Тёмный

OVERPRESSURE SIMULATION | 125mm High Explosive vs Leopard 1 | Pressure Wave Armour Penetration 

SY Simulations
Подписаться 96 тыс.
Просмотров 674 тыс.
50% 1

Simulating the effects of a high explosive pressure wave on the Leopard 1's fighting compartment. The model investigates how the blast wave propagates through the tank and determines how lethal it is by measuring the overpressure inside the vehicle.
The HE projectile has over 3kg of TNT and can penetrate around 40mm of steel; in this simulation the projectile detonates above the hull and turret roofs, where the armour is thinnest. The shrapnel from the HE round is ignored for simplicity, and to purely focus on the pressure effects.
To Note:
The small regions of pressure which develop around the rigid body, or in some cases where the pressure penetrates the rigid bodies are due to the air elements being on both sides of the rigid body at once -this is because the elements aren't small enough. These larger elements also cause instability in the model which caused it to crash, hence why some of the simulations are cut short. This could not be improved as I had already reached the node limit of the software I was using.
Credit for Leopard 1 in thumbnail: ‪@TanksEncyclopediaYT‬
Material properties, armour, and projectile geometries were all taken from literature:
[1] RHA: core.ac.uk/download/pdf/28829...
[2] Air & TNT: osf.io/f8awq/download/?versio...
[3] 3OF19 Geometry: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/125_mm_...
[4] Leopard 1 Armour: www.tankarchives.ca/2016/07/le...
This real-world overpressure effect has recently been implemented into the video game Warthunder...but not very accurately.
Abaqus FEA was used with a Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian model, with Johnson-Cook material properties for steel, ideal gas for air, and JWL for TNT.

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

17 июн 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 449   
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Warthunder devs be like...👀
@dasreddmaestro8287
@dasreddmaestro8287 3 года назад
What are your opinions on WT's Overpressure?
@mr.waffentrager4400
@mr.waffentrager4400 3 года назад
they go "unconscious" really fast
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
@@dasreddmaestro8287 i feel like they model a 'lethal sphere' around the point of impact, and if the armour is penetrated, anything within that sphere is killed...not taking into account that the armour of the vehicle dissipates some of the blast energy, reducing the lethal radius
@theempireofthepeople
@theempireofthepeople 3 года назад
@@SYsimulations nahhh.... They would be like "that one bounced" 🤣🤣
@user-yc1xe1pd1f
@user-yc1xe1pd1f 3 года назад
What do you think about little/no injury for turret crew/driver? Just damaged ears or pressure is enough to deal something more in this case?
@MaiorCJ
@MaiorCJ 3 года назад
War Thunder crew- So everyone gonna sleep?
@nolader28
@nolader28 3 года назад
knocked out, yes
@cpp3221
@cpp3221 3 года назад
Don't worry, a medikit for everyone and your missing head will be restored
@erikhendrych190
@erikhendrych190 3 года назад
69 Likes=perfection
@MaiorCJ
@MaiorCJ 3 года назад
@@erikhendrych190 destroyed
@georgevasilopoulos5359
@georgevasilopoulos5359 3 года назад
Nah they will not die, they'll just turn yellow
@jonathonspears7736
@jonathonspears7736 3 года назад
Keep making these. They are really educational.
@Av-vd3wk
@Av-vd3wk 3 года назад
…For the Russians and Chinese!
@jonathonspears7736
@jonathonspears7736 3 года назад
@@Av-vd3wk Some youtuber with a fancy computer program can do this stuff. If the militaries can't... well you get the point.
@biggusdickus9046
@biggusdickus9046 3 года назад
@@Av-vd3wk Only the brainwashed sheep believe this rubbish and what you said. Spam in a can. lmao
@WilliamTravisIto
@WilliamTravisIto 2 года назад
@@Av-vd3wk muh russians and chinese!! 5 eyes good! 🤓
@KINGKING-qv4vd
@KINGKING-qv4vd 7 месяцев назад
اقرأوا دعاء العهد والفرج لا إلٰه إلّا اللّٰه محمد رسول اللّٰه علي ولي اللّٰه اللهم صلِّ على محمد وآل محمد وعجل فرجهم و ارحمنا بهم 🤍 💚 عن أبي عبد الله عليه السلام قال من قال أربع مرات إذا أصبح - الحمد لله رب العالمين فقد أدى شكر يومه ومن قالها إذا أمسى فقد أدى شكر ليلته. عن أبي عبد الله عليه السلام قال: من قال في كل يوم سبع مرات: الحمد لله على كل نعمة كانت أو هي كائنة، فقد أدى شكر ما مضى وشكر ما بقي (4). لغفران الذنوب قولوا استغفر اللّٰه الذي لا إلٰه إلّا هو الحي القيوم و اتوب اليه 3 مرات يا أبا الفضل العباس يا قمر بني هاشم يا ناصر الحسين يا أخا الحسين قولوها لقضاء الحوائج 🤍💚 313 اللهم العن اول ظالم ظلم حق محمد وآل محمد و الثاني والثالث والرابع و آخر تابع لهم إلى يوم الدين اللهم صلِّ على محمد وآل محمد وعجل فرجهم و ارحمنا بهم اللهم صلِّ على محمد وآل محمد وعجل فرجهم و ارحمنا بهم عند الإنتهاء من الدعاء قولوا ما شاء اللّٰه لا حول ولا قوة إلّا باللّٰه ليستجاب الدعاء إن شاء اللّٰهُ تعالى،،، اقرأوا القرآن واحاديث أهل البيت عليهم الصلاة والسلام، اندبوا الحسين ليلاً و نهاراً بقول وا حسيناه و قول يا حسين يا سيدي و مولاي يا أبا عبد اللّٰه الحُسين، رددوا دائماً يا إمام الزمان 3 مرات. Be shiite Muslim and your life will improve 🤍💚 don't listen to songs and music Read Qur'an and pray to ALLAH Read Al-ahad Duaa and Al-faraj Duaa Stop war and kill the human The so-called State of Israel kills children, women, and innocent people and takes everything from them, and we have evidence
@NevadaGamingWedge
@NevadaGamingWedge 3 года назад
While that "internal explosion" could be seen as Hypothetical, knowing how thin the Leopard 1's armor plates are, and the relative proximity of where that HE shell went off, I'd say that is more an accurate depiction. I like to call this "The Panzer Fault" RIP Driver Hanz.
@nyssfairchild2244
@nyssfairchild2244 3 года назад
I take it as a simulation of a large caliber APHE shell going off.
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
@@nyssfairchild2244 a real APHE shell simulation is coming in the future...
@gian.4388
@gian.4388 3 года назад
@Daniel Wong I swear yesterday an enemy M56 gunner took a whole russian 122mm round right between his asscheeks and only got slightly orange I wish I had the recorded it just to have the hitcam footage lol
@AKAtheA
@AKAtheA 3 года назад
@Daniel Wong now that's an interesting a simulation scenario! APHE or HE-frag detonating inside, with and without "human ERA" :D
@BenjaminFairJaberjawz
@BenjaminFairJaberjawz 3 года назад
@@gian.4388 war thunder replays save automatically for weeks in the replay section if you can find it
@goneracing1646
@goneracing1646 3 года назад
"Little to no injury" = at best they have pieces of the driver and shrapnel embedded in them.
@o-hogameplay185
@o-hogameplay185 3 года назад
Meanwhile: shooting the transmission's upper high angled plate of the chi-ri (20mm thickness) with a 57mm HEAT from the chi-ha kill the chi-ri by overpressure
@panzervpl9406
@panzervpl9406 3 года назад
meanwhile: shooting a tank with aphe the crew: i Do OvErPrEsSuRe
@smoldoggy1005
@smoldoggy1005 3 года назад
Low quality japanese components
@Jan_372
@Jan_372 3 года назад
Best one yet, me shooting a mantlet where my shell landed parallel to the barrel and right next to it. It was with 76mm HEAT-FS for the T92, but it cause overpressure.
@StrikeWyvern
@StrikeWyvern 3 года назад
@@Jan_372 I was in a Jagdtiger and I got shot in the little gun ring by a T92 Shell didn't pen Just overpressured me instantly
@Opalthira
@Opalthira 3 года назад
Meanwhile getting shot by a bmp2 using he rounds from 1+km away in my leopard 2a6 Hits machine gun port and kills the entire crew from over pressure. Guy Shoots wall behind me with missile in t10A Dies from overpressure. War Thunder: It just works.
@FuikaMusic
@FuikaMusic 3 года назад
Good job for this one!
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Thanks! Took way too much time..
@FuikaMusic
@FuikaMusic 3 года назад
@@SYsimulations At least it's worth it!
@dimitrireinhart
@dimitrireinhart 3 года назад
yep very good video, with explanation and angles and animation until the end
@bfps2020
@bfps2020 3 года назад
@@SYsimulations hey can you do a simulation of an APFSDS that could in sim defeat 1000mm RHA equivalent
@joshuakuehn
@joshuakuehn 3 года назад
Excellent name bro
@themodernwarfarehistorian825
@themodernwarfarehistorian825 3 года назад
Behold, the three saviors of humanity against MBTs: - Military History Visualized - Bosnian Ape Society - SY Simulations
@handletemplate
@handletemplate 3 года назад
how about dejmian xyz?
@Solruc_
@Solruc_ 3 года назад
And Red Effect
@snafu1635
@snafu1635 3 года назад
Don't forget Armour archive, HM1199 and dalek 14mc mk2
@crimsonstrykr
@crimsonstrykr 3 года назад
Bosnian Ape Society? I see you are a man of culture as well
@tosyl_chloride
@tosyl_chloride 3 года назад
thank god now my computer is safe from MBTs looking to shoot it
@Shimesaba_love
@Shimesaba_love 3 года назад
meanwhile in warthunder hits the tracks: all crew members die
@antares-the-one
@antares-the-one 3 года назад
Same in the WoT. 120mm HE round hits the front armor of the Maus, 2 members: "ight, imma head out"
@MrNeocrusher
@MrNeocrusher 3 года назад
One of the the best sim I’ve seen so far Looking forward to see an even more detailed tank, (if possible) to see all the damages inside
@Aetius_of_Astora
@Aetius_of_Astora 3 года назад
I believe it was a battlefield game's campaign where i first learned about the dangers of overpressure. One of the Abrams that was acting as support for the infantry hit a mine or something while they had their hatches open and the pressure wave killed the crew despite the tank itself being only lightly damaged. Quite an interesting phenomenon to see simulated.
@00nothingxD
@00nothingxD 3 года назад
those are some pretty cool beans, don't know who you are or why you keep showing up my recommended but I'm glad that you do and I'm finally subscribing
@Cris-xy2gi
@Cris-xy2gi 3 года назад
Dude these simulations are awesome. Keep it up
@MikadoRC
@MikadoRC 3 года назад
Wow, I really like you showing the actual complete model of the tank instead of just some random piece of armor. You should keep this in future videos if possible
@juracan8591
@juracan8591 3 года назад
I would've liked to see the same test done with 3OF26 HE with 5.24kg of TNT equivalent since a few people here seem to think the shell used here is the same used by 125mm cannons in War Thunder when this one has a little over 2kg less of TNT. It's still interesting to see though, and I'm looking forward to see your upcoming HESH video. If possible, I would like to see standard 105mm HESH (4.31kg TNT) versus the ones used by British tanks like 105mm Shell L35 (4.78kg) and 120mm L31A7 (6.56kg). For the memes one on the FV4005's 183mm HESH would be hilarious, 21.76kg of TNT probably won't leave much for the imagination 😅
@satanhell_lord
@satanhell_lord 3 года назад
Not gonna lie, I don't know if I wouldn't wanna be the commander in the second simulation, or if I'd want to be him because at least it's probably an instant/near instant death so way less painful haha
@MarkSmith-wg4is
@MarkSmith-wg4is 3 года назад
I would love to see what x50 30mm HE grenades would do if struck at the same spot on short succession. X50 in a 2000mil sec time span?
@ethanmckinney203
@ethanmckinney203 3 года назад
Massive fratricide.
@taufiqa.farizi9103
@taufiqa.farizi9103 2 года назад
@@ethanmckinney203 yeah... Also, imagine the hell of a sound those projectiles impacting the same spot over and over again.
@ethanmckinney203
@ethanmckinney203 2 года назад
@@taufiqa.farizi9103 I'm not sure you understand what "fratricide" means.
@thunderkunt5416
@thunderkunt5416 3 года назад
Cool stuff :D Now gotta read about this overpressure !
@stormshadow4533
@stormshadow4533 3 года назад
Very nice, thank you for the superb video!
@flyingcactus1953
@flyingcactus1953 3 года назад
this is so awesome
@high-velocitymammal5030
@high-velocitymammal5030 3 года назад
would be interested in seeing some HESH squesh, even if back of plate separation doesn't occur due to multilayer composite (eg T-72), it would be interesting to see the effect of the blast pressures alone.
@Xorgye
@Xorgye 3 года назад
What kind of specifications are you using for simulating the armor properties? There is a lot of thought and material handling that goes into getting the right properties on a seemingly homogeneous plate.
@ernstbusch179
@ernstbusch179 3 года назад
Very interesting, please more!
@asecondofquiet
@asecondofquiet 3 года назад
fantastic vid, would be great to see similar round vs ERA
@simulacrae
@simulacrae 3 года назад
Could you do a simulation as to how shaped charge anti tank weapons work like the AT4 and RPG7? Maybe not on modern MBT’s but APC’s and older tanks.
@josephkony4361
@josephkony4361 3 года назад
Dont mind me just leaving a comment on the best new channel on youtube this year
@Progress_or_Barbarism
@Progress_or_Barbarism 3 года назад
Love the video; educational!
@thomaskositzki9424
@thomaskositzki9424 3 года назад
Wow, these are super cool! Also, I lol'ed because when I read the titel I though "War Thunder"... then I read the description. ^^ Please make more of these! A comparison Pz IV vs T-34 would be very interesting, using their respective standart APHE rounds. Generally I am curious to see the effects of WW2-APHE rounds against crew.
@cunicularius2064
@cunicularius2064 3 года назад
Doing the Lord's work
@KadirBABA
@KadirBABA 3 года назад
What is explosive material ? Not all explosives have the same effect.
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Tnt
@reahs4815
@reahs4815 3 года назад
How can all explosives not have the same effect? (pressure spike)
@kptparker
@kptparker 3 года назад
@@reahs4815 Difference would be in quantity per each type to have same effect. As far as I know.
@nicolassmithlemaire1232
@nicolassmithlemaire1232 3 года назад
@@reahs4815 diferent explosives have different blastwaves speeds and some explosives have more power than others like nitroglycerin is more powerful for the same mass than tnt and is faster burning thus having a faster blast wave to
@radonsider9692
@radonsider9692 3 года назад
Selam abi
@redsnowleopard
@redsnowleopard 3 года назад
Now can you do one on an open top vehicle With a smaller HE shell? I want to see the difference between how pressure acts when confronted with open tops and enclosed vehicles (I feel like pressure would dissipate more in an open top vehicle rather than just killing everyone)
@matthiuskoenig3378
@matthiuskoenig3378 3 года назад
on the flip side the armour plates are going to be weaker (compare a fully closed and tapped up cardboard box to an open-topped cardboard box)
@prinzeugenvansovoyen732
@prinzeugenvansovoyen732 3 года назад
can you drop a steel beam so it lands one end first and show the shockwave bend and stress in material? /a fix steel beam that has something heavy land on the non supported end Also what software do you use to run these pressure flow and dynamic simulations ?
@NotTheCIA1961
@NotTheCIA1961 3 года назад
Could you do a simulation on a large caliber shell impacting on and nearby an open cabin vehicle?
@Bitt3rh0lz
@Bitt3rh0lz 3 года назад
Can you do a penetration and post-penetration explosion sim with the 88mm Panzergranate 39 on any sort of Sherman?
@Daniel-wy2kx
@Daniel-wy2kx 3 года назад
I love this video so much.
@1moderntalking1
@1moderntalking1 3 года назад
Outstanding
@xbobxbob9277
@xbobxbob9277 3 года назад
Just subscribed, amazing contents 👍
@TechMagier
@TechMagier 3 года назад
Good work!
@peterlond4020
@peterlond4020 3 года назад
I need more of this
@meixo9083
@meixo9083 3 года назад
very good!
@captain0080
@captain0080 3 года назад
"shrapnel for all" should be the name of a death metal album.
@TheNightrider88
@TheNightrider88 3 года назад
Great one! Would be nice to see more powerful explosives up to thermobarics.
@abbc5156
@abbc5156 3 года назад
Top tier content!
@christopherhayden3911
@christopherhayden3911 3 года назад
Awesome video just found the channel
@adrian_86
@adrian_86 3 года назад
There are no fatalities, the crew will go unconscious. Awesome channel btw 👍
@kwkfortythree39
@kwkfortythree39 3 года назад
Really interesting!
@lpzstephan7943
@lpzstephan7943 3 года назад
I have no idea whats going on but it's cool.
@skullofserpent5727
@skullofserpent5727 3 года назад
Amazing!
@josephahner3031
@josephahner3031 2 года назад
I always thought that we were critically underestimating the potential damage from plain HE shells. But, are these sims taking spall liners into account and which model of the Leopard 1 are we looking at here?
@FIRE_STORMFOX-3692
@FIRE_STORMFOX-3692 3 года назад
Beautiful
@Aturtle17Mw3
@Aturtle17Mw3 3 года назад
Can you try the pressure wave simulation with a HEAT-FS shell? and if possible the how much heat the crew is exposed to after the armor is perforated.
@alexey_chekhovich
@alexey_chekhovich 3 года назад
Underrated comment. This would be the most interesting simulation in relation to WT since HEATs there have little to no overpressure effect past the armor.
@tw3397
@tw3397 3 года назад
HEAT penetrates the tank with a hypersonic jet of molten copper, the jet is usually smaller than the caliber it got fired with, it destroy everything that is in its path, but would probably stop when hitting a wall inside the tank itself. The jet of molten metal is the lethal thing, there isnt much explosion happening so the effect overpressure has here is kinda small. But you prabably already knew that.
@Pawniac
@Pawniac 3 года назад
@@tw3397 It's plasticized copper, not molten. The copper doesn't have enough time to heat up to its melting point (the jet will be hot, that goes without saying), instead it relies on the kinetic energy of the jet going tens of times the speed of sound to perforate the armor.
@tw3397
@tw3397 3 года назад
@@Pawniac ok, plasticized copper, noted, but the effect i stated still stays the same
@Karza_357
@Karza_357 3 года назад
Very interesting stuff.
@jammygamer8961
@jammygamer8961 3 года назад
so my take away from this is that war thunders overpressure is fairly inaccurate in the sense that its too strong
@arczer2519
@arczer2519 3 года назад
it's way to strong, not talking how shell's that shouldn't have fatal over-pressure (almost all APHE and small caliber HE like 50mm with 170g of TNT) have it...
@kamilszadkowski8864
@kamilszadkowski8864 3 года назад
Is it though? In this test, the tank is basically empty inside. I imagine that the blast wave could create a lot of shrapnel by damaging the equipment inside, not to mention detonating ammunition.
@jammygamer8961
@jammygamer8961 3 года назад
@@kamilszadkowski8864 i can imagine the ammo can take more pressure than the crew since it has to be fired out of a gun
@GordonMusliman
@GordonMusliman 3 года назад
its not too strong but lazily implemented. the plates effect on pressure wave is entirely ignored in gaijiggles model.
@matthiuskoenig3378
@matthiuskoenig3378 3 года назад
@@jammygamer8961 the ammunition isn't just the projectile but also the powder charge
@neromastic4512
@neromastic4512 3 года назад
Now I am amazed by the simulation that is been used. But I would wonder whit everything the same what would happen if it hits the ground under the Tank,how the pressure would go up.
@jordyncollier919
@jordyncollier919 3 года назад
Thank you for revealing my true power
@danny2717
@danny2717 3 года назад
Can u do leopard 2a6 or M1 abrams vs 3OF26?
@jagermainman10yearsago25
@jagermainman10yearsago25 3 года назад
Great now I get to see exactly how my HEAT shell couldn’t pen
@user-jl7un6dn7x
@user-jl7un6dn7x 3 года назад
Awesome
@btbd2785
@btbd2785 3 года назад
Is it the pressure and or the shrapnel that kills? Don't the modern tanks have liners to minimize the shrapnel?
@nikovbn839
@nikovbn839 3 года назад
Hypothetical internal explosion: the crew is scrambled eggs now.
@a.t6066
@a.t6066 3 года назад
More subscribers and views. Your channel didn't take long to becoming popular 👍
@artyomgunard4491
@artyomgunard4491 3 года назад
*Any frontal shot to the hull Driver: Adiós!!!
@noelmoreno5879
@noelmoreno5879 3 года назад
How about a the anti era tip from the apdsfs?
@DerKropa
@DerKropa 3 года назад
Please test overpressure by HEAT shells as well. Imo their overpressure is overpowered in WT.
@alexisbierquedebirkadefauv1744
@alexisbierquedebirkadefauv1744 3 года назад
So basically.. the over pressure itself won't be enough to kill the crew most of the time The shrapnel on the other hand.. Oh and can you please make one on the Abrams and Leopard 2?
@Elyron2004
@Elyron2004 3 года назад
can uou do it with the marder back hull armor against a m103 heatfs round
@energymass7944
@energymass7944 3 года назад
Finally, a weapon powerful enough to shut raid: shitter legends.
@alexdivision4320
@alexdivision4320 3 года назад
I love this
@thisisabsolutelystup
@thisisabsolutelystup 3 года назад
Excellent simulation. What about blast pressuring coming in behind a HEAT shell? Does any come in through the penetration path?
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Thanks! I haven't simulated HEAT yet but i doubt the pressure would have much effect through such a small hole
@thisisabsolutelystup
@thisisabsolutelystup 3 года назад
@@SYsimulations me too, particularly as you're talking about a det in free air vs ingress in to a confined space, which will pressurise much more rapidly than the atmosphere at large. The reason I ask is that a lot of weapons now talk about enhanced behind armour effects, not just spall, implying blast or temperature ingress. I don't believe that's real.
@jomarkde
@jomarkde 3 года назад
Great vid. What unit do the numbers in color map represent? I'd assume it to be in Pa, is that correct?. Btw could you simulate a big blast far away from a tank? Let's say 500kg bomb 15m away? I'm interested in how well will the armour protect the crew without necessarily being penetrated.
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Thanks, its Pa and the values are shown in the legend in the top right. I may do a bomb simulation in the future too
@mitri5389
@mitri5389 3 года назад
the US military has done that already with 500kg bomb they determined that a near miss of 1 to 2 meters would cause a mbt to be combat infective by destroying view ports , tracks, external equipment but not injuring the crew from pressure or from fragmentation. a direct hit would be need to cause complete destruction.
@MrSharp-yg1wb
@MrSharp-yg1wb 3 года назад
What software do you use for simulations?
@paulm3931
@paulm3931 3 года назад
What's that gooey residue all over the inside of the tank? The operators.
@Malaveldt
@Malaveldt 3 года назад
Great sim. I wonder if the internal explosion would blow the turret off.
@andrewsuryali8540
@andrewsuryali8540 3 года назад
Need more than 1 HE shell for that. If he simulated all the ammo stored in the tank and the propellant ignition, then yes, pop goes the turret.
@lennytheburger
@lennytheburger 3 года назад
When the video game dosent use the correct lattice speed when simulating aerodynamics
@digitalprismatics
@digitalprismatics 3 года назад
What software is this? Thank you!
@yasseralwash7127
@yasseralwash7127 3 года назад
Can you make a simulation about the T-14's crew closed capsul How would an impact effect the capsul
@SYsimulations
@SYsimulations 3 года назад
Unfortunately theres not enough information available for the armour arrangement of the capsule so I won't be able to do that realistically
@moltovele9626
@moltovele9626 3 года назад
Gaijin taking notes for the next update here.
@Neeverseen
@Neeverseen 3 года назад
I always wondered how direct fire by a SPH would do. Can you do 155mm. HE against a tank?
@tommiturmiola3682
@tommiturmiola3682 3 года назад
Also 122mm HE. Those have been used in that role recently. Although this simulation does give some idea. Not sure what kind of armour T-series tanks have on hull roof.
@andreasmeyer3593
@andreasmeyer3593 3 года назад
Will it have similar results if it hits the front of the Abrams? M1 also has a huge shoot trap right above the drivers hatch
@yuluoxianjun
@yuluoxianjun 2 года назад
of course.i killed
@diyartokmurzin7154
@diyartokmurzin7154 2 года назад
I wonder what simulation application is used? Is this comsol?
@animeshjain8932
@animeshjain8932 3 года назад
Why the apfsd round don't have a pointed nose in simulation
@lin837pr2
@lin837pr2 3 года назад
Now with the shrapnel. Rip all crew members body’s. Whats coming up next?
@yuluoxianjun
@yuluoxianjun 2 года назад
Can ztz99a s 125mm HE kill m1a2 and leo2 in this way?
@blueprintoc3453
@blueprintoc3453 3 года назад
How does HE lethality stack up against things like blow out panels or other such rapid depressurization methods?
@antares-the-one
@antares-the-one 3 года назад
It mostly doesn't matter. That pressure gradient has inertial nature, not compressional.
@Hokyyy_
@Hokyyy_ 3 года назад
Centurion avre 165mm plz.
@ReviveHF
@ReviveHF 3 года назад
105mm HESH and 120mm HESH vs Challenger 2 turret roofs please
@jordancostello1674
@jordancostello1674 3 года назад
Tank Engineers: go through painstaking efforts to make the safest and most effective tanks for people to drive. Ballistic Physics: SHOCKWAVES GO BOOM
@kenzoo5416
@kenzoo5416 2 года назад
What's the name of the program that you used for that
@nootnoot558
@nootnoot558 3 года назад
"why not,its already 2am i might as well learn about tank round ballistic."
@MrPeperoni79
@MrPeperoni79 Год назад
Please make 183mm HESH vs. Riflemen (with helmet).
@GordonMusliman
@GordonMusliman 3 года назад
From what i have seen wt model is not too strong but lazily implemented. the plates effect on pressure wave is entirely ignored in gaijiggles model. Result ends up being close but in some cases we get bs stuff like 40mm HE shell from Sgt York overpressuring a T-62 from the front.
@NotSureWhyIDoThis
@NotSureWhyIDoThis 3 года назад
Could you do a pressure test to see if ATGM's or HEAT rounds overpressure at all? (Just wanting to shit on warthunder for those having overpressure effects). Secondary request for overpressure from say a 20g tnt explosion inside a tank from a shells explosive filler?
@tommiturmiola3682
@tommiturmiola3682 3 года назад
Seconded. Thing to note is that some armoured vehicles (maybe all) have hatches that are designed to open if the pressure inside gets to dangerous levels. Not sure if this is something that can be simulated.
@alexey_chekhovich
@alexey_chekhovich 3 года назад
@@tommiturmiola3682 even if those hatchets would be opened by the pressure inside - crew would be dead or severely injured at that moment. There is a common myth among BMP crews that open hatches can save you from an rpg shot’s pressure, or you’ll even get thrown out of the vehicle by it. In reality the wave hits almost identically no matter opened or closed the hatchets are - pressure wave passing through the crew almost guaranteed to disable and severely dmg them. And it’s only and RPG, relatively small HEAT, not a proper caliber tank shot.
@tommiturmiola3682
@tommiturmiola3682 3 года назад
@@alexey_chekhovich Depending on the criteria, i'm willing to agree with you. But considering the empirical evidence of personell of various vehicles surviving relatively capable and continuing fighting i would say that there is more to this and thus i would like to see the simulation.
@roymuerlunos2426
@roymuerlunos2426 3 года назад
These are what the protection analysis simulations should be like for War Thunder.
@mikep3180
@mikep3180 3 года назад
bro how long did it take u to make this
@sting2death2
@sting2death2 3 года назад
Why not use 3OF26 instead of OF19?
@blight1934
@blight1934 3 года назад
So milk truck will die. But tanks with sufficent armor can survive overpressure?
@p_filippouz
@p_filippouz 3 года назад
Oh yesssssssss Over🅱️ressure
@jackstecker5796
@jackstecker5796 2 года назад
I dont have my bomb book handy, but if memory serves, less than 0.5 lbs of HE, detonated in a confined space, is lethal out to about 18 feet. Open air detonation, you're looking at 9 feet.
@xx360pwnagexx3
@xx360pwnagexx3 3 года назад
Funny how a 20mm HE shell ignores all laws of physics in war thunder
@petrkdn8224
@petrkdn8224 3 года назад
You are crying that war thunder isnt a perfect real world physics simulator?! Get a life
@dan-oh7jo
@dan-oh7jo 3 года назад
@@petrkdn8224 You are crying because someone is crying that war thunder isnt a perfect real world physics simulator? Get a life.
@supasoljas7824
@supasoljas7824 3 года назад
@@petrkdn8224 I think it's more the fact that HE shells became kinda annoying to fight against, and I'm assuming somehow a 20mm HE can overpressure tanks. You are trying to shit on people with the weak ass excuse that they expect WT to be a realistic physics simulation. Guess what, nobody wants that, we want a game that won't fuck the playerbase over practically 24/7
@tonyennis1787
@tonyennis1787 3 года назад
I can guess what overpressure means, but what is this specifically?
Далее
Overpressure Is A Great Mechanic
8:21
Просмотров 363 тыс.
What it feels like cleaning up after a toddler.
00:40
World Record Tunnel Glide 🪂
00:19
Просмотров 19 млн
Inside the B-17 Ball Turret
18:59
Просмотров 1,9 млн
Every War Tactic Explained in 8 Minutes
8:03
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Why I Don't Use APDS Anymore
14:46
Просмотров 510 тыс.
New German and French Tanks Revealed!
14:29
Просмотров 199 тыс.
How does the ammunition of a towed artillery work?
10:26
Can Giant Wood Block STOP 300 Ton Hydraulic Press?
15:03
Здесь упор в процессор
18:02
Просмотров 371 тыс.
Это Xiaomi Su7 Max 🤯 #xiaomi #su7max
1:01
Просмотров 747 тыс.
#engineering #diy #amazing #electronic #fyp
0:59
Просмотров 1,6 млн
iPhone 16 - НЕ СТОИТ ПРОПУСКАТЬ
4:50