Let's Talk About the ALL-NEW ALL-BLACK X-MEN in Bishop: War College #3 

I'm pretty sure she died but they should have brought her back by now

I always wondered what happened to her, I know she was a hologram on X-Factor, then not sure what happened 2 her after that

Why bring back relevant wellmade interesting black characters when you can just turn all the intetrsting white characters black....

Facts

They're probably Albino😂

Ironically, they would probably be white.

WOULD BE INTERESTING

I'm sure they are black. Storm is still black. It would've been better if they would have flipped everything. It would show the lack of black comic characters, still

smh its the Ku Klux Klan lmfao

Its because cause real life people are a lot harder to convince and way more stubbern.

Indeed

I'm conflicted as well. I mean, I like it, but I'm of the party of expanding upon something original or, in other words, something new. We need more black comic creators like Dwayne McDuffie or the guys from Milestone comics or The Rippaverse. We need a new medium of black characters. But I'm not mad at alternative Earth's and realities, which I'm open to a black X-Men team.

@@KIDSOUL777 well there is a problem in that too. There are a great deal of new comics featuring POC. But they are from small companies, or independent amateur creators. When the big companies do introduce new POC on comics they don’t get traction. In fact they are often seen as woke garbage, cringe, or pushing an agenda.

This comic book will be the first X-Men comic I've bought in decades.

Hell yeah 👍

Yep

A live-action "what if" movie would be amazing !!!💥👍

You are so right. Marvel needs to pay their families.

You do know that when Stan Lee created Magneto he was just a villain of the week, right? It was Chris Claremont that redefined the X-Men, what they fought for, Magneto's backstory, and a lot more; even he said that Professor X and Magneto were NOT based on Martin Luther King Jr and Malcom X, but instead on the Jewish leaders David Ben-Gurion and Menachem Begin.

​@Open-Minded Skeptic we know why. And it's sad

Well it was worth a shot

That would be hilarious 😂

Jean grey telling cyclops nigga plz telepathicly 😂🤣😂 also hitting Logan up like hey bighead at 3am😂🤣 I'm goin to hell

I died and applauded when I saw that. 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

Its very freaky

A bit of Americanitis here. Claremont modeled them after Ben-Gurion (Xavier) and Begin (Magneto). A bit of history: So, the goal was to create a Jewish homeland in Palestine. They bought the land from Ottoman absentee landlords at above-market prices. (And that's where one infamous conflict has its genesis.) Basically Ben-Gurion used diplomacy to get the world to recognize Israel. Begin's group Irgun, by contrast, fought the British during the 40s, and the British enlisted the Arabs (who were still miffed that they now lived on land owned by Jews, rather than land owned by Turks, yes, the Arab-Israeli conflict is That Petty) to fight back. The British played the usual game of divide and rule, but in 1948, the Jews declared their independence, and abolished the Latinate name Palestine for the modern name Israel. Note that Begin still brokered a peace treaty with Egypt decades later when he was Prime Minister. So, it's not like Begin was all that gung ho for war. This shows up throughout the history of the X-Men. Why so much of Xavier and Magneto's story so prominently features Israel. Why Xavier's son (with the usual disclaimers about Charles Xavier as a parent) was in an Israeli mental institution. And so on.

Firstly I'm not American and secondly Malcolm x and Martin Luther king can easily be the influence for Xavier and magneto more so than gurlon and begin.

@@steviejay868 Sorry for the assumption, but there are differences. Malcolm never killed anyone (whereas Begin, like Magneto, killed a lot of people), and MLK wasn't as passive as people think. And of course, Claremont's own words on the matter.

Blowback is mostly because of the whole 'power of being black making everything better' schtick. Comes off a bit too much like someone writing for their own personal fantasy than what made X-Men great.

​@@csx6910 aren't all comics just someone's personal fantasy tho

@@csx6910 I don't feel like that was the issue in the video he made though. It was just a thought exercise about if you were going to make a theoretical team of X-Men where everyone was black who would be in it? Anything else feels liking trying to make a problem where there isn't one.

​@@TrueXSE wasn't that how it used to be before? All white team. So it's a problem when it's a black team? There is absolutely nothing wrong with it, diversity is always the best but we r all biased and we base things on how we see and feel..

@@afro_princess1671 I just meant there was some weird stuff in War College #3 about how being a mutant works that how I read it had weird baggage, that's all. I still liked the concept, I just think there's a better way to execute it. I'm also not a fan of Bishop's writing in this run, but that's a little unrelated and it's better than something like Messiah Complex and all that followed that.

Brogan

I feel Marvel should have a black mutant character with similar powers like Wolverine and Sabretooth. Why make clout by making a black Wolverine when something can be done better? Make a character with their own original thing. Honestly, this should have been considered already.

Hoss?

That was Sebastian Shaw

more like heaven if you ask me

The number 23, more like Air Jordans!🏀😊

Or just Tom Cassidy

Maybe it's Thomas...

I haven't heard about Blackplanet in years lol definitely was there in high school.

@@DZADangerousme too!!!!!! It was so Fun to Create those animated pages

😂😂😂

He's got light skin energy 😂

@BaithNa hahaha, yeah bros eyes is a portal to the lightskined dimension.

The black Cyclops wouldn't need a visor because he actually know how to control his Optic Blast unlike the other one who suffered a head injury.

@@mikejohn29mj big facts 💯

Well, it might surprise you to realize that the X-Men were always 'black' in a manner of speaking. What else is an entire minority race of people lead by an advocate for peace and equality, and a rival willing to use violence to achieve that, in the fight against their oppression at the hands of the bigoted majority race in government in the 1960s US? This isn't some "dipped in chocolate/copy and paste" nonsense readers like you are always yelling about, this is how it would've been in the beginning if not for how unprepared Marvel's younger audience and more moderate readers were for something so radical. As for the black successors or versions of white characters, what's the problem? New characters can be cool and all, but it doesn't compare to the weight and reverence of being the real thing for audiences that want to see that. And it's not like Marvel or DC is erasing the original character's race, you can still have your original white X-Men but we just have our black X-Men too.

Yup

You clearly didn't read the comic or watch the video. You're opinion is irrelevant.

Ya that annoys me too man,.

Exactly noone wants to be sloppy seconds

Much respect and appreciation! Please contact me I would love to interview on my podcast.

Excellent work 👌🏾 Really wish your character designs could make it to the main books, that cyclops design is fire!

Where are the Latin, Native American, and Asian characters?? Hmmm....you conveniently didn't swap other minorities....

@@nothx512 push for that but don’t come for Black folks because y’all didn’t YET AGAIN ride our coat tails to freedom while simultaneously not fighting for us to get ours. Make a movement to have Latins and Asians formatted as Xmen…but don’t pull us down in the attempt.

Its not like mcu 616 and the actor is great... I say do it!

I mean MCU is not 616 I'm tired that everyone wants to make it the same as the comics

Giancarlo Esposito

They always leave breadcrumbs. I think and hope you're right.

Idk, I think he'd be a far better Magneto than Xavier. He already has the right haircut for Magneto and I've never seen how he looks bald.

Like I said in a previous comment, I just hate it when the world is better because of the race swap. Also having this or that race be mutant kindof defeats the point since are there own seprat thing. Its like referring to an alien being white or black it makes no sence.

@@hellblaze10 I think it would be good to make a good background. Like... why is everyone black? Did something happen? We know we had a lot of problems in our "reality" for everyone to be white in the high status. Why would Black be a predominant? Did they find America first? Did they enslave white people? Did they take Egypt? Macedonia? Let's talk about the Apartheid. Did the Blacks become a major force and then exiled the white people? And I'm black too. I like good story writing. If you're making a world, at least make some murky water about how some Reality is a racial utopia.

This is mad stupid dude. Growing up most of my favorite super heroes were black guys. I never once wished they were white.

@@AManChoosesASlaveObeys black people is already one of the majority in the world white people is in fact not they are less then 5%

@@MrKeepitmovin504 what are you talking about