Тёмный

Richard Dawkins vs. Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Political Christian or Truly a Christian? 

The Poetry of Reality with Richard Dawkins
Подписаться 127 тыс.
Просмотров 50 тыс.
50% 1

I will be on tour of North America, UK & EU talking about my latest book, religion, life on earth and beyond. I will be joined on stage by a range of friends and foes on stage. The events will include a Q&A and a limited meet-and-greet. You can get your tickets here: richarddawkinstour.com/
#richarddawkins #richarddawkinstour
--------------
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a hero, a staunch fighter against the violent intolerance and bossy control freakery of Islamism. She is also a personal friend of whom I am very fond. When she recently announced her conversion to Christianity, I assumed that she must be no more than a political Christian, regarding Christianity as a bulwark against Islam. I have some sympathy with the view that if you must have a religion at all, Christianity is hugely better than the leading alternative. In Hilaire Belloc’s words, “Always keep a-hold of Nurse for fear of finding something worse.”
I agreed to have a public conversation with her in New York, in which I was all prepared to emphasize the distinction between a political Christian and a true believing Christian, who actually thinks Jesus was born of a virgin and rose from the dead. I think the distinction is a really important one. I don’t think a political Christian is a real Christian, any more than the kind of cultural Christian I am myself.
When we met on the stage at the Dissident Dialogues meeting in New York, I was wrongfooted when Ayaan began with a personal statement which seemed to suggest that she really is a believing Christian, not just a political Christian. Well, her form of words was “I choose to believe.” I’m not sure what to make of that. Anyways, see what you think; here is the recording of our New York meeting.
--------------
Join Substack:
richarddawkins.substack.com/
Subscribe to Poetry of Reality Channel:
/ @poetryofreality
Follow:
Instagram: / the.poetry.of.reality
Twitter: / richarddawkins
Facebook: / richarddawkinsbooks
Reddit: / thepoetryofreality

Опубликовано:

 

2 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,8 тыс.   
@poetryofreality
@poetryofreality 21 день назад
I will be on tour of North America, UK & EU talking about my latest book, religion, life on earth and beyond. I will be joined on stage by a range of friends and foes on stage. The events will include a Q&A and a limited meet-and-greet. You can get your tickets here:
@xSteve1983x
@xSteve1983x 21 день назад
“Christianity makes me feel better, so I want it to be true” is really all she’s saying.
@drvanhelsingz5133
@drvanhelsingz5133 21 день назад
She keeps avoiding the question
@bouzoukiman5000
@bouzoukiman5000 21 день назад
Every reason Ali gives for her new belief is just ridiculous
@PJM273
@PJM273 21 день назад
"I choose to believe" is not an argument. It is a horrible defense to nonsense. If you were to say to Ayaan, I choose to believe in wokeism, she would shred your logic to pieces. She's lost the plot - I feel sorry for her actually.
@Lance-yl5sz
@Lance-yl5sz 21 день назад
Ayaan has thrown out critical thinking and replaced it with personal feelings.
@tobis.4037
@tobis.4037 21 день назад
"I had a personal crisis" - tells you all you need to know...
@michaelaskari9266
@michaelaskari9266 21 день назад
It's just astounding how someone like Ali can change so drastically and become utterly ridiculous. It's truly unbelievable, a complete and utter shock.
@brandonbee3956
@brandonbee3956 21 день назад
In a nutshell she said: I can’t deal with reality therefore I chose to believe in comforting lies despite all evidence to the contrary
@DrSabriBebawi
@DrSabriBebawi 21 день назад
"All religions are false" is the most truthful statement.
@ratstrydom
@ratstrydom 21 день назад
"I believe because I want to believe". Well there we have it.
@user-ge7mm6wl8d
@user-ge7mm6wl8d 21 день назад
Clinically depressed people are the best targets of cults. 😢
@Boris194786
@Boris194786 21 день назад
"Religion is considered true by the people, false by the wise and useful by the rulers"
@thistles
@thistles 14 дней назад
This is so sad. Richard did a beautiful job of showing his friend compassion while refusing to cave to emotional manipulation. Thank you for holding the line while maintaining both integrity and humanity. ❤
@szarkazm
@szarkazm 21 день назад
Ayaan is so disappointing. I read so many of her books, she was a hero for women. She has been brainwashed, and it is beyond sad.
@arthuroldale-ki2ev
@arthuroldale-ki2ev 21 день назад
When I was a boy (70 years ago) I asked my father about the religion I was having forced on me at school, he said, " Its nonsense lad !" A wise man my dear old Dad!!!!!!!
@RetNemmoc555
@RetNemmoc555 21 день назад
This is painful. She's dodging and weaving. I'm finding it very hard to accept that she actually believes. Science can't fully explain consciousness blah blah, so god? She knows better.
@SteveAgleron
@SteveAgleron 21 день назад
She just needed love when she was at her lowest ebb. Unfortunately a believer got to her first. I cannot believe someone of her intelligence could have been swayed by her yearning to feel better. Its a sad, sad state of affairs. I feel so very sad for her. She is clearly still not over her depression.
@lizzieh5284
@lizzieh5284 21 день назад
Religion isnt a cure for anxiety and depression. It often is the cause of it.
@DerSlashfuhrer
@DerSlashfuhrer 21 день назад
feeling sorry for Richard having to witness how a woman whose intellect and bravery he so greatly respected suddenly starts spouting inane drivel about how the fact the some ancient middle eastern fairytales are 2000 years old somehow makes them wise and true
Далее
Woke Racism Defies Logic!
53:59
Просмотров 74 тыс.
Dawkins re-examined: Dawkins' legacy
48:48
Просмотров 64 тыс.
What in the Hell is HELL? with Dr. Rodney Duke
43:05
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali: From New Atheist to Christian convert
36:15