My Response to Logic 

Did I just voluntarily sit through 18 minutes of couples therapy

I’m at a Super Bowl party but I turned off the game and made everyone watch this. Now I’m never invited to another gathering again. Thanks Anthony!!

Logic: you look so unenthusiastic Anthony: *BECAUSE THE MUSIC BAD BRO*

‘I’m not saying this is a black and white issue- don’t make a joke about that’ made me spit out my coffee

I don’t think anyone expected fantano to make 3 videos on the album “The Big Day” he must love this album

''All hateful opinions of Stevie Wonder are invalid by default'' is the thing everyone can agree to

I laughed my ass of when he showed the MGK review and said “no one deserves this!” 😂

I love this. Would love a spin off of you two doing reviews together, and arguing playfully and seriously

He's had just about enough of our jokes guys

Logics video was a little harsh, but calling him Monoracial was un called for.

Logic is the textbook definition of "I'm not even mad, bro"

2:41 "Because the album bad, dude" -Anthony Fantano, 2023

It’s nice how Logic used to be very serious about everything and now he’s constantly making fun of himself and having fun with everything

"I wear my emotions on my sleeve" no, you wear a range of scores on your torso via the flannel method.

“Thats one of the most savage things ive ever heard someone say about another person” but see hes not saying it about him hes saying it about the music. Its different.

The Swimming Pools chorus also creates the vibe of being … drank … in it’s delivery … which is obviously the point.

It's great that Anthony Fantano is showing his "Rapping Career" through the alias of "Logic" it's nice that he's taking a break in music reviewing, and focusing on his true passion.

That was a very illogical response, Anthony.

love this vid- such an interesting *experiment* reviewing yourself, being reviewed by somebody. i think its cool to hear not only another perspective, but an explanation to your own points.

These reactions were really light-hearted and funny, I thought. As a fan of you, Dev Lemons, and Logic...this is a really fun opportunity to not only be entertained and learn more about each of you, but generally speaking as well, it's a brilliant way for media and acts to collaborate! 😂❤️‍🔥🙌🙏🏼

Seeing this extremely successive rapper this invested in a niche internet subculture and posting about it on his official account is absolutely bonkers

It’s inspiring that Waldo finally found a way to hide in plain sight for over a decade by creating a successful career as a rapper under the pseudonym “Logic”.

This video actually made me so happy man. It's actually pretty dope to see how the friendly part of the internet interacts

I can't believe this rabbithole I fell into... Tony and Bobby's sibling rivalry online is the most hilarious back and forth I've ever seen. You guys are adorable, never change haha

The dynamic between Logic and Fantano is so entertaining lol, they have such different perspectives

this video feels like fantano being logic's dad and giving him advice on how to behave on the internet

It’s pretty impressive how Fantano doesn’t let the actual artist change his mind at all just because of who they are

This was the greatest clash between an old Millennial and young Millennial ever recorded

The louder they announce retirement the faster they return

You can't just make a threat on his life because he 'Wears Glasses too' Anthony.

crazy that no one in logic's corner has been like "hey fam, maybe we should pass on this one"

Logic’s response to Logic

maybe this is an unpopular opinion, but Logic’s not so subtle need for approval from Anthony gives me secondhand embarrassment. Logic is a talented guy, and Fantano himself told him to not give a fuck about what he or anyone else has to say about his music. It’s a cute and funny dynamic, but it’s clear Logic is more into it than Anthony is.

I think it’s so wonderful you guys found each other. It’s my favorite RU-vid love story slightly ahead of Dan and Arin.

I really enjoy whatever this relationship is between Fantano and Logic. I hope this never stops.

Damn. This was more eye-opening than Logic’s review of the review. I actually want to see a review of the review of the review of the review from Logic

Thank you for issuing a response. The two of you joined forces and helped me and likely other viewers to realize that issues aren’t always black and white. Hats off to you for not seeing color.

This video reminds me of a relationship with me and my friend. We have a deep appreciation and love for each other due to the dynamic we used to have and overcoming being enemy’s. But because we are so incredibly different in every aspect, there comes a lot of weird moments. That reminds me of this. the reviewer and the reviewed just can’t be friends without it being awkward as hell

man the chemistry between these two is CRAZY 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 watching Fantano take sh*t for the sh*t he takes is just actually priceless tbh fr ngl

Wow anthony! After I watch ur reaction to the review of ur review, I’m gonna go and watch the review of the review bc I hadn’t see that review… all the while, its 4:19 am right now, not going to sleep I guess. maybe I should review sleep meds

It's okay Mr. Robert Logical, sometimes a mid album still has bangers on it. We still love you.

"Bobthany Blackwhitetano" is probably my favourite joke of this gag

the most genuinely upsetting thing is the fact that it’s not even Logics own album he’s reacting to, if it was his reaction to like “Supermarket” review then it would make a lil more sense. I don’t even think Chance knows or cares who theneedledrop is?

Crazy.. the man said "I got RU-vid premium" then I got an ad the same second

I love how Logic says Fantano, "FAWN-ta-no". So cosmopolitan!

this little brother/older brother dynamic is really fun, i'm digging it.

It seems like Logic just straight up doesn’t understand what criticism is, and what a critic does. It’s something worth looking into, or just thinking about for a while.

The coolest part about Logics music as a hip-hop head is all the little easter eggs in his beats and sample choices and rhymes but not sure what there is to like if you don't get all his and deep cut hip hop references but a lot of times it feels like he's too on the nose and not enough of his own original sound.

melon and logics relationship is logic trying to get his attention and melon cringing at almost everything he says

I really apreciate this level of self criticism from fantano

A podcast with these two would be the first music podcast I've ever subscribed to.

I think for me the biggest thing about negative reviews is their date of release. idk when you put yours out bc new fan, but it really bothers me when I read negative reviews for media before I get the chance to form my own opinion on it. if others around you are saying that x media is bad, when you go to listen to / watch / read x media on your own, your perception of it is going to be influenced already. I feel like allowing / encouraging viewers to try it out themselves first is a great way of showing respect to the artist and the listener. but also, ik thumbnails are important and also if you post a review a month late then less people will care. idk cheers love ur vids an example: I went into the new Thor movie expecting it to be bad, and I was sitting there having to get over my own semi-conscious mental block that "people say this movie is bad, therefor I shouldn't like it" when I realized I was enjoying the movie.

Alright, if Logic is reviewing your work now, you've gotta drop a remix of one of his songs.

Now we need Logic to react to Anthony reacting to Logic

you're very well spoken and can get your message across perfectly

Dunkey said something about that stupid comment he got as well "why are you reviewing something you seem not to like" you can't just continuously listen to play or watch the shit you know you like since then as a reviewer you have 0 value what context would we have if everyone just reviewed everything pefectly because they only review things they enjoy

This was pretty damn entertaining to watch! I do have to say I think the one spot you were off on that Chance review is Zanies & Fools. That track goes hard and Chance has Bars. Chance definitely should’ve ended it, but overall a great track on an album that didn’t have much.

It's actually infuriating how much Logic muddles his namesake by showing the most obtuse reasoning ability

These two have the best thing going on RU-vid right now. Can't wait for Logic's review of this review of his review of the Chance review.

2:13 “throwing it back on bobby” it was so subtle but it had me ROLLING 😂😂😂

Nah Logic is just mad soft man lol. Calling Fantano’s criticism of Chance “the most savage thing I’ve ever heard someone say about someone publicly” is insane… like he’s just not built for this sort of thing and that’s okay, he just needs to stop obsessing over it. You supposed to be a rapper bro, this is hop hop! Come on dawg lol.

It's so nice of Anthony to be supporting Biracial youths from the Baltimore area! Keep Up the good work Anthony!

Logic clearly still doesn’t get it. It’s like he’s lucky enough to have become friends with Fantano for him to get over shit, but he still doesn’t see that Fantano is not some cut throat roast reviewer trying to personally ruin an artist’s day. You can tell he still wrestles with how criticism is communicated in content because he self inserts and doesn’t imagine he’d like being on the receiving end of it.

YES WE ALL WANT GOOD CHANCE THE RAPPER AGAINNNNN I honestly really liked highs and lows and I really want to see him succeed

The worst part is that logic will see this and take it to heart for his next fantano review review

I think Logics video idea is the definition “better on paper”

I feel like for an artist a review is different than a fan looking for new music and seeing if they should check something out. I look at you as a reviewer for recommendations and to deepen my thoughts on music. Haru Nemuri is an artist I never would have checked out if it wasn't for your review of her first album. several other albums I might have been on the fence on checking out over others and because of good reviews I did. I find plenty of issue with some of your reviews but that comes usually from a place of fandom for an artist I know you don't have. while you and everyone have biases you are actually pretty good at being some what unbiased going in to music, you never seem excited to hate music, maybe some pop people, Taylor Swift, you are biased to not liking her more pop lyrics but that's not your thing and every time you've reviewed her you do take the time to praise and talk about the good and bad never just this and that were bad. For an artist though I could see why they would be annoyed if they put time and effort into making an album or song and a reviewer they like didn't see what they were going for or didn't like.

Depth is the exact definition of substance to digest,I personally do not listen to music without depth unless it's the most energetic beat with the most undeserving lyrics that I hate but the beats so good I can push the lyrics off, example:take a step back by ski mask.

He should’ve made a parody video of reviewing you “reviewing” his upcoming album. As a way to promote the upcoming album. Keep it like 3 minutes and full of self aware humor

Remember when Logic said he was going to stream on Twitch full-time. What ever happened with that?

It’s harsh to say that just because logic didn’t make songs that aren’t that deep he shouldn’t care what people think about it. It’s still work he put out there and clearly fantanos opinion mattered since he’s been watching him for a while so of course it’s gonna hurt when you get a negative review

The ad placement 10 secs after 9:21 is genius

That MGK review is my favourite fantano vid next to his Feldman review video, I love that Melon doesn't relish in the negativity and get excited to dunk on something unless it's SO BAD that its interesting.

hitting me with an ad break after anthony fell for the ad in logic's video was next level

This feels like Melon is trying super hard not to be accept the fact that Bobby is in love with him because the internet finds Bobby to be corny AF. But deep down, Melon feels the same way about Bobby. “Ok, fine. We can have a thing, I just don’t want the Internet to find out Bobby.”

This type of back and forth must happen more on this channel. Absolute gold.

It’s weird how Anthony made a video bantering with himself

This just comes across as logic still being upset at fantano for giving all those negative reviews to him and trying to say those reviews were invalid picking out flaws in the way he reviews stuff, except he chose someone else’s album to be the subject and did under the guise of ‘comedy’

y’all just gotta have a series where you both review and album together

I just learned about all the logic drama yesterday, but I have listened to College Park more than any other album EVER. So many good songs.

If you, like me, turned off the Super Bowl to watch Fantano respond to Logic - then it’s a good indicator you need to touch some grass

they had better keep doing this and reacting to each others review of their review of their review of their review

While I’ll say that I do love the Fantano/Logic dynamic and I think this is a fun video, something about the way that Logic phrases his responses just screams “I’m insecure and I want Anthony to like me,”or “He’s being so mean and harsh to these hard working artists and that’s not fair,” and while I do understand his want for approval because validation is a common need that we want from people we admire, it seems like it’s affecting his “logic”(oh damn) and understanding of criticism and that it isn’t a personal attack on the artist itself. I just find it kind of annoying and slightly off putting.. Maybe I’m taking this too seriously and it ain’t that deep, but it’s something that I noticed, I suppose. It’s all good, Logic! You are a talented individual!

"no one deserves this" kills me 😂😂

Bobby didn't mention the Tones and I review. THAT shit was savage haha

Logic bragging that he made 30 million dollars in one year but doesn't pay for RU-vid is high irony.

This is how Logic and Fantano should solely communicate from now on

15:19 I felt that way with Lorde and Haim's second albums. Looking forward to the good and got..wildly pop-y or overproduced respectively.

Just let it go, Logic.

Virgin musician: "An attempt at art is success in art" Chad critic: "Try harder hippie"

Pov: You're watching someone review someone's review on that person's review. How did we get here

Did you know he’s both white and black?! Crazy right

This honestly just makes Logic look dumb, or worse, disingenuous. He doesn't seem to (or refuses to) understand bias, criticism, or logical comparison.

Thanks Anthony, you’ve made me aware of new Logic album.

the thing about reviews is that even they get critiqued. how many times have you read a review and thought this some bs, most people pick shit they agree with or just like the reviewers thoughts but i think reviewers should most definitely looks at stuff they don't like. hell sometimes you might find something you like from a place you thought you knew you wouldn't like.

Looking forward to Chance The Rapper's response to Fantano's response to Logic's review of Needledrop's review of Chance's The Big Day album

Something serious is at stake here: if Fantano did indeed replace his colourful languages and harsh critique with a more respectful approach, many of us probably wouldn’t be here. So the issue here seems to stem from the fact that we collectively revel in Fantano’s “meanness” to pieces of music he dislikes, which in fairness can indeed come across as disparaging to the artists themselves. I think Fantano knows this, so his offer to consider taking on suggestions on how to be more respectful is a little contradictory (even if I don’t doubt his sincerity). Personally I think it’s totally fine - great even in cases - for Fantano to be harsh and mean towards big name artists who dropped the ball. I am more hesitant with smaller artists - though it seems to me that Fantano probably feels this way as well since as far as I know he’s never really been mean to smaller artists.

throwin it back on Bobby

disinterest usually says the most about quality imo, if you’re reviewing something and consistently thinking back to the older works in someone’s catalogue, it says a lot about your opinion implicitly.

I’m looking forward to seeing some more animation from you