Тёмный

Vegetables: Surprisingly Connected Etymologies 

Alliterative
Подписаться 46 тыс.
Просмотров 4,9 тыс.
50% 1

5 pairs of vegetable-related words with surprising connections.
Thank you to all our Patreon supporters! Please check out our Patreon: / theendlessknot
Endless Knot merchandise can be found in our store: www.cafepress.ca/endlessknot
Creative Commons Images:
Broccoli by Tiia Monto commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Romanesco broccoli by Tiia Monto commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Awl from the Swedish History Museum www.flickr.com/photos/histori...
Brochure by Evan Courtney www.flickr.com/photos/mufan96...
St John's Wort by Bjoertvedt commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Gold ring by Arvind commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Carob pods by Chixoy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ga...
Carob seeds by BIYIKLIVIKI commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Basic linguistic sources here: www.alliterative.net/general-c...
Website: www.alliterative.net/
Twitter: / alliterative
Facebook: / alliterativeendlessknot
Tumbler: / alliterative-endlessknot
SoundCloud: / alliterative
Podcast: www.alliterative.net/podcast or itunes.apple.com/ca/podcast/e...
Click here to sign up for our video email list, to be notified when new videos are posted: eepurl.com/6YuJv
Transcript:
Today in “Surprisingly Connected Etymologies”, we’re getting our daily serving of vegetables.
Have you ever read a brochure about broccoli? Me neither, but etymologically it would be appropriate. Both words come from Latin broccus meaning “projecting, pointed”, which may have been borrowed from a Gaulish word related to Gaelic brog “awl”. Broccoli comes from the way the shoots look, and brochure is in reference to the way the pages were stitched together in early brochures. Oh, and another related food word is brochette, from the French for “skewer”.
What’s the connection between cauliflower and a hole? Etymology! Cauliflower comes from Italian cavoli fiori “cabbage flowers” from Latin caulis “cabbage” and flos “flower”. Latin caulis originally meant “stem”, specifically a hollow stem, from the PIE root *kel- “cover, conceal” which also led to the English words hole and hollow, following the standard Germanic sound change in which initial /k/ became /h/, part of what’s called Grimm’s Law - yes, as in the Brothers Grimm, because Jakob Grimm was a linguist as well as a collector of folktales. By the way, that first part of cauliflower is also related to the first part of coleslaw and the word kale - note that those words have the /k/ sounds since they too were borrowed from Latin caulis instead of coming through a Germanic route. And that’s no folktale!
This next one is particularly apt for a discussion of word origins: A radish is a root, and etymologically this is true as well. Radish comes from Latin radix “root” which in turn comes from the PIE root *wrad- “branch, root”, which through the Germanic branch of languages, passing through Old Norse rot “root” and characteristically losing the /w/ before /r/ as is typical in Scandinavian languages, replacing the Old English form wyrt “root, herb, plant” (which survives in plant names like St. John’s wort) gives us the word root. Radical, dude!
If you’ve ever mixed up the words carrot (the vegetable) and carat (the measure of the fineness of gold or weight of diamonds, don’t be embarrassed - because it turns out they’re related! Carrot can be traced back through French and Latin to the Greek word karoton, from the PIE root *ker- “horn” (which indeed gave us the word horn, with the same k to h sound change we saw in cauliflower), because the carrot is shaped like a horn. Also because of its hornlike shape, the related word in Greek keration referred to the seed pod of the carob tree. This Greek word passed into Arabic as qirat, where it came to be used as a small unit of weight (one carob seed = 1 qirat), and from that we eventually get the English word carat, as used by jewelers.
And finally, it’s Halloween and a little costumed witch comes to your door. Do you give them candy or vegetables? Vegetables of course, because you know your etymology! Although the etymology of witch, from Old English wicce, is not entirely certain, it may well come from the PIE root *weg- “to be strong, lively”, through Germanic *wikkjaz “necromancer”, from the idea of “waking the dead”. And this same root, coming through Latin, gives us vegetable, literally something that is alive.
Thanks for watching! This is one in a series of occasional short videos about connected etymologies; to see more, you can also follow the Endless Knot on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram.

Опубликовано:

 

11 авг 2020

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 33   
@jeromydoerksen2603
@jeromydoerksen2603 4 года назад
Fascinating
@CynBH
@CynBH 4 года назад
"Ah, there’s nothing in the world quite like broccoli. Well, nothing except cabbage, cauliflower, kale, brussels sprouts, collard greens, and kohlrabi. All of these vegetables are, in fact, the same species, Brassica oleracea. They all stem (if you’ll pardon the pun) from a wild mustard plant that has been bred in various ways to enhance nutrition or yield, or make it easier to grow and harvest." www.exploratorium.edu/gardening/feed/garden-variety/broccoli.html
@jevongraham5223
@jevongraham5223 4 года назад
Underrated content
@ashypharaoh8407
@ashypharaoh8407 4 года назад
I love this
@curtiswfranks
@curtiswfranks 4 года назад
That was fun!
@MaraK_dialmformara
@MaraK_dialmformara 4 года назад
Thoughts: -Worth noting that “radix” is a technical term for the square root sign. -Is carrot/karat related to caret and/or keratin? -The witch/vegetable connection reminded me of the moment in famous children’s novel The Secret Garden where a live tree branch (found by surprise among dead branches) is described as “wick.” I think. Don’t really trust my memory on that. Also is the “witch” cluster related to “wake” through the necromancy branch?
@Alliterative
@Alliterative 4 года назад
keratin is related: from *ker- "horn" because it's the substance making up horns (and fingernails etc), but caret comes from Latin "it is lacking" from the verb "carere", PIE root *kes- Yes, 'wick' is a Yorkshire dialect word for 'lively' or 'healthy', the OED says it's a variant for 'quick' in the sense of 'alive', but I'm not sure if/how that connects to the *weg- root.
@juanausensi499
@juanausensi499 2 года назад
@@Alliterative Wick - wicked have a similar relationship. Probably a coincidence, but worth noting.
@zacnizib
@zacnizib 4 года назад
What's the etymology of "first"
@jannes3290
@jannes3290 4 года назад
first (adj., adv.) Old English fyrst "foremost, going before all others; chief, principal," also (though rarely) as an adverb, "at first, originally," superlative of fore; from Proto-Germanic *furista- "foremost" (source also of Old Saxon fuirst "first," Old High German furist, Old Norse fyrstr, Danish første, Old Frisian ferist, Middle Dutch vorste "prince," Dutch vorst "first," German Fürst "prince"), from PIE *pre-isto-, superlative of *pre-, from root *per- (1) "forward," hence "in front of, before, first, chief." The usual Old English superlative word was not fyrst, but forma, which shows more clearly the connection to fore. Forma became Middle English firme "first, earliest," but this has not survived.
@Alliterative
@Alliterative 4 года назад
Thanks Jannes!
@hallfiry
@hallfiry 4 года назад
@@jannes3290 Credit: www.etymonline.com/word/first
@damond4
@damond4 4 года назад
“First” is related to "foremost", first in line, in front of all others. The German equivalent "erste" means first in time, previous to all others.
@colinp2238
@colinp2238 4 года назад
@@damond4 So what about erstwhile? Meaning before or earlier.
@shmood3000
@shmood3000 3 года назад
It’s interesting and kind of ironic that we call post-coma unresponsiveness a “vegetative” state since “vegetable” is related to “wake”. Plants have shown signs of intelligence, which we tend not to think about since they don’t move like animals, we think of them as sort of dead. To add to the irony, “wake” can mean to arise from sleep or a kind of funeral ceremony, a life/death duality which James Joyce famously exploited.
@hugovangalen
@hugovangalen 4 года назад
The Dutch word for radix/root interestingly is "wortel" (I can imagine this evolving from *wrad also). Confusingly we also call a carrot, a "wortel".
@Speireata4
@Speireata4 4 года назад
In Germany, a root is a "Wurzel" and in some areas of Germany, a carrot is also called "Wurzel".
@jakubpociecha8819
@jakubpociecha8819 3 года назад
I mean, the Dutch aren't wrong, 'cause the edible part of the carrot is the root Also the Dutch bred carrots to make them orange 'cause it symbolized the House of Orange
@isabellaholden8997
@isabellaholden8997 4 года назад
Most interesting. Thank you.🇿🇦😷👍🙏
@NancyTroutman
@NancyTroutman 4 года назад
Any hope for a video on foods that are not forced upon us by our mothers?
@NancyTroutman
@NancyTroutman 3 года назад
By the way, would you please provide another way than Patreon to support your channel? Not all countries can pull it up.
@ShummaAwilum
@ShummaAwilum 4 года назад
Huh... I always figured the similarity of cauliflower and coleslaw came from both being shit.
@englishwithbatayneh5908
@englishwithbatayneh5908 4 года назад
Are you sure about the relation of the Latin caulis "stem" with the root that gave English hole!!
@Kleshumara
@Kleshumara 4 года назад
We need to update “... cabbages and kings” to something more etymologically accurate!
@Geospasmic
@Geospasmic 4 года назад
Is "brochure" related to "brocade", both being a type of stitched item? E: forgot to mention, this was a roller coaster ride
@Alliterative
@Alliterative 4 года назад
Seems to be, yes -- well spotted! :)
@colinp2238
@colinp2238 4 года назад
Beans and peas?
@Alliterative
@Alliterative 4 года назад
Maybe I’ll get to them in another video! I’m sure there are more interesting veg etymologies out there.
@Felix-wq2ec
@Felix-wq2ec 4 года назад
"Radix" Math flashbacks.
@NancyTroutman
@NancyTroutman 3 года назад
After watching your videos, I have begun to realize that English is merely a whole bunch of languages that were put into a blender and whizzed until smooth. Studying English has turned into a study of history. I am now wondering if you, or any other linguist, has charted English word theft by languages. What language has English stolen from the most? And is there a language out there which English has not stolen from?
@hoathanatos6179
@hoathanatos6179 3 года назад
I wouldn't exactly call it stealing. The Normans conquered England and brought their dialect of French with them as did the Norse bring Old Norse when they migrated to England and Scotland from Scandinavia. Many languages have borrowed words from Latin and Greek as well with them being liturgical and academic languages for many European countries.
Далее
Bug: Word History Connections
13:34
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Birds: Surprisingly Connected Etymologies
5:10
Просмотров 6 тыс.
Etymology and surprising origins of English words
13:48
Does English have a future tense?
17:05
Просмотров 35 тыс.
Where does the Guitar come from?
21:01
Просмотров 4,9 тыс.
Where Does Music Come From?
14:50
Просмотров 23 тыс.
What's the Earliest English Word?
11:46
Просмотров 168 тыс.
Charms, Spells, & Hags: The Endnotes
4:33
Просмотров 10 тыс.
Etymology: Some History of Proto-Indo-European
13:21
Просмотров 148 тыс.
Why are Canadians called Canucks?
7:06
Просмотров 12 тыс.
Sublime: The Aesthetics & Origins of Romanticism
15:31
Fossil: The Language & History of Paleontology
13:15
Просмотров 13 тыс.