"The Dating Game" | CreepyPasta Storytime 

Am i the only one who has read/listened to sooo many pastas that you don't get scared whatsoever by them anymore?

You know what I wish? If MrCreepypasta had a mini series called MrCreepybooze where he would get extremely drunk and read famous Creepypastas like Jeff the Killer or Smile.JPG. It would be like "And then they lit his *hic* lit his face on fire. But it was not jeff, it was DEADPOOL! THEY CAN'T MESS WITH DEADPOOL!" Please, make that a thing MCP!

13:20 "...a metallic rope..." Y'know, a chain.

I remember how much I dislike the protagonist of this creepypasta

Happy Valentine's Day. Do any of you wanna be my valentine? *psycho lady voice* I promise I'm safe to keep around.

I honestly don't like this one. It has an interesting set up, but it's ruined by divulging into pointless gore-porn. Also, the "twist ending" just makes the protagonist out to be the world's biggest idiot. Get a clue, dude.

I love MCP's reaction there xD "giving up a cute girl for Facebook?"

Makes 6 figures at Burger King, creator was on crack making this.

Entering myself into the moment he's watching that last video, I would look at her with a big smile, "all this time, I thought I had to hide who I was from you, but we're the same!" then hug her. And then body slam her, kick her while she was down and nope the fuck out.

when they brought a baby into this... "hell naw to the naw, naw naw"

This was one of the first pastas I ever listened to on your channel back when I first discovered you. Glad to see it come back and be redone. Well done MCP

Dude you add so much emotion to these stories I love it

This was...really dumb. I have never had a problem with suspension of disbelief at all - in fact, superhero stories and the like are some of my favourite pieces of fiction - but this was just...really over the top. I mean, even forgiving the plot holes and the stupidity of the protagonist, and even the unbelievable ending, the story is simply not scary. The violence gets so over-the-top as to cross into the realm of black comedy, and the aforementioned plot holes and poor writing just compound the problem and bring everything down. The story had potential in the beginning, but took - in my opinion - entirely the wrong direction and ended in a disappointing "payoff". Now, this should by no measure be taken as a criticism against MCP or his narrative abilities; the story, for what it is, was told extremely well. MCP is and always has been a marvellous, entertaining reader whose videos are some of my favourites on RU-vid, this is simply not one of my favourite stories that he has chosen. All of that said, I am sure others thoroughly enjoyed the story, and I am glad there is such a variety of content available to us from this talented content creator. TL;DR: loved the narration, hated the story.

I'm sorry, but this story can't hold up in an era where "scary TRUE" and "let's not meet" stories are dominating the community. The protagonist is a douche, the "horror" comes from over the top descriptions of gore and the addition of children and she went Jeff the Killer in the end with her surviving 2 executions. Also, instead of us shocked that the protagonist fell into the same fate again like it happened in "the strangest security tape I've ever seen", I am certain that most of the readers would facepalm at his stupidity.

Thanks for redoing this one, it's a favorite of mine. 👍☺

I missed this story creeps. Thanks for remaking this mate. Damn good narration.

As a mom of an almost 8yr old....this made me shudder. the newborn..... omg. Its hard to get me to squirm, but this? this did it.

"I knew you'd find the key to the basment." I instantly go 0_0 "Sie sind das essen und wir sind die Jager! The basment"

The original video of this creepypasta is the first one I ever saw, and the first I had ever heard of them. It's what got me to start watching and reading them. Thank you very much. You are very talented.

AWESOME! This was creepy! Can't wait for the next one! ^^

"I've been single for a while" Join the club.

YES REBOOT OF ONE OF MY FAVORITE STORIES

classic! I remember this was one of the first videos I watched of mrcreepypasta I'm glad it got a hd remake!

Jesus Christ, that had to be the most fucked up story I ever heard and I've heard some doozies! Great readings though Mr and Mrs Pastas! I'm a big fan of both of you :)

Yeah! MrCreepyPasta, maybe you'll consolidate our sad loneliness this time of year...*Listens to pasta*. Annnnd that's why I'm single.

I specifically remember watching this the first day it was posted! Memories!

congrats on 1,000,000 subs 🙌👏🎉

reading some old stories. awesome I can get with this.

"This when things started to get dark" "She was wearing all black and she was giggling at my jokes" :| so either A you was making a really bad pun or it was dark because you actually made a girl giggle. XD

I would listen to this, but its 12:00 at night, and im the only one awake

Love this one! ❤️ made my valentines day!

Yay! I was waiting for the day this story would be reposted. I knew it was coming.

Wait... What? How is she back!?!? How does he NOT recognize her!?!?!?

this whole thing could've been avoided if he turned the computer back on

I like the first version you did of this. This second one is way more dramatic though. Props!!!

And kingspook too yall both have a voice and way of reading that draws a person into the story love u guys

"Disgusted by the company of my left hand" k

yay! (watches this before I go to bed) Bedtime story!

I knew I recognized this from your previous video's :D it's one of my favorites

😂HE SAID 2 RUNNING EGGS NAILED TO THE WALL, JESUS😂BBBBBEHAVE😂

I didn't notice the face and it scared me omg

(Useless story btw, but can be entertaining :3) So the funny thing is, during my years in high school. i was forced to to take an elective, even when i transferred to online classes. One of them was to make me a better person, i was recommended to take it all because my concealer said it would be an easy passable grade, and to be honest it was. The best part about this class was one of the last things i had to do was pick 10 stories and explain it it has some positive outcome from this list of words the teacher gave me, that was all forced to giving me to tell a nice story with flower and all the happy stuff... I took a challenge to use a creepypasta for every single one, and this story was my favorite one i told and somehow in the very end, i had some mythical magical outcome my teacher bought XD

Happy Valentine's day also great story! :D

o-o this was really good! i acctually broke into a cold sweat xD

didn't you do this one a few years back?

90 percent of Pornstars by name? Rookie Numbers.

this story actually scared me a bit.. GJ MR.PASTA!

So happy you re-did this one. The Dating Game was one of my favorites

psssh, still a better love story than twilight

Love me some yandere's.

I read this a few years ago, but you, sir, make it ten times more horrific. Kudos

"Tired of the comfort of my left hand..." XD

Succubus ????????

I remember this one... This is why I still don't date.

6:53 MCP, good delivery on that. I actually chuckled at the spaghetti-pockets-factor. Your choice of music is a bit "eh" though. I think you should've put something nicer in the background for at least the first 10 minutes. I mean, it's practically a romance story for most of the story xD

I have to admit.. Creepymissuspasta and Mrcreepypasta are my two favorite narrators, so to hear this is like listening to the voice of god!! you know in comparison to awesomeness!!

I liked the Michael Leroi version better

This is such an awful creepypasta. Not scary with one of the most loathsome protagonists in existance...like seriously? Likening your single status to a schizophrenic mental patient?? Jesus..

This was a great one

Great story! I havent listened to the original, but this is great!

Really? Two kids? Both with leukemia? Who would believe that at all?

sleep is for the weak

Love ur channel

wow this was brilliant

This is an old one.

What fucking fedora wrote thus?

Another awesome creep-pasta

This is a new favorite

Lol I read this story about a year ago.I love it.Always gives me chills

Well that was sick and twisted...nice👍🏻

I was listening to this while working on an essay and eating pizza. It ruined my meal and made me take a while to try to focus on my essay.

Falling asleep to these and having those ending sounds come on that get louder.....pure evil.

Oh god, I've seen MichaelLeroi read this. He is, THE BURGER KING!! 😆😂

thought this one sounded familiar...still good. cool to see it reread with more of your experience behind it. nice job.

love ur videos

I absolutely love this story? It was my favorite then and my favorite now.

I remember this story! It was one of my favorites :)

So I have an interview at a daycare tomorrow and for some reason when I heard the little babies death I teared up a bit . 17 years old and a man that's not afraid to admit I teared up ..

I love the way it sounds wen u tell these stories 😉

I remember this story. MrCreeps did it a couple years ago, and it's a classic in my opinion.

Awesome story

I love this video and it's awesome and you will learn how to love it if you don't hear the death and people screaming

One of my favorite stories! 😁

Oh, he redid this one. Very well done. It was actually better then the original.

man brings back memories

Amazing story.

Oh my god MCP your reading one of my favorite stories

Hey u redid it awesome job

I loved it!! I didn't have my phone with me sorry it took so long XD

Fuck. I'm sure most of us have heard this before. So excited! Classic MCP nostalgia

I honestly love this creepypasta and a new version of it I love voth version

violated me with the sharp end of a screwdriver.... sounds like a normal saturday for me

this is my favorite creepypasta

Brings back memories.

ahhh I remember this being one of the first long pastas I saw on this channel at the end of 2012

I love this

amazing video

"Disgusted with the company of my LEFT hand" ah a man of culture

This story is well narrated. Many many applauds , bravo

I actually screamed OMG I love this one