Morally "The NoteBook" Is NOT Acceptable.. *Commentary* 

The part where Noah starts crying after she forgets him again and the staff come in and medicate her always makes me instantly cry.

My Mama and I went to see this movie in the theater when it came out. We were openly sobbing during the scene where Allie recognizes Noah, then falls back into her dementia. We could hear a woman behind us crying and sniffling too, while her husband chuckled a bit at all three of us. However, when the movie was over and the lights came up, I caught him wiping his eyes and blowing his nose. He just looked at me, grinning, and said "Not a word". LOL

I think the reason this resonated so strongly when it came out, was because this was the first mainstream romance that celebrated such flawed characters. Not in a comedic way - in a truly selfish, destructive, slightly frustrating way, but you somehow were still rooting for them.

My parents were married 63 years. Mom came down with dementia. It was rough. But, that last year was good with us children (4) going back and forth to take care of her. If you said the word "Mom" when you started the sentence she may not have remembered us, but felt safe. She could not go 3 feet away from my father without looking for him. What made me lose it was when she was ready to got to bed. Dad would get up and slowly walk her to bed. If she fell a sleep on the couch, he'd sleep next to her in the recliner. She died 3 years ago, dad is 90 and still misses her every day. It's heartbreaking.

"The story of our lives by Allison Hamilton Calhoun. To my love Noah, read this to me & I'll come back to you" 😭😭😭❤

I have seen this movie a 100 times and I ugly cry EVERY time. I love this movie.

I think the reason this one is so emotional is because it is so messy. Real life is never perfect. It's full of twist, turns, regrets, mistakes and so much more. In the end we just hope that we are lucky enough to love and be loved. I had this playing in the background while working on wedding invitations and STILL cried.

James Marsden, the guy who plays the fiance she breaks up with? It feels like he always plays THAT guy, when I see him in movies. He was that guy in Enchanted, he was that guy in Superman Returns... and in this... and to some degree, even in X-Men, cause they kinda got that triangle with Wolverine and Jean going on. >_

Notebook probably has the most passionate love scene ever

“He got money girl aghhhhaaa”💀💀💀😭

Noah didn't want to break up but he thought it was best for her. He loved her so much He sacrificed his feelings. So sweet!

They dies together cause' they couldn't live without each other 😢😭 omg 🥺🤧

I've never seen it. But basically don't watch a Nicholas Sparks movie if you don't want to cry. He'll get you every time. Every effing time.

Rachel McAdams did this movie the same year as Mean Girls. This woman is so talented. #Binges "Time Travelers Wife" and "About Time." That's all I'm gonna say.

I definitely don't see them as couple goals cuz they were kinda toxic with the constant yelling and fighting, but I did root for them to be together throughout the movie. I just wish she would've ended her engagement before going to find Noah.

Bruh this is the best commentary I've seen in a while

Try watching a walk to remember

I don’t like romantic movies but this movie right here.... this emotionally destroys me lol what gets me every time is when older Noah is crying as Ali is getting that shot

I worked in an Alzheimer’s nursing home for 7 yrs. This movie tore me up! I still can’t watch that scene where she remembers and then forgets shortly after without getting emotional. 😭

She always loved him, but since her mother interfered and hid the letters she though he didn't love her so she moved on. Truth and love always win in the end

They also fell in love in real life, and were together for several years. And then broke up, crushing our hearts. Saw this movie with my true love.

Dude, its not just you. There's something about this movie. It rips my heart out in a way I can't even express. I just think about the movie and my eyes start burning. The Notebook caused me to lose my man card.

Ryan gosling and Rachael McAdams were together in real like for like 4 years and engaged in real life. I love the style in this movie.

"If you're not above the age of 18 you cannot watch this." Me at 14: "i love this movie"

Yes... when we look into your eyes... know if you’re seeing/ wanting to see someone else.

“He look like a little rascal” man, that got me 🤣🤣🤣

I love this movie but I can only watch it once every decade. It's just too emotionally exhausting.

"Oh, I forgot about her...He FORGOT about HER" 😂😅😆

I think if the mom didn't hide the letters and Ally knew he wrote then she wouldn't of married the other guy and would of married Noah.

You were so strong in the beginning and then you became all of us and lost it in the end!!!! A walk to remember is another movie that makes me cry everytime!!! You should watch it!

The first time I saw this movie I was in high school on a double date. I cannot explain how difficult and awkward it was to watch this movie on a date and try not to cry in front of a girl or your friend on a first date. We all cried. A lot.

Oh lol when you imatated her laugh, lol oh to funny!!!!

My grandmother had altsheimer and in the end she did not recognized me or my mother. Her last words she said to me were that I am beautiful and in this moment she looked in my eyes and it feld like she saw and remembered me! Everytime I watch this move I have to think about it and I cry more than I will ever admit!

18:00 -(Surprised pikachu face) -"No he is not gonna take that married woman down" -(sips glass with side glance) This was so funny to me

This movie made me bawl like a baby. My grandmother forgot us all, including my grandfather and all i could see is was the real possibility of forgetting my husband. I am not allowed to watch this movie again.

I literally cried with you at the end.

I've only watched some of this movie and even the small amounts that I have watched have made me cry.

This movie gets me in the feels. Shows how messy life is.

This is literally the only chick flick my husband is willing to watch with me all the way through. He liked it so much he told me he hopes we pass away the same way they did (next to each other, not the whole disease thing). ❤️❤️❤️😭😭😭😭

Thank you for reacting to this movie. I got emotional too. Really sad to love someone who doesn't even recognize you anymore. My best friend had dementia and I'm thankful for the good memories we had just talking.

I love this movie. She has Alzheimer’s and that’s what I’m going through with my mom right now. It’s sad to watch her slowly leaving us. I ball my eyes out every time I watch this one. 😭

“ I don’t know why that affected me why it did “ literally me when I seen she moved on

I cry every single time. Even cried watching this reaction lol Beautifully written film and book. I enjoyed your commentary, it was 😄 funny. Thankyou for your service sir 😊💜

The fact that you didn't know that they weren't having sex...lol. After years he did get her virginity She wasn't married and back then premarital sex was something else.

“That’s what we all say, and we’re all lying” 😂😂😂😂 idk how I got here but you made me laugh 😆

I actually broke down crying just watching you watch it. When you realized they died, that's when I finally broke.

First time I watched this movie it made me cry, Makes u believe in soul mates and true love

I really appreciate the authenticity of your reaction and the realness of your commentaries.

Watched it in the theater and everyone was leaving with tears and in silence

your reactions had me cracking up

I know people have their main scene in this movie that makes them bawl but the scene where she’s fighting with her parents about Noah is soooo heart wrenching and underrating. The way she acts when she says “dad I love him” like DAMN LET HER BE W THE POOR BOY IN PEACE

THE “IT WAS US” SCENE HOLY SHITTTTT IM IN PAIN

That was fantastic.... watching see all the moments that I loved when I watched it. I think I've seen it at least 50 times and it STILL makes me cry. I'm glad you enjoyed it 😊

The opening scene kind of goes full circle with the end and also the comment Rachel McAdams says about "If you're a bird, I'm a bird". I BALL EVERY TIME I WATCH THIS MOVIE. YOUR IMITATION OF HER LAUGH "huhhuhuhuhuhh"

Remember the titans is a movie you should watch... Never gets old...

This movie grabs you by the tear ducts every time.

I still managed to ugly cry after watching it so many times🥺

The dementia scenes are hard for me to watch, I lost a grandmother to Alzheimer's.

The Guardian with Ashton Kutcher is one of my favorite movies. And We Are Marshall.

First time I saw this movie: I cried in the shower for 45 minutes…like legit. I was visiting my cousin in Florida and it was the first time me and my then fiancé, now husband, had been apart. So, I was already emotional. I forgot how good and sad this movie is.

Morally though, she was gonna get married based on lies. Her ex fiancé was an innocent person who got hurt in the process, but she got with him based on the lie that Noah broke up with her and never tried to reach out again. So i get it. Her ex got it too. They never got the proper closure nor the opportunity to talk bc the mom got in the way (and the dad).

The amount of things you were predicting correctly right before they happened had me dying😂😂

I think this is maybe my favorite commentary of yours. Just because it was so genuine. I've only ever seen this movie once. I couldn't bring myself to ever watch it again and even seeing just parts of it from this video made me cry. That shit was devastating. They played the hell outta their roles.

I only recently found your channel. I think you are great and I thank YOU for your service to our country and to all of us as subscribers with your content. This reaction is one of the best & most insightful reactions I have ever seen. AND the fact is I see a lot of reactions. Your flow, your wisdom for your age, and so on and so on. Thanks for this vid and the time it must take you (and your editor dude) to have crafted it. Bye for now. Be well.

Yeah, i love this movie, I’m not going to lie. But couple goals? Not exactly. I do believe in soulmates, and that’s what I believe Noah and Ali were, but even the best love stories have bumps in the road, and they had major ones. Like, I’m sure that if those letters hadn’t been kept from her, and she knew that he hadn’t given up on her, she never would have moved on like that. Like she said, she waited for seven years, that’s a long ass time, especially in those days when people were expected to marry much younger, and she was already at least 25 by that point, if she was 18 in the beginning. But there’s no such thing as a perfect love story in the real world. And what gets me every time is the scenes with them as an older couple, especially as it starts nearing the end. The fact that he loved her so much that he played a part to read her that book she wrote for him to read her, just for those rare, few lucid moments, even though it crashed and burned every time, and hurt him so much. THAT is the part that IS couple goals for me. Better or worse, in sickness and in health, I will love you. He took those vows seriously. Them dying together was the final dagger to the heart, while sadly beautiful at the same time. Neither of them were suffering in any way anymore, and they were together. Yeah, this movie is a serious rollercoaster. Thanks for doing it, and thanks for being you and keeping it real, regardless of how you were feeling about it. 😊

First time watcher here and I loved your reaction to this movie! All your emotional moments, dilemma and hilarious comments were on point!

I have never cried so much in a movie, God bless this man. This is real life...people go through this...the hardest thing to see someone with Alzeihmer. 💔

been watching you for a little less than 2 years now… seeing these old videos make me emotional, you’ve come so far and done so well for yourself on here. i’m so proud of you

You should do more movie commentaries!! Also it'll be interesting if you react to military movies and call out whats real or fake and all that craziness . Love your videos !

This has always been my fave. And its totally ok to be emotional Billy.

My favorite of your commentaries 😂 because you weren't focused on mentioning how they look like when kissing lmao (since this story is so sad and draws you in like it's you)...And because you didn't put on any type of front you were very real reacting to the end❤

I've watched like 30 of your videos in the past 2 days and this is the first time I heard you mention being a vet! Thanks for your service c:

man... I only watched the last minutes of this reaction and I'm sobbing all over again

lol when you sipped from the cup I straight died laughing!!! Def subscribed you’re freaking funny as hell ❤️

I never start crying until the end when they end up together and she remembers him then forgets him. And I cry every time

This movie is not couple goals, or I don't watch and be 'so romantic!' to their youngself, but the old version of them is just always making me sob 2 hours legit.

This is what “All’s fair in love and war” means

I CRIED my eyes out when I first saw this, although there's some weird parts I still love this movie, it's a guilty pleasure. ♥♥♥♥♥

Just watched this for the first time i didnt even know i could cry that much

There's a reason this is the only romance movie I like.

Idk why I thought I’d be able to watch this without crying ...like you were def making me laugh throughout most of it but at the end. Got me. I need to find my balls and smoke a blunt

One of my absolute favorites and I’m so glad you had the reaction you had to the entire thing 💜💜 Also thank you for your service! 🇺🇸

Bro u got me crying and laughing at the same time. Love all your reactions ♥️ subscribed

This is my favorite reaction..I cried and laughed when you started crying lmaooo

Movies like this get me every time, My husband and I have been together since we were 17 yrs old, 35 yrs and 5 kids later we still look at each other the same way as we did as teens. I pray every day something like this never happens to us.😢😭

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE BILLY ! ❤️

She wasnt his girl, they hust kept each other company to fill a void. Thats why she was so cool and asked to meet her.

“The best of me” is a good one

I'm doing a marathon of this channel, because, why not? Man, your videos were just always fire! Definitely one of my favorite accounts EVER

this movie made me cry like a baby!!! your commentary is hilarious

I’m here so late but I’ve seen this movie many times and still cried during the reaction lol. I remember bawling my eyes out the first time I saw it 😂😂

This movie gets me everytime... watching your commentary even got me crying.

This movie tore me apart on so many levels, one because I had a history of going back to exes a second time. But ultimately, because my soulmate and I couldnt be together when we were younger. I remember watching this, and couldnt understand why it was affecting me so much. Then, almost 12years ago, we went on our first date as an official couple, and wonderful memories I had apparently blocked of him came flooding back. (During those moments, I remembered this movie...) I had no idea I had blocked out so much from the pain of thinking we would never be together. I think I only watched it 1or2 times, its still too much for me to this day. But, we've been together ever since ❤

Absolutely love your movie reactions

Your commentary throughout this movie made me laugh. Thank you for that

Love this movie! Your reactions crack me up 😂

I didn’t cry watching it for the first time, but I literally was balling for an hour when I read it.

Your commentary is so great. This is great.

The last bit of this movie always brings the waterworks.

i have seen this movie more times than i can count and even reactions like this one still make me lose it... when she realizes its him and they hug and kiss is when the flood gates open and then the rest of it keeps me SOBBING until the end every single DAMN time