Did Human Beings Invent GOD? | Dr. Shabir Ally 

😂😂🤣🤣🤣 I nearly died

True. It's actually a very good point.

@@One-rr8um thank you

And also, according to Islam, many societies outright killed their prophets and messengers, and corrupted the message of god.

I'm a Buddhist - think about bahmian valley on the other hand 'WINK' , but good point :D

Wasn't the question whether man invented god? When you hear that man you can't help but say that man INDEED has invented god. At no point has he proven that this is not the case.

he will make you atheist....😁😁😁😊

Thank you so much for your beautiful dua. We are honoured that you have been supporting us for 10 years! May Allah bless you and your loved ones!

Have you learn anything about how and why Ummah of Muhammad SAW divided in 73 sects? Have you try to find out which one sect is the true sect that follows the teachings of Muhammad SAW? Which sect represents the true God and His teachings?

You need Jesus brother! Allah is false god and Muhammad is a false prophet

Islam will not solve all your problems.

The Conservative Outlet I believe in Jesus as a prophet not he son of god

The Conservative Outlet with all due respect, may i ask why you christians always bash Islam within an ISLAMIC video? Of course, no offense. i respect the fact you want to preach your religion. but it hurts knowing how you're always on islamic videos insulting us. comes of as sort of narcisistic you know?

Moeez Javaid ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-APj0fOzNxFU.html Here’s a great video regarding depression from an islamic POV!

This is textbook example of hasty generalizations. Why don't you learn bit more about the cognitive science of religion www.npr.org/2018/07/16/628792048/creating-god

@@manobik lack of academic perspectives with fallacious and poorly explained assumptions

Anthropological studies of humans creating a God figure out of fear of death and wish for justice does not explain why it’s only present in humans. Because animals has to go through the fear of being eaten alive whole through their existence then why they don’t resort to finding a God figure.

@@tanziamustafa3685 the conclusion you are drawing is not what evolutionary psychologists are saying. Did you listen to the 50 min podcast I shared?

@Jack Michaelson shut up

@Jack Michaelson no, im not gonna behead you. Why do you even think that? All i said is Shut up bcuz u talkin without knowledge.

Wasn't the question whether man invented god? When you hear that man you can't help but say that man INDEED has invented god. At no point has he proven that this is not the case.

That was an excellent comment that you made. Thank you for sharing your comment.

If youve already had severe doubts likely you cant turn back. It must run its course. You like all ppl are resisting it so bad coz u want to believe so bad. Trust me ive been there years ago. Having doubts just makes you look for knowledge which opens up even more questions, Do you not wonder why so many ppl are ignorant of their own faith ?

God is not some chair you can point nor you can quantify it by putting in a test tube, running a controlled scientific experiment, science is however still not yet perfected, due to the problem of underdeterminism(which states a theory with set of proven results can contradict another theory with set of proven results as well) and Problem of Truth of which Godel incompleteness theorem states that mathmatics that contain true statements can never be proven hence proving the limitations of math which is primary and only language which the whole of science depend upon solely. Science thus can never prove or disapprove god at all, like never ever. God is literally outsife domain of the intellect, god can only be known by going meta of things. ultimately self-meta, because god can only be known from within.

No god but God (Allah). Dr. Ally is using God and Allah in the same sense.

There is no worthy of worship except Allah

May be its silence :D

The converse is true. God gives mankind the reasons for his existence.

Religion's aim has always been JUST THAT. The suffering and misery that we all witness around us, mostly, are due to human lust for more stuff, money, and power. We have become sicker as a society globally because the loudest voices are rejecting God, Whom has the right to tell us best how to live in harmony with each other and nature. That is what religion is suppose to be about. But even religion has been and will always be used against morality. So many religious figures of the past have foretold about our present crisis, it amazes me how so few people care to consider what they've said. But, to each his own.

It's the God of the Gaps that fueled Religions. Humans lacked scientific explanations, so things looked like "Magic" or "Divine". Lightning is probably the most powerful and famous example. And Total eclipses. In fact Colombus took over an entire Tribe by threatening them that he will make the Sun will turn black.

@@alexojideagu Good thoughts. This is one of the reasons I have been particularly interested in the recent trends concerning Gobeki Tepe in Turkey. There is a line of thought indicating that the site might represent one of the first efforts to associate cosmic or supernatural forces with Human activities such as agriculture or hunting. Of course academia has been laboring about this regarding stone circles for generations (see: Stonehenge). Thoughts.

We Muslims agree that there's is only one God and agree upon his attributes

There is an interesting posts on belief vs disbelief in the description box of the ffg video. RU-vid wont allow links so u can find the reddit links in this video description : Qur'anic Islam vs Inherited Islam - 'ibada, Taqwa and Shukr

Huh?

Please explain how the first primitive man thought about a creator? Now that is extraordinary baring in mind the concept of creator transcends our physical experience ie omnipotent, omniscient, absolute etc....?

Top man Wasn't the question whether man invented god? When you hear that man you can't help but say that man INDEED has invented god. At no point has he proven that this is not the case.

Are you saying all muslims have an accent?

@@Joe-vn3nh sory.. what i ment was nation / region accent

he is well learned in canada itself

She's not asking own questions.

@@akkad-bakkad what I mean is fallow up question, hard fallow up question, are important to make the truth come out, otherwise , you are at the mercy of the apologist , which usually happens in all religion , sad fact

@@Think_pls the videos should be short, you genius.

No sir you are mistaken

Is this not a difficult question. I would love to hear you answer it. Plus the questions are poses by the viewers.

God of the Gaps

Top man. Wasn't the question whether man invented god? When you hear that man you can't help but say that man INDEED has invented god. At no point has he proven that this is not the case.

Allah spoke to Prophet Moses pbuh ...God didnt come down...God communicated from soundwaves speech from the burning bush it doesnt mean God came and set himself fire in the bush!!

@@fidelcatsro6948 brother its a pure lie read the verse very well and read the tafsir, when Mohammed went for the salat how he described Allah. Man you can't decide us any longer

@@omaribrahim301 which part did i lie? lets test this...if i in Cambodia and I call you on your handphone in Dubai and speak you can hear me talking but does it mean i have to be with you in Dubai coffeeshop as well??? soundwaves amigo!!!

@@fidelcatsro6948 hahahhaha brother is trying to be smart here

Read Qur'an Sura 20: 9- 20 and understand it very well however, the Qur'an says in 6:116 thats its a book that talks in details beside Allah also says that there's nothing that can be compared to him but he came or as you said talked with moses through fire and also talked with the prophet through fire but when the prophet was asked to describe Allah what was his description he gave.

Too Many Marys Peace be upon you. Ask the right questions to get right answers. Ask : Is Quran truly a divine revelation ? The answer is YES. There are thousands of references and profs to prove this. RU-vid chat is not sufficient place. Order from Amazon an inexpensive and small Book “Introduction to Islam” by Dr Hamidullah and you will get comprehensive proofs. In fact just read Quran with open mind and within few days of reading you yourself will agree. Ask same Question for Bible : Is Bile a Divine revelation? Answer is again YES. You already believe it and Muslims too believe it. Question No 2 : Is each and every word of Quran the same as it was revealed during the life time of Prophet Muhammed (peace be upon him) ? Answer is YES !! Again thousands of references and proofs available. Same book “Introduction to Islam” by Dr Hamidullah is one simple inexpensive short reference. Ask Same question for Bible : Is each and every word of Bible the same as it was revealed during the life time of Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him) ? Answer is NO!!! Thousands of references and proofs available on line. In Movie Da Vinci Code the characters prove it under the excuse of “fiction”.!!! But it is common knowledge that words of Bible have been modified / changed /removed. One very useful video on this topic is .. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-n281Zyywyn4.html When you know a certain book is revelation from One Mighty God (this is what it means in Arabic word “Allah”) and that books words are exactly same the way they were revealed during the life time of prophet Muhammed (PBUH) then entire discussion ends there and then. It becomes imperative for us to believe in those words. And few things which we can not decipher, leave it to Allah who will make them evident in the Day of Judgement. If you follow a book which is widely known to be fudged and distorted , the God help you. 🙏🏻

You should ask this question to Arab Christians and Arab Jews. You might get correct answer. Abraham & Jesus spoke Aramaic. Think about it.

You can't invent the Arabic word for God. You are really ignorant. If you can't understand that alone and language your opinion can't even been taken into consideration because you lack a lot of knowledge

@@nlmlkadhsu1868 Peace be upon you !!!

Christian don’t pray like Jews, your lie busted. Jesus spoke Aramaic and you should learn how to say the name of most high in Aramaic. Jews believe in true G_D and you believe in fake G_D.