Southern parties raise fears on likely expansion of LS, loss in seats & gain for Hindi heartland 

At 7:25 Shekhar says 2%. It is not 2%. It is 2 babies per woman.

Have lot of respect for Shekar sir watching him since childhood. But as a millennial it feels so slow and boring compared to other informative video channels. I suggest more animation, faster narration, pictures, video references. All the best!!! ❣❣❣

but again that will not be the solution as the population will still be more in purvanchal region. More people =more seats =more MPs. As India follow this system only . What people ignore is that the state of UP and Bihar have historically more population because of large fertile land . As in past people tend to have only some basic necessities like food housing and clothes so river banks provided very suitable position for civilizations to grow. That's why it was natural for those states to have more population. Infact this is the story of every country whether it is United States or china or Russia. But big population doesn't mean good only . As more people means government have to spend more on insuring good livelihood to them . More competition in home market etc . Moreover southern states have rich coastline too so they generate more money as our bulk of import and export it carried through this States. So will it not be good if those states will share Monet with other states too ?? Should the northern states be punished for having rich and fertile land ?? Remember India is not china here you can't force people to produce less children. It can only be reduced by providing people with education and contraceptives . But as I said earlier for this States the sources of income is limited as most of them are landlocked ( big industries prefer location close to seas for export means) . This complexities may have been the reasons why pm Indira Gandhi and Atal have not touched this issue . And this will be an 'Agnipath ' for anyone who would choose to do it.

It is better to divide the most populous Uttar Pradesh states into many small states than to raise the Lok Sabha seats in the states. When the Uttar Pradesh state are divided, the population is also divided, so there is no need for more MPs due to less population in the divided states. Development of the state is more important than more MPs.

When north Indians breed like pigs, why south should suffer? The cunning fox BJP knows very well that they cannot win in southern states , so they want to create more seats in North based on population and reduce the seats in southern states. So without Southern states help BJP wants to capture power in central.

😂😂

😂😅🤣

Good one

Really good one mate.

Good analogy

Southern states can integrate northerners. Biharis in TN speak better Tamil than native Tamilians

World is facing a population collapse. Which is not a good thing btw. India hasn't Industrialized yet. Population is not a problem for us atleast until we Industrialize. Imagine a third world country going below replacement ratio. Southern India is not Europe, it still looks like a third world.

@@ankitapattanaik6059 Don't copy paste Elon Musk. Western world is facing population collapse, not India.

@@ankitapattanaik6059 Madam open your eyes...population collapse is not India's problem, India's problem right now is population explosion...

@@ashishsunny7963 Are you stupid? Expect for UP and Bihar, almost all states are below 2 tfr. Karnataka is 1.6 I guess. Which is not at all good. State wise dekhoge to real picture dikhega. Aur ek chiz India abhi bhi ek third world country hi hai. Excess population can be used to Industrialize India and build infrastructures. Population decline will be disastrous for India right now. Ek to gareeb mulk aur population bhi collapse ho gayi to India kabhi bhi Industrialize nahi kar paega.

Thank you! Granting more power to UP and Bihar will not change the conditions of the state but only land more money in the pockets of the corrupt politicians running it.

And Muslims should be given Half votes bkz more Population increase

@@ManishSingh-ge1lx xD you just keep dropping bombs everywhere in this video

Same Bihari here , although I dont think future govts would be stupid to decide the no. seats based on population, it would be a disaster.

problem is the lack of proper education. Bihar ranks low in education. Educated people would know to have just 2 kids or start using condoms or other contraceptives for casual $ex

there is no regional consciousness in the ganga basin. It's just caste and country. I'm also a UP wala. Imagine living in a state called "Northern State", like hello, where is our identity?

@@arjavgarg5801 eroded by both our governments and colonialism our classical languages have the status of dehati basha 🙄

@@intredacteddataexpunged9572 Tru h bhai, lekin it's not like the people themselves who speak these languages care about it. They all just go with "it's all Hindi". When will we have Renaissance in the Ganga basin, only God knows. Hindi k 14 to maximum udhar hi milte hain aakhir. Kabir k dohe ghanta hindi hain, kuchh samajh nahi aate.

Bro true, I see jats of West UP getting angry when they are clubbed with stereotypical UP- Bihar gang.

@@sam25332 hey dude Wtf is stereotypical up bihar gang 😐

Not really. It is a mischaracterization that population controlled states are responsible while others are not. Kerala sends much of its brain power overseas while they should send its educated brain power to other parts of india. I can call this action of Kerala also very irresponsible where their population cares for their personal growth but don't want to share their education with other backward areas of India

@@sachin265 do you realise that education is not free . people take loans work part time. They get degrees after their parents sell their home to provide fees .if a Kerala man go to Bihar and UP for job what he will get? How he will be able to lift their family how will repay loan from a low salery available in an over populated country. If you see the income gap between poor and rich in our country it is increasing fast .more the population , rich are becoming richer . while the average salery of majority is not increasing according to inflation as unemployed are desperate to do job for any salery .This is a fact . Living standard (quality) cannot be achieved if country keep on increasing in quantity . Kerala people go abroad send valuable dollar back to india. that is what every over populated developing country desperately needed. If a state keep pumping population , living standard of the country won't change. Infact it will stagnate infrastructure. Just watch Mumbai local train videos. Just see the Rise in pollution of metro cities including capital Delhi. Yes , over pop.states are responsible for many problems.

@7 years and those problems can then br curbed by having more representatives in the Parliament as most central funding would go in developing those underdeveloped infrastructure. Don't complain then that South India will have lower representatives in the new Lok Sabha. Keep sending your brain power outside India for person gain and foreign exchange that only goes to Kerala and develops Kerala and does nothing for the rest of India. So far as what an educated Keralite can do in UP is for their entrepreneurs to open up a factory or a business in UP or Bihar. They can hire management from Kerala while workers can be sourced locally. They can boost the local economy and add a blend to the local culture. It will benefit everyone. Nurses are sent in 1000s to Middle East from Kerala, they take up govt jobs and in 3 months are entitled to take bank loans which pay off all debts of their parents in Kerala, they pay these loans off in 3 to 5 years in the Middle Eastern country. Send these qualified nurses to other states of India where they are needed but NO they are all greedy looking for Dirhams, Dinars and Riyals. Don't sing the National song of unity when it suits you and be greedy behind the scenes when it doesn't.

@@sachin265 the ppl going abroad funds the govt by sending back 25 percent of the state GDP .so shut up and sit down

@@sachin265 ur talking absolute nonsense..how's sending ppl abroad got to do with delimitation?they include the people sent outside ..it's the total birth rate that's counted and the people living in there ..Kerala sends the same number of ppl if not less than what numbers of gujjus goes to America ..have some educated comments to say .please .with each comment ur showing ur moronic upbringing againa dn again

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

@@user-gy4gk5pr1g oh you're sharing your great wisdom here too

@@intredacteddataexpunged9572 stop poking around then.

@@user-gy4gk5pr1g na some comments are actually worth reading through over here

@@user-gy4gk5pr1g then will haryana be equal to UP or maha

Agree they have negligible seats like 1 or 2

True , they need more representation that any part of india

The logic of proportionate representation can not be compromised otherwise it is not democractic

@@alphacompany4837 because they have negligible population

@@VikasKumar-iq8df proportional representation must not be Narrowedly confined to population.

minuscule.

😂 produce the data... Let's see the ratio of Indians letting go of their citizenship in southern states to thier population.. "huge migration" it seems 🤦‍♂️ do ur divide & rule politics elsewhere 👍

@@kalebj7001 what do you mean by produce the data ? The Central govt has not initiated the Census process. And Census is the only way to get the data you are asking for. So, tweet to the PM and HM, or PIL in the SC asking for the data you want.

@@kalebj7001 yes,a huge population from southern states have immigrated to the Gulf to live as modern day slaves

@@abhigyanutsav9651 I find it absolutely laughable when people make such claims. India doesn't allow dual citizenship, that's why people leave their citizenship. Do u know Owner of Lulu group ? He is from kerala. But he is a billionares who operates lulu chain in middle east. A lot of people leave for Dubai due to business.

They can never learn anything....as long as they are obsessed with Hindi.

​@@krisgray1957 Lol, rice bag

If not for South India, North India look like Afghanistan.

@@adghat7819 you have said that like a fool visit haryana himachal or Punjab or Jammu or ladakh to find out if that is true or not

@@amanjha2144 Mostly the hindi heartland that is unproductive.

Will ambani get 1000000 Votes ? Mumbai Pune thane 3 District hold 54% Gdp of Maharashtra Should they have 26 out of 48 Seats of Maharashtra

@Manish Singh U can't understand the meaning of weighted average right?

@@ManishSingh-ge1lx why are you so triggered bro? He is just suggesting a way according to his opinion so that unfairness will not prevail. He didn't mention ambani or any cities. FYI cities all over the world are drivers of economic growth because cities are where majority of economic activity and people that facillitates them live. This is not just case of Maharashtra but all over the world that's why you see richer countries have high urbanisation rate and poorer countries have less urbanisation.

@@iip8948 So, the idea basically becomes, that the well-off people will have all the power. Socialism has gone for a toss in this idea.

It seems to be a well-intentioned idea (in theory), and one could also think of adding more social indicators to it to make it more inclusive. But the weights for those weighted average might get manipulated and hence the process might become controversial. Wonder how it can be implemented!

UP Bihar Rajasthan Assam Odisha West Bengal Madhya Pradesh will make the country burn then

Very well said

hahahahhahahahahhahahaha maharastra gujarat karnataka and tamil nadu

@@_kartik_chauhan then when Uttar Pradesh gdp starts increasing, then these same people will say that 8t should be done on per capitastate GDP. They dont want fair assessment, they will distort statistics any way they want to maintain their political power with zero regard to fundamental principles of democracy.

@@_kartik_chauhan West Bengal and Kerala will lose seats if it's done either by population or GDP metric

even punjab,gujarat all have gone down

Which south india ? Swines were 20% in Kerala Now they are 30%

@@ManishSingh-ge1lx What swines, The same Swines to whom Rajputs were giving their Daughters ????

​@@ManishSingh-ge1lx 😂akbar had 350 north royal wives😂😂

@Kraken Thunder north 90 percent no education and 80 percent poor.

Best solution

Very bad idea, US has this and its a mess more than anything.

​@@avishjha4030 defense must be with States. USA states enjoy great freedom.

Imagine treating your countrymen from the north as second class citizens, making their votes count less just to shore up political clout and continue surviving in your own regional political bastions - so much for people that cry "democracy is under threat" every month...

@@surajs5913 Imagine being called less nationalist, because you don't follow the politics of your brother's state or your brother's language. Imagine losing your voice in your family because you used birth control measures while your brother was competing to produce more kids and in the end want greater say in the famiy mattrs because he has greater no. of kids...

@@ashishsunny7963 imagine treating your brother as less of a human being because of your own hunger for power. Imagine treating his children as strangers instead of treating them as your own. Imagine being so greedy and narrowminded that you dot trat your brother as a brother and instead call names instead of having a conversation with him or even try to understand his realities and difficulties. Imagine instead that you just look after yourself and tell everyone else that your brother can suffer...

@@ashishsunny7963 who lost voice?? These regional parties would never pitch their voice for national level. Coz it's always regional. I live in tamilnadu. For every other issue, they make dravidasthaan as alternative. Even now. They call all B.C, M.B.C and S.C , S.T' s as sons/ daughters of prostitues until they be in Hindu category. You wouldn't have heard that speeches . They never went for national level poltics. What they need is few seats in parliament, few ministries, so they can fill their binamies.

Exactly.., this is ridiculous. Communist form here.., your income is our income

Hindi is and will remain the National language no matter what constitution says in which this point was written just to maintain peace.

@@sachin265 hindi will remain a North Indian subhuman language

@@harieeshrakhavandaran why the audacity and air of superiority? have you any other optiion other than to breathe air, drink water, eat food and provide for your family like other decent Hindi-speaking people? any minority in India whether religion or language have co-existed very well and will do so in the future too. what makes you human and others subhuman? What in Zomato's name is this sublevel mentality?

​@@sachin265 Hindi is not a national language. It's one of the official language. North Indian, Hindi speakers must know that India is more than Hindi belt.

@@mangoesboy It is actually. Anyone in India gets National recognition only when they starts dealing with Hindi speaking population. I can give you 30 examples! :)

why not just multiply the Lok Sabha seats by a factor of 2. Everyone should be happy as the proportion will stay intact, but will also increase peoples representation.

For assembly seats it is not much required but should be done periodically. But for LS is very much required and of urgent need bcoz there is lot of disproportionate representation.

lets do delimitation by economy of each state so people who contribute more has more power to represent and create a healthy competition among states if POWER is the only goal for all parties.

@@gatech5190 mumbai, Delhi, goa would have more seats then the rest. Concerns of rich metro citizens aren't remotely the same as rest of country.

@@berserkhorimiya Then that's how these poor states would try to build their economy to have any power otherwise breeding like dogs doesn't mean you can control entire country.

South India is getting punished for taking development seriously while BIMARU states get freebies for being dumb. What kind of logic is this?

@@TheRishijoesanuwelcome do hindutva side replace South with hindu bimaru with sharia

@@TheRishijoesanu it hasnt been implemented and u are already claiming being punished. I dont want it to be implemented at all but claiming you hv already been punished is just stupid

Unity is strength.. this anti Indian channel doesn't make any sensible news

@sheebaradhakrishnangr India is built on the principle 'Unity in Diversity'. The more diverse people are the more strong the nation becomes. Splitting states into multiple states makes it better for governance and to prosper in human indices. A healthy nation is built upon citizens with a healthy body and mind.

@@sheebaradhakrishnangr Typical gavar andhbhakt

@@santhbalak9086 more states, more governance, more elections, more money required, so more tax. People suffers at the end.

@@mousuminag344 bastard sanghi. When modi spent 50 thousand crores for demonitization. But he ultimately failure and our tax money was was te d. Sanghi thevudia pasanga don't have rights to speak on unity and tax money of people

All because of lalu and nitish they're playing a political seasaw with the cm berth since the 80s and its like LPG reforms never reached Bihar. Both lalu nitish preach socialism brainwashing people like soviet union but without the iron curtain

Agree. Bihar and Jharkhand are tragic stories.

Blame Biharis for electing such clowns

@@ramk2443 bjp is the only hope now fr bihar

@@get2viveksingh also Biharis and people from Jharkhand are the worst migrant workers you'll encounter in Southern states. Pretty much all of them are criminals in disguise

Dear Sunit, Thank you for watching..shekhar

Should voting rights be conferred on the basis of family income, fertility rate, education, etc. also?

@@tushargoyal554 yeah tell me how many brothers and sisters modu have ???

@@tushargoyal554 how is voting impartial if one part's vote is worth more than the other in the same country? If there's inequality somewhere equality is not the solution but equity and justice are.

@@opai1821 Ask him

@@sravaniyadavalli1359 Equity is a bogus concept that prefers favoritism

He is doing better than godi media.

@@balajeemettle better than your Pappu media

@@sunlight2078 go and watch Modi's paltu kutaa GOOswamy

Does SG need to cover South India? He is here to cover national politics and not regional ones

@@fileload9806 I pity your stupidity - i am a South Indian!

It's also important to mention this puritan form of federalism is unique to USA due to their history of conquest. It was kept that way to make sure local white colonisers got to keep their unique social orthodoxy in power. This is why they vote for their governors, have their own supreme court and own legal code.

USA is a divisible federation of indivisible states while India is a indivisible Union of divisible states. The logic aplied in USA is flawed and does not reflect the fundamental principle of universal sufferage - that every citizen's vote should count equally. The interests of regional parties do not supercede the fundamental principles of Indian democracy.

That is for the Senate which is the equivalent of the Rajya Sabha. The House of Representatives which has representation proportional to the population, is the equivalent of our Lok Sabha. In the Indian system, the Lok Sabha has more weight (eg. finance bills, etc.) than the Rajya Sabha. In India, unlike the Senate, the Rajya Sabha also has seats per state proportional to the population of the state.

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state to live, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

@@user-gy4gk5pr1g so UP has same amount of vote as goa? Are citizens of UP second class citizens that their vote counta for less in national level? And what if tomorrow the center decides to divide UP and MP into many more states for ease of administration? Wont you protest even then? This is not about fairness but about maintaining political clout in a ever changing world, because south parties can neither appeal to voters in other states with their exclusive regional ideologies, nor do they want to integrate people from other states into their states out of fear of loss of political power. This debate is not about reward vs punishment, but about maintaining the current status quo to retain what little political power they have left through divisive narrativez.

Karnataka doesnt represent all of the south. TN is far more urbanized

I agree Rohan, but Bangalore urban district has 7 assembly constituencies to represent the city. It is different thing that those MLAs do nothing about the city

nice this could be done

That will not be accurate, since one mp will be allotted a huge population. Instead the better performing states should be given additional votes to the MPs.

And Muslims Should be restricted at 11% Votes as per 1971 They should not be given 15.4% Votes as of today For that We make a rule that 50+ age Muslims can't vote

Nope. This will lead to more problems. Earlier most of the South states were under Madras. Later due to linguistic movements, separate states were created. That led to protection of culture and linguistic identity of the newly formed states. Your idea will lead to merger of states, that will trigger mass protests.

@@user-ul1zz4cw2b each mp will get less people than current.

Adani doesn't want it to happen just like he purchased NDTV to expel Ravish Ji.

Covid is the reason

கநிமொழி

@@mangai3599 கனிமொழி

It is better to divide the most populous Uttar Pradesh states into many small states than to raise the Lok Sabha seats in the states. When Uttar Pradesh is divided into many smaller states, the population is also divided, so there is no need for more MPs due to less population in the divided states. Development of the state is more important than more MPs.

Better call her as 2 G corrupt queen.

Very important for future of ppl 😛

It's as simple as the rich people pay more tax which is then used for development of poor people.

🗿haha so that kelra and tamilnadu would have run their conversion machine freely?

Very well put. The south sends way too much money to the centre and gets very little back and most of it is sent to the northern states. Even the vat system is not great for the southern states. Increasing their governments power to keep and spend their money is definitely an improvement. Secondly, I also think we should rethink the way the RS is organised. Improving the power share of the southern states there (also having money bills passed through RS) will improve the situation. Giving way too much money to the poorly performing states and then handing them the greater power is simply untenable and will lead to poor management of the Union government

@@Haxerous Brother even gujrat, maharastra, haryana sends more money than they receive

@@balajeepratham8200 the context of the video is talking about BIMARU Vs South Indian states, hence my focus there. I know MH and GJ send more money than they received. And I equally support them if they are unjustly losing power in the parliament. However the case for say TN will be more extreme than that of GJ for example.

@@Haxerous No brother. Gujarat's birth rate is also below replacement level. Brother, I totally understand tamil's concern and I oppose this idea as well. So don't worry, even north Indians oppose these ideas.

I think you have angered both North Indians and dravidians with good content 😅😅😂😂 lesser reservation? Lol

Journalist informs, governments reform. This episode has done its job…

This guy really is high on shit 😂😂😂. Punjab's per capita income is 214k which is rising and rising . India's per capita is 201k . Punjab is still higher than national average . When it comes to poverty and other social indicators it even betters itself more . It has almost around 5% poverty comapred to avg of 25% in india . It's definitely way better than up whose stats are like a war infested African country . It's per capita is 81,000. Lowest just above Bihar . it has 37.79% poverty it has the worst healthcare and education system in the country . Tell your bjp local leader to try some new propoganda because no one is gonna beleive that up is not bimaru while Punjab is . Literally it's called the ram rajya but lower caste Hindus face the most violence and discrimination their . 😂😂

Anti national bc tere Bihar se jyada recruitment hai Punjab se army mein

Bimaru state always takes India behind

175000 is still greater than 90000,Use your gray matter every once in a while

South India is getting punished for taking development seriously while BIMARU states get freebies for being dumb. What kind of logic is this?

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

@THE ZOLDICS that's thanks to the developed states that compensate. BIMARU states are taking advantage of being non-performant. Just be honest with yourself and admit you want the Hindi Belt to step over the developed states and control the Centre. Squeeze every single Rupee out of them while you can.

@@yomamasohot6411 bro I think we should wait until every states fertility rate go below 2 and after that 20 years we should expand our parliament seats

@THE ZOLDICS you realise that even at fertility rate 2.1 there will still be large growth for decades before growth stops, because the number of births is still more than the number of deaths?

Easier said than done, all those things will take a generation to come into fruition, that is assuming all the subsequent governments commit to the cause. But ofcourse, it doesn't mean they should not stop trying atleast.

separate south india from north

If it was North centric we would be more developed than south 🙄🙄

@ Bharat Not at all, Unlike USSR not one indian state has the right to leave the Republic of India . It will be civil war if a state decided to leave the republic

@@sunlight2078 Northern are underdeveloped due to its own incompetent leadership and intellectually-illiterate people. The growth rate of northern India has been eaten by the huge population growth there. Non productive expenses to run the northern states are quite high as compared to others like security costs.

​@@sunlight2078You get more funding than the south .It is your problem if you cannot do anything with that fund.

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

@THE ZOLDICS you can lie to people outside the state all you want but not to people living in the state. I have seen what your Yogi govt has done and it is still an embarrassment, to say the least.

@@yomamasohot6411 yes what have yogi done can you point out his mistakes? But I can point out his development work. You don't even know how many infrastructure projects are going on in UP. So keep quiet or come with data, stupid

@@user-gy4gk5pr1g stfu spamming the same dim-witted idea won't make it good.

I think not just with up and bihar , every large state should be divided into 2-4states , tamil Nadu can be divided into 3 parts , maharashtra can be divided into 5 parts , up can be dived into 6 parts . I recommend you, you should read gautam desiraju book on india 2.o. it was very fun and interesting to read, he suggests india should have more small states.

Bihari and UPwalas now make 10-15% of Punjab and Haryana population It's problem in North western states too

Look at US seanate election

They will have Senate which is fixed 2 per state and Senate objectively has a lot more power than House of representatives. Senate might not make new laws but it has a veto on their approval, foreign policy, defense etc. Plus American states have a lot more power than Indian states. Control of police is the only major hard power state govts in india have.

@@siddharthgoyal4008 Actually US political system is a mess and it is half baked. That's why it would lead to frequent lockouts and disagreements between president and their congress. They cannot carry out their policies properly. It would be a mess in India.

If this keeps increasing,we must start demanding separate nation .

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

Divide Kalu states into smaller ones

@@sunlight2078 up bihar are kalu states.

@@shubhamsharma8867 your muthar is from the Kalu South

​@@shubhamsharma8867mazak udaoge to mazak udega

May be you should talk less and listen more. Shekhar has in fact addressed the very same issue in the past, making more or less the same argument that population explosion is a major problem and the biggest hurdle to India's plans for development. This was a different issue, which didn't need a mention of the Muslim/Non-Muslim divide in the analysis. I hope you know that there are more Muslims in the North than in the South.

You might want to check the census for the break up of Hindu-Muslim in Bimaru states before saying stuff like this...

Area hahahhahaha Ladakh gets 11 Loksbaha Arunachal gets 19 Loksbaha Kerala gets 7 Loksbaha

There is no concrete answer

You guys should focus on your homework rather than finding answers to issues after watching a 20min bite size explanation video

Based on area is the stupidest idea ever.

@@ManishSingh-ge1lx All that desert area in Rajasthan will give it so many seats

Thats Why Raja Secaratery Of DMK Before CM Demanded State Autonomy For TN

Southern states just fooled and looted India by opposing and forcing centre to put all the projects in Southern state during 70, 80 , 90s. Because of which northern states got the problem of naxalism.

What is your view on Swines ? Who were 9% in 1947 and 15% Now Should their voteshare be reduced at 9% or They ask another pakistan in few decades ?

@@rajveerkumar642 lol, what are you blabbering. Use facts before commenting . Most of the IITs are still in North India , so does PSUs .. Southern states developed due to good governance and population control unlike Northern states

So basically you started degrading the peoe of north India by calling them bimaru and now you want to make their votes count less than that of a person from south India too? Wow! And i am sure you will portray yourself as some great defender of the constitution tomorrow despite being fundamentally opposed to the idea that all citizens of India are equal and paticipate with true equality in the democratic process of the nation...

@@surajs5913 no no bimaru is like the acronym right?

or we should keep the same weightage like up have 15%,bengal have 8%, kerala have 3.5% seats so this percentage should be maintained in the new setup

Thanks for being there..shekhar

Why increase only for 'big' states (I.e. bimaru states)? That's the issue- giving bigger hindi heartland states more representation is drowning out the voices of smaller states who also incidentally have their population under control. The best option is for the south to secede. We are gaining nothing from being part of this federation of hindi speaking states of mostly poor & illiterate people obsessed with religion.

@@manunair5881 Bigger states are states except north eastern states (except Assam) and Goa. The smaller states have only 1-2 seats in Lok Sabha, so you can increase by 1 or 2 seats. Regarding seceding, it will be easier for you to secede personally from India. Since you have the tail of 'nair' probably Pakistan or China may be interested in you. 😀😎😛😁🤣😜

​@@praveenpchandran China wants only Himalayas.

You mean Number of MP with criminal background .? . when a honest Singapore P.M talked about this in their parliament which resulted in India government getting angry , instead of fixing .

He is not a professor lol

I would say south states are real bimaru. They have bimari called xenophobia. Like rajsthan doesn't even speak hindi, neither does bihar. But but why will you be logical? You just don't want people from your country to work in your state? I mean what logic is this? From your logic shouldn't USA and Europe and middle East ban indian immigrants? Who told you what is bimaru and what not? UP's gdp growth is 12% 3rd highest in india, rajsthan's gdp growth rate is 9%.

Dude. Don't include Kerala in this analysis. Without the Indian state - for it's Fiscal deficits & lack of Industry it will go down like Sri Lanka.

@@preshant91 Kerala and Andhra Pradesh both are bankrupt.. Also these southern states got help from the Freight Equalization Policy of Nehru and States like Jharkhand and Bihar suffered....

@@thedn3164 they are called bimaru for a reason. Poverty, caste fight , Landlords raping girls in Fortuner Cars,etc . But you being a 82 IQ pajeet will not think logically and think emotionally

Separate country is wet dreams. If they were countries they already destroyed each other for resources and water. Example is water and land disputes between states.

Weighted system like the British India when Hindus despite having large population didn't have equal representation?

Stfu Modi's Gujarat is better than your worthless state

@@sunlight2078 You aren't even an Indian if you talk like that.

@@balajeepratham8200 what a hypocrite. Now you are dictating who is Indian

It is better to divide the most populous Uttar Pradesh states into many small states than to raise the Lok Sabha seats in the states. When Uttar Pradesh is divided into many smaller states, the population is also divided, so there is no need for more MPs due to less population in the divided states. Development of the state is more important than more MPs.

So can we reallocate the number of increase in seats in states where they have crossed the 2.1 mark to those who are below as a punishment?

@@sarangakarte9168 It's not a crime to have more than 2 kids, if it's not a crime, there is no point punishing someone who hasn't committed a crime.

@@sarangakarte9168 oh ok I should have my value as a citizen of this country be less than what a south indian has because of actions that weren't even in my control

@@ReligioCritic ohh sorry my mistake 😅 ,i get it. But we should award some seats in South Indian/ better states in replacement rate so they don't feel punished for doing right.

@@intredacteddataexpunged9572 you shouldn't have a less value but you shouldn't get undue advantage also because of your environment.

South India is getting punished for taking development seriously while BIMARU states get freebies for being dumb. What kind of logic is this?

*It's simple* . Delimit the parliament, BUT: 1 state = 1 vote All the members of a state vote for what the vote should be for their own state. Then it won't matter how cramped you make your own state, you still get 1 vote for national issues.

@@TheRishijoesanu It won't. My god, even gujrat will be punished. Modi's home state is gujarat. So wait

This option is worth pondering

Lol the senate is anti democratic last 5 Republican presidents never won a majority in the popular vote but still won

@@bloodwargaming3662 US Senate (upper house of the Congress) has 100 members where each state (irrespective of the size / population) sends two members. The House of representatives (lower house) has representation based on population and state may get more or less seats depending on population inflow or outflow. Your comment is related to US president election.

@@abhijitdeshmukh6902 i commented about that only

Why do you think hindi is pushed via backdoors...simple, so that it becomes easy for jobless youth in BIMARUS to migrate to non hindi states...

@@karthekeyanperiyasamy3093 like it or not English is ligua franca of the world unlike Hindi

Im from Punjab and don’t know what you people keep talking about

@@karthekeyanperiyasamy3093 In which language do you think German, French write the code and publish research papers . Let's even leave that aside , even Hindi is a combination of Urdu/Persian (another invader language FYI) with Sanskrit. It's way better to learn English than Hindi.

@@aravindc102hindhi will survive english best of luck to others.