Tony Abbot is 100% correct with this - he comes across as a person putting a responsible view - which is just the opposite to the PM'S crying emotional attempt to gain a legacy for himself. VOTE NO
He's seen the parliament from inside, now he is seeing it from the outside. I like his reasoning on this. You might say he is using a little bit of lateral thinking.
There is no "responsible view"for Abott.He has always been a racist,sexist ,lgbt hating bigot who defends child abusers like George Pell. Abbott has no values except to "defend 'the faith" regardless!
The people questioning Abbott are so emotionally involved that they become stale structures of bias and hubris. When put against the decency and intellect of Abbott, those walls of bias are crumbled into the small pieces of substance they represent. No wonder Abbott was initially barred from speaking. They were afraid that his knowledge and experience would be hard to gang up on and discredit in front of everyone watching this show of emotional blackmail and political bias. Thank you, Tony.
@@athamg4535 These "poor people" are almost as against the voice as Rowan Dean is. Take a look at Warren Mundine and Senator Jacinta Price said at this very committee hearing regarding the no vote.
@@robertmenzies9474 Reply No all you want It's their country not ours They have their ways It sad it had to be like this. Your bigotry is being noted in history A hole
In the 10 years I lived and worked all around New South Wales erecting steel structures/commercial buildings in the 80's, I saw ONE indigenous man working. His name was Murphy' and he was a rigger. The other times I saw indigenous people was on dole day when they came into town to drink it away.
Things have improved somewhat since then I think. I live in a regional town in the north west and I think most aboriginals here work and have jobs (albeit a lot in the indigenous welfare complex), they are unsung heroes actually, but the problem sub-demographic is visible, antisocial, irritating, and there is too much crime, too much vagrancy and begging, and nothing ever gets done about it.
But we don't all have the same voice. Why do you continue to spread this bullshit. Have you even bothered to read the relevant parts of the constitution?
If aboriginal politicians and activists want change, they need to be elected at the state level so they can influence policy over the bureaucracies and services that are relevant to the demographics that are struggling and problematic. An advisory body at the federal level would be useless I suspect.
@@lieshtmeiser5542 It is also disingenuous to argue as it asserts that only indigenous poor require any voice. Parliament exists for a reason I would have thought.
@@zeropoint546 Absolutely correct! So long as our rulers deliberately lobotomise those they rule with few exceptions, the few exceptions will be trampled underfoot by the ruled & hunted by the rulers... Take cover.
The greens senator was owned by him. Above her mindless ramblings was the things that he said. Tony Abbott just made so much sense. I hope a lot of people see this clip.
@@peted3637 Dorinda Cox seemed to give an arrogant smirk to cover up her disappointment at Abbott's excellent reply... she eventually realised he was speaking with knowledge of the subject matter and couldn't trick him up.
I mean I still don't like the man, maybe it's scarring from those old news clips of him walking out of the surf in his budgie smugglers, but I totally have a new found respect for the man. at least on this issue.
The tone in those angry women’s voices as they spat out their misguided questions, and then completely misrepresenting his thoughtful responses is a testament to where their bile bubbles. He is the epitome of an intelligent balanced thoughtful elder and his words should be respected and heeded.
@@Bennie32831 Instead of trying to embezzle Billions on hokey submarines We could better use that money Reconciling and reconnecting with our Native Bothers and Sisters. They are very important and very an ancient people's.
@@antidepressant11 He does seem to make a better fit as elder statesman than statesman but if a crisis requires it, I hope Parliament appoints him and the Crown confirm him.
I love how people are always paying power games. The woman: "I haven't finished the question yet!" That was very disrespectful to a former prime minister.
@@BlackStump172 I never said he was. I was only repeating what Gillard said to him in parliament. He just brushed it iff like water off a ducks back. All credit to hime.
The way you phrase it is a familiar style of writing. I honestly wonder if the people who voted Biden in were his fans. I wonder the same thing about Albo, I wasnt a fan of any of the politicians on offer at the last election, not remotely.
@@maciamay1393 This issue is one specifically where I think he makes sense. On many other issues - including his approach to the monarchy, his economic and social views - I still don’t agree.
The only thing that never made sense about TA , was the publics belief that the constant attacks in the press for years were the truth .Remember the punch ?
@@prazzo1232 , which Social views dont you agree ? The fact Tony is still married after 38 years ? Or that he is Community minded and is an active member of both Manly Life Saving Club and the Forestville Bush Fire Brigade ?
She’s hasn’t listened to the first 10 minutes. This is symptomatic of the bipolar nature of representation of this committee. So inadequate singular focus.
Tony was a Rhodes Scholar . He is a very intelligent and educated man , who has a conscience and cares for his fellow men , particularly the Aboriginals .
Competing with Morrison and Billy McMahon as our worst PM ever. A professional liar. Now he has to run around dancing crazily to Gina's tune to make a quid. Sad.
@@alliswell2114 Meanwhile, in Australia and all UN Member countries, the evil is going unnoticed by the Citizens .>>>> UN Australian Labor/gang-green Partys Voice invention is not about helping the indigenous Australians, but about the United Nations Australian Labor Government is just pulling the wool over the Aussie People’s eyes using their VOICE invention as a distraction because the UNs Labor Government will agree to the Globalist Monster Bill Gates’s “WHO planned-demic TREATY” giving the unelected Bureaucrats and Globalist MONSTERS in the "World Health Organisation" total control over the Australian people and all our Politicians, including Politicians who are patriots and still work for the People, and the United Nations Labor and LNP Politician TRAITORS in the controlling duopoly these two parties have implemented all UN agendas onto the Australian People for over 40 years. Hardly any people know about this TREASON! >>>>>>>BUT! The end of Australian sovereignty is just days away; do you know that all members of the now evil “WHO” based in Geneva do not pay tax, have diplomatic immunity, are untouchable for any crimes against Humanity, will force the vaccine Passports onto all participating UN Member countries, only the evil WHO will be able to name their next PLANNED-DEMIC what it be? Remember, our Politician TRAITORS and PATRIOTS must do the bidding of this very corrupt WHO. All Bill Gates new vaccines will be mandatory to be injected with their militarised poison, or as in New Zealand, unvaccinated citizens will be tracked down and be injected. Don’t you know that the Globalist monster Bill Gates in the most significant contributor to the WHO? 83% of the WHO funding comes from globalist businesses, and 17% from UN Member countries. The “WHO Planned-demic Treaty” is binding Politicians that sign you up to this WHO abomination are TRAITORS! .>>>>> I don't think India, China, Russia, Saudi Arabia or Brazil will give up their sovereignty to Bill Gates WHO, but we will see. I wonder why the MSM isn't talking about this.
@@grantharrismusic so you don't understand what I said but at the same time you know I'm angry? Come back with a more logical statement and we'll talk.
Tony Abbott spoke well - commonsense approach. At the end of the day, this so-called Voice should unite, not divide; and in its current wording, and the panel representing the voice are not willing to realize this concern. The focus should be: we are One Nation.
@@brianmorris8045 Shall we try some honesty? Can honesty lead us to better outcomes? THE TRUTH. . . Hey, can we bring our monopoly game to your place? Nah, bring that here & we'll spear ya. But, monopoly is good. We'll all have houses & cars & agriculture & fresh food & world standard medical & law & order & clothing & abundant clean drinking water. Nah. Don't want it. Well, why not? Because we just hate ya.
Good work Tony. Love how the greens senator tried twist his words and paint him as a racist but Tony quickly addressed the point and made her confused as to how else she could paint him as a racist.
Like i said i never stole any ones land people just want to be left alone and stop taxing the crap out of us and government pay no price for cost blow outs and balance the books like i have to ,, and so on ,,,
Unfortunately they weren’t listening. This is a snowball & it makes me ill. Senator Cox, Keith & the blonde Senator do not give a dam about Abbotts points, they were talking while he was not only trying to make points, but attacking him. This is unreal.
@@lostinspace699 I find it idiotic as to how people in the last 2 or 3 generations are being blamed for what their ancestors did. No one believes what happened was right, but to blame white people that live now for something they weren’t even alive for is beyond belief. The gov should be focussed on putting in real reforms that soo many Indigenous people have been calling for instead of enshrining a body into the Constitution which has major ramifications and unforeseen consequences just because what partisan politics has done before doesn’t work. This body could easily just be legislated. The gov’s priorities are on spending and saviour complex policies rather than cutting deficits structurally and helping every Australian right now.
Old Richo from Labor went further the other day. Gave up And said we will never fix the Problems. He implied that it's been a waste of money. Only truth comes from an Ex politician.
Ask your self honestly about this then .If he is such a stand up guy why wasn't he pm upto 2"022 even being ultra-right and having lots of his mates in his party being ultra-consertive as they are ?
@@neilwilliams929 because they're NOT ultra conservative. The majority headed to woke town over a decade ago. That's how Turdball knifed him. You've got zero clue.
260speedy ...Your really taking the piss I hope ? This man has Australia's interest s F**k OOFFff " I neally wet my self with laughter ....THATS A GOOD one
Abbot was very reasonable and articulate in defending the right for Australians to Vote No, despite the Labor heavy committee trying to back him into a corner and paint him as a racist. You are not a racist for Voting No. Recognizing Indigenous people as the First Nations' People in the Constitution is fantastic and I welcome it. But this Referendum is attempting to put Indigenous people ABOVE all other Australians in the Constitution and is a perfect example of RACISM. Well done Tony, Vote No.
Oh for the good old days when we had PM Abbott sucking up to China. Selling off the Darwin Port to them, inviting Xi to address Parliament and all the Liberal MPs clapping him wildly like CCP loyalists.
100% agree. This is probably the best thing I’ve seen on this channel and by Tony. He laid out his points eloquently and the Labor and Greens senators had no idea as to how to paint him as a racist and corrupt person.
Rb ...You mean being dodgy a liar and so forth .Think of this one " fb this is the arsehole who wanted to be ambassador to Britain on trade and comes crawling back on his belly back to Australia .Now because he was once a prime minister .He thinks his opinion is more important ....SAY you 🤔
This how a grown up behaves and deals with issues. The contrast with the Yes case activists could not be more stark. He is so across the detail and makes Dorinda Cox especially look like an amateur. He embodies a compassionate NO to the wrong path.
Great point, the ‘yes’ case really does not speak well at all and have no/nonsense arguments. They whisper to each other and don’t even listen to Tony’s responses.
Absolutely brilliant, Tony. And I reflected upon your earlier comments about it’s not for the tax payer to fund lifestyle choices. People in search of education, health and jobs will move to areas where such services exist. I don’t see that happening with remote communities.
The negative impractical aspects of living in remote areas applies to all. Social dysfunction as a result of lower employment opportunities, poorer health, relatively higher crime rates, low school attendance etc can all be improved by moving to where better opportunities can be found. Surely this is a matter of personal choice and responsibility for oneself and ones family?
Good on you Tony Abbott! Truthful. Informative. A fair & clear msg that ALL legislation must be a fair representation of all citizens who 'now' reside in Australia. That is true also for the aboriginals who have been born decades since Caprain Cook discovered Australia.
Well spoken Anthony also well debated by Ms Cox and others Love an excellent respectfully intellegant debate .. need this in New Zealand Please do more of these and share world wide so other nations can follow suit Holistic way forward - good suggestions from Tony
The constitution belongs to the crown, and I applaud that Mr Abbot clarified that, his reference to the preamble is also significant as the preamble clearly says the constitution is the guidelines for the operation of a FRANCHISE I also admire the very fine detail he can recall, clearly of a much higher i intellect than the current batch of pollies
No one has said how this ONE VOICE COMMITTEE is going to fix any issues that all the other aboriginal groups, organizations or committees have failed in improving the issues affecting the aboriginal communities, it looks like another bottomless pit for our tax dollars to be poured into. Maybe politicians need to start listening to the people at grass roots level on what the real problems are & stop supporting the other bottom feeder groups who have done anything for years. Native Australian.
My dear late daughter would only vote for Tony Abbott when she he left or pushed out she said she would only vote for Daffy Duck , in other words Tony was the best. Thank you Tony
I had to come back and listen again. Powerful information from Mr Abbott. The quality of comments of viewers comments is brilliant. ThankYou. I would not be the only one to observe the last comment of that green senator. After Tony Abbott gave a lesson in common-sense She simply stated " thankYou Chair'. Not a modicum of decency to recognise Mr Abbott's final response to the question put to Him.
The gap in life expectancy between indigenous and other can be cut by 25% immediately if substance abuse was not so prevalent among Aboriginals. Incidentally, Asian people on average live longer than Europeans - so we can't rush to assume that all reasons for disparties are due to social factors or institutional factors... they could be due to family, genetic or other factors. "The Voice" will not cure these issues.
This is one country One people Instead of dividing we should put all are effort into making EVERYONE No matter colour,race or genda Anyone and every one who want to succeed in this land should be given all the help they need to do this We will always have radicals both left and right We will never get these people to understand That we are all equal and anywhere there is not equality it should be fix But look at the other countries around our land There is a reason that they want to come to our country We are one and we dont need legislation to separate us Remember UNITED WE STAND dont let these ellites break us And i dont care what race,genda you are
Those senators were really struggling to deal with Tony’s truth telling . They couldn’t possibly agree with anything a misogynistic Liberal prime minister says.
I know an Aboriginal Elder who has said Aboriginals have been trained to help but no help has been given. Money has been given to Aboriginal groups but children are not getting the help they need. She said she will vote no. Central west NSW. Go Tony. But Sharon if you wake up with no purpose everyday and nothing to aim for.. some get into breaking the law for entertainment. I agree with Tony Sharon.. Sharon you tell me how to stop kids walking around the street breaking into businesses and get into drinking alcohol ?.
The 1967 referendum, 90.77% of Australians voted to remove RACE from the Constitution, allowing "indigenous" Australian to be on the same legal footing as ALL other Australians and be counted in the Australian population. The vote secured an amendment to Section 51 (XXVi) and the deletion of Section 127. The campaign slogan was "All Australians Should Be Equal" so, the words "other than the Aboriginal race in any state", were deleted. Australians said NO to race discrimination. S51(xxvi) already allows the government to make special laws in regards to "race" or "special laws' for Aboriginal people. The Voice referendum is a Trojan Horse to undermine our property rights further. Property owners are unaware that our governments have already removed our property ownership rights. ALL Titles Offices across Australia have been privatised and they now have the right to destroy titles. Title deeds have been removed and replaced with “digital certificates” of title and hard copies of titles have been replaced with an electronic system. Laws have been changed so that even if you hold a hard copy of your title, it has no legal weight. The value of your property lies in the TITLE. You may want to listen to this voice of REASON (IMO) Grandma Mulara a holder of Grandmother Lore and Colonial Juris Doctor law, who shares her position on the Voice for you to consider. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-DAhkmFzqugI.html As of 01 July 2022, Aborigines have been given 49.3 per cent of our land mass and they want more, all of it if possible. If the remaining claims of an additional 13.4 per cent are allowed, Aborigines will own 62.7 per cent of Australia. The UN/WEF Agenda 21/30 Using Native Title Now Controls Half of Australia www.justonefocus.org/un-wef-insidious-agenda-21-30-using-native-title-now-controls-half-of-australia/ Other resources: zeeemedia.com/interview/zerotime-grandmother-mulara-how-the-voice-to-parliament-advances-the-nwo/ iliasbafas.wordpress.com/2015/12/03/australia-has-no-legal-constitution/ Copy of Sir Harry Gibbs letter: cirnow.com.au/copy ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7vtXkTX5yaU.html Where does the $$$ trail led to: josephinecashman.com.au/map www.justonefocus.org/australia-under-attack-by-the-un-insider-discovers-plot-to-use-voice-to-strip-our-assets/
every thing he would do would make all of us ,richer ,safer,stronger,live longer and happier.All the leftists want is pain delivered to us ,live in poverty ,become ill ,take your child innosence away and away from, you .The woke are pushing us back to the caves,
The Solicitor General is of the OPINION that the Voice is UNLIKELY to lead to a legal minefield, in other words HOPEFULLY it won't be a COMPLETE DISASTER.
9:50 All the problems wrongdoings, antisocial behavior, criminal behavior, alcoholism, domestic and family violence, sexual assault, crime, robbery, lawlessness of any and all Indigenous Aboriginal, or Torres Strait Islander community people anywhere in Australia is now, and has since European settlement been the responsibility of the greater Australian (European) Australia? They, any Aboriginal, or Torres Strait Islander are in no way directly responsible for how they behave? Wow.
