haven't heard that one. Do you know where I could find it? Also, what do you think of the 2010 remaster? I don't love it.

@1985indeed 3 года назад

@@adamadachi 2010 remaster is a bit "thin" sounding on cd - but as it's the original mix it's good to own for that reason, and some would prefer it. I fell in love with the album based on thw 2000 remix on cd. The mix really brings out the stark nature of the album even more. Track it down. Not sure if it was deleted after the 2010 remaster but it was the go to version in the catalogue from 2000-10. Try amazon or discogs.

@jjmoura2689 3 года назад

Genial esse álbum

@colemanmufc 3 года назад

When is it released? I thought it was suppose to be 16th April. But site still says to pre order.

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Out next Friday, 23rd

@interglotti3858 3 года назад

Ordered the deluxe boxset a while ago, but does it come with a download code, want to listen to it on the go

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Good question! I don't know, I haven't read anything to suggest it does so I'm presuming it doesn't.

@jakedadj81 3 года назад

I wonder if Julian Lennon has any say or gets any royalties from John's solo or Beatles work?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

I hope so! I'm sure I read something suggesting that he does get a cut now, which I don't think was always the case.

@astrosjer822 3 года назад

Great job Andrew. My box set and 2CD versions are on preorder from importcds.com. Best price in US I could find! This is truly one set that you have to go physical media for!

@shewasaworkingclassgirl9998 3 года назад

Can someone time stamp where he pulls out the poster I can’t seem to find it

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

I forgot! I did get out the poster on the vinyl version in here though: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BW3q3Z_GSGg.html

@shewasaworkingclassgirl9998 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic I found it on meanmrmayos video I just wanted to see how big it was (I couldn’t find the measurements of it in the description) lol

@LucasAB1190 2 года назад

I’m sure someone’s already said this but it’s take 5 you can hear an engineer say it just before they start the take.

@Hammerman48 3 года назад

Do you believe that the tracks from Plastic Ono Band were the same mixes that were on the recent Gimme Some Truth box set, as it was only recent? I can’t imagine they would have remixed those 4 tracks again?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

Hi Keith, definitely new remixes, as I mention in this video (with proof and reasons why) when discussing "Love"

@Hammerman48 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Yes, I should have saved my comments until I'd seen the whole review!! I find it surprising that new mixes are created so soon after existing ones. Either smart marketing by EMI or just Yoko being thorough!

@1985indeed 3 года назад

@@Hammerman48 Oh wow! I was wondering this same question. Interesting decision if they have nit great for us Lennon trainspotters!😂

@lukasweichert9391 3 года назад

Probably you didn´t read my question: would you think it would have been a good idea to include live recordings from the Plastic Ono Band to this Deluxe Set (maybe a remixed version from the UNICEF Gig with George Harrison in 1969)? Thank you very much :)

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

I'm sure some people would like them there, I'm happy for it to be without, I'm happy for this to be a studio only set. That's purely my personal preference though.

@lukasweichert9391 3 года назад

@@AndrewDixonMusic Thank you, Andrew. I really appreciate it that you take so much time and energy to do these videos. I see your point in doing the Deluxe Set a set containing the studio work by John around this album. When they will do a deluxe set with Some Time in NYC, then I will have my live recordings. Just as I wrote earlier, whenever I see for example John Live in Toronto 1969, I wish that he would have performed more often. And as rare as his performances are, I hope that someday we will get a deluxe live set with all the well known stuff (Live in NYC 1972, UNICEF 1969) and the lesser known performances (Live Rally Michigan 1971, Sir Lew Grade performance 1975, the Elton John Gig 1974, and so on). Last question: did you see that Dark Horse Records put a Joe Strummer album out?

@AndrewDixonMusic 3 года назад

@@lukasweichert9391 A deluxe live set would be very interesting, but it's such a shame that such a thing is even possible, it really hits home home just how little live work John did without The Beatles! I did see the Dark Horse release, hoping they are going to announce a George All Things Must Pass release soon.