I Watched The Movie *AFTER* For The First Time and It Was Just UNBEARABLY HORRIFIC.. 

I need to talk to whoever said making this movie was a good idea. Drink water Click my link to download Dave today www.dave.com/billybinges Future you will thank you!

Oh God no. Billy, you’re going down a rabbit hole with this one. The movies get worse and worse and honestly I’m ready for you to roast the hell out of them 💀

I don’t know why, but I love watching billy react to toxic romance movies. Him being disgusted is just *chefs kiss*

The books were just as torturous. In the beginning - when she’s in his room - she finds Wuthering Heights, and she’s a literature nerd. When he quotes the book, she’s surprised, thinks it means he’s deep. In reality Wuthering Heights becomes allegorical to their relationship. Two, extremely toxic people engaged in a toxic “romance” 🙄

Y’all show this man some love and respect, he’s torturing himself on our behalf😭😭😭 this movie was ehhh somewhat ok but the movies that come after this one are soo bad💀

Billy, u being annoyed the whole time gave me so much enjoyment 😂😂

Everyone thinks I'm weird for not liking to wear my outside clothes inside. Especially on the bed. Big No. You are quite literally the only person I know who relates.

Drinking game: take a drink every time Billy says “gay boyfriend” 😂

I needed a laugh after the week I’m having. Thank you Billy. I have always liked your videos, and today was a rough day. You brought a smile to my face.

“Does she break up with him before or after she cheats on him?” Well, the movie is called AFTER 😉😂

"Big-headed girl" and "Funny-looking boy" will forever be my fav characters XD Also: "Of course she's never been touched, she's got a gay boyfriend!". Billy, thank you for making my day with this!

I don’t understand how a movie can have so much dialogue and no story. I’m impressed you finished this movie. The only thing it’s good for is roasting 🤣

Billy, I'm so proud of you for sticking through this nonsense (and i read the entire book series- there's 4 books and yes she's just as annoying in the books) 😂 the minute I saw the title, i screamed no because i knew you would hate it. Your disdain for this movie was so funny but i felt so bad you actually watched it. I half thought you'd relate the movie to twilight because they are just as annoying lol. Can't wait for your next video!

Her “high school gay boyfriend” is an insane sentence 😭 you couldn’t pay me to watch this movie tho 😅

This movie is wild and everyone in it is toxic except the school friend. I can't believe you watched this billy lol respect on you for going through this

Billy calling her boyfriend from back home gay the whole time is sending me. 🤣🤣 Also her bf is supposed to be a senior in HS while she’s a freshman in college. Ideally she would’ve been 17 going into HS. But yea kinda weird since she’s moved into the next phase of her life.

“Wooooooow…that’s not her brother? And they kissed 😕” LMFAO I ugly laughed 😭😂

Watching Billy say he relates to Harden and knowing what's coming is hilarious because he's about to 360 himself outta that comparison 🤣

I did not expect Billy to do this movie but I’m so grateful you struggled through it because these movies are ridiculous and horrible. I love them. I know Billy probably won’t do the rest of them (and there’s going to be a fourth one so even more material) so I will cherish this one 😂

“She taking advantage of that sweet sweet little gay boy” 😭😂😭😂

Billy you're exactly what I needed in this night of insomnia ! It's almost 4 in the morning and I'm just chilling watching you react to one of the worst movie ever

In the original story, the dare was that he would take her virginity. And she found out because she found her bloody sheets in his trunk which he needed as proof. Honestly it definitely made him a villain better than the movie’s “I’ll make her fall in love with me” nonsense

I’m proud of you Billy for getting through this!!!

Yes! I was in college and my roommate Suzi had her boyfriend over. I'm a light sleeper, which means that any little noise will wake me up for a minute for sure. But normally I can go back to sleep. So I heard them moving around in bed and originally I was turned kind of towards her bed, so I figured what was about to go down and I rolled over to the other side. And when I did I heard him whisper to her "she's asleep it's okay." And then they proceeded to f***. Lmao

this is the most depressed an exhausted ive ever seen billy lmao like he aint mad or grossed out just. dissapointed

I gotta give you the like, because I cackled my way through the last half. You were SUFFERING. This is why I ain’t ever seen this movie. LOL! I hope you like the next movie you do a commentary for.

Billy please don't torture yourself this series is painful and gets progressively so. I pray for you and everyone else should too.

Also a little backstory for the reason why Hardin started the fight at the camp fire wasn't really for Tessa but he can't stand people forcing themselves on people as he watched his mum get raped when he was a little boy..... also book Hardin NEVER lost a fight. i have no idea why they made him lose the fight in the movie

I haven’t laughed this hard at one of Billy’s videos in a good while. Now he has to watch the rest of them so I can lose it laughing again🤣

I had shower shoes. Flip flops with holes in the bottom. The thought of putting my bare foot on a floor I share with strangers is 🤢

I was a little disappointed that they left out him saving the bloody sheets to prove he took her virginity lol or the fact that they changed it to him trying to get her to love him as oppose to him taking her virginity

You would never catch me in a public shower with my bare feet. Also, I knew within the first 30min of this you would hate it so much. Lol great content though, you always make me laugh during a rough week. Thanks, Billy!!

This is by far THE BEST COMMENTARY you’ve done lmaooo. This truly made my night. Can’t wait for you to watch the other movies 😂

The way it drained his energy! Beginning of the video Billy versus the end, two totally different vibes lol. Also: 100% shower shoes and you can wear outside clothes on my bed but no shoes!

Maybe we could see Ever After? Great live action Cinderella story! Actually my favorite version of it

22:56 YOU GOT ME LAUGHING HARD ON THOSE REACTIONS 😭

Billy, you know damn well you didn't have to do this to yourself or us, I've been drinking my water I swear.😂

BILLY THOUGHT NOAH WAS HER GAY OLDER BROTHER AND COULD NOT HAVE BEEN MORE WRONG IS SO FREAKIN HILARIOUS TO ME 🤣🤣🤣

I've never even heard of this movie so this is an adventure for me. Billy got me convinced to never see it now! Definitely want to see you do the rest of the *50 Shades of Grey* movies. I've never watched the sequels so Billy will be the only way I view parts of it.

After watching the commentary, whoever suggested this should be ashamed of themselves 😒😒😒 POOR BILLY

found your page this morning and been watching it ever since 🤣 your underrated

I just know you're gonna spend the entire time roasting the shit outta this movie and I'm here for it lmao

I thoroughly enjoyed this commentary 🤣🤣 If you plan to do the entire series, you might want to utilise the playspeed button so you can zoom through the bs - there will be a lot of it

I've never read the books or seen the movies but people's reactions are hilarious! Yours especially

now billy....the movies you react to for our entertainment makes you a real one but since you've gone down this wayward path it seems only right that you watch 365 days and apologies in advance to antonio who is also a real one since he has to edit these reactions👏🏾💐👏🏾 #bingers beyond the lights (2014) #bingers dashcam (2022) #bingers the best of me (2014) #bingers high school lover (2017) #bingers fear (1996) #bingers untamed heart (1993)

Congrats, Billy! You made it through a *literal* One Direction fanfiction made into a film!

"I ain't never been touched before bro what is you doin!!" LMFAAAAAAOOOO BILLY IS HILARIOUS😂😂😂😂❤✌

Ayyyyyy Billy back with a splendiferous movie commentary of a less-than favorable movie 💜❤️

25:23 there is actually a song where I'm from that literally goes "drink water and mind my business " 💀🤣🤣

Watching you get more and more filled with rage about how trash this movie is was actually very entertaining 🤣

Billy, good luck with this series. I read the craziest fanfics but I never made it through these books.

Thank you for making me laugh, even tho I was not in the mood at all, thank you, I really needed that now

This is probably one of my favorite commentaries you've done! yes its a trash movie but that's why your reactions are so funny!! I have my headphones on at work (mind you, I work in an office) and I bursted out laughing so many times!! My coworkers think I'm a psycho now lol worth it though!

Watching this movie slowly suck the life from Billy was funny until then end.... Now I just feel really bad! Thanks Billy for suffering so we can be entertained like the mindless TV zombies we are... We truly enjoy your content and no matter how trash you think a reaction is we are here to support it! You can only do so much with the trash you had to work with in the movie.. ahahaha!

Billyyyy English isn’t even my first language and I spelled arbitrary correctly 💀💀

I needed to laugh and you gave me that. Best commentary about After on YT. 🤣

Ah Billy, this was a tough one, could barely enjoy it because I knew you were having a tough time. Thanks for making the video, lets get back to some good ones though

You're so kind always reminding me of water and saying nice things I've only gotten through the intro at this point of me commenting but ur a nice man billy

Hey Billy! Love your content! SO refreshing and SO hilarious! Keep it coming! Please do a commentary on “Everything, Everything” and “All the Bright Places”! :)

watching your reactions is cracking me up! thanks for doing this. made my day. i needed the laugh.

Looking forward to watching this commentary reaction. I've heard about this movie, and seen the trailer. But I've never seen it. This will be a first time watch for me as well. I'm getting a glass of water ready in the refrigerator for when I watch this video. I very highly recommend the Jurassic Park/Jurassic World movie series. #Bingers

The way I spit my water when you said "I ain't never been touched before"🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Aww poor billy. This series will definitely make you tired. However I will say this the second movie was more entertaining. Definitely more ridiculously dramatic yet funny parts.

Love the videos billy u make me laugh every day and u put a smile on my face even when I’m having a bad day I love you so much for helping me feel better after something bad happens💜💜

The way I CACKLED reading this title 😭😭 Billy you brought this on yourself. When you're ready to actually enjoy yourself check out Megamind #bingers

32:17 BILLY OMG i actually sometimes ask my friends to change into different clothes that i provide just so they’re not sitting on my bed or chair with their outside clothes on 😭 idk if that’s weird, but 🤷🏽‍♀️

The gay boyfriend thing 😂💀 Lord have Mercy

I was laughing so hard through this whole thing, you made this movie tolerable 😂

growing up reading fan fictions then having this come out years later, it was awful but also kinda exactly what imagined it to be. #bingers The Perks of Being a Wallflower, i think its something you'd enjoy :) its one of my favorite movies

Bro I LOVE your videos but this is the BEST ONE so far!!!!

I needed this today, both this reaction and the reminder to hydrate X'D Thanks Billy!

It wasn’t bad I loved this I cried laughing so many times😂 as someone who read the books this movie is garbage and they changed the plot bc the movie rated pg surprisingly lol . The bet was to take her virginity not make her fall inlove

Thanks for uploading. Mental health is low today and this perked me up. :)

Has anyone told Billy that her love interest is supposed to be Harry Styles in the books?🤣🤣

I have never even heard of this movie and now I know why there was no after with this lol

this should have just stayed as a wattpad 🤦‍♀️ not even made into a book or movie

This was another fave, lmao u make my day

Lmaoooooo i loved watching you watch this 🤣🤣 it’s so funny . as soon as i peeped her bf was a senior in highschool , and she was starting college i was like she finna cheat

Note for Billy: I am looking, smelling and feeling GOOD-it’s been a great day. You matter and we love you too Billy ❤️💜

WHEN I TELL YOU IM C R Y ING LAUGHING what dyou mean this is ur worst video?? this is ur best! it was so funny that I couldn't stop the tears even if I tried. Thoroughly entertaining! hilarious! it gave me everything. First time I ever wished I could double like a youtube video because my god, my stomach hurts from cracking up.

Yo! The video quality is good! Nice lens Billy!

Honestly one of your funniest videos!!! Terrible movie, but hilarious commentary! Thank you for torturing yourself.

The fact that every single person that watches it think they are brothers always gets me

"This movie is already dumb as hell" 7min 43sec in!! I called it haha!!! pissed under 8min 🤣

I and multiple people thought that that was her brother when watching for the first time they had no chemistry whatsoever

We finally found a love story worst than Twilight.

Did you say deviled egg….😂😂😂😂😭 that one took me away.

I couldn’t get through this. Good for you for doing it! 😂

Thank you so much for doing this reaction video, this movie is hooorrible! I can’t believe they did a trilogy. #bingers

I love the "After" series can you PLEASE do the other two movies tooooooooo please 🥺❗️#BINGERS

You should watch Looking for Alaska It’s a mini series but it’s definitely something I’d like to see you react to

Ew, shower shoes all the way. I have no idea how anyone could go into a public shower barefoot 🤢

I hope you react to the other two, this was hilarious!!

this video seriously made me laugh out loud billy is up there with dylan

I was purposely avoiding this movie bc I knew how bad it was 😭

Billyyyyyy!!! You broke my heart on this one! 💔 This is my alllllll time favorite movie! I’ve seen it more than 100 tines since I first saw it 12/9/19. I’ve seen the sequels numerous times. I paid $421 for my daughter and I to chat with Hero (aka Hardin). I’ve chatted with the author. I’ve read the series (5 books) three times. My daughter and I sell After/Hardin/Hessa March and candles. I have several clothing items that are Hero/After//Hardin related. My daughter and I traveled to ATL for all the filming locations last fall. You’d really be surprised just how many diehard Afternators there are out there! 🤗

Love your shirt and I’m sending extra love because you had to endure the slow torture of watching this god awful movie. My friend was addicted to the book series and I didn’t like fanfiction so I never read them. Watched the first movie and decided never again 😂

In a way you should be proud of the people who suggested this movie. Coz they care more about our entertainment than your feelings. Funniest commentary ever! 😂😂😂

Anger in the first 30 minutes POSITIVE, if not the first 10 lol

Never heard of this. In my day we had Thirteen (2003) as our good-girl-gone-bad teen movie