List of Recommended cEDH commanders for tournaments 

I would be very interested in seeing data on the best winrate of commanders piloted by inexperienced players rather than experienced players; so i can maybe give better recommendations for new players

I dont understand how Rogsi has so many more tournaments than every other deck. It has 150% of the entries of blue farm when blue farm is like 4x more popular according to stats.

Should probably create new terms: replace "reference number" or "total average" with "Skilled Win Rate average" just to be more precise, especially for those who have not seen previous videos. Other than that, I really like the statistical approach.

These stats are incredibly interesting. Everyone was saying korvold is good. I always pointed at the mid tier winrate. But actually it seems pretty promising. At this point I need to play yissan just for the stats

Keep up the good work. Its always nice to see the number and statistic side of magic at play

A pseudocentralized balanced meta is pretty rad. This is pretty sweet.

I would love to hear more information on Sefris, maybe a deeper dive? What lists are they using?

Thank you for analyzing Kenrith, the returned king Cheers

Great video, Not surprised to see rogsi underperforming tbh always seems overhyped, not thats its bad though. Also slightly surprised to see Stella’s win rate that low based on results I’ve seen, maybe moves up with more data but at the same time it is a very stoppable combo.

Nice, Blues clues showing up again. And at +34% none the less

When it comes to Cedh Tymna/Kraum is very promising as it provides a great deal of card advantage as well as in Thorcal/Consult colors with the best interaction and ways to protect the combo in your turn via counter magic/(white for silence effects). Having red for Dockside, Wheels, and Breech pushes this deck very hard it’s truly imo the best deck in the format 1 thing I recommend is if anyone getting into the format or any format know your deck inside and out, strengths and weaknesses and learn to adapt accordingly. I personally am partial to Grenzo Doomsday and though I do not play this deck as often due to my knowledge of the deck I have piloted the deck to some pretty amazing victories. If you plan on entering an event bring the deck your most comfortable playing and just enjoy your time!

I built TnT without knowing it wasnt been played that much anymore, but i love it lol. A little bit difficult to make a sans red ad naus deck work but im testing some shit and im enjoying it a lot

I really wish we had more data on Talion. Seems to be a commander that's very player skill dependent

It would be nice to have your final slide with winrate and entries ontop of commanders 😉😗 Great content anyway

Great video! Any data on Jhoira Weatherlight captain?

I don't find much use for this type of content. A matchup analysis would have been a better use for all the research.

I love the stats but I wonder how to factor in the fact that kinnan generates hate and ire of other players differently. Kinnan thrives on pretty normal mundane moves. Dork, dork, rock for most decks is nothing. With Kinnan, people panic

Hey Mons! I'm completely cool with a direct message on discord or something if necessary, but why have you decided to exclude Erinis + Street Urchin from the data?

YOOOOO, Sefris bros let's go! Mons' pessimism can't keep us down!

You know the biggest issue with commander win rates? The deck is 98 or 99 other cards with variation. This data isn't reliable

TNT IS BACK ON THE MENU BOYSSS

No Gaddock Teeg on this list??? That's b.s ! He's the best! 😂 ❤❤❤

i am curious about the variety of the most successful players. i am sure that one trick ponies are going to be benefited but it would be interesting how many decks some of the better players have brought to tournaments and with how of them they have gotten into top 16 and top 4. i hope i phrased it well enough for it to make sense. i am kinda fried by the heat today.

Im glad to see the deck ive grown to love showing up at tables, aleit not as prevalent as before. Ive been playing tayam now for abt a year and a half just because every game feels like its its own unique puzzle i need to solve on a scale i just cant find with any other cedh deck. I understand that its fallen off, but im curious about ur opinion on something. What kind of card do they need to print for these sorts of grindy creature decks to truly be relevant again?

Where is rog tevesh smh

Cool series!

Great video!

For a lot of tours, a draw is as nearly as important as a win e.g. 2 wins/1 draw = top16. I think you are missing this analysis, although I believe you have the data. You could come up for good commanders in 64 player tours.

has this list included the data from the Cowtown Throwdown? I know there were a lot of Rog Si lists in that top 16. If it does... holy cow Rog Si is stinkin it up D:

Ratadrabik of Urborg

Surprised of not seeing Talion

I feel like this is a really weird way to analyze the data but it’s kinda cool

Why do you recommend Atraxa without showing the winpercent of the non-beginners like you showed for every other commander you recommend?

So looking at how you were composing the data, I think it is a mistake to filter by winrate. You are trying to determine how "good" the decks are based on their winrate. You are filtering your data to only include players that have above a certain winrate. That means that the more players you filter OUT of your data, the more you are inflating a deck's winrate. If a deck is very popular amongst experienced players, unpopular amongst inexperienced players, and is having enough success that a large majority of its pilots are passing that threshold, its numbers will not increase much. That's what's happening with Rog/Si. The deck is too popular amongst experienced pilots, too unpopular amongst inexperienced pilots, and performing too consistently across pilots for your filters to inflate its winrate. Ultimately, if you're testing a statistic it's a mistake to filter data on that statistic.

Is the gitrog monster still a thing ?

Did I miss Tivit? oh there he is, huh not bad.

First :)

You could do a crude normalization multiplying the win rate by 1 - alpha instead of just doing sig vs noj sig

i don't want to sound like i'm "yucking your yum" but i truly feel that we still need to remember that the commander format was created to be a "Casual" format and meant to be a "home" for cards we have in our collection that either "are no longer legal to play in any other format" or "got banned from [insert format here]." While it's fun to play with the "top of the top" and have "prizes on the line" because of the nature of the commander format you could be playing all the best cards, playing them at the most opportune moment. Holding back when you could had made a play and being glad you did. And still lose. There's also the problem your trying to solve which seems like an impossible task, there are commander options that have been around for a long time that "do" perform well in a more competitive setting but for whatever reason players either stopped playing that commander option or opponents would find it easy to stop that player from "playing the game." i feel like there would have to be a decent group of players who KNOW the game really well to do games where it's in many different variations and against various other players. Such a task should take about two thousand years. Could input all this data into an AI and "pokemon battle" each commander deck and their variations through a simulation done by a computer? Just means making the AI go through EVERY relevant card choice for each commander with about one hundred games per variation of a commander deck and in the end i feel all we will accomplish is a whole new way to define "net decking."

I dont think you can claim nadu as confirmed and not sefris, nadu just came out

Don’t waste time to see this video , he don’t have card collection, only play proxys, I don’t see he go to tournaments, some of the deck he say are good , need a lot of training and consistency. There are much better RU-vid cedh creators doing a good job and explaining what is good and what can perform hell . Peace