A new (sort of) concept on my channel! I hope you'll enjoy the video:) Make your own tier list with Tier Maker! tiermaker.com #TierMaker #WhistleRegisterTierList
Welcome to my first TIER list video! For some reason I pronounce the word 'tier' incorrectly, it should sound like 'te-er' Clearly your boy loves cars and trucks
I like Mariah's whistles in her songs because she doesn't use them to show off or be extra. She just adds it like a cherry on top of a cake and they're subtle too.
I couldnt agree. Mariah is a backround singer back then, she know and she learn for along time to created a harmonize. She used her whistle for harmonize and she knew the time to do that
Yeah, and both of them worked hard for that. After Ariana’s cover of Emotions, most ppl questioned her capability to do it live and speculated that she used a lot of autotune, but then she started demonstrating her skills live, and even using whistle in her songs. Morissette, too. She used to get messy in the Emotions climax but now, she has almost full control over her whistle. Plus the “Di Mapaliwanag” whistle riff is really hard but she always nails it. They are amazing!
She's a lightweight singer, no sustainability, Morissette is far superior in every department, Ariana is so overrated, put them on the same stage together it would be embarrassing for Ariana.
@@steveheckle8847 Ariana definitely isn't overrated. At the start of her career maybe but she's improved a considerable amount since then. Her whistles have become far more consistent and she's gotten a lot more comfortable singing in that range, even adding whistles into "Rain On Me", a song that isn't solely hers. She also displayed that she has immense control over her whistles when she harmonized with Mariah in "Oh Santa", by showing her whistles could extend to the low extremes of that register. Now if your talking about both of them as an overall vocalist, then yes Morissette has the advantage, but Ariana has improved her support immensely recently. I'm going to admit that I haven't really been keeping up with Morissette for a while now, but Ariana now supports up to an E5, one note lower than Morissette as far as I'm aware. Ariana was overrated but now I think she deserves all that praise.
so happy to see Minnie getting the love that she deserves cause while I absolutely love Mariah (and I know she’s like the poster girl for whistles), a lot of people tend to forget all about Minnie. great video btw
Morissettes is another level too Tori Kelly, Christ, one of the most annoying voices around, and they still blow smoke up her arse, the girls got no personality, no charisma, and lacks stage presence, very boring.
@@steveheckle8847 omg stfu im tired of seeing u on very video that tori is on. @Aint No Other Fan can’t you block him from ur videos or something, he does nothing but hate on tori like he’s getting paid for it. a whole ass psycho
@@kinnamor8098 thank you for not dragging Morissette. As a fan of Morissette, I have warned him already to keep his words to himself or hate other artists to lift Morissette up.
@@steveheckle8847 stage presence, charisma and personality are all immeasurable for u to say that one has them whilst the others don’t. They are both amazing. They’re in the League of their own. If you’re gonna use subjective aspects of singing to pit artists against each other, just stfu.
Many can whistle and play with it but when it comes to Mariah, her whistles are like rainbow with so many colors and etc. Hopefully we will get to see these singers explore more of this register.
Like imagine in 1990-1992 her whistle is powerfull piercing. In 1993-1995 her whistle is extra soft, 1996 the time she add little bit air on her whistle. And next the texture of whistle change over ang over
Go back to school. Morrrisette is nothing but a Karaoke cover joke. Her little talent shows on RU-vid will never win her a Grammy. A non existent top 10 album. Never graced a top 10 hit on any Music Charts.. Will always be jus a click away..lol
I'm hoping that the vocal coach Normani is working with is helping her strengthen the resonance and control to her voice and helping her establish a better, healthier connection for such high notes like these. I'm hoping they are also helping her with her belting because she honestly does have the capabilities to be a very interesting vocalist. She has the range and the agility as well as a very sweet and captivating tone, her breathe control for the most part is on point for someone who does such challenging choreography during their performances, she just needs to dedicate her time to wanting to perfect her voice.
Agreed on top of that she shows potential in versatility and innovation of her voice like take her demo version of Selena Gomez’s ring, where she brings a unique cross of vocal styling in jazz, soul, and reggae
epic and syco never giving any of the 5H girls a single ounce of proper vocal training has never sat right with me. from xfactor up to self titled, they literally let Lauren and Normani regresss by a large scale.
@@taeslilclown9801 Lauren was a sad case bc on the X factor and pre-2015 reflection she was a true vocal prodigy who had so much potential I believe both their label’s lack of support and Lauren’s weed smoking caused her voice to be destroyed
Ima need Demi to explore whistle more in this new era because she has like two songs (proof and wildfire) but ole girl be laughing her whistle register. like stop playing with me💀💀
Morisette has made a 15-second whistle with unbelievable runs, and she has even spoke a word while whistling. If you're wondering, the word was "Jesus."
Morisette has showcased her whistle countless times in her live performances and can even whistle while her mouth is closed. I'd rather say Morissette is a songbird supreme tier while Mariah Carey is a God-level songbird supreme.
So does Ariana? LMAO they're the same when it comes to whistle register. Ariana didn't use to use it that much because people already compared her too much to Mariah, so she kept it inside, built her career with her own musical style and THEN she started using it.
Rúben Silva but Mori's level are a lot better in my opinion. Ariana's often sound too airy. The "my hair" verse is a good example. I wasn't really that satisfied with the live performance. There was barely any tone present. Just huskiness.
It's because it kinda is. It's a special, connected register that is the highest form of head voice. She was so good at it because she was completely trained as an opera singer
@@narutohyuga1845 so flageolet, im guessing?? i don’t know much about it but i know that i use it sometimes when i attempt to hit whistle notes cause idk i know you can modify whistle register and make sound strong head voice like or vary airy like falsetto but it just feels completely different compare to what whistle registers feels like or at least what i know it as anyway. im not trained in music at all so i could be completely wrong about my own usage of registers lol
@@notyourdaddy2148 yeah, It's definitely more natural sounding when she does it, other whistles sound good, but they almost don't sound like a part of the actual voice
@@narutohyuga1845 i keep going back to the video to see if she transitions to head voice or not and i can’t really tell so she might have just been using flageolet the entire time before that since it is easier to go lower and sound more natural in that register when stepping down to the 5th octave compare to whistle where you can usually tell.
@Elegant Oprah it’s like when you use vocal fry and you can make that flip to go high idk how to explain it, it’s like the the head voice above your head voice if that makes any sense lol
si em oh gosh shady... as if di ka nag cocomment comment sa ibang commentors tapos inaangat mo pataas si morri like theres a sarcasm on it yuck youre being shady here, im just telling a truth.
@@dorious7414 no, when I praise Morissette. I don't shade other singers. Well, I used to that but I learned that it will push away people that could be fans of her.
i remember my mutuals talking about an unreleased Demi's song titled Proof, and they said by the end of the song, she clearly used her whistle register. but yeah i agree with you, she needs to explore it more
I’m loving the improvement and maturing Ariana’s voice is going through 😩!! And Normani has so much potential up there I just can’t stress the fact enough that I hope her vocal coach her guiding on the right path cause her potential through her range really is crazy and I love her❤️.
unless she doesn't whistle too often, that's not a good thing. Anyone who can whistle well could do it live all the time if they wanted to. That's not unique to her. But it wouldn't be healthy in the long run.
@@AGEE_95 true but she's keeping her voice healthy by not smoking, drugs and alcohol. She already survived an operation in her throat when she's still young. Good thing she still managed to have this voice and skills. We fans of Mori do not bash other artists because most of us believed that the more talents available is good for the artists and the industry as a whole. ✌️🥰
Wait..doing a whistle register with your mouth closed is not a normal thing . I mean I can do a whistle register ( not as good as anyone on this list ) but I can do it with my mouth closed is that supposed to be something rare ? I didn’t know . No hate tho
Awesome, thanks for including Morissette. Did you see her sing Pangarap Ko Ibigan Ka and Di Mapaliwanag? Whistles for days. She even whistled along to MC’s Bliss recently for fun. Her I wanna Know what love is whistle is pretty long along with her iconic Akin Ka Na Lang Wish Bus performance.
Amazing video as aways. We all knew who was going to be first, however Ariana and Morissette and Tori get a honorable mention. After all, they did learn from the best.
Morissette is very close to that SS level because she's actually used whistles in her original music. Maybe more creativity and years and she'll be in there. Oh and I think it's pronounced /teer/.
So you kinda doubted if people will concur that mori is in the mariah's daughter tier while you immediately said that ari is without a doubt in that tier? Mori is braver and has more control of the whistle register than ari. Right?
@@aintnootherfan but like you said its your opinion and you know better than people reacting just because they dont know Mori so yeah that was confusing
@@speedycomet1692 No, even if she extend that note up to the 7th octave, she is still in her head voice/falsetto register. She uses a different mechanism. She is actually an expert in super head voice/falsetto.
I think demi should've been in kettles with ailee, cause her laughs are all whistle notes, also she has crazy range in it, but she's definetly not good enough to be with Kelly and Jessie in we're getting somewhere
@@grandeflamesbutera3949 at the same time tho, I don't rlly blame this guy for not knowing about those clips because I honestly haven't seen many until like 2 days ago even tho I'm a huge demi fan , but yea I think she clicks w kettles or something
Perfectly ranked! I really appreciate your knowledge-based processes every time. Would have wished to see Deniece Willams, Lisa Fisher, and maybe Chante Moore and Shanice on here. (I just came back and edited my comment to remove my friendly note about the word "tier" because i watched your vibrato video right after this! :)
Funny how you say you hope noone's gonna question morisette being mariah's daughter. What is there to question? Her whistles are clean and clearer than my future 🙉
Also Demi can whistle for sure ( She whistles alot when laughing and expressing surprise..I mean unintentionally) But she didn’t developed it till now, hopefully in this new era she will ❤️
I was actually waiting for you to put Chante Moore in the Songbird Supreme tier as well. Her control, ease, melisma, play with textures, dynamics, phrasing and stamina in whistle register is ridiculously insane
It was an M3 laryngeal vibratory mechanism. Actual high sixth octave head tone (M2) sounds different. Listen to Chrylyn Bell-Myers or Francine Jones for a good example.
Lovely video! The only thing I didn’t agree with is I would add Morissette to the top, and Jessie up one and Christina down one. Only reason I would add Morissette is because she is so consistent, perfect control and tone, and tbh even though she wasn’t a huge pioneer I personally find her whistles are more full and consistent than Mariah.
I read an article that the tone of your whistle is pretty same as your normal voice. Morissette's vocals are so powerful that is why her whistle is kinda solid and has resonance. Same goes with Queen Mariah. Her whistle follows her whispery voice.
By the way, I am from the Philippines and Mori is a big fan of Mariah. She's big in our country but like others do, adoring Mariah is a thing. (Sorry for my grammar) Mori is also a fan of Beyonce, Christina and Jessie. Jessie actually had a duet with Mori when Mori just started her career last 2013 I guess.
Normani's potential is definetly there. She is currently recording her debut album and I am sure she is going to use her whistle register on at least one song if not a few songs.
8:38 *"I hope no ones questioning that?"* Looks like you doubted this *LIVE SINGER* Morissette. wait, you reminded us to that thing? 😂 The one who *WHISTLED LIVE* a Billion times already? 😂 The one who performed crystalline whistles, pure and authentic quality? The one who perform vocal acrobats to whistles, *chest voice to whistle* transition, and doing *runs* 😂 I think you should ask that on Ariana's. Ariana *kinda* whistled live but not as much and confident as Morissette is. just saying,
@@joanquintero4670 Yeah I watched it already too. In Ariana's early years (teens I guess) she can even speak a whole sentence through whistling. Unbelievable♥️♥️
@@joanquintero4670 I love me some Morissette and Ariana collab. They kinda have similar tones though but different in technique and styles/vocal inflections.
I think Morissette's whistles by themselves have very often rivalled that of the two in Songbird Supremes, but I think to really reach that category you need to have influenced and catapulted whistling in the industry and in society. Both Mimi and Minnie have done that, while the rest (with all due respect as someone who will never reach their statuses) jumped on a bandwagon as best they could. Some did better on that bandwagon, like Mori and Ari, and some did worse.
@@kwaziness Her whistle register is very excellent but her control just isn’t up there with Mimi or Minnie. She’s pitchy and sometimes they don’t musically fit when she’s singing. Mimi and Minnie are pitch perfect 99% of the time and I’ve never heard them oversing or anything with this register
Im a fan but i must say morissette's problem is being pitchy in some of her whistle her control is pretty good she has so much video that prove she can control those whistles sometimes her whistles is inconsistent because she has so many gig/Shows and lack of rest but over all she is the DAUGHTER of my queen MC ♥
@@kwaziness yes, and actually if you don't know. Morissette *reintroduced* whistle in the Philippines through her hits like Akin Ka Na Lang, PKAIK and Di Mapaliwanag. Now, every singer in the country is trying to whistle 😂
@@grandeflamesbutera3949 No, even if she extend that note up to the 7th octave, she uses a different mechanism. She is actually an expert in super head voice/falsetto. The term on what is called does not change when they enter a certain pitch, it is the mechanism they use which is identified by the sound. Whistles sound piercing while head voice still has weight because they still use vocal cords.
@@muhamadzainurahman3210 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-PiTGm5N4RWs.html that was Mori's vocal range. Just an additional knowledge for you 🙂
Im filipino but Im not even a fan of morissette, never listened to her but congrats to her for being on mariah's daughter i never really explore singers from my country 😂, anyone recommend ?
#For me: YASSSSSSSS NORMANI!!! Thanks so much for adding her in this video. I LOVE ❤️ her whistles, so beautiful, so angelic, so soulful and so mesmerising to listen to. That DAMN control she has on it, is #AMAZING. ILYSM Queen Manibear.💋💋💋💋 My Queen 👸 Normani has a beautiful voice that l can listen to forever.💖 I LOVE ❤️ Mariah’s and Tori’s whistles also....♥️♥️♥️♥️ My favourite whistlers EVER.👸👸🥰💖💖👸
I'd like to add Chante Moore to this list. She's covered Loving You a few times but some of those videos have been taken down on RU-vid. She's definitely top tier. I love your videos BTW.
sooner or later Ariana would be an icon/legend, she inspired new artists and legends adored her talent. Love her or not we can't deny her great talent ❤
I think so too, she have names in the overall industry as Ponytail queen, sweatshirt queen, boots queen, cat ears queen, queen of girly, and ofc vocal queen. she is now starting writing songs so... she will be an icon periodt
