Putin’s Gambit: Why He Chose War and How it Will End 

Exactly 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Watch and exchange our impressions and thoughts, being in - perhaps - very remote parts of the Globe :)

And let's not forget that we can have perfect music - for free. And your inner spring mattress, that nylon toothbrush, vaccines, the whole world on your color screen, the world's library in your pocket, instant communications, overweight people, long lives, airconditioning, motor cars and planes, space travel, liberal education, universal franchise and a gazillion other things shows how blessed we are in our science fiction world.

Not completely free. I pay$50/mo. for Internet

This guy is just parotinjkikk

From the Far Side I reply - which is why we should be grateful for global warming. Where do expressions like 'insanely cool' come from to replace the thousands of adjectives that could be used in meaningful speech and writing?

NATO attacked itself when two NATO members (USA and Norway) attacked another NATO member. What does this mean for the future of NATO and how history will remember it?

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found..... The end?

I fear they have been misnamed or lost their way

The NATO expansion was just a propaganda lie to justify the invasion. Even the Russians know that NATO was not going to accept Ukraine in the near future. The same for EU membership. The country was in a to early economic and political development stage to back such decisions. The speech looks bizarre to me, because it basically states: "OK, the war is the NATO and Ukraine fault! Lets give Russia what Putin wants!". That is against the political logic of the East Europe and international rules.

Russia wanted this to be in written form but the west declined

The USA wanted that war to sanction Russian gas supply to EU.

@Ukraine is Russia russia stoked up the fire in donbas getting its people to rebel and then adding its own troops to fight off ukraine who wanted to keep its country in tact....lets face facts russia is geographically weak and should go with the flow of the majority....look at yourselves your not a great people.... and where would you be without oil and gass sales .....shame you forced someone to show you how nuclear worked....your not a creator you scheme your way though life.

A contract with the U.S.A. is not worth the paper its written on. They broke so many contracts over the last decade that they have lost all trust. Only power holds them in position. If this power got to be broken publicly so that all can see the Table will turn against the U.S. many many nations are waiting for that. The U.S. is not to be trusted. Russia hold all theyre contracts. They are trustworthy. Thats what media dont want us to see. Cause it would be over with the U.S.A and theyre impact. Countrys would say why listen to you? You lied and betrayed us many times and now there is a other power no.1 we dont have too any more. 🤷‍♂️

Makes sense!

No contradiction here. If you think you will win a war, you might nevertheless be interested in negotiations. Maybe you win even more.

Putin would sure negotiate, the thing is Russia would comply with the agreement no more than it respects agreed upon humanitarian corridors for evacuation of civilians. That is, it shells the corridors and would attack Ukraine again at first occasion.

Why would you take territory without spilling blood if you THINK you COULD take it by spilling blood? Come on man. You're better than that.

War is risky and dangerous in every way...... if you can get anywhere near what you want without it the better......

How's your boss since the aeroplane crash, Ivan?

I agree with the sentiment, but I disagree with the substance. As it stands, the United States is the best arbiter for anyone's security based off of the unparalleled force projection capabilities it has. The US can afford to guarantee and assist nations far afueld because logistically there is no where that is out of reach for the US. Russia cant guarantee nations in say, Iberia or North West Africa for example. This was seen when Russian guarantees fell short in Vietnam when China invaded them. They just can't offer any sort of tangible support beyond a few hundred kilometers of their border. Should the US be meddling? I think there is a better way personally. But be that as it may, the US is the only country in the world that can affect any measure of security to any nation anywhere in the world.

He is simply restating US arrogance and desire for a unipolar world. That is what this is all about.

@@docprune9922 Putin likes to negotiate with America as he wants to be seen as a leader of a power equal to the US. Not to mention that Putin does not accept sovereignty of anything he can attack and wants to attack.

@@TorianTammas That is why Austin asked Shoigu for a ceasefire, because Ukraine is 'winning' .. get a grip, you muppet.

@@docprune9922 I concur. 120 billion dollars of aid and they still can't recapture lost territory. They're just prolonging the war to make Russia suffer, they know they'll win eventually but the longer the better for them.

sounds like they a plagiarising their opinions from the toilet paper times.

I guess he chooses to express himself carefully in order not to hurt any russian feelings, while at the same time trying to present the facts. Some people might also call it diplomacy or emotional intelligence

@@clover6480 No, the ambiguity is better explained if it is seen as propaganda intended to brainwash the gullible. Whereas, the truth is always paradoxical, there's no reason that Russian can't be both less dangerous than is feared yet still dangerous enough to be treated with respect.

@@jamesedwards.1069 What is so complicated ? Russia is very weak against NATO in conventional war but extremely lethal in nuclear war . Western warheads simply lack targets while russian ones would have a disproportionate effect . So there is incentive from that side to do a kamikaze move when prezented with overwhelming odds - like a NATO offensive .

@@jamesedwards.1069 A country that started an illegal war of aggression and invaded a neighboring countries twice violating treaties they signed and violating the UN Charta does deserve nothing.

He Saw a chance the world being weakened by the epidemic and all the problems following i Think you are right this was a huge part of it

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found.... The end?

We have General's that have Pledged Allegiance to Qanon. Military "experts" should be taken with a grain a salt unless they have a track record of making accurate predictions in the past.

Certainly "Western" military experts should get a big dose of scepticism when discussing combined arms modern war and especially as it applies to Russia,although not all Western military have been lulled into an undeserved sense of might by beating up Iraq. As Andrei Martyanov says,and repeats,no Western military(he particularly means the US) has fought a powerful enemy in combined arms war since Korea. This means they are clueless essentially,whereas Russia has 7 years in Syria to refer to.

He strikes me as having an agenda beyond that of an acedemic.

A lot of intellectual tourism goes unchecked and is inevitably used to discredit analysts and academics for things they never said. If anything, they're too nice about it.

@@antipropo461 Russia had a 2 hour battle with American's in a SNAFU in Syria. Russia lost 200 Men and the US didn't sustain a single casualty. Russian military has proven beyond doubt they are a second rate military power with Nukes. Basically, a giant North Korea.

Yeah pretty funny

he actually said it, you have to rewatch. at the beginning of the lecture

@@andreasfromsanandreas1268 he said that Ukraine has been bombarding the Donbass for 7 years and were ammasing a lot of troops for some reason?

it started because russia hasn't got many warm water ports... and wants to protect what it had....and push hostile countries away from its ships and to control the food supplies of a large part of the world....to become a major player and respect in the world....as nuclear weapons are a dead end and become irrelevent.

@@jpgpearson nukes are definitely not a dead end

You are 💯 right

can't rule it out considering the increasingly deranged ways Putin is showing the man is a lunatic

It makes no sense...unless he is setting a false flag. America has done that before.

Yes, the US acted as if it can change regimes at the cost of thousands of lives worldwide.

But it gets more following/funding/support than a more rigorous approach. After all, most people just want support for a certain narrative rather than truth.

@@MichaelKoksharov and what's the truth? What you want to believe? And this guy who has studied this stuff for decades...his views just don't matter if they don't match up with what you want to believe. And that's how it is with almost everyone. It is hard, maybe impossible, to find someone who really wants to know "the truth".

@@mattcrosby2310 no...you're right because you've almost certainly got it all figured out a priori without doing any study at all.

Indeed, Russia is not surrounded by aggressors. Its aggressor sits a few thousand miles away dictating to Russia's neighbors.

Was Cuba an aggressive neighbour to the USA in 1962? Your theory is compromised before you even finish writing. You need to listen to more of these shows my friend and less CNN and other MSM. .... "going so disastrously for the Russian side"..... as a sea of red slowly creeps down the Eastern side of Ukraine ....? ... sanctions that are now being wound back because they are hurting the Europeans more than Russia.... Forrest? Trees??

Consider- how many of these experts speak ujranian fluently? ?

My guess is a lot of American experts neither speak fluently Ukrainian nor Russian. If they would gave lived for a few years in both countries they would have a clearer view.

@@johnwhite2576 60% of ukrainian speak only Russian 😁, (zelensky didn't now "ukrainian" before) becose they are Russian, efforts to be ukrainian is austrohungarian goal, then communist goal then nato usa goal . Ukrain on slavic language means military BORDER 😉. And for sentries people who settle there have obligations to go to war against invaders of Russian impery. For that role they have be given land and to be free people 😉. On west Ukraine live peaple who speak somthing between Polish and Russian , they are indoctrinated before 150-200y when they live in austrohungarian impery, they abandoned ortodox church, on pressure of Catholic austrohungarian impery and rome papa is head of that church, but they are not Catholic they are uniat, approximately 10milions . They have political power in ukrain pass 20y with suport of west and they destroyed russian soeaking people, language, culture and political parties. That is how it is now. Ukrain is what was always, battle ground between Russia and enemy's of Russia. Military BORDER

But he has a vest, part of a three-piece suit.

remember McCain singing "bomb iran" to the tune of "barbara ann"; remember victoria nuland foolishness saying "F the EU". Muricans only go in guns blazing. and getting paid lobby money.

Status of Ukraine = an existential question for the fantasy world that Putin has created and sold everywhere to his high Power-Distance Index population. It's the Disneyland of FSB.

share us your great philosophy ?

@@coshyno Buy my book.

@@widescreennavel The last line of your book ends: The complete destruction of Russia .

@@joni8090 Putin's book read better in the original German. I think you are thinking of a different book by a disgraced leader who started a little thing we like to call the 2nd World War Two...Putin's strategy to keep NATO from expanding is working like a charm! Russia will be safely surrounded by friends who are concerned about their neighbor. They will work to see that Russia stays within its own established borders.

@@widescreennavel Nothing has changed then !! But , I do think honesty in Negotiations is important don't you ! So far US and cohorts have been building castles on sand and that Never makes for Stability .

And The Trilateral Comission and The Bilderberg Conference. They will make the world a better place! /sarcasm

Don't forget the WEF!!!

Assassins accusing the Assassin

@@pcuimac and mickey-mouse schwab-klaus, and great daddy soros, and bill gates,...!

Bunch of scared babies in this chat. Invisible boogie-men who fulfil every scapegoat for you.

Probably saying something not good about Ukraine, so it got edited out

This talk was superficial garbage. Mearsheimer is the gold standard if you wanna understand this war.

@@daysjours absolutely agree.

Totally agree with you Minsk is the key and the West committed at Minsk to support Ukraine.

Their job is to hide the truth and confuse the public.

@@sonjak8265 - Very much so...:(

what were u expecting?

Exactly ...

Yep we are damed

In his introduction they said that he was an advisor to the US government.

The guy is full of shit. "Putin was planning to have a speech in Kiev within 4 days of the invasion." LMAO! I mean, I get the propaganda but be a bit more subtle and artful about it. He's outright lying about the Europeans being more eager in regards to sanctions than US was. Unless he means UK and Poland, the rest were not. Go and check the first statements coming from Italy and Germany (not sure about France) when banning Russia from the swift system was proposed. They were against it, until the US just grabbed them by their ears. lol Not to mention that US have been pressuring and pushing Germany to shut down the NS2 for years.

@@Juggler4071 Don't argue with Russian simps...

This expert is Putin's wet dream.

@@saelind73 You are absolutely right! He IS full of shit! I am so glad that there are still a lot of people can see things through.

That is because there is us and there is them. We are antithetical. Why would you expect us to be sympathetic to Putin's twisted point of view. If Putin drops a book on his toe, he thinks that it is the result of a western plot. The Putin regime is just a criminal organization, how could we agreed to its continued existence?

always been

Our speaker should have had a better mike, or else two of those lousy ones (one slightly to his left, one slightly to his right). The sound was a failure worthy of the Russian army.

agreed. they could have had somebody passing a mic between the people asking question, ive seen that done in other Q&A sessions and it works well. it was also a little bit annoying how he kept turning his head to address the room as he spoke, getting louder and quieter as he moved past the mic.

what analysis?

There was no analysis, imo he was only giving his thoughts leaving our or rewriting facts, history and international law. IOW the american version of the truth.

They keep repeating the nuclear threat as if it is real. Oh yeah, bio and nukes, keeps getting repeated. Putin has no need to use WMDs. Putin wants to take Ukraine intact, not destroyed. Do you think Putin could level Ukraine with conventional arms if it wanted to? Hum what do you think? Could the USA level other nations with bombs? Hum, like endless bombs in WW2. Oh wait, that happened already!

I don't really like the "if things had been different in the past, would they be different now?" question, because that's just impossible to know and will probably be answered with "obviously yes" and "obviously no" depending on what position you want to argue for. (Personally I would just say that I don't have a reason to believe that things being different in the past would make it different now.)

If Ukraine had been left to its own devices it would remain in Russia's sphere of influence, trade etc. It's was the NATO empire's attempt at pulling it into theirs which split it in Two. The coup of 2004 was reversed because the majority are pro russian. In the 2014 madian coup the west and their ultra nationalist fractions/militias made sure that would not happen. Remember Zelensky elected on a strong peace platform and mandate to implement the Minsk accords but of course our empire couldn't let democracy run it's course. They WANTED this confrontation by proxy and they want to bleed Russia down to the last Ukrainian. Putin took the bait

so, what do you think of all the wars started by the USA since the fall of soviet union? if we want to get to the root of the matter, all the wars since the end of ww2?

Yes, he kinda carefully pointed out that what the first speaker brought up is nonsense to put it politely. Tbh I watched only the first 5 minutes of that and skipped to 39:22 in the hope of finding something more encouraging, I did. Other scholars, particularly those familiar with the inner workings of Russian during the last 20 years, have pointed out in multiple ways that the reason and trigger for Russia‘s Ukraine-war is solely found in the 21st century. That whole Nato-extension variant has been debunked extensively - in particular there were never treaties or promises forbidding independent countries to join Nato. The idea that bigger countries get a say about who their neighbor’s friends may or may not be is history. Also Putin himself is on the record stating that Ukraine in its borders is untouchable - that however must have been before 2006. At some point he found out that to western leaders he is a goon and Putin just didn’t deal well with it. What are a couple of ten-thousand dead compared to an imperator‘s hurt ego after all?

@@michaela.178 you are why there is war in ukraine right now.

Yes. Dr Graham is clearly out of touch with reality in his ivory tower.

It was their territory to begin with

@@SupaHoon Bro Texas was Mexican...your point being?

@@SupaHoon Who is "they"? The association of Austrian house painters? The point is they gave something to Adolf Hitler that a. didn't prevent the Nazis from invading Poland, and b. gave the Nazis well-equipped tank (and other armaments) factories that made the German army far, far stronger than it would have been without it.

Hitler didn't have nukes. Think this through, all the way. This is very grim.

On the other side of the coin, the Minsk agreement was about guaranteeing the security of the Donetsk and Lugansk Regions. Ukraine took now notice, killing 14K people between 2014 and 2022 and continuing arbitrary, random shelling of the areas killing innocent civilians (including children) even days before the Special Military Operation was launched. There are always two sides to each coin.

@@ashecbtb9509 Its a good thing that there were no Ukrainian casualties and there was no invasion of Ukraine in 2014. You are a bot or a sheep!

Immediate security? - The US interfered in the Ukraine and Russia Response..

and Russia responded

yeah giving a military Guarantee in our modern age is a god damn huge nono

Sounds like what Trump did with the Taliban. Didn't go over well, even if the goal was to evacuate since Biden went with the Trump agreement with the Taliban.

It is simple you have to tell Putin that any aggression to another country will be his very last and then fullfill your promise.

@Tom: yes, it's little like having some other country fight our wars for us?.

@@TorianTammas You need a history lesson. America has had a difficult time winning.

@lesia gutierrez Budapest Memorandum was a weak fudge - just a bunch of reassuring *sounding* crap, *containing no firm commitment from anyone other than Ukraine* , which gave up it's nuclear deterrent without demanding a sufficient quid quo pro. There was no promise or assurance that Russia, or any of the signatory nations _guaranteed_ Ukraine's territorial integrity or would ever act in support of it's defence. I wish people would actually read key background texts like that worthless document and understand it properly... And perhaps reflect on inadequate agreement statements and the weasel-word difference between such as "affirm" and "guarantee" and so on. Ukraine at the time was just excessively eager to finally free themselves from the USSR... and too trusting.

they want to repeat the lies. lies that they know what Putin is thinking. they do not.

OSCE, reports from feb.15 to feb.17 (as a comparison), and from feb.18 to feb.23. Add a nomber of citizens of LDPR who had to flee since feb.18 to feb.23. No, distinguished expert will never talk about it, because a distinguished expert's job is to provide a convenient excuse for goverments to keep going with their destructive policies. In simple words, expert has to explain populus, why Ukraine is good and Russia is bad.

intervening in lybia was a humanitarian operation....in irak it was all the deceit from bushe's part

@@rocambole93 By that argument (Libya), Russia's war goal is humanitarian.

@@BusinessAnalyzer ukraine did not threaten to kill half of the russians population like khadafi did

It is only valid if you are unsuccessful. I the other case there is simply no one who could claim such retribution. Your own examples - Iraq and Libya - are perfect.

@@rocambole93 in Libya they announced they were going to sell oil for Gold backed currency. The USA removed Gaddafi from power. In Iraq, Saddam announced he was going to sell oil for Euro's. Within 3 months the "weapons of mass destruction" narrative was created and Bush invaded Iraq. Both of these countries now continue to sell oil for USD. Putin wants to be able to sell his commodities for Rubles. China wants to buy oil for Yuan..... the USA will start WW3 to keep them using $USD. This war in Ukraine is all able who controls the financial system, although 99.9% of people don't understand that, and they will never tell you. Ukraine deserves better, from both the USA and Russia.

From what this guy says,it was Ukraine's fault for wanting to be independent,and taking steps against Russians supplanted upon them, . When did NATO or the EU ever stack k any ountry . And how many countries have joined NATO. Germany has done nothing to assist Ukraine,and has shirked it's commitment to NATO ,only to selfishly control the EU .France fares no better.

Why?

@Charles Yuditsky By homework do you mean a conspiracy theory blog or…?

Well, sanctions against the Russian Federation have caused the Russian GDP to drop by an estimated 10%. If the Russians lose in Ukraine, their GDP will drop by approximately 50%. This being the case, it's safe to say that sanctions are small potatoes. By the same token, western investment in Ukraine is a major factor in the run- up to this conflict- primarily because of the large reserves of natural gas discovered there in 2012. This is one of the two major reasons for the conflict.

Meh. Prof. wasn't listening carefully to what Graham had ALREADY addressed.on NATO.., as he definitely sounds like he's compromised & caught up in the ridiculously oversimplified MSM narrative on this 8-year conflict. -First. Second. The fact he said, "Russia committed *unlawful aggression* so they don't deserve a say in negotiating, is once laughably ludicrous , and again compromised by a false narrative . BOth you and this dude need a good dose of professor John Mearsheimer, ... all his current interviews and especially his 26 MILLION- view , six-year-old lecture on the Ukraine crisis at the time. Great power politics has its own set of rules, just let the US military tell you about it 🤣. ( maybe look at the *Bay of Pigs* Cuban missile crisis.. hmm? For a pretty close parallel, ironic example. Oh.. Except maybe exchange Cuba with MEXICO,... ya know, who's on our border.😏) Then y'all read our US MONROE Document. Look it up --Learn how great power countries operate! 🤷‍♀️

Interestingly I've heard a lot academics often complain about a lack of transparency.

Yes, at least there was somebody in the room prepared to point out that US/Russia negotiations over the fate of Ukraine amounts to Molotov-Ribbentrop all over again. I guess he has actually spoken to some east/central Europeans, which Graham either hasn't or has chosen to ignore. Any civilised person should be hoping that the end point of this is the economic, military and political collapse of Russia, probably in that order, followed by a decade or two in the wilderness while they reorganise themselves and prove themselves suitable for readmission to the civilised world.

@@grafixbyjorj According to Zeihan Russia's economy is doomed to collapse anyway, if only because of demography. Let's hope that the collapse won't be as sudden and complete as the USSR's collapse in 1991. A sudden political vacuum the size of Russia isn't advancing a stable world, thinking of China and Siberia.

@@grafixbyjorj This would be somewhat acceptable if there is a restitution clause for Ukraine considering Russia caused this disaster

it only proves that this so called gentleman knows very little. Waste of time.

NATO propagandists are intellectual pygmies with historical amnesia.

I agree. USSR is NOT Russia today ! Russia a free and sovereign state that returned the priesthood of the church that the USSR killed entirely in its time.

Great response, Guzjebesku. The Ukrainian ambassador to Norway pointed this out clearly. He said that the Red Army that liberated northern Norway in 1945, was something completely different from the Russian aggressors that are invading Ukraine now.

Painting an opponent as insane is a convenient excuse to avoid negotiations. Putin, while ruthless, has never presented himself as insane, and if anything it looks like he believes his own propaganda. Analyzing the situation from Russian perspective as well, is critical to finding a path to peace.

He is an American Putin versteher.

RUSSIA HAS MANY MANY PROBLEMS

Right from the beginning when he was saying "Russia sees it ..." or something similar when what was happening was that Putin, not Russia, was seeing it that way, it was clear his mind was twisted.

Exactly. Thank you.

USA and communist Russia - both must fall to free Europe!

Hmmm... And what happened in 2014?

@@Figlosof coup in ukraine.

@@thepcfd Yanukovych run away after his men kill more than a hundred people in a broad day light. His own party disown him ffs. But even if that was a real "coup" is still doesn't give a right for another nation to annex territories.

Sarkozy was the President of France in 2008, not Hollande.

Would have been even more useful had this discussion been fronted by people who were not CIA assets.

Hear hear!

Please watch Andrei Illarionov. He not only talks about these communications, but discloses what was in them. It isn't pretty.

How do you negotiate with someone who is being disingenuous and has an agenda they intend to pursue regardless of how much you compromise. Some people are just aggressive… The mistake some people make about the kinds of people described as ‘liberals’ is that they avoid conflict at all costs. This really isn’t true. A more accurate assessment is they tend to want to avoid conflict unless it’s required to stand up to bullies. Big difference.

Which video is that?

It might have but I would bet it didn't because the American foreign policy top of the Agenda is to destroy Russia and undermine Putins power. It's sad but our politicians have a way of not realising we are interconnected and we all need eachother. It doesn't matter what colour our skin is or what part of the world we come from, as humans we need eachother and the day we and our politicians realise that, the better our experience on this earth will be.

@@eekiane1921 , oh no. Another "blame it on America" guy. I suppose Putin is innocent in all that's happened. Maybe he is the one that needs to realize the interconnectedness of everything.

Check into the Russian-Opec oil war

@@James-bs8bd Oh, that one was relatively recent and quite hilarious - Russian dummies believed themselves to be able to push around world's largest oil producers.

How are those sanctions working? We are led by children in the west.

@@mikemorehead5794 They are working by depriving Russian usurper an dhis gan gof money , in oreder to drender Russia much less dangerous, as it will not be able to either produce or buy modern weapons (they are already lagging behind anyway). - sicerelly yours Captain Obvious

@Gregory Jones They did. Russians used an excuse, that that they are supplying according to contract, well, yes - the _minimum_ amount according to contract, but that was less than was supplied before and much less than customers were demanding at that time. Russia simply is not a reliable partner, it will screw you over at any moment whenever possible.

History is not something Americans care about, because we are afraid of looking at our own history: slavery, racism, genocide, wars, assassinations, regime changes... The more you look at America's past actions, the more convinced you would be that the US is the real aggressor and villain.

@@dznuts123 I completely disagree with you. First, hating your own country became fashionable over the last 50 years in the US, and it is completely irrelevant in this case. Second, countries of the Old World have so much blood and mistreatment of each other in their history that Americans cannot even imagine. And third, American historians do not understand the relevance and importance of the history for Europeans. For the most part, Americans look forward in their lives trying to improve it. Europeans mostly look back in attempt to find who is responsible for their problems. And this is why America is spearheading all technology advancements, and the rest of the world only follows. My point about this lecturer is very simple. He is looking at the problem between Russia and Ukraine seeing only the last 100 years or so. And the problem goes more than a millennium back to the X century, to the time of Vladimir the Great ruling that land from his capital Kiev, and bringing Orthodox Christianity into this land from Byzantine Empire in 988. Moscow did not exist at that time at all. First time it was mentioned 200 years later. And now, when Moscow want to rule this land they are trying to make historical claims, etc., but they have no foundation to claim their rights! And that is the problem for them. This is why they are trying to destroy Ukraine!!! For most of the people in the West that may sound laughable, but that points only to how much misunderstanding of Russia and what drives it there is in the US and the rest of the Western World.

@@zeigezunt6223 The problem is the US hasn’t learned from its mistakes or tried to be a better player on the international stage. This is actually the same case that you describe, albeit for different countries. History still very much influences the US’s actions.

If you are worrying about trying to "pay back" something which happened 500 years before you were born (ie didn't happen to you, wasn't perpetrated by the people you're fighting, and has no *real* effect on your life) then you are pathetic, and deserve whatever terrible result befalls you. Appealing to ancient history is even worse than just saying "because I feel like it," because at least pure selfishness as a motive is *honest*, whereas ancient history is no better than superstition. None of us were there 500 or 1000 years ago and we have no idea what really happened, only what we were told. History is an important lens to understand how things became as they are, but it is no justification to do evil.

@@thevoxdeus You are confirming exactly what I said about Americans trying to analyze European events without any understanding what is behind them, what drives people to behave the way they do. You can call people "pathetic" as much as you want, you can judge them, tell them that they are horrible and wrong, but doing so you do not gain any understanding of why people behave that way, and thus your conclusion are of no use.

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found.... The end?

They just want to lecture us. They are scared. Really scared of Putin. If Putin was not winning, why be scared?

Perhaps a response wasn't prioritized.

Technology will come if needed

I bet they did not realize they were speaking to half a million viewers within 7 days...

@@AndreasDelleske Yep, people are really searching for real info. Not some fake party line!

Yes ...this guy is nothing ...1 h of nothing, and complains about USA with no good resons.

it was a good over view some things i disagreed with but interesting to hear how many time have the usa given a country all the arms it need and they fell the second they usa leave (afgan ,the nam ) may be they they where just learning from the past and got it wrong the ukraines have some fight in them

Dude it's been obvious for a long time ukrainians were willing to fight that was never the problem anyone who even suspected they would not was deluded kind of like Putin

BS. He wasn't criticising, he was simply stating a fact that was relevant in that context.

The second - maybe, but I think you knew very well how this will play out, what will be Ukrainian stance etc. Ukrainian army has been being trained by NATO experts for years. You can judge the level of cooperation by the quality of the intelligence feed. It cannot be developed in days or weeks. The masterminds who did strategic planning they knew perfectly what number of tanks, howitzers, cannons does Ukraine have. They did not deliver more (then needed) prematurely in order: a) not to scare Russia and thus prevent the war b) not to end the war prematurely, with little loses to Russia In order to diminish military potential of Putin's army it had to be dragged into an ambush, then methodically destroyed. Thus the whole Ukraine is a one big ambush, which goal is to - ironically - to demilitarize, neutralize and denazify Russia. That plan is ambitious but risky and it's hard to tell who is winning. Russia has a great losses, but if they stop in the right moment, they can turn the situation into their advantage: they will slowly cut pieces of Ukraine, like Israel is doing with Palestine. In a way both sides can be victorious: NATO's gain will be in reducing Russia's military power and binding their forces in the region of conflict. Russia will increase it's gains in Donbass, it will get Mariupol, Melitopol and Kherson with prospects for future gains. It will also consolidate own society, as they are now defending themselves against the whole World. These are substantial gains, though for a very high cost.

Crafted nonsense is dangerous

He is completely wrong on about anything he is talking about in this video. His assessment is false, his assumptions is based on nothing and his conclusions will be proven completely wrong. I really don't know what actually opened your eyes and on what kind of infos.

The best of what? He doesn't consider the civil war already brewing in Ukraine or the seemingly inevitable on attack on Crimea by Ukraine. He frames it as a singular issue and totally siloed away from the invasion plans of Russia's "ally" China into Taiwan. He doesn't consider Putin's clearly stated goal of reconstituting the former USSR. The struggle over the routing of gas and oil pipelines through Ukraine also didn't seem to be a partmof his anaysis despite the fact it's been an issue for almost a decade now. He still seems to think a settled agreement includes Crimea staying under Russian occupation which has been thoroughly ruled out by Zelenski, and why wouldn't Ukraine rule it out as it was almost universally accepted as an illegal invasion. And there are more than just 2 potential outcomes as he claims. For example the west, including the US forcing a negotiation by Ukraine by cutting off arms shipments, the collapse of the Russian Federation after Putin's death, a coup from within Russia driven by increasingly negative public opinion of Putin's performance as it drags on, among others. He assumes from the beginning that Russia is still a world power. Aside from kicking around African dictators and carpet-bombing Syrian cities Russia hasn't done anything significant in decades. Russia's reliance on fossil fuels as a major component of it's income is becoming a liability and their future is unclear, the economy in general is wrecked, the shrinking population, it's pretty much all bad news in Russia and Putin has ruled over the collapse. This wasn't the best of anything, just amatuer hour.

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found.... The end?

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found..... The end?

HAHAHAHAHAHA!

Would not you do the same?

@@stevenlight5006 Not if I was trying to win a long term peace, no. All this has done is ensure that the entire continent of Europe will wean itself off Russian energy as fast as it can, so that it can never again be held hostage. It is the biggest own goal, possibly ever. The Russian economy may never recover.

Would I have done the same if I were Putin? The same being: Attacking a neighbour to restore some 19th century imperialistic dream of a Russian empire? Preparing the war by betraying the trust of the Germans who put their strategic gas reserves in the hand of a foreign nation? Lying in the face of Western diplomats who sat at that ridiculously long table for a year although I had already decided to invade? Indiscriminately shelling civilians, hospitals and schools? No, I wouldn't have.

Not true, the delivery of gas through NS2 was ready except for the valves to be opened. When you go to the shop to buy something you only get the item after paying. The same is true in the case of gasdelivery. The problems arose when European countries refused to pay. You're totally overlooking the power of the us and their crimnal behaivour re Europe and the EU.

Try telling a global arms dealer that selling weapons is Wrong 🤣

@@joni8090 It is actually very simple. Mind your own business.

Please go tell United States of Arsenal (aka USA), every foreign policy of USA is basing on its SELFISH interest at all cost of OTHERS.

"Our interests" and "right vs wrong" coincide exactly at the 1991 borders, because any other settlement sends a dangerous signal to both Russia others with imperial ambitions that borders can be moved by force.

@@russellwilliams3209 Oh I'm so Sorry I didn't know I had to ask for your Permission to respond to RU-vid !! Did I touch one of your Nerves ! 🤣

Repeat a lie is what this video is about. Calmly said what you think Putin is thinking. keep speculating and making stuff up. they do not know!

here is a review: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JrMiSQAGOS4.html

MUCH TO THE DISLIKE OF THE ELITES IN WASHINGTON WHO ARE ENGAGED IN DISSEMINATION OF FALSEHOOD BY THE SPREAD OF FAKE NEWS ABOUT UKRAINE.

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found..... The end?

Please read history, it would be helpful for a responsive and responsible guy like you. After all , it is guys like you and me who fix a policy. No offense, bro but a suggestion. Thanks and Peace.

Peter - EXACTLY!!! And the same old rhetoric that preceded Iraq/ Afghanistan/Libya and Syria. Not to mention Lebanon/Egypt/Etitrea/Somalia/Ethoipia/Yemen. The Vampire Parasites and their attack dogs NATO and the MAFIA will never be content until they own ALL the world's resources and are left with only a few slaves to work their precious metal/diamond/opal mines and oil drilling rigs. What is so special about Ukraine all of a sudden? Open Wiki and see what they are sitting on. Billions in untapped resources that the investors have already paid a deposit on. That's why they won't negotiate with Russia. For after Ukraine it will be on to Russia that has more minerals and precious resources than ALL THE REST OF THE WORLD PUT TOGETHER. Never forget the role of Rothschild and Rockefellers who actually control the whole shebang.....

That is typically how diplomacy is done. Imagine electing leaders to conduct diplomacy, crazy!

"Liberal international order"? The west continues to pretend. No such thing outside of their imagination

thanks John, I think you are right, much as Biden and NATO don't want to hear that. Eventually to save Ukraine from a rout, it will mean boots on the ground, planes in the air, and A-10 Warthogs going after all that Russian artillery and rocketry. From wherever it is firing. Had the US, Briton, France and Poland even sent a regiment each before the invasion - since their intelligence proved so accurate - sent them to the vicinity of the major cities but not right to the Russian border, Putin might not have done it. Putin has read us and especially Biden and Germans the way the Nazi leadership read the West, 1935-1939, especially the failure to intervene in the Spanish Civil War, 1936-1938. Now it's hell to pay, with the bill mainly due in Ukrainian blood and structures, all of civil society in ruin in many parts of their country. I'm on the left, but I break with them on this issue.

(Disclaimer: I’m not the lady in the helmet, but she hangs w/ me a lot.) The complaint about “institutes” being off-base is utterly clueless, and typical of ignorant Yanks who demand definitive facts about deeply nuanced situations, and recklessly disclaim responsibility for contributing to sort out the fog of (not so much war as typical INTERnational) affairs. …One is tempted to invoke the model of “praying in one’s own closet.”

Actually, the situation is quite opposite. Russia has done a lot to reset relations with the collective West after the Cold War: they dismantled the Warsaw Pact, abandoned communism, dismantled USSR, allowing former Soviet Republics to become independent, stopped flying strategic bombers next to NATO borders, allowed western experts to inspect nuclear installations, signed a treaty to decrease the number of nuclear weapons, opened up its market to western capital and goods. etc. The West, on the other side, continued flying strategic bombers next to Russian borders, thus showing they still considered Russia an enemy, published online the locations all ex-Soviet nuclear facilities, financed anti-Russian propaganda in ex-Soviet republics, trying to lush them away from Russia, armed and financed radical muslim terrorists from Caucasus, organised a coup in Ukraine, and installed a puppet anti-Russian government in Kiev, encouraged them to start and continue an 8-year-long war in Donbas against their own Russian speaking citizens, and armed and trained their army. The West also broke the agreement not to expand NATO over ex Warsaw Pact countries several times, installed launchers that can fire nuclear missiles in Poland and Romania, and talked about accepting Ukraine in NATO, too, which would allow NATO to put launchers that could reach Russian nuclear missiles in just 5 to 20 minutes. So, it was not concession and appeasement that brought West and Russia to the brink of WW3, but continuous hard line policy of hostility and ignoring any Russian interests or security concerns. That showed Russia that concessions to the collective West were mistake, and that they need to start talking the language of the West - the language of force.

Hardly anybody takes the Kremlin propaganda seriously anymore so spare yourself the trouble. Russia is a mafia state run by a brutal dictator who poisons his political opponents. He is trying to rebuild the Russian/Soviet empire. Fortunately, it looks like his kleptocratic regime (corrupt to the core, based on lies and oppression) will not be able to achieve this.

Agreed. The only person worth listening to from Brown is Blyth and even he gets foreign diplomacy wrong by believing the US state media geopolitical narratives.

Ukraine is trying to raise a million man army. Yet this guy is talking about U.S. boots on the ground.

@@dmiller9786 Ukraine recaptured most of the territory lost, Ru units are tired and depleted... yet this guys still thinks the Ru are gonna win soon..

@@freedomordeath89 not soon but eventually

@@ChicanoBarbarian13 Eventually HOW? based on what actual DATA? The actual DATA shows that Ukraine has more manpower, more money and weapons from NATO, while Russia is alone, without manpower since they cant call ofr mobilization and they are going bankrupt. There's NO LEND LEASE for russia like in 1942. They are done in the long run. Anyone who doesnt see it, its in DENIAL like nazis in 1943 still hoping for a victory "in the long run"

How the hell did you menage to throw Israel into this?

@@michalperach984 What? "Blame Canada" passe. Now it's blame Israel. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ip5OWcoE6GE.html

@@michalperach984 Israel controls much of US foreign policy.

@@ot23234 You should have a special military operation to de-nazify yourself

He works for the CFR. Go figure.

I made it only to the 24th minutes. That was plenty enough. There is no proof whatsoever Russia used chemical weapons in Syria. Actually, the Syrian forces were accused, but it was quickly disproof as a propaganda maneuvering by the revels. The first speaker repeated too many Western points lacking any substance.

German would be the lingua franca and maybe "official" language of the world, most Jews would have been exterminated, there wouldn't even be a "Ukraine" or a "Russia" because of lebensraum...well you get the gist...

I'd love to start squatting on his land with guns and see if he negotiates or calls the cops to forcibly remove me. Then would he say the resulting shootout was could've been negotiated? Negotiation only works when both sides have a respected baseline. Academics...smh.

This guy would be in Berlin, talking about Hitler and how it was unfair what is being done to Germany both now and during the aftermath of WW1. In 1941 this guy would be on Hitlers side.

This isn't 1941, and Putin isn't Hitler.

While it sounds like a dumb ad hitlerum, there is actually a plausible scenario that's fairly similar. Except it would involve the Allies not protecting Poland, so there's no war in the west. Germany and its fascist allies form a de facto EU (without France or the Low Countries). They hate "Russia" with a passion, which in turn is already a sworn enemy of the Allies. So the Allies had good reason to join the "EU" in an effort to take down the USSR. There's even some similarities in timeline: Russia had collapsed ~25 years before, was partially restored in a brutal civil war. Its current leader, Stalin, was a beast who had massacred millions, plotted to restore all of Russia, and ultimately (openly) wanted to take the world, and the USSR had done a lot more to try that, than Russia has. So there's a higher justification then than there is now. Ukraine's situation is slightly different: it was under Stalin's tyranny. Other than that, there was major Ukrainian nationalism, and a significant group that did join the nazis more fully, which is analogous. Finally, the situation has some comparison in the Winter War (likewise a Russian disaster, where the "EU" helped out Finland), so it's a thinkable scenario. For better analogy, we'll assume Hitler agreed to deport the Jews to Palestine (solves that morality) and is willing to let the Slavs die to natural population decline instead of a policy of sterilization. His ambitions were to incorporate a regime-changed European Russia into the Reich, which is a thinkable objective for our EU. Finally to launch the scenario, we assume Ukraine revolts while Russia is weakened by the Winter War, and grabs its current territory. Come 1941, Stalin attacks. The Reich ships arms, and is considering to intervene militarily. To what extent should the Allies, in this scenario, join Hitler in his efforts to at least help Ukraine, and probably take down Stalin's tyranny, and collapse the USSR?

No reparations possible from a Russia that no longer exists as such.

Yes. It seems to me that over the next decade Russia is going to lose the Ukraine-Russia war and eventually even the Crimea. Their oil & gas exports to Europe will be severely curtailed and not likely made up, at least in dollar terms, by exports to the rest of the world. They will continue to be under severe sanctions until they can come up with meaningful reparations. All told, the Russian people will see their standard of living fall, and their military much smaller although qualitatively improved. That includes their nuclear stockpile which is a huge unnecessary drain on the country. 600 nuclear bombs is as effective as 6,000 as a deterrence. Subservient states like Belarus and Georgia will eventually break away with new, probably democratic governments. This is my half-assed assessment of the next few decades for them, given the current situation. Of course, there are so many other things that could happen in the world, all the way from other bad actors (eg. China) acting badly, to the final Republican take-over of the USA, to the breakup of the Russian Federation, to natural disasters. So, it's impossible to predict how the ongoing story of humanity will break. Some closer in time questions include when will Putin go, how quickly can the West ramp up their arms shipments to the Ukraine, how long will it take for the Russian people to grow disenchanted.

Thank you.

Europe and Ukraine have admitted that never had any intention of honoring the men’s agreements. They immediately begin shoving Northeast Russian speaking areas. Which they are still doing this brought on the war. The “sanctions“ that we have put on Russia nothing more than a self destroying embargo on ourselves worse than the era Boylan pargo of the 70s so stupid that it must be on purpose.

Russia didn’t illegally annexed Crimea Crimea voted 95% to annex themselves to Russia. The Russian Navy has already been in Crimea since the 1700s it was still at their deep port in Sevastopol. Enter tally Asian the lovely Ukrainians cut off the water supply to the peninsula. One of the first things the Russians did when they invaded this time of blow up the damn Ukrainians are a bunch of Nazis and we financing train them

Ukraine signed and did not adhere to it as the Nazi's and far right were in charge, not the presidents. Russia had all the right to do what they did after the LPR & DPR requested Tussian assistance to stop Ukraines planned invasion. The only way Tusdia could legally do it was recognise the two regions as independent republics.

RT repeatedly cites OSCE reports as evidence that Ukraine violated Minsk. However, the OSCE reports clearly indicate that Russian forces repeatedly violated Minsk, not Ukraine. Furthermore, Russia vetoed Ukraine's attempts to pass UN resolutions to send blue hat peacekeepers to enforce Minsk. If Putin was interested in adhering to Minks, he would have supported a mission to implement the accords instead of vetoing the proposal.

Usually turns into a grant .. Take a look a lend - lease

I just looked it up and Russia and Great Britain repaid in full !

Money from US to Ukraine is laundered back to politicians accounts.

Do you think that what will remain in the end from Ukraine will be able to pay off lend-lease?

Ukraine will need to pay it back... So Ukraine signed up for decades of control by US due to their debt for fighting their war for them...

The US isnt in a war genius. The only guy who wanted war is Putin.

@@armingleiner5292 wrong. wake up pls

@@turquoiseowl No you wake up from your conspiracy far right/left (either way it is bad) trip. People who think everything is a conspiracy are just lazy with a very weak educational background. Please start educating yourself outside of far right/left garbage on the internet.

@@armingleiner5292 is the leaked recording of Victoria Nuland planning the next government leadership of Ukraine in Feb 2014 three weeks before the violent putsch that resulted in those very people becoming leaders a lazy conspiracy theory? how does an educated person such as yourself interpret that call out of interest?

​@@turquoiseowl Dude I am pro democracy and anti-authoritarianism. I dont care by what means but I want every single oppressive corrupt governent including the Russian and Chinese government toppled. The corrupt pro Russia regime in Ukraine was rightly overthrown. Nobody needs fascist wannabe dictators! Also it was violent because the state shot at protesters, thats why it was violent.

Nuanced analysis? He is partially lying, is not talking about nazis, not talking about the offensive preparation in east ukraine prior to the special military action of russia. And is not even talking about the 2014 Events which were financed and pushed by the USA. Lying about the use of ABC Weapons in Syria , despite beeing debuned long time ago. Yeah... what a paid or ignorant guy he is. I mean working for the CoFR sais it all....

No, it's not, it's propaganda. The US forced NordStream 2 to stop (attempted at least) and kept NATO trying to force Ukraine to join hoping for conflict so they could shut off cheap ass Russian NG's flow to Europe. This is a proxy war by US/west/NATO using Ukrainians as mercs. This is the US making war. NATO should have dissolved when the USSR/Warsaw Pact ended. Be careful about the wording "missed opportunities", yea the west f'd up and gave Russia moral high ground for first strike against all NATO nations. Missed Opportunity.

The Tale of Jack Kiev. Once upon a time, there was a small boy, called Jack Kiev. He was 12 years old and was an orphan. When his mother died recently, he inherited her cottage, with a little bit of land. He worked hard all day every day, cultivating his plot and producing a good yield. He had some extra vegetables and chickens, so he took them to the market for sale. At the market, the elder sons and daughters, of the Otan Family, came and bought his produce. They asked the boy, “Who is in charge of the business, as we need a regular supply? We would like to discuss business and come to some arrangement.” Jack said, “I’m in charge of the business! For I am an orphan and I will supply your needs.” So they signed a contract and Jack’s spirits were lifted, for he was quite sad and lonely. Once a week he went to the Otan household and delivered the wares that they needed and they paid him kindly. Sometime soon after, the Otan Family asked Jack to help with some chores, cutting grass and painting the shed. The Otan house, was very large with many rooms, for they had 16 sons and 17 daughters, who were always kind to Jack, so they became good friends. Jack was overjoyed with finding friendship with the Otan Family. Jack was always hardworking and never failed to be productive. As his own homestead and finance grew, he bought some sheep and reared lambs. Old Father Sam Otan was pleased with Jack. So when Jack turned 14, he made a promise to him. “When you turn 16, you can marry, whichever of my daughters that you find to be most beautiful and you will be my Son!” Jack nearly fainted and cried aloud, “Thank you Father Sam! God has truly blessed me! May Heaven and Earth hold dear to your promise.” One month later, an angry bear from the forest, came upon Jack’s cottage and ravaged his flock and stole some sheep. Jack was mortified and ran to the Otan house. “Help help! There’s a bear at my home, who’s killed my sheep!” The Otan Family were shocked and said, “Don’t worry we will stand by you and help to fight the bear.” So they sent two of the younger sons, who brought their slings and spears and went with Jack to fight the bear. But the bear was too big and strong for them to kill it. But they managed to scare the bear enough, so that it went away. “Thank you for your help!” said Jack and the two sons went back to their home. A couple of weeks passed by and the angry bear came back to Jack’s cottage, killing and eating some lambs. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help help! The bear has come back!” So three of the sons, went with Jack and they all fought against the bear. This time the bear hurt Jack and killed one of the sons and then went back to his lair. The sons went back to their home and reported the news. Two more weeks passed by and the bear came back to Jack’s cottage. It caused great damage to the chicken shed, broke some fences and killed all the chickens. Jack ran back to the Otans and this time, four of the sons, all armed with new swords and shields, went with Jack to fight the bear. They fought for many hours but the bear was too big and strong, even for all of the sons. The bear was enraged, bc it’s foot was hurt by them. It killed two of the sons and wounded the others and then went back to its lair. Two weeks later, the bear and its mate, came upon Jack’s cottage. They killed all the remaining lambs and knocked over a burning lantern, the lantern caught fire to the barn and store houses, destroying all the produce, This time the bears quickly left, before they could be attacked. Jack ran to the Otans, “Help the bears have attacked my home and the place is on fire!” So the Otan Family all quickly went and helped to extinguish the blaze. Five of the sons all stayed with Jack, “We’ll help to rebuild the farm and this time we’ll stay with you, to guard against the bears. They all worked hard to rebuild the farm and the Otans pitched their tent next to Jack’s cottage. But the bears came in the night and killed three of the sons as they slept. Jack and the other two sons ran back to Old Sam Otan and reported the news. Old Sam Otan wept bitterly in his grief and the shock nearly killed him. “Right this time, take some horses and wear armour and buy some new lances and we’ll finish the bears off for good. So six of the sons saddled their horses and went to find the bears. They rode to the forest and crossed the stream that runs from the mountains. They rode for four days and eventually found the bears trail. The eldest son said, “Right we’ll camp here for the night and at dawn we’ll attack the bears. What could possibly go wrong?” The bears caught the scent of the Otan party and came upon them in the darkness. The great bear with his mate and all their cubs with them. They killed all the horses and all of the sons as well, except one who barely managed to escape. He ran all the way home and reported the news. Old Father Otan, his wife and remaining children were stricken with grief. They held council and after many days, they came up with a plan. “Right!” said Old Sam Otan, “I’ve had enough of this great bear! I’ve lost 11 of my sons and we only have 5 left. 7 of my daughters are strong and old enough to fight, as well as any man. We’ll all go to Jack’s cottage together that makes 12 and myself 13. We’ll make traps and build strong fences and walls around the farm.” So they all went to Jack’s farm and did as they had planned and two weeks later the great bear, came to Jack’s farm with his family. The bear saw how strong the defences were, he hesitated and looked across the valley. He saw the Otan house with no walls and no one there, except some young girls and old mother Otan. He had grown tired of the taste of lambs, chickens and horses and now he wanted something else. So the great bear and his family went back to the forest and waited for night to come. He took his family to the Otan house and then charged in with speed and fury. All the bears smashed the doors and windows open and ran through the house, but there was no one there, the house was empty. All of a sudden there was a blast of hunting horns and a great cacophony of noise. The house was surrounded by Jack and all the Otans. Old mother Otan had been warned, by her pet falcon, of an approaching danger and had left with her daughters and gone to her sister’s house. She had sent a carrier pigeon to Old Sam Otan at Jack’s cottage, who ambushed the bears. “Fire!” Screamed Old Sam Otan at the top of his voice and they all hurled their burning torches at the house. Some of the bears ran out and were cut down as they ran and the house burned to the ground. Old Sam Otan and his company went through the ashes and counted all the dead bears. “They’re all here!” said the eldest son, after laying the bears bodies out. “No wait a minute, there’s one missing!” They all scouted around the area, but the mate of the late great bear, was nowhere to be found..... The end?

FAT CHANCE. Ha ha ha. How about add CHINA to NATO?

@@superchuck3259 Huh? 1)China isn't a European country. 2)Yes the EU would have welcomed Russia if it became a real democracy and the markets became freer. No reason why they wouldn't it would be the best way to solve many issues in eastern Europe and Russian relations.

@@vertigo2894 The USA does not feel like a democracy. I checked and it is a Republic. Says so in the Pledge.

@@superchuck3259 It is, an electoral college is meant to represent people across the states. THE US is kind of unique as one can almost call it a collection of mini countries. The point is, there is a constitution and a system of governance that is not dictatorial. At least, if TRUMP doesn't get his way.

I think it's unfair to say that, because of his irrationality and romanticism towards Russia, Putin's incapable of rational thinking. This is how most people are, there are topics which they can view in the abstract without emotions and topics which they attach lots of emotional weight to. You also have to consider he might be making entirely rational decisions, but with genuine beliefs which are at odds with reality. It would make sense to invade Ukraine, if you believe Ukraine was oppressing ethnic russians, if you believed the conflict would be over in a matter of days, if you believed that your military was second to none... Putin, of course, is responsible for developing the culture around him which feeds in the information he gets, so he is at fault. Yet based on what he thinks he knows, his behaviour might be quite rational. Personally, I think it's a mix of both.

Putin is rational but Western leaders aren't. Ask yourself what's more rational, carving off another part of Ukraine to add to Russia, or trying to make Afghanistan feminist.

@@bingxilao9086 Yeah why would you want to have a strategically important country align to your values... I couldn't imagine why... The miscalculation from the West was based on a misunderstanding of the facts. They thought the Afghan National Army was so large, with certain capabilities... When actually due to corruption it wasn't anywhere near the size they thought it was. Not too dissimilar to what happened with Russia in Ukraine.

@@bingxilao9086 Neither goal is rational, both are at sever odds with reality on the ground. Anyway, Putin isn't a rational politician, he tries to attain some muddled historical vision of himself as a great leader that history will remember: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ZwU13-4SakE.html

@@guntguardian3771 Actually, the true reason Afghan army dropped their weapons is that they have no nation to fight for. Why fight if you do not value an abstract thing that you do not bind to the people? People over there have so called pre-modern mentality, watch some anthropologists on that.