Music Teacher Reacts to Jinjer "Who Is Gonna Be The One" | Music Shed #21 

I think that, independent of meaning, both wordings have commas. I am not sure, because I'm basing that on my native language's grammar, which is not English, but, since "technically", in the first case, should be after the verb in the direct order, and in the wording you had it's in the beginning of the sentence, you should put a comma anyway.

@@CesarDainezi Sure, but you wouldn't phrase it like that if you were being formal in the first case, anyway, so it's a moot point. It's done for emphasis here, and it works. Ain't nothing wrong with it.

@@hiTocopter Whatever...

yes PERENNIAL! first then teacher teacher

so much this!

Damn, well said! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Saw them live on a TINY stage last year. They are even more astonishing when close to them. You said it... Her face when she sings. Huh.

that's because she's an introvert :) but on the stage she slays that self-confidence!

@@LadyLazarus1027 Yeah, i think that may be one of the reasons i'm drawn to her, as i am one as well. Hell, I wish i could undergo a transformation like she does.

@@apocalypseofoto lucky...SoB

Give 'Once Human' a go :)

Teacher teacher please..🤞🤞🤞

@@Jessica-zg5mb ooooh yes, once human - eye of chaos is my fav :p

Actually Jinjer is not the only one in the world with this growling voice. Alissa White-Gluz from Arch Enemy has similar growling.

I can't find it! But that's very cool, I'll keep lookin!

Arch enemy vocalists growling sound like an ass.

Anil Singh hater spotted

@@AnilSinghNegii Check out Abnormality

Yes, Perennial is amazing, I Speak Astronomy is good, if you really want to hear her quick vocal changes, Teacher Teacher. For something completely off the wall Judgement and Punishment.

I agree, with one slight difference. I think the lyrics, like the album in general, are referring specifically to the environmental issues, with lines like "does anyone have a reply to the question 'what does the water taste like?'" and "who will recognize his mother's face without the protective mask that she wears?", with the latter frankly hitting harder than ever thanks to covid

@@themorrigan1312 Agreed. It's a war cry.

When the eyelashes come off, it’s gotta be slammin!!!

Seriously. I've done gigs with so many girls that sing like this lol. They don't quite look like her though.

ive heard a lotta metal screamin females but none of them have the powerful badass sounds tatiana does, with great variety in technique. most of the others sound like they are straining or a bit hysterical... as most male screamers do.

Different drummer on the album. The evolution is Vlad....

@@eatfrenchfries1 Vlad is more like a quantum leap in the dynamics department. Every Jinjer drummer has had something great to offer, and a bonus to deep listening to the whole discography is seeing how those differences have always influenced the rest of the compositions. The early stuff is really high energy and musically challenging in a punk-like way. King of Everything shows a clear upgrade in the drum kit sound quality (the drummer for that album now works studio production with the band, especially drums - his career choice). And then there's Vlad the Maestro who honors all of it while finding ways to make it even better on a hilariously small kit.

There is one that has like a title that is in like russian or something.. that's my favorite. Its soooooo good. I think the lyric is "the way I survive"

JINJER - Желаю значит получу (I want it I'll get it) Official Tour Video 2014: music.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-T8QLjAPUwmE.html

@@donutlover9222 The title translates to "I Want It/ I'll Take It," or at least that is how it is presented on various official listing. It's outstanding to be sure and great example of what hardcore music is compared the many other styles Jinjer incorporates. Very aggressive and straight forward. I love it, but my tastes lean a little more in that progressive direction, so songs like "I Speak Astronomy" tend to get a little more play. It's really hard to rank Jinjer songs: they're ALL so good.

Spiritbox is great in the studio, but show me a live show where they do the same. The bassist is strumming a single note the whole time in both.

Show me any other harsh-tone vocalist, period, that is as present and CLEAR in their tone as she is. I'm of the opinion Tatiana is fundamentally the best harsh vocalist on the planet. She doesn't have the biggest range, but is we're talking about overall quality of sound, how it fits in the mix, and how clear you can hear the words she's saying, there just simply isn't a comparison.

@@mikewebster1743 Check out Opeth. I recomend starting with Harlequin Forest. Live or studio, does not matter.

Blue hair does not make a singer...

I second this song. It's a full on brutal technical masterpiece.

Sit, Stay, Roll Over got them the deal with Napalm Records 🔥

Otep Shamaya as well, she can do some brutally low guttural growls.

I agree that the audio quality on Cloud Factory official live isn't the best. The recording of her growls is disappointing. Also the official video is really well done. Who Is Gonna Be The One is the song that made me a harcore Jinjer fan. The ending hits me especially hard because I used to be all-in supporting the people trying to keep things crappy for the sake of thier own wealth and only woke up half a decade ago.

While Kingdom is certainly great, More is even better. And he does it live on EMGTV too, but I never see anyone recommending it.

Higher or deadhead is my choice.

his newest song why? is good to react to. best singer in metal.

I love it: “their cleans!”

Alissa has different styles she can use, doubt she's as flexible as Tati but still pretty good. Reason To Believe includes some clean screaming that is very reminiscent of Axl Rose.

Eugene says the guys come up with songs in different ways. Sometimes one of them will write the song, sometimes they figure it out while jamming. Eugene says Tati improvised most of the vocal composition on their most recent album - Tati's evaluation was less charitable, saying "I wasn't prepared" haha. They did 152 songs on several continents that year and did the album in between all that. I'd note that while Tati gets most of the focus, Tati's vocal composition is heavily based on what the guys create, with the songs that are less creative instrumentally also being the songs that end up kinda flat vocally (at least in compariosn to their best work, it is all excellent metal, but I'm so spoiled haha) - so your statement about the whole being more than the sum of its parts is very spot on. Who Is Gonna Be The One is unique because it was originally composed for two guitarists, then after their rhythm guitarist left to do acting they re-composed it from the ground up to use just Roman's guitar and Eugene's 5 string bass, and refined the song a lot, IMO - most notably the original ending was more jazz, but they turned it into reggae which is awesome. Pit Of Consciousness is absolutely one of the best. And yes, both versions are epic and wll worth reacting to. If only one is done, do the live in Kiev though.

incredible voice

@@MusicShed check out "Perennial". It shows her range and cleans way better.

the most savage growls of anything they've released

That must be THE fav - everyone's telling me bout it, I'm gonna hold off till next reaction!

Metal bands have some of the most skilled musicians in the world. Technically they are spot on!