Тёмный

REAL TALK: Interview with Former Jehovah's Witness 

ExJW Critical Thinker
Подписаться 44 тыс.
Просмотров 65 тыс.
50% 1

#exjwsthink #jehovah #jehovahswitness #exjw #exjwinterview
Former Jehovah's Witness elder/bethelite is discussing his own personal experience about what he knows about the practices and policies of the Watchtower, Bible & Tract Society.
JT & Lady Cee interview a mental health professional that is currently fading from the organization.

Опубликовано:

 

25 дек 2016

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 474   
@MonaLisa-yb9bq
@MonaLisa-yb9bq 4 года назад
Exactly!!! I used to cry during the group for service. I would cry in the washrooms at the back of the Kingdom Hall. And the solution over many decades, is do more bible reading, preaching, praying with my husband (exhusband), etc. Finally, in my forties, I started on anti-depressants. I have clinical depression. Then my husband used to tell me that taking anti-depressants were a bandaid for my REAL problem. So I got rid of my real problem and divorced him!
@WJTM88
@WJTM88 3 года назад
Priceless
@brooklynnedenali8841
@brooklynnedenali8841 6 лет назад
This was so on point. I left at 19 and went back 15 years later. I thought I was doing the right thing and faught to be baptised. After being told by a brother that ran the assembly hall that Jehovah didn't love me due to having a worldly boyfriend. I kept going and became baptized. After baptism, I started noticing many off and odd things. My baptism was the beginning of the worst mistake of my life but also my awakening period. Thank Goodness I observed and woke up.
@ShoNuffSoulBro1
@ShoNuffSoulBro1 5 лет назад
Brooklynne Denali: I too got baptized at 21 because I felt it was the right thing to do, to be in “God's ark” as it were, and because they were preaching heavily that “This Generation” was so near to the End. That was back in 1981 ! ! I've just recently woken up to an awareness of the history of erroneous teachings and failed predictions (such as overlapping generation) and it has caused me much mental anguish and regret.
@albertroy6185
@albertroy6185 2 года назад
I'm
@victoriousballa236
@victoriousballa236 6 лет назад
In 2005 I had a hysterectomy, the doctor woke me out of surgery and said your flossing blood fast you need to rethink blood I said get the machine to recycle mine so he did. I got mersa from the machine which almost took my life as well. I was by myself and when I called my mother and told her the doctors can't believe I'm alive from losing so much blood, she said huh there is some one who needs me right now and hung up the phone. She never did have love that's why this organization is a fit for her. I feel shocked that I'm just seeing g this.Thank you for your help. Agape
@rozs9919
@rozs9919 7 лет назад
I follow my own religion from within. I read the bible, apply what I learn, and share with others. Jesus is the only mediator needed, otherwise go non-denominational.
@lucillehills4012
@lucillehills4012 7 лет назад
Roz S Amen 1 Timothy 2 : 5; Acts 17 : 31 ; Matthew 25 : 31, 32; Luke 21 : 34 - 36
@privateeye6075
@privateeye6075 7 лет назад
Amen, we do not need no seven men who are not inspired by God. We should study on our own.
@UJB123
@UJB123 7 лет назад
Roz S Yep. it's not all that hard to understand not to aggravate your neighbors and not to steal their stuff. To treat others with dignity and help them out (if you can) when in need. Jesus just isn't that difficult to follow.
@dinaleon3247
@dinaleon3247 7 лет назад
Roz S this info is not correct, they actually think that theirs still over 4000 alive in earth. Don't make stories with out facts just because of hate
@bi37
@bi37 7 лет назад
Dina Leon he said ALMOST none which are not alive. Not that they all are dead. And you said that magical word they THINK there might be 4000 left. As usual the gb is clever in word usage. Check back in 20 years they'll still say that same number exits because if all 144,000 are dead and who knows they could all be dead by now. The gb then has to scramble to come up with a new scheme to keep you hanging on.
@nickelslynn9639
@nickelslynn9639 7 лет назад
Thank you so much! First-time listener. This was much-needed information that came to me at a time that has been quite challenging. I have a MA in English, and 3 other writing/computer degrees, so am very well educated, as Wes is, and left for doctrinal reasons, as well as for good plain old common sense reasons. I have been disassociated for 16 years, but the long arm of the WB&TS still reaches into my heart and causes pain. My son and daughter-in-law and small gradsonn (as well as my parents and brother) are still in the Truth. They had been allowing me to see my grandson (off and on depending on how strict they decided to follow the rules that year), and called me Monday to tell me that I could no longer see him. He has been asking for me repeatedly...but they have not responded to my texts or phone calls until this past week. I was told that he has started commenting at the meetings (he is 4), and that he can now no longer have association with me. His constant requests for me have caused them to make a hard stand and it has been heartbreaking, but your show was recomended by my ex-husband once he heard this, and I decided to listen. I'm glad I did. I feel so much better. I just hope that my grandson, who is very intelligent, will soon begin questioning and come up with his own conclusions. In the meantime, I'm wondering what they will tell him? It will most definitely be a lie, which is contrary to their beliefs. They may tell him I don't love Jehovah - WRONG, or that I'm dead -- well I do consider myself "one of the walking dead!," or that I just don't love him anymore -- all would be lies. Time will tell. I will make sure to listen again. Thank you for this comfort in a great time of need. I was brought into the organization at 5 by my mother, baptized at 12, and left at 39. The stories we could all tell would probably make peoples' heads spin...it's nice to know we are not alone.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Your story is very touching, yet we hear it all the time. It is so sad to hear how many people have been affected by their shunning policy and to think your son and daughter-in-law think they are doing the right thing. We are happy that you were able to tune in to our channel. It is our desire to assist those in need if not do anything but provide them with a confirmation that they have made the right decision to leave. Have you had a chance to read about Barbara and Joe Anderson? They too have been shunned by their son and daughter-in-law and they are not allowed to see their grandchildren either. Here is a link to their web site watchtowerdocuments.org/ and here is a link to a video interview where they talk about being shunned ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-j0hPiMIXDWM.html JT worked for Joe Anderson when he was at Bethel and we know them very well. ~Lady Cee
@nickelslynn9639
@nickelslynn9639 7 лет назад
Thanks, Lady Cee, I will look it up. I don't think I have seen that. Keep up the good work.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
You're welcome! all the best to you. Hang in there. Maybe one day there will be a crack in your sons foundation and he will be willing to take a second look.
@nickelslynn9639
@nickelslynn9639 7 лет назад
Thanks. I watched Barbara's story and replied on that post. I hope she sees it.
@savedbygrace791
@savedbygrace791 7 лет назад
Nickels Lynn. I advise you to pray in faith and ask God to deliver your family out of the Org. He is a loving God and nothing is impossible with Him. Never underestimate the power of prayer. God bless you.
@brotherhype-maninchristjes2766
+ExJW Critical Thinker Praise the LORD i was never a Jehovah's Witness ,but what an eye-opener. i love this so much. i am learning so much. God bless. Agape love
@EvelynnLandrum
@EvelynnLandrum 2 года назад
40:27 😂😂😂 "There are some of us who think we know more than Jehovah..." JT you had me dying there! You're the best. 🥰
@lizcuero9065
@lizcuero9065 7 лет назад
I'm 43 and I am working on a resume, cover letter and references! A bit late but I'm changing. Retirement plans ahead.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Liz Cuero Congrats!
@alomaalber6514
@alomaalber6514 6 лет назад
at 43 you have time, save up for retirement! you can do it!
@brickbybrick6516
@brickbybrick6516 5 лет назад
Go into sales. Youv had years/decades of training. I did it and made a decent wage. If you can sell religion, you can sell anything. If its of interest, i can send you a link to a book which perfectly translates theocratic ministry school into real world selling. Just an idea. You can do anything you want. Your free now.
@smellslikefreespirit670
@smellslikefreespirit670 5 лет назад
@@brickbybrick6516 please.... want that book prismur@gmail.com
@brendagordon4571
@brendagordon4571 4 года назад
At 43, you shouldn't have let your age stopped you.
@hermwash
@hermwash 7 лет назад
I really enjoyed listening to this discussion that you had with Wes! It was outstanding. You are correct.....If Jehovah's witnesses could have discussions like this it would be all over for watchtower. Thus the reason for the shunning. I get it. They want people to feel isolated and alone. No independent or critical thinking is allowed by this cult. Great job Lady Cee, JT and Wes!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Thank you!
@Wes41267
@Wes41267 7 лет назад
Thank you for your kind words.
@otistemplejr.7511
@otistemplejr.7511 3 года назад
It's a protection for the religion, the people who are being shunned have come into the light, their followers are in the dark, they don't want their followers to know the truth, that it's a cult
@sonyaabraham826
@sonyaabraham826 4 года назад
Lady Cee, JT and Dr. Allen, enjoyed this Critical Thought segment, Thank you! This is why every exjw should take a Critical Thinking class. It will literally open your eyes and help you to question, discern and process information. Asking critical questions, promotes understanding and making informed decisions when followed by research from various sources. I currently hold a Bachelor’s of Science in Psychology and plan on getting my Masters soon, but found the critical thinking course my favorite.
@lesliejohnson8738
@lesliejohnson8738 4 года назад
Starting at 16:24 with Bro. JT talking about the psychology class and questions he and Lady Cee took, really got me 😥
@southernbawselady7092
@southernbawselady7092 7 лет назад
Thank you!!..Thank you!!..Thank you!!..I needed to hear this amazing discussion because sometimes we can think we are so alone in our thoughts!.. especially when you have no one to share them with due to the fact of someone running to tell the Elders!...I now have the confidence that I was needing in order to stand my ground...I know that I am in good company and I cannot thank you all enough!!.. You all have been a tremendous help to me and I am definitely going to tell everyone about your channel because this is where the real "Truth" is being spoken!.. I love you all from the bottom of my heart!! 💟💜💛💚💖.. please keep the video discussions coming!.. they are very needed and therapeutic!!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
You are quite welcome! Thanks so much for your kind words! hugs
@TeeHuguley
@TeeHuguley 5 лет назад
0
@akatheheretic3014
@akatheheretic3014 4 года назад
Southern Bawse Lady , I couldn't Agree with You more! ☺️
@mindsightent
@mindsightent 6 лет назад
JT I just wanna say, I appreciate what you're doing, you and Lady Cee. Keep up the good work. Everything you touch on is true.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 6 лет назад
mindsightent we are glad you enjoyed it, please be sure to share it EITH anyone you think it might help
@roseofsharon853
@roseofsharon853 7 лет назад
Thank you for doing this interview. I loved listening to the reasons why I believed such rubbish! It made me laugh and really cheered me up. Raymond Franz book also had a profound effect on me. Regarding the points you mentioned about the amount of teenagers that are leaving the organisation, My son, who is 22 and left when he was around 15 told me that all his generation google everything, If a witness called on them they would just look up the subjects on the internet. They are lucky they have the tool that we and our parents didn't have! Good for them!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Rose of Sharon glad you enjoyed it Please share it with someone is all we ask.
@cheyhorse0382
@cheyhorse0382 3 года назад
I relate to sooo much of this, nearly ever topic addressed. I wish I could’ve been part of this conversation, lol. Thank you for this, the reassurance that we’re not crazy.
@cmccracken5976
@cmccracken5976 3 года назад
I left in 2011 and my life got better. I made more money, travelled to Europe, etc. My mental health is so much better.
@marlowebster487
@marlowebster487 5 лет назад
I’m listening in 2019. I hope Brother Wess is enjoying his retirement. Giving thanks for your lives and continually sharing spiritual truths ❣️ #criticalthinking One love from London 🇬🇧
@aprylbeever1741
@aprylbeever1741 6 лет назад
Thank you so much I feel so much better It's been years feeling alone thank you again..
@donnalesacross2053
@donnalesacross2053 5 лет назад
You all killed it I can’t stop laughing out loud real talk
@stylishoversixty9459
@stylishoversixty9459 7 лет назад
Marvelous conversation so many things discussed that not only took me back down my unfortunate memory lane of the many wasted years spent being a part of a mind controlling organization but have definitely reinforced my resolve never again to give a fraction or ounce of consideration of ever rejoining an establishment so full of falsehoods and back peddling JT its great to hearing you again I do enjoy Lady Cee videos and interviews but you always open my eyes to the fact of just how intoxicated I was for several years drinking the JW kool-aid thanks to you both for all the fine work you are doing!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Frank Gadson how have you been
@deekid311
@deekid311 7 лет назад
I can so relate to the brother around the 21/22-minute mark, when he starts talking about how field service is the answer to everything. I'm in a very similar position right now as far as being considered to be a ministerial servant. I'm actually a full-time student who, for the most part, does meet the average monthly quota for time spent in the ministry. Compounded with being in school, my family struggles financially, our living situation isn't the best, and I have a sickly grandmother to care for along with my aunt and mother. Field service is oftentimes the furthest thing from my mind. Yet, when the circuit overseer comes and looks at my service records, the elders tell me I should be doing more, DESPITE everything they know is going on in my life. Ridiculous is an understatement...
@deekid311
@deekid311 7 лет назад
Absolutely, family is first priority. And I'm trying to keep that in the forefront of my mind, but it's hard when you have an aunt that's so brainwashed and devoted to pioneering, who's barely holding on to a part-time job.. she's more so concerned with getting her 70 hours a month rather than getting a DECENT job that can help us SURVIVE. she wouldn't understand, or agree with anything that you're talking about.. she's confident that despite our economic hardship, the "friends" will always come through or help out in some way.. but the whole Bethel layoff fiasco is tangible proof that that's NOT the case.. I am very familiar with Marcus Vaughn's videos. I've been very enlightened by his experiences.. so eye-opening. And you're right; these elders and circuit overseers and governing body members aren't going to pay my bills.. that's why I'm doing what I have to do to live comfortably.
@deekid311
@deekid311 7 лет назад
Apost Hole yes. And anything REMOTELY against the organization, she will quickly dismiss.. she's one of those ones who are very obdurate in her belief in the organization; God himself would have to come down and tell her this religion is corrupt for her to get it
@vitajay85
@vitajay85 7 лет назад
My sister was a JW during the time my mother was dying from lung cancer. She took my mother to the chemo treatments since I wasn't at home during the time and my dad was working hard to make ends meet. She was criticized for not going out in field service. I think this was the reason she left the Watchtower Society. This was sickening to think that they would care more for her going out in field service instead of assisting a dying mother.
@deekid311
@deekid311 7 лет назад
Vi Johnson really a shame.. so sad.. but this just proves how insensitive JWs can be and what they're programmed to care more about..
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Yes, it's very sad how the culture in the organization only praises those that go door-to-door. It was definitely a wake up call for your sister. Sorry your family had to endure that.
@Jennifer-ky9bw
@Jennifer-ky9bw 7 лет назад
This is one of my new favorite channels. Thank you! So much help, with so much skill in educated communication. So refreshing! So exciting to know some in the cult are watching, that may just get that seed planted.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Jennifer Brumlow you are welcome
@lizcuero9065
@lizcuero9065 7 лет назад
Freedom from weirdos feels amazing!
@cynthiacrawford1
@cynthiacrawford1 6 лет назад
My dad has said the same thing “where are we supposed to go?” I don’t know but not there!
@lizcuero9065
@lizcuero9065 7 лет назад
I like the end results of my NEW role models that have graduated from college. I feel like living. Thank you for a glimmer of hope and light at the end of the tunnel! Thank You!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Liz Cuero hang in there
@joie1069
@joie1069 2 года назад
Lady Cee and JT..... I would just like to let you know that I absolutely admire and respect both of you and love your channel! Thank you.
@spikeoramathon
@spikeoramathon 7 лет назад
I think I commented before (I miss my memory), but BRAVO, gentlemen and lady! Wes, I am very impressed! Blessings on you for the work you do. And, JT and Lady Cee, I love hearing both of you. I think this is one of your best vids yet!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Thanks, Spike!
@lindadent1138
@lindadent1138 7 лет назад
I lost my faith and belief in the power of the appointments of the brothers through holy spirit when they appointed my husband ministerial servant.Then eventually elder I reasoned holy spirit has nothing to do with it he was not qualified at all.Our household was weak it appeared strong exsteranally.I was a wife that cried out for help it feel on deaf ears.I labeled it appointed by the buddy system.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
linda dent the Internet is not the friend of folks hiding stuff
@lucillehills4012
@lucillehills4012 7 лет назад
I used to attend the Meeting of a very famous multilevel company that starts with the letter A, I am amazed at how much my brain was being transformed. ..wow. ..as soon as I stopped I became like a popped balloon; and when I decided to stop going to the brain wash I became experiencing the same feeling.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
pick Nona I used to belong to the soap company as well. Very much like the wt indeed
@ChildofGod.501
@ChildofGod.501 7 лет назад
I truly enjoy these interviews. I have experienced the high handed attitude of the elders. I was appalled. I was losing my mother to cancer and was unable to attend meetings or to go out on the service. No one came to my assistance but called for my field service report. My mom died and I was forced to take a look at this religion. They' re cold. They are playing tennis with you all the time. You tell them your problems and they pelt it back at you. You are always not doing enough.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
jason isreal we worked for a cold hearted book publishing company and actually believed it had something to do with our standing before God the Almighty We were so wrong
@jiggyone868
@jiggyone868 4 года назад
Don't blame the local elders, they're also puns in this game. They're all victims in this prison.
@brendagordon4571
@brendagordon4571 4 года назад
Sad, but some cases, it's true The same here.
@jillianlee2878
@jillianlee2878 4 года назад
I know what you mean Jason isreal when I tragically lost my daughter in a traffic accident, I was asked by one of the brothers if I was doing my Bible reading...cold...
@annah5592
@annah5592 5 лет назад
JT sadly what you said about young girls who believe but don't go to meetings and become the poster kid, it's so true. I pulled myself up at the last moment but I'm lucky....and I mean really lucky, to be alive.
@gtjuliemango
@gtjuliemango 6 лет назад
Thank you! These videos are really helping me.
@lizcuero9065
@lizcuero9065 7 лет назад
This is LIFE SAVING.........for REAL!...........so TRUE!
@lovelight8180
@lovelight8180 7 лет назад
i cannot stop laughing because jt, your satire and comic relief is on point!!!! so true and so on point!!! man you should be the "the" ex jw comedian and start a comic relief series!!! lol hahaha. omg! so funny and refreshing. the moses deed at the clerk, the armageddon car, the way you explained how they don't use inspired. man you got it! stay up jt, and keep up your commentary. you keep it real, really real!!!! thanks jt!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
V Jay 😂😂😂😂😂
@sarahmcgee6269
@sarahmcgee6269 6 лет назад
I agree, LOL
@tonyaking3226
@tonyaking3226 5 лет назад
I agree we definitely need it.
@bridgettesbroomcloset4166
@bridgettesbroomcloset4166 7 лет назад
Loved this discussion! and I laughed so hard at the part of "this man is going to deed his house to Moses!" I was picturing the whole train wreck of the scene and laughed so hard that my sides hurt! LOL Thoroughly enjoyed this! Glad I found your channel!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Bridgette's Broom Closet glad you enjoyed it JT
@shimae1964
@shimae1964 5 лет назад
I kept asking for a shepherding call once, and never got one. So I stopped going to the meeting and stopped going in field service. I said if I don't turn in time for 3 months I will go inactive and then they will come around. They still never came. They never knew how to deal with me.
@sarahmcgee6269
@sarahmcgee6269 6 лет назад
THIS IS A WONDERFUL DISCUSSION! I AM NOT, AND NEVER HAVE BEEN A JW. I ALWAYS FELT THEY WERE A CULT!! I HAVE WORKED AND BEEN AROUND JWs. THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH FOR THESE VIDEOS.
@jiggyone868
@jiggyone868 4 года назад
Don't ever be. Run from them
@shimae1964
@shimae1964 5 лет назад
I found your channel last night. I am so thankful that I did. I have struggled in this religion all my life. I was sexually abused as a child from the age of about 5 until the age of 16. My mother claims to be anointed and my father was a Jehovahs witnesses but he got his baptism annulled. So I was raised in the "truth". I told my mother the first time it happened and she told me to go be quiet and go back to bed. She said that Jehovah would settle it in his time. My mother also sold me to different men. I left at 19 by disassociating myself. I went back and left again . I went back again and now I am 54 and leaving again. This time for good. I wish I knew what I know now, then. I would love to talk to you and see what is the best way to tell my story so that other women don't go through what I've been through. thanks for all you do.
@vitajay85
@vitajay85 7 лет назад
I heard so many times that going to college was bad. Both of my kids went to college (they never became JWs). As I told one JW woman, the JW kids who went to college and got "buck wild" were probably "buck wild" before they got on campus. I knew a lot of them who lived "double lives" and I was criticized because my kids went to college. They have degrees and they didn't get "buck wild". My son graduated with honors. I would never discourage young adults from attending college. Many of those JW young adults who didn't attend college don't have much of anything financially.
@Simone69214
@Simone69214 7 лет назад
Brilliant interview JT & Lady Cee. I think the video would of been complimented by seeing the faces of the interviewer and interviewee. Hope that helps. 🇬🇧👏🏽
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Many thanks! Absolutely, it would be nice to see faces, but unfortunately everyone cannot come out and show their face. But, then again, remember when there was a time when we only had radio. LOL ~ Lady Cee
@lindayeager3126
@lindayeager3126 7 лет назад
started studying in 1958, and there were no African Americans then, got baptized in 1960 and still there wasn't any Africans in back then! look back at the old pictures of assemblys , the big new York 5to7day assemblys and there are hardly any! wasn't till later, maybe the 70s that I remember they started coming in! yes, it does skrew the kids up! but I didn't realize it for many years and after 60s years they started to come down on my grandson for dating, and said he should be thrown out of the house! I said hold it , don't agree , Jesus would never treat a kid like that! elders just sat there, dumfounded and short time later ,l started researching and that was it, I knew then I was brainwashed, endedup taking my grandson in ,getting him refocest back to being a first responder and he finished his college! but yes they knew that was his dream since he was little but they didn't care, they tryed to destroy him! that's when I realized something is really wrong with this picture?? and our elders all had good jobs with all benefits and all the trimmings and so do there kids! college too! they would keep it under cover and not brag about it ! so yes, double standard all the way! brainwashing!! sad
@padussia
@padussia 7 лет назад
It's so inspiring how after all of these years you woke up. It gives me hope that my use to be spiritual mom in the organization will wake up. She's now in her early sixties and is very indoctrinated. She and fell out about something personal I told her. She wanted to report me to the elders, and I'm not even baptized. That hurt me so bad, I left the cult and started researching it.
@sarahmcgee6269
@sarahmcgee6269 6 лет назад
You see Linda, that's my point!!! I was raised in the South, and my parent were "share croppers". When I got about 12 years old, I realized that something was wrong with that system. Share cropping was established when "slavery was abolished". Share cropping was an "evil system", cheating, lying, manipulation, control, and the owner/mr charley" did not want us to attend school. School started in September, and we were never able to start until about November because we had to "work the fields", and by that time you were behind in your studies. Thank God for the teachers though, because they always helped us get caught up. I will never forget that horrible time in my life, being manipulated by a "white land owner" who also wanted to own us. I left the south when I graduated, and never looked back. I will NOT ever live in the South again!!! It took me a loooooooooooong time to respect and like white people. GOD changed my heart towards them, but I'll never forget.
@ShoNuffSoulBro1
@ShoNuffSoulBro1 3 года назад
I listened to this interview/ discussion again and this is definitely going in my TopTen list of best Awakened ! ex-JW interviews ! ! I love the banter and you all are so ON POINT 😄. Thanks 🙏🏽
@rosasalazar5966
@rosasalazar5966 6 лет назад
JT you are so smart I like the way you talk, my son and I both got out I was in there 15yrs and we have read raymound Franz book and done our research !!
@BurrQ19
@BurrQ19 7 лет назад
Loved every moment of this. It's just so adsurd how arrogant they are conditioned to be, and to use logical fallacy upon logical fallacy to arrive to their conclusions. Keep up the great work Team!!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Many thanks!
@agileanalyst214
@agileanalyst214 6 лет назад
I'm learning a lot. Plus it really holds on to the listener's attention. Thanks ya'll
@spooksya
@spooksya 7 лет назад
Excellent as always. God bless.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
spooksya glad you enjoyed it - do us a favor please share it with just 2 people - thz
@Arizona764
@Arizona764 7 лет назад
I read that when Rutherford deeded Beth Sarim to "the ancient notables" , it was reported in the San Diego newspaper and it was the talk of the town. Well, an enterprising man showed up at the home and said "I am King David and am here to collect my house".
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Connie Peterson we need to find that article !!! It has to be great reading
@alomaalber6514
@alomaalber6514 6 лет назад
he had a different woman for every day of the week, maybe he rang the bell three times for Wednesday and he had the best whiskey in prohibition!
@teresahopemiller1008
@teresahopemiller1008 5 лет назад
Thank you for your insights
@mudejartrainingnaturalscie6938
The funny thing is the Service Meeting teaches you all the psychological tricks that is being used on you, to use on people door to door.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 6 лет назад
Tohunga Uwishin great point
@mitchstevens4540
@mitchstevens4540 4 года назад
Wow, this was the best conversation if yours I've seen so far. I can relate to him in so many ways. Excellent. I'm from the south too so I relate to JT too. I wish you could interview me but I would probably say exactly what he did.
@jimbobaggans1564
@jimbobaggans1564 5 лет назад
I worked at a Nuclear plant, when I was young. A "brother" raised his voice loud enough for everyone to hear. He said, hey is that place where you work still geared for war? I said, oh yes. I test nuclear warhead detonators. I go out in the field behind the building and blow myself up. Then he got this stupid look on his face. I was on my way out of the organization anyway. So I felt I could say whatever I wanted by then.
@taaadaaa5256
@taaadaaa5256 4 года назад
***AFTER LEAVING CORRUPT WATCHTOWER YOU'LL NEED A PSYCHOLOGIST***
@WJTM88
@WJTM88 3 года назад
so true
@justinthyme3396
@justinthyme3396 3 года назад
This discussion was published Dec.1916....fast forward March 2021. And we're still here. Surely we must be in the last of the last last last days. Ha ha ha ha ha. From Australia
@amazingbibleantiquities7221
@amazingbibleantiquities7221 7 лет назад
I sure enjoy your work! Thanks a bunch! :)
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Marc Basis thz
@LB-os3lb
@LB-os3lb 5 лет назад
This is amazing information. I wish I would have had this type of outlet for discussion 30 years ago. In early 70’s I new some of the information just didn’t seem right. Like disfellowshipping, like blood transfusions. Also, all worldly people are bad. Other things too. I think in general, people want to live in a paradise. People don’t want to die. However, now listening to various ExJW on the internet has shown me that the truth has not been told. Just like my father always said. Thank you for. This.
@ZachtheArvadite
@ZachtheArvadite 7 лет назад
It's funny, I can recall my father also saying, "I can't see this going for more than 5-10 years." And here we are almost 20 years later.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Uplyfting Apostate bingo!!!!
@iambeing4328
@iambeing4328 6 лет назад
Uplyfting Apostate haha.... That's nothing! My brother was 3 and the people studying with my parents said 'he'd probably never even go to school!' ...... He's 45 now.
@musicman6315
@musicman6315 2 месяца назад
Great interview I’m listening in 2024 and it seems like this was done yesterday 👍🏼
@dwmel66
@dwmel66 5 лет назад
Hi JT and Lady Cee I chose a trade because of my upbringing as a Witness and have worked in my field for 35 years. I always wanted to go to college and am currently 1 year away from graduating with a degree in psychology. Of course, I'll be continuing on for a master's degree in counseling. You guys are spot on!!!! Please keep up with these videos. I love it!!! You touch on the points that I have tried to convey to my family, usually while they are disfellowshipped; only to be labeled apostate by some. I do this merely to have them think about the reasons why they want to be reinstated; mainly so they can be in association with other practicing family members. I never really had many friends in the truth, so I have never missed the alleged association. There so many things I'd like to discuss with you guys, but unfortunately it would feel like I am posting a book lol.
@a.toniboysmith7360
@a.toniboysmith7360 4 года назад
My mom and 3 of my sisters and 2 brother in laws are in the truth.
@ethelbentancourt5896
@ethelbentancourt5896 5 лет назад
Amen!All is true statements
@ItWILLbeWONDERFUL_THERE
@ItWILLbeWONDERFUL_THERE 7 лет назад
#Exjwcriticalthinker. So many excellent points!!! And Wes is right; it IS emotional blackmail. Tragic on a massive scale. I remember what Lady C said in a vid (Memory Lane) about this woman who was on her DEATH BED and was asked for her field service report. Dang! These sickos could give an ICEBERG Frostbite! 👍🌨
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Fuzzy Bunny Slippers you are on point
@sable1wolf1
@sable1wolf1 7 лет назад
if your not a critical thinker of watchtower corp after these videos, shame on you! Another great video
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
DP - good to see you! Thanks!!! Are you about ready to tell your story?
@sable1wolf1
@sable1wolf1 7 лет назад
Yes indeed!
@artevizart2600
@artevizart2600 5 лет назад
Book Publishing Company...LoL, brilliant...
@dwmel66
@dwmel66 5 лет назад
I just wanted to add another comment. Disfellowshipping, disassociation, and reproving never worked for me because I never willingly participated in the meeting (I overheard the elders on the committee saying when they sent me out of the room to make a decision). Additionally, I mentioned previously that I never had many friends in the truth, so I didn't miss associating with anyone. I love the point that you made in this video that how can the organization predict the great tribulation when Jesus himself did not know. It never ceases to amaze me that when I have posed this line of thought to some, they bring up the "new light". In the witness quest to disassociate themselves from other religions, the use of "their" verbiage makes me sick. Everything from the friends, who are not very friendly (at least they weren't to me), gatherings, and new light. Also, I'd like to point out that my mother forced me to get baptized as a teen. I was not ready to make such a major decision at that time. I would think "Jehovah knows that I am not ready to do this" as he knows that not what was in my heart at that time. At least not within this organization.
@WJTM88
@WJTM88 3 года назад
completely on point
@chazfoster2477
@chazfoster2477 7 лет назад
Please contact A&E please do a show on Jehovah's Witnesses they need our help I need to be saved
@Jennifer-ky9bw
@Jennifer-ky9bw 7 лет назад
JT, Wes, Lady Cee, You all could be a Leah Remini for the JW. You have excellent communication skills, sense of humor, timing. Maybe you could be on her show to begin with, to introduce your subject of the Watchtower. I can SO see this happening. You have the excellent skills to make this happen. Arts and Entertainment Channel. Please give it a try. Put the fishing pole in that water, see if they bite. A&E is seeing record breaking numbers of audience with Leah's series. Catch that tide!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Many thanks! We appreciate your feedback. Who knows, one day, we might decide to do just that. We are in the process of working on a documentary. Well, it is a bucket list item. LOL
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Thanks Chaz Foster
@intunewiththeworld864
@intunewiththeworld864 6 лет назад
Agreed...A&E would be perfect for the these subjects.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 6 лет назад
chaz foster your wish came true. Lol
@Sanmijil
@Sanmijil 6 лет назад
As a person that studies health blood may not be safe to take because in some cases it can cause heart attacks. But I fully see where these issues explained is of concern.
@ShoNuffSoulBro1
@ShoNuffSoulBro1 5 лет назад
A great conversation ! From minute 37:42 to 43:12, No job skills; consequences of following the direction of the GB to quit good jobs; no retirement planning. Man that was profound. Correlation: Correlating interpretation, conjecture and opinion with The Word of God. Just making stuff up and signing God’s name at the bottom ! Correlating the WT Society/Governing Body with God himself: “Criticizing the WT Society is the same as criticizing Almighty God, YahWeh/Jehovah himself !” We basically follow a group of journalists, a group of writers, authors of books and magazines (of religious opinion) a publishing company. On the one hand it seems the Governing Body reluctantly (and rarely) admits that they are Not Inspired, Not Infallible and yet on the other hand profusely proclaiming that they are directed by God, guided by his Holy Siprit, that they are God’s prophet to the nations and as Mo’ Whiskey Morris declared, they’re words are “from Heaven”. Talking out of both sides of their mouth ! ! Not using the word “Inspired” but applying the definition. And so they demand that adherents follow them as if they are inspired and infallible, demanding unquestioning adherence to changing doctrines and upmost loyalty with the threat of disfellowshipping and total harsh shunning for any who are vocal about contradictions, erroneous teachings, doubts, questions, etc! ! You made some great points ! !
@lizcuero9065
@lizcuero9065 7 лет назад
They survive by putting FEAR into people!
@sovern009
@sovern009 7 лет назад
They will use any tactic imaginable to do what JT said; PUSH THAT PRODUCT..
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Liz Cuero bingo
@ashqelon7267
@ashqelon7267 6 лет назад
Liz Cuero , They all have the same common theme to guilt-trip people and tell them that God's going to devour their money and everything they have if they don't tithe 10% and that if we don't give them money that they were robbing God, And that they are the one and only true church and you cannot associate or Mary or relate to anybody outside that church. Sound all too familiar?? TBN does that also need been doing that for a long time but only in a very subtle way. Those Devils of Hell need to be destroyed.
@1955annemarie
@1955annemarie 6 лет назад
Liz Cuero, FEAR, SHAME, and GUILT are the Watchtower Organization's mains tools used to gain and maintain TYRANNICAL RULE and CONTROL over their members; "conform" and "perform," submit, obey, respect, and, above all, remain unquestioningly LOYAL...OR ELSE...
@lindaanderson1366
@lindaanderson1366 2 года назад
Do they realize how they make JESUS CHRIST our King out to be and THEY say he's not our mediator if I'm correct when he was The Best The Best man that ever THAT ever walked the Earth!!! THE CREATOR want us to realize they he gave us HIS SON John 3-16 he deserve ALL the praise, Honor and Glory for what he did for US!!!❤️ This BROTHER speak so much truth!!!
@tinahill2134
@tinahill2134 3 года назад
Yes sir JT ,there is always a rebottle .
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 3 года назад
tina hill bingo
@gingerandpiggytales
@gingerandpiggytales 6 лет назад
This is so surreal. I've been dissed for 6 years now. I can relate to all this . I always felt like a bad person for feeling this way . The hope of resurrection is why people stay.
@padussia
@padussia 7 лет назад
This is really good. I'm sharing.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
padussia please do
@leocarranza5292
@leocarranza5292 4 года назад
@@ExJWCriticalThinker do u a cell i wanna talk to you jt
@mrngstar1
@mrngstar1 5 лет назад
I was denied a full scholarship to ASU in Spanish--education was bad, etc.
@tonyfernadez472
@tonyfernadez472 7 лет назад
great interview guys awesome jt lady cee.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Many thanks!
@lucillehills4012
@lucillehills4012 7 лет назад
Jeffrey Jackson said : " We are not the only people who represents Jehovah on earth " when he was asked by the judge in Sydney Australia. ..I loved hearing from his own mouth, he also said that "That will be presumptuous to say that we are the only people that Jehovah uses on earth " I thought to myself isn't that Hypocritical? So if we are not the only one, that means we have options right? just thinking
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
pick Nona he was a coward - I know 3rd grade JW kids who have stood up bravely unlike him --Claiming to be some mere "translator down the hall in cubicle C1. Lol
@alomaalber6514
@alomaalber6514 6 лет назад
I guess he knew the Methodists were in Africa early on too! that is a WOW. also the Bible Students are still out there, old sermons from Russell and no videos but yeah they are out there. fascinating!
@carloscorona3628
@carloscorona3628 4 года назад
SAY IT, THE TRUTH, JACKSON PLAIN AND SIMPLE, LIED!!!!
@jessicanerpio-cauldwell4987
@jessicanerpio-cauldwell4987 2 года назад
WT GB'S speaks with a Fork Tongue !!! 🤣🤣🤣
@soliver701
@soliver701 5 лет назад
I know a jw who is 50 years old. He said that when he was a kid in the south, the kh was segregated.
@slicedyougiveloveabadname5599
@slicedyougiveloveabadname5599 7 лет назад
Love your videos guys! Please keep making more.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Sliced You give LOVE a BAD name Thank you! 🙂
@LB-os3lb
@LB-os3lb 5 лет назад
No, when I mentioned 1975 to a witness she told me that was the “dark ages”. We got “new light”. Just totally disrespected me.
@alias41100
@alias41100 5 лет назад
when they say spirit directed,which spirit are they talking about. Not Gods holy spirit thats for sure.
@mbates1000
@mbates1000 5 лет назад
I had the same questions about the so called "New Light". I have said "God will not let you believe and build your life around a lie and then reconstruct doctrine and then say it is because God provided New Light. God cannot lie, has not lied and never has lied but man and organizations will mislead and lie to fit their agendas.
@StreetLove410
@StreetLove410 3 года назад
The political aspect and favoritism I Experienced first hand. I was from a family called Exemplary and when I came back to confess sins I was allowed back based on my parents service. I never returned.
@excelsiorexcelsior1591
@excelsiorexcelsior1591 7 лет назад
Hello JT, Lady C and Wes, Extrapolating one's own experience is seldom helpful. To extrapolate that the majority of folks who leave or are dismissed from the WTBTS for non doctrinal reasons go into lower depths of depravity than worldly people is not backed by my own experiences. Indeed, the "depravity" is given more strength by the unreasonable rules surrounding dating and sex in the WTBTS, together with its views on alcohol and drugs. I am truly glad that you have retained your faith in the Lord Jesus Christ. I agree with his teachings on judgement and mercy. I would like to thank you for encouraging critical thinking. I would encourage all of us to apply this to any Faith we choose to follow. May the Lord bless you Peace be with you, Excelsior!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Excelsior Excelsior points well taken Thanks for posting
@mariposamarshall9773
@mariposamarshall9773 5 лет назад
Excelsior Excelsior
@Simone69214
@Simone69214 7 лет назад
Hi Lady C, thanks for your reply. I don't remember radio days as I'm from the millennial generation, lol. Much well wishes and support from UK 🇬🇧🙏
@ladyceehiddenstruggles
@ladyceehiddenstruggles 7 лет назад
Simone Katherine That would be during my grand parents era. 😂😂😂
@mervjohnson2140
@mervjohnson2140 5 лет назад
TJ & Lady Cee Excellent Video I've Heard This from other Videos About Education & Changing The The Doctrine Also No One KnowsThe The Day &Hour of Our Lord's Return An Yes Lady Cee As You Said The Young One "on The Internet An Do Research An We Are Living in the Age Information Age Finding About The Child Abuse on Line in This Religion As Well As critical thinking The Guy Is Right On Point Among Other Things Excellent Video An Finding About The Truth of What is Happening
@tedlumley4470
@tedlumley4470 7 лет назад
engrossing interview. Loved the segment on 75'. I've heard Jws say that 75 didn't pan out because we don't know when Eve was created and we should've calculated from then. But Jesus would've known when Eve was created and even with that knowledge he didn't know 'the day and the hour'
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Ted Lumley EXCELLENT POINT!!!!!! You knocked it out of the park
@realnursenews
@realnursenews 6 лет назад
No we are not alone. I have my new clientele of friends. That is you guys. I am appreciative. Glad I am out and free. I managed to go to school but knew something was not correct from early on.Contact me my story is unusual but I am free and glad my sons did not get indoctrinated . Thanks for all that you do.
@MelenaSoleil
@MelenaSoleil 6 лет назад
brooklyngirl1560 what is your story? I'm interested to hear it.
@redhowe9492
@redhowe9492 5 лет назад
Have you considered doing, or do you know of anyone else doing, an episode about thriving an ExJW? It’s not easy and it’ll cost you something, but it can give people who’re waking up something to move toward as they walk out the door.
@bubblestar2314
@bubblestar2314 7 лет назад
Very good presentation JT & Lady Cee. (And Wes ) Keep up the good work. I always look forward to your you tube videos. A good share! :-)
@bubblestar2314
@bubblestar2314 7 лет назад
Lots of fun and great material (food for thought)
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Many thanks!
@mervjohnson2140
@mervjohnson2140 3 года назад
Your Right No One KnowsThe Day & Hour Of The Lord's Coming Yet There calculating the date no one knows there are certain things Man is not meant to know and this is one of them
@susycazarin
@susycazarin 6 лет назад
That's why a lot of us get out, and we go straight to drugs and alcohol. Cause we been program to do that!!! Now I understand! Had to go thru the strangle and rehab, to become a normal person. Wow
@a.d.2206
@a.d.2206 3 года назад
This is so true. All the young people I knew that left went buck wild. Please if your young and leaving, go to school! I wish I had left at 18 and went to university. Trust me 40 year old you will thank you.
@RandomPerson-js3rc
@RandomPerson-js3rc 5 лет назад
I had so much product I couldn't move I had to make a move to the trash can on dump day. I felt like a magazine horder.
@ZachtheArvadite
@ZachtheArvadite 7 лет назад
When I was younger I recall love bombing, but there was one congregation I was in in Southwestern Colorado where there was what I would call an undercurrent. There was so much division that I was not truly comfortable going.
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
Uplyfting Apostate that does happen indeed
@MaryMary-xf5ns
@MaryMary-xf5ns 3 года назад
9 no
@formeyousee
@formeyousee 7 лет назад
Bravo! Bravo! This is extremely helpful; one of the best to date. JT, do you still have plans to do a video explaining the different JW titles like: pioneer, publisher, etc. and the hours and demands each position requires? We spoke about it a ways back and I was reminded of it when you compared the Organization to Amway. By the way, great analogy!
@ExJWCriticalThinker
@ExJWCriticalThinker 7 лет назад
formeyousee check the video on ""counting time". we did
@formeyousee
@formeyousee 7 лет назад
Thank you sir. I'll check it out.
@coralrain6332
@coralrain6332 7 лет назад
They instill fear and isolation within their members.
@brendagordon4571
@brendagordon4571 4 года назад
Anybody been keeping up with Hong Kong lately? Plan to go to Seoul Korea next year for my next vacation.
@voiceofthetower
@voiceofthetower 5 лет назад
I know a very wicked and a drunken brother now appointed as an elder in the Twi congregation in Germany , Frankfurt to be precise. That added to my conviction among other things that the selection is based on those who make many hours in the field service not the Holy Spirit
@mynameisnotgirl8184
@mynameisnotgirl8184 5 лет назад
After three days of discovering these videos of ex-JW’s I know now deep in my heart I can be free of the unresolved questions and fear I dealt with growing up with JW parents. After many years of wondering what it would be like to go to college, I enrolled, studied and after years of life changing events, I received an associate degree. I’m now a semester away from my bachelors degree and WILL be continuing to pursue my masters degree. I had a passive aggressive conversation about this today with my mother who is still a JW, and five minutes into a SIMPLE CONVERSATION about critical thinking, she outright stated that she didn’t believe in it. She included that college is an absolute waste of time and could not give me a direct answer when asked if she was supportive of what I was doing. A woman, who always running to her doctor because of her bad knees can’t seem to grasp the basic logic that had that doctor she visits often not gone to college, how would she be able to function now? She also made a statement to me once that put the nail in the coffin. She stated that the entire Civil Rights movement never would’ve happened if....get this, if DR.....as in REVEREND DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING just prayed and read the Bible more.
@mrsmith3869
@mrsmith3869 5 лет назад
I wasnt able to be a hall of fame second basemen cuz it was bad associations Looking back now It was bad associations So im not bitter
@superdave1263
@superdave1263 2 года назад
I wasted 60 years in this criminal organization. First left in 1995 for a brief period of time, but not knowing the real truth about this degenerate enterprise, I had a guilty conscience and so returned briefly a few years later. I approached the elders in the Bay Point, California Congregation about returning to Jehovah. They were so standoffish and wouldn’t acknowledge me even though I was not and had never been disfellowshipped. When they finally spoke to me about returning, I asked them about the child molestation in Pacheco, California. They made up some excuses for paying out five million dollars settlement costs. They severely down played the ongoing problem. Keep in mind, I knew nothing about the Australian Royal Commission. Shortly there after, I was watching RU-vid and I came across exJW videos. That quickly caught my attention and I could not get enough. It all began to make sense, finally. After seeing the changes, and not for the good, the elders and publishers in that congregation basically shunned me. What a welcome back! Since then, I watch as many RU-vid videos about this detestable organization as I can find. I’ve ordered Ray Franz’s book, “Crises of Conscience” which I dare not to have read while a JW. You ex JW’s have saved what little life I have left. Thanks to all the ex JW’s out there, you are the ones that are really saving lives, not the the fake eldership like I used to be in. Thanks especially to JT and Lady Cee for showing us the real truth!
Далее
Jehovah's Witness Fade or Disassociate?
25:45
Просмотров 55 тыс.
🤯 #funny
00:20
Просмотров 1,5 млн
What Has Changed Since I Was a Jehovah's Witness?
34:34
Jehovah's Witnesses & 1975 The End of the World
39:44
Просмотров 109 тыс.
How did Jehovah's Witnesses Come to Practice Idolatry?
27:37
Jehovah's Witnesses: & the 144,000...Heavenly Class
26:32