Hannah Payne's Defense Closing Arguments | Car Crash Vigilante Trial 

#CourtTV What do YOU think? #HannahPayne #VerdictWatch MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/hannah-payne/?

This Attorney is very desperate and embarrassing.

There was nothing there for the lawyer to argue. Everyone is entitled to a defense, but not every case is defendable. Sayonara, Ms Payne. You threw your entire life away. One potential threat off the streets.

Let’s be honest, this lawyer took this case for a quick payday he knew she was guilty

She lost because her lawyer came across as just as entitled as her. Blaming the victim is low

The fact that Hannah was 21 years old when this happened is NOT a factor imo. At 21 I was working full time as a registered nurse. I wouldn't have followed a vehicle involved in a car crash after running thru a red light. That is the responsibility of Law Enforcement. Two witnesses testified that Hannah was enraged. Yelling "get out of the fu**ing car, moth**fu***r" repeatedly. She chose to involve herself in a car crash that she had no part in. Perhaps she needs to consider not carrying a firearm until she deals with her violent temper, rage towards others & involvement in a situation that was none of her business.🕵️‍♂️👮🚔

He said absolutely nothing for almost an hour.

I’d be real surprised if someone hire him again to be there defense attorney

She's guilty

Another Black 65 yr old man in GA who was chased down by a White person ( woman ) in a vehicle with a gun who had no authority to do so, especially for a traffic violation that she wasn't a part of. The 911 operator told her not to chase after the guy but she continued to do so and then confronted the elder gentlemen which led to her pointing and firing a Springfield DX 9 millimeter handgun into his abdomen , killing him. This is the same story that happened to Ahmad Arbery ,also a Black man that was chased down by 3 White men (,the McMichaels) in a pickup with a shotgun while on foot and murdered for going inside an empty house under construction that didn't belong to them. They are serving life sentences without parole. People have a problem in GA when it comes to interfering in situations that are none of their business! 🤔

She would have been better off confessing her to what she did. This long drawn out lie is a waste of tax payers dollars and an insult to the jurors intelligence!!

So because he caused a crash that noone got hurt she terminated he had to die. Yes like the prosecutor said this Mans punishment for a misdemeanor was death, how unreal.

This was the worst defense attorney and strategy I ever seen, She should taken a plea deal.

THE DEFENSE ATTORNEY was too flippant in his demeanor. He should have showed empathy to the victim, agree with the witnesses and argue only whether her actions were reasonable bc EVERYBODY AIN'T LYING. SHE can't tell us anything more; we SAW what we saw and HEARD what we heard SIR

Ha! The defence lawyer criticises witnesses for not telling the same account as initially stated. BUT when his client gives a differing account to what SHE stated, they said , well it was over 4 years ago !! Double standards, methinks!

Hannah Payne got life in prison. 30 years is a life term in Georga. Those who committed serious violent felonies on or after July 1, 2006, must serve 30 years before being eligible for parole. Life in prison is mandatory for murder in Georgia. She got 30 years plus 13 years. That is 43 years. She will be eligible for parole when she is 68 if she does the 30 + 8+ 5.

he is not explaining or convincing the jury that she is innocent. he seems to running through the facts again. isn't his job during closing arguments to present the evidence that she is innocent, no wonder the jury came back so quickly

She’s a Karen with a gun

This lawyer just said a whole lot about nothing 🙄

Is SuperGuilty an option?

What the hell is he talking about....🤔🤦🏿‍♀️

Was something extra in his water bottle??

After the prosecution closing argument, it's game, set and match!!

Looks like Mama Payne (I’m guessing) and family needs a lesson in courtroom decorum as well as her attorney. Twirling her hair conspicuously in the front row and making facing while someone is discussing a MURDER is not a good look, no matter which side you are on.

She’s been eating real good since she was first arrested

Her lawyer had a few shots before coming to court 🤦‍♀️

So disgusting that he said no good deed goes unpunished.

Why is she at that man window???????????!!!!

She killed a man. Guilty.

The defense attorney and her fail to realize that accident was none of her business. i’m sure the semi truck had insurance She should’ve went home?

This lawyer was so petty that he sounded clownish.

This lawyer told me nothing.

I think her attorney did the best he could with what he had. Seriously he had a mountain to climb. I believe he knew what the outcome would be.

Even in the worse case where the man purposely drove off after an accident, there is still no reason why his punishment is death.

He is just mumbling thru this…what is he even talking about…. Just up there wasting everyone’s time

She can't help herself! still busying herself with other people's business! She looked over,messed with the lawyer's legal pad,then shut it!! 😢

So one of the witnesses had a DUI? He’s not on trial for murder.

He sounds drunk.

Hannah has to know that she is French fried 😂😂. Her lawyer is pissing all over the floor 🤷🏾‍♂️

First of all, I almost forgot what the hell this MF was talking about This cigarette, smoking, scotch, or bourbon drinking, Pretender, not a defense attorney, but a pretender, really lost his clients case, his expressions, they were unnecessary, and he looked very gimmicky, plus it was obvious that he was trying to twist, witness statements, etc. This girl was wrong, plain and simple. She should have minded her own business, he should’ve tried to make her look a little softer, but he couldn’t because her 911 spoke volumes

This lawyer can tell a story but that's what it is fiction

I have watched his trial and it’s so sad for the victims family and the defendant and what I can see here. The defendant seems to feel she’s in the right and many people categorize other people in certain way like Karen’s. There’s some truth to this, and somehow she felt empowered to do what she did, and it’s sad because her life is ruined now because she had a gun and felt she had the power and she ruined peoples lives and her self and what really did her in was no remorse or realizing she had no authority to do what she did and this is what people call Karen

I’ve been watching this for 20 minutes and I have no idea what this lawyer is talking about…it just sounds like a bunch of gibberish.

The next time a high school graduate gets to carry a gun to protect herself and her money till, their employers should make sure these very young adults, raised on TV and movies knows the law and rules about carrying weapons.

Is he drunk? In the movie version Nick Nolte should play him

20:54 he is literally just rambling and babbling now and saying absolutely nothing -

He is not a good Attorney. He made himself look bad. He confused himself trying to confuse and discredit the witnesses. If I was his client, I would ask for half or all my money back. And all those who live in the town this attorney lives in, should not hire him.

this defence lawyer is a disaster!!!

She is toast, she is packing heat and maybe she wanted to be Dirty Harry.

Isn't it super dangerous to run to a vehicle that's leaking......especially with a gun that you may be prepared to use?

Bottom line she is not" the law" she should've mind her own damn business.

Why did her attorney not subpoena the truck driver Kimble 🤔 because it would further prove how out of control she was?

lawyers will say anything for a dollar.

she inroduced a gun, it's all her fault

She is guilty

omg this lawyer put's me to sleep! zzzzzzz

What she did was wrong and ugly and she will be punished. But good god. That attorney. Is he drinking? Best her family could afford , I suppose.

this dude is babbling… she bout to get life for that defense closing

Man stop it she know she was wrong stop it dude 😮

Right now as we speak she's being traded for a pack of cigs by Rough Rita to Big Bertha 😂😂😂 merry Christmas

Perry Mason he’s not

There's absolutely NO QUESTION that she is GUILTY!!! Common sense. She chased. She approached. And with a frikkin gun! GUIL THE FUGGIN TY!

I don't think I've laughed so hard reading through these comments about this man's closing lol. Somebody said "He made it worse for Hannah by opening his mouth" LOL naw but fr wtf is he even talking about in his closing? LOL

This attorney is garbage he cannot have been paid for he must have been given to her by the state.

It would of been a better argument if he and her blamed Casper the ghost lol

she had almost 5 yrs to get herself together & could have changed her fate, somewhat by being a human being 🤨 but instead, KARMA spoke for her... 🤦‍♀️

To the Herring family. I am watching the trial from Ontario Canada. I was very touched by your brother. He did not die in vain. If he hadn't died, I would not have known what a great man he really was while he existed on earth. Ken's life on earth has touched many people.

Its a no win situation to blame the deceased victim on what your client did.

When you guilty this not the defense attorney to hire. Hannah didn’t have a chance with him. Guilty of all charges 😢

Man this fool should open a practice with Amber Heards lawyer. They could be the worst legal minds in one quick stop😂

He not making no darn Since

What a BS argument. 1) He never explained why she cut him off preventing him from driving forward when she was supposed to only follow him. 2) He never explained why she decided to exit her vehicle. 3) He never explained how she got close enough to get into a physical altercation with someone that never exited their vehicle.

This guy *LOVES* to hear himself talk.

I know you heard evidence about this. I know you heard evidence about that. But have you considered the Easter Bunny? If you haven’t, why not?

Guilty!

The defendant is toast.

She can't help herself! still busying herself with other people's business! She looked over,messed with the lawyer's legal pad,then shut it!!

Wow, she sure turned into a big heffer since she was arrested.

This bloke sounds sloshed. Let's hope he's not driving home. The same goes for his client.

I can't even watch him. He is making it up as he goes as he knows the Prosecutions argument is watertight

How is everyone evolved in this case wrong accept your client Sir! Everyone testified against your client and there perception of the events are the same! GUILTY AS CHARGED! Oh we also know why you were pretending to fall asleep! Mistrial! 🤔

Where's Vinnie and Lisa when we need them? 😅

The defense attorney looks and sounds like a drunk.

Even if everything he said is true, getting yourself into a situation where the other person could pull the trigger already seems overboard, especially when you consider the authorities typically dont want the public that involved. I like that people in the public try to help officers, but i dont like untrained undividuals pulling guns in situations that dont need em.

Guilty 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

Where is the state closing argument?

Is he drunk?

These conditions that are NOT ONLY applies to the killers/murderers of both Travis (36) & Gregory McMichael (66), William Bryan (52) who had committed both Felon & Malice Murders of Ahmaud Arbery (25) by also these very same conditions should also apply to Hannah Payne as well too which is, Hannah Payne (25) during & also after her prison/jail sentence is simply (NOT) Allowed to make any money for her actions as such as, Book Deals, Movie Deals, Social Media Deals, & or anything along the lines in any way, shape or form of making money of her experience, of her conviction & her trial at all and should any money should been made to going to a Fund for the Kenneth Herring's family and having this condition being imposed before & given in the nature of her case just to seek to make sure based on her actions have found to be guilty of murder that she (DON'T) Reap some sort of benefit profit of her actions via as such renumeration unto from anyone in form of Book Deals, Movie Deals, Consulting Fees, & Telling her story to someone for exchange of money at all of course.

5:05 - Radiation Fluids leaking out of it? What the F is this guy talking about? This is why you shouldn't hire someone who looks like a character out of the Sopranos as your defense lawyer.

She's 21 yo and doesn't see the bad sides... yet she carries a gun....make it make sense!

This attorney just embarrassing himself at this point.

He put me to sleep! Wtf was he even talking about smh.

This weird he a weird lawyer

put her attorney in prison with her

Liar liar liar

So your closing argument is the dead guy was a drug addict? What the actual Eff?

She pursued and trapped a man, everything that happened as a consequence of HER actions alone. She is a loose cannon literally with zero judgment. She shot and killed a man, if she didn't pull her weapon, Mr. Herring would be alive today. A man lost his life because of Payne and should suffer consequences because she should have known better but defied officials telling her to return to the scene because she was nothing more than a witness and witness don't chase down a fender bender and kill him. Geeze, she should have pleaded out.

A 9 years old child is more intelligent enough and fit for the job than this defense lawyer. What a horrific Lawyer., I'm sure he drink one or two glasses of Gin N juice before court, cant you tell?

he reminds me of a slimy car salesman

The lead attorney is a poor excuse for a lawyer. he did an extremely poor job of representing the guilty. Where in the hell did he get his law degree , Mexico?