KIM JIN HO - As We Live (Saldaga) | Immortal Songs 2 | Max & Sujy React 

김진호 ..멋부리지않는 ,멋부릴수없는 진실한 목소리. 심장으로 노래하는 정말 멋진 남자...훌륭한 가수. 늘 응원할게요.

와~ 외국인이 이 노래를 듣는구나.이 노래의 가사나 음원은 너무나 슬프다 못해가슴이 아픕니다. ㅠㅠ

김진호씨! 정말 감동입니다~ 가슴이 저미네요

살다가 이노래가 처음나올땐, 그냥 슬픈노래구나 했는데 이렇게 노래를 들으니, 이렇게 가슴 아플줄이야

정말 김진호의 이 당시 이곡을 부를때 한이 맺혀있었어 자신의 혼에 호소하고 생명을 불태우는듯

크...가사를부를정도라니 곡을이해하고듣는거같아서 너무 좋아요... 좋은리액션감사합니다

Sg워너비는 대한민국 최고지요 여전히 사랑받고 있는 sg워너비노래들

SG Wannabe as a group was actually one of the most popular group in Korea during the mid 2000s. The peak was not very long but for about 4 years, they were the top selling group digital wise and physical albums sold wise in Korea. They won the daesang(grand prize) for 3 straight years.

Amazing performance by Kim Jinho. What do you think? Thx you for watching, Max & Sujy

이곡들을때 항상마음이 찢어지네요ㅠㅠ

진정한 가수.. 늘 응원할께요

채동하 피쳐링 이 여기서 들어가는구나.....얼마나 그리웠으면.......

진심은 통한다...진호의 맘...저 위의 동햄에게도 전해지길~~♥*♥진호 사랑해요.

마이크 하나로 사는 인생이라... 감히 상상도 못할..당신은 정말 대단합니다.

1년전 애엄마랑 같은달에 암으로수술하고 요양병원에서 치료받을때 둘이서 이노래듣고 엄청울었던 기억이 납니다.심장이 차가워지네요.

Kim Jin-ho, who even buried his mom and dad colleagues as deceased.. The song "Living" makes him

국적불문 모든이들의 가슴을 뭉클하게 만드는 대한민국 최고의 명곡

He was apart of one of the most popular korean ballad groups called SG Wannabe. Some of their music videos in the esrly 2000's was unreal!

이야기 듣는 도중에 글남겨요 ㅋ 이와중에 뒤에 소파에서 강아지 자는모습 넘 이뻐요 천사같아요 ㅎ

들을때 마다 눈물이 멈추지 않는곡 ...슬픔의 감정이 목소리를 통해 전달되는군..

채동하님.. 저렇게 젊은 나이에...제가 곧 그 나이가 다가오니 더 마음이 아픕니다.

... I agree... he is so absolutly amazing in telling the song's story His talent is undeniable. 🌹🌹🌹

슬픈데 저쇼파에서 자고있는 댕댕이가 너무 사랑스러워ㅠㅠ💜

I cannot watch this without crying...beautiful performance, and great reaction

이노래 들을때마다 혹은 채동하 이름 들을때마다 너무 눈물나요 sg워너비가 등장해서 팍 터질때가 제 초딩때였는데 수학여행 장기자랑때 남자 아이들이 sg워너비 노래 불렀던게 생각나네요 안쓰럽고 불쌍한 사람...

그리고이노래발표당시에 김진호씨 부친상을 당하면서 불렀다는게 가슴아팠죠...

김진호는 가슴으로부른다 넘넘잘한다

에이씨 또울어버렸어ㅜㅜㅠ

김진호 노래 정말 좋죠 ㅎㅎ

After watching this I went back to when So-Hyang did this song. it was a lot easier for me to understand the pain and anguish that the song talks about. A lot of tears in the audience from both of these performances.

무슨 소리야, 김진호는 팀으로서도 솔로 보컬리스트로서도 이미 한국 탑 반열에 오른 가수인데. 이보다 어떻게 더 높아야 하고 얼마나 더 유명해야해 이미 그는 인정받고 사랑받는 가수야 뭔가 잘못 알고 있는 것 같아서 바로 잡고 싶어지네 타팬인 나조차

He's got a beautiful voice and he did a beautiful rendition of that song!

A stunning, emotional song. Excellent!

제일 진실된 감정과 현재를 노래라는 매체로 자신의 존재를 비추는 그런분이라는 생각이 항상 들어요.세상이 그에게 준 상처도 사랑도 있는 그대로 받아들여 덧붙이지 않고 표현하는 그냥 있는 그대로의 내추럴할 남자이자 묵묵히 견디고 받아들이는 깊이 있는 사람이자 아티스트 그자체 인듯 싶습니다.

표정 보면 안다 이형은 워너비 찐이다.

그와중에 강아지귀 파닥파닥ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

레전드지 이건...

This song makes me so sad I cry everytime

김진호보면 너무 굳건해서 뒤에 있으면 어떤 풍파도 다 막아줄거같은 든든함이 보임 얼마나 많은 상처를 딛고 일어서야 저럴수있을지 가늠도안된다...

중간에 채동하 목소리 나왔던건..아시겠지...?...ㅠㅠ...너무 슬픈 곡. 채동하와 함꼐 불렀을 때의 살다가와 잃어버린 후 살다가의 곡의 느낌이 달라진....

Thanks for this reaction. I didn’t know this performance.

한때 최고의 인기를 누렸어요 한국에서 인기가 없다고? 하셨는데 세대차이 입니다

Kim jin ho-my love by my side- is amazing

예전엔 "살다가" 였는데 나이들고듣는데 "살다 가" 로 들리네요ㅠㅠㅠ

눈물나네요ㅜㅜᆢ

외국인이 이렇게 까지 공감하는건 처음보네.

멍뭉이 귀엽땅♡

채동하........... 너무 마음이 아픕니다

이노래는친할머니생각하게하는노래라서 더욱더눈물이나는노래네요

Oh! It really wasn't until the chorus that I realize this is a song that So-Hyang and the number of other people had covered. I didn't really know what the song was about until you guys explained it. Wow explanation mark What a Sad Song.

정말... 언제나 우리 곁에 있을 줄 알았는데... 자살 소식 듣고 다시는 듣지 못했던 곡...ㅠㅠ

SG 워너비가 인기가 없다니 ㅋㅋ 한시대 풍미한 가수임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Tears tears tears... keep crying .could not stop crying ㅠㅠㅠ

You've got wrong information. He is very famous singer in korea. He is most popular singer.but he didnt show up on tv after one of his member is killed himself thats why.

‘살다가’가 ‘살다가’가 아니라 ‘살다 가’ 였구나.....

김진호♥

쇼파에 댕댕이들,,, 자다가~~ 자다가~~ 자다가~~~ 귀 한번 털고~~~ ~~~~~~쭉 ~~~ 자다가~~~ ~~~~무슨말 하나 귀 쫑긋^~~~~ 자다가~~~!!

살다가... 살다 가...

해외반응 중에서 남자반응 중엔 옆에 캐다나 국기 옷 입은 분이 최고다

이 영상을 보는 나는 슬프지만...뒤에 강아지는 졸고 있어~~~아니...자구있네~~~😭

SG WANNABE is known and respected in SK, they're not as popular bc they don't want to be. They rarely do TV appearances. Kinda like SoHyang, but for different yet similar reasons. They want to help people through their music, hence why he'd rather perform at schools and hospitals. SoHyang also wants to help people, but through God's will.

Actually the song is not written by Chae Dong Ha but by Ryu Jae Hyun, a member of another group called Vibe which is a male R&B duo (formerly trio), the song was the ending song of a korean mbc drama Sad Love Story. Initially, Sg wannabe was a faceless group meaning they released songs without anybody knowing who they are, the intention was to allow the public to only focus on their music instead of appearances. Saldaga was their second album, and the music video for this song is part two of a two part music video, the first part being Sin and Punishment (another SG Wannabe song). Saldaga was the title song, thus i think this album was special for them as it was at the peak of their fame, and that year they got the daesang(grand prize) for the album in the golden disc awards like he said in the video. And yes, when the stage darkened the voice in the background was Chae Dong Ha part in the original song. I have no idea why they are not popular, but I’m sure nobody will doubt that they have strong vocals not only referring to Kim Jin Ho but the rest of the members as well. The first song you heard in the video is called “Timeless” it was their first album title song and my personal favorite. It is a beautiful tribute, thank you for the reaction! If you are interested in Davichi, maybe you can react to this song ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1Xn3EOB69Qc.html its a cover performed on the show called Two Yoo Project - Sugarman on the korea cable channel JTBC, it has english sub but I am not sure of the copyright claim. The show concept is to invite past singers(those that disappeared from the public eye) to the show and have other singers remake their hit songs. Davichi is a female duo and they have stunning vocals too.

제가 보는 유튜버 커플중에 제일 마음따뜻한 커플이십니다♥

아 눈물나요. 눈물났어요 ㅜㅍ

그와중에 외국인뒤에 강아지들 잔다ㅋ

동하형..진호형..용준이형..석훈이형

진짜 끝내주네

Miss Chae Dong-ha so much~~ thx again for you guys reaction to that.

Ali also did a very beautiful and Powerful rendition of this song on the king of masked singers.

살다. 가.....

Kim Jinho is the best singer I know in expressing sadness and regret through his performances as you could tell from Family Portrait and Saldaga (As I Live). The emotion is so raw and heart-felt in these two performances. I wondered also why I don't see him more often. Perhaps the trauma he suffered is so intense that it had molded him as a person and made his music difficult to handle for the general audience, however great it may be. Sohyang also covered this song. Even as an avid Sohyang fan, I'd pick my preference with this rendition from Kim Jinho. Davichi is a femal duo group with fantastic vocals. You saw Kang Minkyung in the show. Her partner is Lee Haeri. As an anecdote, Sohyang took the throne on the show King of Masked Singer from Lee Haeri.

Yes, Dongha was singing in the song. I love KJH, but only for two to three songs. Other than that, I couldn't find any others that resonate with my heart. Dong Ha apparently committed suicide due to depression. He was very close to their manager, who committed suicide a year earlier. The people whom you saw in the room are contestants. The lady is from the group Davichi, which is a very popular two woman group.

WOW!

한국어 너무 귀엽게 하세요 ㅎㅎ

빨래방에서 빨래돌리다가 울고가네..

내눈물이 마를만한데....그렇지않는건...미치겠다ㅠ

절절해 ㅠㅠ

I cry too TT

울다가~ 울다가~~ 푸다다닥!!!(강아지 귀터는 소리) 울다가~

노래 찾고 울고이었는데 뒤에 강아지 때문에 빵터졌네요 너무 평온함

뒤에 강쥐들...주인이 노래를 부르던가 말던가 " 나는 잔다 "모드네 >_

존나 슬프네

지금 들으니까 가사가 좀 유치한대 김진호 목소리가 그걸 뛰어넘내

하 감동 차올랏을때 차태현이 씨앗씨앗으로 감동파괴..

ㅅㅂ 뒤에 쇼파 개꿀잠 자고있는거 개웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋ

OMG amazing!!! Reaction I love this song but My favorite is SoHyang version 😻❤❤

He WASN'T on a band called wonnaone, he IS on a group called SGWannabe...

❤❤❤❤❤

If you check out these reactors, you will see them all crying or even traumatised : 1. Aria K 2. Cleverly Cat 3. Katy 4. Lase O 5. Bananabae and 6. Violett Reacts. Aria K. looked to be traumatised by it. Katy said she also tried committing suicide before hence she could empathise the situation. The rest were also tearing up.

남자들만 알수있는 끈끈한 우정

캐나다 남성분이 감수성이 풍부하신거 같네요

아 ㅠㅠ

뒤에서 개는 세상 편하게 주무시네....ㅋㅋㅋ 아..ㅋ 개웃겨! ㅎㅎ

감정을 느끼시는건 좋은데 영상을 끊고 토크는 안하셨으면해요ㅠ 한참 감정이입하면서 같이 몰입하는데 일시정지 누르고 토크.. 몰입이 깨져요ㅠ 안그래도 유튜브 광고땜에 깨지는데ㅜ 그래도 영상 잘봤습니다! 한국 노래 좋아해주시고 또 같이 슬퍼해주시고 감사해요~

영자막은 분명 맞는데 뭔가.... 한국어.. 한국가사의 의 그런 말로 표현하지못한 정서가 전달이 안되긴한다....... 그래도.... 목소리로 씹캐리............. 다시한번 보고싶습니다 완전체 SG워너비........

Puppy is cuty~♥♥♥

노래 듣다가 눈물아ㆍㆍㆍ 그런데 강아지들 자다가 자다가 자다가~

you must react to So Hyang's cover of As I Live. it is very different, but very beautiful and heartfelt.

소파에서 자는 개 ... 개 웃김 ㅋㅋ

아직은 아냐 살다 가 제발...제발..... 부탁할께 살다 가