ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-3Vlhqnn5POQ.html Look at this video from Atun-She films (my n@zy roommate) What you said litteral happens in it, exept the fact that he first captured the kitchen and then living room
@@bobafet3953 I think hollywood makes sure there is always a black character in each movie. That is pissing off a lot of Europeans who'd want to see movies with just white people.
flownet07 LoL I think you Forgot japan,Italy.Hungary,Finland,Croatia, Spain,Serbia,Slovakia,Romania, Palestine,and Bosnia. All helped the German war machine. 🤦♂️ and they still lost 😂
Pavlov's house stands tall still as a monumnet in Volgograd. I have been there. Russian brothers fought tooth and nail, defended the Stalingrad City and that changed the face of World war II. Love from🇮🇳
@@antares1407 Well done Mate, in that case, Had it not for Czechs occupying Polish Zaolzie since 1920 there would not have been any war at all.... would it?
@@antares1407 Well done, Zaolzie was part of non returnable dowry of Queen Doubravka of Bohemia, and hence ever since had been part of Polish domains, had it not for Czechs to relegate against that deal, there would not have been the need to take control in 1060. ;)
I was born in 1976. All my life I grew up on the history of my country, on the history of my parents and grandfathers. I know and remember everything about fascism and Nazism. We were not taught in school to love and hate any nation. We were taught that all people are people. We are all the same. And when I hear that some nation considers itself the first class, and another slave, it revolts me. Why America and Europe consider themselves first class people! Who are you to think like that? We people of Russia have never, you hear, never thought like that and are not going to think. On this planet, everyone is equal, and before the Lord. Who gave you such a right to manage our lives? Who gave you the right to show us where the truth is where the lie is and to impose this idea on us? You were entrusted with our life, our way of life, and you twist us as you want. Who are you after this? You are the devil
I appreciate this scene because, in a battle as insane as the Battle of stalingrad, with massive casualties on both sides, The soldiers must have been weary af. So good officers who give solid morale speeches is important to keep the troops fighting. It's like motivating a sports team as a head coach in a way. Morale is fragile and could be broken easily.
My great-grandfather died there,and my family and I found his name on a memorial plaque near the eternal flame. I was near this very house, it is even scary to look at it, and what happened in it, even scary to imagine. I think it was actually a lot scarier than it is shown in the movie.
Stalingrad was one hell of a battle. Both sides, Germans and Russian soldiers fought bravely, the germans trying to conquer the city, the russians defending the city. Hats off to both sides!!!
Dr No no the Wehrmacht didn’t do anything. All of the “murdering” in the east which were the Baltic states were done by the SS or einsatzgruppen. The Wehrmacht were just soldiers.
Dr No ok you’re right the many of the Wehrmacht weren’t innocent as it describes that they took part in mass killing. But let us also not forget that both sides equally committed atrocities as the The Red Army raped and killed innocent civilians upon entering Berlin.
There were many such houses in Stalingrad. The house of the Specialists. The Bank Building. Pavlov's House. The Central Railway Station. More men died fighting for them then for entire countries in Europe.
the most terrible and faimos of them all was the tractor factory in Stalingrad. More soldiers died there than in all the buildings that you mention combined
This short movie is about Standard, the city on river Volga. If anyone interested about the story of this house, please search "Pavlov's House" to find out more information about what actually happened there.
Бондарчук не плохой режиссёр, но погоня сейчас голливудскими штампами, зрелещностью и безумными эффектами портит всё. Лучшие фильмы о войне бесспорно были в СССР. Там всегда раскрывался внутренний мир героя, а не погоня за количеством спец эффектов. К тому же сценарист писал сценарий под лёгкими наркотикам))) безсмыслица полнейшая)))
Well ya see there's levels for example Saving private Ryan is pro US but shows the brutal reality the second world war very well. So many Americans get killed in that movie you can't call them super men it's practically just the opposite. Where as more Russians were killed in a level in COD World at War then this one scene. It's basically adding to the whole misconception that Russian was invincible in the war. Which if you ask roughly 21 million Russians who didn't survive it obviously wasn't. Yes all war films are bias to some degree but they're not all propaganda. It's only propaganda when it glorifies combat for one side and makes the other look entirely hapless.
Facsinating scene. An excellent demonstration of the complete futility of war. Just a minute ago, a bunch of guys were healthy and they had a future, but some hell, one of them needs to take the destroyed house, and the second to protect it, although there is nothing of value in the house. A minute has passed and there are no guys, no future, no fathers, brothers, sons...War is senseless and merciless. Old people send young people to die for their obsessive complexes. People should send old people to hell early to stop the madness
Вы много не знаете. Сталинград надо было защищать до последнего. Если бы он не важен был, то его оставили бы. Он давал проход на Кавказ и другие просторы. Там была нефть, газ, и другие полезные ископаемые. Благодаря Сталинграду, немцы не захотели брать Ленинград. Они понимали, что после ещё одной такой битвы, они останутся без армии. Так что защищали не дом, а защищали выход на полезные ископаемые.
@@Thesturmgever коллега, повторяю тем, кто в танке - мой пост совсем не об доме и не об том, кому надо было защищать выход к Кавказу. Мой пост о бессмысленности войны, которая убивает молодых парней, которым насрать на есть выход к Кавказу или нет, которые оказались в военной форме, с оружием, в незнакомом месте не по своей воле, а были призваны исполнить" долг" старыми маразматиками. Властные старики не сидят в окопах, но им все мало своей земли и они хотят заграбастать еще у соседей. Один убил миллионы и застрелился, другой убил, сгноил, умертвил миллионы и умер в луже своей мочи - зачем было войну устраивать? Сразу нельзя было застрелиться?
@@Archibald787 ваще мнение итак понятно, без пояснений. Но для тех кто в бронепоезде с тележкой, я объяснил на сколько важен был этот город и для тех и других. А так, по моему для детей младшей группы детского сада и так понятно, почему война эта безумство.
idiot comment, the movie is based on Pavlov's House (Dom Pavlova) in which the soviets held the house for 60 days against a huge wermacht offensive. actually i guess they had IRL plot armour ;d
I dont think that house last that long. Lot of people doing researched about that. German didnt priority that place on the early-mid time assault because they wait another team from another side to cross but it arrived pretty late before they clear those area.
And he is Avengers: Age of Ultron as well. As that Hydra Baron who experimented on the Twins. And yes he is in Victoria movie as King Leopold I of Belgium
@@user-hn2bb5vh5f Не смотри это. Я долго ждал этот фильм и сильно разочаровался. Лучше "Иди и смотри" пересмотреть чем этот цирк. (Фильм Федора Бондарчука - Сталинград).
According to modern Russian directors, this is how WWII actually happened. More explosions in the manner of Western films and a love story must be present. War without love did not exist. And if you did not have love during the war, then you did not fight at all. *facepalm
Ussr has lost 30 million people during the fights. There was only 40 million people living in France en 1940 I'd rather give up during the France campaign than be forced to fight until death in Stalingrad Soviets were real cannon fodder
@@1112rayquaza that number is way overinflated. It was closer to 20 million. Every year the number seems to get bigger. I've seen low estimates from 19 million and the highest estimate at 27 million. I'll say 23 million because it's the median but 30 million is way over.
@@1112rayquaza I know that, I study history. I'm sure you do to. However you should at least be accurate with your numbers. Don't round up because it undermines the point your making and makes people question other facts you say. Also my comment was facetious and was said as a joke. No need for the over analysis.
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Do you know how hard it is to acquire close combat days, to acquire sufficient even for a Bronze clasp is no easy feat, I have not seen one period photograph of a German soldier in Stalingrad with a CCC badge. If you have one produce sir, produce. I have seen many photographs of germans in Stalingrad with the Infantry Assault Badge.
@@ExRhodesian I don't argue. I live in Stalingrad now (in Volgograd, of course). I know a couple guys who are digging, looking for the bodies of forgotten soldiers and study history of that period, they know better than me. I will ask them.
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Living in Russia you must have lost some ancestors during the war, I now feel we all lost that war, no matter which side our families were on. WW2 was like WW1 a waste of good men and women for the benefit of the bankers and their pals. The same scoundrels who are up to no good now.
@@ExRhodesian I agree. During ww2 my father's father lived near Novorossiysk (another Hero-city). And my mother's father lived in occupied Ukraine. I think something similar is happening in the world right now. Most of civilians dont want war. For example, in eastern Ukraine or the middle east, people die for other people's ideas and other people's money... Where are you from?
@Neptune I have a lot of respect for those Germans, as after all I can't say I disagree at all with the idea of destroying communism. What a different world it might have been.
and what prevented other countries from defending their homeland? For example, France, Ukraine, etc. Maybe the problem here is not in the geographical location, but in the people themselves? at the same time, one Pavlov house lasted longer than the whole of France, Estonia, Latvia, Ukraine combined
While I do find this scene to be quite interesting, I would love it if you could put subtitles next time. Individuals that are part of the Deaf community may find it difficult to understand what they are saying especially since they are not only speaking another language but switch midway through to yet another language. If adding subtitles is too much of a hassle, then you could try adding the transcript feature to make it easier to understand for everyone.
This scene shows the famous Pavlov's house, it is based on real facts, the house that was under Pavlov's command was so resistant that the German army marked it on the map as a place where no troops should pass.
@@jonathanallard2128 Then read about it. The accounts of Stalingrad are harrowing. Like the fight to the death at the grain elevator, losing whole divisions 24 hours after crossing the Volga, the AA gunners who met the Wermacht when at the fringe of Stalingrad. It was D-Day, every day for 6 months. Read Antony Beevor's Stalingrad book.
@@toshirox2 I read a lot about Stalingrad because it is a battle I'm completely fascinated by. I did read Anthony Beevor's Stalingrad and many of his other books too (D-Day, Crete, and the fall of Berlin which was ''my favorite''. I read it twice, and I just about never read a book twice.) I find him easy to read. He includes many small testimonies in his narrating and those are my favorite parts. Your mistake is assuming that the reason why this scene is a joke to me would be because it was too brutal or deadly. I watched it a year ago and I won't watch it again, but it surely ain't that. If you have read some good books written BY veterans, I'd love to have more of your suggestions. Cheers!
@@jonathanallard2128 I believe you with the scene. I saw the guy screaming as her fired the MG and said "nope!". Then looked back at the Germans standing before the attack -- 4 out of 10 held Russian weapons -- in 1942? Doesn't sound right. But movie makers can have it the way they want it. Crete was interesting because the German paratroop corps was crippled and never revived by Hitler who came to the conclusion that a paratrooper attack could not get the element of surprise, when really it was that Enigma had been compromised and the Brits knew the where, when, what of the attack. Did highlight the strengths of the Gemran Luftwaffe and the Brit Royal Navy.
Everybody is a gangsta, until your opposing side fallen comrades in hiding under dead bodies remaining still while grenades are tossed in a room, when your eventually stabbed to death in the shelled out living room.
Fun fact: the Krauts lost more soldiers at the famous Pavlov's house in Stalingrad than during the entire campaign against France in 1940. Russians are real badasses. They crushed 80 per cent of the Hitler's armies
they did that at gun point...and it depends which russian armies you mean. in ww1 they didn't not have success nor in the first wave of ww2. it wasn't until stalin brought over the Mongolians at the point of a gun and when winter came that things changed. There was no planning or skill in what they did. Finally, the germans were outnumbered in literally every battle they fought. the kill rations were as follows Germans 1/ Americans 2, Germans 1/ Brits 4, Germans 1/ Russians 12. As recorded by West Point. The germans made the army of 300 look like Girl Scouts.
That is your stupidity at beliving propaganda bullshit. Is no only an outrageous claim by itself but is also miscounting Chuiko´s book "The beginning of the road" page 173 who claims " ... killed more enemy soldiers than the german lost taking PARIS". Which is not big deal since Paris was declared open city and it was not defended at all.
@@marksaldivar4106 Oh boy! Do you study history by comics right? I can't believe that sane person can type such ridiculous Nazi propaganda in 2022. Actually Red Army was outnumbered by Nazis on 1941. Total qty of German troops participated in Barbarossa was 4 millions. Total qty of Soviet soldiers on western part of USSR was 3,5 millions. Just do you math!
I have heard the story of a German who, already in peacetime, threw down his Bicycle and ran away shouting Stalingrad, Stalingrad, when tourists from Russia uttered the name of General Chuikov
It's a fact of the laws of nature that you can't represent the Wehrmacht in WW2 in any medium without one of them saying "Los Los Los!" It just cannot be done.
I've found different sources that say Russian troops were rearmed for street fighting in stalingrad (smgs). From this video it looks like the Germans were as well (most are armed with smgs), but I've been unable to find anything that confirms it. Can anyone shed any light on this for me? Thanks
The Russian troop quickly adapted themselves for street fighting indeed. Infantry division left their artillery on the other side of the Volga for support while the infantry itself, at least those that survived the first 48 hours, practiced hit and run tactics by night using knife, smg, and shovel. The Germans adapted less quickly and their weapon were not as good : the Ppsh had more ammunition than the MP40, so in close quarter and in urban combat, the aim were less important than the rate of fire. Even the russian antitank rifle, who was just useless at long range against the panzer, was mortal in urban area because the shooter could come close from the tank. It's worth noted that the german were good, and really mowed down the russian a the first weeks of the battle, while enduring more and more causalty as they came closer to the volga. At the end of the battle, the german were still numerous, but their infantry division were just depleted of men...
