I am not even certain why this is a matter of doubt for so many "Muslims"! Seriously, is your faith that weak and frail? We should ask these people who use this as a means to discredit the Prophet (pbuh) what THEY would have done in the exact same situation the Prophet was in. Suppose you are living close to 1500 years ago and some people came to you and sought your medical advise. If you had some knowledge about a particular ingredient that would have helped people who were in dire need of medical intervention, would your personal sensibilities--derived from 21st century society and norms--come in the way? Would you deny people who could be helped by some product, ingredient, substance, simply because you personally found it disagreeable? In the case of the Prophet, his advice helped those people. They were cured. Would you, were you in his place, have denied the people the very thing, the only thing, that actually relieved them of their illness? Would you have allowed their sickness to continue because you found the concept of drinking a substance that is emitted by camels beyond your pomposity, arrogance, conceitedness, and pride? Who is the savage here??
@khalid khalid why are you even acknowledging Gujjar's comment which lacks even a modicum of sincerity, a shred of erudition, or even a discernable trace of engagement with the topic? Why are you asking him for "sources" when his comment is nothing more than pathetic and deplorable attempt at a red herring? What the people did afterwards and the punishment they received has absolutely NOTHING to do with the subject/topic that is being discussed: that certain people were suffering with a specific illness and were given a specific remedy which alleviated that illness. Way too many Muslims are too busy languishing in their ignorance and cry to people like Hijab to "please refute this, please refute that!" Why don't you people start educating yourselves?
Alot of us are missing some knowledge here about this Camel urine. This is just only one hadith reported. it contradicts with Quran 7:157 (that Prophet SAW orders you of which is good and forbid which is evil), Science (it caused MERS-cov virus with 35% death rate) as well as Sahih bukhari itself (Sahih Bukhari 3018) the whole story is actually different. they were hypocrites and drank camel urine n milk by themselves while Prophet SAW just ordered to go to a herd of camel to get the milk (just the milk not urine). do check the hadith please Arabic word by word, They even killed the guide of the camels, Prophet SAW caught them and left them stranded n they died there while no one helped them. check Sahih Bukhari 3018 Arabic word by word. now both hadith contradict themselves, having both in Sahih Bukhari. but when we check the Matn we can clearly say that drinking urine isn't supported by Quran, Science and Hadith itself, instead it goes against as mention. Let me tell Actually how the Hadith is Verified. Actually, all the hadith, even traditionally, they are verified by 2 factors, by sanAd (authenticity of narration) and Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). Nowadays a lot of people are just checking the sanad (authenticity of narration), and starts believing it blindly. not even having a glimpse at Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). saying it cant be wrong since it is in Sahih Bukhari Book. there was a lot of narration which was after 800years, many years later or even recently got refused, because now based on knowledge we can say that there is now an error either in sanad or that it doesn't goes with matn. and sometimes the narrator or the collector of Hadith can make mistake. so why can't this narration too while it goes completely against everything, including Sahih bukhari itself. we must verify the Ahadith since its collection was started after about 200 years of Prophet SAW passing away. Allah ordered us to Follow Allah and The Prophet (4:59) so we must follow the hadith of Prophet SAW but it is necessary to verify the hadith and follow what is Actually the saying of him. So Please do your research and do check the Codes I quoted.
😂 You ask any muslim apologists about and controversial topic in Islam you are going to get any of 3 (only 3) of below replies 1.Hadith is not relaible 2.Meaning of the text of Quran or hadith has a different meaning in Arabic language which you dont know 3.That part of hadith/quran is valid only for people at that time
Or maybe the ones who attack on islam often rely on 1- unreliable hadith 2-changing the meaning of the text 3-choosing texts that are applicable to certain situations and make it as if they are general and applicable for all cases and respond according to that If you have any argument against islam and you watch a response from muslims you should verify it and see if their responses are valid or not
@@AhmedElrashidi 1) "SAHIH" HADEES 😂 2) WDYM CHANGING MEANINGN, IT LITERALLY SAY THE SAME. 😂 3) IF ALL THE VERSE WERE APPLICABLE FOR THOSE SITUATIONS IN PAST, THEN WHY FOLLOW THEM AS UR HOLY BOOK NOW ? 😂 Basic common sensw defeats pisslam.
@@glebb..3416 I Hope one day you stop thinking you are the smartest one in the room before you even understand what the others are talking about .. the comment I responded to was talking general about muslims responses and so did I .. Neither me or the one who I responded to were speaking only in the subject of the video .. I didn't say the hadith is invalid neither mohammed hijab response here .. if you listened to him you will see that he acknowledge that the hadith is sahih ..
Mohammed hijab I disagree with you here. If the prophet SAW said that camel urine was a source of cure for these individuals, then this is a life lesson for us. And we should also act upon it. You shouldn’t imply that the prophet would have re-directed patients to doctors in this century...this is the prophet pbuh you are talking about. If the prophet said it...that’s it..it’s said...it’s done. It’s the haq. It’s the truth. There is no need to justify it. Muslims should do it. That’s it. You shouldnt demean this Hadith by saying it is qais. You have disappointed us today. You have become a partial apologist. Don’t apologise, and don’t justify. This is what our prophet said..and we stand by it 100 percent. That’s it.
@Joe Bide okay I get that...but this Hadith in itself is not an evidence that you have to ignore the other hadiths. Because based on this narration, you are saying that, all other hadiths that are not religious based are all irrelevant. And that’s diabolical to say that. Islam is a way of life. At which point do you draw a line? Does that mean that the way prophet Muhammad pbuh has taught muslims to love our wives should be discarded?(because that’s relationships, not religious) do we discard using miswaak? (Because that is hygiene, not religious?) do we ignore Hadith on over-eating (because that is Health related, not religious?) I don’t agree with your perspective at all. I respect it. But I don’t agree or accept it. But that’s fine. We can agree to disagree. You stick to what you believe. I will stick to what I believe. I take all of what he prophet Muhammad pbuh said and did as haq. And I will continue with that. You pick and choose with what you agree with. At the end of the day, no need to split the Ummah over matters like this.
The prophet didnt say we or the sick should mix camel urine with milk. He only told this to those youths only. The context matters. I dont know if mh is right but do you know better than mh?
So, the argument put forth is that ---had Mohammad been in the 21st century, he would have advised modern medical consultation to those individuals suffering from a specific disease. In that case, doesn't it prove that hadees has to be interpreted as per modern times. Also, the question arises, if camel's urine is not to be used in modern times, why was the incident mentioned at all? there could also be a counter questions- If the words and actions of Prophet Mohammad was specific to those times and may not be relevant in the modern times, why should he be considered as the last messenger? After all, modern times need modern messengers.
The Quran is for all generations and eras. However the saying of the prophet isnt necessarily. For example the prophet used use a miswak, however we shouldn't use it and should use a toothbrush and toothpaste because our modern diet is different to his. Hope answers question
@@footballmontages8496 I am with you brother. With times, the outlook has to change- towards life, culture and religion. the issue is that several Muslims want to remain rigid since the Quran is considered as the complete eternal book from Allah and Mohammad is the last messenger. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-R62reDeErOs.html
We captured some of the women as prisoners, and the long separation from our wives was pressing us hard and we wanted to release sperms outside of the women (coitus interruptus). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) whether it was permissible. He said, "It is better for you to release sperms inside." Sahih al-Bukhari 2542
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
Alot of us are missing some knowledge here about this Camel urine. This is just only one hadith reported. it contradicts with Quran 7:157 (that Prophet SAW orders you of which is good and forbid which is evil), Science (it caused MERS-cov virus with 35% death rate) as well as Sahih bukhari itself (Sahih Bukhari 3018) the whole story is actually different. they were hypocrites and drank camel urine n milk by themselves while Prophet SAW just ordered to go to a herd of camel to get the milk (just the milk not urine). do check the hadith please Arabic word by word, They even killed the guide of the camels, Prophet SAW caught them and left them stranded n they died there while no one helped them. check Sahih Bukhari 3018 Arabic word by word. now both hadith contradict themselves, having both in Sahih Bukhari. but when we check the Matn we can clearly say that drinking urine isn't supported by Quran, Science and Hadith itself, instead it goes against as mention. Let me tell Actually how the Hadith is Verified. Actually, all the hadith, even traditionally, they are verified by 2 factors, by sanAd (authenticity of narration) and Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). Nowadays a lot of people are just checking the sanad (authenticity of narration), and starts believing it blindly. not even having a glimpse at Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). saying it cant be wrong since it is in Sahih Bukhari Book. there was a lot of narration which was after 800years, many years later or even recently got refused, because now based on knowledge we can say that there is now an error either in sanad or that it doesn't goes with matn. and sometimes the narrator or the collector of Hadith can make mistake. so why can't this narration too while it goes completely against everything, including Sahih bukhari itself. we must verify the Ahadith since its collection was started after about 200 years of Prophet SAW passing away. Allah ordered us to Follow Allah and The Prophet (4:59) so we must follow the hadith of Prophet SAW but it is necessary to verify the hadith and follow what is Actually the saying of him. So Please do your research and do check the Codes I quoted.
And Jesus said "Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves. Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles? Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit. A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit. Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire. Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them." Matthew 7:17-20
It would be very unfortunate if on the day of judgement Prophet (PBUH) disowns everything us Muslims have conveniently attributed to him through hadiths. May Allah guide us all.
The fact of the matter is that it clearly helped them. The prophet can only use what is available in his time. He didn't prohibit his companions to search knowledge in those aspects. Our prophet is not a pharmacist. He is a wanner. Fear your lord and prepare for the hereafter whether you are sick or healthy.
@@shahsaud2625 drinking urine is not good advice. If you had no choice but to drink it in a life or death situation then you'd have to but it doesn't have medicinal qualities. In fact, drinking urine exposes us to viruses and pathogens in other animals which is dangerous.
I don’t understand why there is a controversy here. The Hadith is in bukhari. The Prophet salallahu alayhi wa salam recommended a mixture of camel milk and urine for that sick party. So obviously there is healing in it. Nothing wrong with going to secular doctors, but We don’t need pubmed studies nor Ayurvedic medicine to prove Islam. If tomorrow the AMA said honey is unhealthy would you throw out those ahadith as well?
@@patgoulou I have never drunk camel milk nor urine. I am in good health Alhamdulillah and far from Arabia anyways. But this recommendation is from the blessed lips of the Prophet salallahu alayhi wa Salam. You either accept it or reject it. May Allah guide us all.
What would be useful is to have scientists test the claim. It’ll be great to find out if there is a medical benefit to drinking a camel milk urine concoction. I’d love to see what the results show.
I now understood it completely, that during the time of the Prophet Muhammad (S.A)it was the one I'd the best treatements available and there were not much advancements in the field of medicine, but obviously as time passes ee must adapt accordingly. And een the Prophet (S.A) told ud to do thid.
To be fair.. the camel is a unique creature. It can go for months without water and it stores water. I'm sure the urine of a camel is unique and has properties in it without a doubt. We use cow dung to grow food TODAY in 2021. We recycle and filter our own toilet water today in 2021. I see nothing odd about this. Some nomadic people living in the dry and non fertile barren desert who needed aid to remedy sickness. I have no scientific credentials here but just pondering over the urine of a camel, given that it is a unique animal that can go without fluid for a very long time I'm sure the concentration of minerals in its meat, milk and urine is likely extremely rich.
The Camel has a hump. It helps it to survive without food and water its similar to a refrigerator but it does not cool stuff so dont take my example literally. Cow Dung is used as a fertilizer for soil you cant eat it if you eat it youll become sick. The Nomadic people maybe exception as it would have been hard to find water in a desert.
it is part of the hadith. Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 Narrated Anas Radi allahu anha: The climate of Medina did not suit some people, so the Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to follow his shepherd, i.e. his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they followed the shepherd that is the camels and drank their milk and urine till their bodies became healthy. Then they killed the shepherd and drove away the camels. When the news reached the Prophet (ﷺ) he sent some people in their pursuit. When they were brought, he cut their hands and feet and their eyes were branded with heated pieces of iron. THEY WERE MUNAFIQOON SO THEY WERE GIVEN THEY WERE GIVEN THE URINE THEY DESERVED NOTING BUT FILTH AND OUR PROPHET KNEW WHAT THEY WERE ABOUT TO DO
it is part of the hadith. Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 Narrated by Anas Radi allahu anha: The climate of Medina did not suit some people, so the Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to follow his shepherd, i.e. his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they followed the shepherd that is the camels and drank their milk and urine till their bodies became healthy. Then they killed the shepherd and drove away the camels. When the news reached the Prophet (ﷺ) he sent some people in their pursuit. When they were brought, he cut their hands and feet and their eyes were branded with heated pieces of iron. THEY WERE MUNAFIQOON SO THEY WERE GIVEN THEY WERE GIVEN THE URINE THEY DESERVED NOTING BUT FILTH AND OUR PROPHET KNEW WHAT THEY WERE ABOUT TO DO
I believe there was some type of filteration process that were not explictly mentioned in the hadith, i.e. separating and extracting the nutrients by boiling, mixing with other liquids thereby creating other products or any other methods to extract the needed components. Theres no way you can just simply drink urine directly without being affected by some of its toxicity.
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
@@loopydoopi Watch assimal hakeem video on this. There is a whole science dedicated to fiqh matters, so you can't say mental gymnastics because you have limited knowledge of Islam. All of the commands and actions of Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) are relevant for every time period, but some of the commands are situational. Besides, if you are dying from a disease and you had to drink camel urine you would probably drink it. There are medicinal properties of camel urine. Besides there are abundant proofs that Islam is the truth and Prophet Muhammad (Peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) is a prophet of God. I can show you proof.
@@BilalAhmad-sk7gg 😂😂😂😂 If it wasn't for modern medicine all you clowns would be drinking camel piss. You people will believe literally anything that suits your own bias. This hadith has been the reason for people getting MERS (middle east respiratory syndrome). Which can cause death. And yes this explanation was pure mental gymnastics
It was a medicine used in those times and that's it to this hadith.Otherwise,this practice would have been widespread during the Islamic Golden age.Only Hindus in today's world drink cow urine and bathe in cow urine and consider it Holy.
@Jason Wesley _An emotional, a one-dimensional agrument, a fallacy and a strawman._ _Firstly, we solely worship Allāh, the Lord of Abraham, Moses and Jesus (peace be upon them, for they are the prophets of Allāh). You are insulting your own Lord, the Father - calling Allāh a deceiver, while He is the Truth._ _Secondly, Jesus himself was a muslim, a muslim is one who submits himself to his Lord, the One worthy of worship (Allāh). Allāh means One worthy of worship. Throughout the entire Bible, Jesus is only worshipping the Father, and exalting Him alone. Never does Jesus himself says to worship him (to mankind)._ _Thirdly, your own scripture is corrupted, through out the times it has been changed by men. It is not the word of God anymore, Jesus Christ spoke Aramaic, the only oldest manuscript that can be found is in Greek. Other than that, numerous contradictions are found in the Bible, scientific and religious. Whereas, the Holy Qur'an has been preserved since the timeline of Prophet Muhammad (S) - manuscripts dating back to his period. Scientifical miracles, linguistic miracles, zero contradictions and fulfilled prophecies. Fulfilled prophecies are also present in the book of Hadith._ _Fourthly, your own corrupted scripture (due change by men in time), explicitly states the oneness of God, the Father, and He being the Only true God. Timothy 2:5, indicates the Oneness of God, mentioning Jesus as a man, mediator - prophet. John 17:3 - the Father is referred to as the Only true God._ _Fifthly, we muslims follow the teachings of Jesus, than a Christian. Jesus worships God by prostration, we prostrate. He fasts, we fast. Bible is in denial with the consumption of pork and alcoholic beverages, we avoid them. The women in the Bible are instructed to cover their head (hair), muslim women wear hijab._
Yes honey does come from bee vomit and spit but it shouldn’t be compared to human vomit and spit. We are totally different creatures and I think that’s where the problem comes in. Humans comparing animal behavior to human behavior. It’s illogical
Assalamualaikum, could you please do a video on the ajwa dates hadith and how it protects from poison and black magic? It seems a few are interpreting it to mean that ajwa dates can withstand fatal poisons or those given in large amounts and guarantee protection in such cases. I'd really appreciate if you clear this up. JazakAllah khair. May Allah bless you for all the work you do. AMEEN
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
During the pre-lslamic period of ignorance I saw a she-monkey surrounded by a number of monkeys. They were all stoning it, because it had committed illegal sexual intercourse. I too, stoned it along with them. Sahih al-Bukhari 3849
The Hadith about drinking camel urine is considered weak or false by many scholars for various reasons: 1. **Chain of Narration (Isnad):** The chain of narrators (isnad) for this Hadith is not considered strong. Weak or unreliable narrators are present in the chain, which raises doubts about the Hadith's authenticity. 2. **Contradiction with Islamic Principles:** The content of this Hadith contradicts Islamic principles and jurisprudence. Drinking impure substances, such as urine, is generally discouraged in Islamic teachings. 3. **Lack of Consensus:** There is no consensus among Islamic scholars regarding the authenticity of this Hadith. Some scholars have deemed it weak, while others have questioned its legitimacy. 4. **Scientific Concerns:** From a scientific perspective, consuming camel urine is not recommended and can carry health risks. Islamic teachings often encourage good health and hygiene. Given these reasons, many scholars have reservations about the credibility of this Hadith and do not consider it a reliable source for guidance in matters of faith and practice. Islamic jurisprudence relies on authentic and well-documented Hadith, and those with weak chains of narration are generally viewed with caution. It's essential to consult knowledgeable scholars and adhere to widely accepted and reliable Hadith in matters of religious practice.
Its not like Urine consists only of those positive ingrediants and probably some herb would have done the job better considering all the salt and other unclean substances in the urine. Where is there the logic?
Urine is also used for fertility problems. Urine of pregnant women contains the HCG hormone. This hormone is used in the development of the vertility drugs.
it is part of the hadith. Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 Narrated Anas Radi allahu anha: The climate of Medina did not suit some people, so the Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to follow his shepherd, i.e. his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they followed the shepherd that is the camels and drank their milk and urine till their bodies became healthy. Then they killed the shepherd and drove away the camels. When the news reached the Prophet (ﷺ) he sent some people in their pursuit. When they were brought, he cut their hands and feet and their eyes were branded with heated pieces of iron. THEY WERE MUNAFIQOON SO THEY WERE GIVEN THEY WERE GIVEN THE URINE THEY DESERVED NOTING BUT FILTH AND OUR PROPHET KNEW WHAT THEY WERE ABOUT TO DO
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
The Prophet ordered them to drink camels milk and urine. They apostatized, killed the herdsmen and drove off the camels. When they were brought he had their hands and feet cut off. He ordered nails to be heated and after having them blinded with them he throw them in the desert, although they begged for water they were left to die without being given any. (Bukhari and Muslim)
I’m glad you made this video. I just saw an outrageous video with that claim. They also stated that he told them he could only help them if they convert to Islam, which contradicts Baqara 256.
Prophet saww didnt tell them to drink the urine, it was the way of telling or figure of speech in Arabic. I saw a beutiful explanation of the same hadith and the bottom line is that we misinterepted the words of that Hadith.
The Prophet ordered them to drink camels milk and urine. They apostatized, killed the herdsmen and drove off the camels. When they were brought he had their hands and feet cut off. He ordered nails to be heated and after having them blinded with them he throw them in the desert, although they begged for water they were left to die without being given any. (Bukhari and Muslim)
Assalamu alaikum, I would like to express the importance of reading the full Hadith. It clearly states these individuals were munafiqs (hypocrites), there is no Hadith where sahabis are told to drink the urine of camel. These munafiqs later killed a sahabi and were then punished by the prophet ﷺ himself. When telling a Hadith we must tell it in full. For those who understand the wisdom of the prophet Muhammad ﷺ will be able to understand this if they read the Hadith: sahih bukhari, volume 1, the book of wuddu, no. 223
Regarding keeping dogs as pets do you believe the hadiths regarding killing dogs or not having them as pets was specific to times regarding that in the 21st century dogs are vaccinated against rabies and are wormed are Muslims allowed to keep them as pets ?
As pets, no, for sure no, their saliva is also najis so how will you pray properly, that will be A LOT of struggle. islamqa.info/en/answers/377/ruling-on-having-a-dog According to Islaamic Shareeah, it is not permitted to keep a dog except within narrowly-defined limits, as the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) explained: "Whoever keeps a dog, his good deeds will decrease every day by one qeeraat (a unit of measurement), unless it is a dog for farming or herding." According to another report: ". . . unless it is a dog for herding sheep, farming or hunting." (Reported by al-Bukhaari, al-Fath, 2322) Dogs are extremely naajis (impure, unclean). The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "If a dog drinks from the vessel of any one of you, let him wash it seven times" (reported by Muslim, no. 279). According to another report: ". . . and clean it the eighth time with earth." (Saheeh Muslim, no. 280). Whoever keeps a dog in his house is denied the blessing of the angels presence in his house, as the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog." (Reported by al-Bukhaari, 3225). It only remains for us to say that the fact that it is forbidden to keep a dog and interect closely with it does not mean that we should not be kind or feel compassion towards dogs if we see them in a pitiful state. These are two entirely separate matters. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) told us that "a man saw a dog biting the dust because of thirst, so he took his shoe and started to scoop water up with it until the dogs thirst was quenched. Allaah appreciated his good deed and granted him entry to Paradise for it." (Reported by al-Bukhaari, no. 174). According to another report, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "Whilst a man was walking he became very thirsty, so he went down to a well and drank from it. When he came out, he saw a dog panting and biting the soil because of thirst. The man said, He is suffering the same as I suffered, so he filled his shoe (with water), came out and let the dog drink until his thirst was quenched. Allaah appreciated his good deed and forgave him because of it." The people asked, "O Messenger of Allaah, will we be rewarded for how we treat animals?" He said, "In every living thing there is a reward." (Reported by al-Bukhaari, Fath, no. 2363). But yeah regarding the killing of specifically the black dogs topic, I want to know too, hope they make a video
It could've been fully analysed if you could've also mentioned the demise of the men of Ukil and how they were brutally punished at Harra after complaining to be given camels urine and milk and end up stealing the prophet's camels ( Sahih Bukhari 3018 and Sirat Rasul Allah , by Ibn Isaq , page 677 ) . The truth shalt set you free brother .
It seems we have had now three Salafi scholars [ Yasir Qadhi, Sheikh Aseem and now Hijab ] in the space of one year defending this Ahadith, which is found in Sahih Al Bukhari. I note not a single one them tried to investigate if the isnad [chain] had a validity, whether the hadith was in the Prophet's [saw] own words or when it first ever entered the field of hadith studies. The biggest objection to the hadith is of course the Qur'aan, where 'najas' is described as the food of sinners. The salafi dogma of believing everything in Bukhari and sahih Muslim as being the absolute truth is just plain wrong. This is not a criticism of Imam Bukhari, as we do not have any original manuscripts which the great Imam may have written down. I note in recent times only a few Muslim scholars are willing to challenge Ahadith which go against common sense and reason; Muhammad Abdhu, Rashid Rida and Muhammad Asad. Recently Sheikh Atabek , Mufit Abu Laythe and Shabir Ally have taken a similar stance.
Thank you, great comment. Couldn’t agree with you more. They will defend Bukhari till the end regardless of what Hadith is within it and never seem to challenge the chain ever. I don’t know why Our brothers and sisters never question anything just because someone says it is sahih.
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
theres also anti-clotting, anti-inflammatory, abilities. One study even had shown the anti-clotting ability being strengthened when mixing the camels urine with the lipid camel milk. After mixing them actually the study found much more benefits, just a fyi. I read these a while ago, but one can look them up and see wayyy much more than these 2 benefits here.
He's making excuses for prophet's embarrassing advice. Found it disgusting as a Muslim, isn't he the most perfect being ever created and he comes up with this!
Yes they where cured and how do I know this? Because it’s a advise from are beloved prophet to his ummah and we see time and time again how much he cared about the community
Camel Urine? How many out of the entire muslim population drink this today? You cant say it was only for that period in time and situation. You can use that arguement for anything that was practiced in those days and that we do not practice now.
@@scaryjoker If the evil lying violent political racistic man made cultbook the quran are science. Then I don't want to understand science. I don't want to live a lie
Assalamualaikum, I’ve read the Hadith but the part that made me notice is that Rasulallah SAW cut the hands and feet of the people who killed the Shepard and drove the camels away.
I have a question about vaccines that have pig in them. Is it halal to take such vaccines and if not how about if you can’t get vaccines without pig in them????
Search up on > Islamqa.info < idk if they have addressed this, but they answer many questions. (if it’s not allowed)... about if you don’t have access to any other, hmmm, like how realistic is that tho? In terms of like you can buy online, drive a car a bit far etc etc. How serious is the situation, is the person close to dying and may die unless they are treated with it asap? Do you mean a hypothetical situation that you are sick on an island all alone and with no other medicine?
yes please - that way EVERYONE can laugh at how MH throws Mohammed and the scholars under the bus everytime he realises that what Mohammed and the scholars say is stupid. Sahih is SAHIH! You DO NOT have the right to declare in inauthentic! You either leave islam - or you accept these stupid, terribly wrong things that mohammed said!
@@user-bh3vu1bq9o so.... are you better than your scholars? Do you know more than Mohammed? What gives you the ability to disagree with what Mohammed and the scholars teach? Unless you know in your heart the it is lies, foolishness and leads to hate and death.
Arthritis medicine should prefer camel instead of horse. We use animal parts sometimes. People who don't know the wicked ways of medical field should do a research then they will be more disgusted by todays life saving methods.
Question to Hijab: if this hadith was just for a specific situation/time/place are then all the other hadiths,surahs and tafseers just for a specific situation/time/place and not valid today?
@@ahmadhussain9426 No evidence from 7th century for Islam,Muhammad,Quran,Mecca,four caliphs. Ask yourself: Why is an Ummayad caliph minting coins with crosses in 661 A.D. ?
Assalamualeykom brothers jazzakom ALLAH kheyr. Whoever agrees Hijab's justification of drinking camel's urine has to try it truthfuly. The WHO declares the urine of the camel as harmful and dangerous to drink. You can check it out
Alot of us are missing some knowledge here about this Camel urine. This is just only one hadith reported. it contradicts with Quran 7:157 (that Prophet SAW orders you of which is good and forbid which is evil), Science (it caused MERS-cov virus with 35% death rate) as well as Sahih bukhari itself (Sahih Bukhari 3018) the whole story is actually different. they were hypocrites and drank camel urine n milk by themselves while Prophet SAW just ordered to go to a herd of camel to get the milk (just the milk not urine). do check the hadith please Arabic word by word, They even killed the guide of the camels, Prophet SAW caught them and left them stranded n they died there while no one helped them. check Sahih Bukhari 3018 Arabic word by word. now both hadith contradict themselves, having both in Sahih Bukhari. but when we check the Matn we can clearly say that drinking urine isn't supported by Quran, Science and Hadith itself, instead it goes against as mention. Let me tell Actually how the Hadith is Verified. Actually, all the hadith, even traditionally, they are verified by 2 factors, by sanAd (authenticity of narration) and Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). Nowadays a lot of people are just checking the sanad (authenticity of narration), and starts believing it blindly. not even having a glimpse at Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). saying it cant be wrong since it is in Sahih Bukhari Book. there was a lot of narration which was after 800years, many years later or even recently got refused, because now based on knowledge we can say that there is now an error either in sanad or that it doesn't goes with matn. and sometimes the narrator or the collector of Hadith can make mistake. so why can't this narration too while it goes completely against everything, including Sahih bukhari itself. we must verify the Ahadith since its collection was started after about 200 years of Prophet SAW passing away. Allah ordered us to Follow Allah and The Prophet (4:59) so we must follow the hadith of Prophet SAW but it is necessary to verify the hadith and follow what is Actually the saying of him. So Please do your research and do check the Codes I quoted.
A friend of mine told me the milk of the camel was to be drunk while the urine was to be applied to the skin according to explanations of this particularly problematic hadith Anyone came across this explanation as well?
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
We captured some of the women as prisoners, and the long separation from our wives was pressing us hard and we wanted to release sperms outside of the women (coitus interruptus). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) whether it was permissible. He said, "It is better for you to release sperms inside." Sahih al-Bukhari 2542
Jazak Allah Khair for the video. I was wondering if it's possible to please make a video on the reason why our pants should be above our ankles and if it's considered a major sin in a society where many people wear pants below their ankles, and the reason why that is the case is not due to pride but some other reason. I apologize if this isn't the appropriate place to ask but I wasn't sure where else to ask. I know Zakir Naik has recently made a video about this but his video was mainly explaining the views of the different schools of thought if I'm not mistaken.
these people have presented it in a wrong way this advice was not for everyone but for that very specific group of people who were hypocrites. Muhammad ﷺ knew they would turn out to be betrayers and would murder loot and plunder. This guy hasent mentioned what happened next. They murdered looted betrayed and ran away. Later on they were given death punishment with hot iron rods put in their eyes.
We captured some of the women as prisoners, and the long separation from our wives was pressing us hard and we wanted to release sperms outside of the women (coitus interruptus). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) whether it was permissible. He said, "It is better for you to release sperms inside." Sahih al-Bukhari 2542
Listen to this if you want but I strongly suggest to do some personal research for your self urine Carry lots of bacteria you drink urine might end up with a urinary tract infection or 🐪 pox camel pox
I’m just speculating at this point but I know from the hadith the prophet later fought against those people because they rebelled against him. Maybe god told him to tell them to go drink urine as a punishment or a test for them?
Alot of us are missing some knowledge here about this Camel urine. This is just only one hadith reported. it contradicts with Quran 7:157 (that Prophet SAW orders you of which is good and forbid which is evil), Science (it caused MERS-cov virus with 35% death rate) as well as Sahih bukhari itself (Sahih Bukhari 3018) the whole story is actually different. they were hypocrites and drank camel urine n milk by themselves while Prophet SAW just ordered to go to a herd of camel to get the milk (just the milk not urine). do check the hadith please Arabic word by word, They even killed the guide of the camels, Prophet SAW caught them and left them stranded n they died there while no one helped them. check Sahih Bukhari 3018 Arabic word by word. now both hadith contradict themselves, having both in Sahih Bukhari. but when we check the Matn we can clearly say that drinking urine isn't supported by Quran, Science and Hadith itself, instead it goes against as mention. Let me tell Actually how the Hadith is Verified. Actually, all the hadith, even traditionally, they are verified by 2 factors, by sanAd (authenticity of narration) and Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). Nowadays a lot of people are just checking the sanad (authenticity of narration), and starts believing it blindly. not even having a glimpse at Matn (if it goes with Quran, Logic, Text and etc). saying it cant be wrong since it is in Sahih Bukhari Book. there was a lot of narration which was after 800years, many years later or even recently got refused, because now based on knowledge we can say that there is now an error either in sanad or that it doesn't goes with matn. and sometimes the narrator or the collector of Hadith can make mistake. so why can't this narration too while it goes completely against everything, including Sahih bukhari itself. we must verify the Ahadith since its collection was started after about 200 years of Prophet SAW passing away. Allah ordered us to Follow Allah and The Prophet (4:59) so we must follow the hadith of Prophet SAW but it is necessary to verify the hadith and follow what is Actually the saying of him. So Please do your research and do check the Codes I quoted.
76 Medicine (6)Chapter: To treat with the urine of camels(6)باب الدَّوَاءِ بِأَبْوَالِ الإِبِلِ Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 Narrated Anas: The climate of Medina did not suit some people, so the Prophet (ﷺ) ordered them to follow his shepherd, i.e. his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they followed the shepherd that is the camels and drank their milk and urine till their bodies became healthy. Then they killed the shepherd and drove away the camels. When the news reached the Prophet (ﷺ) he sent some people in their pursuit. When they were brought, he cut their hands and feet and their eyes were branded with heated pieces of iron. حَدَّثَنَا مُوسَى بْنُ إِسْمَاعِيلَ، حَدَّثَنَا هَمَّامٌ، عَنْ قَتَادَةَ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ ـ رضى الله عنه ـ أَنَّ نَاسًا، اجْتَوَوْا فِي الْمَدِينَةِ فَأَمَرَهُمُ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَنْ يَلْحَقُوا بِرَاعِيهِ ـ يَعْنِي الإِبِلَ ـ فَيَشْرَبُوا مِنْ أَلْبَانِهَا وَأَبْوَالِهَا، فَلَحِقُوا بِرَاعِيهِ فَشَرِبُوا مِنْ أَلْبَانِهَا وَأَبْوَالِهَا، حَتَّى صَلَحَتْ أَبْدَانُهُمْ فَقَتَلُوا الرَّاعِيَ وَسَاقُوا الإِبِلَ، فَبَلَغَ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم فَبَعَثَ فِي طَلَبِهِمْ، فَجِيءَ بِهِمْ فَقَطَعَ أَيْدِيَهُمْ وَأَرْجُلَهُمْ، وَسَمَرَ أَعْيُنَهُمْ. قَالَ قَتَادَةُ فَحَدَّثَنِي مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سِيرِينَ أَنَّ ذَلِكَ كَانَ قَبْلَ أَنْ تَنْزِلَ الْحُدُودُ. Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 In-book reference : Book 76, Hadith 9 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 71, Hadith 590 If mental gymnastics was an Olympic Sport I’ve got to give it to you Mr Hijab you’ll be who I’d back for a gold medal 🥇. Congratulations Sir 👏🏾
Nice!! even bukhari and shahih contains concoctions. So how many of hadees are their which can be considers as authentic and how much of laws you can deduce from such literature mixed with sporadic stories and deeds of prophet? You're so ashamed of Islamic texts that now you are compelled to excise all the embarrassment recorded in hadees making it a pamphlet.
The effort for approving drinking camel urine LOL . With that logic you can say most of the hadiths were situational yet muslims source their religion from those.
