Ahsoka is a Joke! 

How goes being funny Australian robot?

"umm captain I just read our basic security procedures and they say, do not let any weird random shuttles into your ship when you have a high value prisoner" "shut up number 2, you're fired."

Alright.. Yo.. why is the show lit like daytime rerun of Mexican telenovellas?

Momma always says legend is as legend does

Robot head My take….boring, unbelievable, dumb painting on the wall (did 5 year old ooops I mean 10 year old leia from obi 1 paint it?) Feloni mate, the reason why the first 3 Star Wars made are the best is because they were believable and the story followed each other, fantasy that sent you to another world because the writing and balance of characters was excellent, not this sterile unbelievably crap, it’s downright stupid in places it reminds me of old Star Trek (I know a lot like Star Trek but this is supposed to be Star Wars!) which lets be honest is just plain dumb a lot of the time… Why is he shoehorning what is from here and what is happening here on earth in to fantasy? We watch stuff like this to get TF away from all of that, want to see a cowboy (ohboy more like, looking at you bane) watch a western, Japanese wooden swords for Jedi training 🐶💩, scooters🫣, wtaf!! Want women’s problems and power sorting out watch Thelma and louise from 30 years ago, we don’t need it in Star Wars, you want women leads then no problem, Gyn Erso anyone, bloody fantastic writing, acting! it’s not about complaining about women it’s about the shit writing he does and makes them act out, putting our values on a SPACE FANTASY STORY he’s a big headed dumb cowboy hat wearing shit story writing twat! Seriously I made myself endure obi wan and a book of boba fett and feel gutted a watched them through, I turned this off though half way through episode 3 though cos it is just too much, I can’t take how crap they are anymore, how can they mishandle one of the most loved movies/stories like they are doing it’s depressing!

no, it meant that after all that, feminism prevailed over the injustices of the patriarchal modicum of shitism that is modern day media. they won, now, females can save themselves from whatever the next world war has to offer.

And that is why they need those with short attention spans and little to no critical thought process, the invested a lot into creating almost an entire generation of those.

I clapped! ;)

@PREDATORvRIDDICK It's not that Disney Star Wars means nothing, it's that your head canon means nothing.

Nailed it

So...pre-Disney?

@@ggt47 Yes.

-👴🏻

Literally. Even Beskar wasn't lightsaber proof until Disney made Mandalorian

@@TraceguyRune The EU.

I would like this twice if I could

@@bowseryoutuber3881 haha call it low hanging fruit. But it couldn't miss.

Screw You, Lucas & Filoni!

Ok but Filoni’s done all the actual work with her

0:00 the show has normies asking "Can you die from that?" 🤣🤣🤣

@@jesterssketchbook”but it went to the left and there was a medical bay😩”

Dave Baloney fvcked up lightsabers in the Rebels cartoon - made them way to thin and less intimidating, and also made the Inquisitors use them to fly around like helicopters for Christ sakes.

It gets very easy to believe as the more they keep doing this.

@@disenfranchisedver1tech598 He already f***ed with lightsabers when he brought back Maul, who somehow survived being cut in half and falling from who knows how long of a distance/height.

Spot on

Now it's a longsword with RGB

A light saber is a laser sword that can cut anything like butter how do you fuck that up

@@inquisitionexpecter4263 a longsword thrust through the torso will kill.

@@KeldorDAntrell is either a crappy longsword with rgb or thicc plot armor

@@zogwort1522 Then I have the wrong double-X chromosomes. I want strong male heros not some femboys.

@@wolpertingera5829 You will get what your given and like it, then again maybe if you fold your arms at them & flex hard enough you will get your strong boys back.

@@zogwort1522 Are you sure it isn't the Le Tigra?

It’s all to please the M O D E R N A U D I E N C E S

Please don't pretend to be a woman online. It's cringe.

Tis but a scratch

​@@popegramzz479A scratch?!

LOL that _did_ happen in GOT. Did you forget about how the Dothraki just resurrected? They suicide charged the Night Walkers - and then next thing you know, they’re invading the capital.

​@disguisedcentennial835 well, that's the final season, where nothing made sense anymore lol. Like wtf would you send light cavalry to charge the enemy head on, in the dark when you are the defender in a siege? Especially an undead enemy lol

​@@disguisedcentennial835that was precisely why the show was shit by the end

I mean it was the backstory itself that ruined it

I've heard better dialog from my nephews playing Star Wars

Yes 😅

@@RobotHead He is saying that your manbaby rants are boring and repetitive. We get it, you make money from hating a tv show meant for 12-year-olds. Do the words sell out, hate merchant, and hack mean anything to you?

​@@RobotHeadSo When Anakin was Cut in half and lit on fire but lived was fine though right? Or when maul was cut in half and fell down a bottomless pit and lived was fine though right? Or When Star killer was stabbed through the chest was fine right? Plus qui-gon did not die instantly he was laying there for several minutes before obi-wan got to him unlike sabine who was instantly rushed to the hospital.

​@@ryancampbell5352anakin wasnt cut in half

​@@ryancampbell5352first off Anakin lost his limbs and there are people who have survived burns all over their body in real life. And second using extended material from a cartoon or video game to defend a crappy show doesn't help your argument. It was just as dumb there as it is here so what makes this better?

that's so sad I'm dreading the future of media entertainment

Bro exactly!!! Younger audiences have no choice but to exist in a cinematic vacuum. They actually think this is good storytelling because they have nothing to compare it to.

Na. The younger generation has zero interest in this garbage wars. Star wars is over. Let disney burn down financially. And we don't need no water let the mfer burn! Burn mfer burn!

@@Hotraider I’m hopeful there will, eventually, be a young Scorsese/Coppola/Lucas type resurgence like in the 70s.

You seem to be forgetting that George Lucas put Caravan of Courage into Star Wars canon.

I didn’t watch the episode… It was in an ancient temple?? 😂 FUCK, man, I really wanted to like this thing…

This is a trope common to children's programmes.

Maul and the Grand Inquisitor died in Rebels but I see your point.

How long are we betting on it being before Kanan comes back from the dead? Ahsoka should have stayed dead in Rebels (Clone Wars? I forget) when Vader killed her. That was a truly fitting end and a tragedy of Shakespearean proportions. That - besides the stupid gadgets- marked Filoni out as a hack long before this.

Heck seeing all those characters living after a lightsaber wound makes me think that Han Solo is alive somewhere 🤣

@@francoisregis2155 - Han was Stabbed and Fell into a Miles Deep Pit. Then got up, Shock the Dust off, said Ouch, then got to an Escape Pod ad Fled.

Sabine was also lucky that the evil jedi lady took out the saber the same way she stab her, she could have just move to the right or the left and slice her in two

The alternative would be to have the lightsaber strike bounce off some armor or hit Sabine in a non lethal area for minimal inconvenience

@@TheScarletSlayer Why even go that far. How about we get rid of all forms of violence and have a dance off? That way, no one dies and everyone can walk away afterward feeling like they gave it their best!

@@meal_team_six Why stop there!! Let's have both contestants win because the villain was actually a hero this whole time and something something do the right thing in a bad way.

True, the only reason a Sith would be content with just a stab it'd be because it's 100% deadly (and it was in Lucas SW).If not SW would become The Texas Chainsaw Massacre in space

I just watched The Woke Critic's take on Ahsoka and it made me feel so much better. 😆

@@WarstubNever heard of him, but judging from the name the channel has to be a joke right?

@@racool911 It's some goddamn excellent parody, that's what it is!

It's probably the only parody I enjoy, and I normally dislike parody.

Seems like you’ve passed through the final stage of grieving. Sad.

It’s to be expected

@@chasehedges6775 It is the way!

Agreed. I was genuinely shocked at how good Andor was. I was expecting absolute garbage that was on par with all Disney SW

​@@Lobosalsa9Andor was middle of the road. You just got played again with that one...

@@allankles Trust me, I despise Disney SW, but that show was very good, and it almost hurts to say that, because Disney sucks.

Because of the rise of.. the Message

What do you mean? She was always like that

@@tufab3494 Rebels Sabine was a layered character. Although she was a bit reckless she was loyal to her crew and cared about them. She had her past mistakes and trauma. Not to mention her character arc in the series. This? This is bland.

@@a.s.raiyan2003-4 isn't it clear that something went on between the Ghost Crew after the Battle of Lothal? We don't know why Sabine and Ahsoka are mad at each other, so we can't just complain of her actitude towards it... When we get to know the past between both, we'll be able to trully compare ger way of dealing with Ahsoka. And her interaction with Hera was exactly how it used to happen in the series. Sabine is super well acted imo. Want it or not this show will eventually grow on you. Filoni has really set his stakes high on this one

Offscreen character development is a cardinal sin, especially with established characters that the audience is meant to be invested in and care about. Period.

It's been 25 years since the clone wars and Ahsoka as a teenager. She is going to be different

@@moabman6803 I didn’t say she wouldn’t be different. The problem is that she acts like a Jedi despite denouncing herself as a Jedi. She has not been formally trained since the Clone Wars yet for some reason the way she acts and speaks is significantly different to Rebels. Sure, she could have changed during the five year gap between Rebels and Ahsoka. However, character development during a time skip is just lazy writing.

@@moabman6803 Just look at her portrayal in Rebels. She's still herself. Older, wiser, but still the Ahsoka we know. In this new show, it's like the one piece of advice they gave her was, "Ahsoka is depressed," and she bases her performance in every scene on that one singular idea.

@@ZenMonkeyGod If you watch the most recent episode she is more like her younger self.

"How did Sabine not die from being stabbed with a weapon that literally melts your insides?" "Hey, shut up. So, she gets stabbed, and then she heals up later. Meanwhile..."

​@@G360LIVE"No, no. You see, the hot plasma sword that melts steel when connected missed A VITAL ORGAN, so it's all fine. Stop nitpicking everything!"

​@@Arko777777Yeah or when maul gets cut in half and falls down a bottomless pit and lives haha dumb disney, oh wait...

@@ryancampbell5352 Cutting off limbs isn't the problem. Maul surviving is also bullshit. Nice try though.

Qui-Gon could've been saved if there was more help. He was still alive after the stab until Obi-Wan defeated Maul.

Still trying to find the "good moment or idea."

The Halo franchise since 343 took over

@@PepeSilviaPennypacker True :(

I love Mary Winstead but I hate everything shes in except Birds of Prey must be her looks

Or an Aorta or spinal chord. Her injury was midline; when she woke up, her wound changed locations. She didn’t get to stay in one of those Hospital aquariums either.

I mean, in the newest episode, they made clear that she was actually one of the weakest force user that had been in allowed to train as a jedi. And then proceeded to do terribly in Jedi training, at least purely beyond the basics. Which- tell me if I'm wrong here, but isn't that something that bucks that trend of Star Wars female characters being that soooo strong and independent quality?

@@josephhernandez5386 It was the robot that said this repeatedly. It has a male’s voice programmed in; so, it was mansplaining trying to oppress the woman. I have a feeling she’s going to predictably shock everyone by doing some Force maneuvers. Perhaps a ripoff of Neo’s doubt in The Matrix.

​@@9StickNateif you've watched rebels she's been training for a very long time. It would be a relief to finally see her powers come to fruition.

Soooo true. KK hates George Lucas and the EU.

Snoke is Palpatine's creation, what we are going to see is extra-galactic

If they kill Thrawn off like that there would be literal outrage.

​@@a.s.raiyan2003-4nah, the people who would care are not watching this crap

​@@mfmageiwatchliterally everybody is watching and loving it, you are like those dudes in the back of the class that nobody really wants to talk to

Andor was neither relatable or well written. I watched all of it and was very disappointed, and that was it for Star Wars for me.

@@vestavindSW never was meant to be relatable on a cultural level and it did just that in my opinion with Andor, it was made from a human perspective. The original trilogy was about awesome space wizards but space wizards nonetheless; what was relatable in the original trilogy was the relationship between father and son, not really about who or what they were.

@@vestavindit was logical for the most part (star wars wise) and the story was plausible and pretty well written so i would say it was a good first season

@@whilhelmtell6667 debatable I related hard to Anakin in Episode 3

Andor and Rogue One are the only things Disney has done right in nearly 10 years

I get what you're saying but it's still supposed to be art so its excusable that its in that style

Exactly, Disney Star Wars is not Star Wars. It is a farce

Kathy Sue Wars. It is Kathleen's self-insert fiction after all.

Honestly now I'm questioning if Star Wars was ever really good. Looking back the original trilogy wasn't even all that

@@racool911 - The original has been showing it's age for awhile. Empire and Return are still great. Probably because Lucas handed them over to other directors.

@racool911 How old are you? The OG trilogy are in a different ballpark. Disney's attempts at SW aren't even worthy of the name to me. But again, if you think they're even comparable, that says more about you.

If you think we need more people honestly shitting on Star Wars then you are on the wrong side of RU-vid. I'm not saying I don't like the content, I do, but there are literally hundreds of channels doing the exact same thing.

​@@20TonChop ye tbf there's more channels hating it than liking it. Don't know why this guy thinks robot head is the only one

@@20TonChop We don't need more people shitting on Star Wars, we only need people like him. The reason he's a much needed voice is because he understands filmmaking and is able to show effortlessly how Disney SW is actually much worse than people think.

@@vengeance6833 I never said he was the only one, you obviously missed my point. What I think is that his SW criticism is the one people need to hear because he's the best at it.

@@Maggbba I agree. This channel nails it, so other channels are either redundant or subpar when compared.

Despite how little she appears in it, Hera actually had more personality in Squadrons than this.

Rebels had some amazing scenes, like Darth Mauls final duel.

​@@bunkerhousing That one isn't perfect because Maul doesn't repeat his tactic with Qui-Gon and just instantly goes for the slam...

Hera's conversation with Mon Mothma and the other senators in episode 3 is some of the worst TV writing I've seen in years.

​@@PickpocketJonesI don't know if they are being this bad on purpose or they just terrible writers or both.

100% Anakin called Ashoka snips because she was always joking and you know snippy but in this she's just 😶😶😑 and its just boring I get it she's a super serious jedi master but common

Indeed. Why Ashoka suddenly has the personality of a plank of wood is strange. I get they want her to seem all at peace and one with the universe but in reality she just comes across dull and lifeless.

@@braxxian well she is no longer a teenager that's probably why

Robot head did go too far with his cartoon rant. Cartoons can emote and do more than he thinks, the problem is they dont know how to do it in live action. That and robot head wont ever see clone wars himself xp.

You know? This demostrate how the writers really are ignorant of human feelings. Ahsoka could be portrayed as a wise Force user and also be very fun and laid back. That would send the message that she is really strong. Despite all the trauma she have been through she stayed true to herself. That is what I loved about that character, now she is just meh@@chiefbadmon

Those books were so good!!

This time Thrawn isn’t in the unknown regions he’s in another galaxy.

@@oXRaptorzXo Thrawn has spent the last decade probably playing chess with Ezra. When the imperial remnants find him in the final episode, he'll probably be like "I'm retired now, I don't care for your petty galactic war"

​@@TraceguyRunethats a wise choice if You are a Disney character 😂

ahsoka should of died it would of completed her arc

The exception to the rule that animation directors cannot make live action is Brad Bird going from Pixar to Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol.

Han and Qui Gon Jin. Both were impaled the same way and the consequences were lasting. I honestly think Darth Maul’s impaling of Qui Gon Jin was intended to allow him to die slowly and painfully. Disney turning around and having no less than three characters easily survive these impalings is unbelievably insulting and lazy. Reva didn’t even need medical attention to survive hers. She went on an intergalactic trip right after followed by a long walk on Tattooine. Sabine’s impaling was so unnecessary. The baddie could have just as easily gotten away with no harm done to Sabine and the consequences would have been the same.

You remember Han falling of that bridge after being stabbed? So you don't actually know what killed him. The stab or the fall.

⁠@@ryanlemmers5300- You don't know if Sabine's impaling was unnecessary, as the show is not over yet.

@@dutchbosoxfan8919 I hope you’re right. This series hasn’t displayed the best creative writing so far. Basically goodies and baddies racing to the same destination. I’m hoping there’s an interesting plot twist at some point.

As much as I've written about SW these last few years, Robothead summed it all up in 3 words. Small Cartoon Audience. It's like they all live in a cinematic and literary vacuum. They don't see how other above avg or great stories inspired the creation of other great stories. While this one is largely uninspired outside of the ideas Filoni pasted from Lucas. Or the "young Kirk" scene he pasted from Star Trek 09 with Sabine on the freeway.

And by small its the people who stayed for rebels, because I skipped that when I was 14

Rebels is better than every single Disney live action show, Mando season 1 included.

The sad part is: in order for someone to enjoy Disney Star Wars, they can't care about Star Wars.

The cartoons are peak Star Wars imo even surpassing the OT. Hear me out on this the OT was great but the clone wars and rebels since they have all that time they are able to flesh out their characters and make them amazing. for example Maul was a mid villain at best in TPM but because of both clone wars and rebels he is one of the most beloved characters oat and Filoni is a good writer.. for the cartoons he certainly cannot direct a live action show that’s for sure. My favorite Star Wars characters oat are Anakin/Vader Captain Rex Ahsoka and Maul and Vader is for the ot but Anakin and maul would be mid tier for me and Ahsoka and rex wouldn’t even be on there if it weren’t for those shows so in conclusion Disney has decimated Star Wars except for the cartoons the cartoons are the only thing that Disney Star Wars has left to offer and I’m afraid starting with Ahsoka (a show that never should’ve been live action btw) Disney is gonna ruin that dude of Star Wars as well

I mean fair, but I always thought ahsoka always does that

Nitpicking taken to such an extreme degree. Go watch something else manbaby.

​@@TheRayehThe Clone Wars Pose.

If so the director should point it out and direct them not to do it. No director worth his salt would fail to know what gestures, body language, and posture communicates (no actress should either).

@@TheRayeh even if it's a thing for Ahsoka, a good director would know what the gesture communicates and realise that it's wrong for a jedi. The jedi just aren't arrogant. They are supposed to be as close to perfect beings as is possible, paragons of virtue, excellence, and wisdom. Posturing like a boss is a thing for only the insecure and immature, for those who seek validation from others.

"Cough cough, Anakin, cough cough, Mustafar"

Girl bosses apparently have to look smug and stoic all the time. It's their trade mark. What a joke.

So they wanted Aragorn II (female version)

@@inquisitionexpecter4263 Kinda. Except Aragorn was very proactive and showed his soft side with Arwen. If they make Ashoka hook up with someone (unlikely), I have no doubt it will be a woman, and it will be strictly fun, no long-term committement.

Maybe you haven't noticed, but crossing her arms is kinda her thing... dating waaay back to the Clone Wars MOVIE...

@@LordStarbeard Makes sense that Filoni would ask the actress that, then. What about the smugness and the ever-present slowliness (except when she teleports when training Sabine)? Is that her thing from CW, too?

All energy weapons have to be neutered to not cause permanent damage otherwise it would be classified as an "Deadly Assault Laser Sword" which would put owners on the Space ATF shit-list.

The thing is, animators are experts at making drawings move, not at directing (which is an expertise in conveying communication through acting i.e. voice, movement, expression, gesture, posture etc. and a host of other means of communicating to the viewing audience e.g. proxemics (the distance of the camera from the subject), the angle of the camera, et al.). The best animation is created by a synthesis of the expertise of the director with that of the animator/s i.e. the director carefully communicates exactly how the animated character emotes, moves, what body language they convey with posture, etc. (not forgetting the work of the voice actor, of course). I think Robot Head understands that animation at its best can be just as good as live action (just as live action can be far worse than it ought to be) and was just making a broad point.

Dave filoni isn't open to criticism because he is narcissistic arrogant entitled and selfish

Also, they felt like star wars.

@@angelphoenix7784 Yeah, because the creators knew how to make Star Wars movies and did it because it was their passion and they enjoyed it, not for the sole purpose of money

Basically it boils down to people being flabbergasted that the people Lucas hired to help him make the prequels were largely in sync with him creatively (you know, as you might expect) and didn't constantly trash talk him while being filmed for behind-the-scenes footage. There's no real evidence that Lucas was surrounded by "yes men" to a greater extent than is usually the case. There's this whole mythology about how Lucas was constantly being challenged and put in his place by others during the making of the original trilogy, but if you do a little actual research you find very little evidence of that either, besides some claims made by disgruntled ex-producer Gary Kurtz who was fired halfway through Empire for incompetence and spent the next several decades constructing a self-aggrandizing narrative which recast himself as the hero of Star Wars.

Then why did you manbabies endlessly attack George Lucas over them? You cannot retcon away your words and actions. Just endless whining about everything.

I think the point is something The Critical Drinker & co mentioned yesterday: there's a big difference between a show meant for a young audience, where you have lots of time and freedom to explore stuff and try arcs, and, on the other hand, a 6 ep live show where you have to deliver from day 1, with a much smaller cast and scale. One of this show's problems is that it relies so much on external knowledge (Rebels, basically), and many people haven't watched that. So we don't know why Thrawn is so important, we don't know why Ashoka is important, we don't know why Ezra is important, etc. So far they've found another mcguffin map that makes no sense, and they've had a couple fights. And we've learned that anyone can use the Force now, and that Ashoka can teleport (except when it would actually be useful). I don't think Filoni is gonna be able to bring it home by the time the season ends; it's gonna feel like the end of an arc in CW, rather than the end of a season.

Not just that. He fakes the comparison between the speed ups. The speed of the animated sequence is barely sped up while the live-action is seemingly doubled. I made a quick comparison with the original scenes. This really forces his insecure narrative about cartoons. Also the animated choreography is motion capture so live-action actors were doing the action too.

The 2D Clone Wars show was so much better

It's not that it's a cartoon. It's that it's a CGI "cartoon" with an annoying art style and simplistic dialog --- that makes it even less watchable than simplistic dialog cartoons from the 80s, because at least these have a super high 80s charm.

@@gujono.eiriksson8553so you are just being nostalgic and wanting everything to feel like the 80s

I yhink the show is great

Give it a break. It's only the first few episodes. I'm sure by season 20, they will have much depth and no male good guys.

literally my character had more personality in the 7 mins he was on-screen before being shot to death.

Rebels was great❤ probably on par with clone wars

👀

@putt7515 except for the many, many times it was worse than Clone Wars. Also, Rebels did Thrawn dirty, so even if it was as good as Clone Wars in its other aspects, which it isn’t, it still would be worse.

Because in Disney Star Wars the force is generated by the X chromosomes and stored in the ovaries.

Two words: Girl Power

To be fair, Huyang is a droid. He cannot sense whether she has force potential or not. Obi Wan was the weakest of the young jedi during his time but he became one of the most talented jedi because he worked hard.

Can't wait to hear what Robothead has to say after episode 3 where Ahsoka basically told her anyone can be force sensitive if they just practice lol. Everything is so watered down and meaningless anymore. Force for all, non lethal lightsabers, surviving clearly fatal injuries. It's ridiculous.

Simple: The Force is Female

😂❤

Episode 3 was truly dreadful. That is all

@@SimonLeicester what happened in that episode like actually

Cant wait to see them do the goofy propeller fly in live action with inquisitor sabers. Ill never understand why people loved the cartoons but its funny to see them try to transfer everything to live action

The animated shows were okay for the most part. Honestly I don't think they'll have the helicopter saber effect happen. The closest they ever got to that outside of Rebels was Jedi Fallen Order, when one or two of the Inquisitors did a brief propeller attack that moved laterally during boss fights.

@@joshuastoughton1693 🤡

What a critique "Arm crossing" lol

Watching them just makes me wanna cross my arms 😂

​@@tufab3494Your incessant need to respond to every comment you can about how ridiculous their critiques are is just as ridiculous as the people you're getting upset at. Stay mad

@@seanbarton4530 why is it ridiculous? Just because your anti woke bs lost all its sense already?

@@tufab3494you must be fairly young, friend.

Or slice vertically

Can’t show that

Disney has half a horse, and you can guess which half

Stoic that’s one good way to summarize it, good comment But for me the show seems like they are trying to make a Witcher more then a Jedi ; what’s that about ,hmm so far I don’t like the show … I guess maybe they lost me after mando season 2

Every show made since GoT (still haven't watched it) has been a wannabe, a Frankensteins monster of whatever shows have been pop lately. Thats why everything feels like a walking dead/GoT/insert latest trendy show all in one. There is no creativity in Hollywoo.@@Dragon-pv5oj

You are obviously more force sensitive than sabine is...JEDI 👏🤣👍

It's much worse in Ahsoka because at least in animation they tend to not stretch the scenes to save money on animation, but here he just doesn't cut any of the footage filmed.

Sucks man.

Amen, brother/sister

Filoni is an hypocrite a two face kissing KK’s ass He did the lightsaber think to piss off fans he doesn’t care about the fans. As for the savior of Star Wars my bet was more on Jon Favereau but with mando season 3 im not too sure anymore. But in all seeing this reminds me that Star Wars is dead. Thanks Shitney

Yep

These replies make me realise my comment ended on quite a depressing note...that was not my intention. Let's remember that we'll always have the light that is the original trilogy and, if you don't hate them, the prequels. Blockbuster movies that also manage to tell a meaningful story, that provide figures to look up to, and lessons to live by. Something I also thought about is this: bad content like modern Star Wars is tragic but it should inspire us to tell our own stories, to make something special like George endeavoured to do all those years ago. Let's keep hope alive and strive to be better than this nonsense.

Ah, yes, Hera and Sabine. Well known Jedi.

@@TraceguyRune ahsoka is though

@@johndaltrocanto In a children's TV show

Thanks!

@@RobotHead You are great mate!

It reminds me of promotional material for almost every network TV drama, where the cast stand at a 3/4 angle, arms crossed, and looking at you from the corner or their eyes

I was like why does she keep doing that? She never done it before

Characters in The Clone Wars usually stand with arms crossed because it's easier to animate.

@@user-xx6vy9ri8p Ik this ᵇᵘᵗ the Ahsoka hand on hip is OG go watch TCW I promise you

​@@gc3klol

In the first movie we see the lightsaber cut an arm and leave blood. Would that happen at that temp? That was the first time anyone saw a lightsaber in action. This wasn't addressed until legends. All the movies have been inconsistent.

The original trilogy was great, they are classic space opera, very rewatchable. The prequels are good but tedious and have limited rewatchability due to multiple glaring issues. However, they were designed and directed with earnestness and love by Lucas, you can sense that. Everything after that, save for maybe a few scenes in Mando and Rogue 1, is merely a cash grab by Bob Iger, who doesn't give one flying fuck about story or honoring a cinematic legacy of any kind, much less Star Wars.

@@TheBoondoggler Couldn't have said it better my dude

@@TheBoondoggler I like to say that the Prequels can be saved. With good editing, Jar Jar can be cut way back in TPM, which really helps the pacing of that film, because Jar Jar only seems to interrupt the flow of the film most of the time. The romance in AOTC can be made a lot better, and the cringe dialogue can be removed (I actually made a video on my other channel, Reel Busy Editing, that shows how to re-cut the romance in AOTC). And Revenge of the Sith can become more focused when you remove or cut way down on a couple of the lightsaber fights, among other things. But I do agree that George made those movies with love. He just needed help on the writing and editing side of things.

honestly, the only reason why Star Wars was a really big hit was because there was no internet in the 70's

@@G360LIVE Yep George's poor editing and clunky dialogue needed much more improvement.

It's 6 years before Rey was born.

And then she goes back into the background during the First Order/Resistance conflict and then comes back to say some words after all the conflict is done and Rey is working.

@@motherplayer Oh! And the force ghost of Anakin should be like, "I should stay here with this girl because she is more important than my son or my troubled nephew." But that's before the amnesia.

Oh god

Clone Wars is one of my most favourite shows ever (if we don't count some of the filler episodes :D). I didn't enjoy Rebels that much (not a fan of of World between the worlds), but thought it was mostly fine. Coming into Ahsoka, I was one of the people expecting Dave to save Star Wars after all the recent flops. I didn't expect him to be a great live action director. But I certainly expected him to write a good story . Well, I couldn't have been more wrong. He doesn't even understand his characters from Rebels... I've now truly lost all hope for Disney Star Wars :(

@@vojtar111 I agree that Rebels was not quite on the same level with CW, but at least it was well made, something that is apparently impossible for Disney to achieve nowadays

In his cartoons, he often did the same thing of stealing others’ ideas from the books and then making watered-down copies lol

@@disguisedcentennial835 Nothing wrong with that, as long as your stories land with your audience. That's all most superhero movies are when it comes down to it

It's been a great story so far. I like it.

That actually ended up being awesome, wdym? Maul’s arc with Obi-Wan was one of the best things Filoni ever did. What’s ironic is Filoni killed Maul using a single lightsaber attack in Rebels. Now he’s forgotten about it.

I also hated it, but at least he had a good story after that. But yeah, that was beyond stupid... They should've just made the same story but with savage and no maul. I get that he got revived because he felt like a wasted character, everyone thought he looked so cool on episode 1 and he didn't even had 10 min on screen. So people wanted more, but it was stupid nonetheless.

Maul surviving was great. He was so angry and high on the dark side that he lived off pure crazy rage. Reva didn't sell it though.

Well did they revive him before or after Episode 3 came out? If before then okay fine but after they're just copy and pasting Anakin

@connorrobinson9548 Maul was never revived. He survived off of the dark side of the force. He was so angry at the jedi he lived off of crazy rage, especially toward Kenobi. Maul ends up being a very interesting and evil villain. A lot of people took issue with him living through being cut in half until they watched about 20 minutes in.

And complain about how the actresses cross their arms... Genial, keep falling for others' opinions... At the end of the day there are 2 types of person in the world...

No one's seriously complaining about crossed arms. That was obviously a gag. The most common complaints are the expressionless, bland, and plodding manner in which the characters behave. Given that the actresses are capable, it's got to be the direction they're getting.

This show sucks. and you know it. @@tufab3494

Cause you need a contrast, you need to watch something bad to differentiate the bad with the good and why specifically that is. Sometimes you can see something you though it was gonna be bad and find something you really like or an underrated good work. Unfortunatelly, Ashoka is not a good work, but who would have guessed?

@@tufab3494don’t ignore the genuine well founded complaints just because they don’t fit your argument

There's also the problem in that 90% of the scenes are exposition. The characters don't have any particular dramatic intent aside from talking to each other about people who aren't onscreen. It's almost as if the writers don't know what they're doing and haven't really thought through any of it out such that anyone on set could have also figured out the little bits of business they could be doing.

In Rebels and TCW they always did stuff while they talked, you’re right

But that makes it harder to direct cause it requires continuity which they somehow still screwed up in blocking when Ahsoka has arms folded in mid shot and hands are by her side in wide shot

@@GreenLightMe ya. But I think they usually have someone specifically assigned to continuity for big productions. Keeping track of continuity of props, makeup, costumes, etc.

I can't believe they've done it four times in a year ffs

Yes, every manbaby has to whine about the existence of women.

After I saw his take on Andor ... yeah, it does seem that way. To be fair that was the last one I saw, then this came up in my feed. Went about as expected. I've only watched a handful in the past. I guess it's more of an entertainment thing than actually analyzing anything. The jokes are funny.