Тёмный

HOLDEN VF SS LS3 | NA vs Supercharged 

HarropTV
Подписаться 47 тыс.
Просмотров 175 тыс.
50% 1

There is an age-old argument about which is better NA or Supercharged, while we don’t want to try and solve it, we take a look at the different characteristics of two LS3 cars that took a different path to enhanced performance.
www.harrop.com.au

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

 

6 фев 2018

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 117   
@thesalandkazchannel8971
@thesalandkazchannel8971 6 лет назад
These guys did my ssv ute VF and NA kit exhaust etc and they are awesome guys, plenty of time to show you around and explain everything and the guy tuning in the video (dont know his name) was the guy that did my car and they are all cool and totally professional. I just wish I had more money to step up to the supercharged package, but then Id also need to start budgeting for tyres too.
@Sarncho
@Sarncho 6 лет назад
Hi Sal, is your VF a series 2 LS3? Just wondering it sounds after the OTR modification without the sound enhancer. Thanks!
@thesandeep1987
@thesandeep1987 5 лет назад
How much did it cost you ?
@pitman2911
@pitman2911 5 лет назад
Sal.how much did it cost you bud just thinking of doing the same to my ute..
@snoopfobz
@snoopfobz 4 года назад
How much
@xeftones
@xeftones 5 лет назад
Wish holden they made a LS3 wagon in manual.
@ruppyhouse
@ruppyhouse 6 лет назад
Hi HarropTV, I'm pretty impressed with the Supercharged numbers. A couple of questions. For comparison do you have the dyno graphs from before the modifications? Also, do you know why the torque/power cross over points are not at the same RPM? Thanks.
@dcaseng
@dcaseng 5 лет назад
Are these cars only sold in Australia? These are pretty cool in my opinion.
@dalewhitmore143
@dalewhitmore143 6 лет назад
Do you do LS1 packages? I bet were still talking around the 11-13k mark.
@lindahughes778
@lindahughes778 Год назад
i have a e1 gts ls3 cammed and 3 inch xforce system hiflow cats and varex muffs , if i put a2300 harrop on will it lower the sound of the cam
@DanielOrtegoUSA
@DanielOrtegoUSA 5 лет назад
I have a 2017 Chevy SS sedan aka VFII. I've been on the fence between SC and NA for more than a year. I already have a custom 427 block that can handle 1400hp, but I prefer the sound and grunt of the Harrop Hurricane. It's also a tad more challenging to install on a US left-hand drive. While not near as much bang for the buck; it would be a stand-out compared to SC builds. Aside from bragging rights, I'm not sure I would ever use the TVS2650 to it's potential, because I don't much care for 15-inch M/T's and race modified suspension.
@mikejanson1939
@mikejanson1939 4 года назад
It’s not a Chevy it’s a Holden
@DanielOrtegoUSA
@DanielOrtegoUSA 4 года назад
@@mikejanson1939 Depending on your viewpoint. Here in the USA, I could not order a Holden Commodore from a Chevy dealer, so I had to order the Chevy SS Sedan. I have a hard enough time trying to explain the Chevy SS terminology, followed by the Holden factory thing'.
@nunyubizness5483
@nunyubizness5483 3 года назад
@@DanielOrtegoUSA so that's your name LOL Been reading your posts on the SS forum since you joined. Good to see ya over here. I'm the first member over there. And, also the first banned. F@CK those SS forum moderators. Bunch of censoring D-bags.
@TheAceY2k
@TheAceY2k 5 лет назад
Let me have both please! Once I'm settled, imma be a Holden!
@johndoe-wh6td
@johndoe-wh6td 6 лет назад
I like it! I just dont like somebody’s whining everytime i press the acceleration. And whoever said n/a ( depends what kind of you using engine ) more powerful than supercharged? Commonsense is not very common. Lol
@chinomeehan9061
@chinomeehan9061 6 лет назад
How much for boss 290 FG XR8 supercharged package?
@russellpinkie9775
@russellpinkie9775 Год назад
Fark I love to put a ls3 in my vx wagon 👌,
@chrisfenech6081
@chrisfenech6081 6 лет назад
Good video!What's the difference between your FDFI 2300 and the Magnuson Heartbeat FDFI 2300?With your 2300 kit, you haven't touched the valve train and heads have you?These stock hypereutectic pistons are good for about 410kW (according to GM), you guys are pushing way more than this. Have you guys had no issues with the stock items?Also, your 2300 kit produces more torque than the stock 6l80 transmission was built for.Have you guys had no issues with the stock transmission? Do you torque limit in certain gears?Lastly, how much of an increase to the average fuel consumption do you think one would see?
@tomfanshawe6947
@tomfanshawe6947 6 лет назад
HarropTV what a well throughout, thorough, honest and professional response. This alone is enough to make me steer towards you guys - you seem open, honest and realistic. P.S. great video very informative and well put together. Looking forward to more great content!
@Sixleeta
@Sixleeta 4 года назад
Name of the music in this vid?
@toneabet6252
@toneabet6252 3 года назад
what happens if you put a cam and supercharger
@oscarzt1652
@oscarzt1652 6 лет назад
supercharged is better in the real world because you get more torque and the BWAAAAAAAA scream noise at higher RPMS but I would rather have an NA LS3 that can do 9000rpm
@Elguapo93
@Elguapo93 4 года назад
Why tho? Why not have a car that can do that at 4000rpm? And keep giving lol
@Trpmanne
@Trpmanne 6 лет назад
Where is the Harrop performance shop? I have exhaust cam and otr. But I want the Harrop otr and Cnc heads combo. I do need to get HD clutch as it’s slipping only getting 305kw at the wheels atm
@Trpmanne
@Trpmanne 6 лет назад
HarropTV ah damn hoping close in Sydney
@aussieone3988
@aussieone3988 4 года назад
awesome but the cam not loud enough
@orgillmathew
@orgillmathew 4 года назад
I take option 1
@thomasdavico3107
@thomasdavico3107 4 года назад
Nice vid, However, for the purpose of transparency it would be good if the performance shops (like Harrop)encouraged a trip to the local engineer for certification in order to make them roadworthy.
@closertothetruth9209
@closertothetruth9209 6 лет назад
Supercharged for a sleeper sounds good
@mr260z3
@mr260z3 6 лет назад
Interesting video... I’d be interested in the fuel economy differences between the 2 setups as well as general engine longevity. I’m assuming the boost from the supercharger will strain a factory LS3 more then a head and cam combo.
@kevinobrien4155
@kevinobrien4155 3 года назад
Id be more worried about the longevity of the transmission than the ls3 lol
@ur2slob724
@ur2slob724 2 года назад
If your asking about fuel economy your looking at the wrong car mate. Heaps of Prius for sale
@aussieone3988
@aussieone3988 4 года назад
wow supercharged no problems at all but price tag to much i wait it to drop more
@bigal3446
@bigal3446 6 лет назад
Harrop: with that HO4 cam, what size converter did you fit for the auto? Cheers
@callanfaulkner1192
@callanfaulkner1192 5 лет назад
And what diff gears did you go? 3:9?
@alanblythe9536
@alanblythe9536 4 года назад
@@callanfaulkner1192 3.7 gears, 3500 stall
@ronawitz7965
@ronawitz7965 4 года назад
What type of taillights are on the sedan? I want to upgrade to those! Love the video! Thanks.
@gtbtp2036
@gtbtp2036 4 года назад
RonawitZ they’re off the ‘V’ upgrade
@Wtrxprs007able
@Wtrxprs007able 3 года назад
Factory series 2 calais/ssv
@Aussie_Damo
@Aussie_Damo 6 лет назад
The numbers speak for themselves but the question i wanna know is either S/C or N/A the more bang for buck option?
@__PJ__
@__PJ__ 2 года назад
S/C
@mixalis6168
@mixalis6168 5 лет назад
i want both @!
@jasonswift7098
@jasonswift7098 6 лет назад
I would have thought you have the hurricane set-up if your wanting more power with a best comparison with a supercharged set-up.
@romanjanos
@romanjanos 6 лет назад
HarropTV and it doesn't suit to 6.2 engiene. That set up is amazing for ls7 and not for a ls3
@jasonswift7098
@jasonswift7098 5 лет назад
@@romanjanos You don't know anything about aussie cars and what engines we have.
@romanjanos
@romanjanos 5 лет назад
@@jasonswift7098 I have an hsv clubsport sv black which has an ls3 engiene. The car builded by Nathan Higgins and horsepower factory in Melbourne. I know enough about this cars. I spoke with harrop about they manifold and they didn't recommend for an 6.2 L, just if it stroked.
@romanjanos
@romanjanos 5 лет назад
@@jasonswift7098 plus this engines have outdated from Chevy Corvette/ camaro and then holden could source for the vf2 Commodores.
@mark_tile-man
@mark_tile-man 5 лет назад
Why not have both..
@robertsestito6821
@robertsestito6821 6 лет назад
Why not run the itbs on the wagon?
@undy22
@undy22 Год назад
need both mmm :D
@NicholasCox85
@NicholasCox85 5 лет назад
Why not have both?..... Maybe cause it's like $30,000? Kinda puts a downer on things.
@nunyubizness5483
@nunyubizness5483 3 года назад
@@HarropTV Nice kit. Why such low power to the wheels on the stock LS3 w/headers? I was expecting 700hp and 600tq to the wheels.
@mun33y
@mun33y Год назад
You gotta spend $12,000 + to get an additional 74kw and 157nm by supercharging ??? I’d get a off the shelf turbo kit and call it a day
@clint-zj3cl
@clint-zj3cl 3 года назад
U did the wagooon n/a then sedaaaan . Jokers
@mattdavis2788
@mattdavis2788 4 года назад
Or buy an f6 and do injectors cooler exhaust and make more power for about 1/3 Of the price
@turbosrshit336
@turbosrshit336 4 года назад
Men drive V8's, boys drive 6 cyc
@azza9575
@azza9575 6 лет назад
Anyone with half a bain knows anything with a blower is awsome no comparison
@Gerald5000
@Gerald5000 6 лет назад
I dunno man, part of me loves the power delivery of a blower and the whine, but I'd also love the torquey rumbley feel of an NA engine. Depends how you want the car to feel I guess: noisey hoon car, or sleeper?
@saauuzza
@saauuzza 6 лет назад
Is this the fastest bogan Mobil in Australia?
@thesandeep1987
@thesandeep1987 6 лет назад
Whats the price for NA & Supercharged ?
@closertothetruth9209
@closertothetruth9209 6 лет назад
The comparison in price would be a deciding factor
@mabamabam
@mabamabam 6 лет назад
Just give a rough number.
@rocketmagnet427
@rocketmagnet427 5 лет назад
NA would be 6k max. 2300 fitted with supporting mods would be 15k minimum.
@bobdabuilder4075
@bobdabuilder4075 5 лет назад
gotta be blown to be known
@patrickclose1772
@patrickclose1772 5 лет назад
yesssssss👍👍👍👍🔄👍😱💲💲💲
@liamultraracer2060
@liamultraracer2060 5 лет назад
should of got manuals
@xeftones
@xeftones 5 лет назад
Don't make 6.2 in manual in the wagon except for hsv
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
HarropTV still using a pre-historic hub dyno to get higher numbers??? Why dont you put some wheels on and give customers numbers that go to the ground?
@Aaron.13
@Aaron.13 6 лет назад
It doesn't matter what "numbers" you pull on any dyno, it drives how it drives and a piece of paper can not change that..
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
MrDogsballs ummmmmmm.... never said paper would make it drive different after the job fella, just that the numbers on that 'piece of paper' arent the numbers your putting to the ground
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
H Maccas P.S. its not a dick pulling comp like a reach around, pull through kinda weasel like you would think.... a roller dyno sheet will just be a more accurate reading of what the car actually puts to the ground in everyday situations. Its fucking simple but not as simple as you by the sounds of it
@mranonymous9355
@mranonymous9355 6 лет назад
Good ol' H Maccas sprooking off again
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
H Maccas you truely are an A class fuckwit buddy.... at no stage did i ever say i know more i just dont agree with the final testing method you peanut. Go and do the world a favour mate, u know what i mean. Im done wasting time on simpletons so really do just fuck the fuck off
@AlsAllAussieAdventures
@AlsAllAussieAdventures 6 лет назад
Cant beat the blower!! todays day and age with cops are everywhere, having a fast stealthy car is the go.
@solorunner6391
@solorunner6391 6 лет назад
whipped SC is far more superior than Harrop
@mikenolan3060
@mikenolan3060 3 года назад
Shut up and take my money
@mrmysterious6006
@mrmysterious6006 6 лет назад
Those hub dynoes are not accurate. I would much rather see the power figures with the wheels on as this will show the true number
@revhead929
@revhead929 6 лет назад
Mr Mysterious Dynos are a tuning tool, what matters here is the difference between the power and torque curves of the two cars, tested under what one would assume were the same conditions. Btw on a chassis dyno you can get tyre slip/wheelspin, and it can also be affected by things like tyre compound and pressure. Arguments either way but I would expect that as a tuning tool hub dynos have more repeatable results.
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
revhead929 customers are getting dyno numbers that are basically theoretical or may as well be flywheel hp, and dude my mate dynos 900-1000hp rigs all day with no traction issues. As far as differences go, at an estimate your overpriced mods will help you punch 620hp at the hubs then throw tyres on and run it on proper dyno bet my left nut it will only pull around 580ish. Hope these guys are cheaper than walkinshaw performance anyway
@NicholasCox85
@NicholasCox85 6 лет назад
A hub dyno will be always as, or more accurate than a chassis/rolling dyno. The tyres can slip on a conventional rolling dyno, which leads to errors in the numbers. Different wheel diameters can also make measurements inaccurate. If this is taken out of the equation, how on earth can a hub dyno be worse?
@dcaseng
@dcaseng 5 лет назад
The only thing that matters is measuring stock versus upgrade on the same tool. Every dyno varies in measurement, but as long as you took the before and after on the same Dino, you will get an accurate idea of improvements.
@MadMax-ji8tq
@MadMax-ji8tq 5 лет назад
Good luck hiding a supercharger from your insurance company
@graemewilliams1308
@graemewilliams1308 4 года назад
@Evo Shift Because insurance companies like to find excuses not to pay. Increasing engine power increases their risk. If they know up front then they can either tailor your premium or decline your business.
@Tommo1976
@Tommo1976 4 года назад
@Evo Shift its a great comment, most insurance companies won't insure a V8 if you add a supercharger, turbo or nos. Unless it's standard from the factory, lsa motors. If you find one that will, your paying for it alright.
@mgunner69
@mgunner69 3 года назад
@Evo Shift I bet you're fun at parties
@nunyubizness5483
@nunyubizness5483 3 года назад
@@mgunner69 I sure am. Ask your girl and mom.
@_._._._._._._._
@_._._._._._._._ 4 года назад
My 1974 Morris Marina is faster than these.
@axeman2478
@axeman2478 4 года назад
Do we laugh now or is there more to this comment?🤔
@Brandon-to5sl
@Brandon-to5sl 4 года назад
Lol in aus when max speed is 120km and an turbo ecotec beats most turbo v8s on that speed why go a v8 idk unless you want noise. Supra and skyline are 20 year old engines that make power for less money than an LS god forbid your in an non ls commodore country and even then spending 50k+ on a 15k piece of shit
@MrHC1983
@MrHC1983 Год назад
Great for track useless for around town today now. Too noisy, consumes fuel, speed limits.... But hey anyone under 30 won't care.
@stephenedwards9857
@stephenedwards9857 6 лет назад
what a waste of money on a stationwagan
@andrewross2281
@andrewross2281 6 лет назад
Stephen edwards how dare you say such things
@dimetime0
@dimetime0 6 лет назад
whats wrong with that stationwagon? looks unreal and now sounds and goes unreal
@stephenedwards9857
@stephenedwards9857 6 лет назад
just that...its stationwagon
@yeahnahyeah7872
@yeahnahyeah7872 6 лет назад
Stephen edwards... dont hate cuz u aint got one man, whats your family roll in....prius or a camry?
@stephenedwards9857
@stephenedwards9857 6 лет назад
lolol nice try but way out....6.0 v8 actually
Далее
Harrop Supercharger Testing | LSA-H2650i
4:42
Просмотров 59 тыс.
This Supercharged VF Clubsport is Insane! (605hp*)
11:30
The Hardest Challenge!
00:37
Просмотров 10 млн
Harrop 2300 Supercharger 500RWKW Club
4:36
Просмотров 5 тыс.
Harrop VF SS Upgrade | Part 1
3:36
Просмотров 77 тыс.
HSV GTSR W1 | Harrop Enhanced
2:58
Просмотров 148 тыс.
Mustang Shelby GT500: The Ultimate Muscle Car
0:14
Мгновенная карма 😱
0:10
Просмотров 5 млн