Тёмный

Does PID Tuning matter? Maybe NO? | UAVtech PID Tune for Betafpv 75 Pro Whoop 

ButterflyFPV
Подписаться 714
Просмотров 916
50% 1

At least probably not as much as most people think. Hello my whoop friends. Important: I don't want to tell anyone what is right and what is wrong. And I know this is not a scientific test. And no conclusive proof that everything I say is true. I just want to pass on my experience to you here. I'm simply giving my opinion (the opinion of an experienced race and test pilot) and hope that it can help some of you. My ultimate goal is to pass on the joy of this beautiful hobby to you. Let`s move on. Conclusion of my test flights with various PID tunes (the filter tune was mostly the one from UAVtech, except for the last video): PID tuning doesn't make that much of a difference with a (or my) smooth racing flying style (racing with high kv builds on 3-Blade Props). 5-10% maybe? Definitely not enough that I'm dealing with PID tuning now (not yet). I have more problems with too little power. With more power I could easily fly 20-30% faster. That's why I'd rather take care and experiment with the hardware at the moment so that I can somehow get more power... maybe go back to 2S power train with today's technology?🤔 Please note I wasn't particularly focused on those evenings, hence the many crashes and inaccurate flying. But I can assure you that with all PID tunes (including the stock Betaflight) you can fly very very quickly. Sure, the UAVTech PID Tune feels very clean and precise. But as I said, with more power I could fly much faster. And I don't have any problems with propwash (in indoor racing and outdoor racing flying style) anymore since I'm flying smoothly and efficiently. ⚠️Practice is and remains the most important thing my friends.⚠️ And what I also noticed is that I prefer 96khz software for the ESC in the 1S whoop range (with high kV motors). It gives me more consistency in racing. Especially during training/races over several laps. And as I said, prop wash isn't such a problem if you can fly smoothly. I hope you understand what I mean friends. In any case, I hope you have fun practicing. My tip for everyone: ⚠️Don't waste too much time with PID tuning (racing with high kv builds on 3-Blade Props) until you can fly at least like me or better..⚠️
And a second tip: The 75 Pro is a really good whoop! And even ok for indoor racing like I do when flown with GNB 450mah or GNB 380mah lipos..
Happy whoopin my friends! Whoop whoop! :-)
theuavtech.com/
• Making Whoops FLY BETT...
Thank you UAVtech for this PID and Filter Tune 🙏🏻
0:00 Flight with UAVtech PID Tune (Day2)
1:39 Flight with Betaflight Stock PID Tune (Day2)
2:43 Flight with Betafpv PID Tune (Day2)
3:37 Flight with Betafpv PID Tune (Day1)
5:53 Pictures
Also note the other videos on this channel, the option to subscribe to this channel and my other channels.
Other videos on this topic only - See playlists
If you liked the video - recommend it to friends ☺
Contact for Business Inquiries - Channel Info - Email

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

20 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 19   
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
⚠‼Info is in the VIDEO DESCRIPTION‼⚠
@chettmac
@chettmac 4 месяца назад
Awesome!!
@Tish0eX
@Tish0eX 4 месяца назад
Did you tried quicksilver firmware?
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
No, not yet. But I can test that too.. and emuflight too..
@OliFPV
@OliFPV 3 месяца назад
Sehr geil 🍀 der fliegt halt immer gut 👌 Gruß
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 3 месяца назад
Genau! Also im Prinzip alle Builds mit grosser power to weight ratio (sprich high kv bulds) und dreiblatt props..
@chrisbee5481
@chrisbee5481 4 месяца назад
Den UAVTECH tune konnte ich nur mit reduziertem master slider fliegen. Mir gefällt der meteor75 pro auch echt. Der fliegt auf Augenhöhe mit meinem "mobula7", wobei der längst modifiziert ist, aber du weist was ich meine.
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
Ok also bei mir war es kein problem. Nur beim start hüpft er manchmal wie verrückt auf dem boden😂 aber im flug alles i.O. Ja voll der 75Pro ist wahrscheinlich der aktuell beste BNF allround whoop.. und er ist auch erstaulich stabil..
@andischandra8598
@andischandra8598 4 месяца назад
each individual whoop will differ in pid settings
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
Yes of course. But in this video I investigated the question of whether high kV builds with 3 blade propellers need a PID tune in order to be able to fly quickly. And I came to the conclusion, no, not necessarily. Of course it's better. But if you don't have much time, I think you should concentrate on practicing flying.
@TheGoodShepherdsSheep
@TheGoodShepherdsSheep 4 месяца назад
Liked this comparison 👍 I think the quad was much more locked in but I am commenting from a pure visual perspective I suppose which doesn’t mean much. I also thought the Betafpv tune was noticeably worse out of the 3 which was surprising to me 🤷‍♂️ Luckily I fly so slow that you could do a tune with a blind fold on and it will work for me 😂
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
😂👍Yes, the betafpv tune is really not bad. But to be honest, I also like flying with the stock Betaflight PIDs.🤷🏻‍♂ Maybe I'm just too used to stock betaflight? I'll probably fly with the UAVtech Tune for a while now. The UAVtech tune is quite good..
@TheGoodShepherdsSheep
@TheGoodShepherdsSheep 4 месяца назад
@@butterflyfpv ah my mistake, I actually meant the Betafpv factory tune was worse. I was actually surprised how well to BF tune flew 👌
@JackalFPV
@JackalFPV 4 месяца назад
The Betaflight default tune is optimized for bigger drones - not Whoops. What I know is thath balanced PIDs should work best for Whoops. And a specific tune might work on one FC but not on another brand or another version of a FC even though the rest is equal.
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
@@JackalFPV Yes! But in this video I investigated the question of whether high kV builds with 3 blade propellers need a PID tune in order to be able to fly quickly. And I came to the conclusion, no, not necessarily. Of course it's better. But if you don't have much time, I think you should concentrate on practicing flying first.
@butterflyfpv
@butterflyfpv 4 месяца назад
@@TheGoodShepherdsSheep Yes, to be honest, you can fly quickly with all pid tunes once you get used to it. (racing with high kv builds and 3 blade propellers)
Далее
NEW RCinPower Whoop Motors // 1mm shafts
13:29
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Improving Throttle Chop Bobble or "Throbbles"
19:47
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Meteor 75 pro Betafpv night freestyle
1:35
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.
The Slowest Planes ever Made
17:03
Просмотров 38 тыс.
Я бы сделал дешевле - Samsung Flip 4
1:00
📱 SAMSUNG, ЧТО С ЛИЦОМ? 🤡
0:46
Просмотров 1,2 млн